On 2014 Mar 01, Ellen M Goudsmit commented:

Dr. Melvin Ramsay began writing about the illness now known as ME after the outbreak in north London in 1955. I looked in his book (1988) for a paper written by him in 1959 and found none. The best known article from 1959 was written by the late Dr. Acheson, who gave ME its name in a leader in the Lancet (1956). Dr Ramsay offered a diagnostic protocol but not until the 1980s. I agree with Morris and Maes that the core symptom of ME is an exacerbation of symptoms following minimal exertion (supported by Paul et al who referred to CFS but actually selected patients with ME, pers. comm.). It should also be noted that none of the existing criteria for ME and CFS have been found to have the required specificity and sensitivity. And that includes the 2011 version.

The abstract indicates a lack of attention to detail. This undermines the understanding of the issues and shows a lack of respect, not only for the researchers but also for the patients, 99% of whom would know how to spell the name of arguably one of the most knowledgeable experts in this field. This failure to check for accuracy is a major cause for confusion in the literature on ME and CFS. And what happened to peer review? Any peer would have noticed the problem with the first sentence.

People really interested in ME and CFS may like to purchase an excellent publication by Shepherd and Chaudhuri summarising the knowledge to date. It's available from the ME Association in the UK. An authoritative and accurate review (2013).

Leading article. A new clinical entity? Lancet, 1956, 1, 789-790.

Paul, L et al. Demonstration of delayed recovery from fatiguing exercise in chronic fatigue syndrome. European Journal of Neurology, 1999, 6, 63-69.

Ramsay, AM. Myalgic encephalomyelitis and postviral fatigue states. Second Ed. Gower Medical Publ. 1988. now available from the MEA Association, UK.

On 2014 Mar 01, Ellen M Goudsmit commented:

Dr. Melvin Ramsay began writing about the illness now known as ME after the outbreak in north London in 1955. I looked in his book (1988) for a paper written by him in 1959 and found none. The best known article from 1959 was written by the late Dr. Acheson, who gave ME its name in a leader in the Lancet (1956). Dr Ramsay offered a diagnostic protocol but not until the 1980s. I agree with Morris and Maes that the core symptom of ME is an exacerbation of symptoms following minimal exertion (supported by Paul et al who referred to CFS but actually selected patients with ME, pers. comm.). It should also be noted that none of the existing criteria for ME and CFS have been found to have the required specificity and sensitivity. And that includes the 2011 version.

The abstract indicates a lack of attention to detail. This undermines the understanding of the issues and shows a lack of respect, not only for the researchers but also for the patients, 99% of whom would know how to spell the name of arguably one of the most knowledgeable experts in this field. This failure to check for accuracy is a major cause for confusion in the literature on ME and CFS. And what happened to peer review? Any peer would have noticed the problem with the first sentence.

People really interested in ME and CFS may like to purchase an excellent publication by Shepherd and Chaudhuri summarising the knowledge to date. It's available from the ME Association in the UK. An authoritative and accurate review (2013).

Leading article. A new clinical entity? Lancet, 1956, 1, 789-790.

Paul, L et al. Demonstration of delayed recovery from fatiguing exercise in chronic fatigue syndrome. European Journal of Neurology, 1999, 6, 63-69.

Ramsay, AM. Myalgic encephalomyelitis and postviral fatigue states. Second Ed. Gower Medical Publ. 1988. now available from the MEA Association, UK.