In T.S. Eliot's "The Waste Land," the line "Who is the third who walks always beside you?" evokes a haunting presence, layering the poem with existential uncertainty and a sense of companionship laced with disquiet. From the speaker's point of view, this line captures an intimate yet unsettling inquiry that transcends the immediate relationships, hinting at a spiritual or existential specter that accompanies the living.
The phrase suggests an ambiguous, almost spectral companionship—one that suggests both intimacy and alienation. The “third” figure implies a triangular relationship, where the speaker and another are not alone; instead, they are shadowed by an elusive presence. This presence is not just a literal figure but symbolizes collective trauma, history, or perhaps the weight of modern disillusionment. It evokes a sense of haunting, as if the past—whether personal or cultural—lingers ominously, shaping the present.
Moreover, the use of “who” implies a search for identity, suggesting that the speaker grapples with understanding not just the presence of this third entity, but also their own place within the existential landscape of the poem. The question is both a plea and a probe, inviting readers to ponder the nature of companionship in a fractured world. The haunting nature of this inquiry lies in its open-endedness; it suggests that the answer may elude the speaker, reinforcing the poem's overarching themes of fragmentation and despair.
Ultimately, this line encapsulates the haunting complexity of human experience—where the past, the present, and the metaphysical intertwine, leaving the speaker (and the reader) in a state of reflective disquiet. The third figure symbolizes both loss and the ongoing search for meaning, a companion that walks with us, whether we acknowledge it or not.