2 Matching Annotations
  1. Last 7 days
    1. The Monterey Company, a promotional products manufacturer in Bend, Oregon, with about 16 employees, has begun testing for the skill more directly. In an interview exercise his company has used over the past year, a candidate argues against a manager’s sales plan, then learns the manager heard the argument and kept the plan anyway. A weak answer, Turney says, sounds like, “I’d follow the manager’s decision, but I’d make sure they knew I disagreed every time something went wrong.” “I want people who can tell me when I’m wrong without turning every disagreement into a battle,”

      Highlights the scale problem (which is therefore an opportunity). Also, great example of the need to translate between higher education and industry: it's not just about being nice while disagreeing, which we might call Civil Discourse. In this case, it's about discernment about the stakes of disagreement and using judgement to know when to let it go. If that's something employers need to know but that we're failing to communicate even though it's happening, we're missing an opportunity to add value to our learning records.

    2. A few employers are testing for it in interviews. Chris Sund, president and chief operating officer of Uniti Med and GQR Healthcare, healthcare staffing firms with more than 200 internal employees, asks candidates for internal roles about a time they had an idea outside their area of responsibility and whether they took it to their manager. He then asks how they approached it, how the other person responded and whether anything changed their mind. Those answers, he says, show “both their willingness to speak up and their willingness to listen.” Sund says he can teach job-specific skills, but humility and emotional intelligence are harder to impart. “I want people who can stand behind an opinion while still considering another perspective,” he says
      1. Employers do value these skills
      2. Employers lack validation of these skills
      3. Employers therefore either lack the data or take on the unscalable task of testing for it themselves.