241 Matching Annotations
  1. Jul 2024
    1. DR. Patrialis Akbar, S.H., M.H., Adil Supatra Akbar, S.H., M.Kn., Syaefullah Hamid,S.H., M.H., Muhammad Ainul Syamsu, S.H., M.H., Nurul Azmi, S.H., M.H.,Ardiansyah, S.H., Sudarman, S.H., dan Stefen Alves Tes Mau, S.H., kesemuanyaadalah Advokat dan Konsultan Hukum pada law firm Patrialis Akbar & CO,beralamat di Jalan Jalan Cakrawijaya I, Blok H Nomor 2a-3a, Cipinang Muara,Jatinegara, Jakarta Timur

      patrialis akbar sudah bebas! :(

    2. Remana Nugroho,S.H., Miftakhul Huda, S.H., Suryantara, S.H., M.H., Afif Rosadiansyah, S.H., M.H.,Fanadani Dewi, S.H., Yubi Supriyatna, S.H., Sisca Lisa Siagian, S.H., RR. WM.Yulianti Sapardi, S.H., David Ronald, S.H., M.H., M. Mahrus Ali, S.H., AndinaMardiana, S.H., Ibnu Hardiman, S.H., Makrifat Putra, S.H., M.H., Istiarta FajarPurnama, S.H., M.H.Li., Nur Farid, S.H., Nyoman Yustisia P. Rahardjo, S.H., M.H.,Rini Widiyanti, S.H., Setiyo Hermawan, S.H., Feince Poonis, S.H. Ummi KultsumAnifah Rohmaniya, S.H., M.H., Khairil Amin, S.H., Irvan Yudha Oktara, S.H.,Ridhotul Hairi, S.H., dan Fikri Surya, S.H., Advokat/Pengacara pada BengawanLaw firm, beralamat di Jalan Imam Bonjol Nomor 29, Jakarta Pusat

      juga begitu banyak!

    3. Abdul Aziz Saleh, S.H., M.H.,Mohammad Umar Halimuddin, S.H., M.H., Nur Fadly Danial, S.H., Moh. YudaSudawan, S.H., M.H., Akbar Junaid, S.H., Muhammad Amril Imran, S.H., Delvi, S.H.,M.H., Ramdhany Tri Saputra, S.H., Moh. Fahruddin, S.H., Audy Rahmat, S.H.,Muhammad Aulia Y. Guzasiah, S.H., M.H., Yusran, S.H., Pria Ramadhan Machmud,S.H., Muhammad Wahyu, S.H., Eko S, S.H., Muhammad Nursal, S.H., AzhamIdham, S.H., Dr. Rahmat, S.H., M.H., Fandy Irianto Djudjur, S.H., Julianto Asis, S.H.,M.H., R.A. Shanti Dewi Mulyaraharjani, S.H., M.H., Nasrullah, S.H., M.H. dan MunirKairoti, S.H., M.H. Advokat dan Konsultan Hukum yang tergabung pada TimAdvokasi Inti Partai Amanat Nasional

      begitu banyak!

    Annotators

    Annotators

    Annotators

  2. Apr 2024
  3. Dec 2023
    1. Failing to grasp the true message behind this allegory, traditional commentators misinterpreted this as a ‘real’ event of the remote past that involved physical participation of God, angels, Devil, Adam and his wife! Obviously, this is a very superficial, literal understanding of a very complex, metaphorical description – a description about the Creator’s ‘interaction’ with His creation. This is not only anthropomorphic and idolatrous but also a serious desecration of the underlying spirit of the Quran.

      tidak ada bukti, hanya pernyataan...

    2. Even in our current case study (2:29-38), we notice how the story of Adam appears in a context that repeatedly refers to ‘parables’ and ‘allegories’ (‘mathal’ or ‘parable’ in 2:17, 2:17, 2:26, 2:26; ‘mutashabihan’ or ‘allegories’ in 2:25)

      ini jawaban terhadap 'alegori'...

  4. Apr 2023
    1. PAS is only able to consider grants that will take place in Indonesia or online (ie, virtualprogramming) or a combination of in Indonesia and online (hybrid). The program should beprimarily for Indonesians, though a wider array of audiences/participants may be considered.Preference is for programs that offer meaningful and repeat contact with influential Indonesiansor Indonesians likely to develop into leaders in business, government, academic or civil society.Programs should promote U.S.-Indonesia relations, and may include Americans.

      to fulfill the preference part, then audience should be potential "leaders in business, government, academic or civil society"... then the fund is to sponsor their english learning...

    2. Education and Human Capacity: activities that promote educational partnerships andcooperation between U.S. and Indonesian education institutions (highschool and above),leadership and soft skill development, human capital development, and educational,exchange, and training opportunities for U.S. and Indonesian students and teachers.

      this seems the most appropriate for 1-on-1...

    3. All programs must include an Americancultural or media-related element, or a connection with American expert/s, organization/s,or institution/s in a specific field that will promote increased understanding of U.S. policyand perspectives.

      where is reducates registered? if in indonesia, then co-operation with etin's university...

    Annotators

  5. Oct 2022
    1. They generally have inadequate Islamic education, so it has great potential to cut off Harun Nasution's Muslim intellectual network at the IAIN or UIN.

      what? this conclusion comes out of the blue!

    2. The assumption that Harun Nasution's thinking is philosophical and, therefore, difficult to realize in social reality has been refuted in this article. This article proves that people do not need the details of the contents of an intellectual's thoughts, but rather their influence in opening people's minds to take action.

      where is the refutation?

    3. The assumption that Harun Nasution's thinking is philosophical and, therefore, difficult to realize in social reality has been refuted in this article. This article proves that people do not need the details of the contents of an intellectual's thoughts, but rather their influence in opening people's minds to take action.

      where is the refutation?

    4. However, Muslim intellectuals at UIN Suska Riau are active social actors. In this case, they are agents conducting negotiations with various ideas, including those of Harun Nasution.

      what are these ideas? how do they impact the audience?

    5. ome of these subjects are Introduction to Islamic Religion, Philosophy, Mysticism / Sufism, Theology, Sociology, and Research Methodology. Harun Nasution proposed all these courses in 1973 duringthe IAIN rector meeting in Indonesia (Jabali & Jamhari, 2002: p.33).

      repeated!

    6. This distinction makes lecture rooms and lecturers of UIN or IAIN in Indonesia a new locomotive for rational, critical, open, and moderate Islam.

      under the unwitting guise of u.s imperialism!

    7. Muslim intellectuals such as Harun Nasution supported the New Order policy, which focused on development.Harun Nasution (Uchrawi & Thaha, 1989:45) said:I returned to Indonesia because I agreed with the New Order. There were many changes made by this government, especially compared to the Old Order or that in Egypt, Pakistan, India, or Syria at the same time.

      precisely the problem!

    8. Some Muslim intellectuals such as Nurcholish Madjid, Abdur Rahman Wahid, Dawam Rahardjo, and others are active in non-political areas.

      no such thing as non-political areas... what is means is 'non-electoral political areas'!

    9. The interview was done among five lecturers of UIN Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau. They are selected based on the purposive sampling technique. In this article, all their names are pseudonyms to protect their privacy.

      cukupkah 5 orang, dan di satu kampus saja?

    10. multiple perspectives such as historical and sociological approaches, not only normative approaches

      normatif lawannya deskriptif, tapi istilah2 ini tak juga tepat menggambarkan apa yang mau dikatakan!

    11. Whether thisgeneralization adequately captures the maqasid and spirit of Nasution's reforms canonly be determined by making at least some assessment of the CONTENT of theprogram building Nasution implemented.

      pengakuan harun terhadap mu'tazilah...

  6. Aug 2022
    1. Itu sebabnya Habib Luthfi bin Yahya dengan tegas meminta bendera HTI diturunkan dalam sebuah acara. Mursyid yang juga keturunan Rasulullah ini paham benar dengan sejarah dan status hadits soal bendera ini. Saya ikut pendapatnya Imam Ibn Hajar dan ikut sikap Habib Luthfi.

      'appeal to authority'!

    1. Saya hanya ingin menunjukkan tanpa khilafah (baca: SPI) maka syariat Islam juga bisa diterapkan.

      sempit sekali kalau pemaknaan 'syariat islam' di sini dan di kalimat2 sebelumnya!

    2. Benarkah sejarah khilafah menunjukkan pertumpahan darah tersebut? Ketika Bani Abbasiyah merebut khilafah, darah tertumpah di mana-mana. Ini “rekaman” kejadiannya:Pasukan tentara Bani Abbas menaklukkan kota Damsyik, ibukota Bani Umayyah, dan mereka “memainkan” pedangnya di kalangan penduduk, sehingga membunuh kurang lebih lima puluh ribu orang. Masjid Jami’ milik Bani Umayyah, mereka jadikan kandang kuda-kuda mereka selama tujuh puluh hari, dan mereka menggali kembali kuburan Mu’awiyah serta Bani Umayyah lainnya. Dan ketika mendapati jasad Hisyam bin Abdul Malik masih utuh, mereka lalu menderanya dengan cambuk-cambuk dan menggantungkannya di hadapan pandangan orang banyak selama beberapa hari, kemudian membakarnya dan menaburkan abunya. Mereka juga membunuh setiap anak dari kalangan Bani Umayyah, kemudian menghamparkan permadani di atas jasad-jasad mereka yang sebagiannya masih menggeliat dan gemetaran, lalu mereka duduk di atasnya sambil makan. Mereka juga membunuh semua anggota keluarga Bani Umayyah yang ada di kota Basrah dan menggantungkan jasad-jasad mereka dengan lidah-lidah mereka, kemudian membuang mereka di jalan-jalan kota itu untuk makanan anjing-anjing. Demikian pula yang mereka lakukan terhadap Bani Umayyah di Makkah dan Madinah. Kemudian timbul pemberontakan di kota Musil melawan as-Saffah yang segera mengutus saudaranya, Yahya, untuk menumpas dan memadamkannya. Yahya kemudian mengumumkan di kalangan rakyat: “Barangsiapa memasuki masjid Jami’, maka ia dijamin keamanannya.” Beribu-ribu orang secara berduyun-duyun memasuki masjid, kemudian Yahya menugaskan pengawal-pengawalnya menutup pintu-pintu Masjid dan menghabisi nyawa orang-orang yang berlindung mencari keselamatan itu. Sebanyak sebelas ribu orang meninggal pada peristiwa itu. Dan di malam harinya, Yahya mendengar tangis dan ratapan kaum wanita yang suami-suaminya terbunuh di hari itu, lalu ia pun memerintahkan pembunuhan atas kaum wanita dan anak-anak, sehingga selama tiga hari di kota Musil digenangi oleh darah-darah penduduknya dan berlangsunglah selama itu penangkapan dan penyembelihan yang tidak sedikit pun memiliki belas kasihan terhadap anak kecil, orang tua atau membiarkan seorang laki-laki atau melalaikan seorang wanita. Seorang ahli fiqh terkenal di Khurasn bernama Ibrahim bin Maimum percaya kepada kaum Abbasiyin yang telah berjanji “akan menegakkan hukum-hukum Allah sesuai dengan al-Qur’an dan Sunnah”. Atas dasar itu ia menunjukkan semangat yang berkobar-kobar dalam mendukung mereka, dan selama pemberontakan itu berlangsung, ia adalah tangan kanan Abu Muslim al-Khurasani. Namun ketika ia, setelah berhasilnya gerakan kaum Abbasiyin itu, menuntut kepada Abu Muslim agar menegakkan hukum-hukum Allah dan melarang tindakan-tindakan yang melanggar kitab Allah dan Sunnah Rasul-Nya, segera ia dihukum mati oleh Abu Muslim. Cerita di atas bukan karangan orientalis tapi bisa dibaca di Ibn Atsir, jilid 4, h. 333-340, al-Bidayah, jilid 10, h. 345; Ibn Khaldun, jilid 3, h. 132-133; al-Bidayah, jilid 10, h. 68; al-Thabari, jilid 6, h. 107-109. Buku-buku ini yang menjadi rujukan Abul A’la al-Maududi ketika menceritakan ulang kisah di atas dalam al-Khilafah wa al-Mulk.

      harusnya mulai dari sejarah paling awal, minimal sampai al-qur'an dibakukan!

      merujuk maududi itu pasti 'salah'!

    3. 4. Kalau khilafah berdiri, maka ummat islam akan bersatu. Lantas kenapa harus ditolak? Bukankah kita menginginkan persatuan ummat Sejumlah dalil mengenai persatuan ummat Islam dan kaitannya dengan khilafah banyak dikutip oleh “pejuang khilafah” belakangan ini: Rasulullah SAW bersabda: “Jika dibai’at dua orang Khalifah, maka bunuhlah yang terakhir dari keduanya.” (HR. Muslim) Bagaimana “rekaman” sejarah soal ini? Ini daftar tahun berkuasanya khilafah yang sempat saya catat: Ummayyah (661-750) Abbasiyah (750-1258) Umayyah II (780-1031) Buyids (945-1055) Fatimiyah (909-1171) Saljuk (1055-1194) Ayyubid (1169-1260) Mamluks (1250-1517) Ottoman (1280-1922) Safavid (1501-1722) Mughal (1526-1857) Dari daftar di atas kita ketahui bahwa selepas masa Khulafa al-Rasyidin, ternyata hanya pada masa Umayyah dan awal masa Abbasiyah saja terdapat satu khalifah untuk semua ummat Islam. Sejak tahun 909 (dimana Abbasiyah masih berkuasa) telah berdiri juga kepemimpinan ummat di Egypt oleh Fatimiyyah (bahkan pada periode Fatimiyah inilah Universitas al-Azhar Cairo dibangun). Di masa Abbasiyah, Cordova (Andalusia) juga memisahkan diri dan punya kekhalifahan sendiri (Umayyah II). Di Andalusia inilah sejarah Islam dicatat dengan tinta emas, namun pada saat yang sama terjadi kepemimpinan ganda di tubuh ummat, toh tetap dianggap sukses juga. Pada masa Fatimiyyah di Mesir (909-1171), juga berdiri kekuasaan lainnya: Buyids di Iran-Iraq (945-1055). Buyids hilang, lalu muncul Saljuk (1055-1194), sementara Fatimiyah masih berkuasa di Mesir sampai 1171. Ayubid meneruskan Fatimiyyah dengan kekuasaan meliputi Mesir dan Syria (1169-1260). Dan seterusnya, … silahkan diteruskan sendiri. Jadi, sejarah menunjukkan bahwa khilafah itu tidak satu; ternyata bisa ada dua atau tiga khalifah pada saat yang bersamaan. Siapa yang dipenggal lehernya dan siapa yang memenggal? Mana yang sah dan mana yang harus dibunuh?

      tidak konsisten pandangan tentang hadis... diterima atau ditolak?

    1. Ketiga, kelompok yang hendak mengganti ideologi negara dengan menegakkan Negara Islam dan/atau khilafah. Tindakan mereka merusak kesepakatan pendiri bangsa. Ini radikal dalam politik.

      ini salah secara politik, apalagi dalam demokrasi!

    1. Yang menjadi masalah adalah saat sistem khilafah yang dikonseptualisasikan an-Nabhani ini dianggap sebagai satu-satunya kebenaran, dan itu dipaksakan sebagai khilafah yang benar,”

      menghindari substansi! yang menjadi masalah adalah 'penerapan syariat islam'!

    2. Dengan begitu kita akan memahami bahwa persoalan kepemimpinan—khilafah (red.)—ini sebetulnya sudah selesai dengan diterimanya Pancasila dan UUD 1945, bahkan telah ada amandemen UUD 1945. Kalau memang tak bisa menerima ya silakan ubah konstitusinya… tapi pertarungannya di level parlemen melalui pemilu,”

      kekurangan wawasan! bagaimana ri sendiri tercipta? apakah melalui pemilu?

    3. dalam konteks Indonesia, pandangan para ulama Nusantara yang mengerucut pada pembentukan Republik Indonesia adalah hasil ijtihad yang sah.

      istilah 'ulama nusantara' bermasalah... langsung menunjukkan hegemoni jawa!

  7. Aug 2021
    1. krisis kredit perumahan AS (Subprime Mortgage) adalah dampak dari kekalahan perang dagang AS melawan RRC

      bagaimana alurnya?

      kalau tmm, krisis utang swasta terutama rumah tangga... asalnya adalah keengganan defisit pemerintah...

    Annotators

  8. Jul 2021
    1. eltigani abdul-qadir hamidis Director of the OrientalPrinting and Publishing Groups, Manama, Bahrain. She was formerVisiting Professor in Education at the University of Toronto, Canada, and has contributed a number of articles in journals.

      Dr. Zahra Al Zeera is Director of the Oriental Printing and Publishing Groups, Manama, Bahrain. She was former Visiting Professor in Education at the University of Toronto, Canada, and has contributed a number of articles in journals. https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/5756532.Zahra_Al_Zeera

    Annotators

  9. Jun 2021
    1. That being said, if the tax liabilities happened to grow faster than government spending due to the nature of the tax structure and the institutional lending structure, such growth could be associated with currency strength. This is the recent US model. Growth has been propelled by an accelerating advance of private sector credit growth, so much so that the savings rate has gone negative for perhaps the first time ever. However, though this credit expansion has sustained GDP growth and total employment, it has not been sufficient to sustain corporate profit growth. And, an economy thus propelled may end very badly, as credit expansion without income expansion is case of increasing financial leverage. The mother of all Minsky bubbles is upon us

      sudah memprediksi krisis sejak makalah ini ditulis!

    1. further required to comply with debt and deficit limits. The following financial proposals, therefore, are presented only inresponse tocurrent political realities.

      batas utang terhadap pdb dan defisit terhadap kemenkeu itu berlaku kepada pemerintah (kemenkeu) aja kan? :)

    2. the transition-jobwage becomes the de facto minimum wage for the economy, eliminating the need for specific minimum wage legislation and enforcement, and stabilizing prices also in a recession

      bagaimana dengan negara yang tidak ada upah minimum, atau upah minimum sangat rendah?

    3. The advantage of the transition-jobover unemployment buffer stock is to make “more liquid” labor, because transition-jobworkers are more readily hired by the private sector, thereby better stabilizing private sector wages and prices during an expansion.

      mau menyelesaikan masalah yang dihadapi pada stagnasi 1970an...

    4. Price stability is promoted as the transition-job wagebecomes the defacto minimum wage in the economy, while at the same time the supply of workers employed in transition jobs are readily available to private sector employers and thereby act as an anti inflationary price anchor.

      karena bisa menjamin ketersediaan barang dan jasa!

    Annotators

    1. alat pembayaran yang sah dalam kegiatan perekonomian nasional dan internasional guna mewujudkan kesejahteraan sosial bagi seluruh rakyat Indonesia

      perlu juga disebut kaitannya untuk pemekerjaan!

    Annotators

    1. makna adanya instru-men institusional yang berwenanguntuk menegakkan syari’at Islamsesuai dengan kehendak PiagamJakarta. Dengan begitu, terdapatinstrumen institusional yang meno-pang kewajiban bagi negara danummat Islam untuk melaksanakansyari’at Islam sebagaimana dike-hendaki oleh Piagam Jakarta.

      tapi ini di tingkat kecil (keluarga, waris, dst.)... bagaimana suku bunga, misalnya? :(

    Annotators

  10. May 2021
    1. Pada awalnya, uang berfungsi sebagai alat penukar atau pembayaran. Seiring perkembangan peradaban manusia, uang juga berfungsi sebagai alat penyimpan nilai, satuan hitung, dan ukuran pembayaran yang tertunda.

      ini arus utama!

    Annotators

    1. alat pertukaran atau alat pembayaran seperti kulit kerang, batu permata, gading, telur, garam, beras, binatang ternak, atau benda-benda lainnya. Dalam perkembangan selanjutnya masyarakat menggunakan benda-benda seperti logam dan kertas sebagai uang.

      peran penguasa diabaikan! :(

    Annotators

    1. According to him, the bureaucracy was in practice overstaffed, underpaid, largely incompetent, with overlapping tasks and few responsibilities, whereas patronage distribution was the glue that held the system together (Crouch 2010:17). Compared to his pre-decessor President Suharto had more money to distribute which he derived from oil revenues and foreign aid. This enabled him to control various factions among the elite (military, business, bureaucrats) by granting licenses, access to projects, credit and jobs in exchange for loyalty. A pyramid of patron-client relationships ran down from the presidential palace to the villages, while the entire bureaucracy was permeated with officially encouraged corruption in the context of which government party Golkar operated as a nation-wide patronage network (Crouch 2010:161). There was an informal system of taxa-tion by which bureaucrats supplemented their modest salaries with selling of licenses and levying personalized forms of taxation. In a similar vein the mili-tary, whose budget was only partly covered by the state budget, gathered their own funding through business activities and security services.

      but this is to maintain stability by having only one source of power, the thing that is desired by the u.s and its allies, including the dutch! :(

    Annotators

    1. The growing movement for democratic constitutionalism and globaljustice in western legal and political research centres can play an importantpartnership role in the growth of democratic constitutionalism in practice.

      loe lagi, loe lagi! :(

    Annotators

    1. I believe that Abu Nasr al-Farabi was consciously carrying on the project begun by earlier generations of Muslim philosophers, such as al-Kindī and the circle of translators gathered around him. They had come up with the idea of applying the Greek philosophical and scientific heritage to the contemporary debate concerning the proper interpretation of the Islamic doctrine. As Dimitri Gutas has shown, for a brief but decisive moment in the eighth and ninth centuries CE, holders of political and economic power in the Abbasid state saw rationalist theology and philosophy as potential allies in the cultural sphere, and that the consequent investment in translation and indigenous Arabic literary activity is explicable in this way.

      this is what ovamir anjum criticized!

    1. He agrees in his interpretation with the Mu´tazila: “I believe that in order to make sense of the Qur’an, we need to understand the text metaphorically rather than literally

      but this gives power to the elite thinkers, whereas the qur'an is for all humans... hence the division of elite of elites, elite, and non-elite is wise! as well as its method of information dissemination!

    1. segenggam tanah yang diambildari seluruh unsur-unsur tanah sehingga keturunannyaberpotensi memiliki warna kulit yang berbeda dan karakteryang berbeda

      warna kulit - ok tapi karakter jauh lebih rumit pembuktiannya...

    Annotators

    1. In the image above, trilobites (1) live among many species that are not normally preserved. A typical Cambrian outcrop might produce only trilobites, brachiopods (2), mollusks (3), and crinoids (4). That is a tiny fraction of the full Cambrian biota, better represented by the roster of the Burgess Shale Cambrian Konservat-Lagerstatten. That community includes sponges Vauxia (5), Hazelia (6), and Eifellia (7); brachipods Nisusia (2); priapulid worms Ottoia (8); trilobites Olenoides (1); other arthropods such as Sidneyia (9), Leanchoilia (10), Marella (11), Canadaspis (12), Helmetia (13), Burgessia (14), Tegopelte (15), Naraoia (16), Waptia (17), Sanctacaris (18), and Odaraia (19); lobopods Hallucigenia (20) and Aysheaia (21); mollusks Scenella (3); echinoderms Echmatocrinus (4); and chordates Pikaia (22); among other oddities, including Haplophrentis (23), Opabinia (24), Dinomischus (25), Wiwaxia (26), Amiskwia (27), and Anomalocaris (28)

      ini di mana sumbernya?

    Annotators

  11. Apr 2021

    Annotators

    1. The inherent conflict between rulers seeking to keep their citizens free of debt bondage on the one hand, and creditors seeking their own gains at the palace’s expense, has been a thread running down the history of civilization. The distinctive feature of Western economies is privatization of credit, land, nature, and public infrastructure. That is the real detour from earlier millennia. Archaic societies treated land required for subsistence as a basic right for their citizenry. Instead of commodifying labor and land ownership to make debt bondage and foreclosure irreversible, Mesopotamian rulers proclaimed Clean Slates so as to avoid the financial polarization between creditors and debtors that later brought on a Dark Age. Today the debt dynamic is imposing austerity on today’s Western world, transferring property to creditors who have gained enough control over government to block protection of debtors.

      why is islamic history missing from this analysis?

    1. Dr. Ahmad Sofian, SH, MA Dr. Maqdir Ismail, SH., LLMErlangga Kurniawan, SH, MHIr. Zaim Saidi, MPA

      apakah sudah ada sudut pandang:

      1. mata uang komplementer?

      2. mata uang demokratis?

    2. Dunia Menuju Kembali ke Emas dan Perak

      ini benar, tapi langkah perantara melawan dominasi dolar as...

      china dan rusia misalnya masing2 meningkatkan cadangan emas...

      dalam konteks indonesia, poinnya adalah bagaimana memastikan ketersediaan emas sebagai mata uang untuk mewujudkan pasal 27 ayat 2!

    3. Sementara SDA terbatas jumlahnya.

      ini melawan ayat qur'an!

      1. alam itu makhluk juga, jadi bukan sumber daya semata!

      2. setiap makhluk sudah dijamin rezekinya, jadi masalahnya bukan pada ketersediaan, tapi sistem produksi dan distribusi!

    4. Tidak Semua Benda adalah Uang

      anything can be accepted as money, depending on agreement, and mmt requirement is for the "thing" of money to be obligated as tax payment unit...

    1. Dia membeberkan, bentuk dialog Jakarta-Papua yang disetujui Jokowi ialah “dialog sektoral”. Masing-masing dialog akan fokus terhadap sektor tertentu seperti pendidikan, kesehatan, kehutanan, perkebunan, pertambangan, perikanan, dan lainnya. Mereka perlu merancang tujuan, target, moderator, dan notulen dari dialog sektoral.

      kenapa sektoral pula? :(

    1. respondents in the Asia and the Pacific region emphasize on the needs for Links with indigenous and local knowledge, Open innovation, and Open infrastructures much more than the global inputs(almost twice more).

      global = west?

      asia pacific response can be categorized into identity and funding! :)

  12. Mar 2021
    1. Pekan ini saya memandu sebuah diskusi bersama tujuh perempuan pemberani –seorang guru, seorang pengacara, seorang ombudsman, dua psikolog, dan dua aktivis. Mereka mengadakan pertemuan pers guna mendukung Surat Keputusan Bersama, yang memungkinkan siswi dan guru perempuan untuk memilih apakah akan mengenakan jilbab (istilah umum di Indonesia untuk kain buat menutupi kepala, leher, dan dada) di sekolah negeri. SKB tersebut memerintahkan semua pemerintah daerah dan kepala sekolah untuk mencabut peraturan wajib jilbab di hampir 300.000 sekolah negeri di Indonesia.

      dibayar gak? berapa?

    1. Tidak jelas berapa banyak sekolah negeri, terutama di 24 provinsi yang mayoritas penduduknya Muslim, yang memiliki peraturan wajib jilbab untuk siswi Muslim.

      masak tidak jelas! malas amat sih meneliti!

    2. Status istimewa ini punya konsekuensi yang tak diinginkan. Ia memberanikan berbagai kelompok konservatif Islam di daerah lain di Indonesia.

      berlebihan ini... bagaimana papua? bali?

    3. Pandangan yang lama ditekan mencuat ke permukaan. Banyak kelompok etnis dan agama menuntut lebih banyak suara dalam ranah politik, ekonomi, dan budaya. Beberapa terlibat dalam konflik mematikan, termasuk di Aceh, di mana Gerakan Acheh Merdeka telah memperjuangkan kemerdekaan sejak 1970-an. Serangkaian militansi Islam juga muncul di berbagai daerah. Di Kalimantan, minoritas dijadikan sasaran kebencian. Di kepulauan Maluku terjadi kekerasan sektarian hingga 25,000 meninggal. Setidaknya 90.000 orang terbunuh dalam sebagian besar kekerasan etnis dan agama, dari Sumatra sampai Papua, dalam satu dekade setelah Soeharto mundur.[67]

      faktor destabilisasi oleh asing mau dikemanakan? :(

    4. Semua aktivis ingin merdeka, mendukung Bahasa Indonesia sebagai bahasa nasional, dan bekerja memperkuat organisasi masyarakat sipil. [52][52] Susan Blackburn, “How Do Women Influence Political Islam in Indonesia?”, Qantara, 15 September 2009, https://en.qantara.de/content/susan-blackburn-how-do-women-influence-political-islam-in-indonesia (diakses pada 23 Juli 2020).

      semua? apa buktinya? :(

    5. Wawancara dengan siswi atau narasumber perempuan lain dilakukan secara tatap muka, kecuali masa pandemi, dalam Bahasa Inggris dan Bahasa Indonesia, oleh pewawancara perempuan. Kami memberitahu narasumber bagaimana informasi yang dikumpulkan akan digunakan dan memberi tahu bahwa mereka bisa menolak atau menghentikan wawancara kapan pun. Kami juga menjelaskan tidak akan ada kompensasi atas partisipasi mereka.

      kenapa rupanya kalau ada kompensasi?

    6. Kami melakukan wawancara dengan para siswi dan anggota keluarga mereka di lokasi yang aman, terkadang dekat dengan sekolah. Demi alasan keamanan, termasuk ketakutan para narasumber akan adanya pembalasan berupa perundungan atau intimidasi, kami merahasiakan nama dari hampir semua siswi yang dipaksa memakai jilbab meski mereka sekarang sudah beranjak dewasa, dan, jika mereka masih anak-anak, kami juga merahasiakan nama orang tua mereka. Saat kami menyebut usia, kota, atau organisasi seseorang, kami melakukannya dengan persetujuan mereka. Kami menggunakan nama asli hanya jika individu tersebut bersikeras agar kami menggunakan nama mereka, dan hanya setelah kami yakin itu aman untuk dilakukan. Dalam kebanyakan kasus, orang-orang yang kami sebutkan namanya telah bicara sebelumnya dalam sejumlah laporan media atau menuliskan pengalaman mereka di blog atau media sosial.

      gimana memastikan memang ada wawancara? :(

    7. Bekerja dengan organisasi-organisasi Islam, termasuk Nahdlatul Ulama dan Muhammadiyah, untuk membuat kampanye guna melarang pemaksaan dan tekanan pada anak dan perempuan mengenakan jilbab atau pakaian Islami lainnya, dan mempromosikan toleransi dan kebhinnekaan.

      wtf? :(

    8. Mewajibkan perempuan dan anak perempuan pakai jilbab adalah bagian dari gerakan politik dan keagamaan konservatif untuk mengubah perlindungan hak asasi manusia di Indonesia. Ini merongrong hak anak dan perempuan untuk terbebas dari “kekerasan dan diskriminasi” berdasarkan konstitusi Indonesia. Perempuan berhak atas hak yang sama sebagaimana laki-laki, termasuk hak untuk mengenakan busana yang mereka pilih. Hukum hak asasi manusia internasional menjamin hak untuk secara bebas mewujudkan keyakinan agama seseorang dan hak atas kebebasan berekspresi. Setiap pembatasan terhadap hak ini hanya bisa dilakukan tujuan yang sah, diterapkan dengan cara yang tak sewenang-wenang dan non-diskriminatif.

      ini pasti salah!

    Annotators

    Annotators

  13. Feb 2021
    1. Apakah karena masalah ketidakmampuan menyusun anggaran, atau karena kepentingan sekelompok tertentu yang memiliki akses terhadap penyusunan anggaran atau karena ketidakmampuan meng-estimate cash-in-flow harus dibayar dengan tertunda atau dibatalkannya sejumlah penelitian bahkan bagi peneliti muda (dosen yang belum memiliki jabatan fungsional, yang sering diplesetkan sebagai tentara pelajar) akan layu sebelum berkembang?"

      masalah ini sudah saya selesaikan... :)

  14. Oct 2020
    1. The Indonesian government should use COPE and ARJUNA more than non-inclusive standards such as Scopus and Web of Science .

      cope and arjuna might not be comparable to scopus or wos?

      why not leiden manifesto, sf dora, or ocsdnet manifesto?

    2. The world should envy Indonesian researchers because many Indonesian journals are open access and the majority of scholars publish their articles free of charge.

      this is a simplistic statement... :(

    3. Open access is the start of science development.

      what does this mean? is it a normative or descriptive statement? if descriptive, i think it's wrong. how is open access the start of science development? science could be done or developed both open and closed (descriptive), but better open (normative)

      note:

      normative: how it should be

      descriptive: how it is

    4. This number reflects Indonesia’s important position in global academic publishing. We will explain what this means for the research ecosystem in Indonesia.

      how is it important to the world? the next sentence jumps to local context...

  15. Sep 2020
    1. no theological dimension was present in the eco-nomics of pre‐Mosaic Israel, of Egypt and Babylonia, and of Greece and Rome, the theologicalturn of Mosaic economics was an innovation in the history of economic thought

      absence of evidence does not mean evidence of absence...

      qur'an... adam...

    Annotators

  16. Jul 2020

    Annotators

  17. Jun 2020
    1. Inkorporasi ilmu dalam imperatif tatanan kapitalisme ini menghasilkan capaian-capaian ilmu pengetahuan mengabdi pada keberlangsungan sistem kapitalisme disatu sisi dan perlahan-lahan kehilangan semangat kritik emansipatorisnya (yang hadir diawal berjayanya akal budi yang berhasil membebaskan dirinya dari otoritas tradisi dan dogma keyakinan) bagi pemajuan kehidupan ummat manusia.

      bahas ini... :)

      https://www.newmandala.org/the-professor-and-the-secular/

      https://www.academia.edu/5072649/The_Professor_and_the_Secular

  18. May 2020
    1. How the Islamic economic thought evolved from the latter to the former remains an important area of research

      because of the need to respond to war! but why go to war in the first place?

    Annotators

  19. Apr 2020
    1. Kendati begitu, Jokowi mengingatkan agar defisit yang di atas 3 persen ini tidak berlangsung lebih dari tiga tahun. Artinya, defisit harus kembali di bawah 3 persen pada 2023 mendatang.

      tapi utang akan meningkat, dan berdasarkan pemahaman ini, nanti akan ada usaha mereduksi utang ini, yang berarti austeritas! :(

  20. Feb 2020
    1. Alternatively, by saying that researchers pursue taxpayer funding (rather than scientific funding) the author may be making the implicit assumption that researchers compete to work on projects in the taxpayers’ interest, rather than scientific interest. What do you think?

      i would not agree to this framing...

      i would put it this way... researchers, just like any other humans , are not immune to rewards and punishment, (or STRUCTURE) of their professions...

      if we (the PUBLIC) wish researchers to pursue scientific (however defined) interest, then the structure must be modified accordingly...

      who created the current structure? public and private elites... in democratic states, the public certainly have power over public elites, so they should pressure these public elites to change the structure...

      now, why is the public concerned with science and scientific advancement? to my understanding, this concern is often expressed in state's constitution, which created the public in each particular state...

      then we come to the issue what if the public interest is sometimes against scientific interest? well, this is where (democratic) negotiation takes place... scientists must convince the public that science is useful for them, in all its seeming 'uselessness'...

      many times the scientists only need to convince the public elites for this, not the public as a whole... but i think it's good if scientists are always in touch with the public as a whole with regards to their work if they use public funding...

      in conclusion, i had fun reading the comments, both at the original site and ea forum, because some commenters 'pierced the veil of ideology' behind the original article, and some of the back-and-forth were hilarious with my knowledge of 'money and the state'... would love to expand on this later when i have time... :)

    2. Do you think that when taxpayers complain that research funds are being misspent, they are essentially complaining that not enough research is being done to solve their problems?

      with the understanding of my earlier reply, this should read as: "... when the PUBLIC complain that research funds are being misspent..."

    1. the point here is that individual taxpayers don’t have the right to be indignant about their funds are being misspent by the NIH, as their taxes are not, in fact, being used by the NIH

      nope... :)

  21. Nov 2019
    1. Another case is a paper published in the Non-Open Access journa l requiresapaidsubscription to the publisher for the article to be read or downloaded

      the preceding and this sentences need standalone paragraphs and elaboration... :)

      so this paper is not about values, it's about the practicality or instrumentality of inarxiv... :)

    2. Meanwhile,anarticlewhich under review process would be useful for other researchers if there is a preprint version that can be used

      based on this statement alone, this is both good and bad...

    3. Now it is easy for academics to upload (1) preprint articles (prior peer review), without having to wait for the long w inding road of the review process,(2) postprint artic les, and even (3) articles that have been published but hasn’t online.

      it has always been easy, the only problem was google scholar indexing?

    1. However, it is said that you were banned in 2018, but I know that in 2019 you talked about your organisation per “we” (http://www.eurodoc.net/news/2019/interview-with-jon-tennant-on-open-science-mooc). So was that ban decision binding or secret? I do not understand also why the case became so famous last days. Is your former community asking you for more explanations? Or trying to condemn more?

      this is also very puzzling! why hold off for one year? was there a precipitating event from 2018 to 2019? so "violation moment" did not just just occur once, but also between 2018 and 2019? why the need to post publicly in 2019 but not 2018? also, is it true that members of the opencon code of conduct committee is kept secret? if yes, why?

  22. Oct 2019
    1. it is Schumpeterian activities that will enable a less developedeconomyto mobilize its labor resources towards higher productivity occupations since they can continually expand the market and thus increase the division of labor.

      how about colonialism and imperialism? slavery?

    2. n order to reach such results, one also needs to posit many unrealistic assumptions such as the prior existence of full employment, that there are no externalities, factors can move easily between industries, there are no scale economies, and that both economies are already producing both goods that are to be traded

      sama2 tidak realistis, cuma ini fokusnya konstitusional?

    3. the state names the ‘money of account’ (unit of account) that the citizenry’s debt will be denominated in (Wray1998).

      why and how does the state has this power? violence?

    Annotators

  23. Sep 2019
    1. anchored at the kabupatenwhere a programme officer (under the bupati) is to coordinate a technical, statistical/data, MIS andadministrative team. The programme could reach out to other developmental and promotional programmesin the country to establish (two-way) synergies and also share personnel and infrastructure

      kalau jamppi, kepling/desa/ranting!

    2. helping to alleviate situations of poverty and un/underemployment, and creating productiveassets and services for the economy

      job guarantee first and foremost is a macroeconomic stabilizer! but does this only apply to monetarily sovereign countries?

      what does it mean that indonesia is a monetarily sovereign country but low in currency hierarchy diagram?

    Annotators

  24. May 2019
    1. ag: "The Netherlands never has good intentions; they just continued with all their knowledge about Jan Pieterszoon Coen -van Heutsz -Daendels -Colijn who became Prime Minister -Colonialism -Slavery -Robbery

      are these under the same state structure?

  25. Apr 2019
    1. Contrary to mainstream propaganda, nation-states can still influence corporate behavior. To do so they must engage in regional and international cooperation aimed at instituting a new global social contract that would level up living standards, impose labor and environmental regulations upon transnational corporations, and regulate global financial actors in the interests of equitable and sustainable development. A rebuilt international socialist movement must work towards international cooperation among states to re-institute capital controls and reverse the unfavorable economic conditions of developing nations. If the social democratic welfare state can no longer be sustained strictly on a national level, it must be created on an international level. Absent a worldwide New Deal, even the “privileged” workers of the advanced industrial nations may join the global majority in poverty and hunger. If global social democratic capitalism proves impossible, there will be no chance for an international movement towards the full socialization of the world economy.

      my idea exactly!

    2. While the exact details of a socialist economy are open to debate, it will most likely be a mixture of democratic planning of major investments (e.g., expenditure on infrastructure, investment in natural monopolies such as telecommunications, utilities, transport) and market exchange of consumer goods. Large, concentrated industries such as energy and steel would be publicly owned and managed by worker and consumer representatives. Many consumer-goods industries would be run as cooperatives. Workers would design the division of labor within their workplaces and thus overcome the authoritarianism of the traditional capitalist firm. Economic planning would set a guiding strategy by means of fiscal and monetary policy, with the daily coordination of supply and demand left to the market. But this market would be socialized by rendering it transparent. Enterprises would be obliged to divulge information about the design, production processes, price formation, wage conditions, and environmental consequences of the goods that they make. Publicly supported collectives—consumers’ unions—would analyze this data and propose norms to govern various aspects of these practices. Information about actual production processes and proposed norms would then be disseminated via universal, publicly supported communication networks such as the Internet. This would encourage dialogue between producers and consumers over what is socially needed.

      this is indonesian vision?

    1. Under the theme of "Mission Possible: Seizing the Opportunities of Future Work to Drive Inclusive Growth," Bappenas co-organized the forum with the Australian government.

      forum pembangunan indonesia kok ada keterlibatan pemerintah lain? apakah mereka punya konstitusi yang sama dengan indonesia sehingga kebutuhan dan pengetahuan mereka sama? kan tidak...

      kemudian, kalau pun boleh, kenapa tidak ada australia development forum yang melibatkan indonesia?

  26. Nov 2018
    1. MarwahSINTA ditentukanolehakuntabilitasdantatakelolatermasukpemantauanberbagaiketidakpatutan(misconduct)ilmiahyang tercatatsecarakuantitatif

      SINTA sekarang sudah tidak ada marwahnya... :)

    2. institusiyang bersangkutanmengetahuihaltersebut

      yang berasal dari medan pasti tahu... di grup2 whatsap medan malah sudah disebut2 kartel sitasi... walaupun antara sesama teman2 para koruptor sitasi... :)

    3. Avoiding plagiarism, self-plagiarism, and other questionable writing practices

      ini menyelesaikan masalah di tingkat individual, padahal masalah korupsitasi ini juga bersumber dari tingkat struktural... (misalnya, desain sinta yang menyertakan prosiding tanpa algoritma penjaga...) :)

    4. Perlupendalamanterhadapartikelpadasejumlahauthor dengansitasitinggiuntukmengidentifikasiperilakusitasi, etikapenulisanilmiahdanintegritasilmiah

      ini sudah saya lakukan, salah satunya melalui dokumen korupsitasi... :)

    1. Bank Indonesia has one single overarching objective: to establish and maintain rupiah stability...inflation as the final objective

      indonesia tidak dua mandat seperti fed? kenapa full employment tidak menjadi salah satu mandat?

    Annotators

  27. Oct 2018
    1. Published findings funded by government grants are supposedly to be ‘liberated’ from locked file cabinets and the annals of selfish journals, but any research produced by private funding is nowhere expected to be held to the same standards. Who is it precisely that is capable of comprehension, and therefore really needs unfettered access to publicly funded research? Indeed, what is often misrepresented as ‘openness’ and ‘transparency’ is in fact a posteriori private expropriation. After all, is the average citizen really so des-perate to read and selectively disseminate the latest research reports, or is it instead the corporate research manager? For ‘the widest possible dissemination’, read ‘the most readily monetizable free resource’

      this is where mirowski can be critized... how about the north-south divide? the center-periphery phenomenon discussed in the routledge book?

    1. any natural or legal person

      i would begin an 'attack' (or 'response' if tone must be 'pc'... :)) here... :)

      the acceptance of legal person is problematic... see, for example:

      "For example, and this one bears profound implications, the Islamic so-called “legal” and intellectual traditions have repeatedly, and throughout many centuries, faced one of the most formidable questions that human societies have had to deal with for millennia; that is, the extent of moral responsibility to which the natural individual can and should bear. In every case, the Muslim jurists and their fellow (“non-legal”) intellectuals, remained committed to a view that bars the waiving of moral responsibility from the individual. If the individual is the bearer of ultimate responsibility for living life, he or she must bear the onus of consequences. The severing of this link in the Western world has led to severe and now cruel consequences: for one example, the multinational corporation(s?) that rules our lives. Not that the English Parliament of old did not fully understand the unethical practices of companies of limited liability. It did. In fact, shortly after legalizing this juridical personality for the first time in human history, they reversed their legislation and barred it, the reasoning behind the rejection being its immoral character and consequences. But then–and this is resoundingly telling–it was brought back to the realm of legality again, in London but mainly in Delaware, only to end up ruling the world and wreaking havoc with it. The sharia jurists always insisted on moral (read now: legal) accountability, although their technical and substantive reasoning could have easily accommodated a law of corporation (which could have been developed along the lines of thought that created the waqf system, for example). Few people nowadays realize that the sharia’s techniques of legal reasoning a thousand years ago were at least as sophisticated as any legal reasoning that we know today. But the corporation and much else that allows fictitious bodies to escape legal liability were ontologically aborted at the pre-embryonic stage."

      http://www.jadaliyya.com/Details/30782

      but this opens up a whole can of worms, or the proverbial (and then literal) pandora's box... especially when considering timur kuran's work on this... :)

      another attack/response, much more suitable for europe, is this: http://bostonreview.net/class-inequality/lenore-palladino-public-benefit-incorporated

      and this: "To effect such change the debate needs to be prompt and global. Reforms should be considered through a range of institutions and processes: via provisions in the World Trade Organisation negotiations; in European Union bodies in Brussels; in parliaments and state houses. In an atmosphere of renewed calls for deregulation our starting-point is to turn the argument around and say: if regulated protection is the problem, let us begin with the immunity given to shareholders." https://www.opendemocracy.net/globalization-institutions_government/corporate_responsibilities_4605.jsp

  28. Sep 2018
    1. First, Indonesia needs to invest much more in rebuilding its crumbling physical infrastructure, which is a serious impediment to faster growth. Increased investment in social infrastructure too, to expand and improve the quality of its health services and its education at all levels, particularly in at the secondary and tertiary levels, is essential to stronger growth. Indonesia must also improve its governance and institutions, particularly its bureaucracy and its legal and judicial systems. It remains one of the most corrupt countries in East Asia. Indonesia needs to root out corruption, since a country with pervasive corruption cannot hope to become a dynamic and prosperous country.

      what's the evidence for this?

    2. IMF figures show that over the period 2014–2030 the BRICs are expected to grow so fast that their share of the world economy will rise from 19.4 per cent to 30.3 per cent, exceeding the economies of the US, the EU and Japan. In 2010, China overtook Japan as the second-largest economy in the world, after the US. With a projected 2030 GDP at 94 per cent of that of America, China’s economy will not be far behind the US.

      is this a zero sum game, where one country wins and another lose?

    1. kedaulatan, yang lebih memberi keuntungan bagi perseorangan, kelompok maupun perusahaan multinasional ketimbang bagi kepentingan nasional.

      apakah perjanjian seperti ini tidak terjadi kemudian?

    Annotators

    1. Lukman Lukman1, Muhammad Dimyati2, Yan Rianto1, Imam Much Ibnu Subroto3, Tole Sutikno4, Deden Sumirat Hidayat5, Irene M Nadhiroh6, Deris Stiawan7, Sam Farisa Chaerul Haviana3, Ahmad Heryanto7, Herman Yuliansyah6

      11 orang 7 institusi... apa yang melatari pemilihan institusi2 ini?

      kenapa tidak ada orang sosial humaniora?

      kenapa tidak ada orang sulawesi papua kalimantan?

      dengan indonesia yang begitu beragam, faktor2 keragaman apa lagi yang belum dipertimbangkan? bidang studi dan wilayah sudah...

    2. Rankings will be announced periodically (4 times a year) because real-time rankings may confuse policy-makers if rankings serve as a tool for rewards and penalties based on research performance.

      belum ada justifikasi ranking baik di makalah dan di situs sinta sendiri...

    1. Concerns for such journals are identified by Scopus, or flagged to Scopus by the research community and are taken seriously. If the concern is legitimate, the title will be added to the Re-evaluation program and re-evaluated by the CSAB in the year of identification of the publication concern

      how to find out these concerns?

    2. Outlier journal examples include rapid and unexplainable changes to number of articles published or unexplainable changes in geographical diversity of authors or affiliations. Other features that the algorithm considers are self-citation rate and publication concerns,amongst others.

      what are 'others'? when can the radar criteria be found?

    3. if a journal does not meet all of the six benchmarks for two consecutive years, it will be flagged for re-evaluation by the independentScopus Content Selection and Advisory Board(CSAB)

      'independent'... how is csab independence ensured? any financial compensation? who pay for csab meetings?

    1. al journals, to their concentration in a handful of giant

      Western

      based publishing companies , and on the other by the introduction of quant i fied measurements , o f scientific production in academic promotion procedures, referred to here as ‘ metrification ’ . It has been argued that the quest for a higher IF ranking might induce editors to prefer ‘citable’, mainstream papers to more specializ ed ones (Poria , Schwartz and Uysal 2015) , and shape scholars’ decisions on the kinds of topics and issues they study, and on their choice of methodology and publication venues (Smeyers and Burbules 2011). The perceived centrality of IF might thus deflect t he focus of scientific work from what to publish to where to publish (cf. P e rdue 2015), and to m otivate researchers to pursue mainstream topics of research, believed to be suitable for publication in high IF journals (Poria et al. 2015), rather than tackli ng more innovative, explorat ory

      The Dissemination of the Western Publication Regime to Emerg ing Regions The academic publication regime is culturally, institutionally and linguistically rooted in the West , and bears a distinct Western, or Eurocentric, or even Anglocentric character . The regime was introduced in the West in the contemporary period under the

      pressures of a neo

      liberal ideology , which has expanded from the traditional domain of the economy to embrace other, previously relatively autonomou s domain s such as health , art, religion and academia. But as th is

      neo

      liberal orie ntation increasingly spread to the emerg ing world regions ( Poo c haroen and Brillantes 2013), it engendered a process of ‘ university restructuring [which] is taking a similar path in a variety of countries with different social, political and economic regimes ’ (Torres and Schugurensky 200 2: 429). Under the impact of

      the forces of globalization, and the growing hegemony of neo

      liberalism in many countries, the leadership of universities around the world ha s reconsidered their traditional missions in favor of concerns about excellence, efficiency, expenditures and rate s of retur n , and the enhancement of their global rankings. As part of this re orientatio n, the universities’ leadership adopt ed the requirements of the publication regime , despite its Eurocentrism, and a growing criticism of its metric indicators and ranking methods in Western academia. Consequently, a major transition took place in the universities in th e emerging regions, from interna l traditions of

      Though some of these journals copied the Western procedure of refereeing submissions, the quality of their publications was often problematic and their impact on the field generally low ; they were mostly not included in the major international journal indexes

      The tendency to relate p romotion prospects

      to ISI

      and Scopus

      listed journals has been generated in no small part by the creation in 2001 of the

      Thai

      Journal Citation Index Cent er (TCI) , which in 2008 expanded its coverage to the humanities and social sciences ( Sombatsompop et al. 201 ).

      Universities in Asia , for example, have engaged some senior, often retired, internationally recognized academics from Western countries, to mentor, supervise and guide early career staff , and sometimes even to jointly publish articles with them . In Southeast Asia, s eminars , in which foreign researchers co a ch ed aspiring local staff in writing scientific papers , have been initiated by universities in Brunei, Malaysia , Indonesia and Thailand . Such seminars are less concerned with the subject matter of the early career staff’s work, and more with the way of its pre sentation. In one such instance, two of the authors of this article were invited to a workshop organized in 2014 by the t ourism d epartment of a u niversity in northern Thailand to guide and advise advanced students and early career staff members from several academ i c institution s in writ ing papers publishable in prestigious international journals in tourism studies .