primitives are not back in some remote age — they are not BEHIND
how is he using primitives in comparison to du bois
primitives are not back in some remote age — they are not BEHIND
how is he using primitives in comparison to du bois
of the nervous system and have never in their experience witnessed t
wordsworth mechanical language in the pregace
but that he possessed knowledge, and extraordinary kno
lyric posession
out " life ", bitter to the individual, by a " vision of beauty ". It is a work of the imagination. It gives the feeling
compare this to toomer karintha
Composition is in no essential an escape from life. In fact if it is so it is negligeable to the point of insig- nificance. Whatever « life » the artist may be forced to lead has
Art does not unify life but seperates further.
perfect
perfect beauty?
Wind is in the cane.
cane is product for use. discussion of the correspondent breeze?
. Our congregation had been visiting at Pulverton, and were coming home. There was no wind. The autumn sun, the bell from Ebenezer Church, listless and heavy. Even the pines were stale, sticky, like the smell of food that makes you sick. Be
The contamination of the natural by the human
At dusk, during the hush just after the sawmill had closed down, and before any of the women had started their supper-getting-ready songs, her voice, high-pitched, shrill, would put one’s ears to itching. But no one ever thought to make her stop because of it. She stoned the cows, and beat her dog, and fought the other children... Even t
The domination over the senses by the eye.
e artist must lose such lesser identities in the great well of life. The English poet is not forever protesting and recalling that he is English. It is so natural and easy for him to be English that he can sing as a man. The French novelist is not forever noting: “This is French.” It is so atmospheric for him to be French, that he can devote himself to saying: “T
The English poet does do this though.
the absolutespirit c
where does this term come from.
The return of the repressed, ofwhich we must rid ourselves in order to consider ourselvesas “different”: rational humans, spiritual beings.
Is he saying here that plants are part of the unconscious? The repressed? The natural/physical/ sensuous in opposition to the spiritual/rational.
a lesson plan for a high school classroom around the event, deve
A problem Katie was expressing is how perhaps the community doesn't want to be involved, and how putting it in high schools can be a way to generate interest over a long period.
Working in groups is difficult. In the spirit of working and thinking collectively. Thinking about this along with the ballet, and along with siona, and how much the work of public humanities requires collective. Which sounds obvious but wasn't to me.
tragedy is always and everywhere..
the woman are tragic, the ocean is tragic,
hegemonic blackness
That watches and receives
watch and receive versus grow
Come, hear the woodland linnet, 10How sweet his music; on my lifeThere’s more of wisdom in it
A bird has wisdom, not human> anti-humanist?
y all this toil and trouble?Up! up! my friend, and quit your books,Or surely you’ll grow double
What does he mean by grow double? Is this a sort of recognition of how the publishing of books, education, work to serve the capitalist state. Books can make you two, split?
The double versus the oneness that wordsworth and coleridge are interested in.
I’ve heard of hearts unkind, kind deedsWith coldness still returning.Alas! the gratitude of menHas oftner left me mournin
Heard of hearts unkind- german tragedies? This poem is playing with the genre of ballad, epic, tragedy.
ader! had you in your mindSuch stores as silent thought can bring,O gentle reader! you would findA tale in every thing.
This seems like a rection against the novel reader. Who looks for "outrageous stimulation" (5). Silent thought/meditation (spontaneous thought/feeling)
New objects
consumerism
We murder to dissect
goes back to the double? Split. Books The accrual of knowledge is death/again edenic.
Come forth, and bring with you a heart
Wordsworth thinks it most important to deepen feeling.
u, mid all this mighty sum“Of things for ever speaking,“That nothing of itself will come,“But we must still be seeking
A sort of edenic statement. That gathering "knowledge" is bad. In what way is this the same as Gray's points in "elegy in a country". As well as certain beliefs Guillory points out concerning education...seeing public education as an evil.
In a wise passiveness
"By obeying blindly and mechanically the impulses of those habits" This is a poem about how to create poetry. This poem is about page 4 of preface and Wordsworth's prescription for making poetry. Where does feeling come from for Wordsworth? Feeling is exhalted here. Its interesting that someone who writes poetry in hopes of strengthening affections and enlightening would say that reading cannot feed the mind or generate feelings. Is Wordsworth warning others away from other genres? Is Wordsworth against philosophy, he is obviously against novels.
Our bodies feel, where’er they be
Rather, the deliriumemerges from the intensity of the perceived epistemological disjuncture, theexistential sense that one is standing where one ought not to be andtherefore, for Fanon, every experience must constantly be inte
Then I know. Anywhere is.
I walk the maze of momentsbut everywhere I turn tobegins a new beginningbut never finds a finish
Postcoloniality: Tragedy begets tragedy. Everything is relating. Revolution you think you have finally ended things but only continued cycles of oppression
Tragedy: Tragedy is a system like this.
You go there you’re gone foreverI go there I’ll lose my wayif we stay here we’re not togethe
How does this complicate musuo and tragedy. The person's (you) soul is now dead simply by being in a place. If the speaker goes there they will also be "lost" , losing the ability to make ethical choice or get back to happiness. If they stay "here" they are not together, they remain individual and don't achieve the stickiness that is musuo tragedy. Anywhere
ends primarily on the degree to which the authors ofthe works themselves feel they are spokesperson
Does he mean the author the characters? Sethe feels herself to be a spokesperson for her children. She feels no separation between them and her.
of musuo will help us evaluate various scenes inpostcolonial tragedy with the specific purpose of harnessing Aristotle toa different kind of interpretation
Musuo changes the temporality of Aristoeleian tragedy as having an end as everyone is hurt by the actions. The end cannot be clear. Also, the community is also tragic as they do not excercize choice but also experience damage to their ethics and to their being. Musuo compounds tragedy.
a beginning, a middle, and an end
Postcoloniality complicating tragedy as it does not end. Look at song again. Someone dies someone simply goes on and both are tragic. Sethe's story ends perhaps but beloveds goes on.
symptomatic of an impasse of understa
hamartia is symptomatic of a failure of understanding. Hamartia shows that there is already something wrong before the anagnorisis. Something has happened to the character to impair their judgement or obscure their knowledge.
aligns discovery/knowledg
further define these words by going back to aristotle.
of course, it also attempts to do, but as a means by which torethink postcolonialism through the prism of literary tragedy and vice versa
What is the glaring abscence in the field. How does this book rethink tragedy and postcolonialism, respectively.
Prism is an important word here. Literary tragedy is a prism. It separates light into a spectrum of color. It reflects the real through multiple surfaces/viewpoints that can both clarify and distort simultaneously.
arge and varied history of tragic expression
Simply that tragic expression can take many forms and be read from multiple perspectives.
uch ways, the most active agents of revolution canbecome its factual enemies, even while to others, and evento themselves, they seem its most perfect
how head guy treats matha.
he hero is dead, we are taking a part for the whole, ahero for an action. We think of tragedy as what happens tothe hero, but the ordinary tragic action is what happensthrough the hero. When we confine our attention to thehero, we are
A subversion of tragedy in the old drift as there are no heroes. The hero could be said to be the one who takes themselves out of the story.
A second wave of letters arrives.
overwhelm by letters
They sizzle. They spark.
The words do things. Do the actual words sizzle, do they cause affective response.
figures, and many contain shapes like waves. The annotations are written in an ink that changes now that it’s exposed to air and sun: the inscriptions—signs, lines, circles, arrows, figures—boil on the surface
Just as the words are not translatable, they change based on environment, based on context, the ocean is also unknown, untranslatable.
Because we’re so used to thinking of ourselves as beingseparate and different from everything els
What's going on outside? What if we were to think of everything that happens in the world, the environment/ecology as happening to ourselves. The dolphin did not invite you? Is that only further creating separation? Humans crave connection? Is it a good ethic to assume as much as we can that other beings crave connection? attention
Its intense focus on a single species is motivated by aconcern for—rather than disinterest in
Concern/disinterest feelings
arine science and the artists are wary ofbeing dismissed as New-Age kooks
This is interesting context
ental state that results profoundly shapes the experience ofinterspecies encounter, especially of the inters
Interstices connection forces us to literally alter our behavior and our minds.
he breath work does affect our mental, physicaland emotional state. I would describe it as a feeling of ‘openness
My belief is much of anxiety/fear is a fear of being moved by something outside oneself. What can consciously creating that feeling do for the ease of fear/anxiety.
Through a kind of negative mimesis, it performs the ocean’sessential unknowability, its resistance to easy mappin
The ocean's right to untranslatability. People, oceans, beings have a right to remain unknown. The known is limited.
nimal encounters is not just an idle, self-indulgentcuriosity but something else, perhaps a deep-rooted and nature-afrming need to be better connected to the earthly realities thatour so-called civilization deprives us of, then these practices may besites for fostering a much
To be with a more "friendly people"
m a vital need for interspecies encounter and, on the other,from the potential damage that the fulllment of this needunwittingly inicts on the non-human species involve
Why do we crave interspecies encounters? Because of the way we have been alienated in our own species.
pproach realizing his ambition. Repeat-edly it seems that the poem he wishes he could write-a poemexpressing deep feeling and quiet simplicity-is being under-mined by the cognitive or social
This makes sense of Wordsworth's dismissal of education and "book learning", his own make him unable to write the kind of poem he would like.
. the task of creating the taste by which he isto be enjoyed" (Prose, 111, 80)
ramajin 10 on eliot.
roods over the fancied neglect of the world, in sullen andsolitary vexation.1
I wonder how this connects with Ruths man in wordsworth.
etry” they practice, it stands to reason that this self-definitional drivewould manifest itself not only in the poet’s criticism, as Eliot maintains, but also in thepoetry itself.46 W
wordsworth in expostulationand reply
and extraliterary languages, intensifying andhybridizing them, making them collide and rub up agains
the language of men in wordsworth
ythm and musical effects that are known with our entire bodies.”20 Th
the gwen brooks epigraph in shockley.
earlier works and forms, it is also “born andshaped in the process of interaction and strugg
wordsworth with the novel and philosophy
dimension,” “the physical aspect of language.”18 InLyric Poetry, Mutlu Konuk Blasing characterizes poetry as a platform for “the emotionallyand historically charged materiality of language,” “an excess of ‘sense,’” and “a rhythmicbeat between sense and nonsense.”19 In Poetry
the word sense is rich in wordsworth, robinson, and even shockley with the subject matter of racism which is nonsense and with her tone which is nonsensical when she remarks on the violence, but then changes when it turns to gireving.
ereave
deprived of a close relation upon their death
Ballad. It had the beat inevitable. It had the bloo
What is this definition of ballad doing? Wordsworth denying the blood of ballad.
r their eyes are “deceive
eyes in robinson and shockley
HE MANI
The maniac as the repository of feeling. blindly mechanized by feeling
lm ENCHANTTHEE TO REPOSE
meditation/ stillness
t is possible to be monolingual (I thoroughly am, aren't I ?)and speak a language that is not one's own.
We only ever see through the medium of one language?
akes expansive gestures yet remains amnesiac toward non-American geographies in which America is implicated, geographies that vanish over the intellectual skyline. The spatial amnesia that often attends a bioregional ethic has temporal impl
in caribbean writing, world geographies are always implicated. The US, the UK are always implicated in the very "white" land itself.
s sense—educationally—to begin with local writing; then you expand, adding layers of knowledge.”17There is much to be said for a bioregional approach: it can help instill in us an awareness of our impact on our immediate environment, help ground our sense of environmental responsibility. However, from a postcolonial perspective, a bioregional ethic poses certain problems, for the concentric rings of the bioregionalists more often open out into transce
In environmentalist work there is a sort of faith in the land, whereas in postcolonial lit there is a sort of suspicion. The land is not here to reveal but to break illusions/ shatter. The perspective on the land is constructed by social conditions, not by any "belief" in it's goodness.
bourgeois morality placed the promise of happiness outside of society. He asserted that the possibility of happiness was
when Anderson is looking at the african masks he does this. He only beleives the sensual can be appreicated in art, not in people or in real life, this is why he is so tragic to helga. His pragmaticism.
Helga desires to be a bourgeois art object.
he idea of reason aims at universality, at a society in which the antagonistic interests of '
this is why naxos is so conformist.
the domination of nature,
Helga makes a short critique of this,
justify a capitalist mode of economic organization which made effic
by doing this black people only more further justify the capitalist mode of economics that oppress them.
Because they equated the highest good exclusively with the exercise of reason, they came to regard the pursuit of sensual gratification as something evil. Both philosophers branded as irration
This is my thesis. In an attempt to emphasize black peoples ability to reason, they suppress his other sensual characteristics
a critique of what he termed 'the philosophy of reason
The same critique Larsen aims at middle class black culture in Quicksand.
eudaemonistic or to a hedonistic conception of happiness, any characterization of happiness must entail the satisfaction of some human need or desire.
I could say in my thesis that in the harlem rennaissance there is a conflict between a eudamonistic and a hedonistic conception of happiness that evolves out of the performance principle or economic need.
human happiness requires both the gratification of instinctual in
rather than putting one over the other like the naxos negroes do, and Anne Grey does.
irrationality of sensual satisfactions marked them as dubious contributors to eudaemoni
this is why naxos negroes hold helga in contempt, because she does not value goodness, virtue, and reason over sensual satisfactions. They do not understand her, they see her as irrational. James Vayle is still enthralled by her because he perceives in her the erotic tendencies that she values like no other in his community, people perceive Helga as purely sensual throughout the book, she even runs from it herself because she has been taught not to value it.
ne possessed those things worth having and engaged in activities which were morally virtuous. Because they believed that the capacity to reason represented mankind's unique and highest endowment,
naxos negroes
question of human happiness has been of enduring interest to philosophers since the time of Plato and Aristotle. I
as it is to Helga. This is the major question of quicksand.
aced by an aesthetic ethos which placed the pursuit of happiness above competitive economic pursuits.
Helga, speker of slj, and hughes all wish for this. Helga places the pursuit of happiness sabove economic pursuits when she leaves naxos, leaves her job in harlem, leaves denmark, and goes to the south. All of these places held economic potentials for helga that she abandoned in search of true happiness.
e status quo, in daring to interrupt the necessity by which we are ruled and therefore to be otherwise than we have been obliged to be by the powers that have control over our lives, revolution is almost purely a matter of action, of intervention, o
agnes does this overthrows life as she knows in favor of new
nevitably an invitation to tragedy.98 To act in freedom is to act self- disclosively among a plurality of other (only partially knowable) self- disclosive agents, themselves acting and reacting in time in relation to others in unpredictable ways and in temporally contingent circumstances. Therefore, to act in fr
agnes and ronakd
therefore, are co- constitutive. Consequently, an agent’s purposes only be-come manifest, as it were, retrospectively, as they emerge from the unfold-ing action itself. Against the view that rational agents enjoy an incorrigible, immediate know
we don't even know the purpose of our actions until after the action itself.
evolution, this tendency was not reversed or undone. To the contrary, it was strengthened and reinscribed in a more fatal social and political dynamic. This paternalism enhanced tendencies toward the political monopoly of power and therefore authoritarian
Federico. He wanted revolutionary action to fundamentally change things in the world, however, he was not aware of the way revolution needs to be whole, he didn't get rid of his own tendency to hierarchy and authoritarianism, he wouldn't let the tonga do what they want and instead herds them awayl,
ognitive- affective function, but the exercise of a critical mode of sustain-ing not only the hopes of the vanquished and the common world to which we—and they—belong but, perhaps, the only way to engage the possibility of reflecti
this says what remeberance can do for the defeated
the inspired Caribbean generation of 1968, cultivating the dream of a self- determining island republic free of the tyranny and subjection that had de
link betweej scott's grenada and zambia
mmitments can congeal into night-mare regimes in which people are reduced to being merely the means to
this is what happens to the tsonga
ic anti- tragic figure, Williams saw in Marx precisely a thinker who grasped the long revolution as a “whole action,” as a change in the “form of activity of a society, in its deepest structure of relationships and feel-ings,” as he put it.1
federico's failure to see revolution in this way is what causes him to to follow the behavior of his brother
rstanding as mere violence or as the mere overthrow of a standing government.
this is Federico's view of tragedy.
jected as intolerable and the new is as yet uncertain and unfamiliar—and, moreover, unwanted and resisted by the prevailing powers—human action is even more exposed than usual to the risks and hazards and treacheries of political affairs and therefore more vulnerable to the collisions that can lead to tragedy.
Ronald and Lionel.
They stem from the actions of agents acting in a field of potentially rival actions and in circumstances over which they can, in the end, exercise only partial and unstable control
Agnes' action versus Ronalds.
etermining agents acting in time are pervasively subject to contingency, and therefore to outcomes that are never entirely predictable or guaranteed in advance.1 One consequence of this incalculableness of human actions i
Federico kills his brother, the representative of fascism,to save Sibilla, but his violent action is what changes his and Sibilla's reltionship irreperably.
jet black and glossy and silky . . . and his skin was atransparent green . . . like the sea only not so deep ... and where it was drawn over the cheek bones a palebeautiful red appeared . . . like a blush .
black red and green recurs
lue smoke from an ivory holder ... was that why he loved Beauty ... one can ...or because his body was beautiful . . . and white and warm ... or because his eyes. . . one can love
does he only love beauys whieness
. and in his hand he held . . . an ivory holder . . . inlaid with red
the pan african flag colors of marcus garvey are red black and green. The white encompasses it all hough.
wait Alex ... and Alex became confused and continued his search . . . on hishands and knees ... pushing aside poppy stems and lily stems ... a poppy ... a black poppy ... a lilly ... a redlilly ... and when be looked back he could no longer see Beauty . . . Al
race limits the search for beauty. He almost found it but he must look for blackness and whiteness. Melava and Alex are opposites. White man/black woman.
The Southern night is full of stars, Great big yellow stars. O, sweet as earth, Dusk dark bodies
Both the stars and bodies are not valued because they are in abundance. They are an undifferentiated mass. The job of the black woman is to produce labor force. Just like the stars are supposed to produce light.
hich read: "Light-colored man wanted." It is thistremendous pressure which the sentiment of the country exerts that isoperating on the race. There is involved not only the question of higheropportunity, but often the q
black people do not "crave a new social order but only a larger share in the prevailing one"
or its solution. In this it is similar to the problem ofthe solar system. By a complex, confusing, and almost contradictorymathematical process, by the use of zigzags instead of straight lines, theearth can be proved to be the center of things celestial; but by an operationso simple that it can be comprehended by a schoolboy, its position can beverified among the other worlds which revolve about the sun, and itsmovements harmonized with the laws of the universe. So, when the whiterace assumes as a hypothesis that it is the main object of creation and thatall things else are merely subsidiary to its well-being, sophism, subterfuge,perversion of conscience, arrogance, injus
Black people frame the race question as a matter of progress. But for white people it simply comes to "excercizing domination" "in order to sustain or enhance itself in a privileged position"
heir own inferiority judged by the color line. I do not thinkso. What I have termed an inconsistency is, after all, most natural; it is, infact, a tendency in accordance with what might be called an economicnecessity. So far as racial differences go, the United States puts a greaterpremium on colo
performance principle at work
performance principle. If social revolution is to take place, he held that it will be necessary to first change the consciousnesses and drives of the men and women who could change the world
narrator in colored mans thoughts after the train convo
tted to Eros in its fight against social and instinctual repression. According to Marcuse, "Art represents the ultimate goal of all
the spirituals
the free expression of human drives and the satisfaction of true human needs has e
plays out in blood burning. Because of the domination in society the oppressed Tom cannot act on his needs. Because of domination in the society Bob feels he constantly has to preserve his privilege. Aggression comes out of this.
form of the reality principle and with this term he argued that individuals are judged in this society by virtue of their competitive economic performances.4 Although
why bob had won louisa.. by the way the world reckons things.
he fact of material scarcity provides an explanation for the genesis of repression and domination. Material privation has led to the division of labor, class society and the repression of instinctual gratification. For Marcuse, however, the mere fact of scarcity did not prove the necessity of repression or domination. Anthropological studies, for example, have verified the existence of archaic societies which have been peaceful and egalitarian.It was Marcuse's intention to demonstrate that at the attained level of mature industrial society, an order of abundance could eliminate the repression and dcmination enforced by past orders of scarcity. To accomplish this task he combined Marxian political economy with Freudian metapsychology in order to examine the social
Curious as to how darwinism contributes to the belief that scarcity proves the necessity of repression or domination.
revolution as a “whole action,” as a change in the “form of activity of a society, in its deepest structure of relationships and feel-ings,” as he put it
A whole action. Revolution is commonly thought to be action, war, tangible movement. Very rarely is it a change in the structure of relationships.
expressed itself in vigor and ingenuity rather than in beauty.
capitalism rather than beauty.
s was primitive African music; it may be seen in larger form in the strange chant which heralds "The Coming of John":"You may bury me in the
connection between black music to pritive africamm
walk in the moonlight, I walk in the starlight;I'll lie in the grave and stretch out my arms,I'll go to judgment in the evening of the day,And my soul and thy soul shall meet that day,When I lay this body down.
How has christian ideals of a better life in the after contribute to the death instinct.
oon in the great door was an omen. Negro women improvised songs against its spell. Louisa sang as she came over the crest of the hill from
The natural is evil here.
UP from the skeleton stone walls, up from the rotting floor boards and the solid hand-hewn beams of oak of the pre-war cotton factory, dusk came. Up from the dusk the full moon came. Glowing like a fired pine-knot, it illumined the great door and soft showered the Negro shanties aligned along the single street of factory town. The full moon in the great door was an omen. Negro women improvised songs against its spell.
Because the south has oppressed them the land itself has become evil, dark.
rust me, I’ll have a farm. My own. My bales will buy yo what y gets from white folks now. Silk stockings an purple dresses—course I dont believe what some folks been whisperin as t how y gets them things now
nothing different. larger share in consumption or in current order.
But working in the fields all day, and far away from her, gave him no chance to show it. Though often enough of evenings he had tried to. Somehow, he never got along. Strong as he was with hands upon the ax or plow, he found it difficult to hold her. Or so he thought. But the fact was that he held her to factory town more firmly than he thought for. His black balanced, and pulled against, the wh
He does not have the time needed to fulfill libidinal desires marcuse.
bring their money; they will die not having found it out.
Marcuse, the ego and time.
Smoke is on the hills. Rise up. Smoke is on the hills, O rise And take my soul to Jesus.
death instinct.
through its gradual changes from the heathenismof the Gold Coast to the institutional Negro church of Chicago
That is why Helga submits to the church!!! The Church is perceived as a direct connection to Africa.
m, then their destiny is NOT absorption by the white Americans. That if in America it is to be proven for the first time in the modern world that not only
I wonder how the hate of racial intermingling is motivated in the novel by these passages.
iffers strikingly from the somber yet jewel-rich palette selected by her own discerning eye a
The taste of white Americans. Jewel rich, money signifying. These colors align her with wildness while the others bring out a perceived innate Africanness.
. But she was blind to its charm, purposely aloof and a little contemptuous, and soon her interest in the moving mosaic waned
Because even while being enamored of color as a spectrum, she uses color to bring her closer to the sort of lives white people enjoy, so the spectrum of black color holds no temptation for her.
More often than not, however, definitions of the New Negro asserted that black Americans belonged to a unique race of human beings whose ancestry imparted a distinctive and invaluable racial identity and culture.
Helga feels there is something innately different about blacks, and that it is within her because of this ideological stance.
e crucial role of the past in s
the colonial past as well as anti colonial
at “received a tremendous injection of energy from the historical phenomenon of decolonisation, which infused the novel with a sense of historical agency and a desire to contribute to the construction of viable postcolonial cultural identities for the new African nations” (Booker 2009: 141
how does the old drift draw on and divorce itself from the construction of identities that was concerned with postcolonial futures. How does one construct an identity without a horizon, how much of identity making is concerned with a predetermined future.
the endless and melancholic repeti-tion of itself.18
like sibilla's spin.
nature of this internal connection: mourning can be a response not only to the death of a person but also to the loss of ideals that, as he says, have taken the place of a loved one. In other words, the attachment to such ethical- political ideals as “fatherland” or “liberty” (or “national liberation” or “socialism,” for that matter, to draw closer to the issues at hand in this chapter) is, in psychoanalytic terms, a form of libidinal displacement, a form of substitution, in which a love object is drained of desire that is then transferred, directly or indirectly, into the realm not only of ideas but of ideals. In a somewhat paradoxical way, then, political ideals are founded on object loss
Matha and Godfrey, and her mother.
tions of Memory: The Work of Mourning,” is con- cerned with thinking about the contrast between mourning and melan- cholia in relation to generations of remembering the catastrophic loss of 24 | PROLOGUE
Matha!!!!
en, the past was a social fact; now, however, it is a pathological one. The past is a wound that will not heal. What the past produces now are inward,
Colonial Zambia was a social problem. Now it has become a pathological one
Curiously, it is precisely when the future has ceased to be a source of longing and anticipation that the past has become such a densely animated object of enchantment.” After
the children in OD do this, rifling through old cell phones and tapes talking about old communist stuff.
so many ruins/artifacts in old drrift: the cassette, matha's jacket, lionel's phone. How does looking at the physical landscape as a ruin in our present time change the way we see our time.
I love this article. I wanted to share it with someone but there was noone.Beloved might enjoy but don't want to bombard her. Don't want to spill. To gush.
cultural forms that continue to resonate powerfully as part of what Raymond Williams calls a "selective tradition" (115).14
Williams says that the selective tradition chooses cultural work-art/literature- to highlight and obscure based on the dominant ideology. Work that maintains the dominant ideology-capitalism- is generally highlighted and canonized, while work that is truly subversive is hidden and obscured. This is a somewhat unconscious process. So when we think about why we study Marlowe, and why he has been canonized we have to consider that the reason the culture keeps selecting him may be because he maintains the dominant ideological structure. This reminds me of Bartel and all of those critics from our first readings claiming that Marlowe is truly subversive. While he may have been for his own time, perhaps he isn't for ours and instead upholds our current culture of capitalist globalization.
The "spatial turn" in current criticism of Tamburlaine is, then, I suggest, a symptom that reveals, in spite of its resolute refusal to take up current concerns, a heightened sensitivity to spatial crisis under conditions of late capitalism, and also, it seems to me, a disavowed recognition that primitive accumulation continues into the present moment as capitalism (with)draws sectors, areas, and aspects of existence into and from its active sphere. If I am right about this, we won't be able to understand what Greenblatt has described as the "historical matrix" of Tamburlaine unless we
I agree with Bartolovich's critique of a criticism that is primarily fascinated with the cultural productions of the past and refuses to take up that of the present. For instance, how Sullivan considers the Marlovian hero an "appetitive machine" that is transcendentally homeless without drawing a comparison to our current culture of consumerism and global capitalism, in which some places (markets) are designated to consume without considering the forces (labor) that create them. Just as Tamburlaine goes on his conquest without considering the cultures/people of the nations he is devouring. If his character is an "appetitve machine" then he is like late stage capitalism, concerned primarily with his own private and primitive accumulation of wealth, at the expense of human life and dignity. This seems such an obvious parallel that it does speak to a resolute refusal on the part of Sullivan and other critics to take up current concerns, as Bartolovich says.
Tamburlaine is best understood as an ‘appetitive machine’ whose identityis expressed through the devouring of lands first ‘reduced...to a map’,
The description of Tamburlaine as an "appetitive machine" really helps to make clear how Marlowe's characters have effected Western culture since their debut. I'm interested in how prior to Marlowe the major producer of culture is the church with its teachings of asceticism and how a character like Tamburlaine, a simple sheperds' son who devours lands, who completely sates all his appetites changes that culture. I think that's partly why Tamburlaine is so popular at its inception, it gives regular folk a llicense to indulge their own appetites. Also, later that's very much what England does to the world, reduce places like India and the Americas to a map, from which they can consume and devour the land/materials.