10 Matching Annotations
  1. Jan 2018
    1. If, then, Tragedy is superior to E pie poetry in all , these respects, and, moreover, fulfils its specific func-j, tion better as an art-for each art ought to produce, :\ not any chance pleasure, but the pleasure proper to I . it, as already stated-it plainly follows that Tragedy'! is the· higher art, as attaining its end more perfectly. I( Thus much may suffice concerning Tragic and,k Epic poetry in general; their several kinds and parts;;t with the number of each and their differences; th~'f causes that niake a poem good or bad; the objection~}! of the critics and the answers to these objections.

      Aristotle: "It's all a matter of opinion... but mine is right!"

    2. The question may be raised whether the Epic or Tragic mode .of imitation is the higher. If the more . refined art is the higher, and .the more refined in every case is that which appeals to the. better sort of audience, the art which imitates anything and everything. is manifestly most unrefined.

      He is fighting with the idealism of other critics. Epics were thought of to be more "refined" than tragedies because they contained the stories of heroes/gods & appealed to that of a higher crowd. Aristotle doesn't believe in this, as he thinks that tragedies are the purest form of theatre because they display problems that the majority of the audience can feel and relate to.

    3. Nature herself, as we have said; teaches the choice of the proper measure.

      He's basically saying that things should continue to be done in the way they have always been done.

    4. Recognition, then, being be-tween persons, it may happen that one person only is recognised by the other-when the latter is already known -or it may be necessary that the.recognition should be on both sides.

      This chapter reminds me a lot of the impact of dramatic & situational irony in theatre. Both definitions seem to be present throughout part 11.

    5. Poetry, therefore, is a more philosophi-cal and a higher thing than history: for poetry tends to express the universal, history the particular,

      History is a limited form of prose because the authors are confined to the reality of specific situations, while poets are free to take whatever creative path they choose.

    6. if any one of them is displaced or removed, the whole will be disjointed and disturbed.

      Homer chose specific stories about Odysseus that could easily be pieced together to create a proper plot structure: beginning, middle, and end. If any of these stories were to be taken out, the story wouldn't have been as "epic"... pun intended.

    7. The Spectacle has, indeed, an emotional attrac-tion of its own, but, of all the j,arts,.it is the least artis-tic and connected least with the art of poetry. For the ' power of Tragedy, we may be sure, ,is felt even apart

      In my own words: While Tragedy is meant to be performed, reading it to oneself doesn't dull it's emotional impact.

    8. .fhus the reason why men enjoy seeing a likeness is, that in contemplating it they find themselves learn-ing or inferring; and· saying perhaps, 'Ah, that is he.' For if you happen not _to have seen the original, the · pleasure will be due.riot to the imitation as such, but ·to.the execution, the colouring, or some such other . cause.

      This demonstrates the importance of the "theatrical contract". It illustrates how vital it is to keep in mind how the play will be perceived in the mind of the audience, as "imitation" and "likeness" could definitely qualify as theatrical tools.

    9. The same distinction marks off Trag-edy from Comedy; for Comedy aim, at representing men as worse, Tragedy as better than in actual life.

      Fun Fact: In my humanities class last semester, my teacher discussed how the greeks took the "representing men as worse" part of Comedy so far that many actors would purposely disfigure themselves to appear more "funny looking" to casting directors. They thought this would give them more of a chance at lead roles.

    10. Epic poetry and Tragedy, Comedy also and Dithyrambic poetry, and the music of the flute and of the lyre in most of their forms, are all in their general conception modes of imitation.

      The way I interpret this passage has to do with Aristotle's belief that we all use art as a way to imitate nature. He also believes that this concept is fundamental to the human creative impulse, which is very interesting when thinking about my own creative instincts!