3 Matching Annotations
  1. Dec 2024
    1. The paper stated that it utilized knockout mice. As such, I think reviewing the two types of knockout mice is important. I wouldn't be surprised if they used Conditional Knockout Mice considering their experiment.

    2. Metabolic rewiring yields similar outcomesin both female and male fah−/− miceUp to this point in the study, only male mice were used eventhough sexual dimorphism in response to similar rAAV-basedgenetic treatments had previously been reported (Davidoff et al.2003; Rinn and Snyder 2005; Paulk et al. 2012a). Reassuringly,others have shown that inactivation of Hpd using CRISPR-Cas9corrects the lethal HT-I phenotype in both female and maleFah−/− animals when delivered as plasmids via hydrodynamictail vein injections or rAAV (Pankowicz et al. 2016; Ibraheim et al.2018). Still, the impact of liver-specific inactivation of Hgd andGstz1 via in vivo genome editing in female Fah−/− animals hasyet to be reported. To better account for sex as a biological variableand improve the quality of our study, we targeted Hgd and Gstz1 inneonatal female and male Fah−/− pups side-by-side and monitoredtreatment outcomes. Upon NTBC withdrawal, mice of both sexesexperienced sudden weight loss and hypoglycemia and met theweight loss criterion within 4 days (Fig. 3, a-c). We also observedenlarged and pale kidneys in female mice treated with theHgd-targeting vector (Fig. 3d) like those observed in male Fah−/−mice treated with the same vector (Fig. 5b). In addition, gene dis-ruption efficacy was equivalent in both groups indicating that invivo CRISPR-Cas9 based editing using rAAV8 is similarly effica-cious in our model system (Fig. 3e). Thus, liver-specific inactiva-tion of either Hgd or Gstz1 by rAAV8-SaCas9 yields similarphenotypic outcomes in both female and male Fah−/− mice.

      From this result, the researchers have discovered that there is no significant sex differences in regards to metabolic rewiring. In previous studies, it is stated that only male mice have been used for this type of experiment, even if there were past reports in regards to sexual dimorphism of mice with rAAV-based treatments. While there have been previous studies which looked at gene editing for both males and females, the researchers needed to specifically look at the liver with their gene editing. They did so and discovered the aforementioned result.

    3. Standard care includes diet therapyto limit phenylalanine and tyrosine intake and lifelong treatmentwith 2-(2-nitro-4-trifluoromethylbenzoyl)-1,3-cyclohexanedione(NTBC; also known as nitisinone), a potent inhibitor of the up-stream enzyme HPD (Alvarez et al. 2017), to prevent toxic metab-olite accumulation in the liver and kidneys [Grompe et al. 1995;Lindstedt et al. 1992; Larochelle et al. 2012 (Fig. 1a)]. Importantly,non-compliance with NTBC and diet treatment is a serious chal-lenge for the clinical management of HT-I and results in higherrisks of patients developing hepatocellular carcinoma, as well aspainful corneal lesions due to high circulating tyrosine levelsand neurological crises due to high SA levels (

      From what I gather, people with this mutation have to go this lifelong treatment. My question is how intense is this treatment? I am not too familiar with the intake of these chemicals, are they harmful, or are they similar to simple vitamins? Can people with this condition live "normal" lives or not? I think these questions are good to know if the researchers are trying to find more effective treatment methods.