1,269 Matching Annotations
  1. Mar 2018
    1. Linguistics for TESOL Bilingual Teachers. Artifact #1 is video I created which provides a glimpse into the sociolinguistic situation of a small and somewhat isolated Bangladesh community in the South Bronx

      Remember - What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address? (Cite it directly in your reflection). Language as a System: Candidates demonstrate understanding of language as a system, including phonology, morphology, syntax, semantics, pragmatics, discourse varieties, aspects of social and academic language, rhetorical registers, and writing conventions ​ .

    1. my understanding of this standard

      make sure to quoate the objectives "understand, and use the major theories and research related to the nature and role of culture in their instruction. Because of the way cultural identity influences self-esteem,candidates understand how cultural groups and individual cultural identities affect language learning and school achievement. Theyuse a range of resources to discover more about their students’ backgrounds. Candidates know that students learn more readily when cultural factors are recognized, respected, and accommodat ed, and they demonstrate this knowledge in theircurriculum planning, material selection, and teaching. They involve students’ families and community members in students’ learning."

    1. With continued use, informal and formal assessments will determine if these strategies have in fact fostered literacy and language development. 

      maybe you can mention low vs high stakes?

    2. Since writing this paper, building literacy (in addition to stamina) and use of academic language has been embedded into every lesson. I discovered that academic language is skill that can be taught with modeling, explicit instruction and practice

      why do you think that this is relevant?

    3. more specifically, how cultural dissonance, age, and prior formal education impacts literacy in L1 and L2; and to what degree including specific strategies in the classroom assist ELLs with language acquisition.

      before giving details of your paper - What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address? (Cite it directly in your reflection) - "Candidates understand and apply theories and research in second language acquisition and development to support their ELLs’ social and academic English language and literacy learning and content-area achievement"

    1. I learned to step back and let students take ownership of their learning, fostering metacognitive thinking which further supports content mastery and second language acquisition

      yes! maybe you want to mention the role of the teacher as a facilitator instead of an authoritative figure?

    1. I may start to invite parents into the classroom so they can see my teaching in action and maybe take some aspects of my teaching and use it in the home.

      parenst as observers or as participant/collaborators or the learning process?

    1. understanding and applying knowledge of sociocultural, psychological, and political variables to facilitate the process of learning English, as well as recognizing the importance of ELLs’ L1s and language varieties and build on these skills as a foundation for learning English.

      check my previous comment

    2. Standard 1.B

      "Candidates understand and apply theories and research in second language acquisition and development to support their ELLs’ social and academic English language and literacy learning and content-area achievement." It links directly to you paper ​

    1. Creating this exercise proves that we are true partners in the classroom and allows our strengths to shine.

      you could mention the role of the teacher - not as an authoritative figure, but a facilitator

    2. By reteaching the same vocabulary words every day allows my ELLs experience language in multiple modals and registers.

      wiriting conventions? rhetorical registers?

    3. I feel it best illustrates how vocabulary can inform comprehension.

      Make sure to copy from the standard - whatd does your address "phonology, morphology, syntax, semantics, pragmatics, discourse varieties, aspects of social and academic language, rhetorical registers, and writing conventions"?

    1. f I can push my laziness to the side, I will try to find a school that best fits my needs for the 2018-19 school year, one where I can utilize my knowledge of the social and academic aspects of language.

      more optimistic perspective? laziness??? It is you portfolio - you are introducing yourself.

    2. This creation of this paper was one of the highlights of my graduate school career.

      I know that we talk about this in class already - make sure to read Standard 1.b.: Language Acquisition and Development (This is the artifact that goes with it)

    1. ow the motivation for satisfying these needs or absence of, play a part in the classroom learning of another language.

      the role of motivation - narrow it down to the L2

    2. the impact of culture

      "culture" - the impact of culture and identity in SLA (I think that here is your topic) - you just need to narrow it down Foe example, the case of Latino students (High School) learning English?)

    3. specifically in high school settings where understanding language influences one’s ability to graduate

      ok - here you have your context: High School students (learning English?)

    4. how can the term success be interpreted when teaching ENL students as opposed to teaching a language class

      you need to re-think this question - "success" does not work, it is a broad concept/term

    5. will entail how these theories may be compared to students’ acquisition of a second language learning inside mainly high school classrooms and how students’ success may differ by variance in aptitude.

      ot needed

    6. Or does age not matter at all? In this paper I will discuss how children can acquire a second language and how adults acquire a second language

      you should focus on one specific aspect? (e.g. accent?)

    7. This research paper will unfold this myth by looking at both sides of the argument, is it much easier for a child to acquire a second language

      don't you have an answer after reading chapter 2 and 3?

    8. Are the sociocultural factors and needs the things that motivate language acquisition, L1 or L2? Do these needs supersede the biological limitations with increased exposure to L2 input

      motivation and SLA in adults - maybe college level? ELL high school?

    9. Do students feel consciously or subconsciously inferior to their peers whose L1 is English? Do students feel ashamed or embarrassed by their cultures

      it seems that you are interested in students attitudes

    10. My research will delve into the role of linguistic imperialism in a classroom setting, and how it effects second language learners.

      Iris, you have narrow it down since our last email. tell me about the context - high school, college?

    11. of which a common example is “Spanglish

      scholars who emply "translanguaging" as a method and a theoretical construct would not agree - check Stern and Otheguy and their article about "so called Spanglish" and Ofelia García (todo su trabajo)

    1. What are the cognitive learning styles in learning a second language? How does the brain function affect the learning styles? What is the process of teaching and learning second language? What are the different strategies/methods to support these learning styles when acquiring a second language?

      Lowella, for this paper you should focus on one question. it seems you are interested in learning styles vs learning strategies - check both of them. Do you want to reserach styles or strategies? are you connecting a specific style with a strategy?

    2. We all have different ways to absorb, process, retain and comprehend information.  Some people can follow verbal instructions while others need to use their hands to manipulate things.   This is the same for people who are learning a second language.

      learning styles?

    3. I have done some research on dual language and most of the research I found supports dual language and stresses the importance and benefits of dual language for young children

      need to address your research question

    4. As a teacher of a dual language high school it has been challenging to find a careful balance between native language and second language acquisition.

      Do not add your personal experience on your abstract

    5. how are we to determine the difference between SLI and and SLA? When accurate diagnosis is made then what are some strategies to take in which to find out how to best address their needs?

      SLI - define your context: what type of students? children / adolescent / adults? are they ELL?

    6. “Specific language impairment (SLI) is a language disorder that delays the mastery of language skills in children who have no hearing loss or other developmental delays” (www.nidcd.nih.gov).

      You will need to give a definition in your introduction, not in your abstract

  2. Feb 2018
    1. This example speaks to the importance of attitude, willingness, emotion and the language ego as trumping age in SLA.

      do you think we can find these examples within SLA adults?

    1. The difference between children and adults is that adults use the first language as a basis to attempt to discover the rules of the second language

      could this depend on the teaching method used?

    2. I have some other students that see speaking English as an academic thing and speak Spanish when they were communicating socially or when they are feeling extremely emotional.

      they use language as a performative act?

    3. A leading theory, which establishes a biological determinant of language acquisition is the Critical Period Hypothesis (CPH) “claims that there is such a biological timetable” (Brown, pg.51) which is “Initially the notion of a critical period was connected only to first language acquisition”, however, “Second language researchers have outlined the possibilities of extrapolating the CPH to second language contexts” (pg.51) and have developed a claim,“ that a critical point for second language acquisition occurs around puberty, beyond which people seem to be relatively incapable of acquiring a second language.”(pg.51)

      we have read the chapter - we do not need a summary

    4. My fiance came to the United States of America from D.R when he was 20 years old. He didn’t speak any English only Spanish. It took him approximately 3 years for him to learn the English Language. He expressed to me that what really helped him the most was in the classes he took he purposely did not socialize with Spanish speakers. Most of his friends were Asians, Americans etc. The only common language between them all was English , which forced him to use the second language. So it is very possible and in my opinion common for an adult to learn a second language.

      use this as an argument - apply it critically

    5. The reason I assumed this is because when I was learning Italian in college, it was very hard for me to pick up on the accent. I assumed that because Italian is similar in some ways to Spanish I would pick up on the language really fast but I was wrong. Italian was so hard for me to learn and I believe the reason why was because I was only using the language in class. Many of my peers decided to study abroad in Italy and some even moved there for a couple of years and they achieved “fluency” in the language. The only time I was ever using the language was in class, so I truly believe this was the reason why I didn’t pick up on the language. Also I stopped practicing the language, so now if you speak to me in Italian I will probably only understand 20% of what you are saying.

      you must related your personal experience to the reading from a critical point of view

    6. Chapter 3 reading asks, “Do childhood and adulthood, and the differences between them, hold some keys to language acquisitions models and theories?” The reading offers a the “Critical Period Hypothesis” as one theory addressing this question. The “Critical Period Hypothesis”, suggests that there is a period of life, determined by a biological timetable when language can be more easily acquired and beyond this period, language becomes increasingly more difficult to acquire.

      You do not need to summarize the chapter

    7. There certainly appear to be some potential advantages to an early age for SLA, but there is absolutely no evidence that an adult cannot overcome all of those disadvantages race one, accent…hardly the quintessential criterion for effective learning.” (69-70).

      and?

    8. I do not wholly disagree, but I must keep in mind that although it may be more difficult to teach young people who may have just recently moved to to the United States English, it is not impossible.

      how? why? explain your argument... I want to know more about what you think!

    1. We have all observed children acquiring their first language easily and well, yet individuals learning a second language, particularly in an educational setting, can meet with great difficulty and sometimes failure. (Brown, pg.48)

      why?

    2. have cultivated a sense of identity tied to their culture much less their language.

      but, they could be influenced by what his/her older brother is saying and/or doing???

    3. I would be interested to see if this effect is also prominent with younger age groups as well.

      Good question. I guess they will also be influenced by peer pressure, maybe even more?

    4. I had never considered how crucial language is tied to identity, and with that lens it makes sense why some students would reject another language especially during and after puberty

      yes!

    5. Many times we falsely associate fluency if someone’s targeted language sounds flawless when speaking. Many times we think that someone is particularly talented in language acquisition if they can speak very well and not pay attention to the other aspects of language.

      why? what are the consequences?

    6. I believe that Ausubel’s list of warnings and statements may help me understand this concept. He explains that the first language can facilitate the learning of a second language.

      why? how?

    7. The acquisition of the communicative and functional purposes of language is, in most circumstances, far more important a perfect native accent. Scovel (1988:186)

      and?????

    8. I teach in an international school, all my students are English language learners. In an effort to help my students through their language acquisition process, I work closely with all the teachers in the ninth grade to develop strategies and utilize protocols to increase the usage of English in the class. Learning a second language is not an easy task, especially for the students that are new to the country. When these students arrive to the United States of America, they bring with them the fear, stress and sadness. In general, they are affected socially and emotionally, after leaving their families, friends and culture, to adapt to a new environment where their future is uncertain because they face so many issues. Besides concentrating on learning a new language, they sometimes don’t have a decent place to live. Some of the students often don’t have food to eat or a place to call their homes.

      not related to the reading - please make sure to read the instructions.

    1. nguages fluently and efficiently; moreover, they acquire them “naturally”

      Do you think an adolescent or an adult can learn a language as fluently as someone who had acquired that language as a baby?

    2. At a certain age our brain’s ability to morph and incorporate new information slows down (typically around adolescent years)

      Do you think this is truth? why?

    1. “Piaget described overall development as the result of children’s interaction with their environment, with a complementary interaction between their developing perceptual cognitive capacity and their linguistic experience”.

      and? Try to read between the lines: what does this quote means? Why do you think this is relevant? How do you connect this idea with the TED talk?

    1. This would be a Constructionist method because it allowed me to learn another language by interacting with people and through social experiences within the classroom. I am using Spanish ten out of twelve moths a year, so I am able to retain it and internalize it better than I did Italian

      and it is not a formal teaching enviroment

    1. In my experience, my social interaction and everyday use of the language was more beneficial than any Spanish class I had ever sat in.

      If your were talking with a friend, you are practicing the languagem but this is not formal instruction. Motuvation here plays an important role

    1. I chose this artifact because it illustrates my understanding of how to teach basic sentence structures that English Language Learners must be familiar with if they are going to progress as writers and speakers

      What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address?

    2. This especially helps those students who already possess a limited knowledge of English vocabulary, but it also gives beginning students a solid base from which to grow

      already mentioned (1st paragraph)

    3. This artifact was created in ESC 725 as the first lesson in a series of grammar lessons I implemented in one of my 10th grade ELA classes. The class I taught this lesson with was of 18 students  with English proficiencies ranging from transitioning to commanding. This lesson integrates language instruction in syntactical concepts while also reviewing the ELA content of the The House on Mango Street.

      Good intro! Clear and informative

    1. more specifically how language development and assessments can also be used to drive and deliver instruction in a way that is accessible for all students

      Yes! Accessibility!

    2. This artifact is a grammar mini-lesson I taught on sentence structure that shows my understanding of syntax, but more specifically how to teach sentence structure to high school English Language Learners that struggle with creating basic sentences

      Good! Clear and informative intro!

    3. These grammar lessons were mostly isolated from our content lessons and, while they were effective at the time, I could have pushed my students to gain an even stronger grasp on the concept if they had been given a chance to apply this skill directly to their writing.

      Good!

    4. Both the small and large groups benefited from sentence level instruction, but there are some things I would have done differently.

      First - What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address?

    5. I have questions about how to do this best. Part of me believes that it would be best to start a school-wide initiative backed by my administration, whose primary aim would be to motivate all of the teachers at my school to include language objectives in their lessons; another part of me believes that it might be more useful to execute language objectives extremely well with a small group as an example to the rest of the school and then shine a light on what our group is doing. Part of this effort would be incorporating homonyms, homophones, and the like with our content. Regardless of the approach, I want to start some kind of concentrated effort at my school around language objectives.

      Do not forget your artifact! Make sure to conect these ideas: "Teachers use their knowledge of these inter-related aspects of language to help ELLs acquire English language and literacy to achieve in content areas."

    6. As the only ENL instructor at my school, I want to do more to push my coworkers to think of language as something that can be taught in tandem with content

      how? make sure to come back to the artifact - how can an assignment like this help with the process/situation you are describing?

    7. I am currently working with a primarily Spanish population, and while they have taught me more about the nuts and bolts of my profession than any graduate school course, I feel my experience in Asia is not being put to good use. So, if I can push my laziness to the side, I will try to find a school that best fits my needs for the 2018-19 school year, one where I can utilize my knowledge of the social and academic aspects of language.

      Remember, this is not your teaching statement - it is a reflection about an artifact. Make sure to reflect on the artifact itslef -

    8. Koreans want to become proficient in English at a very quick pace, and become quite frustrated if they are not immediately successful.

      Again - language acquisition & development

    9. anguage acquisition

      after reading the paper, you are applying theories and research in second language acquisition and development to support ELLs' social and academic English language and literacy learning - (STANDARD 1B)

    10. Having taught in Korea for four years, I had grown fond of the Korean people and when I returned to New York City, I had an arsenal of techniques to use to in my teaching practice

      you can link this to the previous paragraph (because of my time spent in Korea...)

    11. “the psychological principles of second-language learning with their application to teaching, as well as the similarities and differences between first- and second-language learning and teaching.” While many of the issues in this course tended to focus on Spanish-speaking ELLs, I felt it was pertinent to concentrate on an emerging group of ELLs (at least in New York City): the East Asian immigrant

      We want to know about the artifact, not the class. Try to focus on the goal of your paper / your research question and why you wanted to solve that question(s)

    12. The focus of this course was second language teaching and learning

      I think that you did a fantastic job on your paper - but I think that this artifact goes with Standrad 1B - Language Acquisition and Development

    1. My learning both languages was never something I thought about until now.

      how was your learning experience in Spanish compare to the one in English? and vice versa?

    2. “Do I speak English better than I speak Spanish? Or do I speak Spanish better than I speak English? Do I know either language?

      or... do you know both languages?

    1. The reading supports the idea of a relationship between social interaction and language development. Mathilda Holzman developed the “reciprocal model” of language development. She believed that there is a reciprocal relationship between an adult language user and the infant-child learning a language (Brown 29). This would suggest that nurturing is more important than “nature” in language learning. Nativists would say that language is a “species-specific” behavior (Brown 24), that we are born with the genetic capacity that allows us to identify and process language

      what do you think?