1,269 Matching Annotations
  1. May 2018
    1. Elicitation feedback was also very effective for various reasons. Ms. Fowler allowed newcomers to participate in their native language of Spanish because she wanted to hear from everyone and make everyone’s thoughts feel valued

      what would happen if teachers does not know the students' first language?

    1. Student responding to a question based on an image about an illustration of children playing a soccer game match:

      really helpful the way that you have conextualized each example

    1. In my opinion socialization is defiantly a great way to learn a language, especially when you aren’t given a lot of support at school or at home.

      what about the strategies?

    1. and try to imitate what they were saying when they were answering questions in class. Frank also told me that watching cartoons in English were a huge help to his English language learning

      learner styles and strategies?

    2. Niove confirmed all of this for me since she has known Frank for the past four years. Besides academics Frank would also throw himself into situations where he was” forced to speak English.”

      learner styles??

    1. w regrets that she cannot read and write it anymore. Lizzy says that her speaking and listening is strong, but she struggles still in reading and writing. While her reading and writing are weak, this also may be due to factors outside of her language since she does have an IEP as well

      learner styles???

    1. She also noted that in the beginning of the fifth grade, she was undergoing a long silent period, mostly because she did not comprehend what was going on. In that time, she was observing the class around her. By the middle the of year, things started to make sense and by the end of the year, she was actively participating in class.

      what could you infer from this/these stage(s)

    2. Prior to learning English, her L1 was Korean, her L2, which was forgotten, was Portuguese, and her L3 was Spanish. She said that in Korean, the sentence structure is subject, object, word, while in English and Spanish, sentences follow a subject, verb, object order

      I wonder how much is due to formal instruction

    1. They are confident, more motivated, take risks, which results in the willingness to learn and communicate with others

      why do you think so? why is there a difference beased on the grade/age?

    2. As educators it’s very important to consider student’s personality factors such as self-esteem, anxiety, inhibitions, motivations when teaching a second language.

      because....

    1. While his scores in both modalities improved, his confidence in both areas is much lower than in his speaking and listening abilities.

      why do you think this is the case?

    2. e likes the informal setting and feels like it’s easier than school; it’s less pressure. Regarding the NYSESLAT, his improvement to Transitioning was on the back of his Listening and Speaking, but his reading and writing left room for improvement.

      so what about his learning styles?

    3. “p” for “b” (blease/please, bush/push) and “v” for “f” (fery/very, fideo/video) because “p” and “v” don’t exist in the Arabic alphabet.

      can you guess why? (I mean, if you know about the phonetics features that make these sounds harder for Arabic speakers)

    1. activities and resources that helped him to learn the language similar to the previous students he identified music and learning lyrics as major factor that helped him, also, T.V shows and interestingly he pointed out that social media (face-book and twitter) helped him learn the language faster because what he read was “short and easy to read

      learning styles?

    2. She also noted that You-tube videos could be credited to her learning English, she enjoys watching tutorials and music videos with the lyrics so she can sing and learn the words. Another activity Mari recounted was the afterschool program her parents signed her up for; she enjoyed the art class and dance class she is a part of.

      based on these activities, what can you suggest about learning styes?

  2. Apr 2018
    1. I am not overtly conscious of myself when I speak.” the two fourth graders responded with either 5 or 4 because they were in an environment that they feel comfortable: close friends and majority of their classmates them were in the same classes prior years so they are not afraid to make mistake or be judged. The seventh grader who responded with a 1 (strongly disagree) because it makes her feel uncomfortable and upset.

      interesting the role age factor is playing here

    1. And she replied that Nursing was more practical and realistic.

      Regarding the styles that you have indicated, what type of strategies do you think could be benefitial for her?

    1. From my conversations with both my students it seems like repeated social interaction in english is a major key to acquiring the language. Being pushed outside their comfort zones, or speaking the language out of necessity to interact with students of different cultures is something that I think is an incredible phenomenon that happens at my school. Moving forward with my own teaching I plan to use grouping more effectively. From Hannah’s story in particular I think that in the long term, my students can benefit greatly from being pushed out of their comfort zones and force themselves to use english as a common ground to interact with their peers.

      what about the role of learning styles in second language acquisition???

    1. Another factor was different grade levels. There was one student who passed the exam the first time she took it, whereas, the other two students I interviewed passed the test after 2 and 5 times respectively.

      huge diverse student body

    1. Vygotsky scaffolds techniques

      Taking into account Vigotsky theory - you can underline the most relevant social factors and possible strategies for the language teacher??

    1. The article also has a model called the socio-educational model that was drawm by Gardner and and MacIntyre in which it demonstrates how affective factors play in a role in second language acquistion.

      how could you connect this theory to the affective filter by Krashen?

    1. If the students attitude towards the new language is negative, it will take a lot longer for that student to learn the new language,. however if the attitude is positive and authentic then it becomes an a quicker process,

      maybe you can add strategies for the teacher

    2. Carol Morgan, University of Durham, Attitude change and foreign language culture learning, 23 December 2008, volume 26, issue 2, April 1993, pp. 66-75

      review citation

    3. Josef Helebrandt and Lucia T. Varona, volume editors Edwart Zlotkovski , _series_editor, Construyenc19-Puentes (BuildingBridges) Concepts and Models for Service Learningin Spanish, pg.59-65

      review citation

    4. The article also stated that the affective filter hypothesis was first purposed by Dudly and Burt back in 1977. Krashen later incorporated it into one of his 5 input hypothesis bak in 1985

      this could be very helpful in order to introduce the affective filter to the reader

    1. translanguaging scholars question the existence of discrete languages, a concept that thus belies the existence of multilingualism. The author argues that political classifications of language “can and should be distinguished from the social and structural idealizations use to study linguistic diversity.”

      I think that this article could be helpful in order to make sure you explain to the reader of your final paper what translanguaging means

    1. A recurring observation is teachers did not feel properly equipped to approach teaching long term ELLs or students with interrupted education.

      this could be perfect to give the reader of your final paper an idea / approximation of the who these students are and the current situation teachers are facing

    1. This article focuses on how cognates can be used to help develop Spanish speakers English Language.

      Related to the first article - maybe emphasize strategies for the Spanish L1

    1. Often ELLs are placed in monolingual instruction programs which are one of the least effective settings, by understanding the role of principals in this decision making, the research will help bridge the gap between language ideologies and ELL program selections.

      Does the article mention the institutional constraints? (maybe something to have in mind)

    2. the research found that Spanish speaking students were able to use their Romance language backgrounds to help assist them when deciphering vocabulary, but Chinese students were able to rely on their test-taking strategies.

      Difference in L1

    1. Article #1

      Please, review instructions: Find & summarize articles 1-3 to be used in your research paper due in class. Provide full, properly formatted APA citation for each article and 50-100 word description of the main findings.

    2. Derderian, Ani & Wang, Penny. (2012). How Culture Affects on English Language Learners’ (ELL’s) Outcomes, with Chinese and Middle Eastern Immigrant Students.  International Journal of Business and Social Science. 3.

      APA Citation??

    1. Posted on April 4, 2018April 4, 2018 by Drew PecuniaDrew.Pecunia Online Assignment #5 Articles 4-6 Article 4:   Oxford, R. L. (1997). Cooperative Learning, Collaborative Learning, and Interaction: Three Communicative Strands in the Language Classroom.The Modern Language Journal,81(4), 443-456. doi:10.1111/j.1540-4781.1997.tb05510.x   Cooperative Learning is highly structured group learning designed to enhance social development such as taking turns, actively listening, as well as, cognitive skill development.  Individuals are held accountable for their work through specific roles and individual grades, as well as group grades. The teacher is the facilitator. Cooperative Learning is more effective than individualistic learning at promoting intrinsic motivation, higher order thinking, and task achievement.  It also increases self-esteem, time on task, improves social interaction and lowers anxiety.   Collaborative Learning has a varying degree of structure and acculturates learners into knowledge communities.  The teacher provides assistance and guidance as the student engages with advanced peers or the teacher. The Zone of proximal development is used.  The emphasis is on the learning process rather than task completion.   Interaction has a varying degree of structure and enables the learner to meaningfully engage with others.  Tasks produce interaction and learning styles and group dynamics are utilized. Interaction takes the form of simulations, games, role plays, drama, and the use of electronic media.  These tasks require the use of authentic language and increase student involvement and motivation.

      50-100 word description? Summary / Synthesis

    1. Of those that agreed, they felt they didn’t care because they are trying to better themselves by learning a new language and it takes time and practice to get better. They felt the person laughing at them is ignorant because they fail to realize that people get better over time when learning and speaking a new language. The two that disagreed expressed that they would rather remain silent than to be laughed at because they don’t want to “sound stupid.

      could you identify these statements/afirmations with the learning styles from chapter 5?

    2. Lastly, statement 10, continuing learning the language outside of class, all students said they do that through using apps like DuoLingo, watching TV and Netflix, talking to people in a store, playing video games, reading, using the internet, social media and listening to music.

      more ralted to the socialization aspect of learning a language

    3. The students mentioned that it helps them learn English in “small pieces” because when there is a lot at once it’s “too much.”

      field independent vs dependent?

    1. In his mainstream class and in the ELL class, there were no speakers of his native language. By fifth grade, he was speaking and writing in English

      Would you say this is an exception?

    2. He stated that he also faces some of the same issues in his home language, more difficulty with grammar and spelling.

      it could also relate to formal instruction on the language?

    3. He says what he has the most trouble with is writing: spelling, grammar, and punctuation

      why do you think the writing was the most difficult part and not the speaking?

    1. I was motivated to learn English because I wanted to attend college and obtain a higher education.

      similar goals/objective as the ones your students mentioned previously

    2. we spoke about the importance of not being overly conscious when speaking, making mistakes is part of the language learning process and is also a way to learn something new about the language.

      great discussion!

    3. the students and I had the opportunity to discuss the learning styles survey as a class, and I was very curious to ask them more about their personal opinions about the different statements and hear from the students that agreed and the students that disagreed on what was being said.

      I think this discussion is also very important in order to make students aware of what you are trying to do

    4. Ten out of he eleven students report that they are motivated to learn the English language because they want to be able to get good paying jobs, communicate with others and pass the English regents exam.

      I am interested in knowing about the other student

    5. The fact that the majority of the students view language mistakes as a learning experience is crucial for the overall language acquisition process.

      yes! this is crucial

    1. I pointed out to Jullee that this was whether she knew it or not, very beneficial to her own education and language acquisition. It is only when we can teach another person on a particular topic that we can attain mastery of that subject.

      Related to the different metacognitive strategies

    2. She would go to after school programs like glee and drama and speak English with other students her age

      I am guessing these activities are not related to the school she attended, right?

    1. “These teachers expressed a preference for correcting L2 errors in the language arts class and tended to correct more errors earlier in the school year than later”

      good sign!

    1. I also like to try and encourage my students to fix their mistakes without me giving them the answer. That is why I try to use elicitation and clarification.

      why is this important to you?

    1. Major of the repairs were by the teacher, since the students were in the editing process of their writing, the teacher need to provide some of the grammatical support in order for their writing have meaning

      Do you think this was the most effective one? and why?

    1. I think it’s the most effective way of correction because you are asking the student to stop and notice the mistake made without the teacher telling the student and  directly correcting the mistake.

      do you think that they are metalinguistically concious?

    1. he benefit of the recast feedback is that the student is able to hear the correct wording of a specific phrase without being made to feel wrong.

      good abservation

    1. When I ask my friends, I don’t feel as bad because they are my friends and they show me I can do it.

      the community environement was/is very important for this student

  3. Mar 2018
    1. Vocabulary learning from reading: examining interactions between task and learner related variables Author(s): Xiaoli Wu, Joost Lowyck, Lies Sercu and Jan Elen Source: European Journal of Psychology of Education, Vol. 28, No. 2 (June 2013), pp. 255- 274 Published by: Springer

      Review APA citation

    1. At the end of the study the results revealed that student writing improved significantly more if they had to correct their own errors versus the teacher handing back writing with the corrections made for them.

      yes! por curiosidad - where ELL an homogeneous group?

    1. The two approaches are compared and contrasted to each other to decipher the more effective strategies in regards to maintaining literary fluency in the language learners first language.

      maybe you can introduce the differences but focus on the US?

    2. of guided practices as an instructional tool to have students write contrast-comparison essays in ESL.

      how do you think you can conect this to the Mnemonic strategies?

    1. the book explains the reasons why many of these traditional ways of teaching needs to change.

      This could work as your introduction - why the traditional way is not working and how there is a need to include social and cultural aspects for a meaningful learning process

    1. The articles explain that issues can arise in execution of teaching and meaningful learning

      what are the main issues? Since it is a recent article, could you connect these issues as themes through the articles?

    1. f explicit or implicit knowledge

      explicit vs implicit learning is a crucial distinction, maybe you can five different examples regarding this distinctions at different levels such as learning vocabulary / lexicon and grammar structures?

    1. Many schools that have adopted the dual language immersion programs have bee unsure on how to properly implement the program and therefore revert to to its original English only program

      important consequence to mention

    1. the various challenges educators face with implementing dual language and suggested practices to remedy the challenges

      you can select some of the challenge for your paper as different themes to talk about

    1. The association had stated “However, given the risk that language disorders pose for students, children need to be assessed for language difficulties early and monitored periodically at critical educational stages

      assessment could be another theme

    2. Raul F. Prezas and Ahyea A. Jo PhD. “Differentiating Language Difference and Language Disorder: Information for Teachers Working with English Language Learners in the Schools.” Journal of Human Services: Training, Research, and Practice 2.1 (2017): 1-22.

      check

    1. lingner, Janette. “DISTINGUISHING LANGUAGE ACQUISITION FROM LEARNING DISABILITIES.” 30 July 2015. NYC Department of Education. Division of English Language Learners and Student Support. 2 December 2017.

      Check

    2. Levie, Ronit, Galit Ben-Zvi and Dorit Ravid. “Morpho-lexical development in language impaired and typically developing Hebrew-speaking children from two SES backgrounds.” Reading and Writing 30.5 (2017): 1035-1064.

      check APA

    1. Wu, Manfred Man-fat. “Is Second Language Teaching Enslavement or Empowerment? Insights from an Hegelian Perspective.” Educational Philosophy and Theory, vol. 50, no. 1, 18 Apr. 2017, pp. 39–48., doi:10.1080/00131857.2017.1317626.

      Check APA

    1. no significant correlation between learning style preferences and instructional method.

      You could divide your your paper depending on the results - if there is a correlation vs if there is not

    1. ELA content we are teaching in a meaningful way it will equip students to write with more freedom and use more complex sentence structure

      Be relective and critical - How did the artifacts contribute to YOUR professional understanding, skills, or dispositions?

    2. support other students with different proficiency levels

      emphasis here "They use multiple modes of assessment and address their students’ diverse backgrounds, developmental needs, and English proficiency as they plan their instruction."

    3. “Planning for Standards-Based ESL and Content Instruction”

      this is Standard 3 in general - make sure to differentiate A, B & C

      first paragraph - What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address?

    4. teach language through content

      Standard 3A - Make sure you focus o "Candidates know, understand, and apply concepts, research, and best practices to plan classroom instruction in a supportive learning environment for ESOL students. Candidates plan for multi-level classrooms with learners from diverse backgrounds using standards-based ESL and content curriculum"

    1. Overall, this reflective journal was a great activity for me to see what I am struggling with as a teacher, and areas for improvement the next time that I teach this topic.

      not need to repeat

    2. This artifact contributed to my professional understanding, skills, and disposition that grammar can be taught in isolation, and should be until students have shown that they have actually mastered grammar.

      Does this alig with the standard? " hey understand that language is developed most effectively in meaningful contexts, and they manage and implement learning around both subject matter and language learning objectives. They use meaningful instruction to build relevant academic vocabulary"

    3. This artifact highlights the perquisite of what students needed to know in order to be successful in their writing. In that, being able to identify different parts of a sentence and knowing how grammar works will not only aid in the language, but it will also help students to be successful in their content area.

      how do you demonstrate the part "developing and Integrating listening, apeaking, reading and wirting..."

    4. this specific lesson

      content? relate to the standard - "Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum by teaching language through academic content and view language and content as joint means to achieve ELLs’ academic and language development goals."

    5. This artifact closely aligns with this standard on how I have “implemented a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading and writing for a variety of social and academic purposes.”

      why? (explain the relation) (briefly)

    1. They feel that they are learning from me and they also feel comfortable with me because they see me as a person they can trust and they are not afraid to make mistakes.

      How did the artifact (the lesson plan, not the teaching) contribute to your professional understanding, skills, or dispositions?

    2. These lessons show how I managed and implemented a variety of standards-based strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English in listening, speaking, reading and writing for academic purpose.

      YES! You may want to indicate the content/gal of the lesson (briefly)

    1. What I appreciated about this classroom observation is that it contained next steps for me to implement as an instructor moving forward.

      what are the next steps? an aexample? (How might you implement some aspect of what you learned from completing this artifact (the informal observation) in the classroom?)

      Moreover, How did the artifacts contribute to YOUR professional understanding, skills, or dispositions?

    1. Their feedback is quickly discussed and then implemented into the next take. After the video is complete the students now have a token to remind them of their hard work and it can always be referred back to for review or when a word is not fully understood.

      How did the artifacts contribute to YOUR professional understanding, skills, or dispositions?

    2.  After learning the vocabulary for the unit, we created a video using a green screen to demonstrate the mastery of the vocabulary and use to reinforce the words.  Many of these words were tier 2 academic vocabulary that are found in many

      What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address?

    1. Allison Lazcano

      Allison, consider re-writing this reflection. (Divide your reflection in paragrpahs) Elements of the Reflective Rationale:

      Briefly describe the context in which the artifacts were produced:
      → graduate course (give the class title/code, specific assignment/project; etc.),
      → conference/workshop/school meeting (location, name, focus)
      → your own classroom (student teaching/observation/actual teaching)
      Respond to these questions in a focused narrative:  What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address? (Cite it directly in your reflection).
      How do the artifacts relate to the standard?  “How do the artifacts demonstrate that you have met the standard?”
      How did the artifacts contribute to your professional understanding, skills, or dispositions? How did it impact or change your own thinking or understanding? In what areas in your teacher development still need to grow relative to this standard?
      Did did completing these artifacts impact students and student learning? (if relevant) How might you implement some aspect of what you learned from completing these artifacts in the classroom?
      
    1. While it did not necessarily change my thinking or understanding, it did reinforce the importance of including in every lesson exercises that help students strengthen their skills in the four language modalities. 

      great!

    2. it explains and rationalizes my strategies and techniques for helping students improve their reading, writing, speaking, and listening.

      make sure to state this at the beginning

    3. I think that one of the most important aspects of my job is to create a positive learning environment where students feel comfortable enough to participate, take risks, and ask questions

      yes!

    4. , and the type of classroom environment I try to cultivate.  It also provides a detailed insight into the strategies I use to deepen student thinking and understanding, the steps I take to help students develop their academic vocabulary, and the activities I use to simultaneously teach both content and language.

      make sure to include this part of the standard - "Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading and writing for a variety of social and academic purposes."

    1. had the opportunity to practice their speaking skills when they turned and talked to their partners. I asked students to discuss amongst themselves some of the resources available to them to help them figure out how to spell a word correctly.

      you relate your artifact with the standard really well, but ow did the artifacts contribute to YOUR professional understanding, skills, or dispositions? How did it impact or change YOUR own thinking or understanding?

      How might you implement some aspect of what you learned from completing these artifacts in the classroom?

    1. “One person speaks at a time. Critique ideas, not people.” In order to more deeply impress this on students, I made a worksheet.

      again, how do the artifacts relate to the standard? “How do the artifacts demonstrate that you have met the standard?”

    2. I would remind them to be respectful and then query who or what we were being respectful for, and for the most part, I was correct and this was all that was necessary. My students worked well in their groups and the small sizes allowed me to take a more “hands off” approach to controlling them.

      again - how the artifact relates to the standard? Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading and writing for a variety of social and academic purposes. Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum by teaching language through academic content and view language and content as joint means to achieve ELLs’ academic and language development goals. They understand that language is developed most effectively in meaningful contexts, and they manage and implement learning around both subject matter and language learning objectives. They use meaningful instruction to build relevant academic vocabulary.

    3. Incorporating rules into the four modalities. Class Rules: Be respectful to yourself and others.

      Jon, make sure to first briefly describe the context in which the artifact was produced and respond to the following question: What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address? (Cite it directly in your reflection).

    1. . Students were also challenged to explain their thinking and reflect on their classmates’ comments using text evidence.

      I think that you can conect this really well with this part of the Standard " manage and implement learning around both subject matter and language learning objectives."

    2. For Standard 3b, I chose my Instruction Commentary from ESC 609/EdTPA seminar to demonstrate my ability to implement pedagogical strategies to support English Language Learners in all four modalities (listening, speaking, reading, and writing) by teaching language through academic content

      Great introduction!

    1. One area of Standard 3.b that I would like to improve on is providing standards-based reading instruction adapted to ELLs. I tend to use the same text for all of my students, with only slight modifications for my ELLs (usually a whole-text translation). However, I feel that I am doing my ELLs a disservice when I don’t honor all of the varying proficiency levels of my students. Even though I do provide texts in a variety of genres related to students’ studies in content-area classes, I need to begin to prepare annotated and abridged versions of texts to my ELLs.

      great job Jared! You have mentioned how you are thinking of implementing some aspects, but how could these modification impact students and student learning?

    1. Writing the commentary itself was tedious, but useful. It forced me to think critically about my instruction and it confirmed my belief that I have a strong rapport with my students. In reviewing the video and writing, I am reminded that the strongest aspect of my teaching is my ability to elicit and build on my students’ responses.

      make sure to address the standard - "Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading and writing for a variety of social and academic purposes. Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum by teaching language through academic content and view language and content as joint means to achieve ELLs’ academic and language development goals. They understand that language is developed most effectively in meaningful contexts, and they manage and implement learning around both subject matter and language learning objectives. They use meaningful instruction to build relevant academic vocabulary.

    2. The instructional commentary required the most work of the edTPA documents and was also the most useful. In creating this commentary, I was required to go back and watch over three hours of video of myself teaching a small group of ELLs. This process showed me what I do well; it also showed me some of the holes in my classroom management and teaching.

      make sure to add - What exact part of the standard do the artifacts address? (Cite it directly in your reflection).

    1. This means that I need to gradually push the students who are ready for a new challenge towards writing paragraphs on their own without the organizer or anchor charts for support.  

      great refection regarding the artifact's impact on students and student learning, but How did the artifacts contribute to your professional understanding, skills, or dispositions?

    2. After the professional development presentation I gave students remarked that they were suing the same TEAL paragraph in all of their classes. This will have a tremendous impact on the students writing skills because they are practicing this strategy across the contents.

      Not just writing - implement the 4 modalities since students are reading, listening & speaking ("Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading and writing for a variety of social and academic purposes")