10,000 Matching Annotations
  1. Last 7 days
    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this study, the authors report the hitherto unobserved types of HTT assemblies observed in human fibroblasts and iPCS-derived neurons in 2D and 3D culture, applying a state-of-the-art confocal microscopy imaging with near 64 nm resolution to decode their structures. They further demonstrate that these assemblies closely contact with various types of Golgi ribbons, stacks, vesicles, and Golgi-derived clathrin-coated vesicles but not mitochondria. They also used single-cell RNAseq to show some interesting findings that supported the suggested defects in Golgi-related function, specifically by downregulation of various cellular processes related to Golgi and vesicle transport functions. They also replicate mHTT nuclear accumulations in striatal neurons, which is considered to be a hallmark of HD pathology, by using long-term neuronal culture. Furthermore, the assemblies showed differential responses to glucose starvation and to autophagy enhancer treatment by onjisaponin F for mutant HTT assemblies, but not for the healthy siblings, in fibroblasts and neurons. Onjisaponin F treatment did not reverse nuclear deposition. They also showed that ASO shortens these polyQ assemblies but does not change neuronal firings that are detected by HD-MEA. Notably, they also used human brain samples to show the existence of polyQ assemblies in fetal and child brain samples. This part is impressive.

      Overall, this work reports a novel polyQ assembly, which was previously reported as a pathogenic factor, has not been reported before for HTT, is related to Golgi activities and vesicular transport, and is dismantled in HD patient cells. The intensive immunostaining and super-resolution scanning are impressive and definitely strengthened by the impact of the findings. The scRNAseq data adds another layer to the observed Golgi impairments and their suggested relationship to Golgi function. The drug testing for polyQ assemblies, especially polyQ assemblies in HD cells, is preliminary. However, the data in this study are enough to support the existence of polyQ assemblies in human cells and their specific relationships with the Golgi apparatus.

      Strengths:

      In this study, the authors used the cells from a large HD family and fetal/child brain samples to decode the structure of endogenous polyQ assemblies. This part is impressive. The intensive staining and super-resolution scanning are amazing. The spatial relationships of polyQ assemblies with the Golgi apparatus and mitochondria are well illustrated.

      Comments on revised version.

      In this revision, the authors have addressed all the comments and the manuscript has been better improved.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The manuscript by Thompson and Gold reported that, although baseline and evoked LC activity were positively correlated with baseline pupil size and evoked pupil dilation, respectively, there were no reliable cross-epoch relationships between LC activity and pupil size - that is, between baseline LC activity and evoked pupil dilation or between baseline pupil size and evoked LC activity. A major strength of the study is its large dataset, comprising recordings from more than 100 LC single units collected across 83 recording sessions in two monkeys. The authors further strengthened their conclusions by performing several control analyses to rule out potential confounds, including whether the findings were influenced by 1) the use of residuals in the main analyses, 2) the possibility that the auditory stimulus failed to evoke the full dynamic range of LC activity and pupil responses, and 3) nonlinear cross-epoch relationships between LC activity and pupil size. In addition, by demonstrating that the results remain robust in the subset of neurons exhibiting significant baseline LC-pupil relationships, the authors further strengthen their conclusions.

      As pupil size is increasingly used as an index of arousal, these findings are particularly important because they remind researchers to exercise caution when assuming that non-illuminance-mediated fluctuations in pupil size can reliably serve as a proxy for LC activity under all experimental conditions

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have thoroughly addressed my previous comments, and I appreciate their efforts in revising the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Hernandez-Nunez et al. investigate the development and function of neural circuits involved in the regulation of heart rate in larval zebrafish. Using conserved genetic markers, they identify neural pathways involved in the bidirectional control of heart rate and in providing sensory feedback, potentially enabling more precise tuning. The main observation is that the different elements of this circuit are laid down in a developmentally staggered manner.

      At 4 days old, the heart rate is invariant to a range of sensory stimuli, and the vagal motor or sympathetic pathways could not be seen to innervate the heart. Progressively through development, the heart is first innervated by the vagal motor pathway, whose axons are cholinergic, before the formation of phox2bb+ intracardiac neurons (ICNs). At this stage, before the first ICNs are observed, activation of the vagal motor pathway by optogenetic activation of a localized population of cholinergic hindbrain neurons leads to bradycardia. After the vagal motor innervation begins, the sympathetic pathway innervates the heart, which could be visualized in the form of TH+ fibers from the anterior paravertebral ganglia (APG). The activity of the TH+ APG neurons was diverse and showed proportional, integral and derivative like relationships to the heart rate, suggesting a role in more precise tuning of the rate than what could be achieved through the vagal pathway alone. The sensory vagus innervation of the heart was identified to be the last stage to develop, however, neurons in the nodose ganglion exhibited diverse responses tuned to the heart rate well before the innervation reached the heart. The authors attribute this to the fact that other indirect sensory cues from the gills or vasculature could be used to sense heart rate prior to innervation.

      This study identifies key components of the control loop required for the regulation of heart rate in zebrafish. The control mechanism appears to be independent of the cues that trigger heart rate changes, indicating that the circuit is indeed part of an interoceptive pathway for heart rate control. Evidence for the staggered development of the vagal-motor, sympathetic and sensory pathways is conclusive, and as the authors discuss, this phenomenon progressively allows for finer grained control of the heart rate. This could be achieved through proportional-integral-derivative like control properties emerging in a diverse set of neurons in the APG and sensory feedback of the state of the heart. In line with these findings, the baseline variability of heart rate prior to innervation at 4 days old appears to be comparatively lower than the later stages (Fig 1C, D, supp. Fig 1C-F) and increases over development. This has been quantified in supp. Fig 2.

      Based on this observation and the time courses of the kernels identified by the GLMs, I would expect heart rate fluctuations of a finer time scale, ultimately limited by the time course of GCaMP6s, to be captured by the models in Figs 3, 5 and 7, in addition to the stimulus locked changes that are highlighted. While the models yield valuable insight in the form of the activation kernels and their potential roles, in one instance, it captures the potential contribution of either the motor vagus or the APG to the change in heart rate. This makes it challenging to identify where it falls short and the potential functions of pathways that have not been probed. Some other known modulatory influences on the cardiac rhythm are mentioned in the text, however exploring these pathways would be outside the scope of this study.

      Lastly, the proposed anatomical connectivity of the heart-brain circuit is based on tracts observed in this study as well as those inferred from function and from previous studies. The authors have included a section on the limitations of the model, where they importantly clarify that the proposed mechanisms, although likely, do not establish direct synaptic connectivity, for example whether the brainstem neurons identified for their functional roles are the ones that give rise to efferent projections via the motor vagus nerve. The addition of clear labels in Fig 9 also helps the reader interpret relationships between model components more clearly.

      To conclude, this study establishes the larval zebrafish as a tractable in vivo model to study heart-brain interoceptive and regulatory circuits through development and describes a detailed mechanistic framework to take forward.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is an interesting mechanistic study on the topic of Vincristine-induced peripheral neuropathy (VIPN). It defines E-selectin as critical molecule of promoting VIPN, acting via immune cell recruitment and inflammasome-mediated signalling.

      Using antibody treatments, genetic models and in vitro studies, the authors convincingly show that E-Selectin is a driver of VIPN.

      Strengths:

      In vivo studies are robust and useful. Antibody studies as well as the inflammasome-related work are very well done.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Martin Cuadrado and coauthors use O-chain biosynthesis gene clusters (OBCs) within metagenomes and SAGs to determine clone-level differences in distribution in the Mediterranean Sea. They observe two distinct consortia: one specific to surface samples (C1) and another to deep/winter samples (C2). In the discussion, the authors suggest that differences in carbon utilization capabilities in the ocean may drive this partitioning.

      Strengths:

      One of the main strengths of this paper is its use of specific clonal barcodes to analyze strain-level population structure, which allows researchers to discern distribution patterns through a different lens, with higher resolution than 16S genes. The work is important and could be a more widely used tool for examining SAR11 distributions in the ocean.

      Weaknesses:

      I feel the authors fall short in showing whether partitioning across consortia could be generalized beyond the Mediterranean Sea. If so, the work would be more impactful with additional data beyond the Mediterranean. Furthermore, the authors could have contextualized OCB sequence variability with other SAR11 clade genomes, such as those reported by Freel et al., 2025 (doi:10.1038/s41467-025-67043-6), to identify additional patterns that could explain differences between consortia; could these differences be functional? The authors invoke possible differences in the flexome of genomes within the identified consortia to explain this partitioning, but the hypothesis remains largely unexplored. For instance, the authors discuss differences in environmental context across consortia (nutrient availability, light intensity, etc.), which may in turn be associated with different functional capabilities. Is the incidence of genes related to efficient nutrient uptake systems or proteorhodopsin phototrophy increased in the surface consortium? The authors do not examine any specific functions in SAGs or whole genomes available in databases that may share the OCBs studied here. If those functions don't explain the changes, would viral specificity be the reason? I feel this discussion is needed, at least in the last section.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary

      In this work by Saito et al., the fate of p62 is studied. Under normal cellular conditions, p62 acts as a cargo receptor, binds cargo, and is recruited to the growing autophagosomal membrane via its interaction with LC3. When lysosomal function is inhibited, these structures can also be secreted in a process called secretory autophagy. This valuable paper tries to address the fate of p62. By fusing a HiBiT peptide at the C-terminus of endogenously expressed p62, extremely low amounts of p62 can be detected in the media surrounding HEK293 cells. Most of the secreted p62 was found in membrane-enclosed structures that are continuously secreted from the cells, a process that is dramatically increased after lysosomal inhibition via BafA1. This process is ATG5- and FIP200-dependent. Interestingly, this process depends on p62's ability to oligomerize, but does not depend on its ability to bind LC3, KEAP1, or poly-ubiquitin. KEAP1 was also detected in these membrane-enclosed vesicles, and its secretion did not depend on p62 interaction, but was also increased upon lysosomal inhibition. The exact secretion mechanism was not fully elucidated in this manuscript, but it was found to be RAB27-dependent. Future studies will be needed to fully map the cellular mechanism behind p62 secretion.

      Strengths

      (1) Fusion of the HiBiT peptide to p62 allows for careful quantification of secreted p62 and is of interest to the wider research community as it is an interesting strategy.

      (2) Work on endogenous expression levels of p62 avoids artifacts due to overexpression and adds to the conclusions of the paper.

      (3) Several mutants were analyzed to assess which binding partners of p62 are co-sorted to secreted vesicles.

      Weaknesses

      (1) The exact form of p62 is not clear. The fractions analyzed are pellets that sedimented at two different centrifugation speeds, supernatant, and whether the signal increases upon detergent addition. No effort was made to do further analyses on what these fractions contain or what they look like.

      (2) As pointed out in the discussion, p62 needs to oligomerize to be sorted to these vesicles, and this process is not dependent on LC3 binding. No efforts were made to exclude binding to other cargo receptors via mutation or knockdown, i.e., NBR1 D50R.

      (3) The supernatant was not fully analyzed. It is unclear whether "soluble" p62 secretion is also continuous, whether it depends on ATG5/FIP200, is affected by lysosome inhibition and whether is it potentially decreased upon p62 oligomerization.

      (4) Besides p62 and KEAP1, the contents of the vesicles were not analyzed, and it is unclear whether they contain lipidated LC3 or other autophagy proteins.

      (5) Some details of the experiments are slightly inconsistent. For instance, in Figure 3C, close to zero p62 is detected in the pellet fraction in the absence of detergent. In Figure 4, there is some p62 detected under those same conditions. I believe both of those experiments were done under the same conditions, yet yielded slightly different results. This does not detract from the conclusions of the paper, however.

      Conclusion/discussion

      The work presented is interesting and sheds light on an under-studied cellular function. The method used in this manuscript is very interesting and has the potential to be widely applicable to answer other research questions in other low-protein concentration scenarios. It will be very interesting to see which other autophagy proteins get secreted and what cellular mechanism is used to achieve this.

    1. COBOL

      FORTRAN에서 COBOL·LUNAR·SHRDLU·NaturalJava로 넘어가는 대목 에서 도구가 많이 나오지만, 각 사례가 무엇을 더 쉽게 했는지 독자가 머릿속으로 계속 비교해야 합니다. 사례마다 “사람이 하던 일 / 도구가 맡은 일 / 사람이 여전히 정한 일”을 한 문장으로 정리하거나, 중간에 짧은 요약을 넣으면 흐름을 따라가기 쉬울 것 같습니다.

    2. 문장 구조를 읽는 데 성공하더라도 ’당신의’가 누구의 소유를 뜻하는지 처리할 규칙이 없었고, 자료에는 표본의 무게도 없었다.

      실패 원인이 문장 구조 처리와 데이터 부재, 두 가지로 제시됩니다. 하지만 무게 자료가 없었다면 질문에 답할 수 없었던 가장 직접적인 이유는 데이터 부재로 보입니다. 시스템이 어디까지 문장을 분석했고 어느 단계에서 실패했는지 구분해 설명하면 사례가 더 명확히 읽힐 것 같습니다.

    3. 프로그램과 이를 사용하는 데 필요한 자료 등을 통틀어 소프트웨어라고 부른다.

      앞에서는 프로그램과 코드의 차이를 설명하고, 여기서는 자료도 소프트웨어에 포함한다고 합니다. 독자는 “신청자 명단 같은 데이터도 소프트웨어인가?”라고 헷갈릴 수 있을 것 같습니다. 소프트웨어와 데이터의 관계를 구분하거나, 이 문장을 더 단순하게 다듬으면 좋겠습니다.

    1. 신청 화면, CSV를 읽는 코드

      “신청 화면”, “CSV를 읽는 코드”, “공통 함수”, “이미 저장된 신청 명단”이 짧은 구간에 함께 등장합니다. 개발자가 아닌 독자는 무엇이 각각의 파일이고, 왜 같은 규칙을 두 곳에 적용해야 하는지 놓칠 수 있을 것 같습니다. “웹으로 신청한 사람과 파일에서 가져온 사람을 한 명단에 합친다”는 그림이나 짧은 단계 설명을 먼저 두면 이해하기 더 쉬울 것 같습니다.

    2. 두 경우의 차이는 최종적으로 몇 개의 파일을 고쳤는지보다, 어디를 어떻게 고칠지 알아내는 과정까지 맡겼는지에 있다

      앞서 Composer와 에이전트의 설명이 길게 이어져 독자가 차이를 놓칠 수도 있을 것 같습니다. 개발자가 수정 방법을 지정하는 경우와 도구가 원인을 찾아 수정 방법까지 정하는 경우를 짧게 설명해주면 요점이 잘 드러날 것 같습니다.

    1. 4.4. 화면 표시와 데이터 접근 권한을 구분해야 한다

      권한 설정과 데이터가 사용자 기기로 전달되는 설명은 중요하지만, 앞의 화면 구성 이야기에서 갑자기 기술적인 보안 세부로 넘어가는 느낌이 듭니다. “명단을 화면에서 감추는 것만으로는 접근을 막을 수 없다”는 쉬운 사례를 먼저 들고, 왜 데이터 접근 권한 설정이 필요한지 연결하면 비개발자도 따라가기 조금 더 쉬울 것 같습니다.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Schneider et al. ask whether adding environmental complexity to a simple prey capture task reveals learning that the simple task does not engage. They train six mice to hunt cockroaches in an empty arena for about ten weeks and then test them for eight days in an arena with objects that block movement and vision and give the prey places to hide. In the enriched arena, capture success increases and trial duration decreases across the eight days. The authors divide the behavior into three states: pursuit, search, and abandonment. Search dominates the trials, followed by pursuit. Interestingly, the time spent in search and pursuit does not change with experience. They show that pursuit kinematics are largely stable, whereas search speed and its variability increase. During search, mice prefer sequences of three distinct objects over returning to the object they just visited, and this preference is absent on the first day. Mice also shift their search toward the ping-pong balls, where roaches are most often found, and toward actions that displace the balls and flush hidden prey. A minimal agent-based model with short-term memory of visited objects and object-specific search values reproduces these patterns. The authors conclude that learning in a complex environment is expressed in search rather than pursuit, and that unenriched arenas can support expert performance without engaging memory-guided search.

      Strengths:

      Laboratory versions of ethological tasks often remove the environmental structure that shapes the behavior in nature, and the authors make a good case that this matters. The paradigm is simple, inexpensive, and easy to reproduce in other laboratories. The object-referenced ethogram links each action to the object it is directed at, which is a useful addition to unsupervised approaches. The authors combine several independent analyses (state segmentation, kinematics, object sequences, object occupancy, and classified object interactions), and these point in a consistent direction.

      Weaknesses:

      The most important weakness is a missing control where mice experience the objects without the prey. Mice were tested in the enriched arena with prey from the first day the objects were introduced. Many of the changes described in search, including the increase in speed and variability (Figure S4), the shift in object occupancy (Figure 5), and the change in object interactions (Figure 7), could reflect habituation to the new objects in the enriched arena rather than learning about prey behavior. A group exposed to the objects without prey, or pre-exposed to the objects before prey are introduced, is needed to attribute these changes to prey capture.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      This work uses extremely high-resolution diffusion MRI to reveal hippocampal layers and fiber organization in ex vivo tissue, showing compelling (and beautiful) evidence that this dMRI microscopy can truly act as "3D virtual histology" that gives information and signatures conveyed through a number of traditional stains.

      Specifically, they scan hippocampal tissue blocks (one from a control donor and one from an AD donor) using a 14.1T scanner, and compare diffusion maps and 3D tractography against axons, dendrites, amyloid, and tau. Acquisition is an impressive 50x50x100 µm resolution over 78 hours of scanning. They show (i) clearly distinguished hippocampal layers, (ii) this clear separation is lost at> 100 µm and beyond, (iii) tractography depicts several pathways consistent with the perforant path, mossy fibers, and Schaffer collaterals, (iv) the AD specimen showed weaker layer contrast, structural discontinuity, and disorganized trajectories (which agree with histological observations).

      Overall, I very much enjoyed reading this work; it read like a fully polished paper. I recommend only what I consider very minor revisions. And I would consider none a "requirement" for future revisions, as they are mostly stylistic preferences, small clarifications, and organizational choices.

      (1) The first results section "Diffusion MR microscopy protocol and multi-modal dataset of the human hippocampus" describes "methods". It contains/describes the acquisition, resolution, staining, and layer segmentation/naming (whereas the next section is the first results showing that diffusion microscopy allowed clear separation of layers).

      (2) There are some terms or scales that are introduced but may be ambiguous or not clear to readers. I'm assuming "diffusion MRI microscopy" is diffusion MRI on the scale of microns (or 10s of microns). "Meseoscopoic and microscopic" scales might be clarified.

      (3) "Structure tensor analysis" is introduced (and in the methods) without giving the reasons "why" this is used. The authors are using it to validate and compare orientation. The methods are described, but it isn't immediately intuitive what you are using ST analysis for (unless one is already familiar with this image processing technique).

      (4) This does not need to be addressed in the paper, but a recommendation: with 1mM Gd, you can likely get by with a much lower TR with 3D EPI, allowing much higher SNR-time efficiency, and it may be beneficial to avoid averaging and pursue more unique directions.

      (5) The image showing TDI might benefit from scaling each result independently - the 400 µm, by definition, has fewer streamlines per voxel, and is darker (and less visually appealing).

      (6) The Tri-synaptic pathway results are fascinating, a beautiful visualization of these small connections using tractography, and likely the first time I've seen this in a convincing manner using diffusion MRI. I'm unsure if the novelty of these findings is fully conveyed - adding a "virtual dissection" aspect to the "virtual histology".

      (7) Regarding Figure 5, "Disorganized radial dendritic orientations", are these disorganized, or rather geometrically different (i.e., less orthogonal), but still coherent? I wonder if, very simply, organizational coherence could additionally be quantified. Although, again, this is more a curiosity and specificity of the word "disorganized", and I do not consider further analysis a necessity.

      (8) Is the dataset made available (I may have missed this in the text)?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Large oocytes show prominent waves of cortical contractions. Previous works combining experiments and computational modeling have shown that the waves are driven by gradients of CDK1 kinase activity that trigger excitable Rho activity patterns on the cortex. This present work combines two previously published mathematical models for CDK1 activation and Rho activation, respectively. They show that the models combined can explain diverse shapes of cortical contractions observed in different species and at various stages of development. This shows how the same molecular machinery can generate diverse patterns dependent on the size of the system and the size and position of the cell nucleus.

      Strengths:

      (1) Carefully done modeling work providing a simple and elegant explanation for a complex cellular behavior.

      (2) Very nicely illustrated, simulations can be directly compared to previous experimental observations.

      (3) Explains observations made in different model systems, providing a unifying model.

      Overall, I find this work important, as it shows that combining models of the CDK1 gradient and Rho activation modules can explain the surface contraction waves observed in oocytes. Strikingly, it elegantly explains the differences seen between different experimental systems. While previously these were considered a 'controversy', modeling shows that the differences are simply a consequence of the difference in the size of the oocytes. In addition, the model makes several intriguing predictions that can be tested in future experiments.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This paper describes a study that uses a combination of observational and experimental techniques to investigate the hypothesis that the zona incerta is a neural loci where sensory information is integrated to interpret the motivational value of reward-associated cues. They show that manipulation of GABAergic neurons in this region bidirectionally modulates responding during a progressive ratio test, that activating these neurons recovers motivational deficits incurred by chronic stress, and that they fire in response to reward-associated visual or auditory cues. They also showed that activity in these neurons is not necessary for incentive salience of reward-associated cues, because inactivating them did not prevent Pavlovian-instrumental transfer. However, activating them did enhance responding during the presentation of reward-associated cues in females but not in males.

      Strengths:

      The study has a very systematic and elegant approach to assess how this region responds first to intrinsic motivation and then to motivation-enhancing effects of reward-associated cues.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This paper investigates the idea that the protracted maturation of the prefrontal cortex - often viewed as a developmental limitation - may actually confer advantages for conceptual learning in children. The authors focus on semantic control processes, which govern the context-sensitive application of conceptual knowledge, and are closely associated with late-developing regions of the prefrontal cortex.

      Drawing on a computational model, the paper formally tests whether delayed maturation of semantic control promotes the acquisition of conceptual knowledge. The simulations demonstrate that when semantic control and anatomical connectivity mature later, conceptual learning is accelerated without compromising the integrity of the learned representations. Notably, the benefit is most apparent when control connections target intermediate layers in the computational model, suggesting a nuanced interplay between control processes and the underlying conceptual network.

      To validate these computational insights in a human developmental context, the authors conduct a meta-analysis of the classic triadic matching task - a paradigm where participants decide which of two choices best matches a reference concept based on either taxonomic or thematic relations. Critically, when these relations conflict, semantic control is required to select the context-appropriate match. Results indicate that context-sensitive semantic control develops more slowly than basic conceptual knowledge, showing marked improvements between 3 and 6 years of age.

      Overall, the paper argues that the delayed development of prefrontal cortex-based control processes allows for a period of less constrained learning, ultimately enhancing conceptual acquisition. The findings challenge the traditional view of late PFC maturation as solely disadvantageous and instead position it as an adaptive feature for building robust conceptual frameworks in early childhood.

      Strengths:

      (1) Novel Theoretical Contribution

      The paper offers a compelling, counterintuitive argument that a developmental lag in the maturation of control processes might be beneficial for semantic learning. This stands in contrast to the conventional framing of late prefrontal cortex (PFC) development as purely disadvantageous (e.g., a "necessary but unfortunate" constraint).

      (2) Well-Grounded Computational Approach

      The authors propose a neural network model that is both theoretically driven (hub-and-spoke framework) and systematically tested under various conditions (different timelines for control onset, and different connectivity patterns). Their simulations replicate and extend previous findings about how insulating the multimodal hub from direct control inputs helps preserve abstract conceptual representations.

      (3) Neuro-anatomical basis

      The paper connects its computational claims to empirical neuroanatomy, particularly the lack of direct structural connectivity between ventral ATL (the "hub") and the PFC in humans. This lends biological plausibility to the argument that control signals likely reach the ATL via intermediate regions (e.g., posterior temporal cortex).

      (4) Meta-Analysis of Triadic Match-to-Sample

      The authors leverage decades of developmental data on conceptual matching tasks, reframing them in terms of semantic control vs. semantic representation. Their analysis nicely illustrates that children can identify semantic relationships (taxonomic or thematic) at age 2 if the task does not require them to select between conflicting semantic relations. In contrast, the ability to choose a task-relevant relation only emerges more robustly in 3-6 years. This developmental pattern aligns with the computational model's predictions.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors reply to all my comments and acknowledge the limitations of the paper.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study profiles the genome-wide distribution of DNA methylation using methylation capture sequencing in four stages of male germ cells: Thy1+ (undifferentiated spermatogonia), Kit+ (differentiated spermatogonia), pachytene spermatocytes, and round spermatids. These analyses revealed site-specific loss of DNA methylation in pachytene cells compared with differentiating spermatogonia. Integrated analysis using published datasets indicate that hypomethylated sites correlate with nucleosome retention sites and bivalent histone methylation sites in sperm.

      Strengths:

      The methyl-seq approach provides a comprehensive profile of DNA methylation in male germ cells. The concept that DNA hypomethylation in in meiotic cells precedes histone modification and histone retention in sperm is interesting.

      Weaknesses:

      All previous weaknesses have been addressed in the revision.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Alizadeh et al. investigate how varying cellular E/I (excitatory/inhibitory) composition impacts coding across cortical layers. They build on findings from a recent study (Huang et al., 2022) that demonstrated a decrease in the fraction of inhibitory neurons from L2/3 to L4. Using a network of excitatory and inhibitory leaky integrate-and-fire neurons, they systematically assess how these anatomical features influence the dimensionality of network activity and coding capacity. Their key finding is that increasing the proportion of inhibitory neurons enhances the dimensionality of activity and improves the encoding of time-varying stimuli.

      Strengths:

      The authors use a clear methodology and well-established model of network activity that allows them to relate network parameters to the coding properties. They systematically evaluate the impact of the key features of the inhibitory population. Thus, in addition to changing the fraction of inhibitory cells, they control for the inhibitory firing threshold of inhibitory neurons and connection strength between inhibitory and excitatory cells. Furthermore, they show their modeling results are aligned with the analysis of the spiking activity in L2/3 vs. L4 from the Allen Institute data.

      Weaknesses:

      One general shortcoming of this approach is that it focuses on a small preselected number of network features. For example, it is unclear to what extent the results would be affected by other aspects of the organization of cortical columns, such as subclasses of inhibitory cells (SOM, VIP, PV), specific differences in synapses, realistic population sizes, or even connectivity between layers. Similarly, the models of L2/3 and L4 are constrained based on a limited set of observations, and it has not been demonstrated whether the same findings hold true for V1 recordings analyzed by the authors. The modeling relies on anatomical data from the barrel cortex, but the decoding comparison is based on V1 data.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The macaque monkey is often considered as the animal model of choice to study the neural correlates of visual perception, due to the close similarities to humans in terms of anatomy, physiology and behaviour (Van Essen and Dierker, 2007; DiCarlo et al., 2012; Roelfsema and Treue, 2014; Picaud et al., 2019; Van Essen et al., 2019; Hesse and Tsao, 2020). Quite some studies have been performed to compare the behaviour of macaque monkeys and humans on visual perception tasks. However, it remains difficult to compare the results of these studies as the methods that are used differ significantly between these studies. Furthermore, behavioural studies of macaque monkeys often involve extensive training as the tasks were relatively hard, making it difficult to compare the results with humans, who generally require very little training. The authors present a set of experiments to compare visual perception between macaque monkeys and humans, using the exact same behavioral task that is easy to learn and therefore requires very little training. As expected, they overall find that the two species behave similarly. However, they find a number of interesting exceptions.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the current study is the relatively large number of tasks that were tested in the same subjects. This is made possible by using the oddball visual search task, which macaque monkeys can learn very quickly. This means that few trials are sufficient to obtain a significant difference between conditions, minimizing learning effects. Although this type of task has been used in previous studies (Sablé-Meyer et al., 2021), the current manuscript makes better use of the advantages and explains them more explicitly.

      In addition, the study finds a number of interesting differences between macaque monkeys and humans. In particular, while humans can dissociate horizontally mirrored images better than vertically mirrored images, monkeys show no difference between these two conditions (Experiment 4). Also, while humans dissociate images better based on the global shape of a stimulus, monkeys dissociate images better based on local elements of a stimulus (Experiments 5 and 6). Although these findings are largely a replication of previous results, they have not yet been studied together with other tasks within the same individual subjects, and the low number of trials avoids any learning effects.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this review, the authors set out to synthesize how cryo-EM is reshaping RNA structural biology, moving the field from the determination of static, individual conformations toward the reconstruction of dynamic conformational ensembles and energy landscapes. Through eight case studies spanning ribozymes, riboswitches, viral RNAs, and synthetic RNA assemblies, they aim to show how cryo-EM has revealed mechanisms of RNA motion, including folding, ligand-dependent switching, and cooperative assembly, and to provide a practical account of the experimental and computational challenges (construct design, sample preparation, vitrification, data analysis) that are specific to dynamic RNA targets.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript succeeds in bringing together a wide and genuinely current range of case studies illustrating the field's shift toward dynamics-focused cryo-EM, several published within the last one to two years. The dedicated "Challenges" section, which walks through construct engineering, buffer and vitrification optimization, grid screening, and heterogeneity-resolving computational approaches, is a particularly useful and practical contribution; it goes beyond simply cataloguing structures and gives readers new to the area a genuine methodological roadmap. The figures are detailed and well matched to the quantitative claims made in the text (helix rotations, distances, RMSDs), which strengthens the paper's value as a reference resource.

      Comments on revised version:

      The authors have addressed all my comments, including correcting the cobalamin riboswitch description and adding the recommended literature.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is an interesting study that addresses an important question: how does the response to heat stress degrade in older individuals? The authors assess this in young (4d old) and aged (30d old) Drosophila adult females, assessing global changes in gene expression in animals subjected to and recovering from a 2-hour heat stress. They find that global responses to heat stress are indistinguishable in young and old adult flies, suggesting that aging and response to heat are independent inputs with regard to global gene expression. Loss of insulin-producing cells from early larval stages altered the ways in which stress and aging regulate gene expression, with sets of genes responding to heat stress in an age-dependent manner.

      The findings are intriguing, but the role of insulin signaling in switching genome-wide responses to stress and aging is challenging to interpret due to the timing of insulin-producing cell ablation. Consequently, alterations in developmental processes that are dependent on insulin-producing cell function may contribute to the gene expression programs observed here.

      (1) Expression of the UAS-reaper transgene under control of Dilp2-GAL4 likely leads to elimination of insulin-producing cells (IPCs) from at least the first larval instar, if not earlier. Consequently, a large number of processes ranging from animal growth and fertility (as the authors note) to brain development will be affected by this manipulation. This is important because the authors interpret their findings as demonstrating "a state of active repression maintained by high IIS activity", but it is not clear that these changes are due to active insulin signaling rather than changes that occurred during development.

      (2) Does reduced fertility itself, without altering insulin signaling, lead to the global changes in gene regulation that the authors observed in old vs young and IPC-intact vs IPC-ablated animals? Addressing this would shore up the idea raised in the discussion about reallocation of resources from stress to reproduction.

      (3) All measures of gene expression were made using RNA-sequencing of whole-fly transcriptomes, which limits finer-grained assessment of organs that contribute most strongly to the gene expression patterns observed here.

      (4) The authors compare gene expression in young and old adult flies (subjected to heat stress or not and with IPCs or not). Broadly speaking, they do not directly compare gene expression between IPC-intact and IPC-ablated animals, except for data shown in Figure 7. Additional comparisons of this nature would be helpful in showing the trends in the data.

      (5) The sample size for the RNA-Seq experiments is not included.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this study, the authors aim to provide proof-of-concept evidence to support the development of a targeted anti-TGF beta therapy for the treatment of solid tumours and fibrotic diseases. By mimicking a natural strategy employed by a murine parasite, they aim to provide a foundational design for a precision, cell-targeted therapeutic to circumvent the prohibitive toxicity associated with systemic TGF-beta inhibition.

      Strengths:

      (1) The authors demonstrate the design of a molecule that can achieve an in vitro selectivity of around 300-fold and show a functional effect of inhibition on fibrotic signalling and myofibroblast phenotype. A 300-fold cellular potency window would be expected to be of clinical and therapeutic relevance if it could be replicated across tissues.

      (2) The mechanistic investigations around receptor internalisation and degradation are solid and are supported by a paper that has been published since this manuscript was submitted (van Dinther et al. 2026).

      (3) The paper gives some insights into factors that may further influence selectivity. The authors note that whilst the non-target HEK293 cells are 100-fold less sensitive than the MCF5 lung fibroblasts to TGF-beta inhibition with the targeted molecule, the HEK293 are more sensitive to the untargeted ligand. This raises the likelihood that expression levels of the therapeutic target may play into the selectivity of the molecule as well as the expression distribution of the targeting protein.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The cell line chosen to demonstrate selectivity is an embryonic line with characteristics of neural progenitor cells and, as such, not relevant to the intended patient populations for TGF-beta inhibitors. This study could have had more impact if it had investigated selectivity against the cell types relevant to the known cardiovascular side effects associated with TGF-beta inhibitors.

      (2) The authors mention that selectivity may be influenced by expression levels of the target proteins but do not compare expression levels of TGFBR2 and PDGFRA in HEK293 and MCF5 lung fibroblasts directly. Furthermore, there is little investigation into the relative impact of different binding affinities against both TGFBR2 and PDGFRA; the paper could have been more compelling if this concept had been expanded on. A deep understanding of relative binding kinetics and target protein expression levels will be critical to the successful development of a cell-targeted TGF-beta inhibitor.

      (3) The molecule developed is aimed exclusively at targeting pathogenic fibroblasts, but pulmonary fibrosis is a complex disease involving multiple cell types that respond to TGF-beta. This includes the epithelial alveolar type II cell, which is known to be a driver of disease. A truly disease-modifying therapeutic will need to tackle multiple cell types in IPF whilst minimising the impact on protective TGF-beta functions.

      Impact:

      A targeted TGF-beta therapeutic that enables selective inhibition of the pathological functions of TGF-beta whilst maintaining normal homeostatic signalling would have far-reaching benefits for patients. This study demonstrates for the first time that a naturally occurring helminth strategy for TGF-beta modulation can be adapted for human tissue targeting in vitro. It raises interesting potential as a therapeutic strategy, though the data as presented currently is far from that required for a convincing preclinical data package. The pharmacology will be complex, and it is of note that the helminth strategy to modulate the pathway local to the site of infection utilises multiple proteins and multiple targeting domains. Systemic modulation is an even higher bar, requiring detailed knowledge of the system kinetics and extensive in vitro profiling of normal and disease tissue responses. The next steps would also include an understanding of the therapeutic window required in vivo.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary and strengths:

      The authors present a description of their online tool to estimate real world performance of predictive models. The authors bring together different calculations to make better informed implementation choices. It is a very nice tool to go from effect sizes to base rates to decision curve analysis. The paper describes the background and use of the tool with examples and seems like an extended version of their online how-to. The method itself is not new, but I think the tool will be valuable for researchers from different fields. There are already tools for the conversion of effect sizes (my current favourite is https://www.escal.site/), but I haven't seen measurement noise being incorporated previously. The main benefit is the evaluation of performance under different real-world scenarios. Code is available on Github and the manuscript is well-written.

      Weaknesses:

      While comprehensive explanation and examples are important for correct use of the tool, I don't really see the added value of a peer reviewed publication over and above the authors' online how-to, as the software has already been published (Karvelis, P. and Diaconescu, A. O. (2025b). E2p simulator: An interactive tool for estimating real world predictive utility of research findings. Journal of Open Source Software, 10(114):8334)

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have adequately addressed my previous comments.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this study by Lästad et al., the dry mass and mass density of confluent MDCK epithelia are carefully measured using 2D and 3D QPI microscopy. Extensive imaging experiments were performed. The single-cell-resolved data show that the cell mass density is relatively conserved, even though there is considerable cell height and cell volume variation. There appear to be transport processes happening between neighboring cells within the epithelium.

      Strengths:

      The data appears to be high quality, with good statistics. I think the conclusions are generally interesting and sound, with some questions noted below.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) I think the weakest part might be Figure 3 concerning cell volume and area. The authors refer to their previously published paper on their segmentation and height determination methods. It appears that some of these results may depend on the parameters of the imaging method, although I am not an expert. I am wondering to what extent the data depends on these image analysis methods. For example, there are some Gaussian blur parameters used. Do these parameters significantly affect the results? I suspect not, but I would be more convinced if additional validation is shown.

      (2) Along the same vein, I couldn't find how the velocity field in Equation 8 was determined. This seems to be a critical quantity for conclusions in Figure 5.

      (3) Equation 8 assumes that mass is conserved within the epithelium. Is this really the case in the experiment? If some cells are growing, then there should be a source term in Equation 8. Could some of the mass non-conservation come from growth fluctuations?

      (4) The paper is nearly entirely physical measurements. While I am fine with this, it would be nice to perform some biological manipulation to validate the results. For instance, if there is mass transport between cells, then blocking tight junctions might stop this. Or if serum is removed, then cells would be arrested, and mass would definitely (maybe?) be conserved?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      This is an interesting paper with important results. The authors, working in V1, have previously, in a 2022 paper, defined sensitizing and depressing excitatory (E) cells as those whose response increases or decreases, respectively, across the 10 seconds of showing a drifting grating stimulus. They showed that sensitizing E cells are dominantly inhibited by SST inhibitory cells, which are dominantly depressing, and that depressing E cells are dominantly inhibited by PV inhibitory cells, which are very largely sensitizing. It's been well established that locomotion greatly increases E-cell firing rates in V1 compared to rest, but much remains to be worked out as to the mechanism. Here, they find that locomotion increases the responses of the sensitizing E cells much more than depressing cells. They develop a model of changes in synaptic weights between rest and locomotion to account for the changes. One reason that sensitizers are increased more by locomotion than depressors is that PV cells, which more strongly inhibit depressors, have increased firing for locomotion, whereas SST cells, which more strongly inhibit sensitizers, don't change their firing rates with locomotion. However, in the mode,l a complex array of postulated changes in connection strengths is also involved.

      Comments on revised version.

      To my previous review, I just want to add that the authors have taken the reviews very seriously, responded to them thoroughly and well and with a number of new studies that greatly strengthen the work.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The article titled "Identification of neurodevelopmental organization of the cell populations of juvenile Huntington's disease using dorso-ventral HD organoids and HD mouse embryos" analyses an in vitro human brain organoid model containing dorsal and ventral telencephalum structures derived from human iPSC from Huntington's disease patients or control subjects.

      The authors describe differences in the pattern of expression of genes related to proliferation and neuronal maturation, with a slower pattern of differentiation present in HD cells. Moreover, the authors described a higher differentiation capacity of HD cells to generate choroid plexus identity following dorsal telencephalon prime protocol differentiation when compared to control cells.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work by Ribeiro and colleagues examines circuit mechanisms by which the fruit fly regulates its behavioral response to moving objects. Previous studies, including one by the authors, identified that LC10a visual projection neurons promote tracking of female flies during male courtship behavior. In the present paper, the authors focus on LC10d visual projection neurons and show that these neurons mediate avoidance of visual objects, thereby revealing opposing functions performed by closely related visual projection neurons. In contrast to LC10a's role in promoting courtship pursuit, LC10d appears to promote object avoidance before courtship begins, as silencing LC10d results in increased tracking of visual objects. In vivo functional imaging experiments show that LC10d is broadly tuned to moving objects, and analyses of the connectome and subsequent behavioral experiments identify a class of descending neurons, DNa10, as a downstream behavioral effector of a subset of LC10d with frontal receptive fields. Together, this study suggests an important role of LC10d in regulating behavioral responses to moving visual objects.

      Strengths:

      (1) Specific genetic drivers were used to perform behavioral manipulation and calcium imaging, revealing behavioral roles and stimulus tuning of previously uncharacterized LC10d neurons.

      (2) Many experiments were performed in parallel for LC10d and LC10a, allowing for direct comparisons of behavioral phenotypes and stimulus responses between these two neuron types.

      (3) In addition to the role of LC10d neurons in male object avoidance, the paper also investigates their role in females and shows that this avoidance maneuver (i.e., displacing the object out of the frontal visual field) in females facilitates male courtship behavior, suggesting how a sexually isomorphic behavioral response can lead to sexually dimorphic consequences during courtship.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The study would benefit from more statistical rigor. Many behavioral observations central to the paper's conclusion are not accompanied by statistical testing; for example, the apparent pre-courtship avoidance of the visual object and its suppression upon LC10d silencing.

      (2) Many important panels report only center values without error bars or confidence intervals; thus, it is not possible to assess the variance of data (e.g., fly-to-fly variability), making it difficult to judge the robustness of the effects.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary of aims.

      The authors ask whether training on an obliquely oriented Gabor patch changes how people later follow differently oriented Gabor patches with their eyes. Tilted patterns produce a bias in the initial direction of pursuit because of the aperture problem. The authors report that this initial bias does not change over five training sessions. They do report a compensatory pursuit response that corrects the direction of the eye movement, and that this correction becomes faster with training. They attribute the faster correction to a later compensatory response, and they interpret this as learning in internal sensorimotor models.

      Strengths.

      The experiment is well done, and the question of how sensorimotor learning deals with a perceptual bias that cannot be removed is interesting. The interpretations are reasonable and fit the general approach of the study. Including independent conditions and a separate cohort is also a useful addition.

      Weaknesses.

      My main concern is that the results are hard to follow and at times inconsistent, and the analyses may be more extensive than needed.

      Do the results support the conclusions? The central idea, that training speeds up a delayed compensatory correction without changing the initial bias, is plausible and may well be correct. As the paper stands, however, the support is only partial. The inconsistent windows and sessions, the statistical issues, and the unclear description of how the key latencies were obtained make it hard to judge how robust the main findings are. The pattern of analyses can also give the impression that they were chosen after the fact.

      Impact.

      If the findings hold up under a clearer and more consistent analysis, they would be of interest to researchers studying eye movements, motion perception and sensorimotor learning.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Hou and colleagues aimed to characterize bulk medial prefrontal cortex calcium signal surrounding reward prediction error processing to determine encoding of value, valence, and sign. While a salience signal was observed, they also identified a causal role for mPFC activity surrounding movement, independent of task.

      Strengths:

      Overall, this manuscript from Hou and colleagues is an enjoyable read and a well-considered manuscript presenting findings that clearly were different from hypothesized. I applaud the authors for their deep dive into this and the push toward more causal interrogation of the mPFC in regulating movement-related outcomes, and think as a whole the manuscript adds to the literature. Major strengths include the careful consideration of appetitive vs. aversive behaviors and leveraging of individual differences, the integration of fiber photometry data with optogenetic manipulations, and the cautious interpretation of findings.

      Weaknesses:

      Some minor weaknesses were noted, including a lack of clarity/consideration of the specific medial prefrontal cortex subregion targeted (appears to be prelimbic), which has important implications for generalizability of the findings due to downstream connectivity, and potentially also integration with what is known for other regions (e.g., ACC) in regulating behavior. In addition, while the authors' conclusions regarding bulk signal are sound within the dataset, and their conclusion to interpret these signals with caution is valid, it may be beneficial to also interpret these findings in light of other literature describing mPFC subregion activity in the regulation of movement and actions broadly, including areas where there are alignment vs disagreement.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      In this study, Rau and colleagues investigate how concept knowledge is organized into task-specific representational spaces in the MTL, and how this relates to episodic memory formation. Using behavioral ratings of animal concepts in two task contexts, they reconstruct conceptual spaces and show that MTL, and particularly HPC, representations align with task-relevant spaces, track their reorganization across tasks, and relate to subsequent memory. This is an interesting and well-designed study that addresses important questions. The methods are careful, and testing generalization via inferred concept pairs is an elegant approach.

      I have a number of questions, including clarifications and questions about the analyses. These concern what some of the metrics capture and how they relate to the authors' conclusions.

      (1) On inferred distances / latent spaces:

      The RSA is restricted to inferred (never directly rated) concept pairs, which seems an important feature of the design: regions aligned with these distances represent a task-relevant space that generalizes beyond the explicitly probed comparisons. This could be emphasized more. Relatedly, I was surprised not to see frontoparietal or "multiple-demand" regions, which might be expected to represent task-relevant comparisons. One possibility is that such regions encode the explicitly compared pairs (external attention), whereas HPC and default-mode regions encode the latent space supporting inference (internal attention). Could the authors test this by, e.g., comparing alignment for rated vs inferred pairs?

      (2) Sizes or strength of the effects:

      Inferring distances is a nice approach, and the cross-validation is a good way to test whether the reconstructed spaces are valid. Is there a sense of prediction accuracy, for example, the error and variance for a given inferred distance? A standardized measure might be more interpretable.

      Similarity is greater for task-relevant than task-irrelevant spaces. Are the absolute values interpretable, or do they depend on how participants used the rating scale? In any case, a noise ceiling or effect size measure would help indicate how strong these effects are.

      (3) Space-level reorganization (Figure 4A):

      What does the space-level reorganization analysis (Figure 4A) show? As I understand it, space1-space2 similarity is computed separately for the reconstructed behavioral spaces and the HPC concept RSMs, and the two values are then correlated across participants. It's not clear to me why this between-participant relationship would indicate that the HPC flexibly reorganizes representations according to task demands. The subsequent within-subject concept-level analysis seems to capture this better?

      (4) Concept-level reorganization metric:

      Could the authors clarify how the origin (0, 0) of the reconstructed spaces is defined? Since the least-squares solution is only determined up to a constant shift, I assume the origin corresponds to the centroid of the concepts, but it would help to state this. It would also be useful to confirm whether dimensions were scaled (e.g., z-scored) before computing distances. Otherwise, differences in rating spread between spaces could influence the metric.

      More generally, I wondered whether the metric captures reorganization per se, or rather a change in how extreme or atypical a concept is relative to the others. A concept could change its relationships to other concepts substantially while keeping a similar distance from the centroid.

      This also seems different from the neural measure, which reflects how much a concept's own pattern changes across spaces. Would it be more straightforward to compare each concept's pairwise distances to the other concepts across spaces? This would also relate more clearly to the neural data, for example via the equivalent neural similarity profiles.

      Finally, the hypothesis implies greater neural differentiation across than within spaces for concepts that reorganize more. Between- and within-space similarity are currently tested separately, but a significant effect for one and not the other does not show that they differ. Would it be informative to test a per-concept differentiation score (within minus between) directly?

      (5) Memory confidence:

      Why is position in the space predicted to relate to memory confidence rather than to memory performance itself? I would have predicted an effect on memory, since a concept that is more distinctive in this space should be better remembered. I would have predicted this even more so for sensory features.

      (6) Anterior-posterior HPC:

      Is there an anterior-posterior HPC difference for more abstract vs more concrete conceptual features, and potentially in other areas? For example, size is relatively concrete, whereas proximity and climate are more abstract or less tied to perceptual features (though I'm not sure of the exact ranking).

      (7) Voxel overlap analysis:

      The overlap analysis (Figure 6D-E) compares voxels within TFCE-significant clusters across contrasts. However, cluster extent depends on the sensitivity of each contrast rather than on the tuning or strength of individual voxels. For example, the task-specific map includes very large clusters, and the DNN map combines eight layers. Absence of overlap also does not imply absence of a representation, since voxels may carry information below threshold. The percentages may therefore be misleading. Could the authors use a threshold-independent approach, such as correlating unthresholded maps or comparing effect sizes within ROIs?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The manuscript addresses the lack of a general explanatory framework for the secretion of metabolites by microorganisms and proposes a compelling hypothesis - the concept of "metabolite value" - which is tested both computationally and experimentally. The hypothesis is clearly formulated and represents a promising attempt to offer a unified perspective on this long-standing question.

      Previous major comments (from review at another journal):

      (1) L58ff: Only net accumulations of one average cell in a potentially heterogenous cell population can be measured. More "valuable" metabolites would also be preferentially taken up by other cells. The authors should comment with respect to the working hypothesis.

      (2) L90ff: There are some open questions regarding the selected metabolome data. Of the 126 metabolites measured, up to 56% were released during exponential growth, and 34 of these were used to calculate the release rates. Although the amount of data is considerable, it remains unclear why these particular metabolites were selected. For example, why was metanephrine included as a non-native metabolite of E. coli? Why not just focus on the metabolites that are mapped by the applied GEM?

      (3) L105ff: To substantiate the hypothesis regarding metabolite value, the use of data sets from different strains and conditions, as well as different GEMs, is compelling. However, if the hypothesis is correct, one could question the validity of models that currently do not take metabolite release into account. In this way, the single-factor approach, which examines the effect of the release of a specific metabolite on the growth rate, could lead to distorted results. The authors should comment on this.

      (4) L127ff.: The statement that "43% of the variability" is explained by metabolite value is difficult to interpret without further context - it may represent a substantial effect, or it may be of limited explanatory power. This requires clearer framing. It is also surprising that intracellular concentration appears to have such little influence. While the data may support this conclusion, the result is counterintuitive and would benefit from further discussion or contextualization.

      (5) L193ff: Without Figure S20B, it is impossible to understand the effects of the various knockouts in the cell. Why was DlacA used as a negative control? Furthermore, it is to be expected that the substrate of an enzyme whose gene has been deleted will accumulate. To what extent does this approach, which is based on such clear genetic disturbances, support the general metabolite value hypothesis, which is primarily intended to explain native cell metabolism?

      (6) Figure S25: Based on the raw data shown, it is not entirely convincing that a true chemostat steady state was achieved. In a properly operated chemostat, a metabolic steady state is established, meaning that extracellular metabolite concentrations reflect a balance of secretion, uptake, and dilution. Under such conditions, it is not possible to determine whether specific exometabolites are being re-assimilated; one might only conclude that their net secretion rates are constant.

      In addition, several extracellular metabolite profiles are difficult to reconcile with metabolic expectations. For example, the increase of F6P in a pgi knockout strain and the lack of accumulation of AKG-derived amino acids in a sucB mutant are surprising. The authors should provide more explanations.

      (7) L253ff: The statement that "our findings so far suggest that microbes can modulate metabolite release rates" is difficult to reconcile with the central hypothesis. The manuscript initially proposes that the abstract parameter "metabolite value" determines secretion levels, rather than active modulation by the cell. This conceptual distinction requires clarification.

      (8) The dataset of 66 knockout strains growing on glucose is extensive, but some methodological details are not sufficiently described in the "Materials and Methods" section. For example, there is no explanation as to why 8,700 measurements were performed on 2,100 samples and whether the samples were injected multiple times. Furthermore, the criteria for selecting the 10 time points and the approach for data normalization (e.g., TIC normalization) are not specified.

      (10) From a conceptual point of view, the energy costs of metabolite transport are not taken into account. If the "metabolite value" is also related to active import as a compensation mechanism, the costs associated with metabolite transport and transporter synthesis should be included in the discussion.

      Comments on latest version:

      The authors have thoroughly addressed my previous concerns.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this concisely written report, Li et al. propose the role of a previously uncharacterized protein called YfiM, as a lipid-linked oligosaccharide pyrophosphatase in E. coli. This work is important because lipid-linked oligosaccharide (LLO) metabolism is poorly understood across all domains of life. First, the authors detected pyrophosphatase activity against a model dolichol-linked oligosaccharide substrate in E. coli membrane fractions via fluorescent labeling of cleaved products. The authors found a structural homolog of VanZ, which they proposed causes vancomycin resistance by hydrolyzing Lipid II in Gram-positive Enterococcus faecium. E. coli protein YfiM was identified as structurally related to VanZ using a structural model-based BLAST search. Using the purified protein and a model substrate, they examined the in vitro catalytic activity of YfiM (shown to be dependent on Ca2+ and Mn2+) and validated the proposed catalytic residues that were conserved in VanZ.

      Moreover, the authors found that deletion of yfiM led to higher sensitivity to vancomycin compared to WT, and overexpression of YfiM led to increased resistance to vancomycin. These experiments support the hypothesis that YfiM is a Lipid II pyrophosphatase (although additional experiments are suggested). Further, membranes that lack yfiM can no longer hydrolyze the model LLO substrate. Lastly, they identified a plant ortholog of YfiM and found that the plant ortholog also exhibited pyrophosphatase activity against dolichol-linked oligosaccharides, highlighting the conservation of this activity across various domains of life. These findings are strong and important, and should be of broad interest to biochemists.

      Strengths:

      The authors use complementary methods to support their findings (computational protein modeling, phylogenetic analyses, protein biochemical assays, and genetic knockouts).

      Weaknesses:

      The work does not show a direct assay that tests YfiM with the proposed substrate (Lipid II), and doesn't provide further evidence for a proposed compensatory mechanism against outer membrane stress upon YfiM overexpression.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This paper presents a large structural survey of extracellular vesicles (EVs) and non-vesicular extracellular particles (NVEPs) in the olfactory sensilla of Drosophila melanogaster. Using high-pressure freezing and serial block-face SEM, the authors avoid many of the artifacts associated with conventional fixation and analyze more than 7,800 particles across 352 sensilla. The manuscript maps the distribution of these particles, describes their morphological heterogeneity, and examines their likely origins across different sensillum classes in both normal and degenerating tissue.

      Strengths:

      The strongest aspect of the paper is the imaging. Preservation is painstakingly controlled. The cryofixation appears to preserve the sensillum lymph in a convincing native state than standard preparation methods, giving this work gravitas. Further the authors characterized thousands of particles, further making this data strong.

      The figures are strong. They are clear, easy to read, and generally well designed, I think people will use this paper as a model on how to present complex data in a concise and straightforward manner. The manuscript is careful in how it presents the dataset and does not overinterpret the descriptive observations. As an ultrastructural resource, this paper will be useful to the field. The identification of auxiliary support cells as major secretory sites, together with the striking accumulation of EVs in degenerating tissue, will provide a useful starting point for future work.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Richardson et al. propose a new method for identifying loci underlying reproductive barriers based on Dxy-based distance trees. They apply this method to the well-studied model system Antirrhinum majus and identify seven genomic regions associated with flower color loci, five of which are known from previous studies, while three new regions emerge from this study. The authors validate their findings using allele frequencies across a natural hybrid zone and link genetic variation to observed phenotypes using an impressive set of quantitative data from controlled crosses. Six regions exhibit steep allele frequency clines across the narrow hybrid zone (which exhibits no obvious difference in environment or pollinators), supporting the hypothesis that color genes are associated with reproductive barriers. One additional region is associated with plant height, though its contribution as a barrier locus remains unclear.

      The ability to perform genome scans without a priori knowledge of the phenotypic or ecological features that separate natural populations is highly valuable for non-model, less-studied organisms. The use of trees, specifically based on Dxy distances, to sidestep the need for a priori defined population contrasts reflects other recent developments in population genetics where tree topologies - which carry more information than scalar summary statistics - are leveraged for inferring population evolutionary history. The use of the root branch length (SRB) as the outlier metric makes this method tuned to detect old and highly divergent alleles sheltered from gene flow across major tree partitions. Overall, the method's recovery of known flower loci in the well-studied A. majus system lends confidence to the approach. However, some aspects - particularly related to the theory of hybrid incompatibilities and their detection through the Dxy metric, the conceptual framing of the method, and its power under different evolutionary parameters - need to be clarified.

      (1) There exists rich literature on the use of Dxy to detect so-called 'speciation genes' in the alternative contexts of primary divergence and secondary contact, with some of the best-known empirical cases consistent with the latter scenario. This secondary contact scenario is also proposed by the authors to underlie the evolution of flower loci here in A. majus. While it is clear that Dxy-tree outliers reflect deeply divergent loci, it is unclear whether these necessarily reflect barrier loci (underlying hybrid incompatibility) or if they may also reflect adaptive loci composed of old haplotypes carried by the parental lineages and maintained by divergent selection. The authors identify flower color genes as barrier loci, whereas the locus associated with plant height is interpreted in the context of adaptation. Moreover, the model presented to explain the flower barrier loci is in essence driven by divergent selection. Overall, little effort is made in the paper to explain conceptually different processes, and the ambiguity of the text makes interpretation difficult and inconclusive. This lack of conceptual elaboration also hinders interpretation of the Dxy-based distance trees in general. For example, it is unclear what the genome-wide Dxy tree (which appears distinct from the consensus phylogeny) is supposed to reflect, what evolutionary mechanisms could generate alternative tree topologies (partitions), how much of this is due to technical noise and skewed sampling versus demographic history and lineage sorting, and how such alternative partitions should be treated. The theoretical basis for distinguishing barrier from (old) adaptive loci, the properties of Dxy relative to other metrics, and the relationship between Dxy trees and these fundamental concepts need to be explained in light of the evolutionary mechanisms that generate the signal captured by this metric.

      (2) The paper would benefit from power analyses to assess the method's sensitivity and specificity under a range of evolutionary parameters (e.g. divergence time, migration rate), i.e., how old and how reduced must the local migration rate be (in comparison to the genome-wide distribution) for this method to be able to detect a significant signal? Knowledge of the sensitivity, specificity and limits of this approach is crucial, especially for the method's target application, i.e., less well-studied organisms with poorly characterized phenotypes. The most convincing results presented in the paper fall back to the partition corresponding to loci underlying divergent phenotypes that were already known a priori (i.e., the flower color loci), therefore questioning the primary scope of the new method. Further, the implementation presented currently lacks statistical procedures to discern significant forests from potential false positives. Guidance on model parameters (SRB and cophenetic correlation coefficient c thresholds, which are shown to have large effects on the results) should be proposed beyond heuristics, ideally based on an empirical null and probabilistic framework, and accounting for multiple hypothesis testing, to properly quantify model power.

      (3) The approach of using progressive elimination to cluster trees (into forests) may be problematic, because forest clusters are not strictly determined by those with the closest tree distance but rather by the order of seed trees (e.g., if the first seed tree has a 0.7 correlation with tree T1 and the second seed tree has a 0.9 correlation with that same tree T1, then even though tree T1 is closer to the second seed tree, it will be clustered with the first seed tree's forest). Clustering error from seed tree stochasticity is reduced by repeating the tree-scanning 100 times with independent random seeds; however, implementing a convergence metric to formalize this, or implementing an alternative algorithm that avoids progressive elimination of trees, would be a more robust solution.

      (4) The authors present two competing hypotheses: (i) that flower color genes act as barrier loci because they are eco-adaptive, and (ii) that the fitness landscape for flower color has two peaks within the same environment. The alternative framing of these two hypotheses is confusing because having multiple peaks in a fitness landscape is not mutually exclusive to being eco-adaptive, as they actually mention in the discussion. It would be less confusing if these were simply presented as one-peak versus two-peak fitness landscape alternatives.

      The study's proposed method of blind genomic tree scans is potentially very valuable to biologists working in the fields of speciation and adaptation. Here, in this case study on the model system A. majus, complementary evidence based on allele frequency clines and validation experiments using controlled crosses provides solid support for their results. However, for general application to other species - including non-model and less-studied species - more detailed profiling of the method and clearer conceptual framing is needed.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      Summary

      The authors investigated the impact of an auditory stimulus on visual integration at the behavioral, electrophysiological, and mechanistic levels. Although the role of alpha oscillations in visual perception has been widely studied, how visual cortical dynamics are influenced by cross-modal stimulation remains poorly understood. Using a two-flash fusion task, the authors demonstrated that auditory stimulation systematically prolonged the temporal window for visual integration by slowing the frequency of visual alpha oscillations. Interestingly, individuals showing greater auditory-induced slowing also exhibited a larger extension of the fusion threshold. Their results further revealed that auditory stimulation disrupted the link between prestimulus alpha frequency and perceptual outcome, while strengthening the association between prestimulus alpha phase and perception. Based on the perceptual cycles framework, the authors developed a model that accounts for these findings in terms of auditory-induced phase resetting. Importantly, the model assigns distinct roles to alpha frequency and phase: while frequency determines whether the two flashes occur within the same alpha cycle, phase modulates the reliability of the resulting perceptual report. This framework provides a mechanistic account of how auditory stimulation can differentially modulate the contribution of alpha dynamics to perception, highlighting the importance of investigating cross-modal influences on ongoing brain dynamics. More broadly, the model extends the perceptual cycles framework by proposing a mechanistic account of how alpha frequency and phase jointly shape perception during cross-modal processing. Overall, the authors successfully address their aims, and the convergence of behavioral, electrophysiological, stimulation, and modelling approaches provides strong support for their conclusions. By extending current accounts of alpha dynamics to cross-modal perception, the study offers a more naturalistic perspective on sensory processing and provides a useful methodological framework for understanding how alpha dynamics support perceptual integration across sensory modalities.

      Strengths

      The results are supported by a combination of complementary and well-established experimental and analytical approaches (e.g., two-flash fusion task, psychometric curves, and phase opposition), providing a strong methodological basis and enabling direct comparisons with previous findings in the literature. The authors also effectively relate their findings to the existing literature throughout the Discussion, placing their results within the broader context of current knowledge on alpha oscillations, perceptual cycles, and cross-modal integration.

      Importantly, the authors go beyond the correlational evidence provided by the EEG analyses by using tACS to experimentally manipulate alpha frequency, providing additional support for their main conclusions and strengthening the interpretation of the observed relationship between alpha dynamics and visual integration.

      A further strength of the study is the proposed model, which extends the perceptual cycles framework by assigning distinct functional roles to different features of alpha oscillations. In particular, distinguishing the contribution of alpha frequency from that of alpha phase provides a more nuanced account of how alpha dynamics shape perception. Importantly, this framework generates testable predictions that could be investigated using other experimental approaches and paradigms.

      Finally, the use of cross-modal stimulation provides a more naturalistic perspective on sensory processing, as perception in everyday life rarely occurs within isolated sensory modalities. By investigating how auditory stimulation interacts with visual alpha dynamics, the study therefore extends the investigation of alpha-mediated perceptual processes to a more ecologically relevant context.

      Comments on revised version.

      Following the previous rounds of review, I am very satisfied with the authors' revisions. The additional analyses and clarifications have substantially strengthened the manuscript, and the authors have provided detailed explanations addressing the points raised previously. Overall, I have no major concerns regarding the revised manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors address how a stable functional architecture supports flexible neural dynamics. They propose that brain activity measured with fMRI is a superposition of a small number of large-scale propagating modes, or "flows". Each flow is a "wave-like" pattern that engages brain networks in a fixed order, and these flows are the same across people and across rest and task. In this view, different cognitive states arise not from reconfiguring brain networks but from changing the relative timing, or phase, of these fixed flows: which flows are in step at a given moment determines which regions appear active. The strength, or amplitude, of each flow is instead proposed to reflect stable individual traits. To identify the flows, the authors divide fMRI signals into 27 large-scale networks, fit a single linear model describing how activity in these networks evolves from one time point to the next, and take the oscillatory components of this model (13 pairs of complex eigenvectors, via dynamic mode decomposition) as the flows. Using modes fitted to HCP resting-state data, the authors report that the principal flow aligns with the first two cortical FC gradients and with subcortical and cerebellar gradients, and that the next three flows capture lateralized interactions among the default mode, executive and salience networks. Modulating only the flow phases reconstructs activation maps from 23 tasks, and FC predicted from the modes matches task-state FC. Phase features decode the 23 tasks with 89.9% accuracy, compared with 76.6% for network activation and 28.4% for flow amplitude; flow amplitudes are heritable and modestly associated with general cognitive ability.

      Strengths:

      (1) The question is important, and a compact description linking resting-state organization, task activation and individual differences is interesting.

      (2) The analyses use large, public datasets (HCP, a multi-domain task battery and an audiovisual speech dataset), with held-out prediction and an independent replication sample.

      (3) The decoding result is the most novel contribution. Phase features separate conditions whose activation maps are nearly identical, which, if robust, indicates that the timing of large-scale propagation carries state information that activation amplitude does not.

      (4) The separation of group-level modes from subject-level amplitudes provides a common coordinate system for comparing individuals.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Relation to prior work:

      The stability-flexibility problem and the role of relative phase are central to coordination dynamics and metastability theory (Tognoli & Kelso, Neuron 2014), and connectome models have shown that dynamic phase flows coexist with stable time-averaged FC (Roberts et al., Nat. Commun. 2019). The correspondence between FC gradients, networks, the global signal and a few propagating patterns was also established previously with complex PCA on HCP data (Bolt et al., Nat. Neurosci. 2022). Readers should view the gradient and network results as a replication with a different decomposition.

      (2) Mechanism:

      The framework is descriptive: task phases are estimated from data, not generated by a model. The work therefore does not show how phase alignments are selected or sustained, and claims that cognition "emerges from" phase dynamics should be read as compatibility rather than demonstration.

      (3) Baselines and null models:

      The reconstruction is not compared with the ceiling set by projecting maps onto the 27 networks, or with amplitude-only and random-phase reconstructions. The decoding compares feature sets of different sizes. The only dynamical null is AR(1), and the gain over it during tasks is small.

      (4) Internal consistency:

      FC is argued to be invariant because phases decorrelate over time, yet the task analysis assumes phases held in specific alignments within blocks. These assumptions need to be reconciled.

      (5) (Possible) Physiological confounds:

      HCP data were analyzed without nuisance or global signal regression. The principal flow likely overlaps with the global, arousal-linked signal, whose apparent sequence partly reflects vascular transit delays. Recent work in mice shows that the leading propagating mode of infra-slow cortical activity, identified with the same DMD approach, can be reconstructed from pupil diameter alone, indicating that it largely reflects arousal dynamics (Raut et al., Nature 2025). This caveat extends to the heritability and cognition associations of flow amplitude, and to the interpretation of the flows as separate, cognitively specific processes.

      Overall, the work offers a useful descriptive decomposition and an intriguing decoding result, but its broader theoretical claims are not yet supported and should be read in the context of the prior literature on similar questions.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this work Ganesh and colleagues use experimental data from Hi-C and from the live-cell imaging to evaluate different polymer models of 3D genome organization in Drosophila based on both structural and dynamic properties. The authors consider several leading hypotheses, which are examined sequentially in increasing level of complexity - from the minimal Rouse polymer, to a model combining sequence-specific compartmentalization and loop-extrusion without extrusion blockers. They conclude that the combination of both compartmentalization and loop-extrusion gives the best agreement with the data. Their analysis also leads to concrete predictions about the processivity of cohesin loop extrusion in Drosophila, and a conclusion that the compartmental interactions strength is poised near criticality in the coil-globule phase space.

      Strengths:

      There is considerable interest in the field in understanding the mechanisms responsible for the 3D spatial organization genome and the dynamic movement of the genome, which has major implications for our understanding of long-range transcriptional regulation and other genome behaviors. The live-cell experimental work which this study draws on highlights the limitations of existing models to explain even the dynamic behaviors observed in the data, further exciting interest in further exploration. Therefore, this paper seeks to address an important gap in the field. The work is written in a well-organized, well-illustrated fashion. The text and figures are nicely integrated, easy to read, and explain challenging concepts with elegance and brevity in a manner that will be accessible to a broad audience.

      Comments on revised version.

      In their revision, the authors develop a creative work around to mitigate the effects of the homie tether elements - genetic components that are present in the live-cell data used but not the Hi-C data used for analysis in the paper, that otherwise create a conflict between the two results. Indeed, when these elements are not present, most of the genomic intervals sampled fail to interact at a frequency sufficient to induce expression by the reporter gene at all, whereas with these elements, significant transcription events were observed, and the contact frequency was increased substantially in the few cases where it was compared directly. As these synthetic elements affect both the 3D spatial organization and the dynamic behavior of the chromatin, they clearly confound any generalization to how chromatin in the wild-type Drosophila embryo behaves in a generalized sense, by identifying and masking bound interactions, the structural alterations caused by these elements was minimized, facilitating both the analysis and this interesting generalization.

      The paper would be strong still with a more thorough evaluation of the effectiveness of the masking of the tether interactions, and the corresponding improved agreement this creates between the imaging data and Hi-C data.

      These results are likely to be of interest to the broader community. They offer a plausible explanation of exciting and open quandary in the field raised by recent work. They also reinforce an emerging picture in which major properties of biological systems are poised near critical transitions of physical systems.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors present a novel, first-of-its-kind mathematical framework aimed at investigating the spatial redistribution of retinal microglia across specific anatomical layers-the outer plexiform layer (OPL), inner plexiform layer (IPL), and ganglion cell layer/nerve fiber layer (GCL/NFL)-during acute inflammation induced by exposure to lipopolysaccharide (LPS; a bacterial endotoxin). The model couples an LPS pharmacokinetic (PK) model with a system of ODEs describing cell migration between layers. The authors used experimental data from mice subject to an LPS challenge to select and calibrate a final model among different candidates. The authors then extended the framework to rats and rhesus macaques using blood LPS PK data, and simulated how different administration routes (intravenous vs. intraperitoneal) and species contexts might influence retinal microglia layout. To draw core conclusions, the authors also executed a careful global sensitivity analysis. Their primary conclusion is that redistribution patterns observed in mouse retinal microglia, and hypothesized in rats and macaques, are dictated predominantly by LPS pharmacokinetics and delivery routes rather than initial cellular distribution states.

      Strengths:

      (1) The manuscript establishes a first-of-its-kind, baseline mechanistic model for retinal immune cell movement between specific layers. This constitutes a solid contribution to theoretical studies of opthamology.

      (2) The authors perform thoughtful model selection and include in the supporting information a suite of alternative models. By testing and comparing alternative modeling hypotheses, the authors support their final choice of model as a deliberate and data-driven process.

      (3) High technical quality: The authors present a clear, thorough, and transparent technical description of the modeling and subsequent analyses. The use of profile likelihood to estimate parameter intervals is strong as it reveals any structural identifiability issues. The inclusion of a meticulous global sensitivity analysis adds rigor to the investigation.

      Weaknesses:

      I do, however, have some concerns about this study.

      (1) The authors are clear that this is a first-of-its-kind study, and while that's exciting, the authors never explicitly explain why mapping the precise spatial redistribution of microglia across the OPL, IPL, and GCL/NFL matters to the broader scientific community. This is likely low-hanging fruit: what disorders are associated with inflammation in these layers, for example?

      (2) The model relies entirely on blood concentration of LPS. That is, with one exception, every forward and backward migration rate in the ODE system (eqs 4-6) is directly multiplied by the circulating blood LPS fraction B/(B+eta_G, O). Because blood LPS concentration enters nearly every migration term, the model structurally assigns PK a central role in determining redistribution dynamics. It is difficult to disentangle whether the dominance of PK in the sensitivity analysis reflects a biological insight inferred from the data or a property imposed by the model architecture.

      (3) In equations (5) and (6), the return pathway from the GCL/NFL back to the IPL (G -> I) is modeled as a homeostatic density-dependent term (k_G*G*(G/G_0-1)) that is completely independent of B. The authors explicitly justify this choice by stating it enforces a "once inflammatory signals begin to weaken, microglia in the GCL/NFL are expected to return to their homeostatic density on a shorter time scale" (lines 190-192). However, because the k_G term lacks any mathematical coupling to B(t), it does not "wait" for the stimulus to subside, even during peak inflammation. The term appears to represent density-dependent regulation rather than inflammation-dependent resolution. The biological interpretation given in the text does not seem to follow directly from the mathematics.

      (4) It is also unclear why no LPS-dependent return pathway from the GCL/NFL to the IPL is considered. Such a mechanism could potentially provide a biologically plausible alternative to the purely density-dependent k_G term discussed above. Notably, no such term appears in any candidate model presented in the Supporting Information (the mention of k_GI in line 426 is likely a typo meant to be k_G).

      (5) The 95% Confidence Intervals (CIs) for the primary migration parameters (k_OI and k_IO) are unbounded above (line 284, Figure S3). This practical non-identifiability is rather unsatisfying and concerning: it indicates that the available mouse experimental data is insufficient to put a ceiling on cell migration speeds. The data do not appear to constrain an upper limit on migration speed (potentially because of the use of Hill functions).

      (6) Because the true statistical ranges stretch to infinity, the authors have to choose a range for PRCC. They choose to substitute an arbitrary Delta chi^2 <= 1 cutoff ("practical ranges") to run the PRCC sensitivity analysis and shift parameters through an arbitrary 600% blowout window. While the authors' transparency is commendable, the sensitivity analysis appears to depend on investigator-defined parameter bounds rather than ranges supported by the available data.

      (7) A key study prediction is that species-specific PK is a major factor affecting redistribution. However, the model uses systemic blood LPS concentration as the driving variable for microglial migration. Ocular exposure is not explicitly modeled. This omission becomes particularly important in the cross-species simulations, where anatomical differences between species could alter the relationship between systemic and retinal exposure. Because species comparisons are performed primarily by changing the blood PK profile (and, in the case of macaques, changing initial cellular distributions) while keeping retinal migration dynamics fixed, it is unclear whether the reported differences represent species-specific retinal biology or simply the expected consequence of imposing different LPS exposure patterns.

      (8) If I understand the framework correctly, the rat and rhesus macaque simulations utilize mouse-calibrated migration parameters and cellular sensitivity thresholds. Parameters governing responsiveness to LPS exposure (e.g., eta_O) are estimated entirely from mouse data and assumed to remain unchanged across species. The cross-species simulations primarily vary the blood PK profile while holding retinal response dynamics fixed. While this approach is useful for isolating the effect of systemic exposure, it limits the extent to which the resulting predictions can be interpreted as species-specific retinal biology.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors perform extracellular Neuropixels recordings in awake mice to characterize the firing properties of neurons in the three major subdivisions of the mediodorsal nucleus of the thalamus, which plays roles in executive functioning and social behavior.

      The authors found that the medial, central, and lateral subdivisions did have substantial differences in their firing properties that allowed for estimation of subdivision better than chance.

      Strengths:

      The strengths of the manuscript include the importance of this topic, which expands our understanding of MD thalamus (1) so we can move beyond generalizing findings from sensory thalamus to higher-order thalamus and (2) to guide future neurostimulation strategies. The strengths include the size of the data sets and the number of animals sampled. The manuscript is well-written, and the figures are clear. The results support the conclusions. This data set will be valuable for scientists involved in studying the higher-order thalamus and lower-order thalamus.

      Weaknesses:

      The major suggestion I have is to increase the rigor by using a linear mixed-effects model to account for the effects of cohort and animal. I don't think this additional analysis will change the findings or conclusions, but it will strengthen the statistical foundation of the paper. Studying only male mice limits the generalizability of the findings.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      In this study, the authors investigate the role of PARP16, an ER-resident mono-ADP-ribosyltransferase, in the heart. To address this, they generate a set of complementary mouse models: whole-body Parp16 knockout mice, constitutive and tamoxifen-inducible cardiomyocyte-specific knockout mice, and cardiomyocyte-specific transgenic mice overexpressing PARP16. Using these models, they show that loss of PARP16 causes pathological cardiac remodeling, whereas its overexpression protects the heart from isoproterenol-induced damage. Mechanistically, they propose that PARP16 regulates the nuclear translocation and transcriptional activity of NFAT1 through mono-ADP-ribosylation (MARylation), thereby linking this post-translational modification to hypertrophic and remodeling signaling in the heart. The conclusions rest on in vivo phenotyping, biochemical assays and immunofluorescence analyses.

      Most of the conclusions are supported by the data, but some aspects of the biochemical assays, western blots and data analysis need to be clarified and improved.

      Specific comments:

      (1) Figure 1:

      In Figure 1F, the authors describe a reorganization of α-actinin, but no quantification supports this conclusion; the phenotype should be quantified. The immunofluorescence images are not sufficiently clear and need to be improved. The organization of Figure 1J is misleading, and the transfection control should be separated from the ANP and α-actinin staining. The PARP16 immunofluorescence is not convincing: no clear difference is observed between the control in Figure 1F and the PARP16-overexpressing samples in Figure 1J. If the protein is tagged, an anti-tag antibody should be used to show overexpression. The catalogue number reported in the Methods for the PARP16 antibody is incorrect. In Figures 1G and 1K, the meaning of "−ve" and "+ve" is not explained. Moreover, the graphs lack error bars, and the number of experiments is not reported.

      (2) Figure 7:

      In Figure 7B, quantification of the blot should be included. Panels 7G and 7J report the same values for VIVIT-treated samples, and their representation in two separate graphs is misleading. The authors should merge them into a single graph including pre-treatment, vehicle and VIVIT-treated samples. In Figure 7K, the identity of p-NFAT1 is unclear: is the band at the same molecular weight as total NFAT1? No arrow is indicated in the raw data file, and no molecular weight markers are shown. If it comes from a different gel, was the phosphorylated form normalized to its own loading control? Why does NFAT1 run at 140 kDa here rather than at 110 kDa, as in all other panels? The quantification in 7L does not reflect the blot shown in Figure 7K.

      (3) Figure 8:

      The description of Figure 8 in the text is confusing. In Figure 8A, the results for PARP16 WT overexpression are misleading: why is the effect of PARP16 WT overexpression more pronounced upon silencing? The authors should discuss this point and include a control western blot showing effective knockdown and rescue of PARP16 protein upon overexpression. The level of PARP16 overexpression in Figure 8C is unexpectedly low, almost comparable to the non-transfected sample, and is therefore not convincing. Moreover, GAPDH and PARP16 migrate at almost the same molecular weight (about 36 kDa), yet the band indicated as PARP16 in the raw images is at a higher molecular weight than expected and than indicated in Figure 8C. The loss of the PARP16-NFAT1 interaction upon overexpression of PARP16 Y254A should be commented on in the text. Finally, no reference to panel 8D was found in the text.

      (4) Supplementary data:

      In lines 202-206, the authors state that "immunoblotting and gene expression analyses did not reveal marked alterations in the major UPR pathways in PARP16-deficient hearts (Fig. S1E-G)", and conclude that ER stress is absent. This conclusion is only partially supported. Gene expression of UPR targets is unchanged (S1G), but the western blot (S1E) and its quantification (S1F) do not support the same conclusion. PARP16 is important for PERK and IRE1 activation upon ER stress, and phosphorylation of eIF2α (p-eIF2α normalized to total eIF2α?) is significantly reduced in the PARP16 KO samples, suggesting an alteration of the PERK axis. To rule out defects in the IRE1 branch, XBP1 mRNA splicing should be evaluated by PCR. Since PARP16 loss could affect the stability of its substrates PERK and IRE1, measuring GRP78/BiP protein and mRNA levels would help assess cardiac UPR induction. Finally, the blot shows n=3 samples, while the quantification is based on n=4; why was the fourth sample excluded from the image in the raw data of Figure S1? Additional points: the font size for "110 kDa" should be corrected. Figures S2B and S2C show the same limitations reported for Figures 1F and 1K, respectively. Figure S3E is not discussed in the main text. This panel shows an HA-NFAT1 immunoprecipitation in the presence or absence of PARP16-FLAG, but the expression of HA-NFAT1 (input) and its immunoprecipitation (IP HA) are very limited. By contrast, the amount of co-immunoprecipitated PARP16-FLAG is abundant relative to the bait, even though its expression in the input is poor compared to the non-transfected samples. Collectively, this experiment is not convincing.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this work, the authors aim to explore in detail the effects of the DNA-PK inhibitor AZD7648 (AZD), previously applied by themselves and others as a strategy to enhance homology-directed repair in genome editing by shifting the balance of repair events away from non-homologous end joining (NHEJ), which is mediated by DNA-PKcs. While successful at promoting NHEJ and thus desired targeted editing, various reports in the field have described DNA-PK inhibitors as also promoting large-scale structural variants at the target site and elsewhere in the genome

      In this study, Cloarec-Ung and team use two approaches, namely bulk long-read nanopore sequencing and, at the single-cell level, STRAND-seq, an approach to map strand-specific read alignments for each chromosome, to define the nature of such SVs in singly (SRSF2 or DNMT3a) and doubly edited hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) with AZD treatment. For both sequencing approaches, the authors developed custom analysis pipelines to improve/expand SV calling. In the case of long-read sequencing, this pertains to a strategy to discriminate true deletions from sequencing artifact truncated reads, while in the STRAND-seq analysis they developed a strategy to call inter-chromosomal events in addition to the intrachromosomal events previous pipelines have been optimized for.

      The authors describe two main findings:

      (1) DNA-PK inhibition modestly increases the frequency of on-target large deletions above CRISPR editing, which they also describe as inducing a high frequency of editing on its own.

      (2) They show that in the single-edit scenario, genome-wide off-target editing is low-frequency in nature with editing alone and not substantially increased with AZD. Multiple editing events did however, exhibit increased SVs, including translocations, with AZD treatment resolving this. Pursuing the potential to ameliorate the elevation of large on-target deletions via DNA-PK, the authors also explored the inhibition of PolQ-dependent theta-mediated end joining (TMEJ), a process anticipated to increase in response to the repression of NHEJ and thus potentially drive these elevated SVs. They describe the addition of a DNA PolQ inhibitor, showing through long-read sequencing a mitigation of the AZD-dependent and independent large on-target deletions.

      Altogether, this work provides validation that CRISPR cutting coupled with HDR repair carries risks of a variety of SV events, that AZD addition can promote these (in particular large on-target deletions and inversions) but modestly, and offers a strategy to mitigate some of these SVs, namely large on-target deletions. This work will be of interest to those in the gene therapy space and working to understand the fundamental control of gene editing strategies and DNA repair mechanisms.

      Strengths:

      The bilateral anchoring strategy the authors develop represents a generally useful new approach for calling a large category of deletion events on long-read data.

      Similarly, the inter-chromosomal chromatin exchange calling pipeline provides a helpful advance in measuring these changes in single-cell STRAND-seq data.

      The study provides a comprehensive mapping of all manner of SVs spanning on- and off-target deletions, duplications, inversions, and translocations through two orthogonal approaches and in the same, highly relevant HSPC context.

      The use of STRAND-seq provides an unbiased assessment of SVs across the genome and can also capture the maternal vs paternal chromosome contributions and the combinations of SVs that occur at the individual cell level, which offers new insights not previously provided with bulk-level analyses or approaches that are "bait-dependent" and linked to changes that involve the target site.

      The PolQ inhibitor (PolQi) studies provide good evidence that some of the unwanted SVs enacted in CRISPR HDR strategies can be offset by preventing TMEJ with this approach. They further convincingly indicate that the combined effects of AZD and PolQi could be an advantageous approach to both achieve highly efficient on-target editing while minimizing detrimental genomic changes, particularly large deletions.

      Weaknesses:

      Although STRAND-seq provides several unique advantages, certain questions could not be rigorously addressed in the present study. In particular, assessing statistically significant differences between conditions was complicated by the inherent cellular heterogeneity captured by this single-cell technology. Robust quantification of SV patterns generally requires profiling large numbers of cells; however, only modest numbers of cells were available for each editing condition in this study. As a result, the number of detected SV events was insufficient to support robust statistical testing across groups, necessitating more qualitative comparisons of SV patterns and frequencies.

      As the authors discuss, another caveat of STRAND-seq is the requirement of carrying out sequencing after HSPCs have been cultured for 7-9 days, which could underestimate the editing changes as cells are lost both by selection and random attrition over this time.

      While a bulk sequencing approach, CAST-seq has been used by others in the field for mapping SVs and, if tested here, could have offered a direct comparison to the author's STRAND-seq outcomes as well as a means to benchmark both techniques and cross-compare results to other studies. This strategy could also have allowed for the more direct testing of the full scope of SVs occurring directly following editing.

      Relating to the long-read sequencing done, mixing of HSPCs from female and male was performed, and the total number of male vs. female HSPC samples individually edited was small. While there was an intriguing observation of a potential increased rate of large deletions in the HSPCs of male cord blood donors, the study was underpowered and thus could not verify this with statistical significance.

      One caveat to the bilateral anchoring strategy used in the long-read pipeline would seem to be the possibility of undercalling telomeric deletions, which may be of particular importance in this study given that SRSF2 is subtelomeric on Chromosome 17.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public Review):

      This paper describes careful work on the effects of light adaptation on the spatio-temporal receptive fields of retinal ganglion cells assessed using an ex vivo preparation on a multielectrode array. The results are analyzed systematically and clearly but do not provide a clear insight into this important aspect of retinal function, in part because of doubts about how they might extrapolate to the situation in vivo.

      Strengths:

      - A potentially interesting question: Do changes in average luminance alter spatio-temporal receptive fields of different types of retinal ganglion cell (RGC) in different ways? Or are different types of RGC affected in similar ways and to similar extents? Previous work going back decades has investigated the effects of luminance adaptation in a piece-meal way but this study makes a more systematic comparison across six types of RGC.

      - Experiments and analyses have been carried to a very good level.

      - Thorough description of the results with clear figures.

      - A scholarly presentation that includes important literature.

      Weaknesses:

      - Some of the effects observed in the six types of RGC, such as shortening of integration times at higher luminance, have been recognized for some time (as is clearly discussed).

      - The most novel funding is probably that one of the six types of RGC, the ON brisk-sustained, exhibited a proportionately larger change in integration time than other types, but this has not been placed in a functional context. The impact of the paper in terms of understanding retinal processing is unclear.

      - A major drawback of all work on an MEA, usually ignored by users of this technique, is that diffusible neuromodulators are removed by perfusion. Neuromodulators can profoundly adjust processing through the retina and their levels can change in response to changes in luminance. The retinal network on an MEA is therefore likely to be far from its normal state. It is hard to know how far the ability of a retina on MEA to adapt reflects adaptation in vivo.

      - An important control, reversing the direction of the luminance change, has not been carried out. If stepping back from a higher light level to a lower level does not (at least partially) reverse the changes caused by an increase in luminance, it may be that the lack of a pigment epithelium is affecting the results more severely than estimated by calculation.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This paper investigates how physical perception and morphology are integrated to determine what kinds of substrates different species of insects, here flies, prefer for laying their eggs. These questions have far-ranging implications, in particular because the authors include Drosophila suzukii, a lineage of Drosophila that has made the transition from rotting to fresh fruit and therefore functions as a significant agricultural pest. Through careful experimentation, the authors show that individual components of oviposition behavior, including chemosensory and physical perception of substrate stiffness, vary across ten species, creating unique responses in each. By integrating functional and fitness experiments, the authors provide evidence linking these differences to morphology, genetics, and the neural basis of behavior.

      Strengths:

      A significant strength of the paper is the elegant simplicity of the experiments. Even though many of these species have been studied for decades in the laboratory, there is still much to learn from straightforward observations of their behavior under different conditions. The authors show that there are species-specific responses to the physical perception of stiffness (something often overlooked in studies of oviposition preference), that these responses are associated with fruit ripeness, but that they can be successfully separated from chemosensory signals in the laboratory. They further show that the morphology of the egg-laying machinery, in particular the ovipositor, has implications for the success of these preferences, as it allows some species to successfully pierce the skin of ripe fruits, with the result that larvae are able to feed and develop into adult flies. Finally, they show that differences in behavior in response to stiffness are in part associated with apparent differences in the function of key genes (e.g., iav). When iav sequences from D. immigrans or D. suzukii are expressed in D. melanogaster, they do not fully rescue the stiffness-dependent oviposition phenotype.

      Weaknesses:

      The weaknesses of the paper are largely in the interpretation of these results. Cross-species studies such as these, especially in Drosophila, face challenges in interpreting the evolutionary and ecological basis of observed behaviors. This is in part because we often consider these species in isolation from their natural environments and phylogenetic context. The authors attempt to tackle this problem by examining adult emergence from substrates collected in the wild, and their results are broadly consistent with what is suggested by the laboratory assays.

      However, some of the most interesting and complex aspects of their results remain insufficiently explored. For example, across their assays of physical and chemical preferences for oviposition, they find that:

      (1) D. suzukii has a clear preference for ripe fruit and reduced avoidance of stiff substrates, representing a substantial shift in niche use.

      (2) D. immigrans is capable of using ripe fruit as a substrate but shows nearly no preference between ripe and rotten fruit or between stiff and soft substrates.

      (3) D. biarmipes shows a preference for ripe-fruit chemical cues and will lay eggs on ripe fruits, despite a strong aversion to stiff agarose substrates.

      (4) D. mercatorum will likewise lay eggs on ripe fruits and stiff substrates, predominantly on the surface, but has a clear preference for other options.

      (5) D. quadrilineata, like D. immigrans, has the ovipositor morphology required to successfully lay eggs in ripe and stiff substrates but shows a strong preference for rotten fruit and soft substrates.

      A major result communicated through these experiments is therefore that multiple inputs must be integrated to determine oviposition behavior, and that each species appears to weigh these inputs differently. The diversity of these responses is itself one of the most interesting findings of the study, but the authors' focus on a binary interpretation of niche specialization obscures this variation rather than embracing it.

      The field ecology data provide useful evidence of natural host associations, but the reported sampling information limits their interpretation. Without information on sampling effort, host availability, and fruit ripeness and damage at collection, it is difficult to establish differences in niche breadth or exclusion from particular hosts. Adult emergence also does not reveal whether females laid eggs through intact skin or used previously damaged or decaying fruit. These results are therefore consistent with the laboratory observations, but do not establish that mechanical access determines ecological partitioning or reduces competition in the wild.

      More generally, it is difficult in studies comparing species that have been maintained for generations under laboratory conditions to interpret variation in behaviors observed in the laboratory. We expect differences across species because they have distinct genomes, ecologies, and evolutionary histories. Moreover, some species may have spent many more generations under laboratory conditions than others, and standard laboratory conditions were largely designed around some species (particularly D. melanogaster) rather than others. This makes it difficult to establish the extent to which differences in oviposition reflect biologically meaningful differences in preference that might allow them to function within a specific niche. For example, it may not be helpful to compare absolute oviposition rates under the same experimental conditions given that species differ in the number of ovarioles in their ovaries, rates of oogenesis, metabolism, and other aspects of reproductive biology. Within-species choice assays partly account for differences in egg production, although relative preferences may still depend on multiple aspects of reproductive biology and the options provided. Even so, it is valuable to see how these species behave under the same experimental conditions, if only to establish a comparative baseline.

      One direction in which this work could point in the future is toward investigating the ecology of these flies under the conditions in which their traits were likely to have evolved. These traits presumably arose in ecosystems where competition and interactions with other species were important components of fitness, yet under laboratory conditions these factors are largely removed and therefore invisible. Some of the summary statements in the manuscript also reflect a tendency to interpret species in terms of niche specialization versus niche expansion ("generalism"), when in reality these species are responding to multiple stimuli, and their observed behavior reflects only one component of their potential niche use. Placing the diversity of behavioral responses documented here into a broader ecological and evolutionary context would therefore strengthen the interpretation of an already valuable comparative dataset.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary

      In this manuscript, Gini et al. investigate the mechanisms by which CDK4 and CDK6 upregulation drives resistance to EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) in EGFR-mutant lung adenocarcinoma (LUAD). The study utilizes preclinical models, including cell line-derived xenografts (CDXs), patient-derived xenografts (PDXs), and primary organoids, alongside large-scale clinical genomic datasets. The authors demonstrate that CDK4 or CDK6 overexpression allows cancer cells to bypass EGFR TKI-induced G1/S arrest, leading to continuous cell cycle progression. This sustained proliferation during EGFR inhibition induces DNA replication stress, activates DNA damage response pathways (such as ATM and TPX2), and ultimately causes genomic instability. The authors also show that this leads in turn to the upregulation of tumor-promoting genes (e.g., AGR2, ASNS, STEAP1) and an epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) phenotype. Moreover, the authors show that combinatorial treatment utilizing TKIs such as osimertinib alongside CDK4/6 inhibitors effectively suppresses proliferation, mitigates DNA damage, and restores TKI sensitivity in preclinical models.

      Overall, this is a highly translational study that provides a strong mechanistic rationale for biomarker-driven clinical trials combining EGFR and CDK4/6 inhibitors. However, there are a few experimental and analytical areas that require clarification or additional data to fully support the authors' conclusions.

      Major Comments

      (1) Reliance on overexpression models over loss-of-function

      The mechanistic studies mainly rely on overexpression of CDK4 and CDK6 to simulate the amplified state. Although the authors argued that the level of overexpression mimic that observed in resistant tumors, a complementary study in which CDK4/CDK6 were suppressed in a model where CDK4/CDK6 is amplified (such as HCC827 or TH116) and replication stress and osimertinib sensitivity tested would greatly strengthen their observations. Indeed, there is mention of CDK4 constructs to perform knockdown studies in the methods, but those studies are not included in this submission.

      (2) Mechanistic link between genomic instability and specific gene amplifications

      The authors highlight that CDK4/6 activation leads to recurrent copy number gains and transcriptional upregulation of specific pro-tumor genes including AGR2, ASNS, and STEAP1. While the paper establishes that CDK4/6 overexpression causes general genomic instability (increased FGA), it does not mechanistically explain why these specific genes are consistently amplified. The authors should investigate or discuss whether these specific loci are inherently fragile under replication stress, if they are direct downstream targets of the E2F transcriptional program, or if this is a result of random genomic instability followed by strong positive selection under osimertinib pressure.

      (3) Discrepancies in tumor mutational burden (TMB) reporting

      There is a slight contradiction regarding the TMB data that needs to be clarified for readers. The manuscript states that in the clinical datasets, "EGFR-mutant LUAD harboring cell cycle gene alterations exhibited significantly elevated FGA and TMB relative to cell cycle-negative tumors" (Line 265-266). However, in the next section, the authors say, "Notably, no corresponding increase in TMB was observed with CDK4 or CDK6 CNA, similar to our findings in preclinical models" (Line 271-273). The authors should clarify or discuss why broad cell cycle alterations correlate with high TMB, while CDK4/6-specific alterations drive structural instability (FGA) without increasing TMB.

      Comment on revised version.

      While this reviewer appreciates the reticence to embark on extensive open-ended studies, the authors were asked to do limited experiments to further confirm the generalizability of the studies. Knockdown studies in cell lines with amplifications would confirm small molecule studies, and the use of other EGFR inhibitors would provide evidence that the findings are not specific to one inhibitor. As such, it is disappointing that the authors have elected to argue that these studies are beyond the scope of this report - indeed, they would strengthen this report, which could be quite impactful.

    1. CLINICAL REPORT A 32-month-old girl presented with a history of increased sweating mainly at night-time, reddening of the skin of hands and forearms, epigastric pain and weight loss of about 7% following a febrile illness 2 months prior to admission. On physical examination, she had erythema of both hands and forearms with cold, moist skin and was otherwise unremarkable. In particular, there were no café au lait macules, freckling, cutaneous neurofibromas, or Lisch nodules on eye examination. Her growth parameters were; length 98 cm (97th centile), weight 13.5 kg (50th centile), and OFC 50.2 cm (75th centile). Her blood pressure was elevated to 167/108 mm Hg (95th centile for 3 years: 110/69 mm Hg [National High Blood Pressure Education Program Working Group, 2004]). Initial laboratory findings were non-specific; virus-serology showed recent HHV6 infection. Chest X-ray, electrocardiogram and echocardiography were normal. Abdominal ultrasound identified a mass in the region of the right adrenal gland, which showed inhomogeneous gadolinium-uptake on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The presumed diagnosis of neuroblastoma was supported by a marked elevation of urinary vanillylmandelic acid, whereas urinary homovanillic acid and dopamine were within the normal range. However, I-123-metaiodobenzylguanidine (MIBG) scanning and F18-FDG-PET-CT did not show tracer-uptake by the tumor. Serial blood pressure measurements showed sustained arterial hypertension that was refractory to conventional antihypertensive treatment with nifedipine. Pheochromocytoma was confirmed by a marked elevation of serum-chromogranin A (855.1 ng/ml; normal range [NR] 0–100) and elevated plasma catecholamines: normetanephrine (4,781 pg/ml; NR: 0–200), noradrenaline (15,802 pg/ml; NR: 0–600), adrenaline (400 pg/ml; NR: 1–100), and dopamine (195 pg/ml; NR: 1–100). Metanephrine was within the normal range. Following pretreatment with phenoxybenzamine, partial right adrenalectomy was performed. Histopathology confirmed the diagnosis of pheochromocytoma with marked areas of necrosis (Fig. 1). One week after surgery, plasma and urinary catecholamines/metanephrins had returned to normal. Genetic workup identified a heterozygous mutation c.491A>G (Q164R) (Fig. 2) in exon 3 of the VHL gene. Due to the very young age of the patient we excluded additional mutations in exons 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, and 16 of the RET-protooncogene and in the exons, at the exon–intron-borders and in the 5′ non-translated regions of the SDHB-, SDHD-, and SDHC genes by molecular genetic analysis. Screening of the patient for other manifestations of VHL (retinal and CNS hemangioblastomas, endolymphatic sac tumors, renal, and pancreatic cysts) by MRI imaging of abdomen, head and spine as well as fundus examination did not identify other manifestations of VHL. Upon follow-up, the child gained 4 kg of weight within 4 months and she is normotensive with normal urinary and plasma metanephrins.

      PatientID: 1 (case)

      KindredID: 1

      Case: F, 5Y5M, Ethnicity Unknown

      DiseaseAssertion: pheochromocytoma

      FamilyInfo: Extended analyses of her relatives (parents, a sibling, and, subsequently, in the paternal grandparents) showed that the mutation occurred de novo in the patient’s father who was subsequently diagnosed with bilateral pheochromocytomas and a retinal angioma.

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0006748 (adrenal pheochromocytoma)

      CaseHPOFreeText: At 2.75Y, the young girl presented with pheochromocytoma, after presenting with a history of increased sweating mainly at night-time, reddening of the skin of hands and forearms, epigastric pain and weight loss. Abdominal ultrasound identified a mass in the region of the right adrenal gland, which showed inhomogeneous gadolinium-uptake on magnetic resonance imaging

      CaseNotHPOs: HP:0009711; HP:0010797; HP:0030393; HP:0000107; HP:0001737 (retinal capillary hemangioma, hemangioblastomas. endolymphatic sac tumor, renal cyst, pancreatic cysts)

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: retinal and CNS hemangioblastomas, endolymphatic sac tumors, renal, and pancreatic cysts) by MRI imaging of abdomen, head and spine as well as fundus examination did not identify other manifestations of VHL. Additionally, there were no caf?e au lait macules, freckling, cutaneous neurofibromas, or Lisch nodules on eye examination.

      CasePreviousTesting: RET, SDHB, SDHC, SDHD

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: p.Q164R (c.491A>G)

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: 2238 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/variation/2238/

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: missense_variant;transition

      CivicName: Q164R (c.491A>G)

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    1. PatientID: H13

      KindredID: 1

      Case: M, 58Y0M, Ethnicity Unknown

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      FamilyInfo: No definite family history of VHL disease or hemangioblastoma brain tumors.

      CohortInfo: Eleven patients with sporadic hemangioblastoma were enrolled and diagnosed with a neurological examination. Four of these were found to have a germline mutation of the VHL gene.

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0009713 (Spinal hemangioblastoma)

      CaseHPOFreeText: Tumor location: C2. Patient underwent total excision of the tumor resulting in complete recovery.

      CaseNotHPOs: HP:0009711; HP:0002012 (Retinal capillary hemangioma, Abnormality of the abdominal organs)

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: Negative ophthalmoscopic examinations for hemangioblastoma, and unremarkable abdominal ultrasounds and computed tomographic imaging.

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: Table 1.

      Variant: p.T133Nfs*2 (c.397dup)

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: CA645524931, https://reg.clinicalgenome.org/redmine/projects/registry/genboree_registry/by_canonicalid?canonicalid=CA645524931

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: plus_1_frameshift_variant; duplication

      CivicName: T133Nfs*2 (c.397dup)

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

  2. Nov 2026
    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In their manuscript entitled " Single-molecule behavior and cell-growth regulation in human RTKs" Abe et al. demonstrate automated single-particle tracking of 52 receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) in both resting state and upon stimulation with the respective ligands. The approach is based on transient transfection of cells with each RTK tagged with a Halo-tag, allowing for subsequent dye labeling and live cell video recording using TIRF microscopy. Subsequently, a seemingly commercial analysis software is used to then obtain particle trajectories from single molecule localizations and analyze their properties using a hidden Markov model. The authors have previously demonstrated pioneering work in the field of single-particle tracking with respect to automation (Yasui et al, 2018) and analysis (Yanagawa et al, 2021), and in this work they scale their approach up to characterize a broad set of RTKs. The resulting observations are a powerful demonstration of the benefits of SPT in general and significantly advance our understanding of the dynamics of RTKs as a class, beyond the most prominently studied candidate EGFR, as well as promising evolutionary insights.

      The authors satisfactorily addressed all my previously raised points.

      Significance:

      The manuscript by Abe et al. represents a significant advancement in the field of single-particle tracking (SPT) by scaling up recording 52 human receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs), offering comprehensive insights into their dynamics beyond the traditionally studied EGFR. While the study demonstrates cutting edge single-particle tracking and provides promising evolutionary insights, it currently lacks certain methodological details that are essential for reproducibility, such as specific parameters used in particle localization and trajectory analysis. The exclusion of 6 out of 58 human RTKs without discussion also requires further explanation, but overall, the study fills a knowledge gap by providing a broad overview of RTK dynamics and their diffusion behavior. Overall, this work should have broad appeal to fields such as cell signaling as well as methods development int the area of single-particle tracking.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Over the past 3 or 4 decades, our understanding of the molecular mechanism underlying the circadian clock has increased substantially. This is in large part due to successful forward and reverse genetics approaches applied to a broad range of genetic model systems notably Drosophila, Neurospora, mouse, Arabidopsis and cyanobacteria. Although the clock components in these species are diverse, the basic operating principles are highly conserved allowing us to build a general view of clock mechanisms. Looking forwards, there are still many unanswered questions regarding how clocks are organized at the systems level and in turn how they are coupled to key aspects of physiology. Each model species has its own set of advantages and disadvantages for tackling particular questions. As this timely review aims to illustrate, the zebrafish has become into a particularly valuable model for exploring circadian clock biology. This is in part due to its technical advantages, accessibility of early developmental stages and its directly light-entrainable peripheral clocks. This provides unparalleled opportunities for studying the circadian clock hierarchy and its links with physiology.

      Strengths:

      This review does a good job of integrating the many lines of circadian clock research where the zebrafish has been used as a model and provides an overview of many future challenges it is well suited to tackle.

      Weaknesses:

      There are many citation errors as well as inaccurate and misleading statements that must absolutely be remedied in a revised version.

      Comments on revised version.

      There are still several issues that need attention, relating again to poor attention to detail in the selection of citations as well as conclusions made by the authors that are not backed up by the published data that they cite.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This paper presents a large structural survey of extracellular vesicles (EVs) and non-vesicular extracellular particles (NVEPs) in the olfactory sensilla of Drosophila melanogaster. Using high-pressure freezing and serial block-face SEM, the authors avoid many of the artifacts associated with conventional fixation and analyze more than 7,800 particles across 352 sensilla. The manuscript maps the distribution of these particles, describes their morphological heterogeneity, and examines their likely origins across different sensillum classes in both normal and degenerating tissue.

      Strengths:

      The strongest aspect of the paper is the imaging. Preservation is painstakingly controlled. The cryofixation appears to preserve the sensillum lymph in a convincing native state than standard preparation methods, giving this work gravitas. Further the authors characterized thousands of particles, further making this data strong.

      The figures are strong. They are clear, easy to read, and generally well designed, I think people will use this paper as a model on how to present complex data in a concise and straightforward manner. The manuscript is careful in how it presents the dataset and does not overinterpret the descriptive observations. As an ultrastructural resource, this paper will be useful to the field. The identification of auxiliary support cells as major secretory sites, together with the striking accumulation of EVs in degenerating tissue, will provide a useful starting point for future work.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have completely addressed my concerns from the initial review. The revised text and Methods now clearly explain the vesicle categorization specifically how "dense," "cargo-filled," and "double EVs" are defined as strictly morphological groupings rather than verified biological classes. This is a rigorous and valuable ultrastructural resource.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Wang et al. examined an engineered senescent tumor cell-based live vaccine, in which senescent tumor cells are co-encapsulated with liposomal celecoxib in a chitosan hydrogel. The authors propose that prolonged persistence of senescent cells, combined with COX2/PGE2 inhibition, restores natural killer cell and dendritic cell crosstalk, enhances type 1 conventional dendritic cell recruitment, and drives robust CD8+ T-cell-mediated anti-tumor immunity. The study is nicely executed and clearly presented, with extensive in vitro and in vivo validation across multiple tumor models, including melanoma brain metastases and orthotopic pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma. The revision adds four new experiments and substantially expands the discussion, and addresses most of the concerns raised previously.

      In the revised version, the authors have directly tested whether the vaccine works through senescence-specific antigens or through antigens shared with the parental tumor. Using matched and antigen-mismatched senescent cell vaccines in mice bearing the same tumor, they find that the matched vaccine is considerably more effective, and they have accordingly removed their earlier speculation about senescence-specific neoantigens from the discussion. This is a well-designed comparison, and the authors willingness to revise their interpretation in light of the new data is a strength of the revision. As presented, the statement that these data demonstrate the point is stronger than the evidence supports. The comparison between the two vaccine arms, which is the contrast on which the conclusion depends, is also not shown statistically in the figure.

      The authors have likewise strengthened the case that the immunological effects reflect prostaglandin E2 suppression rather than properties peculiar to celecoxib, by showing a comparable effect with a second inhibitor and reversal by added prostaglandin E2. The logic of this experiment is sound and the rescue arm is the appropriate control. However, the result is shown only as representative images, without cell counts, sample sizes, or statistical analysis, whereas the equivalent experiment in the original submission was quantified. In its present form, readers cannot judge the magnitude or reliability of the effect.

      On the question of eventual clearance of the senescent cells, the authors now provide a time course showing that the hydrogel degrades fully within four weeks, with no histological evidence of tissue damage. This is a useful addition. It should be noted, however, that this experiment documents the fate of the delivery matrix rather than of the cells themselves, so the inference that exposure of the local tissue to senescent cells and their secretory products is bounded at approximately four weeks does not strictly follow from it. The authors already report imaging of labelled senescent cells elsewhere in the manuscript, and extending that readout across the same time course would address the question directly. Degradation is also assessed only by gross photographs, and the absence of immune infiltration is based on histology without quantification.

      The authors have appropriately acknowledged that the requirement for type 1 conventional dendritic cells was not tested, explaining that the relevant genetic models were unavailable. This is a reasonable position, and the limitation is candidly stated. Readers should therefore understand the proposed innate-to-adaptive mechanism as correlative, some of the surrounding language in the discussion still implies a causal chain that has not been established. The remaining points raised previously, concerning senescence heterogeneity, terminology, and translational considerations, have been addressed satisfactorily through new discussion sections.

      Strengths:

      (1) Strong conceptual framework combining senescence biology and biomaterials.

      (2) Impressive breadth of in vivo models, including brain metastasis and orthotopic pancreatic cancer.

      (3) Clear immunological readouts.

      (4) A well-controlled new experiment distinguishing shared from senescence-specific tumor antigens, with the interpretation revised accordingly.

      Evidence that the effect reflects prostaglandin E2 suppression rather than a single compound.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The requirement for type 1 conventional dendritic cells remains untested, so the proposed mechanism is correlative.

      (2) Several new supporting datasets are presented without quantification, sample sizes, or statistical analysis.

      (3) Clearance of the senescent cells themselves is inferred from degradation of the delivery matrix rather than measured directly.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Foik et al. studied the regulation of the fro operon in response to HOCl and Taurine N-chloramine, oxidants derived from immune cells, especially neutrophils. They use a transcriptional fusion of YFP to the froA promotor in an mCherry expressing P. aeruginosa strain to determine fro induction under the microscope. They use this system to study fro expression in medium, in the presence of neutrophils and macrophages, neutrophil-conditioned medium, and several chemical stimuli, including NaCl, HOCl, taurine N-chloramine, hydrogen peroxide, nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, and sodium hydroxide. They also use a corneal infection model to demonstrate that froA is upregulated in P. aeruginosa 20 h post infection and perform transcriptional analyses in WT and a froR mutant in response to HOCl.

      Strengths:

      Their data clearly shows that HOCl is a strong inducer of the fro Operon. Addition of HOCl-quenching chemicals together with HOCl abrogates the response. They also show that a froR mutant is more susceptible to HOCl than WT. Their transcriptomic data reveals genes under control of the FroR/FroI sigma factor/anti sigma factor system.

      Unexpected outcomes and open questions for future research:

      (1) As outlined above, HOCl seems to be a strong inducer of the fro operon. Interestingly, during interaction with immune cells, macrophages and neutrophils seem to induce a reporter gene under fro control in a similar manner, although macrophages are generally thought to produce less HOCl, when compared to neutrophils. May be this view needs to be revised, or another reactive species, produced by macrophages, can activate the fro operon as well: H2O2 might be produced in sufficient quantities by these immune cells.

      (2) The fro operon was originally described to be activated by shear stress ("flow-regulated operon") by Sanfilippo et al. (2019, Nat Microbiol, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41564-019-0455-0). This initial study used plain LB medium in a fluidic chamber to induce the shear stress. However, later studies by Padron et al. (2023, Proc Nat Acad Sci USA, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2216774120) showed that the presence of hydrogen peroxide is required in the flow medium to induce the fro operon and that the naturally occurring amount of hydrogen peroxide in plain LB is sufficient. To clarify this fact, the authors could amend their sentence in line 84 to read "P. aeruginosa responds to shear generated by the flow of hydrogen peroxide-containing fluids via the fro operon, which is upregulated in the bacterium during infection in humans". In light of the authors' new findings, it seems likely that in contrast to H2O2, HOCl does not need the additional shear stress to activate the fro-operon, while the underlying oxidative mechanism of activation is the same. As the authors suggest, additional shear stress could lead to fro induction at even lower HOCl concentrations, but this has not been tested.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study aims to demonstrate that humanized immune system (HIS) mouse models can recapitulate colorectal cancer (CRC) immunology for immune-oncology research. The rationale is convincing, and there is an unmet need to overcome the limitations of other genetically engineered or syngeneic mouse cancer models. The authors bring new knowledge to the field through this comprehensive single-cell study across both normal spleen and CRC tumors, benchmarked against publicly available scRNA-seq datasets. They show that general immune subsets found in humans are achieved in these HIS mice, including exhausted T cells and other activated T cell states, which they were able to identify through single-cell transcriptional profiling. The authors demonstrate the feasibility of generating HIS mice with subcutaneous CRC tumors that resemble features of human tumor immunology, but there is still room for improvement and additional analyses to expand on these findings.

      Strengths:

      The matching of HIS mouse data to human data was logical and a good way to benchmark the dataset. Additionally, the use of cell lines representing each of the consensus molecular subtypes (CMS) gave way for a more nuanced approach to studying the HIS mice as opposed to a singular representation of CRC. In general, the data generated from this study provide ample ground for further exploration and analysis.

      Weaknesses:

      Most of the analyses are compositional - e.g., percentages from dissociated tissues without environmental or spatial context. While establishing abundance and distributions of cell types is important to convince the field of the utility of these models, measuring the presence of these cell types alone may not be sufficient to explain their reliability as a concrete preclinical model.

      Moreover, while the major immune cell types were present in both HIS mice and the human spleens from publicly available datasets, there were still discrepancies present that may not be fully explained by technical constraints alone, and a deeper look at these differences could be useful. The discussion provided an overview of the limitations of the model (high abundance of immature pro B cells, absence of human stromal components, limited myeloid lineage maturation), which was appreciated.

      There was more left to be desired with the CMS group comparisons - it was interesting that cell composition did not differ between CMS1 and CMS4 subtypes but that the location of specific cell types mattered (e.g., increased CD4+ T cells and CD163+ macrophages at the tumor center in CMS4 tumors). This may ultimately be related to how tumors respond to treatments, and a better understanding of the contributions of spatial localization of immune cells in HIS mice could be beneficial. It would also be interesting to show the transcriptional profiles of the CMS2 and CMS3 tumors despite them being generally non-immunogenic, in case there are differences with human data. Like in human data, there is also clearly a lot of "inter-patient" variability among the HIS mice across cell types, which could potentially be a case for uneven benchmarking. Overall, this is a commendable effort, but it misses some key experiments that could provide even more compelling evidence that these HIS mice can be used as standalone models for the evaluation of immunomodulatory treatments in CRC.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Authors examined neural substrates for cognitive empathy (conceptually understanding others' emotions) versus affective empathy (automatically sharing others' emotions) development in 3-5-year-old toddlers and argued that cognitive empathy emerges earlier than affective empathy, challenging the predominant view that affective empathy develops earlier. The authors developed an empathy test for toddlers while measuring their brain activity with fNIRS (particularly in MPFC, STG, DLPFC, and TPJ) and heart rate. They found different brain region activation in cognitive versus affective empathy tasks, as well as age-related changes in the activation of right MPFC and right TPJ.

      Strengths:

      This work investigated the development of different components of empathy, which is a quite understudied topic. The authors developed an age-appropriate task for toddlers to measure their cognitive empathy and affective empathy, which is likely useful for future research in this field. Their methods are sound, and give the relatively large sample, the results look interesting and relatively solid.

      Weaknesses:

      Although the authors have tempered some of their claims in the revision, parts of the paper still strongly advocate for the earlier developmental emergence of cognitive empathy (e.g., with the foundational affective empathy model and wordings such as "this provide the first direct evidence for the earlier emergence of cognitive empathy", "this groundbreaking empirical evidence in support of a foundational cognitive empathy model") . Given the limitations that the authors currently acknowledge (e.g., longitudinal data needed, possible maturation of other cognitive processes recruited by the task), the evidence does not seem to fully support such strong temporal assertions.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors have added new text that clarifies the key limitations of cRSA that tRSA addresses, including a textual description of an example setting, and elaborated on how to think about the pairwise dependencies in both cRSA and tRSA, highlighting that tRSA is not 'immune' to inference problems caused by dependencies and cautioning researchers to cross-check results with permutation-based inference. Both additions are helpful improvements to the paper.

      To address the previous concern around generalizability of the findings, the paper now also includes a cRSA/tRSA comparison in a second real fMRI dataset, in Appendix. This dataset shows highly similar outcomes for cRSA and tRSA, thus providing support that the method's sensitivity (vis-à-vis cRSA) generalizes to another dataset. However, it does not clearly showcase the claimed 'benefit' of tRSA - unlike in the fMRI dataset in the main text, where tRSA is used to model item-level variance so as to better detect mnemonic effects. Thus, the additional insight from the second dataset is limited.

      To address concerns around code accessibility, a public repository with R code is now available, containing a simple example script that shows how to run tRSA on a simulated model representational structure and simulated noisy neural activity measurement, plus a script for running what appears to be the full set of simulations from the paper. However, reproducible code for the fMRI analyses as reported in the paper seem to be absent and a comprehensive README explaining what these scripts do, or how to use them, is lacking. Thus, the facilitation offered to help other researchers adopt the proposed method remains minimal.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors use a combination of genomics, genome conformation assays and CRISPR-mediated deletion to study the transcriptional regulation of the SOX2 gene in human neural stem cells (hNSCs) with a focus on conserved distal elements already known to regulate Sox2 in mouse neural stem cells.

      Strengths:

      The authors show that two distal elements located ~550kb downstream of the SOX2 gene are important for SOX2 transcription in hNSC. They investigate both the deletion of these elements in established hNSCs and in hNSCs generated by differentiation of human pluripotent stem cells suggesting these elements are important in both establishment and maintenance of SOX2 expression in hNSCs.

      Weaknesses:

      Homologous elements have been studied in the mouse genome and have conserved function in the regulation of Sox2 in mouse NSCs. These studies are cited but the findings in the studies are not made clear in the text. Although the authors cite relevant literature that studies this element in the mouse genome they fall short of making it clear that in mouse NSCs homozygous deletion of this element, termed DNE, has been shown to greatly reduce Sox2 expression (PMID: 36717694). As a result, the authors overstate the novelty of their findings as they do not make previous findings clear.

      Inclusion of biological replicates for the scRNA-seq and replicate CRISPR-deleted clones would strengthen the study.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      In this study, the authors investigate the spatial organization of direction and orientation selectivity in the mouse superior colliculus (SC) and its retinal inputs. By combining two-photon imaging of retinal boutons and SC neurons with Neuropixels recordings, they assess whether tuning preferences form structured maps or are arranged in a salt-and-pepper fashion. They further compare SC tuning organization to previously described retinal geometric models to determine the extent to which collicular responses inherit retinal topography. The authors conclude that SC inherits a cardinally biased topographic scaffold from the retina, which progressively weakens with depth, and that strong global maps are absent.

      A major strength of the study is the impressive combination of methodologies, including imaging of retinal boutons, imaging of SC neurons, and large-scale electrophysiological recordings across SC depth. The direct comparison to retinal geometric models is particularly valuable, as it situates the SC within a broader framework of retinotopic information transfer and advances our understanding of how retinal computations are transformed in downstream targets.

      A limitation of the study, however, is that the imaging experiments sample only a relatively small and spatially homogeneous region of the visual field, whereas the electrophysiological recordings cover a different portion of SC. This separation makes it difficult to form a fully integrated, global picture of the spatial organization of direction and orientation selectivity across the entire collicular map.

      Comments on the latest version:

      The revised manuscript has addressed several of my previous concerns. The limited spatial coverage remains an important constraint on conclusions regarding large-scale organization, but this limitation is now more explicitly acknowledged. I have two remaining comments regarding the interpretation of specific analyses.

      (1) Definition of the population used to test the retinal orientation model:

      I appreciate the authors' clarification that direction and orientation/axis tuning are not treated as mutually exclusive, as their goal is to quantify the information about each stimulus feature present in the responses rather than to identify distinct functional cell classes. However, I am less convinced that the same rationale applies to the comparison with the retinal orientation model in Figure 3.

      The orientation model used in Figure 3 is derived from the topographic organization of OSGCs, whereas the population tested against this model includes a large number of boutons classified as both DS and OS/axis-selective. For these units, orientation/axis preference can be derived from a direction-selective response and does not necessarily imply that the bouton originates from an OSGC. It is therefore unclear why these boutons should be expected to follow a topographic model derived specifically from OSGCs.

      The authors should therefore clarify the biological rationale for applying the OSGC model to the combined population and discuss whether the apparent correspondence with retinal orientation topography depends on including DS+OS/axis-selective boutons.

      (2) Multiple boutons from the same RGC

      I agree with the authors' response that if some RGCs make more boutons than others, this may represent genuine weighting of the retinal input received by SC and should not necessarily be corrected away. However, this rationale does not fully apply to analyses asking whether nearby boutons have more similar tuning than expected by chance (Figure 5). Multiple boutons from the same axon would be both spatially close and similarly tuned and could therefore account for at least part of the very short-range similarity observed among retinal boutons. The manuscript should therefore be careful not to interpret this effect as evidence for spatial organization across independent RGC inputs unless axonal identity can be controlled.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript investigates how the metabolically activated proteostasis regulator AA147 influences CD4+ T-cell differentiation. The authors provide evidence that AA147 preferentially suppresses TH17 differentiation, reduces RORγt protein abundance without substantially decreasing Rorc transcription, and engages an NRF2-dependent antioxidant response associated with reduced intracellular ROS. In addition, the study identifies a broader, NRF2- and ATF6-independent reduction in IRF4 that is accompanied by decreased effector cytokine production across several CD4+ T-cell subsets.

      Strengths:

      The work addresses an interesting intersection between proteostasis, redox regulation, and T-cell differentiation, and several aspects of the study are compelling. In particular, the combination of genetic NRF2 deficiency, pharmacological pathway perturbation, RNA-seq, quantitative proteomics, and testing under distinct TH17-polarizing conditions provides multiple complementary lines of evidence. The observation that AA147 reduces RORγt without substantially altering Rorc transcription also raises an interesting possibility of post-translational control of TH17 lineage specification.

      Weaknesses:

      Several of the central mechanistic conclusions currently extend beyond what is directly demonstrated. In particular, the proposed causal pathway linking AA147-induced NRF2 activation and reduced ROS to proteasomal degradation of RORγt remains incompletely established. Moreover, the broad effects of AA147 on IRF4 and cytokine production across multiple CD4+ T-cell subsets complicate the claim of selective TH17 targeting. Finally, the current study is largely restricted to ex vivo murine differentiation, whereas the Discussion emphasizes potential therapeutic application in inflammatory disease. Addressing the points below would substantially strengthen both the mechanistic depth and the overall interpretation of the study.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript presents a miniaturized microscope capable of structured illumination using the HiLo approach. This is achieved through adding a second excitation path with a Ronchi grating to generate time-multiplexed excitation that sequentially generates wide-field and lined images at 15 FPS each. Through lightweight HiLo computation, this results in a 15 FPS recording with larger spatial components removed. Structured illumination can reduce background signal, out-of-focus neuronal signals, and can achieve optical sectioning for multi-plane imaging in some cases. The core engineering idea in this manuscript is clever and motivated by a fundamentally limiting aspect of wide-field imaging.

      My central problem is that I cannot identify what the authors are arguing for overall. The paper evaluates HiLo against two conditions: raw widefield ROI pixel-averaging, and full CNMF source extraction. Nothing in between the 2 extremes is considered but this is the space where it seems the real gains from this approach could be made. Within those two conditions, the authors report that after CNMF extraction, HiLo provides no significant advantage in SNR or decoding accuracy. A spatial-information difference remains, but it disappears for deconvolved signals after event-rate matching. The conclusion I can draw from the manuscript's central figure is that one should use a conventional widefield miniscope and run CNMF. The remaining claim, that HiLo lets you skip offline demixing, is a narrow one, and it is not demonstrated, including in the authors' closed-loop experiment, where spatial footprints were identified offline in advance. I do not think this is what the authors intend to convey, but the manuscript lacks support for another story.

      Beyond this, the manuscript has a number of unsupported critical claims and gaps in methodology and comparisons, which I try to outline below. I think the approach and tool itself are interesting, but as presented, I am not able to judge how much it improves real-world 1p imaging, and I suspect the improvement is smaller and more specific than the framing implies. To be clear, I think there is value in this work, but I think the claims need to be narrowed to what is currently demonstrated or analysis be added to support unsupported claims.

      Major Concerns:

      (1) The comparison space is missing its middle, where HiLo would be most relevant to compare against other widefield processing

      HiLo combines a physical change in hardware and acquisition with a computational processing step, and the manuscript never separates the two. The demonstrated advantages of this approach are either measured against unprocessed widefield or mostly disappear once CNMF is applied.

      The comparison that likely is most relevant, widefield with lightweight preprocessing alone, spatial filtering and background subtraction as simple as removing a minimum projection, appears nowhere. These steps are standard in the field and are built into essentially every CNMF pipeline, including Minian, MIN1PIPE, and CaImAn. As presented, it is unclear whether the physical Ronchi mask achieves anything that lightweight preprocessing cannot.

      The current comparisons do not establish how much benefit specifically requires patterned acquisition rather than lightweight digital background suppression: HiLo + CNMF performs no better than widefield + CNMF on SNR or decoding accuracy. The small spatial information difference that remains does not survive the authors' own activity rate matching control. If optical sectioning were removing background that computation could not, these comparisons should favor HiLo.

      Separately, and I do not see this acknowledged anywhere, HiLo is given twice the raw data, since each output frame is built from two camera frames while the widefield condition is one of those streams at 15 FPS.

      (2) Inconsistent use of CNMF-E comparisons

      CNMF is run with different parameters on the two modalities, justified on the grounds that the modalities "differ in signal intensity and signal-to-noise characteristics." That difference is the quantity being measured, so the justification is possibly circular.

      CNMF is also used in two structurally different roles that are never distinguished. In one, it serves only to find and segment cell footprints. In the other, its extracted traces are used directly. The first use discards demixing, which is a major point of CNMF and the reason it is standard in the field, not SNR improvement. The manuscript does not address demixing, which is arguably the most important processing challenge in 1P imaging due to scattering and cell overlap. Optical sectioning can indeed help in certain cases of this but that isn't argued, supported, or shown here. It leaves me asking what I think is an important question given how this manuscript is structured: what are the limits on how HiLo can separate out-of-plane cells?

      (3) Concerns around simulated data

      The performance of HiLo depends on the patterned line spacing/frequency relative to the spatial scale of features being suppressed vs retained. The simulated data does not address this dependency. The grating period is given as roughly 28 µm at the sample plane, but the spatial frequency response it produces is never characterized, and the simulated neurons and local background are described only as having "distinct dimensions" with no sizes stated. The one ratio that determines the outcome is therefore unspecified on both sides. Without a spatial frequency filtering curve, or performance across a range of spatial scales, the simulation could simply be tuned to the pattern spacing that gives optimal results. Related to this: how was the pattern line spacing determined? Was it optimized for the brain region, microscope parameters, expression pattern, and imaging depth used in experiments? This is not discussed.

      (4) Support for calling HiLo "multi-plane or volumetric imaging"

      I do not think the data support this being two distinct planes in the brain. The quoted axial sectioning is narrower than the stated separation between the two planes, which should leave little signal leaking between them, yet Figure 3D reports a substantial fraction of cells detected in both. These are difficult to reconcile.

      Field curvature is a possible straightforward alternative explanation for two focal settings yielding largely non-overlapping cell sets, and nothing in Figure 3 distinguishes it from true depth sectioning. It would equally explain the SNR difference in Figure 3E as increased aberration toward the edge of the GRIN lens. CA1 is also approximately a single cell layer thick, which makes resolving cells at truly different depths here unlikely. I am not suggesting that these alternatives necessarily explain the result, but they should be distinguished from true depth-resolved optical sectioning before the data are characterized as volumetric imaging.

      Lastly, the claim in lines 165-168 that this "increases neuronal yield while maintaining reliable signal quality across imaging depths" lacks the proper comparison. Figure 3 has no widefield condition, so yield is compared only against a single HiLo plane. The proper comparison would be against processed widefield imaging at a single optimally-chosen focal plane. Lower per-plane counts are also expected by design under optical sectioning and cannot serve as evidence of improved performance without that control.

      (5) Place cell analysis

      I have several methodological concerns with the place cell analysis:

      a) Place field analysis should use deconvolved neural activity, not calcium signals. Deconvolved signals appear only in Figure 4 and Figure Supplement 2; the main figure uses ΔF/F for the ROI condition and raw CNMF fluorescence for the other.

      b) Lines 170-172 motivate this analysis by the "improved performance of HiLo imaging in suppressing background fluorescence for ROI-based signals," but ROI averaging without demixing is not the standard analysis for place-cell inference. CNMF or similar demixing is generally used and should be the main comparison.

      Concerning the spatial info content differences in Figure 4: how do the authors know that HiLo+CNMF is more correct than WF+CNMF? They observe a minor but significant difference, but there is no literature (and none cited) that would support the implied conclusion that, since HiLo results in higher spatial info content, it is somehow extracting more accurate neuronal dynamics. Even if decoding performance improved, Figure 4I shows no significance for CNMF-extracted signals, and artificially suppressing weak parts of a place field could improve these metrics without reflecting truer neural signals. The authors' own data argue for exactly this: HiLo signals show significantly lower event rates, and when event rates are matched between conditions the spatial information difference disappears (Figure 4-figure supplement 2). However, this control was applied only to the deconvolved signals and not to the ROI-based signals that carry the central claim.

      (6) Real-time experiment adds little value

      The closed-loop demonstration does not establish that HiLo enables anything beyond current capabilities. Spatial footprints are identified offline before training, and there are existing real-time streaming calcium imaging approaches that work once cell footprints are identified. The DeCalciOn approach (Chen et al., eLife 2023) demonstrates that similar decoder performance can be achieved without even requiring cell ROIs.

      I do note that the discussion states these demonstrations are not intended to define the primary application domain of the device. Nevertheless, the title leads with real-time neural decoding, and the demonstration occupies a main figure. I don't believe anything in it demonstrates that the described experiments are enabled by HiLo and could not be done with existing widefield systems right now. The authors would benefit from being able to directly show and argue for this, or they should change the framing of this section.

      Overall Assessment:

      The core engineering contribution, integrating structured illumination into a miniature microscope with a reasonably direct approach, is a clever design that is worth reporting. However, the manuscript's central claims about improved performance are undermined by how the comparisons are set up. Fully processed HiLo data is placed against either raw widefield or full CNMF, with nothing in between, and that middle ground is where the standard lightweight processing used across the field actually sits. Where CNMF is applied to both, the advantage largely disappears, which makes it difficult to tell what the physical approach is contributing at all. The multi-plane imaging claims may be overstated and potentially confounded by field curvature, while the correspondence between the bench calibration and effective in vivo axial sectioning is not directly validated. The place cell analysis has methodological issues, and the real-time decoding demonstration does not establish that HiLo enables capabilities beyond what existing systems can achieve.

      My view is that the claims need to be narrowed to what is currently demonstrated, or the analyses added to support them, and I would be happy to read and review a revised version.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Caio and colleagues ask whether localized injury to the adult Drosophila optic lobe (OL) produces a measurable deficit in visually guided behavior, and whether flies recover that behavior over time. Building on the authors' earlier work showing that OL stab lesions reactivate quiescent, deadpan-positive neural progenitors, they use the Buridan arena to record locomotion and orientation towards two inaccessible vertical stripes. They report that bilateral OL lesions selectively increase the stripe deviation angle one day after injury while leaving most locomotor parameters intact; that flies tracked longitudinally improve their orientation by one week post-injury and then plateau or decline; that a majority of individuals re-express their pre-injury left/right approach bias; and that RNAi knockdown of myc in adult progenitors, which the authors have previously shown blocks injury-induced proliferation, abolishes the one-week improvement. From this, they propose that activation of adult progenitors supports behavioral recovery during an early plasticity window.

      Strengths:

      (1) The behavioral paradigm is well matched to the lesion: Rather than a global measure such as climbing or negative geotaxis, the authors use a readout - stripe fixation - that depends on the structure they damage and on an identified circuit element (dorsal cluster neurons, DCNs). The demonstration that stripe deviation changes (while activity time, number of walks, and most other CeTrAn software parameters do not) is the most persuasive part of the paper and is supported by two independent, reasonably large cohorts.

      (2) Longitudinal within-individual tracking is a real methodological contribution: Most invertebrate injury studies compare independent groups at successive timepoints. Recording each fly at baseline, 1 dpi, 1 wpi, and 2 wpi, and then plotting individual recovery trajectories, is the right design for a question about recovery, and it is what makes the question about idiosyncratic traits askable at all. The field would benefit from this becoming standard.

      (3) Baseline pre-screening is a thoughtful design choice: Selecting high-responder flies before injury (Figure 2B) sensibly removes the large fraction of animals whose baseline stripe fixation is too weak for a deficit to be detectable, and the inclusion of a thorax-puncture group addresses the generic-wounding alternative, at least in part.

      (4) The study links a cellular phenomenon the laboratory has characterized in detail to a functional outcome: Attempting to connect adult neurogenesis in the fly to behavior, rather than stopping at cell counts, is the right ambition and is unusual in this literature.

      (5) The individuality framing is novel and interesting: Asking whether an animal recovers not merely a species-typical behavior but its own idiosyncratic version of it is a genuinely original question, and one for which Drosophila is unusually well suited.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The title implies more than the data show:

      No measure of plasticity, such as cellular, synaptic, or circuit, is made in this manuscript; what is measured is behavioral recovery, with one genetic perturbation (using one RNA line) implicating progenitors. A title and abstract framed around behavioral recovery and its progenitor dependence would match the evidence. In addition, the proposal that newly generated medulla neurons integrate within seven days to restore a developmentally specified, individual-specific approach bias is a strong claim that warrants explicit discussion against simpler alternatives (circuit-level compensation, synaptic adaptation, resolution of peripheral damage). Lastly, the manuscript lacks a paragraph that discusses the study's limitations.

      (2) Damage to the eye itself is not excluded as the cause of either the deficit or the recovery:

      The lesion is made by passing a 0.2 mm filament through the compound eye to the level of the medulla. Relative to the dimensions of the fly head, this is a substantial injury to the retina, and photoreceptor loss, corneal damage, hemolymph leakage, or melanization would all be expected to degrade stripe fixation without any optic lobe circuit involvement - and would all be expected to resolve or stabilize over roughly a week. The manuscript contains no histology of the lesion site, no documentation of lesion extent or reproducibility, and no independent assay of peripheral visual function (electroretinogram, optomotor response, phototaxis) at any timepoint. The thorax puncture controls for systemic wounding but not for eye damage, which is the relevant confound here.

      (3) Specificity to optic lobe damage is overstated relative to what Figure 2C shows:

      The text describes the thorax-injury group as showing "a very mild increase... except for 2 individuals", but the mean of this group in Figure 2C rises appreciably from baseline, and the within-group statistics for that comparison are not reported. If thoracic puncture alone degrades stripe fixation, then part of the OL effect is attributable to general injury, illness, or reduced arousal, and the conclusion that the deficit is "strongly dependent on OL injury" needs to be toned down.

      (4) The progenitor-dependence conclusion is underpowered:

      The key group (injured myc RNAi flies) contains 11 animals, against 29-30 for the injured control. The conclusion is drawn from the fact that improvement reaches significance in the control group and not in the myc RNAi group; this is a comparison of "presence vs. absence of significance", not a test of whether the two recovery trajectories differ, and with the difference in animal numbers, the asymmetry is expected on power grounds alone. The group/time interaction is not reported. In addition, there is no independent myc RNAi line, no rescue, no orthogonal means of blocking progenitor division, no driver-only or UAS-only controls at 29 {degree sign}C, and no verification in these particular cohorts that proliferation was in fact blocked. Myc is pleiotropic, and dpn-T2A-Gal4 expression is not restricted with certainty to the progenitors of interest, so an effect on behavior through a route other than blocked progenitor division cannot presently be excluded.

      (5) The assay's range is never established:

      No condition in the paper (blind flies, or the arena without stripes) defines the stripe deviation expected from an animal with no usable vision, so the reader cannot judge what fraction of the available dynamic range the deficit occupies.

      (6) Selection on a noisy post-injury measurement, without a selection-matched control, can generate apparent recovery in the absence of any biology:

      For the longitudinal experiments (Figures 3 and 4), the authors retain only flies whose stripe deviation exceeded 30{degree sign} at 1 dpi (e.g., 29 of 89 injured animals in Figure 3). Selecting individuals on the extreme value of a variable measured with error guarantees that, by regression to the mean alone, their next measurement will, on average, be closer to the population mean. The non-injured comparison group (n = 65) is the full, unselected cohort and was not subjected to an equivalent selection step, so the two trajectories are not comparable.

      (7) The idiosyncrasy result is not supported by a statistical test:

      Recovery of an individual's pre-injury left/right bias is scored as a binary outcome, and 62% is reported as recovery. For a binary trait, 50% is the chance expectation; no null model, no test, no confidence interval, and no sample size for the pie chart are given, and the test-retest stability of the bias in uninjured flies over the same interval, the necessary benchmark, is not shown.

      (8) "Plasticity window" is inferred from three time points:

      With measurements at 1 dpi, 1 wpi, and 2 wpi only, the time course between one day and one week is unsampled, so the onset, duration, and closure of the proposed window are not resolved. The 2 wpi decline is attributed to aging, which the non-injured controls support, but this also means aging and recovery act in opposite directions across the very interval used to define the window.

      Impact and utility:

      If the recovery phenomenon survives the controls outlined above, the approach would be genuinely useful to the field: a quantitative, individually resolved, repeatable behavioral assay for functional outcome after CNS injury in an organism with the genetic tools to dissect the underlying cellular events. That combination does not currently exist in Drosophila injury work, where functional outcome is typically scored coarsely. The idiosyncrasy angle also connects two literatures - injury/regeneration and behavioral individuality - that have developed largely independently, and the question of whether recovery restores the individual or merely the species-typical phenotype is worth asking well beyond the fly.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors used multivariate and multi-session fMRI approaches to address an important question: how the brain coordinates binocular rivalry with binocular integration of disparity information. Compared to binocular fusion, binocular rivalry stimuli presented in the central visual field disrupted the disparity representation of a surround stimulus composed of random-dot stereograms (RDS) in V3A and IPS of the dorsal visual stream. This disruption to binocular disparity was observed not only for correlated RDS, but also for anti-correlated RDS in V3A, which shows an inverted disparity representation. Finally, informational connectivity analysis suggests weakened information flow between V3A and other visual areas. The authors conclude that V3A and IPS of the dorsal visual stream serve as key regions coordinating interocular competition and integration in binocular vision.

      Strengths:

      The study used a factorial design to manipulate binocular disparity and binocular competition independently in the same fMRI experiment. A large amount of fMRI data was acquired for each participant from multiple sessions to improve the reliability of results at the individual level. Several multivariate methods, including multivoxel decoding and cross decoding, decision-angle analysis, and informational connectivity, were applied appropriately to address the same question from different angles. The results were quite clear, especially the increasing rivalry cost to disparity decoding along the visual hierarchy shown in Figure 2B. The manuscript is well written.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The number of participants (n = 8) is extremely small for a conventional 3T fMRI study. While the Ng et al. 2021 study used the same number of participants, it is ultra-high-field fMRI that has much higher signal sensitivity and specificity than 3T fMRI. Thus, it cannot be used to justify the low number of participants in the current study (Line 339).

      (2) While a large amount of data (5 hours of fMRI) has been acquired for each participant from multiple sessions, there is no demonstration of whether the results were reproducible across sessions or reliable within each participant.

      (3) The retinotopic ROI for the annulus of the disparity stimulus was not accurate. While they used a retinotopic localizer (Line 450), the contrast between the annulus stimulus and fixation is not location-specific and will certainly activate brain regions corresponding to the central binocular grating stimuli. This contamination of signal from the central stimulus is more severe in higher-order brain regions like V3A and IPS, which could explain the disruption to disparity decoding in these regions.

      (4) This is extremely worrisome because there was no behavioral effect or rivalry cost on RDS stimulus surrounding the rivalry stimuli. The rationale for studying the interaction between binocular rivalry competition and binocular disparity integration using two different stimuli at different locations is not explained in the manuscript.

      (5) The no-report paradigm cannot be justified by the claim that anti-correlated RDS failed to produce depth perception (Line 76). Their behavioral results in Figure 1C clearly show that participants reported inverted depth to anti-correlated RDS.

      (6) MRI data acquisition. The authors mentioned parallel imaging (GRAPPA = 2) to reduce distortion, but there is still missing important information about image distortion. Has partial Fourier been used? What is the pixel bandwidth and echo spacing?

      (7) MRI preprocessing. The preprocessing section does not describe the method used for spatial alignment of functional data across sessions. This is important because all data were combined for multivariate analyses, and alignment errors arising from inaccurate methods would greatly impact the accuracy of the results.

      (8) One-sided tests were not justified. Many important claims were supported by one-sided tests, including the rivalry effect in the correlated condition (CF vs. CR) and informational connectivity (vs. 0). This is suspicious and unusual. The authors must justify why they chose one-sided tests for their main results.

      (9) 12 disparity conditions were combined into 2 conditions for analysis, but the authors did not explain why. They could potentially look at the rivalry cost to disparity tuning in these brain regions.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This article reports what appears to be the first evidence of healed injuries on an apex predator of the Cambrian: a radiodont flap, probably belonging to Amplectobelua symbrachiata. Because the injuries show signs of healing, the animal survived the attack, which provides direct evidence of predatory interactions among the apex predators of the Cambrian and sheds new light on the structure of food webs at that time.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript is short but well written, and the evidence for healing is clearly presented. I find this study genuinely interesting and a valuable contribution to our understanding of Cambrian ecosystems. The figures are of high quality and help readers understand both the results and the interpretations proposed by the authors.

      Weaknesses:

      My main criticism concerns the interpretation of the shape of the injuries and, therefore, how the predation would have occurred. The injuries are presented as W-shaped, which is true for only part of them. This contrasts with the drawing, which shows a large W-shaped injury that fits the oral cone drawing perfectly. I think it is too simplified compared to the real shape of the injury. To me, it looks more like a large V-shape with two irregularities. In my opinion, the large V-shape could correspond to a bite from the oral cone, but shaped by one plate only, while the two irregularities, which led the authors to call it W-shaped, could have been shaped by the frontal appendages. It could therefore be proof of the function of the appendages: grasping prey to bring it to the mouth. It also seems that the oral cone drawing used as a model is not identified. Do we have an Amplectobelua oral cone, or does it suggest Ramskoeldia? This needs further clarification. A new paper on radiodont oral cones, which figures most of them, has just come out (Potin et al. 2026, Swiss Journal of Palaeontology).

      Omnidens is also mentioned as a potential predator; however, this is not supported by any drawing, which would be good to have, as it is mentioned in the abstract.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Guo et al. investigate how acute stress affects memory-based inference and whether retrieval practice protects against these effects. Across two experiments involving 136 participants, the authors report that stress impairs inference performance and alters rapid neural reactivation of bridge-related memories. Retrieval practice appears to preserve both inference performance and the associated neural reactivation.

      Strengths:

      (1) Two independent experiments strengthen confidence in the behavioral findings.

      (2) Time-resolved EEG decoding provides valuable temporal information about bridge-related memory reactivation during inference.

      (3) The findings connect a practical learning strategy with behavioral and neural measures of resilience to acute stress.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The physiological interpretation requires some clarification. Although the manuscript acknowledges that cortisol was not measured, wording referring to a confirmed cortisol peak remains. The timing reflects an expected physiological response rather than a measured peak, and the available measurements cannot distinguish the respective contributions of glucocorticoid and adrenergic activity.

      (2) Significant comparisons in Figures 4 and 6 remain difficult to identify in the supplied revised manuscript. Clear annotations and corresponding legend definitions would improve interpretation.

      The authors have acknowledged these concerns in their response, but the corresponding revisions are not fully reflected in the manuscript provided. These remaining issues can be addressed through minor revisions.

      Appraisal and Impact

      This study provides evidence linking stress-related impairment in memory-based inference to altered rapid reactivation of bridge-related memories. The combination of behavioral experiments and time-resolved EEG offers insight into the processes supporting inference under stress. The finding that retrieval practice can preserve performance and associated neural reactivation is relevant to cognitive neuroscience and applied learning research.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors sought to understand the drivers of spontaneous attentional bias and melodic expectation generation during listening to short two-part classical pieces. They measured scalp EEG data in a monophonic condition and trained a model to reconstruct the audio envelope from the EEG. They then used this model to probe which of the two voices was best reflected in the neural signal during two polyphonic conditions. In one condition the original piece was presented, in the other the voices were switched in an attempt to distinguish between effects of (a) the pitch range of one voice compared to the other and (b) intrinsic melodic features. They also collected a behavioural measure of attentional bias for a subset of the stimuli in a separate study. Further modelling assessed whether expectations of how the melody would unfold were formed based on an integrated percept of melody across the two voices or based on a single voice. The authors sought to relate the findings to different theories of how musical/auditory scene analysis occurs, based on divided attention, figure-ground perception, and stream integration.

      Strengths:

      (1) A clever but simple manipulation - transposing the voices such that the higher one became the lower one - allowed an assessment of different factors that might affect the allocation of attention.

      (2) State-of-the-art analytic techniques were applied to (a) build a music attention decoder (these are more commonly encountered for speech) (b) relate the neural data to features of the stimulus at the level of acoustics and expectation.

      (3) The effects appeared robust across the group, not driven by a handful of participants.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Although melody statistics are mentioned throughout, none have been reported. It would be helpful to see the features that lead to "motif attractiveness" quantified, as well as how they differ across lines. The work of David Huron such as at https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3469013.3469016 provides examples that could be calculated with ease and compared across the two lines: "the tendency for small over large pitch movements, for large leaps to ascend, for musical phrases to fall in pitch, and for phrases to begin with an initial pitch rise". The authors also mention differences in ornamentation. Such comparisons would make more tangible for the reader what does differ across the original "melody" and "support" line. In particular, as the authors themselves note, lines in double-counterpoint pieces can to a degree operate interchangeably. Bach's inventions in particular use a lot of direct repetition (up to octave invariance), which one would expect to minimise differences in the statistics mentioned. If there were differences in the number of note onsets in the "melody" and "support" line, the implications for attentional capture and biasing of TRF estimates need to be considered. references purporting to relate to melodic statistics (11-14 in original numbering) seem rather to relate to high-voice superiority.

      (2) Clearer details of how the integration model was implemented will be critical to interpreting the results relating to melodic expectations. It is not obvious how notes with simultaneous onsets were included in the model.

      (3) The behavioural and neural measures of attentional bias are time-averaged over a stimulus, but readers may be left with the impression that they were time-resolved, given references to "integration rate" (for example).

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      This is my review of the revised manuscript, which I initially reviewed in 2025. I thank the authors for their thoughtful responses and additional analyses, including the Bayes factor analyses, tSNR checks, analyses relating pRF properties to behavioral performance, and clarification that PPA scene selectivity did not differ significantly between DPs and controls. I also appreciate the discussion acknowledging that intact pRF properties do not necessarily mean intact holistic processing. I have one remaining suggestion to make this distinction clearer, related to the interpretation of spatial integration.

      Spatial integration and spatial pooling are well-established terms in the pRF literature. However, spatial integration can refer to several processes in the context of developmental prosopagnosia:

      (1) Neural spatial integration: How neural populations combine inputs across visual space, characterized in part by pRF size and spatial summation.

      (2) Perceptual spatial integration: How facial features interact to form a holistic representation, assessed using tasks such as composite-face and part-whole tests.

      (3) Integration across viewing: How information sampled over successive eye movements contributes to a face representation.

      The larger DP sample, consistent results, and Bayesian analyses make a stronger case against the first account that face-recognition difficulties stem from abnormally small pRFs. However, they do not establish that these other aspects of spatial integration are intact. Thus, my remaining concern with "normal spatial integration" in the title & main text is therefore about the semantics of the wording rather than the statistics. I suggest using "preserved population receptive field properties" or "preserved neural spatial integration" throughout the manuscript.

      One minor note:. The merged PDF does not appear to reflect the revisions, so I used the article file with highlighted changes for this review. However, I could not find the following passage from the authors' response in neither version.<br /> "However, intact pRF properties do not preclude impairments to holistic processing. Such behavioral deficits could instead arise from abnormalities in broader neural networks due to either altered functional connectivity (Avidan et al., 2014; Lohse et al., 2016; Rosenthal et al., 2017) or structural connectivity (Gomez et al., 2015; Song et al., 2015b)."

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Poge et al. present a workflow for studying plant tissue by combining high-pressure freezing, cryo-fluorescence microscopy, FIB milling, and cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET). They tested various plant tissues, including Physcomitrium patens, Arabidopsis thaliana, and Limonium bicolor. The authors successfully produce thin lamellae suitable for cryo-ET studies. Using sub-tomogram averaging, they determined the Rubisco structure at subnanometer resolution, demonstrating the potential of this workflow for plant tissue studies.

      Strengths:

      This manuscript is likely the first to systematically apply FIB milling and cryo-ET to plant tissue samples. It provides a detailed methodological description, which is not only valuable for plant tissue studies but also adaptable to a broader range of biological tissue samples. The study compares the plunge freezing method with a high-pressure freezing method, demonstrating that high-pressure freezing can vitrify thick tissues while preserving their native state. Additionally, the authors explore two methods for plant tissue sample preparation, the "waffle" method and in-carrier high-pressure freezing combined with the "lift-out" approach. The "waffle" method is suitable for samples less than 25um, while the in-carrier high-pressure freezing method can process samples up to 100um.

      Weaknesses:

      The described workflow is very complicated and requires special expertise. The success rate of this workflow is not very high, particularly for high-pressure freezing and life-out technology. Further improvements are needed for automation and increasing throughput.

      Comments on revised version:

      I am satisfied with the revision and have no more comments.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study uses comparative phylogenetic methods to examine the evolution of male and female antagonistic traits in a group of small water striders. Water striders have long been a model system for studies into the sexual conflict that arises through anisogamy, the differential investment in gametes by males and females. Here, the authors aimed to reveal the evolutionary rates and trajectories of male grasping and female anti-grasping traits across species of the minute water-strider subgenus Pseudovelia. This was done by combining multiple genomic techniques to generate phylogenies to test trait evolution, quantify rates of evolution, and identify instances of incomplete lineage sorting (a result of rapid diversification) and introgression (the result of interbreeding between genetically different populations/species).

      Strengths:

      The strengths of this study lie in its comparative macroveolutionary framework, in particular the generation of multiple phylogenetic hypotheses using different methods (mitochondrial genes, USCOs, and SNPs) and contrasting these to glean insights into evolutionary patterns across species. Additionally, the authors compare not only the evolutionary rates of male vs female antagonistic traits and how these may be implicated in diversification, but also address variation between different male antagonistic traits. This reminds us that the overall phenotype of an organism represents an amalgam of characters, whose trajectories are driven by diverse evolutionary pressures and constraints.

      Weaknesses:

      The main weakness of the study is the lack of underlying experimental evidence to explicitly show the grasping and anti-grasping functions of the various male and female traits, relying instead on studies of similar structures in more distantly related taxa. Without explicitly showing the functional mechanisms and reproductive costs of these traits, the resulting interpretations are wholly speculative. However, I would argue that such macroevolutionary studies are still very useful and provide the groundwork for future studies untangling the relative roles of sexual conflict, cryptic female choice, sperm competition and reproductive interference in trait evolution and ultimately in speciation.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      The authors provide an extensively revised version of this manuscript in which they addressed many of the comments. I find their additional work and effort to address the reviewers' suggestions commendable. However, my first concern from the previous round of reviewing remains and I urge the authors to address it.

      My concern relates to the shade treatments and the consistency with which they are described. Although the authors added details in the main text, the conditions remain insufficiently defined in the Materials and Methods, in some figure legends and the figures themselves (e.g., Fig. 4).

      More importantly, the terms canopy shade and proximity shade are still used incorrectly (in figure 4), please make sure to check this throughout the ms.

      In nature, canopy shade combines reduced PAR and reduced R:FR, whereas proximity shade primarily involves a reduction in R:FR without reduced PAR. Here, both treatments have the same PAR (45 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹), while the condition termed proximity shade actually has a lower R:FR (0.06) than the condition termed canopy shade (0.15) (see lines 405-407 of the text), while in natural conditions the R/FR ratio is lower under canopy shade than proximity shade. Thus, these designations are inconsistent with their accepted meaning in the field and are likely to confuse readers, particularly non-specialists.

      I therefore recommend replacing them (in the figure itself, the legends and text) with terminology that reflects the actual light conditions used (PAR and R/FR), without giving it a name that is confusing. Alternatively, one could imagine that what the authors call canopy and proximity shade are two proximity shade conditions (because compared to WL of the same PAR) with increasing density of neighbouring plants (leading to a reduction of R/FR).

      Whatever the authors decide to do, please change the name of the conditions corresponding to PAR 45 microE R/FR 0.06 and PAR 45 microE R/FR 0.15. As suggested above, the latter could be called neighbour shade (PAR 45 microE R/FR 0.15), which would be consistent with the literature and natural conditions (considering that it is compared to WL PAR 45 microE with a high R/FR). The former could then be "strong neighbour competition shade"? Because R/FR is further reduced to 0.06.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors attack an important and challenging problem on how to make living tissues (especially mammalian brain) more transparent for light microscopy, while minimizing or eliminating the toxic side effects of such intervention. A few groundbreaking publications have advanced this field recently, eg. (Ou et al., Science, 2024, Inagaki et al., Nat. Meth. 2026). In this work, the authors apply iodixanol to increase the refractive index (RI) of ACSF, thereby making brain tissues slightly more transparent while minimizing the osmotic stress associated with such intervention.

      Strengths:

      The approach is methodologically valid, and the authors carefully tested both optical and behavior effects of I-ACSF injection in mice.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The authors do not cite a recent key paper in the field of in vivo tissue clearing, against which the results of this work should be compared: Inagaki, S., Nakagawa-Tamagawa, N., Huynh, N.Z. et al. Isotonic and minimally invasive optical clearing media for live cell imaging ex vivo and in vivo. Nat Methods 23, 839-853 (2026).

      (2) Use of iodixanol is not novel for in vivo compatible tuning of refractive index (REF 31, Boothe et al., 2017).

      (3) Relatively small increase in RI from ACSF (1.34) to I-ACSF (1.385, by 0.045, slightly above the cytoplasm RI 1.368), especially compared to other intracellular components (lipids and proteins, 1.43-1.55) which are the root causes of light scattering.

      (4) As a result, there is very small improvement in tissue transparency (e.g., Figure 1a).

      (5) Even at this modest RI increase, mouse behavior differs significantly from controls (Figure 2).

      (6) Also, in 2P microscopy experiments (Figure 5), the tissue clearing effect is very modest.

      (7) Line 306 calling it a 'dramatic enhancement' is an overstatement.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study demonstrates that low-voltage oscillations in neuronal ensembles can contribute to learning and memory. The authors identify long-lasting plasticity in the dynamics of oscillatory intracellular calcium store release in key neurons of Aplysia's food-seeking network, serving as a subcellular substrate for operant-reward learning that leads to the rhythmic expression of motor output producing compulsive-like behavior.

      Strengths:

      The study used a combination of well-designed and rigorously executed behavioural and electrophysiological experiments in an extremely well-defined nervous system to test the hypothesis that spontaneous voltage oscillations in neuronal ensembles play a critical role in memory formation and storage.

      Weaknesses:

      I was unable to identify any major weakness in this study. The authors fully achieved their aims, and the results support their conclusions.

      Conclusion:

      This is a potentially impactful study that supports the notion that non-synaptic subcellular mechanisms make an important contribution to neuronal ensemble plasticity underpinning associative learning. I regard the utility value of the methods and data to the community as high.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Prior work identified TMEM30B (knockout mice) as well as ATP8B1 (human genetics and mouse model), ATP8A2 (knockout mice), and ATP811A (human genetics) as relevant for hearing. The authors also reasoned that given the recent discovery of TMC1 and TMC2's dual function as mechanotransduction channels of the inner ear and as lipid scramblases, a counterpart flippase should be in the sensory hair-cell stereocilia bundle where mechanotransduction happens. They use CRISPR/CAS to modify the endogenous mouse genes and add an HA tag at the N-terminus of the ATP8B1, ATP8A1, ATP8A2, and ATP11A proteins. Their experiments with these mice unambiguously localized ATP8B1 at the base of outer hair cell stereocilia bundles. Knockout of ATP8B1 results in loss of outer hair cells, deficient auditory function (ABR), and degeneration of outer hair cell stereocilia bundles. Similarly, hair cells from genetically modified mice with endogenous HA-tagged TMEM30B proteins show localization of this protein to outer hair cell stereocilia bundles. TMEM30B knock out mice phenocopy the ATP8B1 knock out model. Interestingly, the authors show that annexing V staining precedes hair cell loss in ATP8B1 and TMEM30B knockout mice.

      Strengths:

      (1) Use of knock-in HA-tagged proteins to unambiguously localize ATP8B1 and TMEM30B

      (2) Systematic characterization of auditory function (ABR), hair cell loss, and hair-cell stereocilia bundle morphology.

      (3) Advances our understanding of the role played by lipid homeostasis in auditory function.

      (4) Reports on mouse models that will be helpful to further understand the mechanistic role played by ATP8B1 and TMEM30B in normal hearing and hereditary deafness.

      Comments on second revision:

      It is interesting that in the images selected as representative of the new experiments the effect seems to be opposite to what was reported before - more ATP8B1-HA in the bundle with transduction blockage. However, this does not seem to be supported by the quantification, and further exploration at different ages, blocker concentrations, effective transduction blockage, etc. might be needed to really have a solid result. Thus, I agree that leaving out these results, and the previous sections linking mechanotransduction to localization of ATP8B1, is the best option.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study proposes that predictive spatial representations in medial entorhinal cortex (MEC) grid cells arise through two distinct biophysical mechanisms: (1) HCN conductance-dependent temporal dynamics, which generate modest forward shifts (~5% of grid field diameter) in Layer II cells, and (2) network asymmetry, enabling larger predictive shifts (~25% of grid field diameter) in Layer III cells. The model further predicts a dorsoventral gradient in predictive coding magnitude, correlating with observed HCN conductance variations. These results provide a mechanistic framework for understanding how intrinsic cellular properties and circuit architecture collectively enable prospective spatial coding in the MEC. This is an important and novel study with a new model.

      Strengths:

      These findings reveal how cellular properties and circuit design enable prospective spatial coding. This novel, impactful study will interest the field upon publication.

      Weaknesses:

      Some of the model is too mathematical and not fit with the biological observation.

      Comments on revised version.

      I have no other concern about the papers.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this study, the authors propose that there are two types of letter knowledge: knowledge about letter sound and knowledge about letter shape. Based on previous studies on implicit statistical learning in adults and babies, the authors hypothesized that passive exposure to letters in the environment allows early readers to acquire knowledge of letter shapes even before knowledge of letter-sound association. Children performed a set of experiments that measures letter shape familiarity, letter-sound association performance, visual processing of letters, and a reading-related cognitive skill. The results show that even the children who have little to no knowledge of letter names are familiar with letter shapes, and that this letter shape familiarity is predictive of performance in visual processing of letters.

      Strengths:

      The authors' hypothesis is based on widely accepted findings in vision science that repeated exposure to certain stimuli promotes implicit learning of, for example, statistical properties of the stimuli. They used simple and well-established tasks in large-scale experiments with a special population (i.e., children). The data analysis is quite comprehensive, accounting for any alternative explanations when needed. The data supports at least a part of their hypothesis that the knowledge of letter shapes is distinct from, and precedes, the knowledge of letter-sound association, and is associated with performance in visual processing of the letters. This study shed light on a rather overlooked aspect of letter knowledge, i.e., letter shapes, challenging the idea that letters are learned only through formal instruction and calling for future research on the role of passive exposure to letters in reading acquisition.

      Weaknesses:

      Although the authors have successfully identified the knowledge of letter shapes as another type of letter knowledge other than the knowledge of letter-sound association, the question of whether it drives the subsequent reading acquisition remains largely unanswered. The authors collected a RAN score, which is known to robustly predict future reading fluency, but it did not show a significant partial correlation with familiarity accuracy (i.e., familiarity accuracy is not necessary to predict RAN score). Future work may address whether the knowledge of letter shape leads to better reading fluency that is not captured by RAN scores.

      Comments on revised version:

      The authors have adequately addressed my comments. I don't have any further comments.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The study investigated the distinct roles of phasic and tonic pain in adaptive behavior. Phasic pain was proposed to function as a teaching signal, promoting avoidance of further injury, while tonic pain was hypothesized to support recuperative behavior by reducing motivational vigor. This hypothesis was tested using an immersive virtual reality (VR) EEG foraging task, in which participants harvested fruit in a forest environment. Some fruits triggered brief phasic pain to the grasping hand, which in turn reduced the likelihood of choosing those fruits. Concurrently, tonic pressure pain applied to the contralateral upper arm was associated with reduced action velocities. The authors employed a free-operant computational framework to quantify how phasic and tonic pain modulate motivational vigor and decision value. Importantly, model parameters were found to correlate with EEG responses, providing neurophysiological support for the hypothesized functional distinctions.

      Comments on revised version.

      All my comments have been well addressed.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript combines fMRI and EEG investigations performed at two research sites to examine 'willed' or volitional visuospatial attention, as contrasted with more standard cued (or 'instructed') visuospatial attention. The primary findings are: 1) willed attention (vs. instructed attention) drives additional cortical circuitry across a broad fronto-parietal network; 2) the direction of willed attention, but not instructed attention can be decoded from the pre-cue EEG data and from MVPA analysis of the trial-level fMRI data; and 3) the subjects with high EEG decoding also exhibited high neural efficiency (i.e., high decoding with low BOLD signal change) in the fMRI data. There are significant concerns regarding the statistical rigor of the direction decoding analyses. These were incompletely addressed in the revision. These concerns are laid out in more detail below. Additionally, there is a concern over the degree to which the present research paradigm adequately examines 'willed attention,' which may mute the potential impact.

      Strengths:

      The focus on willed attention attempts to move beyond some of the many limitations of standard laboratory investigations of attention.

      The shared paradigm across two modalities and two research sites demonstrates solid reproducibility, even though a few minor differences are observed across sites.

      Weaknesses:

      Major Concerns:

      This revised manuscript addresses most of the concerns raised in the first set of reviews, however significant concerns still remain with regards to the 'multivariate analysis of cue-evoked BOLD activation' methods and results. This is central to many of the novel claims of this manuscript, therefore it is hoped that the authors will address this further. Two key concerns were raised by reviewers 2 and 3 about the decoding analyses reported in Figures 3 and 4. Although these concerns were addressed separately, both concerns impact both the fMRI and alpha power analyses but were not addressed within a single analysis for each data set. This appears to leave the critical decoding analysis results unresolved. The revised manuscript still states "For both datasets, decoding accuracy for the instructed trials was not significantly different from chance level (50%) for all the ROIs." However, the 50% level is not the appropriate comparison for statistical testing. Specifically, Figures 3 and 4 should be reproduced with analyses that include the appropriate corrections and controls.

      There are 2 key issues: 1) Many individual subjects did not choose left or right at a 50-50 probability and these subject-level response biases provide a trivial means by which a classifier can perform above 50%; 2) Classifiers can 'perform above chance, by chance.' Empirical estimates of 'chance', generated by label swapping permutations are strongly recommended. Both issues are critical for both the MVPA and alpha power decoding analysis. In their supplemental materials of the revision the authors address point 1 for the alpha power decoding and point 2 for the MVPA decoding, but they do not address both issues together for either data set. This needs to be done if we are to believe the decoding results. Each concern appears to reduce classifier performance or significance; therefore, it is not clear which results would survive joint application of correction methods.

      Figure 4: This reviewer (R2) raised concerns that individual subjects likely exhibited unequal numbers of right and left decisions, which would allow a simple classifier to perform > 50% by always guessing the biased direction. Figure A3a demonstrates that indeed many subjects exhibited biases in one direction or the other. The fact that these biases average out to close to 50% across the subject pool (Figure 3a) is irrelevant to the decoder analysis, which is performed at the individual subject level. The analysis presented for the alpha power decoding in Figure A3b addresses the imbalance by throwing out trials to balance the right/left decisions within subjects. This seems like a reasonable approach. The net effect is that the overall classifier performance drops from 56.83% accuracy to 52.81%, confirming that subject response biases were a large factor in MVPA performance. In support of the author claims, 52.81% performance is found to be significantly greater than chance in the combined data set (p=0.028). The results of this analysis should replace what is currently displayed in Figure 4, and also the contents of Figure A1. Since Figure 4 divides the data into site-specific results and into time courses, it is far from clear which of these results will remain significant.

      Figure 3: The subject-level response biases are not addressed within the fMRI decoding analysis of Figure 3 but should be. Then the permutation analysis of Table A1 should be performed. Or an alternate approach could be taken that addresses both issues simultaneously. The results of the combined analysis should replace what is reported in Figure 3, which very likely overstates the effects.

      Discussion: There are concerns about this experimental paradigm carrying the banner of Willed Attention, because the application of 'Will' appears quite modest. Yes, extra brain activity is exhibited for this condition vs. its control, but do the cognitive processes isolated adequately stand in for 'Willed Attention?" Willed attention, as operationally defined here, appears to involve a simple decision process prior to the shifting of spatial attention. In this revision, the authors have provided additional context that should aid future studies.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript investigates a timely question concerning how expectations about visual features relate to changes in perceptual sensitivity that occur before an eye movement. The authors manipulated the probability of two target orientations while participants prepared a visually guided eye movement and measured both perceptual sensitivity and eye-movement behavior. They report enhanced sensitivity both for targets presented at the upcoming eye-movement goal and for low-probability orientations, with no interaction between these effects. Low-probability orientations additionally delayed eye-movement initiation when they appeared at the movement goal, but not when they appeared at the opposite location. A follow-up experiment reproduced the latency difference for targets presented at the movement goal.

      The combination of perceptual and eye-movement measures is a strength of the study, and the reported effects are interesting. However, I think the interpretation of both the perceptual probability effect and, particularly, the eye-movement latency effect requires reconsideration. In its current form, the study provides solid evidence for effects of feature probability on perceptual sensitivity and eye-movement timing, but incomplete evidence that these effects reflect the proposed mechanisms.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript addresses an interesting and timely question by bringing together two areas that have largely been studied separately: expectations about visual features and changes in perceptual sensitivity associated with preparation of an eye movement. The experimental design allows the effects of feature probability and eye-movement direction to be assessed within the same task, and the authors complement their perceptual measurements with several measures of eye-movement behavior.

      The main empirical effects are clear. The study reproduces the well-established enhancement of perceptual sensitivity at an upcoming eye-movement goal and demonstrates an additional effect of feature probability, with greater sensitivity for low-probability orientations. The observation that feature probability also relates to eye-movement latency is potentially particularly interesting. The authors additionally conducted a follow-up experiment specifically targeting this latency effect, and they use complementary frequentist and Bayesian analyses to quantify several of their key results.

      Weaknesses:

      A first concern is the interpretation of the feature-probability effect as an effect of expectation. The high-probability orientation was presented four times as frequently as the low-probability orientation. Feature probability is therefore intrinsically confounded with stimulus repetition and adaptation. Greater sensitivity for low-probability orientations could reflect enhanced processing of unexpected information, as proposed by the authors, but it could also arise from attenuation of sensitivity to the repeatedly presented high-probability orientation. The experiment convincingly demonstrates an effect of feature probability, but does not distinguish these mechanisms. This distinction is important for interpreting the effect specifically in terms of prediction or expectation.

      My main concern regards the interpretation of the eye-movement latency results. The authors interpret the approximately 3-ms additional delay for low-probability features at the eye-movement goal in terms of an unexpected feature interrupting or updating the decision process underlying the prepared movement, which they describe as "oculomotor procrastination." However, a visual transient presented during eye-movement preparation is known to transiently inhibit eye-movement initiation. Stimulus-induced oculomotor inhibition therefore provides a more proximal alternative framework for the observed latency effects and is currently not considered. Indeed, the proposed description of newly arriving visual information briefly postponing movement release appears closely related to this phenomenon.

      Relatedly, the spatial specificity of the probability effect does not necessarily establish that feature expectation selectively modifies the prepared action. Perceptual sensitivity is substantially enhanced at the eye-movement goal. Thus, the absence of a probability-dependent latency effect at the opposite location could potentially result from weaker processing of the stimulus there, whereas a better-processed unexpected stimulus at the eye-movement goal may produce stronger stimulus-induced inhibition. The authors show that the interaction remains after accounting for correct versus incorrect perceptual reports, but response accuracy does not equate to the strength of the underlying sensory representation across locations. This issue is particularly relevant to the authors' subsequent discussion of separate visual mechanisms for perception and action. The accumulator and dual-systems interpretations should, in my view, be reconsidered in light of the oculomotor-inhibition account.

      An important related limitation is that the latency analyses compare trials in which the Gabor appeared at the eye-movement goal with trials in which it appeared at the opposite location. The finding that latencies are longer in the former condition therefore does not itself establish that presentation of the Gabor delayed eye movements. Experiment 1 includes target-absent catch trials, which could provide an informative baseline for determining whether target presentation itself produces a latency cost. Characterizing this effect is important for distinguishing the proposed account from stimulus-induced inhibition.

      The interpretation of the temporal analyses also requires caution. Target presentation occurred at a fixed time after the eye-movement cue, whereas its timing relative to eye-movement onset was determined retrospectively by when the eye movement occurred. Critically, the manuscript itself demonstrates that target processing and feature probability alter eye-movement latency. The stimulus used to measure perceptual sensitivity can therefore alter the event relative to which its "presaccadic" timing is defined. Splitting trials separately within conditions avoids a simple imbalance of trials between temporal bins but does not eliminate this dependency. This is particularly relevant because estimates of the time course of perceptual sensitivity around eye movements are known to depend on the stimuli used to measure them. Consequently, the different temporal profiles reported for feature probability and presaccadic enhancement should be interpreted cautiously.

      Finally, the visual stimulation itself is spatially asymmetric. A Gabor is presented at only one of the two possible locations before bilateral masks appear. Target onset therefore provides information about the location containing the perceptual signal and produces a visual transient at one location but not the other. This design makes it difficult to separate effects associated with presaccadic selection from differences in the visual input occurring at versus away from the eye-movement goal. A spatially balanced design in which visual stimuli appear simultaneously at both locations would provide a cleaner test.

      Overall, the empirical findings are potentially valuable for understanding how learned feature probabilities relate to perception and eye-movement behavior. However, the present design does not uniquely attribute the perceptual effect to expectation rather than repetition-related processes, and the latency findings should be evaluated within the established framework of stimulus-induced oculomotor inhibition before stronger conclusions about distinct mechanisms for perception and action are drawn.

    1. Lucia, who had grown shrewd in her years of dealing with men denied that the foetus was Takesure’s. She accredited it instead tomy father, although this could not have been true. My father, doin his best not to offend Babamukuru, had sensibly not allowed himself to enjoy Lucia’s voluptuousness until after she had fallen pregnant. From this feat of self-control Lucia had deduced that my

      A paragraph shows that women in some families have no position to be trust by their families and even to make decision but even to accept any fate comes to face them

    2. What was needed in that kitchen was a combination of Maiguru’s detachment and Lucia’s direction. Everybody needed to broaden out a little, to stop and consider the alternatives, but the matter was too intimate. It stung too saltily, too sharply and agonisingly the sensitive images that the women had of themselves,images that were really no more than reflections. But the women had been taught to recognise these reflections as self and it was frightening now to even begin to think that, the very facts which set them apart as a group, as women, as a certain kind of person, were only myths; frightening to acknowledge that generations of threat and assault and neglect had battered these myths into the extreme, dividing reality they faced, of the Maigurus or the Lucias.So instead of a broadening from both positions, instead of an encompassing expansion and a growth, the fear made it necessary to tighten up. Each retreated more resolutely into their roles, pretending while they did that actually they were advancing, had in fact initiated an offensive, when really, for each one of them, it was a last solitary, hopeless defence of the security of their illusions.

      this paragraph exposes tension among women themselves .as they graplle with their subjugation instead of uniting in solidarity against patriarchal system that exploit them.

    3. Do you really have a Master’s Degree?’ Maiguru was flattered. ‘Didn’t you know?’ she smiled at me over the top of her glasses. How could I have known? No one had ever mentioned it to me. ‘But Maiguru,’ I answered immediately, emboldened by the thought of my aunt obtaining a Master’s Degree, ‘did you ever say?’ “Did you ever ask?’ she countered, and continued, ‘yes, we both studied, your uncle and I, in South Africa for our Bachelor’s Degrees and in England for our Master’s.” ‘I thought you went to look after Babamukuru,’ I said. ‘That’s all people ever say.’ Maiguru snorted. ‘And what do you expect? Why should a woman go all that way and put up with all those problems if not to look after her husband?’ Maiguru was more serious than she had ever been before. Her seriousness changed her from a sweet, soft dove to something more like a wasp. ‘That’s what they like to think I did,” she continued sourly. The lower half of her face, and only the lower half, because it did not quite reach the eyes, set itself into sullen lines of discontent. She bent over her books to hide them, and to prove that she was not unhappy at all she made a chuckling sound. I think she thought gaily but sounding pained. ‘Whatever they thought,’ she said, ‘much good did it do them! I still studied for that degree and got it in spite of all of them — your uncle, your grandparents and the rest of your family. Can you tell me now that they aren’t pleased that I did, even if they don’t admit it? No! Your uncle wouldn’t be able to do half the things he does if I didn’t work as well!” ‘You must earn a lot of money,’ I breathed in awe. My aunt laughed and said she never received her salary. I was aghast. ‘What happens to your money?’ I asked. “The money that you earn. Does the Government take it?’ For I was beginning to understand that our Government was not a good one. ‘You could say that,’ my aunt laughed, forcing herself to be merry again but not succeeding. She gave up, took off her glasses and leaned back in her seat, staring wistfully through the verandah’s arches to the mountains and beyond. ‘What it is,” she sighed, ‘to have to choose between self and security. When I was in England I glimpsed for a little while the things I could have been, the things I could have done if - if —if things were ~ different - But there was Babawa Chido and the children and the family.

      Tambu learns that Maiguru has a Master's degree, and this shows that Maiguru 's education was worthless. In that page, Tambu asks in shock, "Do you really have a Master's degree?", and Maiguru answers, "Did you ever ask?". This proves Tambu did not even know Maiguru was educated. If her degree was worth something, Tambu would have known.

      The central tension is that education for women is nothing and worthless.Her must degree did not give her freedom.her husband was in control. She also says,"When i was in England I glimpsed for a little while the things I could have been, the things I could have done if-if-if things were different but there was Babawa Chido and children and family". Also, she said she never received her salary. She could not use the money she earned for her own purposes and been prevented by marriage from doing the things she wanted to do. That is central tension for me.

    4. Maiguru snorted. ‘And what do you expect? Why should a woman go all that way and put up with all those problems if not to look after her husband?’

      This passage highlights the struggle between personal ambitions and family responsibilities. Maiguru is educated and has her own dreams, but she has sacrificed many of them because of her marriage. The author shows that women can lose their independence even when they are educated and financially productive.

    5. It’s everything, it’s everywhere. So where do you break out to?

      This passage shows the book’s central tension. Education and money have given Maiguru and Nyasha more than most women around them, but they are still trapped. Nyasha realises the problem is not only Babamukuru but a whole system of patriarchy and colonial values, so there is nowhere to escape to. Maiguru’s five days away, and her return after staying with her brother, prove this. Tambu believes education will set her free, but Nyasha shows that freedom is not that simple.

    6. ‘It’s bad enough,’ she said severely, ‘when a country gets colonised, but when the peopledo as well! That’s the end, really, that’s the end.’

      Tambu believes that leaving the old ways behind means progress. Nyasha answers that colonisation also happens in people’s minds. This is the book’s argument about colonial education.

    7. My vagueness and my reverence for my uncle, what he was, what he had achieved, what he represented and therefore what he wanted, had stunted the growth of my faculty of criticism, sapped the energy that in childhood I had used to define my own position.

      Her reverence for Babamukuru and the benefits he gives her have made her unable to question him. She cannot even say that the wedding is a farce.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The study by Angla et al. proposes a model in which NT-3 produced by motor neurons regulates interneuron numbers and distribution in a non-cell autonomous manner. The authors demonstrate that ablation of motor neurons (MNs) and global and conditional deletion of OC transcription factors lead to changes in interneuron distribution. They identify that NT3 is upregulated after MN-specific OC deletion in RNA-seq experiments and show that olig2-cre mediated NT3 deletion leads to increased ventral interneuron numbers, altered distribution and defects in locomotor behavior. The authors conclude that MN-derived NT3, under OC control, regulates interneuron development. While this is an intriguing hypothesis, the study does not consolidate the results from the different experimental models in a cohesive model to provide any mechanistic insights into how NT3 may accomplish this function.

      (1) The authors utilize different experimental models (OC transcription factor global and conditional knockouts, DTA ablation and NT3 deletion) to show that MNs may influence interneuron numbers and positioning, but there doesn't seem to be a direct link into how each manipulation relates to the others in an informative way. For example, the relationship between OC and NT3 deletion data is not entirely clear, even though NT3 is downstream of OC transcription factors. Both deletions lead to changes in interneuron distribution but there doesn't seem to be any correlation between the two that relates to relative changes in NT3 levels. Although it is understandable that transcription factor manipulations may have additional effects, it is hard to derive any mechanistic insights into how exactly MNs influence interneuron differentiation or migration from the data presented here. Similarly, while the rationale for following up on NT3 seems to be the chick electroporation experiments, only a very minor decrease in Chx10 interneurons is shown in those experiments. Shouldn't NT3 overexpression lead to substantial decreases in IN numbers according to the authors' model?

      (2) The study primarily quantifies interneuron numbers and distribution at different levels of the spinal cord and under different genetic manipulations. In different figures, the values and distributions shown for controls vary quite a lot. For example, in figure 2B vs figure 4B, the number of FoxP2+ V1 neurons at brachial levels is ~350 vs 125. Similarly, the control distributions in 2I and 4I are quite different. While this can be partially explained by technical issues, it remains challenging to determine whether the conclusions regarding the impact of each genetic manipulation on interneuron numbers and distribution are valid.

      (3) It is not clear that the behavioral phenotypes seen in the olig2-cre mediated deletion of NT3 can be attributed to specific changes in interneuron development, connectivity or function. While the behavioral phenotype is in theory consistent with defects in motor circuits, there is a big gap between the embryonic changes shown here and behavior, with no in between circuit level changes in locomotor circuits shown. Thus, the behavioral experiments are not very informative as to how exactly components of motor circuits might be altered with the NT3 deletion.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public Review):

      The authors applied existing ReadZS and the SpliZ methods, previously developed to analyze RNA process in scRNA-seq data, to Visium data to study spatial splicing and RNA processing events in tissues. The authors showed several example genes in mouse brain and kidney, whose processing are spatially regulated. The paper touches an important question in RNA biology about how RNA processing is regulated spatially. Both experimental and computational challenges remain to address it. The low discovery rates in Visium may have significantly limited the discovery. Despite some potentially interesting findings, the claims remain to be validated by orthogonal experimental approaches.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study introduces SPEx, an approach that combines physical expansion, imaging-guided microdissection, and mass spectrometry for compartment-resolved proteomic analysis. Using the nucleus, nucleolus, and Golgi apparatus as examples, the authors demonstrate that SPEx can identify proteins enriched or depleted in defined subcellular regions.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the method is its accessibility and flexibility. It combines established technologies without requiring genetic manipulation or specialized proximity-labeling strategies, while direct imaging-based selection allows regions of interest to be defined according to their spatial and morphological context. The complementary comparative strategies used in the study provide convincing support for compartment-specific protein enrichment and depletion.

      An important limitation is the lack of depth resolution during microdissection, which can introduce contributions from material above or below the selected region, particularly for small structures. Appropriate comparative controls are therefore important for interpreting SPEx measurements. The current study is also primarily a proof of principle in a single cultured cell type, and its ability to capture changes across biological states or perturbations remains to be established.

      Overall, the study provides convincing evidence that SPEx is a useful and flexible addition to the spatial proteomics toolbox, with particular potential for applications requiring direct image-based selection of subcellular regions.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript presents an interesting and conceptually valuable analysis of compensatory evolution using a large combinatorial deep-mutational-scanning dataset for yeast His3p.

      Strengths:

      I particularly like the identification of "super compensatory" substitutions that improve fitness across diverse genetic backgrounds and apparently reduce the sensitivity of the local fitness landscape to subsequent mutations. The work connects epistasis, protein stability, mutational robustness, and evolvability in a clear and potentially broadly relevant manner.

      The authors provide several complementary lines of evidence in support of this central conclusion. In particular, the new experimental validation of S189A is an important strength because it directly demonstrates that a predicted super compensator can buffer the effects of diverse deleterious substitutions, while analyses of additional DMS datasets from other proteins and assay systems suggest that the phenomenon is not restricted to the original His3p landscape.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have satisfactorily addressed all of my previous concerns.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In the manuscript entitled, "NAD boosting mediated by CD38 inhibition drives reversal of a pathological vicious cycle of intracrine activity and inflammation in eyelid meibomian gland dysfunction", the authors demonstrate strong correlations between a pro-inflammatory state, the activity of an intracrine hormone (3 beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase, 3B-HSD) and the NAD co-factor. Specifically, in a 3B-HSD knockout mouse, there was an upregulation in pro-inflammatory cytokines and increased CD38+ cells (CD38 is an enzyme that depletes NAD, a necessary cofactor for 3B-HSD activity). Conversely, induction of inflammation in the eyelids resulted in reductions in 3B-HSD activity. Supplementation with 5 alpha-dihydrotestosterone (DHT) or the NAD precursor NMN, and inhibition of CD38 activity (78c), corrected the pathologies observed in both the 3B-HSD knockout mouse and the pro-inflammatory model (LPS injection into eyelids).

      Strengths:

      The experiments were performed with good rigor, assessing the impact of inflammation and 3B-HSD activity using multiple model systems. The endpoints represented a combination of transcriptional changes, protein quantification, enzymatic activity, and immunofluorescent microscopy. The authors use human tissue from both younger and older individuals to justify their hypotheses that increased CD38 + cells and reduced 3B-HSD quantity exist in older individuals. The data provide the foundation for assessing more global changes to the tear film and ocular surface.

      Weaknesses:

      The main weaknesses of the study include:

      (1) An absence of information on meibomian gland health, tear film and ocular surface.

      (2) Too few human subjects to validate the hypotheses.

      Overall, this study demonstrates an important relationship that exists between intracrine signaling, inflammation and cofactor signaling, and represents a novel approach in therapeutic design for patients with meibomian gland dysfunction.

      Comments on the revised version:

      The title of the manuscript is a bit deceiving, particularly because it mentions "meibomian gland dysfunction". The authors would need to demonstrate abnormalities in lipid synthesis (quantity or quality) and ocular surface changes associated with loss of this intracrine signaling. The data presented are strong for demonstrating the role of NAD synthesis and utilization in meibomian gland homeostasis, but do not explain the role in ophthalmic diseases, such as MGD. This could possibly be applicable to forms of blepharitis or conjunctivitis as well given their findings of CD38+ cells present in the eyelids of the KO mice. Therefore, the authors should remove the claims of meibomian gland dysfunction in the title and comments in the abstract. Instead, they could use meibomian gland homeostasis for both sections.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Public summary

      Summary:

      The authors wanted to investigate how cells defend against intracellular pathogens, such as Shigella and Burkholderia species, that coopt the host actin machinery to spread from cell-to-cell. Previous work has identified IFNg-inducible GTPase of the Guanylate Binding Protein (GBP) family in cytosolic defence against Gram-negative bacteria. By forming a coat around Shigella, human GBP1 suppresses actin-based motility by displacing IcsA, which is the actin-polymerising virulence factor present at bacterial poles. In addition, GBP1 recruits the cytosolic LPS-sensor, caspase-4, to the bacterial surface, which results in the removal of bacterial replicative niches via pyroptotic cell death. Here they followed up their finding that GBP1 can reduce actin-based motility of Shigella in HeLa cells and surprisingly fails to do so during Burkholderia infection. In contrast, in T24 bladder epithelial cells, GBP1 is competent in blocking Burkholderia actin-tails. They therefore wanted to identify the GBP1-independent factor that blocks actin-based motility in IFNg-treated cells that is absent in HeLa cells.

      Major strengths and weaknesses of the methods and results:

      The authors report a second IFNg-dependent pathway involving the protein product of the gene GVIN1, which was previously thought to be a pseudogene. GVIN1 (GTPase, very large interferon inducible 1) is thus the first human member of this family of ~250 kDa putative GTPases to be demonstrated to be functional and have potential antimicrobial roles. The discovery that GVIN1 is indeed functional, forms coats on Burkholderia in an LPS O-antigen-dependent manner, and limits actin-dependent motility are the main strengths of this paper. The authors use CRISPR/Cas9-based knockouts in HeLa and T24 cells, and complement them, to demonstrate GBP1 and GVIN1 are both required to inhibit actin-based motility.

      An appraisal of whether the authors achieved their aims, and whether the results support their conclusions.

      The authors achieved their main goals through well-planned experiments and unbiased screens. They succeeded in finding the factor that blocks actin-based motility independently of GBP1. This is driven by GVIN1, which coats bacteria and limiting actin-tail formation by reducing the expression of BimA through currently unknown mechanisms. Further, they found that an O-antigen mutant can escape coating by GVIN1, indicating the requirement for these polysaccharides in GVIN1-dependent bacterial sensing. However, the authors have not investigated whether GVIN1, which has two GTPase-domains, does indeed have GTPase activity and whether GVIN1 and GBP1 together completely block cell-to-cell spread by Burkholderia and thereby restrict bacterial numbers over the infection time course. They also do not show whether GBP1 and GVIN1 target the same bacterial cell or different populations of bacteria.

      A discussion of the likely impact of the work on the field, and the utility of the methods and data to the community.

      This work uncovers the antimicrobial actions of a member of yet another family of IFNg-induced GTPases, which potentially acts against other intracellular pathogens. GVIN1 appears to operate independently and in parallel to GBP1, pointing to the breadth and complexity of the IFNg-inducible GTPase families.

      Comments on revised version.

      They have addressed my comments.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This paper attempts to examine how rare, extreme events impact decision-making in rats. The paper used an extensive behavioural study with rats to evaluate how the probability and magnitude of outcomes impact preference. The paper, however, provides limited evidence for the conclusions because the design did not allow for the isolation of the rare, extreme events in choice. There are many confounding factors, including the outcome variance and presence of less-rare, and less-extreme outcome in the same conditions.

      Strengths.

      (1) The major strength of the paper is the significant volume of behavioural data with a reasonable sample size of 20 rats.

      (2) The paper attempts to examine losses with rats (a notoriously tricky problem with non-human animals) by substituting time-outs as a proxy for losses. This allows for mixed gambles that have both gain and loss possible outcomes.

      (3) The paper integrates both a behavioural and a modelling approach to get at the factors that drive decision-making.

      (4) The paper takes seriously the question of what it means for an event to be rare, pushing to less frequent outcomes than usually used with non-human animals.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This article by Bhattacharya et al. investigates how neural stem cells (NSCs, NBs) in Drosophila integrate spatial and temporal cues to activate neuron-specific terminal selector (TS) genes. Prior to this work, it was understood that NSCs utilize spatial transcription factors (STFs) and temporal transcription factors (TTFs) to determine lineage identity and birth order, but the mechanisms of integration were not fully elucidated. The authors employed chromatin profiling techniques to analyze the binding of STFs and TTFs in two specific neuroblast lineages, NB5-6 and NB7-4. They found that Gsb (an STF) binds both accessible and less-accessible chromatin in NB5-6, while En (another STF) binds only to pre-accessible chromatin in NB7-4. The findings support an "STF code" where the combination of pioneer and non-pioneer spatial factors, along with temporal factors, triggers neuroblast-specific enhancer activation and determines lineage identity.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have made extensive revisions and addressed the concerns raised in my previous review. Overall, I find the revised manuscript substantially improved, both experimentally and conceptually. In particular, the additional locus-level and genome-wide analyses, the motif analysis of En occupancy, the attempted endogenous Gsb depletion, and the revised interpretations and distributed STF-code model have strengthened the manuscript considerably.

      (1) Adding Gsb occupancy profiles at specific gene loci such as lbe, ap, and eya, along with chromatin accessibility, Hb binding, and expression data at ems, enhances the link between TaDa results and lineage phenotypes. Although these data do not prove direct regulation of each locus, they strongly support a correlation between Gsb binding, chromatin state, and neural stem cell identity. Therefore, this aspect is mostly addressed, as long as the manuscript does not present these correlations as conclusive evidence of direct regulation.

      (2) We appreciate the additional genome-wide analysis distinguishing genomic loci that gain versus lose accessibility following Gsb misexpression, as well as the comparison with two independent Gsb occupancy datasets and the corresponding Hb occupancy analysis. These data strongly support the conclusion that Gsb has chromatin-remodelling capacity and that accessibility loss occurs at loci associated with Gsb occupancy.<br /> We also appreciate the authors attempt to examine endogenous Gsb function using early CRISPR depletion and their explanation of why this approach could not subsequently be coupled to lineage-specific TaDa. The inability to directly assess chromatin consequences of Gsb loss in native NB5-6 remains a limitation, but the authors have now acknowledged this appropriately. We therefore consider this comment substantially addressed.<br /> We would, however, encourage the authors to distinguish clearly between demonstrated chromatin-remodelling capacity and the stronger, physiologically unresolved claim that Gsb establishes chromatin priming in NB5-6.

      (3) The response to the question about "En not being a pioneer factor" is particularly satisfactory. The new motif analysis directly tackles the concern that the lack of En occupancy at NB5-6-specific sites might just be due to the absence of En binding motifs. The similar presence of En motifs at NB5-6- and NB7-4-specific sites strengthens the conclusion that differing occupancy is unlikely caused by motif absence. Additionally, comparing the accessibility dependence of En and Gsb occupancy helps argue against the idea that TaDa cannot detect binding at less accessible loci. Importantly, the authors have removed the categorical claim that "En is not a pioneer factor" and now limit their conclusion to the specific developmental and cellular context studied. This response adequately addresses the comment.

      (4) The revised distributed STF-code model is clearer and provides a useful framework for explaining the complementary roles of Gsb, En, and other spatial factors. I would encourage the authors to clarify that the proposed stepwise model is a conceptual framework rather than an experimentally established temporal sequence. In particular, the data do not directly demonstrate that Gsb-dependent chromatin priming is causally followed by Hb recruitment at the same loci. Similarly, the division of labour among STF components should not be interpreted as mutually exclusive, since individual STFs could contribute to both chromatin remodelling and TTF-dependent enhancer regulation. The schematic and accompanying text should therefore distinguish the demonstrated differences in Gsb and En chromatin engagement from the broader proposed model.

      (5) The authors correctly recognise that the factors determining the NB7-4 accessibility landscape are still unknown. Pinpointing Msh and other motif-enriched candidates clarifies this issue and offers valuable leads for future research.

      Overall, the authors have responded constructively to the major concerns raised in the review. The revised manuscript presents a substantially more coherent model in which STF-code components have distinct but complementary roles in shaping the chromatin landscape and enabling lineage-specific Hb engagement.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This important manuscript presents solid evidence that the major contribution of KMT2A to ribosomal gene transcription is through promoting histone acetylation rather than H3K4 methylation. It is suggested this occurs in part through interactions of KMT2A with PCAF.

      Strengths:

      This manuscript advances an important concept that chromatin modifying enzymes can also function to promote transcription through interactions with other transcriptional regulators independently of their catalytic functions. The data are overall supportive of this conclusion for KDM2A.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Care needs to be taken regarding interpreting the lack of effect of depleting KMTs or HATs on histone acetylation or methylation levels. There are several overlapping HATS or KMTs that generate these modifications. The most that can be said from these negative results is that the depleted HAT or KMT is not the sole enzyme generating these modifications at these loci.

      (2) The biochemistry supporting an interaction between KDM2A and PCAF is under-developed and not strong enough to support this conclusion at this point.

      (3) It is concluded that acetylation causes increased rDNA transcription. However, acetylation may be a consequence of transcription instead, especially over transcribed regions.

      (4) Some conclusions, for example implicating PCAF, are based on overexpression experiments that are very artificial and difficult to draw conclusions from.

      (5) Several figures are generated using publicly available data sets that were reanalyze using updated reference genomes, sometimes from different cell lines/types. This seems to be a useful exercise but the methods should include information regarding the robustness of these data sets.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Kašnik et al. set out test whether the previously reported requirement for the inner nuclear protein Samp1in myogenic differentiation and its also previously reported role in chromatin organization at the nuclear periphery are functionally linked. The authors confirm using a previously characterized shRNA system in cultured C2C12 cells that Samp1 loss leads to myogenic differentiation defects. Loss of Samp1 results in gene expression changes, including of genes associated with myogenesis and also interfered with the formation of peripheral heterochromatin and peripheralization of chromosome 8 which has previously been reported to be associated with myogenic differentiation. Finally, many of the downregulated genes by Samp1 loss were found in chromatin domains bound by lamin B.

      Strengths:

      The strength of this study is that is represents a rather straightforward analysis of the loss of Samp1 in myogenic differentiation in vitro. The RNAseq data is informative and is in line with the observed differentiation defects. In addition, the experiments are clearly designed and cleanly performed.

      Weaknesses:

      The major weakness of the study is that major conclusions are strongly overinterpreted and the degree of advance compared to prior studies is limited.

      The study does not - as claimed by the authors - functionally link Samp1 to myogenic differentiation via its role in genome organization. As outlined by the authors there is already considerable evidence for a role of Samp1 in myogenic differentiation. There is also prior data to show that Samp1 loss prevents peripheralization of chromosome 8. The data reported in this study add further data to a possible functional link between these two events, but similar to the currently available data, the evidence remain circumstantial and they fall short of the authors' claim - and stated goal - of directly demonstrating a functional role of Samp1 in myogenesis via genome organization. The presented data does not rule out that the two effects represent unrelated functions of Samp1. The authors have not shown as claimed that Samp1 exerts its effect on myogenesis via genome reorganization.

      The most relevant piece of data to point to such a link is the DamID data in Figure 3 showing that many downregulated Samp1-sensitive genes reside in lamin B associated chromatin. However, in this experiment, critical controls are missing to demonstrate that this effect represents an enrichment of Samp1-sensitive genes (see Recommendations).

      While the RNAseq data offers the opportunity to speculate on pathways involved in myogenesis, none of the proposed pathways are experimentally tested to validate their functional roles. They remain hypothetical but are presented as demonstrated facts.

      Finally, many of the findings are confirmatory in nature, such as the finding that Samp1 inhibits myogenic differentiation, that differentiation is accompanied by chromatin peripheralization or affects MAPK signaling.

    1. PatientID: None

      KindredID: 1

      Case: M, 2Y0M, Danish

      DiseaseAssertion:Asymptomatic

      FamilyInfo: The patient's father had the p.P2P VHL mutation as well as another VHL mutation (p.P81S) and presented with renal cell carcinoma. The patient's uncles had this p.P81S mutation but were both asymptomatic. The patient's paternal grandmother also had this mutation and had breast cancer. See Figure 1 for family pedigree.

      CasePresentingHPOs: N/A

      CaseHPOFreeText:N/A

      CaseNotHPOs: N/A

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: p.P2= (c.6C>G)

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: 456593 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/variation/456593/

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: 0.000 https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/variant/3-10183537-C-G

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: synonymous_variant

      CivicName: P2= (c.6C>G)

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    2. along with a silent mutation p.P2P (c.6C>G) in the VHL gene

      PatientID: None

      KindredID: 1

      Case: M, 31Y0M, Danish

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      FamilyInfo: The patient's brother carried the mutation. The proband’s paternal uncle died from metastasizing RCC at 46 years of age, and the proband’s father died from urosepsis in relation to bladder cancer in situ at the age of 56. Neither of these men were able to undergo genetic testing. The patient's mother was found to carry the mutation and had breast cancer. The maternal grandmother as well as a half brother were found to harbour the mutation but were asymptomatic. The proband's child was found to have a different VHL mutation (p.P2P). See Figure 1 for family pedigree.

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0005584 (renal cell carcinoma)

      CaseHPOFreeText: The patient presented with renal cell carcinoma at age 29.

      CaseNotHPOs: N/A

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: p.P2= (c.6C>G)

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: 456593 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/variation/456593/

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: 0.000 https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/variant/3-10183537-C-G

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: synonymous_variant

      CivicName: P2=(c.6C>G) and P81S(c.241C>T)

      MultipleGeneVariants: Germline, VHL, c.241C>T (p.Pro81Ser)

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript presents an MspA nanopore-based approach for investigating the conformational dynamics and interactions of the intrinsically disordered transactivation domain of p53. The authors resolve multiple current states associated with trapped p53-TAD, identify differences between the wild-type protein and the N29K/N30D variant, and extend the approach to examine MDM2 binding and the effects of EGCG. The combination of single-molecule recordings, hidden Markov modeling, and molecular dynamics simulations provides a useful framework for studying disordered proteins under nanopore confinement.

      Strengths:

      The experimental observations are compelling, and the manuscript makes a valuable methodological contribution.

      Weaknesses:

      The analysis and interpretation could be strengthened.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors demonstrated that the amino acid transporter CD98hc (SLC3A2) undergoes fast endophilin-mediated endocytosis (FEME), followed by rapid β1-integrin-dependent recycling back to the plasma membrane. The latter is essential to maintain CD98hc membrane levels and counteract bursts of endocytosis in both endothelial and osteosarcoma cells.

      Strengths:

      The authors used pharmacological inhibitors, siRNA-mediated downregulation and CRISPR approaches to identify the regulators of CD98hc trafficking in different cell systems, strongly supporting their conclusions. In addition, they complemented their experimental results with computational models, which further validate their conclusions

      Weaknesses:

      The mechanistic details of how the interaction between CD98hc and b1 integrin determines CD98hc recycling have not been explored in the current version of the manuscript. Moreover, despite the title mentioning metabolic homeostasis, there is limited insight into how changes in CD98hc recycling affect intracellular amino acid content and cell metabolism, and how this impacts cell growth.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors aim to assess how the functional organisation of the hippocampus is related to the geometry and neurobiological differences of the hippocampus. In particular, the authors focus on the first three eigenvectors of hippocampal-cortical functional connectivity, based on non-linear dimensionality reduction on resting-state functional MRI data. Furthermore, the work aims to describe changes in these functional axes and their relation to other factors throughout youth and evaluate whether they are predictive of individual variations in cognition.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of this study is the attempt to replicate key findings across multiple developmental cohorts.

      Weaknesses:

      The major weaknesses of the manuscript center on gaps in technical transparency and several conceptual inaccuracies. The machine learning methodology used for cognitive prediction is scarce, leaving little means to evaluate whether the behavioral results suffer from data leakage or overfitting. The introduction sets up an oversimplified historical premise regarding the field's understanding and appreciation of hippocampal connectivity, and contains several incorrect references that throw doubt on the argumentation. Additionally, T1w/T2w signal intensity is incorrectly used as synonymous with myelin, despite gold-standard histological validation showing a non-significant correlation between T1w/T2w and myelin staining (Sandrone et al., 2013).

      Appraisal of Aims and Conclusions:

      The authors partially achieve their aims by illustrating certain age-related changes in hippocampal function; however, the correlative study design is not equipped to examine how these changes are "shaped" by geometry, myelination, or gene expression (especially the latter two). Furthermore, conclusions were often overstated based on small effect sizes.

      Context and Field Impact:

      This work adds to a growing body of literature focused on gradient-based representations of hippocampal topology. By applying these methods across a wide developmental age bracket, it provides a useful reference point for how the hippocampus and wider cortex interact during maturation. To improve utility to the neuroimaging and cognitive neuroscience communities, the nesting of subfields within the eigenvector topology should be addressed, too.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Niu et al. develop a biochemical pipeline using systematic co-immunoprecipitation from cell lysate coupled with in vitro binding studies to test hypotheses generated based on structure prediction of how the kinesin heavy chain is autoinhibited through intramolecular interactions, as well as interactions with the kinesin light chain. Additionally, the authors provide insight into kinesin heavy chain binding to the cargo adaptor TRAK. Structural understanding of kinesin regulation has been elusive due to apparent flexibility of the motor. The advent of protein structure prediction, validated through cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS), has provided an inroad to understanding kinesin regulation (Tan et al., Weijman et al.). Most recently, Ashaduzzaman et al. have used cross-linking and local refinement to obtain a reconstruction of the autoinhibited KHC:KLC tetramer. The biochemical analysis presented here extends previous studies and has enabled the authors to define the hierarchy of competing KHC interactions with KLC and the TRAK2 adaptor.

      Strengths:

      While other studies relied predominantly on XL-MS to validate autoinhibitory contacts in the KHC:KLC autoinhibited tetramer, the present study used in-cell interactions to define minimal interacting units, and measured the effects of prediction-guided mutagenesis on their interaction in vitro. This complementary approach stratifies the multitude of predicted autoinhibitory interactions and offers a functional test for reported structures and structure predictions.

      Weaknesses:

      The work is not appropriately placed in the context of previous literature. The KHC:KLC assembly interface (Figures 1 and 2) was previously predicted by Weijman et al., supported by XL-MS in Tan et al., and subsequently visualized by cryo-EM in Ashaduzzaman et al. Contacts between the regions designated in this study as KHC CC1 and CC4 (Figure 6) were also reported by Tan et al. and Ashaduzzaman et al. Similarly, a structural model of TRAK2:KHC (Figures 3-4) was previously reported and tested by co-immunoprecipitation and mutagenesis by Gladkova et al. Tan et al. additionally mapped binding of the related adaptor TRAK1 to KIF5B using XL-MS. These results should be discussed throughout to help the reader understand whether biochemical observations are consistent with prior work, or whether they hint at previously unknown regulatory mechanisms.

      To test the KHC:KLC and KHC:TRAK2 predicted interfaces, mutations of hydrophobic residues were introduced in KHC (Figures 2 and 4), and TRAK2 (Figure 4). However, both KHC and TRAK2 exist as homodimers in solution. Are these mutations specific to destabilizing the heterotetramers, or do they also affect the KHC and TRAK2 homodimers? Such an effect could provide an alternative explanation for reduced binding and impaired mitochondrial recruitment of KIF5C by TRAK2 mutants, such as L217Q/L220Q. Retained mitochondrial localization of TRAK2 mediated by the C-terminus is not a good proxy for functionality of the N-terminal motor-binding region. Mutants should be assessed for stability and dimerization propensity, and their effects fully described.

      Several structure-prediction models are introduced without pLDDT and PAE confidence plots. These are necessary to assess structure prediction confidence. Additionally, residue number labels would help orient the reader as to the boundaries of the protein fragments modelled.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Nakatani et al. developed a conductance-based, morphologically realistic computational model of an astrocyte soma and its perisynaptic processes (PAPs) to examine how extracellular potassium shapes the astrocytic membrane potential across spatial scales. The model builds on previously published morphological and electrophysiological data, as well as experimental measurements of transporter and ion-channel expression levels. It incorporates the astrocytic potassium channels Kir4.1, the Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase, the K2P leak channels TREK-1 and TWIK-1, and gap-junctional coupling to neighboring processes via connexin-43. Glutamate transporters (GLT-1), NMDA receptors, and GABA_A receptors are also included to examine neurotransmitter-mediated depolarization.

      The authors propose that a compartmental model that explicitly distinguishes the soma from the PAPs, provides important insights into realistic potassium uptake and the electrophysiological properties of these distinct compartments.

      Strengths:

      (1) Clearing extracellular K⁺ is one of the most fundamental functions of astrocytes. Failures of K⁺ buffering are implicated in epilepsy, spreading depolarization, and several neurodegenerative conditions. Yet how K⁺ handling is divided between perisynaptic processes and the rest of the cell, and how this shapes local membrane potential, remains poorly understood. The study gives a mechanistic account. The soma behaves as a low-resistance K⁺ "sink" with little voltage changes for local K⁺ elevations around the PAPs, while producing much smaller, than expected by simply by Nernst equation. The local membrane potential deviates from E_K because current escapes to the rest of the cell. This framing separates physiological, synapse-scale K⁺ handling from global, pathological K⁺ load.

      (2) The model described here fills an important gap in computational modelling of astrocytes. While computational models are now central to neuroscience, astrocytes and their interactions with neurons remain relatively underrepresented in mainstream computational modeling. Existing models mostly treat either whole-cell K⁺ buffering or the isolated perisynaptic compartment. This is novel in that it connects the two within one framework and provides a tool to address how astrocytes integrate local and global signals.

      (3) Including realistic morphology shows that spatial heterogeneity matters. A key conceptual strength is that the model does not treat the astrocyte as a single, well-mixed, isopotential compartment. Using an EM-informed morphology with perisynaptic astrocytic processes, it shows that stimulus location and spatial extent shape the membrane response. Fine processes, constricted segments, and local conductance ratios generate responses that cannot be predicted from whole-cell properties alone. These questions are difficult to address experimentally because fine processes are below the resolution of conventional electrophysiology, and somatic recordings are limited by space-clamping. An in silico approach is therefore especially valuable, as it allows controlled manipulation of individual variables, such as stimulus location, channel density, and extracellular volume, that cannot be varied independently in tissue.

      (4) It is built using standard, open tools, and therefore the model can be extended with ease by future studies. The model is implemented in NEURON, the most widely used simulator for biophysically detailed cells, with mechanisms written in NMODL and driven through Python. It also uses a previously published astrocyte morphology. Parameters are listed, and the authors state that the model files are in a repository. Together, these make the model accessible and reproducible if the repository link is also provided.

      (5) The model is anchored to experimental data. Kir4.1 and K2P leak conductance were fitted to experimental current-voltage data (Figure S2), and other channel parameters were constrained by the literature. Notably, the authors avoided channel formulations with built-in mechanisms that fix the resting potential, which are common in earlier astrocyte models. The resting potential and K⁺ responses therefore emerge from the conductance rather than being imposed. The model also reproduces established whole-cell behavior, including Nernstian responses to bath K⁺ application, before being used for new predictions.

      (6) The study tests several candidate mechanisms for peripheral depolarization within one framework and offers a way to reconcile conflicting results: K⁺ through Kir4.1, GLT-1, Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase, K⁺/glutamate spillover, and astrocytic GABA_A and NMDA receptors, all of which in principle can produce responses of the observed depolarization under various conditions. The model therefore offers a biophysical explanation for discrepancies in the astrocyte literature.

      (7) The work makes several testable predictions:<br /> a) the local [K⁺]o required for a given PAP depolarization;<br /> b) local depolarization depends on the spatial extent of activation;<br /> c) somatic recordings would not detect PAP depolarizations.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The Nernst equation itself does not appear to break down; local E_K should still follow it. Rather, the membrane potential deviates from E_K because low-resistance electrical coupling allows current to spread to the rest of the cell. I suggest rewording this statement for accuracy.

      (2) The Methods mention an uploaded repository, but no link is provided. The authors should include a public link and deposit the model in ModelDB or a comparable repository.

      (3) The deployed morphology is hippocampal, not cortical. But the paper's conclusions are for cortical somatosensory astrocytes based on morphological similarity. That deserves additional explanation, especially since PAP geometry is central to the conclusions.

      (4) Astrocytic NMDA receptors best fit the observed depolarizations. However, because the experiments in Armbruster et al. were performed in the presence of APV, an NMDA receptor antagonist, the authors suggest that the responses may involve APV-insensitive NMDA receptor subunits. This explanation would be stronger if supported by evidence that these subunits are expressed in cortical astrocyte PAPs.

      (5) For activation of GABA_A receptors on astrocyte PAPs, the source of GABA is unclear, since the stimulated ascending axons are glutamatergic. The model shows these receptors could explain the data, not how they might be activated. This deserves an explanation.

      (6) I also recommend adding a discussion paragraph on the functional implications of heterogeneous astrocytic control of potassium homeostasis. Do the results suggest that astrocytes efficiently buffer K⁺ under normal conditions but fail during widespread K⁺ accumulation?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Tian & colleagues generate and characterize six novel humanized mouse models engineered to express precursor human antibody repertoires for inducing multiple lineages of broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs) against HIV-1. Building on prior "VRC01-class" proof-of-concept work, this manuscript advances the field by demonstrating the value and suitability of these sophisticated models for testing the ability of vaccine candidates to induce bnAbs. By utilizing flow cytometry and HGTS sequencing techniques, the authors demonstrate that the targeted bnAb minigenes successfully undergo physiological V(D)J recombination and junctional diversification. Despite phenotypic heterogeneity in B-cell development, they show that these models reproducibly produce diverse repertoires enriched for functional humanized B-cell receptors expressing knock-in-derived bnAb precursor rearrangements, a subset of which yield the long, correctly charged CDRH3 loops required to target conserved but glycan-shielded bnAb epitopes. This achievement successfully overcomes a major vaccine testing bottleneck by providing a pool of patient-deduced precursor configurations in sufficient amounts to reliably study how subsequent somatic mutation events are induced by candidate vaccine protocols (with the potential exception of the PG9 model). Crucially, the comparative utilization of Kymab data serves as an excellent control to demonstrate the extreme rarity of bnAb rearrangements in fully locus-humanized mice, beautifully illustrating the design limitations of humanized models without adjusting for the much smaller repertoires of mice. Finally, the discussion is nuanced and well-written, including articulating the models' free availability and highlighting why these small-animal systems are complementary-and sometimes essential-in relation to rhesus macaque systems.

      The paper's conclusions are robustly data-supported, with the only slight weakness being that the Kymab data were extrapolated rather than derived from actual head-to-head analyses. The comments below predominantly aim to provide further context and clarity-mainly in the abstract, results, and discussion sections-to this already excellent, highly detailed study. Refining the text clarity and phenotypic observations will further polish this impressive manuscript.

      (1) Abstract Clarity:<br /> Concluding sentences should incorporate the discussion's explanation: finding natively low-frequency precursors in standard humanized locus mice is statistically prohibitive due to their smaller absolute B-cell compartment. These models bypass this restriction by maximizing relevant segment expression to expand the functional CDR3 search space.

      (2) Results (Line 183, BG18 expansion):<br /> The intriguing expanded B1 cell population warrants more conservative commentary regarding genuine autoreactivity versus other possibilities, such as hyperactive baseline signaling via autophosphorylation (as shown by Hassan Jumaa for certain HC/LC clonotypes). While beyond this manuscript's scope, these mechanisms are differentiable via calcium flux assays with general anti-BCR signaling reagents.

      (3) Results (p15/Line 324, PCT64/CH235 Vκ Allelic Architecture):<br /> The text states that lacking a recombination cassette caused hVκ3-20 to account for only a fraction of rearrangements. While Figure 1B's general engineering feature (tandem reverse hJκ-RSS 23 and 12 RSS hJκ) implies human Vκ should predominate everywhere, Figure 1C suggests hVκ3-20's low representation in CH235 and PCT64 models stems from being introduced differently-specifically via pre-rearranged minigenes rather than unaltered RSS orientations in an unrearranged cassette. The authors should clarify this point in the text and/or Figure 1.

      (4) Results (p14, Clever Engineering of λLC rearranging mice):<br /> Replacing mCκ with hCλ3 is a clever genetic trick and an important proof of concept for stably accommodating a human lambda rearranging light chain cassette within the mouse kappa locus. This excellent methodological highlight deserves prominent recognition as a template for other model developers. I suggest giving this further play in the discussion.

      (5) Discussion (Model Comparisons & Baseline Resolution):<br /> The authors aptly compare these humanized mice to macaques; in addition to their superior scalability, they point out that macaques don't recapitulate human-specific bnAb-relevant configurations in certain instances (like lacking the VH1-2 minigene for VRC01-class responses, or utilizing germline D segments that favor V2 apex responses, potentially overestimating human responses). To further enhance nuance, referencing other prior review KI model literature on this topic (some published by these authors) would be beneficial. For context, KI-derived adoptive transfer models offer more potential diversity (thus, 'higher bar' off-target response testing) and frequency control but are restricted to short priming studies. Conversely, the rearranging models in this study support full vaccine regimens and generate multiple variant bnAb precursors to compare potential in vivo response plasticity.

      (6) Discussion (Baseline phenotypes):<br /> One limitation of the cellular flow data, albeit beyond the manuscript's current scope, is that the baseline phenotypes predominantly reflect variations of a fixed pair of V(D)J rearrangements, rather than bona fide patient-derived UCA bnAb precursors with correct charges/lengths. To help resolve pre-antigenic functional signaling boundaries and thus potentially aid immunogen design, the discussion could note how future work could aim to use techniques like single-cell transcriptomics to map expressed selection signatures of bnAb precursor paired V(D)J's to rule out anergy or survival/death gene signatures.

      (7) Discussion (PG9 Model & HCDR3 Length Constraints):<br /> While the PG9 model's failure to produce bona fide precursors is unsurprising given its long HCDR3, the authors should provide a bit more detail as to whether a subset of PG9 variants with slightly shorter HCDR3s are permissive for bnAb production (analogous to DH511/10E8). Providing the specific HCDR3 sizes generated by this model in relation to recently discovered monkey antibodies-which are shorter/different but function like PG9 bnAbs (e.g., Guenega et al Nature 2026) - would offer excellent context. Such related lineage and/or lineage precursor variants could serve as structural alternatives, and highlighting how these length constraints impact selection provides vital boundary conditions for the immunogen design field when planning germline-targeting regimens.

    1. 2 Partial deletion Deletion of exon 1 and 2 1 0

      GroupID: 2

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      Group size: 1

      GroupNumberMales: N/A

      GroupNumberFemales: N/A

      GroupEthnicity: N/A

      GroupAgeRange: N/A

      Group Info: Retrospective analysis of a longitudinal cohort of 21 VHL germline mutation carriers and retinal haemangioblastomas. All patients were categorized in two genotypic categories: missense mutations and truncating mutations.

      GroupPresentingHPOs: HP:0009711 (retinal capillary hemangioma)

      GroupHPOFreeText: The patient presented with retinal capillary hemangioma.

      GroupNotHPOs: N/A

      GroupNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      GroupPreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: Table S1

      Variant: Exon 1-2 deletion

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: cDNA level information: c.(?_1)_463+?del

      MutationType: exon_loss_deletion

      CivicName: Exon 1-2 deletion

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Breuig et al. studied the effect of Dnm2 conditional knockout in the developing neocortex. The authors generated CNS-specific Dnm2 conditional knockout (cKO) mice using Nestin-Cre, Emx1-Cre, and Nex1-Cre drivers. Confirming existing findings of previous research, they reported that Dnm2 was the predominant dynamin isoform in the embryonic forebrain by immunoblot, as well as by analysis of published single-cell and spatial transcriptomic atlases. The authors went on to demonstrate that deletion of Dnm2 in progenitors causes disorganization of the ventricular zone, depletion of Sox2+ progenitors, an excess of Tbr2+ intermediate progenitor cells and Tuj1+ immature neurons, as well as periventricular hemorrhage and perinatal lethality. On the contrary, deletion of Dnm2 in postmitotic neurons produces no detectable phenotype. In the mutant cortex, Dnm2 conditional knockout led to accumulation of Dll1, reduced cleavage of NICD, and reduced Hes1/Hes5 expression. To separate ligand- from receptor-side effects, they utilized a neural stem cell co-culture assay. They tested dynamin function in the in vitro assay using a variety of molecules and probes, including a dominant-negative Dnm2 (K44A), an shRNA, and the tamoxifen-inducible deletion in reprogrammed Dnm2-floxed neural stem cells. They further performed postnatal electroporation with Hes5-EGFP and Dll1-mOrange2 reporters and an in vivo dual-luciferase assay to test the effect of receptor side effects. In summary, they showed that inhibiting or downregulating Dnm2 increases Notch signaling levels, while the involvement of Dll1 remains unclear depending on the experimental condition.

      Strengths:

      The topic of the manuscript, which is the molecular mechanisms and the signal transduction of neural stem cell maintenance, is of fundamental importance to the field of neurodevelopment. The conditional knockout strategy is compelling.

      Weaknesses:

      The central claims of the current manuscript are not sufficiently supported by experimental results. The rigor of the experiments conducted also needs to be significantly improved.

      (1) Quantification and statistical analyses of the core in vivo phenotypes are essential to establish the central claim of progenitor depletion and premature neurogenesis. Only representative images of Sox2, Ki67, Tbr2, Ngn2, Tuj1, and cleaved Caspase-3 are shown (Figures 2, 3, 4, S2, S3), as is the EM observation of increased clathrin-coated vesicles (Figure 3G-H).

      (2) The authors report that "the brain of mutant animals appears indistinguishable from control littermates". However, based on the representative images of Figure 2, at 11.5 the disorganization of the neocortex and the disruption of the radial columns have already manifested. The authors should carefully describe the aspects of the brain that they deemed indistinguishable between control and mutant animals, and by what criteria.

      (3) The transition from Dnm2 conditional knockout (cKO) to Notch signaling appears somewhat abrupt. The authors should provide additional experimental evidence or literature precedents to logically bridge this gap.

      (4) The claim that dynamin inhibition in receptor-expressing cells increases Notch signaling is not supported by the comparisons shown. In Figure 7D, the significant receptor-side comparison is K44A-receiver + Dll1 versus K44A-receiver without ligand, which tests whether ligand-driven activation survives dynamin inhibition, not whether it is enhanced. The in vivo results are marked p = 0.07 (Fig. 8F), p = 0.07 (Fig. 8L), and n.s. (Fig. 8Q), yet the text states the increase was significant, and the Figure 8 title asserts it. This is the paper's most novel claim and the basis of the ligand/receptor dichotomy in the title and Abstract. As stated, it is not supported at conventional significance.

      (5) Since the prominent phenotype of Dnm2 cKO was a reduction in radial glial cells, the subsequent reduction of signaling molecules (Hes1, Hes5, etc.) may be due to the reduced progenitor pool, rather than cell-autonomous reduction of Notch signaling. Quantitative results, such as the ones in Figure 6, should take changes in cellular composition into consideration and normalize to the reduced proportion of apical progenitors.

      (6) The authors stated that Notch ligands "accumulate at the cell surface," but all immunostaining appears to be on permeabilized tissue, and no internalization assay is reported. The proposed mechanism is a block in ligand endocytosis. Accumulated Dll1 in permeabilized sections is equally consistent with intracellular retention in stalled endocytic intermediates, which the EM in Figure 3G-H might actually favor.

      (7) Inconsistency in the cortical regions examined (Anterior vs posterior, medial vs lateral, etc.). Are the observations and experiments conducted in the same region of the cortex? If so, which region and why?

      (8) Statistical tests should be described in sufficient detail in the methods section. The number of samples or replications needs to be reported for all experiments. The "Imaging and Quantification" section also did not provide enough information (the authors only stated that "Cell counts were performed on matched cortical regions across genotypes and developmental stages"). Figure legends report significance (Figs. 6B, 6C, 7D, 7F, 8F, 8L, 8Q, S6) without specifying what was compared or how in the corresponding main text or methods.

      (9) The main text attributes the cNICD (Val1744) result to Figure 5A-B, but the Figure 5 legend describes the red channel as "NICD (red; total Notch intracellular domain)," which is the antibody that the main text explicitly distinguishes. Figs. 4 and 5 appear to show overlapping Dll1/NICD data.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors of Saqib et al "Deep phenotyping and multi-omics analyses reveal systems-wide metabolic dysregulation in a refined trisomy mouse model of Down syndrome" were testing the hypothesis that metabolic dysregulation in Ts66Yah Down syndrome model, as compared to euploid mice, would replicate metabolic dysregulation in individuals with DS. The authors then compared the results from Ts66Yah mice in the present study mostly with results from Ts65Dn and Dp1Yey mice, where they had reported metabolic differences in previous studies.

      Strengths:

      Strengths of the methods and results include multiple phenotypes examining potential metabolic differences, analysis of male and female mice separately with appropriate numbers of mice (power), and the ability to compare the results to other DS mouse models, which is very useful in selecting appropriate DS mouse models to test metabolic and other related phenotypes.

      The authors have shown that Ts66Yah mice differ from euploid mice in many of their metabolic parameters. Male and female Ts66Yah mice have differing phenotypes in specific metabolic parameters, but the overall result of glucose intolerance, insulin resistance, altered inflammatory cytokines, and dysregulated serum and liver metabolomes is shared between male and female mice.

      Weaknesses:

      Weaknesses include how the data are presented. There are some questions about methodology that leave some doubt in the analyses. The comparisons of Ts66Yah to Ts65Dn and Dp1Yey mice are less convincing, mostly due to oversimplifying the genetic constructs of DS mouse models.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript extends previous work from Calvin et al. and examines hippocampal representations during approach-avoidance conflict in a robotic predator foraging task. The paradigm itself is very interesting and addresses an important but relatively understudied question in the navigation and foraging literature: how the brain balances risk versus reward during goal-directed behavior. While hippocampal representations of positively valenced goals and future intentions have been extensively studied, much less is known about how these representations evolve during risk-reward tradeoffs involving threat.

      The authors use a relatively simple and interpretable decoding approach together with thoughtful behavioral comparisons to ask whether future behavioral outcome can be read out from hippocampal activity before behavior diverges. The most compelling comparison is between mid-track aborts (MTAs) and mid-track continues (MTCs), where the animals initially exhibit very similar pause behavior but ultimately either abort or continue the trajectory. The authors show that decoded location during these pauses differs prior to the overt manifestation of the behavioral decision, suggesting that hippocampal representations may reflect evolving internal evaluation processes during approach-avoidance conflict.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the work is the behavioral paradigm itself. This type of risk-reward conflict task is relatively uncommon in the hippocampal navigation literature and provides a rich framework for examining defensive decision-making during naturalistic foraging behavior.

      The decoding analyses are also relatively simple and easy to interpret. Rather than relying on highly complex modeling approaches, the authors use straightforward comparisons of decoded spatial representations across behavioral conditions, making the results accessible and conceptually clear.

      Another strength is the use of behavioral controls to isolate comparisons between related behaviors. In particular, the comparison between MTAs and MTCs is compelling because the animals exhibit similar pause states before the behavioral outcomes diverge. This provides a useful framework for asking whether hippocampal activity reflects future behavioral outcome before the decision is overtly expressed.

      Overall, the study asks an interesting question using a novel paradigm and provides evidence that hippocampal representations during approach-avoidance conflict may reflect future behavioral trajectory.

      Weaknesses:

      The main weakness is that many of the reported effects are relatively subtle and are not sufficiently controlled for differences in speed, trajectory structure, and other behavioral variables across conditions. While the subtraction plots (green versus purple decoding differences) appear visually striking, the actual effect sizes are fairly small, making it difficult to assess how robust or behaviorally meaningful these differences are.

      Relatedly, many of the most interesting questions in this task concern how behavior unfolds dynamically within a trial, yet much of the analysis averages across events and trajectories. As a result, potentially important aspects of the behavior may be obscured.

      In particular, the manuscript would benefit from richer characterization of the animals' actual movement trajectories and spatial strategies. Because the analyses rely heavily on linearized position, it is difficult to determine whether animals behave differently in two-dimensional space across conditions. For example, during continued approaches, do animals preferentially hug the wall opposite the robot? Do different behavioral conditions show distinct lateral occupancy or trajectory structure? These types of analyses would make the behavioral interpretation substantially more compelling.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      This is an interesting study in Drosophila comparing potentially differential requirements for subsets of Kenyon Cells (KCs) and Dopaminergic neurons (DANS) in olfactory dishabituation driven by either a novel odor ("homosensory") or footshock ("heterosensory). The authors measure olfactory aversion to Octanol (OCT) in a T-maze, induce olfactory habituation with 4-minunute prior exposure to OCT, and use either brief yeast odor (YO) or footshock (FS) to achieve dishabituation. The major observation that YO-mediate dishabituation is mediated by reward activated DANs (PAM cluster), while FS mediated dishabituation is mediated by punishment-activated PPL-DANs is generally solid and convincing. Also convincing are experiments showing the involvement of KCs in the pathway for YO and FS induced dishabituation, and the argument that KCs drive DAN activation that causes dishabituation, though not experimentally shown, is more than reasonable. The work is significant because, as the authors take pains to point out, circuits and pathways for dishabituation have been very lightly studied and clear identification of dopaminergic neuron subsets in dishabituation achieved to different means, represents unique and interesting progress.

      Comments on revised version.

      I am appreciative of the authors' effort to address the various concerns and queries of the reviewers. The revised work, which more clearly positions the work, better specifies the conclusions reached and their relevance to the broader field, is a very interesting and useful addition to the field.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript investigates how animals adapt their metabolism to conditions of reduced nutrient availability. Using C. elegans, the authors identify a neuropeptide signaling network that promotes intestinal lipid mobilization when nutrient acquisition is compromised. The study proposes that nutrient stress activates signaling involving NLP-10, NPR-35, FLP-18, and NPR-4, ultimately leading to increased utilization of stored triglycerides.

      A major strength of the work is the combination of multiple experimental approaches, including genetic analyses, neuron-specific rescue experiments, starvation paradigms, and lipid measurements. Together, these experiments support the conclusion that the identified neuropeptide pathway contributes to the regulation of energy stores during nutrient stress. The observation that similar signaling components function in both the mutant and starvation contexts strengthens the physiological relevance of the findings.

      Strengths:

      The revised manuscript is substantially improved and presents a coherent model linking sensory and interneuronal signaling to peripheral metabolic responses. The data convincingly establish functional roles for the identified neuropeptide components in controlling fat storage and mobilization.

      Readers should keep in mind that the exact relationships among pathway components are not completely resolved. While the genetic evidence supports placement of NLP-10, NPR-35, FLP-18, and NPR-4 within a common regulatory framework, the data are somewhat less definitive regarding the precise order of signaling events and whether all interactions are direct. The authors appropriately acknowledge some of this complexity, and a clearer distinction between experimentally demonstrated versus inferred connections would further strengthen the presentation.

      Overall, this is a carefully executed and biologically interesting study that advances our understanding of neuroendocrine control of metabolism during nutrient limitation.

      Weaknesses:

      No weaknesses were noted by this reviewer in the revision. My main comment is that whilst I appreciate the authors' efforts to refine the signaling model in response to earlier comments, the pathway architecture remains somewhat complex, particularly regarding the relationships among NLP-10, NPR-35, FLP-18, and NPR-4. I encourage the authors to make one final pass through the text and model figure to clearly distinguish interactions that are directly supported by experimental evidence from those that remain inferred based on genetic relationships. This would help readers accurately interpret the strength of evidence supporting each step of the proposed pathway.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The manuscript by Hou et al. tests the hypothesis that SNr neurons' activity is inhibited during specific movements, allowing the selection of specific movements. They do so by performing electrophysiological recordings in SNr, in head-fixed mice trained to perform self-paced reaching or self-paced licking. They first show that SNr neurons present ramping activity hundreds of milliseconds before reaching, with the vast majority of cells presenting positive increases in activity in these rampings. Then they show that the activity of these cells is related to the velocity (and ramping) of movements, independently of the timing to initiate. They verify these findings in spontaneous reaching. To then test the activity of the same cells in self-paced reaching vs. licking, they found that the vast majority of cells present congruent firing between conditions (not opposite firing as expected). Further, they ran controls asking whether dips in activity are related to specific movements, checked if the specific cells that are correlated with lick cycles respond differently in self-paced reaching vs. licking, asked whether there could be differences in activity in reaching to different targets, to finally "opto-tag" SNr- orofacial vs SNr-arm cells and asked whether these differentiate their spiking in reaching vs. licking, concluding that a very minority of SNr neurons distinguished between movements while the vast majority presented congruent modulations among movements.

      Strengths:

      The study is a tour de force, testing the general assumption of action selection being reflected in SNr spiking.

      Weakness:

      Even though the authors set up an amazing set of experiments to test the mentioned hypothesis, their final opto-tagging experiment needs to be screened to better support their conclusion.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript by Pain et al. explores the functional maturation of key oculomotor populations responsible for gaze stabilization. The work is motivated by our poor understanding of this process in establishing appropriate reflexes during development. The authors focus on two types of abducens motoneurons implicated in the maturation of angular vestibulo-ocular reflexes (VOR) in amphibian tadpoles, namely spontaneous motor units that provide baseline control and silent motor units recruited only during head motion. This is a particularly good choice given the well-defined and evolutionarily conserved functions of these populations and the ease with which they can be tracked during changes in angular VOR as tadpoles develop.

      The authors first use semi-intact larval preparations and both step and sinusoidal horizontal stimuli to characterize developmental improvements in angular VOR, which include faster, more robust compensation of head rotation and higher frequency tuning. Next, to explore the central versus peripheral origins of maturational changes, the authors use galvanic vestibular stimulation of the vestibular nerve (which should be independent of canal size) and BrdU-pulse chase to track neurogenesis, which strongly link improvements in VOR to changes in existing circuits, rather than the addition of new ones. To provide a more comprehensive assessment of what these functional changes may entail, they then perform recordings of changes in motor neuron discharge patterns during development specific to horizontal motion. By combining with sophisticated spike sorting analysis, these data reveals improvements in head velocity encoding by silent subtypes, while head positioning by spontaneous subtypes is relatively consistent during development. Finally, electron microscopy analysis of the abducens motor nerve is used to demonstrate that improvements in encoding are accompanied by broad changes in peripheral myelination and innervation.

      Together, the data argue that silent abducens motor units show the largest changes in recruitment in response to sinusoidal head rotations, which is accompanied by increases in myelination and signal fidelity. Ultimately, the work suggests that improvements in oculomotor reflexes during development are accomplished by non-uniform changes within defined oculomotor populations, which is novel and interesting.

      Strengths:

      Overall, the data are very convincing, the analysis is thorough, the findings will be of interest to those in the VOR field, and also set the stage for future investigations aimed at uncovering the mechanistic underpinnings of this cool observation. I only have a few comments to consider for improvement.

      Weaknesses:

      Major.

      (1) A bit more clarity is needed.

      For non-specialists, it would be helpful in the introduction (e.g., Line 52) to spell out what the functional differences are to begin between spontaneous and silent subtypes. The contribution to head positioning versus head velocity is raised later on, but bringing it up earlier would be helpful to understand the functional implications of differences up front.

      (2) Figure call outs.

      These should be double-checked. I found one that did not seem appropriate on line 332. In addition, the reference to Figure 3A and the spike rate are not illustrated.

      (3) Spelling and grammar.

      It would be helpful to proofread more carefully for typographical errors, particularly in terms of using singular versus plural and the appropriate articles. Most are minor (those that I found listed below), but in one case the lack of clarity was particularly problematic. On Line 518: 'Altogether, past studies and our present work suggest the existence'. Consider revising this sentence; it reads now that motoneurons mature 'conjointly'; however, this does not seem to capture the main point here, which is that they are not maturing at the same time. Do the authors mean staggered or conjointly with the behaviours they control?

      (4) Interpretation.

      In the discussion, it would be good to be clearer that myelination will not explain the changes in firing pattern, but could explain the behavioural changes. Ideally, this would be linked to the different types, but I appreciate it is not easy to decipher that from EM.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study characterizes wing flicking in sexually immature female Drosophila as a transient behavior that produces patterned acoustic signals and suppresses male courtship. The authors show that wing flicking is restricted to a short developmental window, is influenced by multiple components of male courtship and juvenile hormone-dependent maturation, and depends on Dsx+ pC1 neurons. They further show that wing flicking shortens male song bouts and reduces copulation attempts, and propose that it functions as a rejection signal associated with sexual immaturity. Overall, this is an interesting and valuable study that provides new insight into a little-characterized stage of female sexual maturation. The core characterizations are compelling, and some additional clarification and refinement of the mechanistic interpretations would further strengthen the manuscript.

      Strengths:

      The work expands our understanding of female sexual behavior and highlights sexual maturation as an active transition between distinct behavioral states rather than simply the acquisition of receptivity. The comparison with the post-mating unreceptive state is especially informative. It also brings richness to the understanding by combining behavioral, developmental, and neural analyses and interpretation. The data showing how male behaviors are influenced by female wing flicks are particularly compelling and represent a critical aspect of behavioral characterization that is often overlooked.

      Weaknesses:

      Event-level analysis of behaviors such as singing, chasing, tapping, licking, or attempted copulation would help clarify the sensory and social context of female wing flicks. The neural conclusion also requires some caution. The split-GAL4 reagent used to assign the phenotype to pC1a labels two pC1 neurons per hemisphere in this study, whereas pC1a is generally described as a single bilateral pair. Given the functional heterogeneity of pC1 subtypes, the current data do not fully exclude a contribution from another pC1 subtype. While the comparison with male agonistic wing signals is informative and interesting, the rejective wing flicks of immature females may be more directly comparable to the previously reported wing flicks and song produced by young and mature males in response to male courtship, which are not mentioned or explored in this study.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript presents COB, a computational database for the systematic identification and classification of chloroplast-associated beta-barrel proteins across Viridiplantae. The authors combine evolutionary contact-map features with machine-learning classification, sequence-based searches and structural predictions to generate a large collection of candidate beta-barrel proteins. In addition to established OEP families, they identify two previously uncharacterized groups, BUL16 and BUL22, analyze the evolutionary distribution and structural diversity of beta-barrel proteins, and propose a number of novel hybrid beta-barrel assemblies involving members of the TOC159 family.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the study is the establishment of a dedicated and comprehensive resource for chloroplast beta-barrel proteins. These proteins have historically been difficult to identify and predict reliably, and the broad taxonomic coverage of COB should therefore be highly useful for the chloroplast and plant membrane biology communities.

      The manuscript also goes beyond database construction by exploring structural and evolutionary properties of the identified proteins. In particular, the analyses of beta-strand number, open versus closed barrel conformations, taxonomic distribution, and the identification of BUL16 and BUL22 generate several interesting hypotheses that may stimulate future experimental work.

      The authors are generally appropriately cautious in acknowledging limitations of the structural predictions, particularly with respect to open and hybrid barrel conformations.

      Weaknesses:

      The principal limitation of the study is that it is entirely computational. This is not necessarily problematic for a database/resource paper, but several of the most interesting biological conclusions remain speculative and are not independently validated.

      This is particularly relevant for the proposed hybrid beta-barrel assemblies. While the known TOC75-TOC159 interaction provides a biologically established example, the predicted interactions of TOC159-family proteins with OEP24, OEP80 and TGD4 are more difficult to reconcile with the known functions of these proteins and currently lack experimental support.

      A second conceptual issue concerns the newly identified BUL16 and BUL22 groups. The authors explicitly state that these proteins cannot confidently be assigned to the chloroplast outer envelope, yet they are subsequently analyzed together with established OEP families. This makes it difficult to distinguish between evidence for a beta-barrel fold and evidence for chloroplast outer-envelope localization.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Strengths

      The manuscript claims that standard methods for deep recurrent RL ("meta-RL"; Wang et al., 2017) provide a poor match to behavior data from humans and animals in many situations, including the two-step task and a mouse behavior dataset previously published by these authors. This negative story is solid and convincing.

      The manuscript refines this model by introducing an online variant of deep recurrent RL. This is a good idea for many reasons. One compelling one, which the authors could choose to emphasize more, is that neurobiology does not respect a strict separation between "online" periods during which weights do not change and "offline" periods in which they do. Both weights and activities are changing all the time. Another is that the behavior literature provides abundant reason to believe in short-timescale innate reward-seeking mechanisms, which offline batch-based RL does not provide.

      The manuscript shows that this online deep recurrent RL can provide a good match to their mouse behavior data. This involves a 2AFC perceptual decision-making task with strong temporal dependencies between the stimuli. In one condition, the stimulus on a particular trial is very likely to be identical to the one on the previous trial and only rarely switches; in another, the stimulus is very likely to differ, and only rarely repeats. Mice find the first condition much easier to learn, perhaps because of an innate win-stay/lose-switch bias which is helpful in the first but harmful in the second.

      It also provides evidence that online deep recurrent RL can provide a good match to neural data from the OFC in this task. In the "repeat" condition, their model learns the task largely in weights, which is possible because the weight learning rule is hard-coded to be win-stay/lose-switch. In the "alternate" condition, the model must learn it in activities. Broadly consistent with this, mice in the "alternate" condition, but not the "repeat" condition, show strong task-based representations in the OFC.

      Taken together, these results are a meaningful advance in applying the "NeuroAI" research program to the case of trial-by-trial reward learning.

      Weaknesses

      (1) The key innovation of this manuscript is replacing batch-based recurrent deep RL (which they call "meta RL"), in which weights are updated once per batch via backpropagation through time, with a version of online recurrent deep RL in which weights are updated after every trial.

      It is difficult for readers to understand how the version of online deep RL being used works, how it compares to other possibilities, and why it was chosen. The manuscript describes it as truncated backprop through time (TBPTT, equation 9). It is not clear from the equation what the truncation window is. If it is only a single trial, then it is unclear how a network trained in this way manages to do the representation learning necessary to do anything model-based at all.

      Various other techniques for real-time recurrent learning exist, many under the heading of "biologically plausible" deep learning. These include techniques involving synaptic eligibility traces (e.g., Murray et al., 2019; Bellec et al., 2020) and possibly others.

      The manuscript calls this "Hybrid Deep RL". This name is confusing to me and may be confusing to readers. If this method is a "hybrid" between deep RL and some other thing, it's not clear to me what that other thing might be. It seems rather to be a variant of deep RL. I'd suggest a name that's clearer about that and more specific, perhaps "Online" or "Real-time" Deep RL, or similar. The manuscript also describes it in places as a "two-module" system, which is confusing to readers because it has one module: a single RNN with a single learning rule.

      The manuscript would benefit greatly from a more careful discussion of these issues and a positioning of the model within the literature. What is lost when giving up BPTT? (long-timescale representation learning, which is often crucial for RL). What is gained? (learning rules that are local in time and space, and therefore more plausible as mechanistic models of biological learning). Where can we expect this method to fail? (tasks with temporal dependencies that are meaningfully longer than the TBPTT window). What alternatives exist? (eligibility trace methods, etc)

      (2) The manuscript claims that their model "reproduced mixed strategies of humans in a two-step task". This portion of the paper is brief and unconvincing.

      The key diagnostic plot, the trial-history regression in figure 1e, shows behavior that looks almost entirely model-free. There is little, if any, separation between the lines for "common" and "uncommon" within either of "rewarded" or "unrewarded". The bar plot does show an apparent difference, but these one-trial-back analyses are subject to many confounds.

      Human studies involving this task typically involve each participant performing only a single session lasting ~100s of trials. When participants are run for multiple sessions, behavioral strategies change, becoming substantially more "model-based" (Economides et al., 2015). If I understand correctly, the model here is trained for 100 sessions of 100 trials, and the data we are shown comes only from the last 25. A fairer comparison would be to show only the first, or first few, of these sessions.

      I imagine that H-DRL is unlikely to show much of a model-based pattern within the first session, as it will require averaging over many trials to learn to sculpt activity dynamics appropriately. By the same token, I am skeptical that H-DRL is plausible as a mechanistic account of the human two-step task - instead, I think it is much more likely that explicit working memory mechanisms are involved (e.g., Otto et al., 2013). H-DRL may be a better model of the two-step task as implemented in animals (Miller et al, 2017; Miranda et al., 2020; Akam et al., 2021).

      The manuscript claims that human subjects on the two-step task typically use a mixture of both model-based and model-free strategies, and that neurobiology supports a division between the two. Both of these points are controversial, at least: da Silva and Hare (2020) present a compelling argument that humans are primarily model-free, and neural recordings dating back to the very first two-step task paper (Daw et al., 2011) show overlapping signals.

      I do think it might be possible to address this with more careful writing and further simulations. But I do not think this is necessary. The rhetorical role of the two-step task in this manuscript seems really just to be illustrating that H-DRL can exhibit different online learning strategies in activities and in weights. This point is made far more convincingly by the analysis of the mouse perceptual decision-making task. I'd recommend simply dropping the two-step task, and its associated claims, from the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      In this manuscript, the authors investigate transcriptional diversity and similarities between mechanosensory hair cells across different species to provide an atlas of hair-cell-enriched genes.

      Their analysis encompasses publicly available and a few newly generated single-cell RNA-seq data from human, mouse, chick and zebrafish, in total comprising 43 populations of hair cells from different organs (cochlea, vestibular sense organs, lateral line) and different stages. They first compare the transcriptome of each hair cell population with that of supporting cells from the same data to find hair-cell-enriched genes. To do this, they use a score (AUC) that reflects how well a gene separates both cell populations; this approach identifies about 5000 genes enriched in at least one of 29 mechanosensory populations. Grouping these genes by their enrichment pattern gives 22 clusters of co-regulated genes, many species- or organ-specific and a few shared by most hair cells.

      Compared with previously published lists of hair cell genes, they define 884 "pan-HCE" genes enriched in most hair cells across species. This set is enriched for stereocilia and deafness genes. In situ hybridization is presented to support enrichment for 7 of 10 tested genes.

      Adding 14 immature populations splits the list into early-and-sustained, transient and late genes. The authors then use these to assess the maturity of hair cells from cochlear organoids, regenerating chicken basilar papilla, reprogrammed fibroblasts, and developing zebrafish, mouse and human tissue. All data are released through a Shiny app and the gEAR portal.

      Overall, this is a useful resource for the community, presented in an exploitable format. It is timely; the inclusion of many datasets is very valuable, and the comparison of HCs vs SCs from each organ is a good approach. I have some concerns regarding the clarity in describing the analysis, whether some findings could reflect differences between datasets, and how cell 'maturity' is defined.

      Major comments:

      (1) The data were generated by different labs, different methods and sequencing platforms. Hierarchical clustering of the data splits cells mainly by species. It is not clear to me that the authors have ruled out that this indeed reflects biology or could be due to technical differences. This needs to be discussed. Is it possible to show that the results hold for data generated with the same platform?

      (2) The calculation of enrichment scores needs clarification. In the methods, it says that AUC values below 0.5 were set to 0.5 and then supporting cell-enriched genes were set to 1 − AUC. How do supporting cell-enriched genes like ID2 end up with values like 0.11 (Figure 2C)? Please describe the calculation step by step; how were skipped genes because of low expression handled?

      (3) It is not clear how duplicated genes were handled when assigning orthologues; the approach allows one-to-many. How were they combined into a single score? The results say that each human gene was linked separately to each ortholog?

      (4) The reference gene list for known hair cell genes seems to overlap with genes reported to be enriched; this seems to be a circular argument. Among the hand-curated list are stereocilia-associated genes, which are then reported to be enriched. Is it possible to test enrichment using gene sets that were not used to choose the threshold?

      (5) The authors need to define how they classify cells as mature, maturing, and immature - there are no definitions at all. Provide these and appropriate references. Mouse P7 cells are classified as mature, which they are not. Later data depend on this classification, so it needs to be justified properly.

      (6) The authors assess maturity of hair cells in organoids; it seems that this depends on the % of genes in each set (mature, maturing, immature) that pass the cutoff. Has this been compared to a random or control set?

      (7) Verification of hair cell enrichment by HCR/RNAscope: This verification is not very convincing for most genes tested. 30% of the genes tested fail, while genes described to be HC-specific are also expressed in surrounding cells. E.g. Figure 5C: both Apba1 and Pcsk5 seem to be expressed in hair cells as well as the surrounding cells; Figure 5D: both genes are not expressed in all hair cells. Figure 5 supplement 2B: the images of the organ of Corti are too low resolution and magnification to identify hair cells reliably. It is not possible to see if these genes are indeed expressed in hair cells. If the authors claim HC enrichment, they need to provide quantification of expression levels e.g. HCs vs SCs and show negative controls.

      (8) A new single-cell dataset from human embryos has just become available; van der Valk et al., 1026, Nat. Neuroscience. This dataset fills an important gap in their current analysis, and it would be very good to integrate it.

      (9) The figure legends are often a bit short and do not explain the figures well; please review and expand.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The paper asks whether the classic complementary learning system (CLS) can be instantiated in an LLM.

      The authors first show that continual fine-tuning and three regularization remedies (L2, EWC, on-policy distillation) fail to encode new episodes without memory interference. They then propose to use gated LoRA instead: one dedicated low-rank adapter per episode for encoding, with winner-take-all selection among adapters based on embedding similarity for retrieval, and finally replays stored episodes in batches to fine-tune the base weights for consolidation.

      The evaluation covers storage capacity, end-to-end recall at up to 1,000 episodes, question answering (via a two-stage "internal RAG" and via direct parametric access), and consolidation, on two datasets: Wikipedia paragraphs and an autobiographical dataset, and two LLMs: Llama-8B and Qwen-8B.

      Strengths:

      (1) The attempt to instantiate a CLS in an LLM is very interesting, timely, and potentially useful for AI.

      (2) The use of LoRA as the episodic encoding mechanism is efficient: they showed that LLMs can store 1,000 episodes with a small amount of parameters (< 0.01% relative to the base model).

      (3) The evaluation is careful. The negative results on regularization are informative. An LLM judge is validated against other metrics, with very informative failure examples (e.g., the "Man on the Run" case, where teacher-forced accuracy is 0.91 but every fact is fabricated).

      Weaknesses:

      I think the main thing is that the two systems, at this point, do not richly interact:

      (1) The episodic component is not meaningfully involved in consolidation. In this model, consolidation is batch re-training with replay, not transfer. The consolidated model is trained from the raw passages - the authors state that it "relearns the same episodes into the shared base weights by batch replay of the original passages, rather than transferring parameters from the episodic adapters."

      (2) The influence of semantic memory on episodic encoding is not deeply investigated. For example, empirically, schema-consistent information is acquired rapidly (Tse et al., 2007). It would be informative to understand if this model shows a similar effect. Overall, showing that this method works for a pre-trained LLM is a strength, but it would be very exciting to know how that impacts encoding.

      (3) This might be out of scope, but I still wonder, eventually, how this kind of system would decide when to use episodic vs semantic memory. This is relevant to the author's points that the low-rank adaptor can be freed after consolidation, which is true, but to do that autonomously, the system needs to know whether a memory is fully consolidated. Overall, I think this would be an interesting future direction.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors set out to assess the in vitro potency of a new POLQ helicase inhibitor, assess its in vitro BRCA1/2 synthetic lethal properties, and confirm how it performs in vivo in PDX and cell line xenografts. The authors also show an anecdotal patient response with a PARP inhibitor + POLQ inhibitor combination.

      Strengths:

      This is a novel POLQi of the helicase activity. The anecdotal clinical response in a heavily pre-treated patient is interesting.

      Weaknesses:

      Most of these issues could be addressed by changes to the main text, i.e. by the authors describing limitations/caveats to interpretation, etc.

      (1) The clinical anecdote is interesting but underanalyzed. It's difficult, though, to know one way or the other whether the PARPi+ POLQi treatment effect (only partial response) has anything to do with the 53bp1 mutation. There is a causative sign that the 53bp1 mutation could be the cause of PARPi resistance (the increase in 53bp1 mutation allele frequency in PARPi-naïve vs PARPi-resistant tumors), but no similar sign to show that the 53bp1 mutant tumor clone is targeted by POLQi treatment. For example, does 53bp1 mutation allele frequency fall in ascites or ctDNA during the course of treatment, or is the 53bp1 mutation lost in a tumor taken at the end of treatment?

      (2) Although the relevant work is cited, the authors should be more explicit in the introduction and state that there is already evidence from 2 papers that Combined loss of BRCA1 and 53bp1 causes enhanced sensitivity to small-molecule POLQ helicase or polymerase inhibitors.

      (3) Figure 4. Not exacerbating existing PARPi myelosuppression is great, but the authors have to acknowledge that the myelosuppression is still present when POLQ+ PARPI is used. Single-agent POLQi doesn't give myelotoxicity, but it also does not give strong anti-tumor efficacy. i.e. it would be fair for the authors to acknowledge this.

      (4) The increase in reticulocytes when mice are treated with POLQi could be a sign that there is an effect on myeloid lineages, but the animals are responding by increased production of this young myeloid lineage. Alternatively, this reticulocyte increase could drive or be a sign of pathology (polycythaemia vera, etc.). It would be good to see a commentary on this in the Discussion.

      (5) Re Figure 4. A therapeutic advance would be to see that, compared to other PARPi combinations such as platinum + PARPi or temozolomide + PARPi, a POLQ + PARPi combination doesn't give the same myelosuppression that these combinations do (by analogy, combined platinum + PARPi gives curative responses in mice but also wipes out the adaptive immune system). The authors need to add data showing the platinum+ PARPi positive control, or at the very least add a limitations of the study section to the manuscript to explain this fairly.

      (6) Figure 2 might give the impression that the new POLQi gives a similar, if not greater, BRCA2 synthetic lethal effect than a PARPi (e.g. 2d-f). It would help readers to see the full saruparib and olaparib dose-response curves, not (as per 2 A, B, C) just the single point estimates.

      (7) Why was DOTC42510 not profiled for PARPi?

      (8) Figure 2f shows error bars on an n=2 dataset - one cannot estimate variance from only an n=2 dataset range.

      (9) Is there a statistical analysis on Figure 2G?

      (10) Figure 3. Olaparib 25 mg/kg QD is well below the MTD in mice. This makes the olaparib response in HCT116 BRCA2 k/o xenografts look modest when compared to the combinations.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors mapped context-dependent fitness of more than 1,400 clinical K. pneumoniae isolates across 214 antibiotic, chemical, environmental, metal, envelope and nutrient conditions, integrating fitness measurements with whole-genome sequencing to build a genotype-phenotype-fitness framework and a machine learning pipeline for predicting bacterial fitness across environments.

      Strengths:

      The scale of the dataset is remarkable both in terms of isolates and conditions tested. The central findings that fitness is strongly condition-dependent and that resistance-associated features help under selection are well supported. Resource accessibility (ColonyExplorer portal, code, trained models) is excellent, allowing future integration of different genetic backgrounds and environmental contexts.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Normalisation uses a plate-level random effect and plate-median scaling, whereas within-plate (position) effects and their correction are not described, although typically required in such high-density arrays.

      (2) Hypermucoid or heavily encapsulated isolates may form smaller but denser colonies. The area-opacity correlation (Figure S3A) does not exclude this, so the virulence-associated costs in selected conditions (Figures 2F-G, S5A) could be partly measurement-driven.

      (3) Plasmid effects are attributed causally from observational data. Fitness effects are inferred from short-read replicon calls (Figure 3) and may be confounded by lineage and co-occurring resistance determinants.

      (4) The study does not apply linear mixed model GWAS on the continuous fitness phenotype, relying instead on median dichotomization with a non-mixed model that is vulnerable to population structure (especially in a highly clonal species) and could exacerbate apparent separation, inflating association counts.

      (5) GWAS-derived features appear to have been selected using all isolates rather than within each training fold. Test-set labels thus influenced which features entered the models, biasing correlation, coverage and interval estimates upward. Although mitigating overfitting, nested hyperparameter tuning and lineage-stratified tests do not remove this bias. Because of this, I do not find the claim that genomic variants predict fitness beyond population structure adequately supported yet.

      With the points above addressed, I believe this work would be highly valuable for prioritising genes and variants for functional validation and for generally studying fitness trade-offs in hospital pathogens.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Large oocytes show prominent waves of cortical contractions. Previous works combining experiments and computational modeling have shown that the waves are driven by gradients of CDK1 kinase activity that trigger excitable Rho activity patterns on the cortex. This present work combines two previously published mathematical models for CDK1 activation and Rho activation, respectively. They show that the models combined can explain diverse shapes of cortical contractions observed in different species and at various stages of development. This shows how the same molecular machinery can generate diverse patterns dependent on the size of the system and the size and position of the cell nucleus.

      Strengths:

      (1) Carefully done modeling work providing a simple and elegant explanation for a complex cellular behavior.

      (2) Very nicely illustrated, simulations can be directly compared to previous experimental observations.

      (3) Explains observations made in different model systems, providing a unifying model.

      Overall, I find this work important, as it shows that combining models of the CDK1 gradient and Rho activation modules can explain the surface contraction waves observed in oocytes. Strikingly, it elegantly explains the differences seen between different experimental systems. While previously these were considered a 'controversy', modeling shows that the differences are simply a consequence of the difference in the size of the oocytes. In addition, the model makes several intriguing predictions that can be tested in future experiments.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors performed bioinformatic analyses to trace the genomic history of the clinically relevant pT181 plasmid. Specifically, they:

      (1) tracked the presence of pT181 across different S. aureus strain backgrounds through time. It was first found in one, later multiple strains, though this may reflect changes in sampling over time.

      (2) estimated the mutation rate of the chromosome and plasmid.

      (3) estimated the plasmid copy number of pT181, and found that it decreased over time. The latter was supported by two sets of statistical analyses, first showing that the number of single-copy isolates increased over time, and second, that the multicopy isolates demonstrated a lower PCN over time.

      (4) reported the different integration sites at which pT181 integrated into the genome.

      As a caveat, they mentioned that identical plasmid sequences have variable plasmid copy numbers across different genomes in their dataset.

      Strengths:

      This is a very solid, well-considered bioinformatic study on publicly available data. I greatly appreciate the thoughtful approach the authors have taken to their subject matter, neither over- nor underselling their results. It is a strength that the authors focussed on a single plasmid in a single bacterial species, as it allowed them to take into account unique knowledge about the biology of this system and really dive deep into the evolution of this specific plasmid. It makes for a compelling case study. At the same time, I think the introduction and discussion can be strengthened to demonstrate what lessons might be drawn from this case study for other plasmids.

      Weaknesses:

      The finding that the pT181 copy number declined over time is the most interesting claim of the paper to me, and not something that I have seen done before. While the authors have looked at some confounders in this analysis, I think this could be strengthened further in a revision.

      For the flow of the storyline, I also think the estimation of mutation rates (starting L181) and integration into the chromosome (starting L255) could be moved to the supplement or a later position in the main text.

      Clearly, the use of publicly available data prevents the authors from controlling the growth and sequencing conditions of the isolates. It is striking that they observe a clear signal in spite of this, but I would have loved to see more discussion of the metadata that came with the publicly available sequences and even more use of that metadata to control for confounding.

      Comment from the Reviewing Editor:

      Reviewer #2's comment about the weakness due to "confounders in this analysis" has been addressed in the revision through additional analysis using metadata to control for confounding.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript by Yang and authors presents an interesting set of new microfossils from the early Cambrian of South China. These are interpreted as segmented bilaterians, and so may be the oldest such examples in the fossil record, with implications for our understanding of early animal evolution. Further, the preservation of these fossils as microbial pseudomorphs is a unique pathway to fossilize such important organisms.

      Strengths:

      The fossils are impressive and arguments for their affinities as segmented bilaterians are convincing. Discussion of somewhat novel preservation is detailed and helpful to understand this taphonomic mode.

      Weaknesses:

      It needs to be clear what the authors' definition of a "segment" is and how that matches (or not) other interpretations. Arguments by Hannibal and Patel (2013, EvoDevo) convincingly define all segmented organisms based on polarity within repeated units of bilaterally symmetrical animals, but others may disagree. The manuscript would benefit from discussion of this in the introduction, laying out a hypothesis for what we might expect to find as evidence of the earliest segmented animals and then describing these new fossils within that context.

      As it currently reads, the definition of a segment is not presented until the discussion and is somewhat ambiguous, seemingly referring to any organism with bilateral symmetry and repeated units. However, modern (e.g. tardigrades) non-segmented animals exhibit these features but are not considered truly segmented. This is critical as various Precambrian fossils (Arborea (Dunn et al., 2019, Palaeontology); Cloudina (Schiffbauer et al., 2020, Nature Communications) Dickinsonia (Gold et al., 2015, Evolution and Development); Parvancorina (Darroch et al., 2017, Biology Letters); Spriggina (Evans et al., 2026, Scientific Reports); Yilingia (Chen et al., 2019, Nature) etc.), have been argued to possess bilateral symmetry ad have bodies composed of repeated units. These older examples should be acknowledged and discussed in detail. Stating that "the identity of these [Precambrian] organisms is controversial" (line 51) is not justification for the main claims of this paper, and it should be clear what distinguishes the new fossils from previously proposed evidence of earlier segmented bilaterians. I believe there is a case to be made in support of the authors' claims, but this context is vital to make that argument convincingly. It is also worth discussing evidence of segmented bilaterians in the early Cambrian trace fossil record, such as Treptichnus pedum (Kesidis et al., 2019, Proceedings B) and Rusophycus (Daley et al., 2018 PNAS), that may predate or be roughly coeval with these fossil remains.

    1. PatientID: None

      KindredID: 1

      Case: F, 24Y0M, Ethnicity Unknown

      DiseaseAssertion: Assumed VHL

      FamilyInfo: Third child of healthy unrelated parents; she has two healthy older sisters.

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0001511; HP:0001999; HP:0000952; HP:0001943; HP:0001508; HP:0000851; HP:0001250; HP:0002650; HP:0001332; HP:0001263; HP:0006880 (Intrauterine growth retardation, Abnormal facial shape, Jaundice, Hypoglycemia, Failure to thrive, Congenital hypothyroidism, Seizure, Scoliosis, Dystonia, Global developmental delay, Cerebellar hemangioblastoma)

      CaseHPOFreeText: Normally born after 37 weeks pregnancy. During the prenatal period, she showed intrauterine growth retardation of unknown cause. At birth, dysmorphic features were noted (full list in table 1). After birth, she was treated for physiological jaundice and hypoglycemia. In addition, she has problem for failure to thrive and feeding difficulties associated with poor sucking and regurgitation. Furthermore, she was diagnosed with a congenital hypothyroidism in the neonatal screening. At 26 months old, she developed epilepsy. At 7Y, was considered to have Rett syndrome because of stereotypic hand movements since 2 years old, scoliosis and dystonia. Her psychomotor development was severely delayed: she had no ability to move by herself, visual contact, or social interaction. Brain MRI was performed at 1 year old and 6 years old. Both of these showed no abnormal findings. At 16 years old, follow-up MRI unexpectedly demonstrated a solid tumor with peritumoral edema at right cerebellum; diagnosed a cerebellar hemangioblastoma and confirmed through histopathology.

      CaseNotHPOs: HP:0002012 (Abnormality of the abdominal organs)

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: Repeat brain MRI, fundoscopy, abdominal echography and CT, blood and urine testing revealed no other tumors associated with VHL.

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: Complete Deletion

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: No mutation was detected in MECP2 on chromosome Xq28. At 5 months old, her chromosome analysis of the white blood cells revealed a distal deletion of the short arm of chromosome 3. Genomic DNA from the patient and her parents revealed a de novo 11.0-Mb deletion at 3p26.3-25.3 that included VHL and a paternally inherited 740-kb gain at Xp22.2-22.13, which was predicted to be a benign copy number variation. Unfortunately, since the mutation analysis of VHL was not performed using resected tumor tissues in the present case, “the second hit” could not be confirmed. Thus, the reason remains unclear why a cerebellar hemangioblastoma developed in her.

      MutationType: deletion

      CivicName: 3p26.3-25.3 11Mb del

      MultipleGeneVariants: see VariantEvidence.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      While the aim of this study is interesting and the methods are advanced, the novel insight and conclusions rather feel limited at present, particularly considering the literature already available on the functional role of p197. There are some notable methodological issues in quantifying the EZF that need to be addressed.

      The claims accompanying p197 and its role in EZF tethering to the BB and pBB to the OMM, as well as its effect on mitochondrial membranes, as displayed in Figure 3, should be augmented via additional comparative measurements with tdzoid cell tomograms, given that tomograms were generated for tdzoid cell lines, but are only utilised in a limited manner for Figures S4 and S5. This represents an underutilised opportunity to use this technique to contrast BB, pBB and mitochondrial membrane separation in a comprehensive manner beyond what previous studies could achieve.

      The authors need to justify specifically why different methodologies were employed for minimum filament length measurements between NP-40 wild-type cells and non-detergent-treated Zoid cells, preventing these datasets from being broadly comparable.

      The reliance on mutant cell lines (primarily zoids) for conclusions needs to be acknowledged to a greater extent, such as when comparing results with previous works (Line 334) and naturally within the limitations mentioned in the discussion.

      The integration of the discussion with relevant literature concerning Cryo-EM and trypanosomatid cytoskeletal studies feels somewhat limited; for example, no mention or comparison with the formative Höög et al. 2012 study for Cryo-EM within trypanosome flagella and basal bodies.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The article by Ribeiro et al. provides further mechanistic understanding of the abilities of cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) to cross directly through the membrane. The authors performed a transcriptomic evaluation to conclude that CPPs enter via direct translocation through cells undergoing cell division, particularly in G2/M phase cells. They reasoned that this is due to the expression of KCNH1, a potassium channel, which is hypothesized to fluctuate throughout the cell cycle and peak at G2/M phase. This expression, in turn, hyperpolarizes the cells, enabling the direct translocation of CPPs.

      The uptake mechanism of CPPs has long been debated. The authors and other groups have previously mentioned the importance of cell membrane potential and the involvement of specific ion channels in its regulation. The current work further adds a layer of understanding by connecting the occurrence of direct translocation to a specific cell cycle phase, which may be of great relevance when considering the use of CPPs for cells that are constantly dividing, such as cancer cells.

      Strengths:

      The work took advantage of transcriptomics and the unique use of the PIP-FUCCI system to determine the different uptake of CPPs in different cell cycle stages. All the data are in agreement with each other, especially when observing the membrane potential change through the cell cycle stages. The experiments are well executed and are all complementary to the authors' hypothesis.

      Weaknesses:

      The article could be further strengthened through:

      (1) Implementation of additional confirmatory experiments

      (2) Positioning against other recently reported channel proteins

      (3) Confirming whether CPPs with different physicochemical properties are also affected by the fluctuation of KCNH1 expression

      (4) Determining whether the concept of cell cycle-dependent membrane potential change is applicable not just in model cells, but also in cells that undergo rapid cell cycles, and

      (5) Relating CPP direct translocation to known biological phenomena that are physiologically similar.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors ask whether membrane transport could have contributed to the emergence of the molecular configuration characteristic of extant RNA. They examine the permeability of α- and β-furanosides and of different nucleotide phosphate isomers using fatty-acid-based PAMPA systems, supported by partitioning experiments and molecular simulations.<br /> The central finding is that closely related molecular species show different transport behaviour: β-furanosides are preferentially transported, while 5′-phosphorylated nucleotides are less permeable than 2′- and 3′-phosphates. These observations are potentially interesting because membrane transport could influence the composition of an evolving compartment.

      Strengths:

      (1) The study addresses an interesting and relatively underexplored role for membranes in prebiotic chemical evolution.

      (2) The comparison of closely related molecular species provides a potentially useful demonstration that membrane transport can discriminate between different nucleotide configurations. The experimental and computational approaches complement each other.

      (3) The analysis of 5′-, 2′-, 3′- and cyclic phosphate species is particularly interesting and could provide a useful framework for thinking about how membrane transport interacts with nucleotide chemistry.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The principal concern is that the manuscript moves from differential permeability to evolutionary selection rather too quickly. The experiments demonstrate differences in transport, but do not establish that these differences would produce sufficient intracellular enrichment, persistence or functional consequences to drive selection of the canonical RNA configuration.

      (2) The relevance of the PAMPA system to primitive vesicles is also not fully established. Membrane permeability depends strongly on membrane composition and environmental conditions, and the relationship between the membrane compositions used in the principal experiments and plausible primitive vesicles needs to be clearer.

      (3) Similarly, the pH-gradient experiments show an effect of pH on transport, but a gradient between two macroscopic PAMPA reservoirs does not demonstrate that primitive fatty-acid vesicles could maintain a comparable gradient.

      (4) Finally, some of the key results are presented as changes in relative composition rather than direct measurements of molecular flux. The distinction between compositional enrichment, partitioning and permeability should therefore be clearer. The molecular simulations provide useful support but, given the small calculated free-energy differences and acknowledged limitations in the nucleotide simulations, do not independently establish the mechanism.

      Overall, the work contains potentially valuable observations, but I think the conclusions should be framed more cautiously. The most compelling interpretation is that membrane transport could have been one component of a multifactorial chemical-selection process, alongside prebiotic synthesis, stability and nucleotide chemistry, rather than that membrane permeability itself explains the emergence of canonical RNA.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors aim to assess how the functional organisation of the hippocampus is related to the geometry and neurobiological differences of the hippocampus. In particular, the authors focus on the first three eigenvectors of hippocampal-cortical functional connectivity, based on non-linear dimensionality reduction on resting-state functional MRI data. Furthermore, the work aims to describe changes in these functional axes, and their relation to other factors, throughout youth and evaluate whether they are predictive of individual variations in cognition.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of this study is the attempt to replicate key findings across multiple developmental cohorts.

      Weaknesses:

      T1w/T2w signal intensity is incorrectly used as synonymous with myelin.

      Appraisal of Aims and Conclusions:

      The authors partially achieve their aims by illustrating certain age-related changes in hippocampal function; however, the correlative study design is not equipped to examine how these changes are "shaped" by geometry, myelination or gene expression (especially the latter two). Furthermore, conclusions were often overstated based on small effect sizes.

      Context and Field Impact:

      This work adds to a growing body of literature focused on gradient-based representations of hippocampal topology. By applying these methods across a wide developmental age bracket, it provides a useful reference point for how the hippocampus and wider cortex interact during maturation. To improve utility to the neuroimaging and cognitive neuroscience communities, the nesting of subfields within the eigenvector topology should be addressed too.

      Comments on revised version.

      I appreciate the authors' revisions and their clear efforts to improve technical transparency throughout the manuscript. I believe the manuscript could have been more strongly improved were the authors more constructive than defensive in their responses, but the manuscript is nevertheless more clear.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Electron microscopy (EM) offers resolution of neuronal ultrastructure not available through any other technique, but it has a limited "field of view". Also, an EM study's value is limited by the ability to identify neuron types within that field of view. This data set largely overcomes both limitations, first, through the analysis of contiguous blocks of SEM-FIB data spanning almost half a millimeter in extent, serially milled at an exceptionally fine 8 nm to create isotropic 8 nm voxels, and, secondly, through efforts that identified most neurons within the sectioned volume. In overcoming the usual limitations, the authors can offer an overview of the capacity of different classes of neurons to control the size and distribution of their mitochondria - a non-trivial outcome considering the essential role of mitochondria in generating cellular ATP and neurotransmitter precursors. The science community is doubly served by the authors' website "neuPrint" which is accessible to the public, where the data can be visualized and interrogated according to various hypotheses. As it stands, this study fails to reach its otherwise exceptional potential as analysis errors throw a shadow over the findings.

      Strengths:

      (1) This is the first comprehensive analysis of mitochondrial morphometrics and ultrastructural positioning across a substantial portion of an insect brain. The adult fruit fly brain was previously milled at 8 nm intervals and imaged at 4 nm/pixel (Scheffer et al., 2020), offering an unprecedented data set for mining mitochondrial parameters relevant to neuronal function (this manuscript).

      (2) The value of the data set has been amplified through systematic identification of neuronal identities and likely neurotransmitter types. The numbers of mitochondria (>6,000,000), neurons (>20,000), and neuron types (5,555) included in the study are similarly unprecedented.

      (3) The language of the manuscript is straightforward and accessible.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The data describing mean median (mean of the medians derived from many neuron types) mitochondrial volume (Fig.2B) and mean median length (Fig.2C) are not internally consistent, i.e. an ellipsoid with volume 0.15 cubic microns requires a longest axis of at least ~0.66 microns to remain a valid prolate shape (i.e., for the long axis to exceed the two minor axes); the reported value of 0.55 microns falls well short of this, indicating the two panels are not describing a geometrically coherent object. This inconsistency can be reconciled only by looking at the supplementary data, where the data are reported for each cell type and the relevant column is titled "Median miitochondrion long axis (r0)" (sic). Here it is evident that the parameter being reported on each plot in Figure 2C is in fact the radius of the long axis and not mitochondrion "length" as currently stated.

      (2) However, even with the correction referred to above, the mean median mitochondrial diameter, i.e., minor axes, would be 0.5 microns, a robust mitochondrion for otherwise fine central processes, and double the diameters reported from C.elegans motor neurons (Riboul et al., 2024) and interneurons within the optic lobe of the miniature parasitic wasp (Fischer et al., 2017). While it is a dubious exercise to reverse engineer possible ellipsoid body dimensions from the mean of medians of both longest axis and volume, the inconsistency remains when referring to the mean of medians of smaller groups of neurons in the supplementary data.

      (3) The estimates of mitochondrial volume density are uncommonly high, i.e., 4%-24%, with a mean median of 10%. These values are 2-3 fold greater than estimates from comparable EM studies, e.g. 4-6% for C.elegans motor neurons (Riboul et al., 2024); 4-6% for Drosophila larval motor neuron terminals (Justs et al., 2022); and 4-8% for lamina-medulla and medial-medulla interneurons in the miniature parasitic wasp (Fischer et al., 2017). Estimates from rat brain are similarly small, not exceeding 8% (e.g., Santuy et al., 2018), leading to concerns that, just like the two-fold error in reporting mitochondrial lengths, a two-fold error has propagated in mitochondrial volume density.

      (4) The internal inconsistency in reported mitochondrial axis length can be identified from the manuscript's own numbers alone, using simple arithmetic. By contrast, the plausibility of the resulting mitochondrial minor-axis diameter (~0.5 microns), and of the reported mitochondrial volume density (4-24%, median 10%), can only be assessed by comparison with the wider literature - where comparable EM-based estimates across several species consistently fall in the 0.18-0.24 micron (diameter) and 4-8% (density) range, respectively. Both this literature comparison and the simple arithmetic used to establish the axis-length inconsistency were available to a reviewer. The other parameters reported throughout the manuscript are inscrutable, i.e., not readily checked by arithmetic or by comparison with existing literature. Nevertheless, the errors and implausibilities identified above throw a shadow over every other piece of data.

      (5) Putting errors to one side, if the authors wish to report values in an unprecedented range, they need to do so with due diligence and defend the novelty of their data in the context of precedence in the field.

      Assessment of whether aims were met:

      The authors did not achieve their aims, but those aims remain well within their reach, as processing data sets is generally trivial relative to the physical act of repeating experiments and recapturing ideal experimental conditions.

      Discussion of the likely impact:

      This manuscript has great bones, and should it receive the attention/rigor it deserves, it is likely to become the go-to reference for mitochondrial morphometrics and positioning across whole central neurons in Drosophila, specifically, and in insects in general.

      Several of the findings in this study, should they persist through reanalysis, are likely to be impactful. A particularly interesting finding is that the size of the closest mitochondrion is larger at pre- rather than post-synaptic compartments (line 309; Figure 7). The dogma in neuroscience, mostly stemming from studies on vertebrate neurons and partly supported by the misguided use of fluorescence microscopy to assess mitochondrial size and distribution, is that mitochondria are larger in dendrites than in axons. The ability to assess a compartment as either pre- or post-synaptic in the present study gets to the heart of the matter about pre- vs post-synaptic dependence on mitochondrial function without getting drawn into arguments about more macroscopic cell structures that may or may not be preserved between insects and vertebrates. This finding is worth discussing in the context of the mouse data from Sager et al., 2026, Science, but it is a discussion that requires consideration of the relative volume of the pre- vs post-synaptic compartments, and whether mitochondria have the same opportunity to closely attend postsynaptic compartments.

      A second finding, and one that might have received more attention in the discussion, was the observation: "KC presynapses with smaller median distances to mitochondria have larger nearest mitochondria, ... . For KCs and MBONs, the mitochondrial volume is inversely correlated with the distance". There are several avenues here that might have been explored. Firstly, in the context of data processing, and secondly, in the context of bioenergetics, the implication of greater intermittence of input at any particular postsynapse, and less intermittence of output at any particular presynapse. Lastly, implications with regard to the relative reliance on mitochondria for neurotransmitter synthesis between pre- vs post-synaptic compartments, an implication that might be addressed through reference to the particular neurotransmitters of each neuron class and whether that neurotransmitter is directly dependent on neighboring mitochondria for precursors.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Broadly, the authors use a wide range of lines targeting dopaminergic neurons in different behavioral paradigms to determine their role in behavior.

      Strengths:

      There is a comprehensive use of lines and assays by a single group, such that internally consistent comparisons can be made.

      Weaknesses:

      It is not clear to what extent these broad assays will provide concrete answers that enable a "unified hypothesis" of how dopamine functions in behavior.

      The manuscript has a feel of being a mix of an original paper, commentary, hypothesis-generating outlook, a focused summary, and a broad review of the field. As someone outside this field, I find that it has its advantages and disadvantages. For example, the final sentence of the Abstract, despite multiple readings, is not obvious to someone outside the field. Plus, due to the large number of references for any one view, it is not clear which work is saying exactly what. For example, which of the fly papers on dopamine clearly say they favor the "common currency" model? Do these references also use this term? Even for a reference that occurs multiple times (Jovanoski and Waddell, 2025), it's not clear what this paper actually proposes.

      Also, what does "a reporter for a specific goal" mean (Line 16 of Abstract, and lines 1986-1987 of Discussion)? They provide a nice example of a tethered fly and what happens when it is suddenly released, vs a free-flying fly that has entered a maze--what is the difference here in terms of dopamine function and the fly's "goal" and how does the fly know the difference? When a fly is free flying in a maze, how does it know that it has just been released from a tether, or whether it has entered a maze as it was freely flying outside it?

      And for their "unified hypothesis", how does a fly know that it is in "controls its environment" versus "lack of control"?

      In sum, I found this paper to be valuable in bringing up the different views of dopamine signaling. However, it was a bit unclear at the end as to what dopamine is actually doing in the fly.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Olmstead et al. present ACT-DEPP, a single-nucleus RNA-sequencing atlas of the mouse hippocampus. The atlas profiles transcription after environmental enrichment, after kainate-induced seizure, and at four circadian time points, and all nuclei are registered to the Allen Brain Cell taxonomy. The authors report three main findings. First, seizure and novel experience induce transcriptional programs that differ greatly in magnitude. Second, ZT12 is a transcriptional inflection point shared across cell types. Third, induction of classical immediate early genes (IEGs) is broadly maintained across circadian phases, with only a few genes showing circadian-activity interactions.

      The study is ambitious in scope, and the dataset is rigorously collected. Registering the data to the ABC taxonomy makes them easy to reuse and to integrate with other brain-wide resources. In the revision, the authors substantially strengthened the analyses and refined their interpretations. Overall, the descriptive conclusions are well supported.

      Locomotor activity was not recorded, so some ZT-dependent effects may partly reflect behavioral state as well as intrinsic clock regulation. The authors clearly acknowledge this in the Limitations section. With relatively few replicates per ZT, small circadian-activity interactions may go undetected. The pathways highlighted in Fig. 6I-J are best viewed as hypothesis-generating. These points are appropriately framed and do not detract from the value of the work. This study will be a useful reference for investigators studying IEG biology, experience-dependent plasticity, and circadian regulation in the brain.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this paper, the authors report a quantitative change in the functional connectivity between cortical domains in mice, due to the influence of the psychedelic, DOI. Additionally, they report that specific cell types (and circuits) within the brain may be involved in the changes in the observed functional connectivity. This will have important implications - both for basic neuroscience and with potential translational implications.

      Strengths:

      This is a fascinating result - especially since the work on psychedelics has predominantly been focused on humans - and therefore a deeper understanding of cell-type-specific responses due to psychedelics has remained poorly studied. Given that psychedelics result in a variety of distinct changes within the circuit - both affecting plasticity and the steady-state dynamics - it is critical to characterize these changes within a system where we can measure changes in individual cell types.

      Weaknesses:

      The authors attempt to model the types of analyses that have been performed in humans within mice. Perhaps because of their attempt to translate from one system to another, the quantitative justification for each of the specific analyses that have been performed appears unclear within the mouse system. This makes some of their analyses, as currently structured, appear incomplete, and we have detailed the resulting questions in the following comments:

      (1) The concept of a "cortical domain" is used in the abstract and is a fundamental component of the paper. We were not familiar with the concept prior to its use in this paper and, given the importance of the concept, it would be helpful to clearly delineate what the authors define as a domain at the outset, so that readers can build their expectations. Further, both AL and PM have been used as acronyms for secondary visual areas (which the authors are very familiar with). This leads to further confusion for the reader. As such, it would be helpful to clearly delineate that these are distinct acronyms for a distinct class of spatial feature within the brain - even within the abstract.

      (2) The authors define the AL and PM cortical domains through the use of a threshold on the seed correlation maps. They chose a threshold of 35%, but it's not clear why that threshold was chosen - and what would occur if the authors used a different threshold instead. Would the boundaries change significantly, and would the rest of their results then be affected by this change?

      (3) The authors report that the behavioral events that show a maximally distinguishable response in the PM and AL domains are behavioral fidgets. However, the authors do not define either (a) the set of all possible behavioral events which they compared against (and how those behavioral events were assayed), and (b) the quantitative definition of fidgets that was used. This is particularly critical since the authors use the fidget response as a metric of responsiveness in the rest of the paper.

      (4) The authors report that the AL and PM domains correlate with the projection patterns of specific neuromodulatory systems. Given the (apparently) arbitrary threshold used in the definition of the AL and PM domains, and the fact that the authors mention that they examined "some of the major neuromodulatory systems", it is unclear how to interpret this result.

      (5) The authors claim that the DOI-induced increase in the correlation between the cortical domains is 5-HT2A dependent, and their evidence for this depends on a block of the 5-HT2A receptor via ketanserin, in the presence of DOI. However, the result that they report from ketanserin is a decrease in the correlations below baseline, and not simply a removal of the effect observed in DOI. This suggests that the effect of DOI on the network cannot be simplistically explained through 5-HT2A dependence, and requires some further characterization and / or explanation.

      (6) The authors introduce the concept of "amplitude of activity variation". However, they do not define the specific quantification that they are using in the text. Additionally, their justification for the use of the concept is also unclear. Why should the activity of input variation change "on first approximation"? If this is a quantifiable prediction, what is the approximation? Increasing the precision of their introduction of the concept would greatly aid the reader in interpreting the results in Figure 4.

      (7) The authors report that EEG responses do not directly reflect the opposing responses observed via widefield calcium imaging. They conclude that "the opposing effects we observe in calcium activity are difficult to relate to psychedelic-induced EEG effects in humans". However, their apparent effects are also not observed in mouse EEG recordings. As such, their claim is unclear - are they reporting that calcium recordings are not reflected in EEG responses, or is there a specific effect present in mice that is absent in humans?

      (8) The authors compare the widefield response resulting from stimulation of specific populations of cortical and subcortical neurons prior to and under the influence of DOI. They claim that the resulting changes provide "candidate circuit mechanisms" for the effects observed during DOI. However, the observed changes due to stimulation do not match the specific changes observed during DOI, making it hard to justify their claim. Indeed, one could hypothesize that the observed changes are only due to downstream effects in a secondary population, only indirectly stimulated through the authors' paradigm. As such, clarification of their results and increased precision of their claims would be helpful. As one example, the authors could provide a model for how the specific changes that they observe during stimulation may directly result in the domain-specific changes observed due to DOI.

      (9) Following up on question (8), it would also be helpful for the authors to characterize the space of stimulation paradigms within the selected neuronal populations. How specific are the changes that they observe to the specific stimulation paradigm used? Are these stimulation paradigms biologically plausible? And, if not, what precisely do we learn through this stimulation?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study investigates how the timing of dopaminergic signals influences associative learning and memory in Drosophila larvae. Using optogenetic activation and inhibition of the dopaminergic neurons DAN-f1 and DAN-g1, the authors examine their roles during different phases of aversive olfactory learning and memory testing. The study reports that manipulating these neurons can alter behavioral performance not only when the manipulation is paired with punishment, but also during non-punished periods and during memory testing. The finding that behavior induced by artificial activation of these neurons can be expressed across different test conditions is also interesting. Overall, the study provides valuable observations concerning the timing-dependent roles of dopaminergic signals in associative learning.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the study is the systematic manipulation of the same dopaminergic neurons at different stages of the behavioral paradigm. This provides a useful framework for examining whether dopaminergic signals have functions beyond their conventional role as reinforcement signals during training. The study also combines optogenetic activation and inhibition with behavioral assays and measurements of neuronal responses. Several of the observations are potentially informative for understanding how dopaminergic signals contribute to memory formation and expression in a context- and trimming-dependent manner.

      Weaknesses:

      The main weakness is that several conclusions are stronger than warranted by the current evidence. The optogenetic control experiments do not fully distinguish the effects of light, genotype, and opsin expression, and some experimental and control genotypes already differ in naïve behavior.

      In addition, some conclusions rely on whether individual groups differ from zero rather than on significant differences between experimental groups. This affects key claims concerning loss of memory formation or expression.

      The comparison between optogenetic reinforcement and natural punishment is also confounded by a fixed training order, making it difficult to separate reinforcement strength from recency or interference effects.

      Finally, the proposed role of baseline dopaminergic activity is not directly supported by physiological measurements in the relevant neurons under the experimental conditions.

      Overall, these issues make the evidence for several of the main mechanistic conclusions incomplete.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is an important, timely and extremely well-conducted study, providing 3D EM data of the highest quality for identification of modulatory axons in the neocortex. The field of connectomics, in which ever larger 3D EM volumes are being acquired, has so far focused on glutamatergic and GABAergic synaptic circuits in the cerebral cortex. These obviously constitute the major fraction of synapses and are known to form high-specificity networks. However, it has been clear that modulatory systems originating in subcortical structures are an important additional defining property of neocortical circuits. Without a clear identification of these specific axon types, their identification in 3D EM data has so far not been possible at scale.

      Strength:

      The present study addresses this issue and resolves the problem of identifying modulatory axons in 3D EM data of the cerebral cortex. Given the fast pace of development in the field of connectomics, such high-quality information is extremely relevant and of substantial impact for the field. The study is conducted beautifully, and the figures are very clear.

      Slight weakness:

      For the quantitative analyses, it would be highly appreciated to plot the raw data distributions as scatter plots. This is particularly important because, for many readers, these data will serve as a benchmark for classifying and identifying such synapses. Thus, any parameter distributions that are (close to) disjunct will be extremely informative. Along those lines, even at the level of the already extracted parameters, it would be very interesting to see whether the authors can already train a simple classifier that would allow the identification of cholinergic and serotonergic synapses or axons in the low-dimensional parameter space that has already been sampled.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript presents a comprehensive and useful evaluation of the association between extinction risk and niche limits. If these results were clearly articulated, then the manuscript would make a valuable contribution to the literature. However, I struggled to understand the manuscript, as the terms and methodology are not clearly defined. I realize that methods do not belong in the main text, but as written, it is often very difficult to understand what was calculated.

      To give an example. In the abstract, the main result is: "Species with colder upper thermal (niche) limits are more likely to be classified as threatened across taxa." In the 1st paragraph of the discussion, we read: "We show that... species with narrower and colder thermal niches face greater threats to extinction...". These are three different variables: colder upper thermal limits, narrower thermal niches and colder thermal niches. I really did not see where these were all defined in the manuscript, why so many different variables are considered and why the results are not consistent. I think this is likely a case of insufficient care in term definition and usage, but I found it rather difficult to follow the manuscript as a result. Clearer short explanations of terms (including a sense of how they were calculated/what they actually mean) and consistent use of terms would make the manuscript much more understandable.

      Next, there are extra bits of information - for example, much of a paragraph in the introduction devoted to dispersal, many references to land-use (though I did not see that land-use was considered in this manuscript), and overly long discussion paragraphs that are highly speculative (or at least lack citations).

      Finally, while I am a big proponent of identifying macro-ecological patterns, I would appreciate a critical discussion of what assumptions are made (i.e., everything about a microclimate; no consideration of extremes, etc.) and what the approach may be missing. This is not to invalidate the work, but to give the reader greater confidence that such broad-scale analyses are informative and are not glossing over too much species-specific ecology or finer spatial or temporal scale heterogeneity.

      In summary, I think the paper has great potential but would benefit from a very conscious and careful revision.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In a series of experiments, the authors addressed the effect of the number of CS1-CS2 pairings, their order, and the time between their pairings and the second phase (CS2-US) in a sensory-preconditioning procedure. They hypothesized that:

      (1) A higher number of CS1-CS2 pairings would favor the integration of CS1-CS2 and CS2-US associations via chaining at Test of CS1, as the CS2 develops a stronger prediction of the absence of CS1 in Phase 1, thus preventing the formation of a CS1-US association in Phase 2 and a chaining mechanism at Test of CS1 (CS1-->CS2-->US). In contrast, when the order is reversed (CS2-->CS1), a higher number of pairings should not change the mechanism of integration, as CS2 becomes a predictor of the presence of CS1. This would preserve the retrieval of CS1 and the formation of a CS1-US association in Phase 2 (mediated learning), while weakening the CS1-->CS2 link required for chaining at Test.

      (2) A longer interval between the two phases of sensory-preconditioning would disrupt the retrieval of the order of the CS1-->CS2 association. Consequently, CS2 is no longer a good predictor of the absence of CS1, and the latter gets associated with the US in Phase 2, thus favoring a chaining mechanism at Test of CS1.

      (3) A reminder of the CS1-CS2 order after a long interval between the two phases of sensory-preconditioning should restore the retrieval of the order of the CS1-->CS2 association, thus reversing the effect of time, and favoring a chaining strategy at Test of CS1.

      To distinguish the two mechanisms, the authors blocked NMDA receptors in the PRh with DAPV before Stage 2. If integration occurs through a mediated CS1-US association formed in Stage 2, DAPV should reduce freezing to CS1 at test; if it occurs through chaining at test, DAPV should have no effect.

      Strengths:

      The strategies developed by the authors to address this issue are elegant and well controlled. While the sensory-preconditioning procedure has been extensively investigated, the mechanisms underlying the integration of separately acquired associations remain unclear. This study determines - in a convincing manner - the conditions under which a conditioned response is expressed via a chaining or mediated learning mechanism.

      Weaknesses:

      The role of NMDA antagonism is somewhat ambiguous throughout the manuscript. Does it prevent retrieval or acquisition or both?

      (The Introduction (lines 98 to 101) refers to retrieval, while the Results (lines 128 to 132) and Discussion (lines 329 to 331) refer to acquisition.

  3. Oct 2026
    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The primary objective of this study was to establish a practical and functional framework for propagation of stable transgenic cell lines of Blastocystis, a common animal gut microeukaryote. Although the work focused on Blastocystis ST7-B, a subtype with relatively low prevalence in humans, this choice is justified by its association with more frequent negative health effects. Beyond their relevance to the medical field, the methodological advances described here have the potential to also expand cell biology studies of this anaerobic organism, including its unusual mitochondria and redox metabolism.

      Strengths:

      Prior to this work, genetic tools for Blastocystis were very limited, relying on a single strong promoter-terminator combination. The authors successfully expanded the available promoter set across a range of expression strengths by testing two dozen variants in luciferase-based assays. Critically, they developed an integrated workflow from a modular transgenic construct design to an expanded inventory of molecular components (promoters, reporters), optimized DNA delivery, stepwise antibiotic resistance-mediated clonal selection and propagation, and to reporter validation. The evaluation of several anaerobiosis-compatible labeling strategies for live (and fixed) cell optical imaging will be particularly useful, with the SNAP-tag system appearing especially promising for Blastocystis.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors aim to determine whether mitochondrial genotype influence telomere length. By generating cybrids harboring different mitochondrial backgrounds, the authors seek to establish a mechanistic link between mitochondrial status and telomere biology.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the study is the use of cybrid technology, which provides a great approach to investigate the role of mitochondrial DNA independently of the nuclear genome. The authors also employ multiple complementary assays to assess telomere-related phenotypes associated with mitochondrial dysfunction. Together, these experiments generate an interesting dataset that will be of value to researchers interested in the intersection between mitochondrial biology, genome stability, aging and development. These results also build on previous work supporting roles for ROS/mitochondria in driving telomere shortening.

      Overall, this study provides interesting evidence linking mitochondrial background to telomere biology. The cybrid models represent a useful resource for the field and the work raises important questions regarding mitochondria-telomere communication.

      Comments on revised version.

      In my view, authors have answered satisfactorily my concerns.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors investigate whether inhibition of the WNK-SPAK/OSR1 pathway using the allosteric inhibitor WNK463 improves neuronal chloride homeostasis and suppresses epileptiform activity in organotypic hippocampal slice cultures. Using SuperClomeleon imaging combined with extracellular field recordings, they demonstrate that WNK463 accelerates recovery of intracellular chloride following chloride loading, reduces interictal chloride accumulation, and progressively suppresses recurrent ictal-like discharges. Pharmacological inhibition and siRNA-mediated knockdown of NKCC1 and KCC2 are then used to investigate the contribution of these transporters to the anti-ictal effects of WNK463.

      Strengths:

      The study addresses an important question in the field of chloride homeostasis and epilepsy and combines complementary experimental approaches. In particular, the distinction between baseline chloride measured in the presence of TTX and activity-dependent interictal chloride accumulation provides a useful conceptual framework for interpreting previous studies of WNK-SPAK inhibition. The imaging, electrophysiological, and pharmacological data are internally consistent and support the conclusion that WNK463 alters chloride dynamics and substantially suppresses ictal-like activity in this model.

      Weaknesses:

      The revised manuscript addresses several concerns raised in my initial review. The authors have broadened the discussion of KCC2 dysfunction and added further context on therapeutic targeting, as well as a useful discussion of the limitations of the organotypic hippocampal slice model.

      My main remaining concern is the mechanistic interpretation of the data. The authors have appropriately softened several statements and now acknowledge that membrane potential and the GABA reversal potential were not directly measured. However, strong mechanistic conclusions remain in the revised manuscript, including statements that the anti-ictal effects of WNK463 are "primarily mediated" by reduced NKCC1 and enhanced KCC2 transport activity and are "mainly due to" NKCC1 inhibition and KCC2 activation. These conclusions go beyond what is directly demonstrated, as WNK463-induced regulation of NKCC1 and KCC2 was not directly measured in this preparation. Lee et al. (2022) provides important support for this mechanism, demonstrating reduced KCC2-T1007 phosphorylation and enhanced KCC2-dependent chloride extrusion following WNK463 treatment. However, these findings were obtained using different experimental preparations, including cultured cortical neurons and an acute 4-AP seizure model. The current experiments therefore support a contribution of NKCC1 and KCC2, but do not directly establish coordinated regulation of these transporters as the primary mechanism underlying seizure suppression. This is also relevant to the simultaneous NKCC1/KCC2 inhibition experiments, where the overall anti-ictal effect of WNK463 is reduced but not completely abolished.

      The statistical reporting has also been improved, but the experimental unit remains unclear for analyses involving multiple cells recorded from individual slices. The authors clarify the use of repeated-measures analyses, but it remains unclear whether individual cells or slices were treated as independent observations and how multiple cells from the same slice were accounted for statistically.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      In this manuscript, the authors investigate how the oncogenic fusion protein NUP98-KDM5A alters gene expression in leukemia, using a combination of cellular experiments with model and patient cell lines, as well as in vitro studies. Upon transfection of U2OS cells with mEGFP-tagged NUP98-KDM5A, the authors show that the fusion proteins form sub-micrometer puncta, whereas KDM5A alone does not. These foci are also observed at expected native expression levels (using OpenCell data). The tag has an effect here, as switching to an mCherry tag raises the apparent saturation concentration for phase separation. Finally, the authors show via super-resolution imaging that the foci correlate with H3K4me3 distribution.

      In vitro, the fusion protein forms amorphous, gel-like condensates at double-digit nanomolar concentrations. Truncation analysis identifies PHD3 of KDM5A as required for maximal phase separation, consistent with the ability of the protein to bind H3K4me3 peptides. Addition of polynucleosomes increases the amount of fusion protein partitioning into the condensate in an H3K4me3-binding-dependent manner. Condensates are gel-like with slow internal dynamics in vitro; in cells, however, the dynamics depend on the position of the EGFP tag (no corresponding experiments with mCherry are shown). Reconstitution with H3K4me3- and H3K4me0-modified arrays shows colocalization with both wild-type NUP98-KDM5A and the binding mutant. Here, H3K4me3 arrays recruit ~20% more protein and yield gel-like structures in a manner dependent on the PTM and on the PHD finger.

      In cells, the fusion protein colocalizes with H3K4me3-marked loci, including the HOX clusters, as confirmed by FISH. Finally, re-analysis of published expression datasets from patient cells shows that genes are predominantly upregulated and that the upregulated genes are H3K4me3-marked.

      This is a well-executed mechanistic study. The data convincingly establish that NUP98-KDM5A forms sub-micrometer foci at realistic expression levels, that these foci correlate with H3K4me3-marked sites, that the PHD3-H3K4me3 interaction mediates chromatin binding while the NUP98 moiety drives phase separation in vitro, that foci in cells overlap genes heavily decorated with H3K4me3, and that H3K4me3-marked genes are those found to be upregulated in patient datasets. These are important mechanistic findings and of interest to the community.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors set out to examine how psilocybin acutely alters learning in rats in a reward-based probabilistic choice task. Additionally, they asked how psilocybin acutely alters encoding of decision variables in the prefrontal cortex (PFC).

      Strengths:

      The behavioral paradigm is robust. Thorough and rigorous computational analyses suggest that psilocybin may differentially modulate the impact of rewarded and unrewarded outcomes and enhance exploration under uncertainty. Single-unit neural activity in PFC suggests a potential mechanism for these effects, with psilocybin inducing opposing effects on encoding of rewarded and unrewarded actions. These findings are potentially exciting and important.

      Weaknesses:

      The major weakness of this work is the lack of a saline-treated control. All conclusions rest on analyses that are limited to within-animal comparisons between a baseline session and a later session in which rats were injected with psilocybin prior to session start. There is no control for the injection stress or passage of time. The manuscript mentions that 5 of 8 mice were also tested in a session following a saline injection, but because data were lost for some animals, this was not pursued. Figure S1G reports very limited analysis of this data to suggest that there is no effect. At a minimum, this must be analyzed in full (behavioral and neural data) and included in the manuscript to support the central claim that the effects reported are indeed attributable to psilocybin.

      Beyond this, it would be of interest to examine if the effect of psilocybin is restricted to the acute session or if any effects persist.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors track structural role representations during stimulus processing, which is relevant to study how prior experience shapes new learning. They employ a sequence learning task based on graph factorization and record brain activity using MEG to investigate whether graph factors are reused during learning and inference in a new graph. MEG data were recorded during passive stimulus presentation, while behavior is assessed in a subset of probe trials testing either experienced or inferred successions in the graph. The authors report neural similarity among stimuli conditional on their role in subprocesses, and a correlation between evidence for role representations and performance in experience probes, but not in inference probes.

      The interpretation of "knowledge transfer" in the title and abstract is, however, constrained by the absence of a corresponding relationship with performance in the inference probes, which provide the behavioral measure of transfer. While the authors discuss why role representations might relate more closely to experience than inference probes in this task, this distinction makes the link between the neural findings and transfer weaker than the current framing suggests. (E.g., "was positively related to behavioral success in subprocess knowledge transfer" in the abstract could be misleading)

      More broadly, the framing of the results as a mechanism for structure transfer or structural scaffolding appears stronger than warranted by the evidence. The findings indicate representations consistent with reusable roles, but do not establish that these representations functionally facilitate learning and transfer. The claims should align with this distinction between evidence for representational reuse and structural scaffolding.

      Also, apart from abstract roles, simpler categorical grouping of different stimuli belonging to the same subprocess could produce increased similarity.

      Relatedly, although the MEG-behavior (experience probes) correlation is significant for Component 6 but not Component 4, the difference between the two correlations is not significant. Interpreting the correlation as selective to the structurally relevant graph is thus difficult to statistically substantiate.

      Overall, the study provides a well-designed paradigm for investigating compositional representations during structural generalization at high temporal resolution. However, the findings do not provide sufficient evidence to frame them as a mechanism for structure transfer.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The revised manuscript has improved substantially. The authors have addressed the main concerns raised during the previous round by introducing an IVT-based calibration framework, evaluating background calls across probability thresholds, examining basecalling mismatches, and replacing "stoichiometry" with the more appropriate term "predicted modification proportion." The expanded discussion of non-DRACH predictions is also useful and appropriately balanced. Overall, the study now provides a valuable practical framework for Dorado-based RNA modification analysis.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Ding et al. examine the role of TIE1 in cardiac chamber morphogenesis using genetic mouse models targeting Tie1, Tek, or both, and analyzing endocardial cell-mediated chamber formation across multiple embryonic developmental and postnatal stages, supported by analysis of published single cell datasets and new bulk RNA seq analyses of murine cardiac tissue. The authors find that Tie1 and Tek expression is higher in atrial than ventricular endocardial cells. Notably, endothelial TIE1 is required for atrial trabeculation at E12.5, but is less critical in ventricular trabeculation. TIE1 also acts synergistically with TIE2 during atrial trabeculation. While Tie1 deficiency alone does not cause defects at E10.5, combined heterozygous deletion of Tek disrupts both atrial and ventricular development at E10.5. This synergy is further supported by analyses at later embryonic stages and in postnatal hearts.

      Strengths:

      The study is well designed, clearly written, and supported by high-quality figures. The performed experiments demonstrate a previously unrecognized role for TIE1 in cardiac development and identify synergistic control of cardiac morphogenesis by TIE1 and TIE2. This synergy is consistent with the previously identified roles of TIE1 and TIE2 in venous development and with TIE1 involvement in angiopoietin-dependent postnatal vascular and lymphatic remodeling. Together, these findings support a role for TIE1 as a contributor to ANGPT1-TIE2 signaling during heart development.

      Weaknesses:

      The manuscript does not include direct mechanistic studies; however, RNA seq analysis of atria and ventricles showed reduced expression of Tek, Dll1, and Notch1 upon Tie1 deficiency in developing hearts. Although no direct mechanistic experiments are performed, potential mechanisms based on previously published work such as TIE1-TIE2 heterodimer formation, effects on endothelial junctions, migration, survival and venous development are discussed in the context of TIE1-TIE2 synergy.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript examined the impact of sulcal morphology on reading development. A very specific feature on the ventral surface of the brain was identified, namely the presence of an interruption in the posterior portion of the left occipitotemporal sulcus (pOTS). Compared to children with a continuous pOTS, children with an interruption at age 5 years had better reading ability at age 8. This was a large effect measured in 43 children. Surprisingly, this morphological feature was a better predictor of reading ability than measures of pre-literacy cognitive skills, such as phonological awareness. The effect was tested and reproduced across several different measures of reading ability. The authors hypothesised that the mechanism underlying this benefit related to greater local connectivity, which confers a computational advantage. This was demonstrated using analysis of diffusion-weighted imaging data in 29 of the children obtained at age 8.

      Strengths:

      The novelty of the manuscript is threefold: (i) the measure was made in children who were pre-literate (previous work was in older children and adults); (ii) longitudinal brain imaging and behavioural data were analysed; and (iii) diffusion data were analysed to test a hypothesis about the underlying mechanism.

      The manuscript is exceptionally well written. The methods are detailed and easily reproduced. The approach is thoughtful and meticulous. All possible alternatives appear to have been considered. Where possible, further analyses have been done to address these alternatives. For example, the testing of the specificity of the sulcal interruption to left pOTS was an important addition. None predicted reading skills.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript challenges the long-standing assumption that Yoda1 and Yoda2 are PIEZO1-selective activators. Using patch-clamp electrophysiology and calcium imaging in HEK293TΔPZ1 cells overexpressing PIEZO2, the authors demonstrate that Yoda1 potentiates PIEZO2 stretch-activated currents to a similar extent as PIEZO1 and slows PIEZO2 poking-current inactivation (albeit with lower efficacy). They further show that the more potent analog Yoda2 affects PIEZO2 at nanomolar concentrations and use mutagenesis and molecular dynamics simulations to propose that Yoda2's benzoic acid group forms a transient salt bridge with R1724 in the putative Yoda binding pocket, explaining its enhanced potency.

      Strengths:

      The authors are established Piezo/biophysics experts; the study is highly important, technically competent, and carries significant implications for the reinterpretation of prior work that used Yoda compounds as PIEZO1-selective probes.

      The core finding that Yoda1 modulates PIEZO2 stretch currents is convincing and important.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is a very interesting paper bringing new and important information about the poorly understood rhodopsin 7 photoreceptive molecule. The very ancient origin of the gene is revealed in addition to data supporting a signaling pathway that is different from the one known for the canonical rhodopsins. Precise expression data, particularly in the optic lobe of the fly, as well as clear behavioral phenotypes in responses to light changes, make this study a strong contribution to the understanding of the still-debated function of rhodopsin 7.

      Specific comments

      (1) Title and abstract: Contribution of Rh7 to circadian clock regulation

      a) It is not that clear to me what rhodopsin does in terms of circadian regulation (even though its function might be circadianly regulated). The clear role in the light/dark distribution of activity might not be circadian per se, but mostly light/dark- driven and there is no evidence here for a role in the entrainment of the clock.

      b) The authors should cite Lazopulo, which nicely shows that Rh7 has an important role in peripheral neurons to allow flies to escape from blue light (see below).

      (2) Figure 2 C

      The finding showing that Galphaz but not Galphaq can trigger signaling from light-excited Rh7 is a very intriguing finding to better understand Rh7 function. Since Galphaz is related to Gi/o, it would be interesting to test those, for example, by expressing RNAi with Rh7-gal4 and testing the Light-dark or light-off response behavior.

      (3) Figures 3-4

      The change in the locomotor activity distribution between light and dark in LD conditions provides a nice assay for Rh7 function. Since Lazopulo et al. (2019) have shown that wild-type but not Rh7 mutants do escape from blue light, it would be important to compare and discuss these LD behavior data with the Lazopulo results. Precisely, is this nighttime preference linked to blue light?

      The expression data are really nice and show that Rh7 is mostly a non-retinal photoreceptor. However, the paper would be strongly reinforced by correlating this with the LD behavior. The LD phenotype should be tested in flies with Rh7 expression rescued under Rh7gal4 control (as done for the startle response). This is important to show whether the expression pattern is likely responsible for the described Rh7 function in LD. If L5 and or M11 drivers are available, they should be used to rescue Rh7? Since expression in some clock neurons is shown, the rescue experiment should also be done with a clock neuron driver.

      In the same line, can the LD phenotype (or startle response phenotype of Figure 4) be restored by expressing Rh7 under ppk control, as shown for the blue light avoidance phenotype by Lazopulo et al?

      Finally, the Rh7 "darkfly" rescued flies should be tested in LD.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors aimed to understand how the transcription factor Erbb4 contributes local circuit dynamics and affects performance. This is an interesting question because Erbb4 is largely localized to PV cells in the olfactory bulb (OB) and upregulated following exposure to an olfactory discrimination task.

      Strengths:

      They have now validated their local, PV-specific knockout strategy, which more directly tests their hypothesis.

      The inclusion of optogenetically evoked presynaptic responses from PV cells onto M/T cells also strengthened the conclusion that this synapse was altered.

      The authors also now included slice recordings from PV cells, which helps to form a more comprehensive picture of the circuit.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The data used to support their spike sorting approach is now included but is difficult to evaluate. In Figure 4 - supp 1B, they show what appears to be mean + sem of concatenated waveforms from one tetrode, but this is not explained anywhere. Moreover, the timescale seems to be off by an order of magnitude. It also seems that the spike widths in panel E are bimodally distributed, with many of the half-widths being more consistent with fast-spiking cells. There is a high density of PV cells in the same layer where they record M/T cells, so is it not possible that some of the units were PV cells (note: this was suggested in the previous review as a potential exciting direction to further validate their findings)? It is still unclear how the authors confidently record from only M/T cells when there is no mention of how other units (e.g., fast-spiking cells) are excluded. The methods state that only M/T cells can be recorded from this layer, which is an oversimplification and appears at odds with the apparent diversity in waveforms and responses.

      (2) Upon review, the authors acknowledge that the PV-Erbb4+/+ and PV-Erbb4-/- mice were recorded in separate batches where the control mice were exposed to unwanted artefacts related to a solenoid valve. While we don't know how much that change influenced the results, even with careful analysis, it does draw attention to a major weakness in study design where controls and experimental mice are not run simultaneously. The presence of an artefact from the solenoid valve (perhaps a noise?) immediately before odor presentation for controls, but not experimental mice, should be considered by the reader when it comes to evaluating the odor-evoked responses.

      Overall, I feel the manuscript is much improved and more solidly demonstrates that Erbb4 expression in PV cells plays a major role in regulating local OB circuit dynamics and influences odor processing. The remaining weaknesses surrounding the in vivo single unit recordings from PV-Erbb4+/+ versus PV-Erbb4-/- mice reduce my confidence in the validity of the results, but the general agreement of the in vitro work is more re-assuring.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study by Suzuki et al. reports an interesting stereo-selective role of D-serine in regulating one-carbon metabolism during neurodevelopment to adapt the functional transition, probably through the competition with mitochondrial transport of L-serine. The authors provide a multi-layered set of evidence, including metabolomics, enzyme assays, mitochondrial transport competition and functional assays in immature/neural progenitor cells, to build up a conceptual integration of D-serine as both a neurotransmitter and a metabolic regulator in central neural system, which raises a broad potential interest to the neuroscience and metabolism communities.

      Strengths:

      This work provides a conceptual advance that D-serine is not only serves as a traditional neurotransmitter in central neural system but also critically contributes to metabolic regulation of neural cells. The authors performed solid metabolomic assays to validate the suppressive effect of D-serine on one-carbon metabolic pathway, providing some evidence that D-serine competitively inhibits mitochondrial serine transport, but not directly impairs SHMT2 enzymatic activity. All these data indicate a critical role of D-serine synthesis during neural maturation and suggest a potential translational strategy for targeting serine metabolism in neural tumors.

      Comments on previous version.

      My previous concerns have been appropriately addressed or discussed in this revised version of manuscript. I have to say that, at this stage, I have no further questions.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors study cardiac deceleration during threat responses in Drosophila. Particularly, it focuses on identifying the neuronal control of this deceleration. Using behavioral and cardiac tracking and analysis, genetics and calcium imaging, they identify two pairs of dopaminergic neurons involved in cardiac deceleration during air puff responses.

      Strengths:

      The study is overall well done and the paper clearly written. Particularly the work on identifying the two pairs of dopaminergic neurons involved in cardiac deceleration using a series of drivers and generating new ones is rigorous and extensive. Finally, the authors manipulate heartbeat to investigate how it influences threat responses. Although the evidence that heartbeat deceleration-induced increase in locomotion remains partial, the study reveals important insight in the relationship between locomotion, cardiac activity and neuromodulatory system during threat responses.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public Review):

      The authors develop an experimental framework to precisely control temperature in an arena and make quantitative measurements of thermal avoidance behavior in Drosophila. They find that wild-type animals show robust heat avoidance behavior and suggest that antennal ablation reduces this heat avoidance. They also make a novel claim that antennal inputs do more than simple heat detection but play a role in navigation strategies like centrophobism and are needed for decision-making at thermal boundaries. The fundamental two-choice behavior paradigm or the use of peltier modules for temperature control have been employed previously in the field. The strength of this work lies in detailed behavioral measurements. However, the study falls short due to a lack of adequate experimental controls. The authors then model this behavior as a classical Braitenberg vehicle of sensory-motor transformation. Overall, the paper has some interesting insights into in-depth analysis of Drosophila navigation in thermal gradients, but their evidence only partially supports their claims.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Ma et al. use human-chimpanzee tetraploid cells to examine species differences in DNA methylation. They identify differentially methylated regions under cis or trans regulation. Cis-DMRs are enriched near SNVs that disrupt or create CpGs, providing a plausible mechanism for cis changes in methylation. They also seek to identify transcription factors that might affect methylation in trans, as well as gene sets with evidence for consistent changes in methylation and expression between humans and chimpanzees, suggesting that they may underlie lineage-specific traits.

      Strengths:

      The authors have generated a new dataset across multiple different cell types examining differences in DNA methylation between humans and chimpanzees using human diploid cells, chimpanzee diploid cells, and human-chimpanzee tetraploid cells. Using this dataset, they identify that cis-DMRs are enriched near SNVs that disrupt or create CpGs compared to trans-DMRs and identify transcription factors as candidate trans-acting factors. Both identified SNVs and transcription factors are good candidates for future experimentation. The authors also find that cis-DMRs are more highly correlated with cis-expressed genes than trans-DMRs with trans-expressed genes, providing evidence that methylation and expression are linked genome-wide. Further, they apply a clever sign test approach to identify gene pathways with evidence for lineage-specific selection.

      Comments on revised version.

      They authors have addressed my concerns from their initial manuscript. In particular, the authors have noted the limitations of their study as appropriate, including the use of permissive FDR cut-offs.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The revised manuscript by Nohara et al. presents a novel 3D assay that allows for stratification of epithelia, active EMT through small pores, and active MET. They show that 3um pores allow for keratinocytes to sample the pore through filopodia and up regulate EMT genes to transverse the pores to the other side of the membrane where EMT genes are down regulated as the cells re-establish stratified epithelia. The TGFbeta pathway and actin polymerization promotes movement of cells into the pores and Piezo1 and KRT6 actively block this movement. This work provides a novel 3D assay that is likely to become a benchmark to analyze these processes using a more complex system than other current culture-specific EMT and MET assays.

      Strengths:

      The strengths of the manuscript include the foundational analysis of the pathways involved in establishing the 3-compartment epithelium. The authors have incorporated live imaging, drug studies, KO analysis, and RNA-sequencing to show the relevant pathways involved. The authors were responsive to the original round of reviews and present a much-improved study with greater details on molecular markers, quantification, and clarity.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      This study from de Boer, Lamme, Verdwaald and Schafer describes the de novo AI-guided design of miniproteins that target the chemokine CCL25, with the aim to modulate the activation and signalling of the chemokine receptors CCR9 and ACKR4. The study focuses on characterising four miniproteins that all bind CCL25 with good affinity. Three designs appear to prevent CCL25 binding to both CCR9 and ACKR4, with increasing concentrations of miniproteins resulting in decreased arrestin (both receptors) and mini G protein recruitment (CCR9), less inhibition of forskolin-stimulated cAMP (CCR9), and decreased GRK3 recruitment and receptor internalisation (CCR9). One miniprotein, VUP25111, changes the properties of CCL25 rather than preventing ligand/receptor interactions, resulting in greater selectivity for CCR9 over ACKR4 and a G protein-biased signalling profile (maintenance of mini G protein recruitment, GRK3 recruitment, inhibition of cAMP and receptor internalisation, but loss of arrestin recruitment). VUP25111 also maintained chemotactic migration in MOLT-4 T lymphoblast cells, whereas this response was lost in the presence of the other three miniproteins.

      Overall, this is a very interesting application of AI-designed de novo miniproteins to modulate GPCR responses by directly binding the ligand rather than the receptor. This is a conceptually very intriguing approach that could, in principle, be extended to other GPCR systems beyond the chemokine family. The authors deploy an impressive array of assays spanning multiple signalling endpoints, providing a thorough picture of how each miniprotein influences receptor activation and downstream signalling. The presentation of concentration-response relationships for CCL25 alone and in the presence of each miniprotein is particularly informative, and the figures are very well constructed throughout. The inclusion of clear cartoons illustrating the basis of each assay is a nice touch that will help readers from outside the immediate field follow the logic of each experiment.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, Hossaim and colleagues investigate the role of the ITK kinase in modulating inflammation in a pristane-induced lung hemorrhage model. Using a germline ITK KO mouse, they report that loss of ITK skews the T cell compartment toward a memory-like state, expanding Tregs, and conferring protection against alveolar hemorrhage, inflammatory monocyte recruitment, proteinuria, and systemic cytokine elevation. They further show that transfer of ITK-deficient Tregs into wild-type hosts with established disease attenuates injury and shifts the cytokine balance toward resolution, and that ITK-deficient Tregs carry a transcriptional signature enriched for OXPHOS, mTORC1, MYC, and cell-cycle programs. While these observations are interesting for the development of potential immunotherapies, there are several issues with the methodological approach that support the authors' claims, tempering my enthusiasm for this manuscript.

      Strengths:

      (1) The clinical motivation and potential targeted therapies are relevant.

      (2) The murine phenotype seems robust.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed my comments appropriately.

    1. GroupID: 63

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      GroupSize: 3

      GroupNumberMales: N/A

      GroupNumberFemales: N/A

      GroupEthnicity: Japanese

      GroupAgeRange: N/A

      GroupInfo: 3 individuals from a single family (ID 63).

      GroupPresentingHPOs: HP:0001732; HP:0005584; HP:0010797 (Abnormality of the pancreas, Renal cell carcinoma, Hemangioblastoma)

      GroupHPOFreeText: CNS hemangioblastoma (2/3), renal cell carcinoma (3/3) and pancreatic cyst or tumor (unspecified) (1/3).

      GroupNotHPOs: HP:0009711 (Retinal capillary hemangioma)

      GroupNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      GroupPreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: p.S168Tfs*2 (c.503_513del)

      LegacyVariant: c.716_726del (c.716del11bp)

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: CA2573131812, https://reg.clinicalgenome.org/redmine/projects/registry/genboree_registry/by_caid?caid=CA2573131812

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: deletion; minus_2_frameshift_variant

      CivicName: S168Tfs*2 (c.503_513del)

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    1. An association of candidate gene haplotypes and bleeding severity in von Willebrand disease type 2A, 2B, and 2M pedigrees

      PMID: 16409463

      Notes: several variants, currently curating c.823T>C (p.Cys275Arg) and family 11 proband is compound het with p.Pro1337Leu. Nucleotide position are not provided and the family is asserted as type B but no GPIb, RIPA or VWF platelet binding assay data are reported.

    1. {"type":"entrez-nucleotide","attrs":{"text":"NM_017890.4","term_id":"384551660","term_text":"NM_017890.4"}}NM_017890.4:c.6879delT

      Case# RQMR10_V-2

      Demographics: Female, 20 yrs at report,

      CasePresentingHPOs HP:0000729, HP:0001763, HP:0001761, HP:0001956, HP:0000577

      CaseNotHPOs

      CasePreviousTesting

      CaseMethod1

      CaseMethod2

      CaseGenotypingMethod

      Variant NM_017890.4:c.6879delT(p.Phe2293Leufs*24)

      ClinVar

      CAID CA4824093

      gnomAD 0.00003250 (South Asian)

      VariantEvidence The proband is homozygous for the variant. This variant introduces a frameshift, resulting in premature protein truncation. The variant was found to cosegregate with disease in the family and was not found in 293 healthy ethnicity-matched controls. It is reported in a heterozygous state at a frequency of 0.00003250 in South Asians in gnomAD.

      CaseAddInfo

      CasePMIDs

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors seek to understand the hierarchical temporal representation of social communicative actions in the posterior superior temporal sulcus and other regions of the lateral pathway. They apply an analysis framework in which they predict fMRI responses from EEG responses to the same stimuli. (The EEG stimuli were shorter versions of the same clips shown as fMRI stimuli.) They examine which temporal segments of EEG data are most predictive of responses in which part of the brain. They find that early (< 100 ms post-stimulus) EEG activity is predictive of responses in early visual cortex, and that later (~ 150 ms post-stimulus) EEG activity is predictive of responses in the lateral visual stream. They then model the fMRI responses predicted by the EEG signals - which they term the "EEG-relevant" portion of the fMRI signal - as a function of various social and visual factors. They conclude that social interactions elicit responses in aSTS-SI later than low-level visual features elicit responses in early visual cortex, and they provide some evidence that mid-level social primitives elicit responses in mid-level areas somewhere in between.

      Strengths:

      I find the question and the framework interesting. The extraction of "EEG-relevant" fMRI signal as a target for visual and social feature-based encoding models has potential, though the approach in this instance suffers from low signal-to-noise. The evidence that the anterior portion of the superior temporal sulcus responds to communicative actions is clear and supports prior work in this regard.

      Weaknesses:

      I think there are several important points that the authors need to address to strengthen their case, and I think that many points could use more explicit description, explanation, and discussion.

      Major concerns:

      First, the basis of the EEG predictions of fMRI activity is not clear. The paradigm relies on predicting fMRI responses at each voxel from a weighted combination of EEG responses measured anywhere over the scalp. However, the authors never show any kind of weight map to visualize which electrodes on the scalp were weighted to predict responses in each fMRI voxel or ROI. I see that the use of PCA to orthogonalize the EEG responses creates problems with localizing the predictive signal in EEG to particular electrodes. Is the PCA step necessary? In any case, some form of analysis to estimate where in the brain the predictive EEG signal is coming from seems important. It's fairly clear that the best signal quality in the EEG recordings is in the early visual cortex. Thus, it could be the case that electrodes over EVC provide the main basis for predictions across the entire brain, with different temporal phases of EVC activity associated with activity in different regions in the fMRI data. It could also be the case (tho less likely in my opinion) that activity in regions away from EVC on the scalp provides the basis for predicting more anterior brain regions in the fMRI data. These two possibilities each suggest a substantially different interpretation of the present results: in the former case, there may be some sort of feedback loop between early visual areas and lateral areas; in the latter case, the hierarchical interpretation the authors have laid out seems more plausible. It seems important to draw a distinction between these possibilities.

      In any case, the authors should say more in the discussion about the sources of EEG signals and fMRI signals and the relationship between the two.

      On a similar note: the authors show that their EEG data was reliable based on a split-half analysis of the data. However, the authors only show average split-half correlation across electrodes and subjects. It stands to reason that some electrodes were much more reliable than others. The authors should show a map of electrode reliability across the scalp. One relevant question is: are there reliable electrode locations throughout the visual cortex? Or are the EEG signals only, or by far most reliable, in EVC? (How reliable is the EEG signal in regions that are at least somewhat near to the location of the lateral regions that is the principal object of investigation here?)

      The use of predicted fMRI signals (predicted by EEG) as a target for image & social feature encoding models is only valid to the extent that the EEG signals accurately predict the fMRI signals. The prediction accuracy going from EEG to fMRI is not very high - a correlation of less than 0.2 in most regions besides EVC and the anterior extent of the activity along the ventral temporal lobe. In the best-predicted regions, the activity only reaches a correlation of 0.3. The majority of the signal (> 90% of the variance) is unmodeled in this analysis. Thus, I would hesitate to characterize the evidence for activation by particular stimulus features at particular times in this analysis as "strong". The authors themselves are somewhat ambivalent on this point, as well. While they write in the conclusion: "Finally, we find strong evidence that social interactions are computed via hierarchical computation of low- and mid-level social visual features in the lateral visual pathway." However, This statement conflicts somewhat with other statements the authors make in the discussion section: "Together, these results suggest that lateral visual regions may not be organized in a strict feedforward hierarchy as has previously been suggested" Later in the discussion there is more ambivalence about the hierarchical nature of the representation: "Our findings suggest that the processing of social action features from posterior to anterior brain regions does not adhere to a strict feedforward hierarchy." The authors should present a more consistent interpretation of their findings.

      Finally, the low performance of most of the mid-level models in mid-level regions is a concern; it points to poor signal overall. The common threads in the models that do predict responses above chance seem to be space (spatial expanse and agent distance) and salience (to the extent that arousal may constitute salience). This raises a question: Were the social model features correlated with either of the low-level model features?

      I think that the overriding issue here is poor signal quality in the EEG data. The estimate of repeatability from the split-half analysis is not high, even on average for the whole brain; it is likely to be very poor for areas outside EVC. I think this matters. An important null hypothesis to consider is that there may be a few fairly low-level, or at least simple and straightforward, elements of the response that are reflected in the noisy EEG signal. Chief among these is likely to be that the most salient or high-contrast retinotopic regions in the image, which both AlexNet and motion energy models would likely pick up on, are likely to elicit responses in EVC. This is likely why EVC is by far the best-predicted region, both based on the raw EEG data and in the two-step regression analysis. There could be elements of spatial priority at all levels of the visual system. This could be what the authors are observing: there is some relatively small (in terms of variance explained) component of the signal that is common to many regions, and which emerges somewhat later in later regions due to conduction delays.

      I think an important exception to this signal problem is the finding of communicative actions eliciting responses in aSTS-SI. That seems very robust and clear.

      Medium comments:

      There should be a section in the methods on how the ROIs were defined. (There is a brief description in the results section, but this is not sufficient). The ROI outlines should also be displayed somewhere in the paper (not just circles showing the general region as in Figure 1). Figure 3 would be a nice place for them, as would Figure S3.

      It's also worth noting in the methods and discussion that the use of template ROIs for hMT in particular is potentially sub-optimal. hMT lies in anatomically variable locations across subjects. One reason for the seemingly weak signal in hMT may be that the voxels being averaged do not fall within the true hMT for each subject.

      In the results (section 3.2.1), the authors write, "We scored the regression by predicting the EEG-predicted fMRI activity (estimated fMRItest) to the held-out test videos and then correlating the actual fMRI response (fMRItest) in the test set to this prediction at each time point (estimated fMRItest)." Unless I am missing something, I think the authors can safely say that they predicted responses to the withheld stimuli without specifying the intended prediction target (whether it is the fMRI data or the estimated fMRI data), because the prediction is simply based on weights, labeled or estimated image features, and stimuli. So, the prediction might as well be a direct prediction of the fMRI test data. It seems to me that mentioning the estimated fMRI test in this sentence only muddies the waters.

      In the two-stage regression analysis, were all the visual and social features fit to the EEG-predicted fMRI data in a single regression? Was this regression regularized? How many parameters total were fit? (This is clear for the AlexNet and motion energy models, but not clear for the other features - were they all single-feature models?)

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Drosophila haematopoiesis has been shown to be governed by a number of signalling pathways such as JAK/STAT and Dpp. This important study shows a role for nutrient sensing and autophagy in determining blood cell differentiation. The authors show that General control non-derepressible 5 (Gcn5), a histone acetyltransferase affects blood cell differentiation. Gcn5 also negatively regulates autophagy through its effector TFEB which directly regulates autophagy genes. The authors also show that mTORC1 modulates Gcn5 levels and through it TFEB activity thus acting as a fine-tuning mechanism which maintains optimal levels of autophagy.

      Strengths:

      The main strength of the work lies in the interesting finding that cellular metabolic processes such as autophagy has a direct role in blood cell differentiation and has the potential to be of interest to those working on vertebrate haematopoiesis as well. The report has generated intriguing data, using promoters specific for sub sections of the lymph gland, that different cellular subsets of the lymph gland contribute differently towards haematopoiesis, but this is not followed up in detail and the final conclusions are derived from a combination of whole lymph gland perturbations as well as those from specific promoters.

      Weakness:

      (1) Gc5 seems to be expressed throughout the lymph gland but modulating it in the subsections do not have the same result. It is very striking that the knockdown of Gcn5 in the prohemocyte population does not have an effect on differentiation whereas overexpression does. And the modulations of Gcn5 in PSC also has variable effects across hemocyte subpopulations which is not explored in the manuscript. Interestingly, also the domain deletion constructs show differential effect on blood cell differentiation when altered solely in the prohemocytes which is not explained. While Gcn5 can be seen in all sections of the lymph gland in the first figure, under the HHLT-Gal4 and Hml-Gal4, Gcn5 looks cytoplasmic and almost completely excluded from the nucleus strikingly unlike Gcn5 expression under the Collier-Gal4 and Dome-Gal4. The rest of the experiments in the manuscript are done with multiple promoters, with autophagy flux measured by modulating Gcn5 with a pan hemocyte promoter, but the mTORC1-Gcn5 axis is explored using chemical modulators which affect the whole of the lymph gland (Fig7) or using two pro-hemocyte promoters (Fig8).

      (2) The knockdown of Gcn5 seems to affect the gland size (A compared to B and C). Since mTORC1 is a central regulator of cell size, it is possible that some of the effects seen in these knockdowns are potentially through mTORC1 affecting size suggesting that the signalling axis between mTORC1 and Gcn5 might not be a one-way axis as suggested in Figure 9. Also, this would mean that in experiments where absolute cell counts of crystal cells or niche cells are used to assess blood cell differentiation, further analysis to consider total cell numbers in the lymph gland would strengthen the manuscript.

      (3) A genetic manipulation of mTORC1 specifically in the pro hemocytes would strengthen the role of mTORC1 in the pathway rather than the chemical modulation which affects the whole of the lymph gland.

      Comments on the revised manuscript:

      Overall, the revisions make the narrative more coherent and pertinent to the results presented. The authors have also added new data and the analysis supports their conclusions.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors extend the ORGaNICs framework (a recurrent circuit that dynamically implements divisive normalization) to connected cortical areas with explicit top-down feedback. Because the network has a known analytical fixed point that coincides with (or closely approximates) the normalization equation, the authors can linearize about that fixed point and derive closed-form expressions for the power spectral density, inter-areal coherence, and communication subspaces. Using a two-area instantiation (V1 & V2) with a single fixed parameter set and no data fitting, they show the model reproduces: (i) contrast-response functions with steeper slope V2; (ii) gamma-band power and coherence peaks that shift to higher frequency with contrast; and (iii) a low-dimensional inter-areal communication subspace that is lower-dimensional than the within-area subspace. They derive parallel predictions of what happens by changing model parameters: feedback gain enhances inter-areal and suppresses within-area communication, and normalization is necessary for both the oscillatory dynamics and the reduced subspace dimensionality. A three-area extension (V1&V4, V1&V5/MT) is used to argue that differential top-down feedback can dynamically route functional connectivity.

      Strengths:

      (1) Analytical tractability: Deriving power spectra, coherence, and communication-subspace structure in closed form from a known fixed point is genuinely valuable.

      (2) Conceptual unification: Framing coherence and communication subspaces as arising from the same normalization-driven dynamics is an elegant and useful contribution.

      (3) Breadth from few assumptions: A large range of phenomena (contrast gain, gamma dynamics) emerges from normalization-based model assumptions.

      (4) Biological grounding: The mapping of model variables onto identified cell types connects the abstract computation to known cortical microcircuitry.

      (5) The prediction that input-gain versus feedback-gain modulation produce distinct spectral signatures gives experimentalists a clear way to test the framework.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      The manuscript investigates the coupling of saccadic eye-movements (S) with directed tail flips (T), and the remarkable discovery is that tail flips that are preceded by a conjugate sacced (S-T) can be credibly classified as specific "volitional" turns that are distinguished from the standard tail movements that seem to be more of a spontaneous and "impulsive" nature.

      They show that 'turning intent', as indicated by a small increase in S, is elevated by aversive odors, while 'gliding intent', as indicated by a decrease in S and an increase in undulation cycles, is elevated by appetitive odors.

      This is a very important finding, which is backed up by a thorough behavioral analysis, and the identification of neural populations in the pallium and sub-pallium that clearly distinguish between these kinds of turns is very promising. Here they identify neuronal populations that are preferentially active during - and predictive of - coupled (S-T) versus isolated (T) tail flips.

      Especially the fact that S-T turns (but not T turns) can be predicted already by pre-event, ramping, pallial activity is intriguing.

      The authors then go on and demonstrate that the frequency of (S-T) turns is modulated in fish exposed to appetitive or aversive odors.<br /> Specifically, they quantify the aversiveness and appetitive-ness of several odors in a free swimming assay, they select a couple of these odors based on their valence and they demonstrate that these odors induce moderate modulation in the frequency of eye saccades (S) and tail flips (T) and (S-T) turns.

      The study is rigorous and thorough and the findings are informative and novel.

      In important controls they confirm that brain wide imaging can distinguish between appetitive and aversive context, and they show that pallial activation by aversive odors is consistent with neural activity in the rhombencephalon that correlates with turning activity, whereas sub-pallial activation by appetitive odors correlates with rhombencephalic activity related to gliding.

      It's all very good.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed all my concerns.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study presents a fundamental new finding - the identification of a sensory-neuron itch receptor, MRGPRX4, as an unexpected melanoma oncogene through a mechanism of lineage-inappropriate expression rather than mutation. The evidence supporting the core observation (tumor-specific upregulation, restriction to invasive transcriptional states, and sufficiency to drive fully penetrant metastatic melanoma in vivo) is compelling, drawing on convergent human genomic datasets and a well-controlled genetic mouse model. However, several of the mechanistic and translational claims - particularly regarding causal drivers of invasion, the immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment, and in vivo pharmacological efficacy - rely on correlative evidence.

      Strengths:

      The authors propose that MRGPRX4, normally restricted to a subset of peripheral sensory neurons, is aberrantly re-expressed in melanoma rather than through mutational mechanisms, and that this re-expression is sufficient to drive tumorigenesis through basal, ligand-independent GPCR signaling. This is a genuinely novel model for oncogenesis, and the manuscript deploys an impressive range of approaches - bulk and single-cell transcriptomics, spatial transcriptomics, proteomics, phosphoproteomics, and pharmacology - to support it.

      The claim that MRGPRX4 is selectively upregulated in melanoma and confined to neural-crest-like/invasive transcriptional states is well supported, with consistent results across multiple independent human scRNA-seq datasets. The claim that ectopic MRGPRX4 is sufficient to drive melanoma is convincingly demonstrated by the fully penetrant, metastatic phenotype in the Tyr-CreER;MRGPRX4-LSL model, with appropriate specificity controls showing that MRGPRX1, MRGPRX2, and MRGPRX3 do not phenocopy this effect.

      The claim that MRGPRX4 signals through basal, ligand-independent activity is reasonably well supported by bile-acid quantification showing endogenous ligand concentrations well below the EC50 required for activation.

      Overall assessment:

      The manuscript's central, most novel claim - that lineage-inappropriate expression of a sensory GPCR is sufficient to drive melanoma - is compellingly supported. The secondary mechanistic and translational claims built around this finding are convincing and consistent with the broader literature but are currently supported by correlative rather than causal or functional evidence.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript Zhu, Emanuelli and colleagues describe a novel pharmacological activator of the Integrated Stress Response kinase GCN2. The work is conclusive and biochemically solid. This work significantly adds to the pharmacological arsenal targeting the ISR and in particular GCN2.

      Strengths:

      Strong biochemistry, novel molecular activator of GCN2 (GCN1 independent).

      Weaknesses:

      Rationale for the screen not exploited in the results (e.g. pathogenic GCN2 mutants), lots of cell-based read-outs not endogenous.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors did a great job at addressing my initial critique on their manuscript and consequently I have no further comment.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript, by Kang and colleagues, examines the activity of the Gasdermin (GSDM) family of proteins in epidermal skin cells called keratinocytes. Gasdermins are a relatively recently discovered family of pore-forming proteins that are generally studied for their role in inflammasome activation and pyroptosis. The role and functions of GSDMs in keratinocytes are not fully understood, but programmed cell death is important to keratinocytes as part of the cornification process. Keratinocyte pyroptosis associated with GSDMD and GSDME has been linked to the pathogenesis of psoriasis, and GSDMA-mediated pyroptosis in keratinocytes is responsive to Staphylococcus aureus infection. These data suggest that defining the role of GSDM in keratinocytes could provide valuable insight into the treatment of skin pathologies, particularly those involving inflammation.

      Strengths:

      In this study, the authors use two human keratinocyte cell lines to focus primarily on the biology of GSDM in keratinocytes, particularly A, B and C, both during homeostatic conditions and in response to some pathogenic stimuli. The data indicate that the full-length GSDMA and B proteins are colocalizing not to the plasma membrane, but to the cytoskeletal, cytoplasmic or membrane fractions, in direct contrast to a number of other studies. Further, there are data showing the GSDM are not cleaved by the same proteases as in other studies, and that GSDMA is not involved control of Vaccinia virus skin infection. The controls for cleavage done in HeLa cells with a number of inhibitors were particularly strong, and the overall finding is interesting and potentially important, providing novel insight in the biology of GSDM proteins in keratinocytes. The second half of the paper focuses on treatment with calyculin A, a protein phosphatase inhibitor that the authors report recapitulates acantholysis, i.e. the loss of cell-cell junctions between keratinocytes. Calyculin A altered the localization of GSDM but increased cell death and keratin release irrespective of GSDM activity, suggesting that acantholytic cell death does not involve GSDM. Overall, these data are an interesting study showing differences in GSDM biology in keratinocytes and indicating that GSDM are not involved in a number of pathogenic processes associated with skin diseases.

      Weaknesses:

      Unfortunately, the data supporting these findings are not particularly strong and are somewhat confusing, and the study is not well organized. One of the major weaknesses is that most work was done in two human keratinocyte cell lines, and subcellular localization subcellular localization results were not consistent between the two lines. This is not hugely surprising, as cell lines even from the same cell type are very different, and the authors note that there may be some variability associated with the model used. However, the inconsistency between the two lines, alongside the lack of comparison to primary cells or patient data, makes it very difficult to determine which, if any, result accurately recapitulates the biology in human cells. The authors do suggest that the N-TERT line is more similar to primary cells but rely on a single study and no other research or data to support this. Several other experiments compare the keratinocyte lines to a colorectal adenocarcinoma cell line, showing the keratinocytes are also different from these cells, but it is not clear that they support the information about GSDM in either keratinocyte line other than showing that keratinocytes are distinct from colorectal cells.

      There are several specific concerns regarding the data, particularly the western blotting. In a number of the blots, there are bands which are not mentioned. For example, in Figure 3A, "GSDMA and GSDMB translocated from the cytoskeleton equally to both the cytoplasmic and membrane fractions upon calyculin A treatment". But in the western blot shown, GSDMA moves from being entirely in the cytoskeleton to having lighter bands in the cytoskeleton and chromatin-bound regions and heavier bands in the membrane and cytoplasm. GSDMB shows heavier bands in the membrane and cytoplasm after Calyculin A, but the heaviest band remains in the chromatin-bound region. In addition, the western blots have no associated N or pooled data graph with statistics, so it is not clear how many studies it represents or if there were significant changes. A lack of statistical analysis was also seen in the Yoyo-1, membrane ballooning and cell death analyses in 3A, 3C, 4B and 4C, with the membrane ballooning finding being entirely qualitative and not using any image analysis - comparison of P2A or cell area could resolve this. The methods do note that unpaired T-tests and 2-way ANOVAs were performed in some places, so the results of these should be clearly shown on the graphs. Beyond this, all of the localization studies rely on a single modality, western blotting. This finding should be supported by orthogonal approaches, ideally immunofluorescence. Finally, the presence of GAPDH in the supernatant (5A) raises an important issue regarding nonspecific intracellular release. If the GAPDH is present in the sup that is representative of cell damage and does not correlate with the absence of other intracellular markers - such as those found in lysates - in the supernatant.

      The final weakness of the paper was that it is not really clear what the study is trying to say, and it was difficult to follow the logic and data, with several figures being out of order. There are a number of statements that feel overinterpreted, such as stating that clathrin-mediated endocytosis is required for calyculin A mediated acantholysis. While it is clear that Calyculin A recapitulates features similar to acantholysis, it is a broad perturbation of the cell, and it is not clear that it is the same process. Further, the pharmacological evidence is not strong enough to make such a clear claim about the role of clathrin-mediated endocytosis. Similarly, the statement that "GSDMs can induce pyroptosis not only in their cleaved forms but also as full-length proteins through specific post-translational modifications" is much too strong for these data. The terminology surrounding "pyroptosis" should be used more carefully, as yoyo-1 uptake and membrane ballooning demonstrate membrane permeability and morphological changes but are not sufficient for cell death.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The present work was aimed at investigating the specific contributions of thalamic nuclei to associative threat learning and extinction. Using fMRI, it examined activation patterns across pulvinar divisions, the lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN), and the mediodorsal thalamus (MD) during threat acquisition, extinction, and recall. It goals was to uncover whether distinct thalamic systems support different modes of learning-automatic survival mechanisms versus more deliberate processes-and to propose a hierarchical pulvinar model of fear conditioning. The manuscript also tried to refine current neuroanatomical models of threat learning and memory, highlighting the role of thalamic nuclei in it.

      Strengths:

      (1) Valuable theoretical elaboration and modeling regarding the differential role of pulvinar subdivisions on feedforward (inferior, lateral) and higher-order integration (anterior), and their functional interplay with other relevant subcortical and cortical structures in associative threat and extinction learning.

      (2) Large sample sizes and multipronged analytical approaches were used for hypothesis testing.

      (3) Exhaustive literature review in the field of associative threat, as well as regarding the role of thalamic nuclei and other brain structures in it.

      Comments on revised version:

      My three main concerns remain insufficiently addressed or only partially addressed in the study limitations. First, using 3 mm isotropic voxels limits anatomical and functional specificity when investigating small thalamic nuclei. Higher-resolution fMRI protocols and probabilistic thalamic atlases that allow subject-specific segmentation have been available for several years and could have been used to improve anatomical precision. Second, although analyses in normalized space are widely accepted for group-level analyses, normalization can distort the size and boundaries of small thalamic nuclei. Analyses in native space, using subject-specific segmentation, would help address this limitation, particularly given the relatively low functional resolution. Finally, standard preprocessing procedures and the inclusion of motion parameters as covariates do not fully exclude residual motion-related effects or potential differences in motion across experimental conditions. The authors do not report additional motion quality-control procedures, such as excluding participants with excessive motion or substantial translational or rotational drift. Taken together, these concerns prevent me from upgrading my assessment.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work by Hayford, Baleami, Stauffer et al. addresses the standard view of drug-tolerant persister (DTP) cells in cancer. The current model treats each DTP as a uniform, single-cell phenotype that survives therapy. Building on the authors' earlier "idling" DTP concept (Paudel et al. 2018), this study instead provides evidence that DTPs are heterogeneous populations of multiple co-existing sub-states whose individual division/death rates balance out to produce near-zero net population growth.

      Using BRAF-mutant melanoma (SKMEL5) cells treated with the BRAF inhibitor PLX4720, the authors combine single-cell RNA-seq, bulk RNA-seq, ATAC-seq, DNA lineage barcoding (ClonMapper), calcium-flux assays, and ferroptosis drug-response assays to show:

      (1) Idling DTP populations show fewer, but still multiple, distinct transcriptomic sub-states compared to untreated cells (Figure 1).

      (2) They arise from nearly all pre-existing cell lineages rather than from selective expansion of a resistant clone (Figure 2).

      (3) Transcriptomic and epigenomic data converge on altered ion-channel/calcium-handling genes; functional calcium-flux assays confirm reduced store-operated calcium entry (SOCE) in these cells (Figure 3).

      (4) These cells are around 3-fold more sensitive to the ferroptosis inducer RSL3 (GPX4 inhibitor), an effect reversible by the ferroptosis inhibitor ferrostatin-1 (Figure 4).

      The authors propose targeted landscaping, in which drug treatment reshapes a cell population's phenotypic landscape rather than selecting a single resistant subtype, implying that eradicating DTPs will require sequential interventions that progressively narrow the landscape, rather than targeting a presumed uniform persister state.

      Strengths:

      (1) scRNA-seq, bulk RNA-seq, ATAC-seq, lineage barcoding, calcium-flux assays, and drug-response assays all point toward the same conclusions, strengthening confidence in the findings.

      (2) The ClonMapper approach directly tests (and rules out) clonal selection as the origin of DTPs - a key alternative explanation the authors address rigorously.

      (3) The calcium-flux assay and RSL3/ferrostatin-1 ferroptosis experiments provide direct functional confirmation of transcriptomic/epigenomic predictions, moving beyond correlative sequencing data.

      (4) The "bulk" vs. "single-cell-state" and the "targeted landscaping" analogy is useful for framing future treatment strategies.

      (5) Discussion explicitly flags that the data are not time-resolved single-cell trajectories, and that the ferroptosis vulnerability's exact molecular driver is not identified.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) All experiments use one melanoma cell line (SKMEL5 and its subclones), so generalizability to other BRAF-mutant melanomas or other cancer types/drugs is unproven.

      (2) As the authors acknowledge, the study lacks time-lapse/lineage-resolved tracking of individual cells transitioning between sub-states.

      (3) Much of the ion-channel and metabolic pathway evidence relies on gene set enrichment, which is suggestive but not itself mechanistic; the calcium-flux assay has the main functional role.

      (4) The paper demonstrates increased RSL3 sensitivity and rescue by ferrostatin-1, but doesn't identify the specific molecular driver linking ion-channel remodeling to ferroptosis susceptibility.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Liu, He, et al. record intracranial EEG from the hippocampus and lateral temporal lobe in thirteen neurosurgical patients performing a delayed match-to-sample visual short-term memory task. They ask whether hippocampal sharp-wave ripples, well established in long-term memory consolidation, also contribute to the active maintenance of visual representations. The authors report that hippocampal ripple rates ramp up across the 7-second maintenance period, that hippocampal ripples co-occur with lateral temporal ripples, and that these coupled events coincide with above-chance category decoding in the lateral temporal lobe. These findings are interpreted within the dynamic coding framework of working memory. In this revision, the authors have been very responsive and have added ripple validation, aperiodic and high-frequency activity controls, direct interaction tests, and peak-lag analyses, which have strengthened the manuscript considerably. The study now provides solid evidence that hippocampal high-frequency activity ramps up during maintenance in a manner that scales with short-term memory success. Some of the more specific interpretations remain open: whether the effect is ripple-specific, whether it is specific to short-term memory, and whether coupled ripples link the hippocampal ramp to cortical reactivation. The work will be of considerable interest to researchers studying working memory and human ripples and opens promising directions for future studies with parametric manipulations and broader cortical coverage.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work highlights a new approach to build an array of highly stable peptide MHC-I using temperature exchange, which can be used to identify antigen specific CD8+ T cells.

      Strengths:

      In this work, the authors have proposed an alternative method to reload the peptide MHC-I molecule. Their temperature-exchange approach is distinct from current reloadable peptide MHC technologies involving photolabile peptide, empty MHC-I (Nat Commun 11, 1314 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-14862-4), tapasin/TAPBPR chaperone-assisted (eLife 7:e40126.), enzyme exchangeable (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31201791/) and small alcohol (Curr Res Immunol. 2022 Aug 18;3:167-174. doi: 10.1016/j.crimmu.2022.08.002) approaches

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The revised manuscript has improved substantially. The authors have addressed the main concerns raised during the previous round by introducing an IVT-based calibration framework, evaluating background calls across probability thresholds, examining basecalling mismatches, and replacing "stoichiometry" with the more appropriate term "predicted modification proportion." The expanded discussion of non-DRACH predictions is also useful and appropriately balanced. Overall, the study now provides a valuable practical framework for Dorado-based RNA modification analysis.

      I have only a few remaining comments, all of which should be addressable through clarification and minor textual revisions.

      (1) The comparison between NHDF and HD10.6 cells does not appear to include independent biological replicates. The observed differences in predicted m6A/A proportions should therefore be presented as differences between the two datasets rather than as general cell-type-specific effects. The interpretation is already cautious in the Discussion, but similar wording should be used in the Abstract, Results heading, and title if applicable.

      (2) The direction of the comparison in Figure 3D should be clarified. The percentages represent the fraction of GLORI sites that is also detected by Dorado. Thus, the analysis shows that Dorado increasingly recovers high-proportion GLORI sites. It does not directly demonstrate that high-proportion Dorado predictions are increasingly validated by GLORI. The text should reflect this distinction, and the figure should clearly identify which circle represents each method.

      (3) The ratio of calls detected in IVT relative to biological samples is a useful empirical measure of background, but it is not formally a false-positive rate because the true status and testability of every site are not known. A term such as "IVT-to-sample call ratio" or "empirical background-call ratio" would be more precise and would not alter the main conclusion regarding the value of stringent filtering.

      (4) The description of the change-point framework still contains the placeholder "at least X-fold more signal." The actual enrichment threshold should be provided. The authors should also ensure that a log2 ratio threshold of 1.5 is not described as 1.5-fold enrichment, since these values are not equivalent.

      These are relatively minor issues. The authors have responded constructively to the previous reviews, and I do not consider further experimental work necessary.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The manuscript is extremely clear and well written, the experimental evidence is strong and the methods are clearly described, so I do not have major issues to raise. A few minor issues are listed below. Some of these were presented in my first review but were not addressed by the authors.

      (2) In Section 3.3 the authors say that direct paths connecting Class I and Class IV behave similarly to indirect paths, despite having lower scores according to the RBM. How generic is this? Does it also happen for other classes? This might be an important point to address as direct paths are easier to sample.

      (3) The path shown in Fig.4 goes through a region of non-functionality around sequences 18-19. It seems that the sample path is basically exploring the functional regions for Class I and Class II/III separately trying to approach the other class, but then it can't really do the switch.

      By contrast the path going from Class I to Class IV seems able to perform the functional switch in a single step (20-21) without losing too much of the function.

      Perhaps the authors could better comment on this? Is this a limitation of the sampling method, or a fundamental biological fact?

      (4) On page 12 it is stated that temperature was chosen to 1/3 to maximize the score. This is important and should be mentioned earlier (I didn't notice it until that point).

      (5) On page 13 it is stated that "However, the scores of the ancestral sequences along the phylogenetic pathways assigned by the RBM are significantly lower than the ones of the RBM-designed sequences. This result is expected as ASR reconstruction does not take into account epistasis, differently from RBM, and we expect ASR sequences to generally be of lesser quality."

      I was very surprised by this result. My own experience with ASR shows that on the contrary, sequences found by ASR (via maximum likelihood) tend to have high scores in the (R)BM and tend to be more stable than extant sequences. I attribute this to the fact that ASR typically finds a "consensus" sequence that maximizes the contribution to the score coming from the fields (the profile), which is typically dominant over the epistatic signal, resulting in a bigger score. Maybe the authors did not use maximum likelihood in the ASR? Some clarification might be useful here.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The revised manuscript by Nohara et al. presents a novel 3D assay that allows for stratification of epithelia, active EMT through small pores, and active MET. They show that 3um pores allow for keratinocytes to sample the pore through filopodia and up regulate EMT genes to transverse the pores to the other side of the membrane where EMT genes are down regulated as the cells re-establish stratified epithelia. The TGFbeta pathway and actin polymerization promotes movement of cells into the pores and Piezo1 and KRT6 actively block this movement. This work provides a novel 3D assay that is likely to become a benchmark to analyze these processes using a more complex system than other current culture-specific EMT and MET assays.

      Strengths:

      The strengths of the manuscript include the foundational analysis of the pathways involved in establishing the 3-compartment epithelium. The authors have incorporated live imaging, drug studies, KO analysis, and RNA-sequencing to show the relevant pathways involved. The authors were responsive to the original round of reviews and present a much-improved study with greater details on molecular markers, quantification, and clarity.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Enhancer elements are regulatory DNA sequences that are capable of driving specific expression patterns. As these elements are generally short and context-independent, enhancers can be used in expression vectors (e.g., packaged in an adeno-associated virus, AAV) to limit expression to target cell populations. This approach was identified as a major strategy for cell-type-specific manipulation in the brain and has been pursued by both standard research studies as well as large-scale efforts led by the BRAIN Initiative. This manuscript describes a major effort to generate enhancer-AAVs targeting astrocytes and oligodendrocytes orchestrated by a large research team led by the Allen Institute for Brain Science. This manuscript parallels other recent publications describing sets of enhancer-AAVs, following rigorous, similar methods with relatively broad testing and application.

      To identify and screen candidate enhancers, the scientists prioritized candidates via analysis of single-nucleus accessibility and methylation datasets (i.e., snATAC-seq) and tested them in mice. The scientists prioritized candidate enhancers that exhibited specificity of accessibility in the target cell type. Following selection, the scientists cloned the candidate sequences into AAV vectors with a minimal promoter and reporter gene, packaged the virus, delivered it to the mouse brain, and screened for activity based on reporter expression. Candidates that passed initial screening were further characterized via imaging and sorting, followed by single-cell RNA-seq. This process had around a 50% success rate and yielded 25 astrocyte and 21 oligodendrocyte enhancer-AAVs with the targeted cell-type-specific expression patterns.

      The scientists went on to test for subtype-specific activity patterns, finding wide diversity in astrocyte activities across sub-populations and conversely, homogenous oligodendrocyte activation. They optimized a few of these via concatenating the enhancer core sequence to increase expression levels of the reporter gene and showed strong specificity and completeness of cell targeting for a set of these enhancer-AAVs. Following characterization and validation, they then deployed these enhancer-AAVs in a number of demonstration applications to show the utility for basic and translational science. All the constructs developed here are available for public use via Addgene, ensuring that these new tools can be used by other researchers.

      There really are no obvious weaknesses in the work presented here, from the generation of the enhancer-AAVs to use in sophisticated validation studies. The enhancer-AAV testing is rigorous and provides critical information necessary for other scientists to select and use these constructs. The applications demonstrate the power of enhancer-AAV approaches. The toolbox presented here may not enable specific targeting of all relevant cellular subtypes or activity states for astrocytes and oligodendrocytes, and future work will be needed to fully understand the activity of the enhancers, identity of the target cell types, and context-dependent utility of these constructs. However, the set of enhancer-AAVs developed here should be transformative for researchers working on accessing and manipulating these cell types and have a major impact on the field.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study aims to assess the drivers of the interspecific distribution of transposable elements (TEs), using genomes from the Sauropsids clade. In particular, the authors test the mutational hazard hypothesis (MHH), which stipulates that slightly deleterious TEs should preferentially accumulate in populations with smaller population sizes, where purifying selection is weaker.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript is clearly written, and the underlying concepts (MHH, Simpson's paradox) are well introduced and discussed. In that respect, the manuscript is highly didactic and an enjoyable read. The authors employ state-of-the-art phylogeny-aware statistical procedures, including structural equation modeling to infer causal relationships. The results are of high interest: the authors report that correlations between TE frequencies and proxies of population size (life-history traits - such as body mass, and molecular traits - such as the dN/dS ratio), which appear at large evolutionary scales, disappear when within-clade relationships are examined. The authors discuss these results and propose that at shorter time scales, clade- and TE family-specific bursts dominate the dynamics of TE dynamics.

      Weaknesses:

      While I generally agree with the authors' interpretation and find these results of great interest, I have several concerns about the underlying statistical analyses and think that some possible alternative explanations of a methodological nature should be checked to confirm the results.

      (1) Three types of statistical analyses are employed: Pearson correlation coefficient, phylogenetic generalised least-squares (PGLS), and structural equation modelling (SEM). Both the Pearson correlation test and the PGLS assume normality (binormality in the case of Pearson's correlation) and linearity (and this is very likely the case for SEM as well, although it depends on the exact method employed). Deviation from these hypotheses can create erroneous P-value computations (in both directions). I could not find any assessment of how well the data fit these hypotheses in the manuscript; differences in significance could reflect differences in how the data fulfil these assumptions across time scales. Figure 2a suggests at least a deviation from normality, be it because of the Aves clade alone. A non-parametric correlation (such as Kendall's tau) should be used instead of Pearson's correlation, as it assumes neither normality nor linearity. The PGLS analysis is trickier in that respect: the authors should check the normality and independence of the model residuals (and likely homoscedasticity too, unless the underlying model allows for lineage-specific variance). An alternative would be to transform the variables using phylogenetic independent contrasts (PIC, which still assumes a Brownian model - as does the PGLS) and use a non-parametric correlation on the resulting PICs. I don't have expertise in SEM, but a quick search suggests that non-parametric (or at least non-linear) SEM implementations are available.

      (2) The positive correlation (l208, l299) with generation time should be further commented on, as it has the opposite direction as expected. Following the proposed rationale, species with shorter generation times should have more TEs, shouldn't they? Unless "generation time" here actually refers to the number of generations per year, instead of the duration of a generation, as the text suggests?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Negreira et al. present an application of a novel single-cell genomics approach to investigate the genetic heterogeneity of Leishmania parasites. Leishmania, while also representing a major global disease with hundreds of thousands of cases annually, serves as a model to test the rigor of the sequencing strategy. Its complex karyotypic nature necessitates a method that is capable of resolving natural variation to better understand genome dynamics. Importantly, an earlier single-cell genomics platform (10x Chromium) is no longer available, and new methods need to be evaluated to fill in this gap.

      The study was designed to evaluate whether a capsule-based cell capture method combined with primary template-directed amplification (PTA) could maintain levels of genomic heterogeneity represented in an equal mixture of two Leishmania strains. This was a high bar, given the relatively small protozoan genome and prior studies that showed limitations of single-cell genomics, especially for gene-level copy number changes. Overall, the study found that semi-permeable capsules (SPC) are an effective way to isolate high-quality single cells. Additionally, short reads from amplified genomes effectively maintained the relative levels of variation in the two strains on the chromosome, gene copy, and individual base level. Thus, this method will be useful to evaluate adaptive strategies of Leishmania. Many researchers will also refer to these studies to set up SPC collection and PTA methods for their organism of choice.

      Strengths:

      (1) The use of SPC and PTA in a non-bacterial organism is novel. The study displays the utility of these methods to isolate and amplify single genomes to a level that can be sequenced, despite being a motile organism with a GC-rich genome.

      (2) The authors clearly outlined their optimization strategy and provided numerous quality-control metrics that inspire confidence in the success of achieving even chromosomal coverage relative to ploidy.

      (3) The use of two distinct Leishmania strains with known clonal status provided strong evidence that PTA-based amplification could reflect genome differences and displayed the utility of the method for studies of rare genotypes.

      (4) Evaluating the SPCs pre- and post-amplification with microscopy is a practical and robust way of determining the success of SPC formation and PTA.

      (5) The authors show that the PTA-based approach easily resolved major genotypic ploidy in agreement with a prior 10x Chromium-based study. The new method had improved resolution of drug resistance genotypes in the form of both copy-number variations and single-nucleotide polymorphisms.

      (6) In general, the authors are very thorough in describing the methods, including those used to optimize PTA lysis and amplification steps (fresh vs frozen cells, naked DNA vs sorted cells, etc). This demonstrates a depth of knowledge about the procedure and leaves few unanswered questions.

      (7) The custom, multifaceted, computational assessment of coverage evenness is a major strength of the study and demonstrates that the authors acknowledge potential computational factors that could impact the analysis.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, Hossaim and colleagues investigate the role of the ITK kinase in modulating inflammation in a pristane-induced lung hemorrhage model. Using a germline ITK KO mouse, they report that loss of ITK skews the T cell compartment toward a memory-like state, expanding Tregs, and conferring protection against alveolar hemorrhage, inflammatory monocyte recruitment, proteinuria, and systemic cytokine elevation. They further show that transfer of ITK-deficient Tregs into wild-type hosts with established disease attenuates injury and shifts the cytokine balance toward resolution, and that ITK-deficient Tregs carry a transcriptional signature enriched for OXPHOS, mTORC1, MYC, and cell-cycle programs. While these observations are interesting for the development of potential immunotherapies, there are several issues with the methodological approach that support the authors' claims, tempering my enthusiasm for this manuscript.

      Strengths:

      (1) The clinical motivation and potential targeted therapies are relevant.

      (2) The murine phenotype seems robust.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed my comments appropriately.

    1. De novo and inherited dominant variants in U4 and U6 snRNA genes cause retinitis pigmentosa

      PMID: 41513982

      Gene: RNU4-2

      HGNC: 10193

      Disease: inherited retinal dystrophy

      MONDO: 0019118

      InheritancePattern: autosomal dominant

      Prevalence: The prevelance of retinitis pigmentosa in general is between 1 in 750 and 1 in 9,000 individuals (PMID: 37108642). The proportion of those cases caused by RNU4-2 variants is not well known.

      Penetrance: Penetrance appears to be incomplete, with family pedigrees including apparently unaffected carriers.

    1. 1 Partial deletion Deletion of exon 1 and 2 1 0

      GroupID: 1

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      Group size: 1

      GroupNumberMales: N/A

      GroupNumberFemales: N/A

      GroupEthnicity: N/A

      GroupAgeRange: N/A

      Group Info: Retrospective analysis of a longitudinal cohort of 21 VHL germline mutation carriers and retinal haemangioblastomas. All patients were categorized in two genotypic categories: missense mutations and truncating mutations. 

      GroupPresentingHPOs: HP:0009711 (retinal capillary hemangioma)

      GroupHPOFreeText: The patient presented with retinal capillary hemangioma.

      GroupNotHPOs: N/A

      GroupNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      GroupPreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: Table S1

      Variant: Exon 1-2 deletion

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: Chr3(GRCh37): g.10182301_10188764del; c.-1231_463+444del6464

      MutationType: exon_loss_deletion

      CivicName: Exon 1-2 deletion

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors tackle the question of whether conceptual absence is neurally encoded in the same way as perceptual absence. On one hand, the neural bases of perceptual absence have been largely investigated, as exemplified by the study of neural correlates of perception of aware vs. unaware stimuli, and on the other hand, the overlapping neural encoding of symbolic ('0') and non-symbolic (number of dots) formats of numerical absence has been previously established (Barnett & Fleming, 2024). However, the direct comparison of neural representations between numerical and perceptual absences remained to be investigated.

      This article fills this gap by designing a Magneto-EncephaloGraphy (MEG) study using multi-voxel pattern analysis (MVPA) and temporal generalization to probe the similarity of neural patterns across the representation of perceptual absence (lack of stimuli), symbolic ('0'), and non-symbolic (number of dots) formats of numerical absence. They confirmed previously obtained evidence for shared neural representation across both formats of numerical absence. They report evidence for an absence of shared representation between both formats of numerical absence on one hand and perceptual absence on the other hand, while controlling for the confounding effect of low-level visual features. Their results overall support the conclusion that conceptual and perceptual absence are neurally encoded in a distinct way and speak in favour of a boundary between the representation of the concepts and the percept of absence.

      Major strengths:

      (1) Behavioral and neuroimaging results convincingly demonstrate that neural encoding of symbolic and non-symbolic absences is shared and situated on a graded, abstract neural number line, replicating previous results, notably from the authors themselves (Barnett & Fleming, 2024).

      (2) They show that neural encoding of perceptual and numerical absence do not generalise across each other, while controlling for spurious confounds due to visual stimuli that are commonly shared in the cases of non-symbolic numerical absence and perceptual absences.

      (3) They adequately use Bayesian analysis to distinguish absence of evidence vs. evidence of absence to support their claim.

      (4) The interpretation of numerical absence as a representation of the concept of "nothingness" is adequate, although it might be further discussed by distinguishing the concept of "zero" on a number line from the concept of nothingness and that of an empty set (Nieder, 2016).

      (5) The discussion about development and metacognition paves an interesting road for further investigation on the acquisition of the concept of zero, especially in light of debates on the progressive development of metacognitive abilities in children (Goupil & Kouider, 2019).

      (6) Data and code are published with open-source access, allowing the community to further investigate the points as major weaknesses evoked below, if desired.

      Comments on revised version.

      I appreciated the authors' responses as they provided important additions to their discussion and supplementary information.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors document that GM-CSF prevents the loss of ILC3 populations and inhibits pro-inflammatory cytokine production during gut inflammation. They combine a preclinical model of gut inflammation in zebrafish with spatial transcriptomic analysis of samples from Crohn's disease patients. The data show that GM-CSF ameliorates gut inflammation by (1) curtailing the differentiation of disease-associated ILC1 and (2) by "boosting" the tissue repair function of ILC3.

      The topic of the manuscript is interesting and highly relevant to the question of how intestinal inflammation is initiated or perpetuated. However, there are some limitations. Specifically, it remains unclear through which distinct molecular programs macrophages maintain "beneficial" ILC3 and how they prevent the differentiation or expansion of disease-associated ILC1. Based on previous data, these processes may be interconnected as ILC3 show remarkable plasticity and can convert into ILC1-like cells ("ex-ILC3").

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work presents a valuable resource by generating a comprehensive bulk RNA sequencing catalogue of gene expression in the mouse duodenum and ileum during the first postnatal month. The central findings of this work are based on analysis of this dataset. Specifically, the authors characterized molecular shifts that occur as the intestine matures from an immature to an adult-like state, investigating both temporal changes and regional differences between the proximal and distal small intestine. They also sought to validate key findings through complementary methods and to provide comparative context with human intestinal samples derived from premature infants. This study will provide a solid reference dataset for the community of researchers studying postnatal gastrointestinal development and diseases that arise during these stages. However, the study lacks in functional validation of the interpretations.

      Strengths:

      (1) The inclusion of numerous time points (day 0 through 4 weeks) and comparative analyses throughout the first postnatal month.

      (2) Validation of key interpretations of RNA-seq data by other methods

      (3) Linking mouse postnatal development to human premature infant development, enhancing its clinical relevance. The inclusion of human intestinal biopsy and organoid data for comparison further strengthens this link.

      (4) The investigation covers a wide array of developmental gene categories with known significance, including epithelial differentiation markers (e.g., Vil1, Muc2, Lyz1), intestinal stem cell markers (e.g., Lgr5, Olfm4, Ascl2), mesenchymal markers (e.g., Pdgfra, Vim), Wnt signaling components (e.g., Wnt3, Wnt5a, Ctnnb1), and various immune genes (e.g., defensins, T cell, B cell, ILC, macrophage markers).

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The primary limitation is that there is no functional validation. The study primarily focuses on interpretation of RNA expression. This is a common limitation of transcriptomic "atlas" studies, but the functional and mechanistic relevance of these interpretations remains to be determined.

      (2) The data are derived from bulk RNA-Seq of full-thickness intestinal tissue. While this approach helps capture rare cell types and both epithelial and mesenchymal components simultaneously, it does not provide cell-type specific gene expression profiles, which might obscure important nuances. Future investigations using single-cell sequencing would be a logical follow-up.

      (3) The day 4 samples were omitted due to quality issues, which might have led to missing some dynamic changes, especially given that some ISC genes show dynamic changes around day 6.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is a technically sophisticated effort to visualize the nanoscale organization of native surface AMPA receptors in adult mouse brain. The authors combine chemical labeling of endogenous AMPARs with 3D, 2-color super-resolution microscopy. They use this to compare hippocampal and cortical AMPAR organization and to characterize changes in a P301S mutant mouse tauopathy model. The authors report a greater density of surface AMPAR localizations in hippocampal CA1 than in two examined cortical regions, as well as a smaller fraction of AMPARs organized in synaptic clusters. They report that PS19 tauopathy is associated with reduced hippocampal AMPAR localization density, a relative depletion of the population classified as extrasynaptic, and reduced organization of receptors within synaptic nanodomains.

      Strengths:

      The methodological contribution is substantial. The authors developed a valuable set of methods for examining endogenous surface AMPAR organization in brain tissue. The imaging methodology could be useful across many questions in synaptic neuroscience.

      Weaknesses:

      While the biological observations are interesting, several aspects of the neuroscience interpretation require clarification, and some of the biological conclusions should be weakened unless the measurements can better justify them. I provide several comments intended to strengthen this interesting manuscript.

      (1) The authors measure fluorescent localization counts but often interpret these as AMPAR numbers. I believe that individual fluorophores can generate multiple localizations and that labeling efficiency can vary, challenging their frequent interpretation as AMPAR numbers. Importantly, AMPARs are tetrameric complexes with potentially different subunit compositions, so one AMPAR could be observed as 0-4 fluorescent localizations. The uncertainty is particularly important for comparisons of AMPAR abundance per cluster and nanodomain. The authors should consistently distinguish localization density from receptor number and clarify which conclusions depend on assumptions about labeling and the assumptions of photophysical equivalence between experimental conditions. The paper would be more rigorous and the claims more legitimate if the authors were disciplined throughout about using empirical descriptors instead of interpretations.

      (2) The distinction between synaptic and extrasynaptic receptors is central to the manuscript. The authors identify synaptic receptors either through density-based clustering or proximity to PSD-95 clusters. However, neither measure directly establishes anatomical synaptic localization. This is particularly consequential because only ~1/3 of morphologically identified YFP-positive spines contain PSD-95 clusters that meet the detection criteria. It seems to me that AMPARs associated with weakly-labeled or undetected synapses could then be erroneously classified as extrasynaptic. PSD-95 detection should be assessed across regions and genotypes, and a sensitivity analysis undertaken to ensure that the conclusions are robust to the choices of clustering and distance thresholds.

      (3) The authors suggest that the larger extrasynaptic AMPAR population in the hippocampus provides a reserve for rapid synaptic recruitment and that its reduction in tauopathy constrains plasticity. This is plausible, but receptor abundance does not establish receptor mobility or availability for synaptic capture. The importance of AMPAR surface diffusion for hippocampal LTP and contextual learning has been demonstrated (see Penn et al., Nature, 2017), but the current study does not measure diffusion or receptor exchange. The authors should temper their interpretation and explain the caveats.

      (4) The authors infer that there has been a preferential extrasynaptic AMPAR loss from the reduced total AMPAR localization density and the increased synaptic fraction they measured. Because both synaptic and extrasynaptic populations could decrease even when the synaptic fraction increases, they should calculate the synaptic and extrasynaptic localization densities separately for each mouse. This would clarify the magnitude and selectivity of the changes that they report and help to reconcile the potentially contradictory increased synaptic fraction with reduced AMPAR localization density within synaptic clusters and nanodomains.

      (5) The authors adjust DBSCAN parameters for PS19 hippocampus in response to reduced overall localization density. Because the resulting clustering measurements are themselves used to establish genotype differences, it is important to demonstrate that the conclusions are robust to parameter selection. Analyses using identical parameter sets across conditions, together with simulations in which WT localization patterns are subsampled to match PS19 localization density, would help determine whether the reported changes reflect biological reorganization rather than density-dependent detection effects. Similar validation is important for the nanodomain analysis. I found that, in general, the authors should have made a greater effort to ensure that their measurements are robust to the parameter choices.

      (6) CA1 comparisons with motor/somatosensory cortex require more precise anatomical characterization. What cortical layers and hippocampal dendritic compartments are being compared? These are not homogeneous structures in almost any regard. AMPAR or, more empirically, fluorescence localization density per imaging field is not necessarily equivalent to AMPAR density per dendritic membrane area or per synapse. Differences in neuropil composition, spine density, and synapse density could contribute to the observed differences when there is, in fact, no AMPAR density per dendritic membrane area. Proper anatomical normalization or a stricter comparison of equivalent neuronal compartments would strengthen the interpretation. I believe that the authors are aware of the issue, as they did an analysis along a single dendrite, but this has to be done more thoroughly for them to justify the conclusions they assert.

      (7) The main comparisons involve three mice per group, and the authors correctly analyze mouse-level averages. Nonetheless, the small number of biological replicates limits the strength of the conclusions about regional specificity and disease effects. The test statistics and degrees of freedom, not just the p-values, should be presented. In addition, effect sizes and individual mouse values should be presented. The absence of a statistically significant cortical effect does not establish that cortex is unaffected. There could be genotype-by-region interactions, which the authors should check.

      (8) The authors describe that 6-mo PS19 mice precede neurodegeneration and they assert that the observed AMPAR-associated changes relate to the onset of synaptic dysfunction. However, Yoshiyama et al., Neuron, 2007 demonstrate hippocampal synapse loss and impaired synaptic function at three months in PS19 mice, before detecting fibrillary tau. The present observations likely occur after synaptic pathology in thePS19 mice. The authors should distinguish structural correlates of established dysfunction from the mechanisms that may have initiated that dysfunction. More importantly, the assertion that neuronal or synaptic anatomy is preserved in the PS19 mice should be supported by appropriate measurements.

      (9) The reduction of the AMPAR nanodomain organization is potentially important. However, the authors do not measure presynaptic release sites or trans-synaptic alignment. To be rigorous, the data establish altered postsynaptic receptor organization but do not demonstrate disruption of trans-synaptic nanocolumns or establish the functional consequences for quantal transmission. If the authors do not provide evidence for these claims they should not make them and make it clear these are (reasonable) speculations for which they did not collect the data.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript investigates whether transglutaminase 2 (TG2) released from intestinal epithelial cells (IECs) can trigger anti-TG2 autoantibody production by activating TG2-specific B cells that recognize the TG2-gluten complex, with assistance from gluten-specific T cells.

      Strengths:

      The main study is well designed and mechanistically important, providing direct evidence for a longstanding hypothesis in celiac disease pathogenesis. The mouse model, which uses an inducible TG2 fusion to a deamidated gluten peptide sequence (TG2-DGP fusion) in IECs, is elegant and directly tests a mechanism that could previously only be inferred indirectly. The Sollid group previously showed TG2 is present in the gut lumen (Meling et al., 2024) and can facilitate B-T cell collaboration in vitro (Iversen et al., 2020). This paper closes the loop by showing IEC-restricted TG2-DGP expression drives autoantibody formation in vivo. The experiments include appropriate controls, including the use of a Tgm2-/- B cell donor to avoid confounding by TG2 shed during cell isolation. The paper also shows that B cell expansion occurs in Peyer's patches (PP), whereas class-switching involves mesenteric lymph nodes (MLN).

      Weaknesses:

      Some suggestions for revision:

      (1) Physiological relevance of antigen dose and kinetics. The dox-induced pulse of TG2-DGP expression is a bolus-like event, whereas endogenous IEC shedding and TG2 release presumably occur continuously at low levels. The author should discuss more how the kinetics and magnitude of the induced signal compare with estimated physiological TG2 derived from IEC turnover, and whether the strong immunogenicity observed here could overstate the potency of the natural process.

      (2) The translational value of the model may hinge on epitope relevance. Celiac anti-TG2 antibodies preferentially target a small number of conformational epitopes on open TG2, and this restriction is tied to how TG2 is captured and presented. A central claim of the paper is that IEC-derived TG2 is the relevant source for autoantibody elicitation, rather than extracellular matrix-associated TG2 or other pools. If IEC-derived TG2 only activates non-human-relevant epitopes, that would undermine the claim that this is the mechanism responsible for the actual patient autoantibody repertoire. Whether IEC-derived TG2-DGP would recruit a broader range of TG2 epitopes seen in human disease, or only the subset compatible with this conformational epitope, is worth examining.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study examines how genes involved in cellular recycling (autophagy) influence lifespan under different experimental conditions. The findings help clarify why previous studies have reported conflicting results about whether blocking autophagy shortens or extends lifespan. The work will be of interest to researchers studying aging and cellular stress responses, particularly those using model organisms.

      Strengths:

      The findings are valuable, as they help resolve inconsistencies within a specific subfield of aging research. The evidence presented is solid, as the data broadly support the primary claims of the study. In addition, the discussion is thorough and thoughtfully integrates the findings within the broader context of the field.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this MEG study, the authors assess the oscillatory dynamics of object naming in 27 participants. The authors observed two distinct theta-coupled networks: a ventral occipito-temporal network linked to object recognition and a medial fronto-temporal network linked to lexico-semantic retrieval. Moreover, when contrasting object naming to a scrambled image control task, they observed increased theta-gamma phase amplitude coupling in the LIFG and fusiform gyrus. The authors conclude that theta-coupling ensures the binding of recognition and retrieval processes in object naming, while the theta-gamma phase amplitude coupling ensures local computations within those networks.

      Strengths:

      Addressing the question 'which oscillatory dynamics govern speech planning' is interesting and timely, since not much empirical evidence on this topic is currently available. Whole-brain MEG assessing phase and phase-amplitude coupling for object naming are not commonly attempted, and the study boosts a lot of power. Furthermore, the writing is concise and clear, making the paper easy to follow and pleasant to read.

      Weaknesses:

      My overall assessment is that the claims and conclusions of this study are stronger than the evidence supports, and this is because of several design weaknesses which I will detail below. Moreover, this study gives too one-sided a perspective on the current state-of-the-art in the neurophysiology of speech planning/object naming, and the presented conclusions can solely be understood from that narrow theoretical perspective.

      (1) One of my bigger concerns is the lack of any language-related manipulations that allows to independently isolate the processing components the authors discuss. Object naming (speech planning) is a complex, multifaceted mental operation where different representations and processing levels can overlap in time and space (e.g., Indefrey, 2011; Hickok, 2012; Dell et al., 2013; Munding et al., 2016; Strijkers & Costa, 2016; Nozari & Pinet, 2020; De Zubicaray, 2023; Pickering & Strijkers, 2025). Without attempting to isolate those specific representations and/or processes and solely looking at object naming in general, the only manner to interpret the data is by relying on a priori defined and often one-to-one mappings of space and function in light of a specific theoretical perspective. This is indeed what the authors do in the current study, by linking certain brain regions they observe (e.g., more occipital for object recognition and more fronto-temporal for lexico-semantics) to the function assigned in dual-route models (note also that the authors rely on the dual-route models of comprehension, not production per se; see below). While doing so is of course legitimate, it does strongly reduce the impact of the results since they do not concern a direct empirical demonstration of the authors' conclusions, but an indirect inference based on a single theoretical framework. To give a few examples of how this weakens the conclusions: How do the authors know the fronto-temporal network is lexico-semantic and not phonological, as many other models would pose (e.g., Indefrey & Level, 2004; 2011; Hickok, 2012; 2014; De Zubicaray, 2023)? Similarly, theta-coupling in production is not uniquely related to lexico-semantics, but could also be linked to the syllabic rate (speech rate; e.g., Giraud & Poeppel, 2012; Meyer, 2018), or to working memory in production (e.g., Piai & Zheng, 2019). The occipito-temporal network may be involved in object recognition, but it may also reflect (embodied) word semantics, in particular for imageable objects as in the current study (e.g., Strijkers & Costa, 2016; Pulvermuller, 2018). In my opinion, given the lack of independent manipulations, these (and other) alternative conclusions are equally plausible, and the authors' interpretations of the data pattern are tentative at best; this is a substantial limitation in my view.

      (2) The authors may object that they do have a contrast, namely the control condition. However, the control condition and the object naming condition differ in so many crucial aspects that it does not serve as a reliable control to address the above issues with interpretational strength. The control condition solely deals with low-level visual input, but not with conceptual and language-related processing, nor with motor preparation and articulation (since repeatedly saying 'no' is a flawed control for the more complex and variable naming responses required in object naming).

      (3) Moreover, the timings between the control and object naming conditions are confounded: Naming and control RTs differ by 270 ms. The 1 s pre-response window therefore spans 0.08 to 1.08 s post-stimulus in naming, but −0.19 to +0.81 s in control. Hence, part of the contrast may rather reflect 'when' something was measured rather than 'what' processing differences it is supposed to reflect.

      (4) As far as I can tell, the authors did not assess potential pre-articulation motor confounds in the data via ICA and/or recorded EMG activity (e.g., Vos et al., 2010; Porcaro et al., 2015; Strijkers et al., 2017; Abbasi et al., 2021). This may be relevant since motor preparatory activity is known to emerge well before actual articulation (e.g., Ries et al., 2013), and may (pre-)track articulatory speech rate in the theta range (e.g., Abbasi et al., 2023).

      (5) Why are items not modelled as random intercepts/slopes? With 200 different stimuli, item variability seems relevant to include in the statistical models.

      (6) I found that the authors gave a very restricted and not up-to-date literature overview on the neural basis of object naming. They mainly consider a dual route architecture. I understand that the authors don't wish (nor have to) give a complete overview of the different neurobiological models of object naming. However, the dual route model they cite is the speech processing and comprehension model (e.g., Hickok & Poeppel, 2004; 2007), which has no clear link to object naming, and they don't mention the production versions of a dual route architecture (e.g., Ueno et al., 2011; Hickok, 2012). Moreover, as mentioned also in comment 1, several other critical models (and more relevant for object naming specifically) are neglected: classical sequential object naming models (e.g., Indefrey & Levelt, 2004; Indefrey, 2011; Roelofs, 2014), interactive models (e.g., Dell et al., 2013; Dell & Chang, 2014), or more recent parallel models (e.g., Strijkers & Costa, 2016; Pickering & Costa, 2025) (for recent reviews see: e.g., Nozari & Pinet, 2020; Kerr et al., 2023; de Zubicaray, 2023). If the authors prefer to solely focus on a single class of models, that's fine (though a model that is more tightly linked to object naming would have been more relevant), but that limited scope should at the very least be acknowledged.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this study, the authors investigate luminal architectural reorganization during embryo implantation. Using 3D histological reconstruction, single-cell RNA sequencing, spatial transcriptomics, and genetic mouse models, the authors the uterine luminal epithelium undergoes rapid morphogenetic remodeling during the implantation. They further propose that a stress-responsive p38α signaling program coordinates epithelial remodeling and epithelial-stromal communication to establish an implantation-competent uterine lumen.

      Strengths:

      This study clearly described the changes of luminal architecture during implantation. Moreover, they also used integration of multiple advanced techniques, including 3D tissue reconstruction, single-cell transcriptomics, spatial transcriptomics, and genetic mouse models, which together provide a detailed description of the molecular characters of the uterine architecture during implantation.

      Weaknesses:

      The principal knockout model uses Pgr-Cre, which deletes p38α in both epithelial and stromal compartments. Importantly, they also added epithelial-specific knockout (Ltf-Cre) demonstrates that epithelial deletion alone produces only mild abnormalities and does not recapitulate the severe implantation phenotype observed in the uterine knockout. These data suggest that the critical function of p38α likely resides in stromal cells or in epithelial-stromal interactions. Consequently, the manuscript's title and central conclusion currently a little bit overstate epithelial regulation.

      The data of this study are now support the main conclusions.

      Impact of the work on the field:

      This work will likely become an important resource for researchers studying embryo implantation because it provides a detailed atlas of peri-implantation uterine morphology integrated with spatial and single-cell transcriptomic datasets. The imaging methodology and quantitative description of luminal remodeling are likely to be widely useful.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Rezaei et al. determined the cryo-electron microscopy structure of human ABCG5/8 in complex with ergosterol, revealing a conserved sterol-binding site at the transmembrane domain (TMD) interface, signifying the role of a specific key residue, Y432, in the interaction. ATPase assays showed the effective stimulation of ATPase activity of ABCG5/8 in the presence of ergosterol than cholesterol and CHS. The role of Y432 in the interaction with the transporter and stimulation of its ATPase activity was further supported by a mutagenesis study.

      Strengths:

      The study has been supported well with the structural and biochemical data combined with molecular dynamics simulations. The methods are very well detailed, which is helpful for the reader.

      Weaknesses:

      A few more experiments along similar lines (structures and mutagenesis and ATPase experiments) would have strengthened the molecular mechanism of sterol transport. Also, the physiological relevance of this sterol-ABCG5/8 structure has not been elaborated or connected via any experiments.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors developed a reinforcement learning framework to identify stimulation patterns that produce a predefined activity pattern in neuronal networks cultured on a microelectrode array. The main contribution of this study lies in the development and validation of the experimental framework, rather than in providing new insight into neuronal response properties or the biological mechanisms underlying network activity.

      A major strength of the work is that the framework is implemented using open-source software. Electrical stimulation through microelectrode arrays is already widely used, and the proposed approach is therefore likely to be of interest to researchers seeking to automate the exploration and optimization of stimulation parameters. The authors also provide the software, hardware configuration, and experimental data, which substantially improves transparency and should facilitate reproduction and further development of the system by other laboratories.

      The experiments provide a useful proof of concept showing that the framework can search for stimulation patterns associated with the predefined task in the tested neuronal network. The evidence is solid for demonstrating the feasibility of the approach within this specific experimental configuration. In particular, the closed-loop integration of stimulation, recording, evaluation of the neuronal response, and subsequent selection of stimulation patterns is clearly implemented and experimentally tested.

      An important limitation is that the framework was evaluated using a relatively small and highly structured network. Four stimulation electrodes were positioned around a single network, and stimulation was delivered to microchannels in which axons were concentrated. This configuration is well suited to the initial demonstration, but it remains uncertain whether the same approach will perform similarly in conventional monolayer dissociated cultures, larger networks, or systems with different numbers and spatial arrangements of electrodes. Additional validation across a broader range of network structures and experimental configurations would therefore be needed to establish the general applicability of the framework.

      Overall, this study presents a valuable and reproducible methodological framework for the closed-loop optimization of electrical stimulation in cultured neuronal networks. Its likely impact lies primarily in providing an accessible experimental and computational platform that can be adapted for studies requiring systematic exploration of stimulation patterns, although the extent to which the current findings generalize beyond the tested network configuration remains to be determined.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors build on previous work demonstrating that the microtubule-associated protein CKAP2 functions at the mitotic spindle to regulate microtubule dynamics for proper chromosome segregation. Here they show that CKAP2 and its paralog CKAP2L also function at the cilium to regulate cilium formation and Hedgehog signaling.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the manuscript is the use of GFP-CKAP2 knockin cells and the examination of single and double CKAP2 and CKAP2L knockout cells. The authors use live imaging of the knockin cells to show that CKAP2 localizes to the primary cilium of RPE1 cells after assembly.

      The authors use the knockout cells to show that loss of either CKAP2 or CKAP2L results in longer cilia and a dampened Hedgehog response, whereas loss of both CKAP2 and CKAP2L results in shorter cilia and an even more dampened Hedgehog response.

      Weaknesses:

      The data are compelling and support the conclusions. However, the findings would be significantly strengthened by using additional markers of the cilium, not just acetylated tubulin.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors report on how a prion protein originating in yeast inside the gut interacts with a host insect's physiology to influence organismal traits important to fitness. Other recent studies have strongly found that interactions between gut yeasts and their Drosophila hosts are important to feeding behaviour, growth performance, and cold tolerance. They even point to the gut-brain axis. The authors extended from this work, combining screening approaches, genome-wide association studies, and forward genetics to determine that octopamine and serotonin signalling are important to these effects.

      Strengths:

      The data represent a valuable addition to the literature. There is a growing appreciation that host-microbiome interactions are important to animal performance and fitness, and this work provides strong evidence for a causal role of a prion protein in such a relationship. The high-throughput screening approaches and sequencing were, to the best of my knowledge, completed correctly. The idea that prion proteins could influence host physiology in beneficial ways is compelling, and the authors have done a great job of walking the reader through their reasoning and the multiple lines of evidence that support their reasoning.

      Weaknesses:

      While this is an interesting topic that is worthy of investigation, and identifying a causal role for a prion protein in host effects is a significant advance, other aspects of the novelty of the work are strongly overstated. No clear justification is provided for why cold tolerance was a particular trait of interest in the present study. Yet, a recent publication in the Journal of Experimental Biology clearly demonstrated a role of gut yeasts in Drosophila cold tolerance and is not cited or otherwise acknowledged [see: Jiménez-Padilla and Sinclair. Gut yeasts accelerate chill coma recovery in Drosophila melanogaster. J Exp Biol (2026) 229 (9): jeb251533]. I trust this is an oversight and will be corrected. Integrating this knowledge into the narrative of the paper would strongly improve the reasoning for this study.

      The authors rely on a review of chill coma mechanisms from 2011 as their primary source of information for interpreting their results in relation to insect cold tolerance. A great deal of work has been done by several research groups on the physiology of cold tolerance in chill-susceptible insects in the past 15 years, much of which has relied on Drosophila as a model system. I think this is important and could inform the conclusions being reached and future work that extends from this work. For example, it is now well established that the renal system is centrally important to insect cold tolerance, including chill coma recovery phenotypes, but this is not being acknowledged or integrated into the narrative here and should be. Many of the mechanisms of interest highlighted in the present work are also directly relevant to other ionoregulatory epithelia beyond nervous tissue, and global knockdowns using the UAS/Gal4 approach will impact all tissues in which these genes are expressed. Figure 2D shows how these genes are enriched in the CNS, but also the midgut and Malpighian tubules, two ionoregulatory organs of import to cold tolerance.

      The method the authors used to assess cold tolerance is not typically preferred by researchers who commonly study these phenotypes. Holding flies continuously at 4-6{degree sign}C and assessing whether or not they remain active is a reasonable approach, and I am confident that the differences observed among groups are real. However, chill coma onset and recovery are thought to be mediated by a complex combination of temperature effects on nervous, muscle, and renal function, and this assay method may conflate chill coma resistance with the capacity for chill coma recovery. This means variation in this assay could arise from differences in initial CTmin, plasticity in CTmin induced by RCH before chill coma is induced, or plasticity in neurumuscular/renal function that allows for recovery during the assay. I say this in part because Drosophila are documented to enter chill coma and then recover while the assay is ongoing, particularly around temperatures close to the CTmin [see: MacMillan et al., The capacity to maintain ion and water homeostasis underlies interspecific variation in Drosophila cold tolerance. Sci. Rep. 5:18607]. Therefore, flies active after 2 hours may never have entered chill coma, or may have entered and then recovered. Serotonin and octopamine signalling may be critical to one or both of these possibilities, and maybe in different ways, especially because these hormones play critically important roles in both renal and nervous function.

      Infectious prions are known to cross gut epithelia and the Drosophila gut is known to take up large organic molecules via endocytosis and exocytosis, so I am not entirely convinced that the effects observed necessarily result through the gut-brain axis. Future studies could be focused on observing whether these prion proteins remain in the gut, or act directly on other tissues via the hemolymph.

      The CAFÉ assay used in the study is a tried and true way to measure feeding behaviour in Drosophila. The data in Figure 1H look like a single measurement per individual, unless they have been modified for presentation. From the text provided, it is not clear to me how the authors accounted for changes in feeding behaviour at different times of day. Feeding behaviour is regulated by the circadian rhythm in digestive tissues. If activity is enhanced at night, as in the present study, are MRPL10+ flies also feeding during the night more than the WT flies?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The author uses multinomial logistic regression to assign fitness values to SARS-CoV-2 and Influenza H3N2 clades. The mean population fitness, referred to as the cumulative fitness flux, is tracked throughout evolution to describe the rate of adaptation. The author shows a clear decrease in the rate of adaptation for SARS-CoV-2 after mid 2022, coinciding with the emergence of the Omicron clades; the rate of adaptation of H3N2 is much slower, but inferred to be constant in time. With this analysis, the author confirms Fisher's fundamental theorem of natural selection. Using a fine-grained clade definition scheme, the author attributes changes in fitness to substitutions in different genomic regions, highlighting the importance of the spike and, in particular, the RBD region of spike. A fitness model based on a multinomial regression is shown to perform better than EvEscape and protein-language-model semanticity to predict changes in fitness.

      Strengths:

      The author provides an interactive reading experience on the github.io hosted website, which has additional interactivity with figures and offers simple manipulation of what is shown. The methods are well explained and are easy to follow. The conclusions of the study- the decrease in the rate of adaptation of SARS-CoV-2, mutations in Spike S1 as the main driver of evolution, and the Spike S1 mutational count as predictor of fitness change - are clear to follow.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The main conclusions that (i) the rate of adaptation of SARS-CoV-2 has decreased after Jun 2022 and is lower than in Influenza H3N2 and (ii) that mutations in Spike S1 are the main drivers of evolution are not novel.

      (2) At the core, the multinomial logistic regression assumes a time-independent fitness value for each viral clade, while the clade fitness is not constant and depends on the population immunity, which will change over time. As a result, the fitness increase can be wrongly interpreted: The author observes a doubling of the mean fitness every 6 months from Jan 2021 to Jun 2022, and every 2.4 years from July 2022 to Dec 2025. We would then expect that the mean fitness in Dec 2025, \bar{f}_t, has increased more than 2 to the power 4, as compared to the mean fitness in Jan 2021, \bar{f}_0 (\bar{f}_t > 2^{4} \bar{f}_0). Is the mean viral fitness in Dec 2025 more than 16 times higher than in Jan 2021? Fitness differences between viral populations at different times cannot be meaningfully compared because the fitness landscape is time-dependent. The increase in fitness, without accounting for the change in population immunity, is in part an artifact of the multinomial regression.

      (3) The multinomial regression treats the fitness landscape on which the virus evolves as static. However the fitness landscape is actually time-dependent, as population immunity changes. For a static fitness landscape, the cumulative fitness flux is the mean population fitness. However, for a dynamic fitness landscape, this is no longer the case: the (mean population) fitness changes both because of adaptation, and because changes of changes in the fitness landscape, i.e., an increase in population immunity will decrease fitness non-uniformly, also affecting individual selection coefficients s_i(t). This leads to cases where the cumulative fitness flux between t_0 and t_n can be positive, but the fitness remains the same. This study neglects the time-dependence of the fitness landscape and therefore incorrectly calculate the fitness flux, leading to an overestimation of the rate of adaptation.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript by Lahne et al. connects retinoic acid (RA) signaling regulation to the length of outer segments (OS) in UV-sensitive cone photoreceptors located in a specialized region of the zebrafish retina called the high acuity zone (AZ). The authors provide potentially compelling, but as it stands, incomplete, evidence that the Müller glia (possibly through expression of the Cyp26 RA-degrading enzyme) may act to regulate spatially restricted RA availability to UV cones in the AZ, supporting these UV cones to grow longer OS. While the evidence presented is indeed suggestive, it is not directly linked and is insufficient to support the full conclusions presented.

      Strengths:

      (1) The experiments make outstanding use of the strengths offered by the zebrafish model, including excellent reporter lines for RA signaling and Müller glia visualization, fluorescent in situ hybridization, high resolution fluorescent microscopy, and pharmacological manipulations; tools which are all well selected and utilized.

      (2) The pharmacological manipulations allow temporally controlled modulation of RA signaling and Cyp26 enzyme activity at developmental timepoints of interest.

      (3) Manipulation of RA signaling impacts cone OS lengths.

      (4) The Müller glia express mRNA transcripts encoding the RA-degrading enzyme Cyp26 and respond to RA signaling modulation in a manner consistent with a role in regulating RA signaling.

      (5) The use of DAPT to prevent Müller glia differentiation in the retina is used to attempt to implicate the Muller glia in the regulation of RA signaling and UV cone OS length.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The experiments cannot rule out a role for other cell types in driving the outcomes studied (UV cone OS length). The expression of Cyp26 transcripts by the Müller glia does not specifically align with the high acuity zone, and other cell types show signal for these transcripts. Impacts on RA signaling, as well as Cyp26 expression can be detected in regions potentially implicating cell types other than the Müller glia. One region of Cyp26 transcript signal is consistent with the Retinal Pigment Epithelium (RPE), and cells in this same region also show RA signaling changes in response to pharmacological treatments.

      (2) The analysis following pharmacological manipulations lacks quantification of UV cone numbers and their morphology after the treatments, which could indicate broader impacts on cones that may manifest in their outer segments.

      (3) The cell-type assignment of RARE:GFP-positive ONL cells is central to the proposed non-cell-autonomous mechanism, yet representative colocalization images supporting the quantification are not fully shown.

      (4) The SyGCaMP6f activity reporter experiments are a nice addition, but the results are not necessarily directly connected to OS length or to the Müller glia.

      (5) The experiments using DAPT to prevent Muller glia development are not sufficiently executed to support the conclusions presented, and their efficacy in inhibiting Müller glia development, as well as UV-cone-specific impacts, are not demonstrated. These treatments could have broad impacts on photoreceptor maturation, retinal organization, or trophic support.

      (6) The title refers to glial regulation of "local retinoic acid levels." However, the study measures: A synthetic RARE reporter, RA-responsive genes and pharmacological responses.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work shows experimentally and computationally that single CA1 neurons can perform mismatch detection on patterned CA3 inputs and that STP and EI balance underlie this detection.

      Strengths:

      It has been known that STP can enhance the EPSP when the corresponding presynaptic input exhibits abrupt changes in firing rate. This work provides experimental evidence and further computational support for the hypothesis that the basic computation through STP is useful for detecting abrupt changes in the spatial pattern of synaptic inputs at the Schaffer collaterals. Further, their results indicate the novel view that mismatch detection is most efficient when gamma-frequency bursting inputs exhibit mismatches between theta cycles. The authors included novel results in the revised manuscript to show that the effective frequency range of gamma oscillation is broad, including both slow and fast gamma bands.

      In the initial submission, the dependence of mismatch detection performance on model parameters and experimental settings, such as pattern overlaps and other network parameters, was not sufficiently explored. In the revised manuscript, the authors extensively studied these points and summarized the novel results in Fig. 9. Furthermore, the authors clarified that jitters in input spikes can improve detection performance in some cases. These results show the robustness of their results against variations in external and internal conditions.

      Weaknesses:

      While this study shows an intriguing example of combined experimental and computational studies, the results of experiments and those of the computational model display relatively large deviations in some conditions. The cause of this discrepancy needs further clarification.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary

      The paper investigates whether the real-time physical experience of the body shapes high-level physical reasoning. Participants played a set of computerized tool-use reasoning games (the Virtual Tools paradigm) in which they must use knowledge of physical laws - including gravity, collisions, and inertia - to guide a ball into a target area. In Study 1, participants played the games under terrestrial gravity while receiving either Galvanic Vestibular Stimulation (GVS), which introduces noise into the vestibular organ and disrupts gravitational signalling, or a Sham condition with matched skin sensation. In Study 2, a separate cohort played the same games redesigned under hypogravity (0.5 g - half Earth g) or hypergravity (2 g - double Earth g), again with concurrent GVS or Sham stimulation. Performance was assessed through success rate, number of attempts, and time per attempt; strategy was assessed through the spatial distance between successive tool placements and the frequency of tool switching across attempts. A post-hoc gravity-weighted index (GWI) was computed to compare the effect of vestibular perturbation across the two studies. The main finding is that GVS impairs performance in gravity-dependent games under terrestrial gravity, yet the same perturbation appears to be neutral or even beneficial when the game environment involves non-terrestrial gravity - a result the authors interpret as evidence for an adaptable, body-grounded internal model of physics.

      Strengths

      One of the most notable strengths of this work is its conceptual positioning at the intersection of embodied cognition and physical reasoning. Rather than treating the human body either as an abstract information-processing device or as a purely biomechanical system, the authors take seriously the idea that cognition is scaffolded by ongoing sensorimotor state - and they test this idea with a paradigm that is both tractable and theoretically motivated. The use of the Virtual Tools paradigm is well-suited to this goal: the games vary systematically in their reliance on gravitational predictions, allowing selective impairment (rather than general disruption) to serve as a signature of embodied physical reasoning.

      The dual-study design is another strength. Testing the same vestibular perturbation under terrestrial and altered game-gravity conditions and observing a reversal in its effect depending on context, provides a form of internal control that is conceptually compelling. The additional clustering analyses (Dirichlet Process Gaussian Mixture Model and leave-one-out kernel density classification) strengthen the strategy results beyond raw distance measures, confirming that GVS systematically shifts participants' spatial exploration strategies.

      The paper is also clearly written and engages meaningfully with relevant theoretical frameworks - predictive coding, embodied cognition, and stochastic resonance - making it accessible and stimulating for a broad audience.

      Weaknesses

      (1) Absence of multiple-comparisons correction. A large number of game-level pairwise t-tests are conducted in both studies (upward of twenty per study) without correction for familywise error rate. The game-level effects that anchor the main narrative - in Study 1 alone: Remove, GoalMove, Spiky, Falling_A, Shafts_B, Gap, and Chaining - arise from an uncorrected pool of comparisons. The probability that some of these constitute false positives is non-trivial. The authors should apply a correction (e.g., Benjamini-Hochberg) or at minimum discuss this limitation explicitly.

      (2) The facilitation claim rests on a post-hoc and arbitrarily parameterized index. The gravity-weighted index (GWI), which drives the central cross-study comparison uses integer coefficients (1, 2, 3) to weight games by gravity dependency level. These coefficients are entirely arbitrary and bear no principled relationship to the actual gravitational magnitudes used in the study. Why not use the gravity dependency ratings themselves, or the empirically estimated gravity impact scores from the computational modelling mentioned in the Methods? The choice of weights should be either principled or tested across a range of values to demonstrate robustness. Furthermore, the notation in equation (1) as currently typeset reads as "Gravity minus Weighted Index" rather than "Gravity-Weighted Index"; this should be corrected.

      (3) The "facilitation" interpretation exceeds what the data in Study 2 directly support. Across all games in Study 2, GVS versus Sham differences in absolute performance are non-significant in all directions. The facilitation claim derives entirely from the GWI being higher in Study 2 than in Study 1 - a between-subjects comparison involving different participant groups and a non-pre-registered metric. The language of "facilitation" should be tempered accordingly, or the authors should provide additional analyses to support this framing.

      (4) Gravitational manipulation is visual only, and the vestibular system is only one component of the gravity-sensing network. Gravity perception results, as the authors very well know, from a distributed multisensory integration process that involves, in addition to the vestibular system, visual, proprioceptive, and visceral inputs. The present paradigm manipulates gravitational context solely through visual cues and targets the vestibular system through GVS - a point the authors acknowledge but do not discuss in sufficient depth. It is important to distinguish clearly between real gravitational alterations (as achieved in parabolic flight or centrifuge environments, where the entire body is physically subjected to a different gravitational vector) and virtually altered gravity, where only one sensory modality is targeted while others remain anchored to 1 g. The scope of the conclusions should reflect this distinction.

      (5) The choice of 0.5 g and 2 g may lack sensitivity. Combining the two altered-gravity conditions in Study 2 because no significant effect of hypo versus hypergravity was found is statistically pragmatic but conceptually unsatisfying. There is evidence in the space physiology literature that gravitational processing is not linearly symmetric around 1 g: threshold effects exist below and above terrestrial gravity that may not be captured by modest deviations (half and double g) - see refs below. It is worth discussing whether the absence of a hypo/hyper distinction in Study 2 reflects a genuine equivalence or a lack of sensitivity, and whether more extreme conditions (e.g., near-zero g or 4-5 g) might reveal different processing regimes. Whether 0.5 g and 2 g were sufficient to saturate the system or merely insufficient to perturb it remains an open question with direct implications for the interpretation of the null GWI effects on strategy measures.

      Lee SMC, Ribeiro LC, Martin DS, Zwart SR, Feiveson AH, Laurie SS, Macias BR, Crucian BE, Krieger S, Weber D, Grune T, Platts SH, Smith SM, and Stenger MB. Arterial structure and function during and after long-duration spaceflight. J Appl Physiol (1985) 129: 108-123, 2020.

      de Winkel KN, Clément G, Groen EL, and Werkhoven PJ. The perception of verticality in lunar and Martian gravity conditions. Neurosci Lett 529: 7-11, 2012.

      Clément G, Moore ST, Raphan T, and Cohen B. Perception of tilt (somatogravic illusion) in response to sustained linear acceleration during spaceflight. Exp Brain Res 138: 410-418, 2001.

      Benson AJ, Kass JR, and Vogel H. European vestibular experiments on the Spacelab-1 mission: 4. Thresholds of perception of whole-body linear oscillation. Exp Brain Res 64: 264-271, 1986.

      (6) High-level reasoning is not defined with sufficient precision. The term "high-level reasoning" appears from the title onward and in the heading of the Study 1 results section (line 138), but it is never formally defined. The reader needs a clearer account of what distinguishes high-level physical reasoning from low-level sensorimotor prediction, and where the games used here fall along that continuum. What specific physical competencies - ballistic trajectories, free-fall predictions, collision dynamics, frictional forces, inertial effects - are required across the game set? When describing the subset of games that drive key effects, this information is critical for evaluating whether effects are specific to gravity reasoning or to some other physical concept.

      (7) Performance measures are disconnected from underlying kinematics. The performance measures (success rate, number of attempts, time per attempt) are coarse, high-level summaries. Time per attempt is used as a proxy for performance efficiency, yet participants received no instructions regarding speed, and different individuals may have adopted systematically different speed-accuracy trade-offs. It would be valuable to know whether time per attempt correlates with attempt number within a given game (which would indicate within-game learning) and whether mouse movement data - trajectory, velocity, hesitation - were recorded and could be analysed to provide more mechanistic insight into strategy formation.

      Comments on revised version.

      My overall assessment remains positive. I consider the findings important and the evidence solid. The study uses an original experimental approach to address a theoretically significant question, and I consider the data sufficient to support the more constrained conclusion that ongoing vestibular information can influence physical reasoning in a context-dependent manner.

      I agree with the other reviewers that the game-level multiple comparisons require appropriate statistical treatment and that the Gravity-Weighted Index should not carry more inferential weight than justified by its construction. I also agree that some of the broader mechanistic interpretations should be presented cautiously. These issues concern primarily the strength and scope of interpretation rather than the validity of the experimental findings themselves.

      I do not, however, consider the absence of preregistration of the exploratory analyses to constitute a methodological weakness in itself. Preregistration is desirable when analyses are intended to provide confirmatory evidence, but it is not a prerequisite for a scientifically informative exploratory analysis. The important distinction is that exploratory analyses should be transparently identified as such and their conclusions should be appropriately qualified. In my view, the relevant concern here is therefore the inferential weight placed on these analyses, rather than the fact that they were not preregistered.

      I would consequently retain a rating of solid for the strength of evidence rather than incomplete. The main claims are supported provided they are formulated at an appropriate level of specificity; the evidence is less secure for the broader mechanistic claims concerning general recalibration of internal models of gravity.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Wenke et al. investigated the role of vlPAG somatostatin-expressing neurons in the mediation of analgesia during defensive states. A newly developed paradigm of cued fear-conditioned analgesia, which consists of a combination of an auditory fear retrieval session and a pain test, was used to evaluate this cell population's contribution to fear-mediated analgesia. Optogenetic manipulation of vlPAG SST+ neurons modulated the responses to a nociceptive cue (Hot Plate) presented concomitantly with an aversively conditioned tone. At the same time, alterations in the freezing levels could be observed during optogenetic activation of vlPAG SST+ neurons. In order to disentangle the impact of these cells on analgesia from their impact on the expression of defensive behaviors, the authors performed electrophysiological recordings from the dorsal horn in the spinal cord of anesthetized mice. A vlPAG-RVM-DH pathway was identified to trigger nociceptive C-fibers upon optic activation of the RVM. Finally, pathway-specific activation of SST+ vlPAG-RVM neurons could abolish CS-induced analgesia.

      Strengths:

      The study addresses a relevant topic, that is, brainstem circuits for pain-modulatory mechanisms as part of defensive states evoked by threat. This is important because the circuit mechanisms underlying pain are still not fully understood, and defining molecular markers of cellular circuit substrates may support the identification of potential pharmaceutical targets in treating pain. The authors confirm a previous study in that a somatostatin-positive cellular population presents a crucial vlPAG circuit element mediating anti-nociceptive effects. Key novelty aspects of the present study are the demonstration that these neurons seem to play a role specifically in threat-induced analgesia. This was possible by the elegant design and application of a novel fear analgesia paradigm, combined with cell- and pathway-specific optogenetics.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this study, the authors ask whether spatial cognition is under sexual selection in mountain chickadees. To do so, the authors examined a large dataset that includes a) spatial cognition data for both males and females (obtained via use of a clever RFID-based feeder system) and b) social and extra-pair paternity nesting data. As predicted, males with higher spatial cognition sired more extra-pair offspring, and extra-pair sires had, on average, higher spatial cognition scores than the males they cuckolded. Interestingly, females with lower spatial cognition scores were more likely to seek extra-pair copulations, potentially to compensate for their own low spatial cognition. Surprisingly, there was no difference in spatial cognition scores between males that sired their own offspring and those that lost paternity at the nest. Also surprising was the fact that there were no differences in patterns of extra-pair paternity and spatial cognition between high- and low-elevation sites. The latter is particularly surprising in that spatial cognition should be under stronger selection at the high elevation site. Overall, this is a fascinating study that demonstrates that spatial cognition - a trait under natural selection as it directly impacts winter foraging and survival behaviour -is also under sexual selection.

      Strengths:

      The authors have a robust dataset (n = 732 offspring sampled over 3 years), high-quality spatial cognition data collected with a procedure that has been well-honed over the years, and couple the data with solid statistical procedures that address many potential covariates and potentially confounding factors. In addition, the authors are careful in the discussion to elaborate on the many potential alternative explanations from the results and questions that are likely to arise in the minds of readers (e.g., how are females assessing male spatial ability?)

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Harduf et al. investigated the mechanisms underlying the sense of agency (SoA), the feeling of being in control of our actions. SoA is thought to arise from the comparison of action outcome predictions, emerging from forward models, with the actually observed outcomes. Current literature has not elucidated how cues from different forward models predicting different features of actions are combined to form a final agency judgement. The authors investigate this gap by introducing various combinations of spatial and temporal mismatches during a virtual reality (VR) based reaching task, and recording participants' agency judgements. Then, they fit different models of cue combination to behavioural data and compare them. The authors find compelling evidence that a model in which the effects of spatial and temporal incongruence are multiplied provides the best fit, outperforming models that do not combine spatial and temporal incongruences, and one model that combines them by averaging rather than multiplying. The authors argue that sense of agency emerges from the domain-general integration of different forward models.

      Strengths:

      The experiments are well designed, and model validation is compelling thanks to the comparison with an appropriate set of alternative models and replication of the results in a first exploratory cohort and in a pre-registered validation cohort. The writing is generally very clear, and the presentation of the results is exhaustive yet compact, making the paper very readable. I also commend the authors for empirically addressing whether and how the integration of different cues contribute to the sense of agency, an idea which has been more widely proposed conceptually than empirically investigated.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The terminology is not always clearly defined, and the authors are not sufficiently rigorous in specifying what gap their study aims to address exactly, and to what extent it succeeds. The authors acknowledge that the idea that cue combination underlies sense of agency was already proposed, yet frame their contribution as showing that "integration" underlies sense of agency. However, it is unclear what the authors exactly mean by "integration". Also, it is not well specified what a domain-general representation is exactly, and how such a notion is not already included in the previously proposed cue combination theory. Overall, the authors seem to imply the main contribution of the paper is to elucidate both whether and how cue integration is performed. However, the most novel contribution of the study appears to concern the "how" rather than the "whether".

      (2) The authors should have discussed their findings in light of Bayesian inference, which has already been proposed as the basis of cue combination for sense of agency. The fact that a multiplication of the different cues fits the data better than an averaging makes it too tempting to think about Bayesian inference to ignore such idea. Indeed, if cues are assumed to provide statistically independent evidence about the probability of self-causation, then they should combine in a multiplicative way rather than by averaging. Even if the experimental design or pre-registration constraints preclude a formal Bayesian analysis, this point should be discussed and related to previous literature.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This paper investigates how curricula should be structured to support learning in complex tasks, focusing on the distinction between concept discovery (learning new components) and concept implementation (learning how to use them in increasingly complex sequences). The main finding is that participants tend to prioritize discovering new concepts, even though learning outcomes are better when they instead practice implementing known concepts in increasingly complex ways.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the paper is the experimental paradigm. The grid-world task is a novel way of independently manipulating two dimensions of complexity that are often confounded: the number of concepts that need to be learned and the complexity with which those concepts must be deployed. Participants have to learn how the underlying tools operate and use them in different configurations, which provides an interesting setting for studying variability in how individuals structure their own learning. Additionally, the experiments progress from correlational analyses of self-directed learning, to randomized experimental comparisons of curricula, and finally to transfer and adaptive curriculum tests. Overall, this paper addresses an important question about whether the complexity of concept discovery versus implementation is better for structuring learning.

      Weaknesses:

      The main concern is that the paper's conclusions do not seem to fully match the evidence. The authors present the results as identifying a relatively general principle of complex learning, such that we should master a concept's implementation before introducing new concepts. There was no implementation-first advantage in the transfer phase, and when testing was delayed by one week, the curriculum difference was no longer detectable. Although the implementation-first curriculum improves immediate performance within the constraints of these experimental paradigms, it is less clear that it produces more generalizable learning. Additionally, it is not sufficiently clear how the "flow" measure was created, what "flow" means in the context of subjective task experience, or more broadly in everyday learning, and what inferential role the measure plays in the paper.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors set out to characterize how four studied components of executive function (Inhibitory Control, Shifting, Updating, and Working Memory) are organized in rhesus monkeys, using a battery of four touchscreen tasks performed repeatedly across many sessions. They report that individual monkeys fall into distinct "cognitive phenotypes," and that statistical modeling of the task scores reveals four separable latent factors, which they interpret as evidence against a single shared "general" executive function factor in this species. The four latent factors (Shifting/Learning, Exogenous Inhibitory Control, Endogenous Inhibitory Control, and Working Memory Updating) are slightly different from those mentioned in the introduction, which is of interest to refine the definition and assessment of executive functions in non-human primates.

      Strengths:

      (1) The multi-task, repeated-measures design is a substantial undertaking and yields a large, richly characterized behavioral dataset from the same animals across many sessions. The use of 4 different cognitive tasks is uncommon in this field and a real asset to the study.

      (2) The overall approach of testing the reliability of each behavioral measure before including it in further analysis is a sound and appreciated practice, backed up with overall appropriate data analysis strategies.

      (3) The attempt to move beyond single-task designs, which dominate the non-human primate literature, toward a broader profiling of executive sub-functions is conceptually valuable and timely.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The four factors introduced early in the paper are not the same four factors that emerge from the final statistical analysis, and this shift is not clearly flagged or explained to the reader, which is likely to cause confusion about what the paper is actually demonstrating. In addition, working memory vs. updating are not clearly defined or distinguished. The introduction and discussion sometimes treat "updating" and "working memory" as separate executive functions, but the literature the authors themselves cite (e.g., Friedman & Miyake, 2017) treats updating as a component nested within working memory rather than a fully independent dimension. This conceptual ambiguity carries through the paper and affects how the reported four-factor structure should be interpreted.

      (2) The grouping of very different types of behavioral measures (accuracy-based executive function metrics, reaction-time/processing-speed metrics, and reward/loss motivational-effect metrics) under a single "cognitive metric" label in Figure 2 is potentially misleading, since these are not conceptually equivalent, and the paper later treats them separately in supplementary analyses. This could give readers the impression that all reported metrics are equally informative tests of the four-domain hypothesis, when only a subset actually is.

      (3) The rationale for how motivational & valence effects (gains/losses) were analyzed is not well supported. Effects of loss versus gain may reflect risk attitudes or loss-aversion documented in the primate literature, rather than motivation per se, and this alternative explanation is not discussed.

      (4) The Discussion would benefit from acknowledging other factors that could influence performance and phenotype membership across sessions (such as age, sex, social rank, or stress) and from clarifying whether the identified cognitive phenotypes are expected to be stable traits or could shift with further training. Additionally, some interpretive statements appear in the Results section rather than the Discussion, which is inconsistent with how results and interpretation are normally separated, and could give undue weight to preliminary interpretations.

      (5) Concerns about the reliability of some response-time-based measures. In the Continuous Updating task, reaction times appear to drop unexpectedly at the highest difficulty levels for each animal, which may reflect animals disengaging from the task (e.g., random choice heuristic) rather than a genuine cognitive effect, and could also reflect thinner, unevenly sampled data at these levels rather than a true average. If so, the slope measures derived from these data may need to be recalculated after appropriately filtering the trials. Related to this, individual differences in hand-resting position in front of the screen are acknowledged by the authors as a source of noise in reaction times across tasks, but no correction or normalization for this is applied.

      (6) The Supplementary Methods referenced in the text (e.g., for the variance decomposition and additional factor analyses) do not appear to be included anywhere in the submitted materials, only Supplementary Results, making some analyses difficult to fully evaluate. There is no information about the subject age, sex, species, etc.

      Achievement of aims and impact:

      The authors largely achieve their stated aim of demonstrating that monkeys' executive function performance is reliable and structured in different dimensions rather than guided by a single factor, and the discovery of stable individual "cognitive phenotypes" across sessions is a genuinely interesting and useful contribution. However, the conceptual framework of the study needs to be better clarified (i.e. are working memory and updating truly separable?) and enriched with relevant inputs from the fields of comparative cognition and cognitive ethology in non-human primates and beyond. The conclusions about Response Times (RT) may change after proper or further analysis of these metrics; additional relevant dimensions may then be disentangled by considering the sources of variability in these RT data (i.e., motivation, emotional state). With clarification of these points, this work has the potential to become a useful reference and methodological resource for the field of comparative cognition and non-human primate cognitive neuroscience.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors investigate the causal role of the LC in mobilizing cognitive resources. Two rhesus macaques expressing TH-dependent inhibitory (hM4Di) DREADDs in the LC, alongside one non-transduced control, performed a spatial foraging task under visible (transparent) and hidden (opaque) reward conditions. The authors report that systemic DCZ (0.1 mg/kg) administration selectively impaired performance in the memory-guided opaque condition in the DREADD animals, concluding that LC activity is causally required for allocating cognitive effort

      Strengths:

      (1) Achieving cell-type-specific, reversible chemogenetic inhibition in the macaque LC is a substantial technical achievement that successfully bypasses the limitations of systemic noradrenergic pharmacology.

      (2) The experimental setup elegantly isolates memory-guided action selection from global arousal, sedation, or motivational deficits, providing a useful quantitative constraint for LC functional models.

      (3) The introduction and discussion clearly identify the limitations of using indirect pupillometry to assess locus coeruleus activity. The authors thoughtfully frame their targeted manipulation as a critical complement to existing literature without overstating their claims.

      (4) Demonstrating that the DREADD animals navigated the board similarly regardless of reward visibility is a valuable null finding. This specific result provides crucial evidence for addressing the memory-versus-effort debate. Elevating this insight from a subordinate clause to a more prominent position will further maximize the paper's impact.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The current behavioral metrics-specifically mean inter-choice distance and success rates bounded by a "random agent" baseline-cannot distinguish between a working memory deficit and a fundamental shift in search strategy. Because performance is a many-to-one function of memory quality and search policy, animals could achieve the observed outcomes either by executing a tight local sweep with "leaky" memory for visited wells, or by abandoning tight spatial locality for a dispersed, near-random walk with intact memory. Without a detailed characterization of the animals' actual step-by-step visit sequences and spatial consistency across conditions, the data cannot adjudicate whether LC inhibition degrades an existing habitual policy (a memory/maintenance deficit) or impairs the adoption of a structured policy (an effort-mobilization/task-set deficit). Clarifying this is critical, as the two interpretations engage distinctly different LC-prefrontal mechanisms.

      (2) The analyses of within-session behaviors rely on arbitrary reward-inclusion thresholds (e.g., 20 or 23 rewards) and censoring rules that obscure the temporal dynamics of the task. Because wells are depleted without replacement, the difficulty and working memory burden rise steeply as the board empties. A constant, time-invariant memory deficit could readily produce the observed early vs. late performance pattern, as the detectable cost of forgetting accrues heavily after the 20th reward. Furthermore, early-session failures to maintain an effective policy naturally lead to continued responding after depletion. However, the imposed time caps compress variance exactly where this within-session causal chain would be most evident, leaving the claimed independence of the early and late deficits unsupported.

      (3) The experimental timeline heavily confounds chemogenetic manipulation with elapsed time. Test weeks 1-2 were exclusively saline, and weeks 3-4 were exclusively DCZ, with treatment alternation only occurring in weeks 5-6. Consequently, the critical contrast between opaque saline and DCZ conditions is largely a between-block comparison across a month of testing. Plausible time-varying factors-such as habituation, declining novelty of a daily home-cage task, and accumulating satiety-all directionally align with the reported DCZ impairment, undermining the isolation of the chemogenetic effect.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      In the present study, the authors report the role of virus-induced apoptosis in positively regulating innate immune response. Upon infection, host cell apoptosis is triggered as a defense mechanism against virus replication. Culmination of infected-cell death impairs replicative potential for viruses hence attenuating virus propagation. Reports exist denoting inhibitory effect of apoptosis upon innate immune signaling. Contrary to that, findings of this manuscript underscore possible role of apoptosis in enhancing innate immune signaling and effector response. Infection-induced activation of caspases (3, 6, 7 and 8) has been demonstrated to cleave DRP1 protein. DRP1, acting as positive regulator for mitochondrial fission, upon degradation leads to altered mitochondrial morphology (elongation).

      Mitochondria being a hub for innate immune signaling (via operation of RLR-MAVS-downstream effector molecule-axis), upon elongation as a result of DRP1 depletion results in greater innate immune signal flux and interferon induction. Increased interferon induction thus acts to inhibit virus propagation, as demonstrated by the authors using cell-culture models.

      Strengths:

      (1) The findings presented by the authors have been validated by employing elaborate biochemical experimental approaches. The study entails extensive biochemical characterization of DRP1 residues targeted by activated caspases, in vitro assays validating caspase-mediated DRP1 cleavage & caspase-DRP1 interaction.

      (2) This study possesses broad implications since authors demonstrate role of caspase-mediated DRP1 cleavage in promoting innate immunity, in context of infection by diverse viruses (both RNA and DNA viruses).

      Weakness:

      Although the authors undertook a thorough experimental approach attempting to validate their findings, all the experiments were performed using either cell-culture models for infection or in vitro biochemical assays (cleavage and protein-protein interaction). Additional experimentation using animal models (in vivo) will further help strengthen biological significance of their findings under more physiological settings.

      Comments on revised version.

      I am satisfied with the revised version of the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work presents interesting findings where addition of exogenous ATP extends replicative lifespan of yeast cells in a way that seems uncorrelated with actual increased intracellular ATP levels or mitochondria. To be clear, addition of ATP to yeast growth media increases the number of cell divisions per cell in yeast. Expression of the NTT1 ATP transporter gene increases intracellular ATP levels according to LCMS analysis, but the effect on replicative lifespan works without the NTT1 gene and without an intracellular increase in ATP (possibly with a decrease in intracellular ATP), so the effect appears to be independent of the effect on intracellular ATP levels or mitochondria, as mitochondria-less R0 yeast cells also have increased numbers of cell division when grown with extracellular ATP. I would not state that the data support a role for ATP availability regulating aging because human cells do not import ATP from the environment; maybe for yeast or microbes that import ATP unlike normal human cells that make all their own. I would not state that the data support a role for ATP in increasing replicative lifespan since there is no correlation between increased lifespan an increased ATP- rather the opposite is shown - you got no correlation between intracellular ATP at replicative lifespan. What you show is that you can increase replicative lifespan when you increase extracellular ATP in a way that doesn't matter if you further increase intracellular ATP with NTT1, but maybe you were saturated. But then, intracellular ATP doesn't correlate either. So, it doesn't make sense to say that the paper shows that increasing ATP increases replicative lifespan. You gave the cells what seems like an osmotic stress and it didn't even matter if they had the mitochondria to respond. Lifespan didn't correlate with more ATP at all. So, it seems incorrect to indicate that ATP regulates lifespan in yeast, when you haven't shown that it just wasn't osmotic stress and you have shown that it doesn't really have anything to do with how much ATP each cell has. Rather, it seems more like it's the robustness of some other response to the ATP and not how much they imported.

      The authors point out in their rebuttal that, paraphrased, with the QUEEN reporter gene that quantifies ATP via ratiometric fluorescence, some cells increase atp with age, some cells decrease it and others show no age related changes, so it would not be meaningful to make an ATP measurement in old cells. Essentially, that line of reasoning further supports that, while adding extracellular atp seems to increase replicative lifespan, the lack of correlation between intracellular ATP and replicative aging suggest that they are eliciting a stress response to having high extracellular ATP. The increased replicative lifespan seems to be caused by some kind of stress response to the extracellular ATP, possibly osmotic. So, this is an interesting result that suggests that there are mechanisms to respond to high extracellular ATP that result in increased replicative lifespan that aren't caused by the ATP per say, but by having a high concentration of ATP, outside the cell. This paper seems like it might relate to the Kaeberlein paper about high osmolarity increasing replicative lifespan, but I don't know if this condition qualifies as high osmolarity.

      As an aside, this seems like a better model for increased tumor cell growth in the presence of increased extracellular ATP, which happens in some cancers.

      Strengths:

      Longitudinal imaging of single cells. Analyzed ATP levels with two approaches. Creative approach to use NTT1 transporter to increase intracellular ATP levels (that did nothing for lifespan). Solid replicative lifespan data. Seemingly clear lack of correlation between ATP and replicative lifespan among individual cells strongly pointing so some kind of stress response, possibly some kind of osmolarity response like Kaeberlein 2002.

      Weaknesses/inconclusive data:

      The LCMS data seems better than the microscopy data on ATP because it does not suffer from signal interference/befuddlement from autofluorescence or pH or age-related changes in either of those parameters. The authors seem to have subtracted an average autofluorescence from each cell in their revised analysis, but it is unclear if this value changes with age to account for age related changes in autofluorescence; it is also unclear if signal attenuation as a function of age-related intracellular pH change was accounted for. They may have age-related values for autofluorescence or age-related changes in intracellular pH that affect fluorescence of GFP if they go back to their raw data, which might be useful for signal cleanup.