- Sep 2024
-
bipartisanpolicy.org bipartisanpolicy.org
-
% of children
compare to state average in virginia- bodes well
-
-
www.doe.virginia.gov www.doe.virginia.gov
-
(VQB5)
1 - Method to measure current state of ECC quality
-
- Nov 2023
-
www.pewresearch.org www.pewresearch.org
-
g economic inequa
most think that fed government and large corporations share the responsibility of regulating income inequality. This is fundamentally problematic, as politicians are legally allowed to take massive donations from such corporations to support their interests. Unions offer a disruption of this power dynamic, backed by the leverage of withholding the labor that creates this wealth, to bend the ears of corporations and the federal government alike.
-
-
www.pewresearch.org www.pewresearch.org
-
Most Americans Say There Is Too Much Economic Inequality in the U.S., but Fewer Than Half Call It a Top Priority
use this page to make the point that majority of americans veiw income inequality as a problem, and the following page to prove that it is a problem. also use this page to say that "relativly few see it as a top policy priority for the federal government." alternative, more direcet method of addressing such inequalities - circumnavigating the powers of the federal government and building up strong unions
-
-
www.pewresearch.org www.pewresearch.org
-
The reason for this is that middle-income families are more dependent on home equity as a source of wealth than upper-income families, and the bursting of the housing bubble in 2006 had more of an impact on their net worth.
though this market factor caused this, include about how union membership mitigates for reliance on home equity with wages and benefits, alongside a platform for adressing issues
-
-
Local file Local file
-
Partlybecause it was established with little scientificbasis roughly 50 years ago, the thresholds forthe official measure are widely understood tobe too low
the poverty level as a measurement understates the actual amount of economically vulnerable citizens in the united states.
-
crowding effect,
crowding effect vs threat effect
-
f demo-graphics and economic performance are thedominant influences on U.S. working pov-erty, unionization might play only a marginalor insignificant role.
"economic performance" and worker productivity has skyrocketed in recent years while wages have remained stagnant, as there is no incentove for those in power to advocate for raised wages
-
Unions and theregulations they establish might create rentsonly for protected insiders, and might exclude,have little impact on, or even worsen thelabor market for poor workers.
doesnt adress union threat effect, in which unions increase benefits for non-union workers.
-
Third, even if unions raise some workers’earnings, these benefits might not reach thebottom of the labor market. Less-skilled, low-paid workers are unlikely to be unionized orcovered by union contracts.
essentially saying "unions might not help the working poor becuase unions are weak." if more joined unions, they would be stronger... this point is irrelevent.
-
Since the early2000s, only about 3 percent of workers inNorth Carolina have been unionized—a levelunprecedented in available data for affluentdemocracies
emphasizing weak unions in the US
-
The problem is that the working poor, notthe unemployed poor, are the most typicalpoor
most impovrished americans have jobs. 61% of impovrished families in the US have at least one employed member
-
The effects ofunionization are larger than the effects of states’ economic performance and social policies
unions are more influential on working poverty than state policy and economic performance
-
Researchthat does exist on working poverty concentrates on demographics and economic performanceand neglects institutions.
further comment on current literature
-
U.S.poverty research devotes much more attention to joblessness than to working poverty.
because poverty among the working poor does not fit the US narrative that poverty can be overcome with hard work, and that the unemployed are lazy and s\deserving of their poverty.
-
-
Local file Local file
-
The Treaty of Detroit was succeeded bythe Washington Consensus, an era of deregu-lation and eroded pay norms in which earn-ings inequality increased as managers’ andprofessionals’ compensation rose.
lots of important history regarding unionization
-
n the1960s,
paragraph gives historical account of how unions effectivly influence and work alongside politicians and presidents to enforce fair wages
-
Union political pressurealso reaches beyond wages to social legisla-tion. For example, major unions regularlybacked proposals for universal healthcare andsupported the creation of Medicare in themid-1960
the ability for unions to fight for equity is not limited to labor conditions. just as unions were blocked by policies influenced by corperate donations, unions are in the unique position to combat what is essensially bribary with extra steps- they have the pwoer to strike and threaten corporate profits. In this way, unions serve as a leverage-backed platform to enact equitible change in opposition to greed-driven policy.
-
Reuther aimed to “reshape theconsciousness of millions of industrial work-ers, making them disciplined trade unionists,militant social democrats, and racial egalitar-ians.”
can be put in conversation with individualist culture article about american culture being inheretly anti-union- that unions have the power to reshape culture within its members, just as this one leader did.
it is effective in doing this as its platform is concerning issues that immediately and tangibly effect the futures of its members
-
In our theory of the moraleconomy, unions help materialize labor mar-ket norms of equity (1) culturally, throughpublic speech about economic inequality, (2)politically, by influencing social policy, and(3) institutionally, through rules governingthe labor market
theory of moral economy
-
We relax these assumptions, arguing thatthe labor market is embedded in a moraleconomy in which norms of equity reduceinequality in pay. The moral economy con-sists of norms prescribing fair distributionthat are institutionalized in the market’s for-mal rules and customs. In a robust moraleconomy, violation of distributional normsinspires condemnation and charges of injus-tic
authors asset otherwise, that unions change the social norms of our economy. in turn, violation of these norms results in "condemnation and charges of injustice"
-
The theory of union threat takes a rationalistview of employers and a minimalist view oflabor market institutions. Employers mini-mize labor costs and only raise wages whenthreatened with even greater pay increasesthrough unionization
traditional understanding of union threat effect
-
The theory of union threat has distribu-tional implications. If unions threaten toorganize low-wage workers, employers mayraise wages, thereby equalizing the wagedistribution
union threat effect explained and proven to be true
-
Employer opposition unfolded in anincreasingly adverse political context forlabor. Hacker and Pierson (2010) report thatan influx of corporate donations influencedpolicymakers to oppose pro-union reforms oflabor law in the 1970s. Union reform effortswere defeated, and the National Labor RelationsBoard’s rightward shift under Republicanadministrations made organizing more diffi-cult in the 1980s. Political defeats in the1970s and 1980s yielded a set of “enervated”labor laws that enabled employers to blockorganizing campaigns and weaken existingunions (Cowie 2010:288)
unions outspent by corperate donations to policy makers to oppose pro union labor efforts. This is essentially bribery, how is this legal?
also rightward shifts in government to block unions
-
The biggest driver of decline in the per-centage unionized was employment growthoutside the traditional union strongholds ofmanufacturing, construction, and transportation,utilities, and communication
a factor which led to union decline was a decrease in economic relevence of the most unionized industries at the time
-
In this case, deunioniza-tion explains a fifth of the inequality increasefor women and a third for men. The decline oforganized labor among men contributes asmuch to rising wage inequality as does thegrowing stratification of pay by education.
though these two factors are equally influential, deunionization could easily have a compunding effect alopngside any other market factor. As workers have less leverage and voice, they have no platform to advocate for the issues that conern them, such as these market factors. The timely and effective fixing of issues that concern laborers requires strong unions, even for market factors not directly related to the decision to unionize.
as larger companies put profits before people time and time again, organized labor offers an opportunity for a discussion of fair labor backed by leverage of strike- enabeling them to speak to more powerful employers in a language they can undertand,: their profits.
-
Union decline marks an erosion ofthe moral economy and its underlying distri-butional norms.
in a less "moral economy" where workers rights are respected, they will be less likley to show any "loyalty" to their employers and job retension will be lower. costs for hiring and training new employees, loss of experienced senior staff who can guide new employees, etc.
-
We argue thatunions also contribute to a moral economythat institutionalizes norms for fair pay, evenfor nonunion workers
unions advocate not only for bennefits and pay, but "norms of equity" in the labor market. as non union employers must keep up with unionized employers offering workers bennefits and better pay to retain skilled staff, and to "advert the trheat of union organization" in their own workforce to retain power, they too are compelled to adhere to concerns of equity for their workers. WIthout unions, there is no self-interested reason for emploeyrs to show such concern.
-
market explanation
inequality rises is blamed on tech, immigration, outsourcing of unskilled labor, higher cost of college for skilled workers as a result of icnreased demand for skilled labor- weaker unions unable to advocate for workers a less popular explanation
market explanation contextualizes issue as unfixible and out of the hands of employers, though this is not the case...
-
-
www.proquest.com www.proquest.com
-
Finally, other employers in the same geographical area, although not affected by the ordinance, may boost wages to effectively compete for comparable employees in the labor market, an economic phenomenon also referred to as a spill-over effect.
ordeinances, although often only covering employees under specific conidtions or in certain sectors, pressure employers to better compensate their employees to remain competetive regardless of if they're required to by law/
-
One earlier stud
many many examples of the 3 biggest critiques of a living wage being proven wrong
-
ssuming this entire increase was passed on to consumers, prices would rise approximately 2.1 %
a small price to pay for a living wage
-
Finally, more employers noticed improvements as opposed to deterioration in employee behavior after living wage implementation including overall worker performance (35 % vs. 4 %), morale (47 % vs. 16 %), customer service (45 % vs. 3 %), less absenteeism (29 % vs. 5 %), reduction in disciplinary problems (44 % vs. 9 %) or equipment maintenance problems (29 % vs. 4 %).
employee quality and effort skyrockets after receiving adequate pay
-
As estimated by these researchers, this lost revenue could be recovered in its entirety by charging each airline passenger an additional $1.42
this small change in consumer cost would compensate employers completly for paying their workers a living wage in this case
-
According to Freema
response to job loss critique
-
these critics, implementing a living wage will result in a decreased number of jobs for low-wage workers; alternatively, it also could lead to covered employees being replaced by workers possessing higher skills. Decreased employment opportunities for low-wage workers in cities with living wage ordinances also would result from companies fleeing to locations where they are not required to abide by these wage provisions. Finally, increased costs for municipal governments will ultimately lead to less money being devoted to ameliorating poverty as well as providing more job opportunities to low-wage workers
critique of living wage laws
-
Although calculating the number of low-wage workers included under living wage statutes is difficult, a conservative estimate would place the figure at between 100,000 to 250,000 as of the end of 2002. This represents a tiny percentage of the estimated 30 to 40 million people who receive poverty-level wages in this country (Luce 2002; p. 404, 2004, p. 53).
reletivly few are protected by these limited ordinances
-
Effective monitoring is an essential component for the successful implementation of a living wage ordinance.
as not all workers are covered by these limited living wage ordinances, many are not aware weather or not they qualify to make a living wage. Fthey are less able to tell if they are being underpaid if they dont know the protections provided to them
-
Research has demonstrated that living wage laws are more likely to be passed because of the specific political, rather than economic, conditions that exist in geographic areas throughout the country. These circumstances include the presence of more liberal voters, a local chapter of ACORN and higher union density rates
predictors of living wage ordinances being passed, includes unions.
-
iving wage statutes usually assume one of two types
coverage under living wage ordienances only cover some jobs
-
-
psycnet.apa.org psycnet.apa.org
-
or of this
essentially arguing that the visibility of wealthy "neighbors" influencs life sadisfaction in tandem with actual wealth inequality. As extravigantly wealthy individuals have become more visible in the digital age, along with increasing actual wealthy inequality, people are not only poorer but far more misrable! yay!
-
-
www-jstor-org.proxy.library.vcu.edu www-jstor-org.proxy.library.vcu.edu
-
222 State and Local Government Review 43(3)increases that local government employeesmay have received during this survey periodsuch as merit increases, step increases, and/orlongevity pay. While it is reported that benefitshave generally increased during this surveyperiod, this may or may not be a result of moregenerous benefits being extracted. Risinghealth care costs are a major budgetary drainon local governments and paying for these mayaccount for significant compensation increases.In light of this discussion, it is important toconsider limitations to this study. First, datacollection methods in this study relied on selfreports that may be susceptible to response bias.Second, the survey focused on the largest countyand city governments. The extent to whichsmaller local governments have similar or different experiences and practices is not clear.Finally, the survey did not capture the size of thebudget shortfall, and this may have influencedthe choice regarding some responses. Despitethese limitations, this research offers importantinsights into public sector compensation practices in the United States.ConclusionThe fiscal stress on local governments is projected to continue for the next several years;and the choices available for cities and countiesappear to be limited. The workforces of localgovernments are becoming increasingly unionized. As a result, wages and benefits have beenincreasing; even during tough economic times.The inability (or unwillingness) of many jurisdictions to raise taxes and the reluctance ofpublic sector unions to agree to wage and benefit reductions will leave many state and localgovernments with limited options and make itincreasingly difficult to offer the same levelof services in their jurisdict
increasing benefits regardless of financial stress for localm governments - the money is there. find above point on how counties tend to have less financial distress than cities, as they are more likley to have wealthy suburbs in their tax bases. meanwhile, cities have a greater burden of infrastructure to maintain, and more often support those who rely on benefits
-
- Aug 2023
-
read.amazon.com read.amazon.comKindle1
-
aaaa
-
- May 2023
-
www.sciencedirect.com www.sciencedirect.com
-
ne of the key observations from this table is that roundworm and whipworm were found in more countries than any other parasites. They are both faecal-oral parasites, spread by poor sanitation and faecal contamination of food.
Most prevalent parasities spread by shit in food, yet roman and greek knowlegde of sanitization was widely known in europe following the collapse of the roman empire.
-
There is some evidence for the use of topical medications containing mercury to treat ectoparasites in 1400s Europe. Ferdinand II of Aragon was the King of Naples in Italy, and he lived from 1467 to 1496. Analysis of his naturally mummified body shows that he was infected with both head lice (P. humanus capitis) and pubic lice (P. pubis). Tests of the hair from his head showed very high levels of mercury (827 parts per million), suggestive of the topical application of a mercury-containing medicine to try and kill off the head lice. However, his pubic hair did not show these very high levels (10 parts per million), implying that he did not undergo treatment for his pubic lice
evidence for mercury to treat ectoparasites
-
Hippocrates was an ancient Greek medical practitioner who lived on the island of Kos in the Aegean Sea during the fifth and fourth centuries BC. He and his students wrote a number of medical texts that attempted to give a framework to their understanding of disease at that early time (Mann, 2012, Totelin, 2009). This is relevant to the study of the medieval period as the Hippocratic Corpus of texts was still regarded as the fundamental basis for the understanding of disease and its treatment right through the medieval period.
Much of medeival undertsandings of medicine worked off of a framework developed by hippocrates
-
-
-
After 1163, when the Church forbid the clergy to shed blood, 32 priests and monkscontinued to practice medicine, and the surgery was relegated to their former lay assis-tants whose primary duty was shaving the monks’ heads and thus arose the lower pro-fession of barber-surgeons
regarding surgical practices
-
-
research.reading.ac.uk research.reading.ac.uk
-
toothpicks, tweezers and ear-scoops; while corrective measures included medieval spectacles, carved in bone or wood
preventitive care
-
Prayer and good food were long thought to be the main cures for sickness used by medieval monks,
could add to overveiw- popular perception of medieval medicine.
-
-
www-jstor-org.proxy.library.vcu.edu www-jstor-org.proxy.library.vcu.edu
-
t seem inspired byFrankenstein and Jurassic P
article can be used to illustrate the importance of preventative care over treatment during this period.
-
-
www-jstor-org.proxy.library.vcu.edu www-jstor-org.proxy.library.vcu.edu
-
Information and ideas aboutmedicine circulated orally and from one generation to the next, meaningthat people were the key vector for cultural transmission. While there weredistinctive local differences in terms of medical knowledge and practice, itis evident that there was a shared medical culture in the Norman worlds,reflecting both broader cultural homogeneities and the fact that peoplewere on the move, transmitting information about health and disease thatwas fundamentally important to all sectors of society.This content downloaded from 128.172.10.194 on Mon, 08 May 2023 20:39:13 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
While medical information was primarily tranbsmitted orally from one generation to the next, many documents record the echange of dominant medical udnertsandigns of the time primarily from england to france.
-
the development ofthe professional roles of the physician and the surgeon, and the possessionof knowledge about practices such as bloodletting, apothecary and evenabortion, testify to less tangible aspects of transmission and exchange
as there is far less artifact evidence for these practices, documnets have served very valuable in uncovering these practices.
-
other women, however, undoubtedly engaged in medical practice, fulfillingroles such as midwifery, surgery and nursing. The Register mentions thepresence of two village midwives when the nun Nicola gave birth inside thenunnery of Saint-Saëns (north-east of Rouen) in July 1259. The midwivesare described as ‘mulieres ... obstetrices’,
aformentioned document evidence of the prevalence of women in the medical field dispite not being given access to medical texts, and often times not being alowed to read and write.
-
For Normandy, further light on the presence of medical practitioners isshed by the Register of Eudes Rigaud, archbishop of Rouen from 1248 to1276, which records his numerous visits to parish churches, monasteries,hospitals and leprosaria in the archdiocese of Rouen between 1248 and
this document is evidence of the practitioners present at many treatments and operrations.
-
were associated with springs whose waters were certainly in later centuriesbelieved to have beneficial effects; these springs would also have provided awater supply for the resident leper communities. 18 Although the sulphurousspring at Burton Lazars was located outside the monastic precinct, waterwithin the precinct itself has been shown also to have likely had a mineralcontent. 19 Bathing was an important aspect of the bodily care of lepers, andwas linked too to the care of their souls, since it was analogous to baptism
evidence of leper houses as being constructed beside natural springs so that they may bathe and drink from certain springs beleived to have medicinal properties
-
his letteris suggestive of the transmission of medical expertise by correspondence atthis time. A detailed description of the characteristics of the illness was vitalto facilitating the practice of medicine from a distance; when a physicianwas able to examine a patient in person, he still took a detailed case history,as well as examining the patient’s blood and urine
evidence of transmission of medical expertise from english archbishop of canturbury anselm and other local physicians
-
At Canterbury, Archbishop Lanfranc established twohospitals within the city, and a leprosarium outside the walls, in the 1080s.The hospital of St. John provided for the poor, the sick and the elderly, whilethe hospital of St. Gregory, opposite, catered for the clergy of St. John’s andfor elderly priests. St. Gregory’s very quickly ceased to have a hos
shows medival udnertsanding of the need to quarentine the sick
-
Hospitals for the sick and the poor in Normandy and England predate theNorman Conquest.
separate "leper houses" made to house, tend to, and quarantine lepers, as well as large hospitals are constructed in the 11th cent. france.
-
Medical texts also circulated as a result of diplomatic exchanges betweenroyal courts. In 1157–8 a number of gifts were sent from the imperial courtat Constantinople to that of Henry II of England. A Latin translation ofa Greek gynaecological text, the Gynaecia Cleopatrae, was almost certainlysent to Henry’s queen Eleanor of Aquitaine as part of this envoy. One of theextant copies of this translation, a late thirteenth-century French manuscript(Cambridge, Trinity College MS. R. 14. 30) includes a dedication statingthat the work was brought from Constantinople by Henry, a member ofthe household of Emperor Manuel (1143–80), and written (or copied) forthe queen of England.11
evidence of sharing of medical information between england, france, and italy.
-
The expertise in medicine at Bury during Baldwin’s abbacy is furtherindicated by the use of precise medical vocabulary in the Miracles of St.Edmund composed by Herman the Archdeacon at this time
bury abbey as significant english medical site
-
A mid eleventh-century manuscript with a Bury pressmark (BritishLibrary MS. Sloane 1621), containing medical recipes, was transportedfrom the continent to the abbey, and appears to be closely associated withBaldwin himself. As Debby Banham has shown, this manuscript marksa key moment in the introduction of new medical knowledge and newframeworks for presenting medical information into England
Monks were often responsible for the spread of medical information. Not only were many medical practitioners, but were able to read and write latin due to their study of the bible. As latin was a known language in much of the former holy roman empire, their ability to translate their findings into latin made their findings more accessible.
-
f life in monastic communities, where regular bloodletting was practisedto maintain the proper humoral balance within the bodies of monks andnuns, and the infirmary served as a space for treatment and recuperationwhen necessary
Monastic communities as sites for treatment of illness and disease.
-
- Dec 2022
-
www.asanet.org www.asanet.org
-
In the1960s, unions influenced national pay policywhen the Kennedy and Johnson administra-tions set wage and price targets to stabilizeprices and promote the “distributional equity”of wages (Ulman 1998:170). The Nixonadministration also adopted a tripartite wagepolicy. Concluding that “no program workswithout labor cooperation,” (Matusow1998:160), Nixon’s national pay board urgedwage restraint in major contract negotiationsbut also examined executive pay levels, sup-ported raises for low-wage workers, and mon-itored merit pay increases
more historic background
-
In our theory of the moraleconomy, unions help materialize labor mar-ket norms of equity (1) culturally, throughpublic speech about economic inequality, (2)politically, by influencing social policy, and(3) institutionally, through rules governingthe labor market
yeah
-
Union effects on nonunion workers canwork in several ways. Nonunion employersmay raise wages to avert the threat of unionorganizatio
how the presence of unions helps workers even if they cant afford to join the union
-
-
journalistsresource.org journalistsresource.org
-
Further, a “premium” of 10% to 20% higher income for union households compared with non-union households from the 1940s through the mid-2010s remains “relatively consistent over our long sample period, despite the large swings in density and composition of union members that we document,” the authors write.
illustrates that the benefits of unionization have been felt until recently, its a rescent issue
-
-
www.americanprogress.org www.americanprogress.org
-
Families can put these additional assets toward important uses such as children’s education or, as demonstrated in Table 1, home ownership,
showing how unions can help these families get ahead
-
Black households with a union member have median wealth that is more than three times the median wealth of nonunion Black households. Hispanic households with a union member have median wealth that is more than five times the median wealth of nonunion Hispanic households. White households with a union member have nearly two times the median wealth of nonunion white households
shows how unions close the racial wealth gap.
-
Finally, strong union contracts create more stable jobs, with protections such as dispute resolution giving workers the ability to stay with a single employer for a longer period of time
put this in converation with rising turnover rates- staying with the same company yeilds greater opportunity for advancement.
-
-
-
Right-to-work laws undermine unions’ ability to collect “fair share fees” from workers whose interests they represent. Fair share fees cover the costs of bargaining, contract administration, and grievance processes that unions are required by law to undertake on behalf of all (union and nonunion) members of a collective bargaining unit. Without fair share fees, union power degrades quickly
right to work laws undermine unions ability to operate effectivly
-
Unions communicate with their members about issues and candidates to make sure workers have information when they go to the polls on Election Day
this first sentence idsplays how unions are also good for informing voters, and spurring critical evaluations of current political ongoings. In short, unions are creating more voters, and more intellegent ones.
-
Unions boost civic participation
engaging in the collective barganing that unions accomplish help workers to think critically about the value of their labor. This boost in civic participation assures the interests of workers are betting represented in United States democracy
-
Union workers get more advance notice of their work schedules
this and the above factor is important for mothers juggling childcare and working shifts. This is important, as unpaid maternity leave is a large contrinbguter to the gender pay gap
-
e.g., on account of race, religion, disability, or other identities that are protected classes). Union contracts typically have provisions that require employers to have a proper, documented, performance-related reason for disciplining or dismissing a worker (“just cause”) and generally the worker has a chance to improve performance before the employer moves to dismiss the worker. Collective bargaining agreements also typically include a grievance and arbitration process to allow workers and the union to challenge unfair discipline or termination
relate to amazon unionization story
-
-
Local file Local file
-
n my previous books,Reviving the Strike andStrikeBack, I looked back to labor history to argue that we needto revive the strike. I argued that in both the 1930s forprivate workers and the 1960s for public-sector workers,the strike was the indispensable tactic that helped win ourunions. Here, likewise, we can look to labor history todemonstrate the power of a unionism shaped by classstruggle principles.
current events- the strike is being used for rail unions and amazon union
-
We are getting ourasses kicked. Only six out of a hundred private-sectorworkers belong to unions. Most major industries such astrucking, residential construction, retail, and finance arevirtually non-union. Where remnants of unionism do exist,such as meatpacking, the established unions arebureaucratic and ineffectual. Our contracts have beendecimated, and once-strong pensions and health-careprograms have been gutted. Optimism only goes so far, andat some point realism needs to take hold
decline of unionism
-
Class struggle unionism is responsible for some of thebrightest moments in labor history. It motivated theIndustrial Workers of the World in their brand ofrevolutionary unionism, which contributed to some of thegreatest strikes in US history. The great socialist leaderEugene Debs moved from conservative railroad businessunionism to socialism through participation in classstruggle. The key militants in the great strikes of 1934 inMinneapolis, Toledo, and the West Coast were classstruggle unionists. Adherents built a civil rights unionism inthe US South following World War II
historic background
-
- Nov 2019
-
www.washingtonpost.com www.washingtonpost.com
-
Victoria Pierson, a second-year teacher at Elkhardt-Thompson Middle School in Richmond, said unpredictable heating and cooling, exposed wiring and cockroaches undermine gains students have made in reading and attendance. Her school is one of three Richmond campuses scheduled for replacement.“Teachers aren’t speaking out to put shame on our school buildings or to put shame on their school districts,” Pierson said. “This is a state funding issue. Our legislators are telling us constantly, over and over again, that we don’t value public education because they’re not passing budgets that reflect that.”
first hand account
-
Two other measures did not survive scrutiny — one that would have dedicated money to repairing school roofs and another that would have asked voters whether they wanted the state to issue $3 billion in bonds for school construction.
potential solutions.
-
A bipartisan panel of Virginia lawmakers examined school modernization, developing a slate of proposals. One measure, which encourages schools to design buildings powered by renewable energy and allows them to sell excess energy, was signed into law by Northam.
solution
-
Despite broad consensus in Richmond and other cash-strapped Virginia school systems that classroom conditions are a problem, most of the dollars needed to fund construction have not materialized.The state budget includes $35 million in new money for school construction, less than half of the $80 million initially proposed by Gov. Ralph Northam (D).
aspects of problem
-
Last year, the Richmond City Council imposed a 1.5-percentage-point increase in the meals tax to pay for $150 million in school construction. Mayor Levar Stoney laid out an $800 million plan to fully fund school construction over two decades, after voters resoundingly approved a ballot measure that required him to do so or admit it can’t be done.
what is being done about the problem
-
Concerns over school building conditions are long-standing. Former governor Robert F. McDonnell (R) ordered a building inventory of Virginia’s public schools. The state determined in 2013 that more than 60 percent of schools were at least 40 years old and that it would cost more than $18 billion to complete renovations for Virginia schools more than 30 years old.
repair cost
-
School systems are forced to shuffle local dollars to keep employees, siphoning money available for construction projects. And communities with more robust tax bases can generally afford to contribute more local dollars for schools and often do, aggravating inequities.
equity
-
Aghomo, a 10th-grader who aspires to study public policy in college, said classroom surroundings — chairs that fall apart, paint that chips, scant or outdated technology — affect her morale.“We’re asked to compete nationally or statewide when we don’t have the resources other schools have,” Aghomo said. “If we’re forever trying to catch up, then there’s really no use.”
first hand account
-
Since the 2008-2009 school year, state aid per student has dropped 8 percent when adjusted for inflation, said Chris Duncombe, a policy director for the Commonwealth Institute for Fiscal Analysis, a left-leaning Richmond think tank.
aid- problem data
-
The consequences persist — at Hayter’s daughter’s elementary school, parents have volunteered to beautify the campus, including playground cleanups and groundskeeping.“I’ve used weed whackers at my daughter’s school,” he said.
current solution- volunteers
-
“I’ve looked at city budgets from the 1980s and the 1990s, and it’s not as if Richmond wasn’t trying to pump money into the city school system,” Hayter said. “It’s just that they didn’t have it.”
history
-
Building conditions also speak to issues of equity, Richmond educators say: Students in the city school system are overwhelmingly black and Hispanic, and 66 percent are economically disadvantaged.
equity
-
White flight to the suburbs depreciated tax bases in Richmond and other cities in the late 20th century, often meaning fewer dollars were available to public schools, said Julian Maxwell Hayter, an associate professor of leadership studies at the University of Richmond. The ubiquity of neighborhood schools also meant Richmond had to deal with highly concentrated poverty at some campuses.
history
-
Classroom temperature, noise and cleanliness can have significant consequences for students’ well-being, said Lorraine E. Maxwell, an environmental psychologist and associate professor at Cornell University.Learning is affected not just by personal characteristics such as ethnicity, family income and individual potential, but also by “the multiple ways in which the school communicates that learning and achievement is possible and important,” Maxwell wrote in a 2016 study of New York public schools.
expert opinions
-
At Binford Middle School, a long, commanding building that sits among rowhouses, the tall windows to Sarah Pedersen’s first-floor classroom are sealed shut. Temperatures have risen to 95 degrees when the boiler runs too hot, she said, prompting her to turn on the air conditioner.ADBut the unit is so loud that she can run it only a few minutes before students complain of headaches and discomfort.“It’s inhumane. These are inhumane conditions,” said Pedersen, who noted that she hasn’t had problems with her heating in recent months.
condition details
-
Lux Aghomo recalled hovering over her science midterm exam in the top floor of Richmond Community High in January, keeping warm with a puffy green winter jacket. Her fingers were cold as she moved a pencil down the page.AD‘Kids are freezing’: Amid bitter cold, Baltimore schools, students struggleThe heating problem was eventually fixed, Aghomo said, but her story wasn’t exceptional: Other students and teachers in Richmond said faulty heating and cooling systems produce temperature extremes that make it difficult to focus and, in some cases, have caused or inflamed health problems.“Students are forced to do work even in conditions where they can’t really think or function as well as they could,” Aghomo said. “It makes me feel like my education isn’t valued as much as people from other counties and other schools.”
what this problem looks like for individuals
-
Lux Aghomo recalled hovering over her science midterm exam in the top floor of Richmond Community High in January, keeping warm with a puffy green winter jacket. Her fingers were cold as she moved a pencil down the page.
imagery
-
“Our schools should convey the notion that we, the adults, love our kids when they walk into them,” said Kamras, who built his career in D.C. Public Schools. “And our schools convey the notion that, at best, we are indifferent and, at worst, we don’t care.”
quotable words/perspective
-
But it could be decades before all 44 public schools in the city are rehabilitated or rebuilt, meaning at least another generation of students will sit in buildings that Kamras condemned as “borderline criminal.”
consequences of not solving problem
-
The district approved $150 million in school construction spending last year, most of which was earmarked to replace three schools.
progress
-
In Virginia, the issue has resonated across geographic and political lines, unifying urban and rural school systems that have struggled to raise enough local dollars to compensate for what they describe as inadequate state support. But measures to infuse state coffers with money for school repairs failed to clear the General Assembly this year.In Richmond, the city has reached its debt ceiling, meaning it cannot borrow money to pay for school construction, said Superintendent Jason Kamras. It would cost $800 million to pay for all the construction needed in Richmond’s public schools, according to the city.
scale/severity of problem
-
Officials in Maryland’s Prince George’s County plan to use public-private partnerships to build and maintain several public schools in hopes of hastening construction and paring down an estimated $8.5 billion maintenance and construction backlog.
Current solution example
-
A 2014 federal study found that 53 percent of schools needed repairs, renovations or updates and that $197 billion was needed to bring schools to “good overall condition.” Other projections peg construction costs even higher, with the National Council on School Facilities estimating that public school buildings are in need of $542 billion in upkeep.
What is needed for a solution
-
Substandard conditions can compromise students’ attendance and performance, leading to absenteeism and lower achievement, studies show.
why this problem matters
-
effective imagery
-