- Mar 2024
-
drive.google.com drive.google.com
-
The video is shocking.
I agree with this
-
- Jan 2024
-
student.cs.uwaterloo.ca student.cs.uwaterloo.ca
-
This means that for every advantage a new technology offers, there is always a corresponding disadvantage. The disadvantage may exceed in importance the advantage, or the advantage may well be worth the cost.
Share an example of a technology you frequently use and share some of its advantages and disadvantages.
-
This means that every new technology benefits some and harms others
I thought this was a really interesting insight that I hadn't really thought about before.
-
You will also find that in most cases they will completely neglect to mention any of the liabilities of computers.
Why do you think we tend to only focus on the potential positives/benefits and not the potential negatives/costs?
-
-
drive.google.com drive.google.com
-
Postman’s (1995) vision for a technology educa-tion that emphasizes critically examining technology’s effects on humans
Notice that they are using a classic piece of work from Postman (1995)
-
We take a broad view of technology that includes all products ofhuman intention, from physical artifacts like pencils and windows to processesand techniques like agriculture and oil refinement.
What are the advantages and disadvantage of such a broad view? This reminds me of ML argument of crayons as technologies. [pencil; post-it; rock]
-
Technology education oughtto do more than provide students with technical skills; it should prepare themto critique the technical, psychosocial, and political dimensions of technol-ogy, both in relation to themselves and the communities to which they belong
I like this focus
-
How are stu-dents being prepared to discuss and make decisions about technologies that could havelasting impacts on their collective lives?
We need to prepare student to discuss and understand the implications of tech choices, so as to understand their impact on both individuals and society.
-
What relationshipsdo we want with technology?
What types of relationships are possible?
-
- Dec 2023
-
paultough.com paultough.com
-
What the research I’ve described here makes clear, I hope, is that the trajectory that children’s lives follow can sometimes be redirected by things that might at first seem, to the adults in their lives, to be small and insignificant. The tone of a parent’s voice. The words a teacher writes on a Post-it note. The way a math class is organized. The extra time that a mentor or a coach takes to listen to a child facing a challenge. Those personal actions can create powerful changes, and those individual changes can resonate on a national scale.
This is a great argument for the importance of a teacher's work. Through small acts, they can make a profound difference.
-
23. Solutions
What good is a solution if it doesn't get implemented?
-
They also express concern that students without the deep and broad background knowledge and fluency that affluent children generally absorb from their homes and communities first need to develop that core knowledge before they can benefit from a collaborative, project-based approach.
This is an interesting point - can you not profit from PBL if you haven't had the lived experiences of a more privileged studennt?
-
Research on both inequality across schools and tracking within schools has suggested that students in more affluent schools and top tracks are given the kind of problem-solving education that befits the future managerial class, whereas students in lower tracks and higher-poverty schools are given the kind of rule-following tasks that mirror much of factory and other working-class work.”
These insights are based on the research of Jean Anyon. She collected data in 5 different schools, that served particular social classes and noted the differences in how students are taught, based on the social class the school served.
-
“Deeper learning has historically been the province of the advantaged — those who could afford to send their children to the best private schools and to live in the most desirable school districts,”
This reminds me of the John Dewey quote: "What the best and wisest parent wants for his child, that must we want for all the children of the community. Anything less is unlovely, and left unchecked, destroys our democracy.”
-
develop not just students’ content knowledge and intellectual ability, but their noncognitive capacities
Focus should not be on just on learning stuff, but also on developing a willingness to keep trying in the face of obstacles or setbacks.
-
When most of our current pedagogical practices were developed more than a century ago, the essential economic purpose of public schools was to produce industrial workers who were fast and reliable when assigned repetitive mechanical or clerical tasks. In this century, deeper-learning proponents argue, the job market requires a very different set of skills, one that our current educational system is not configured to help students develop: the ability to work in teams, to present ideas to a group, to write effectively, to think deeply and analytically about problems, to take information and techniques learned in one context and adapt them to a new and unfamiliar problem or situation.
Important point - the way that we have traditionally taught are a reflection of a different world. Yes...there has been that little evolution in how we teach!
-
student-centered learning
this is a contrast to teacher-centered practices
-
22. Deeper Learning
I appreciate how helping children succeeding is encouraging us to think about providing more engaging learning opportunities.
-
But students in schools serving mostly low-income children were almost all (91 percent) in classrooms marked by basic, uninteresting teaching.
Think back to your SL school's SARC report - is you school serving mostly low-income students?
-
And while the Science authors found instruction to be basic and repetitive even in American schools with a mostly middle-class or upper-middle-class student population, they found that the situation was considerably worse in schools that enrolled a lot of low-income children.
How do you think this finding impacts other aspects of classroom life - like motivation and classroom management?
-
Pianta’s researchers found that in almost every school they observed, the instruction students received was repetitive and undemanding, limited mostly to the endless practice of basic skills.
This is depressing. Do you feel that this is true about the instruction that you observed in your SL placement?
-
21. Challenge
I wonder how this is related to persistance.
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
- Nov 2023
-
paultough.com paultough.com
-
heir crew is the place at school where they most feel a sense of belonging; for some of them, it’s the place where they most feel a sense of belonging, period.
Working to establish intentional relationships
-
Turnaround’s coaches eventually persuaded the teachers, after months of professional-development sessions, classroom observations, and one-on-one conversations, that giving students more opportunity to experience autonomy, and to engage more deeply in their own learning, would actually make the climate in the classrooms calmer, not crazier.
If you haven't been given autonomy, it is harder to give it to others.
-
Giving students more autonomy in their learning meant giving up control — handing over the reins of the classroom
I think JCOS is a good example fo a school giving students more autonomy.
-
helping teachers create and communicate clear expectations and rules, and consistent consequences for violating those rules, and providing them with tools to help de-escalate conflicts when they did arise.
Important things to establish from the beginning
-
the coaches gave teachers strategies designed to help them build a “positive emotional climate” and show “sensitivity to student needs for autonomy.”
This makes me think of the parent education written about earlier in this book.
-
when teachers are trained in how to create a better environment in the classroom, that can have a measurable effect on student performance.
What does that better environment look like?
-
At the same time, Turnaround’s staff works to improve the classroom environment as a whole, coaching teachers on strategies to improve students’ academic outcomes by improving their experience in class.
Like how Turnaround works with both students and teachers to make change.
-
tries to address similar wounds
trying to heal wounds....
-
BAM groups
Notice how these resources are being integrated into schools.
-
BAM seems to work by influencing the important mental functions that a stress-filled childhood tends to impair, like impulse control and the ability to successfully manage aggressive feelings.
This is evidence that it is possible to overcome a less than desirable early childhood.
-
19. Relationships
building trust through relationships
-
early adversity, growing up in difficult circumstances often has an effect on children’s mental representations of the world as well
Has an impact on how children see themselves and their place in the world.
-
18. Mindsets
Once a mind is "set" - how changeable is it?
-
I belong in this academic community; My ability and competence grow with my effort; I can succeed at this; and This work has value for me.
Farrington's 4 academic mindsets
-
key factor behind academic perseverance was students’ academic mindset — the attitudes and self-perceptions
Academic Mindset = attitudes + self-perceptsion
-
act gritty
Interesting distinction - being gritty vs. acting gritty
-
all students are more likely to demonstrate perseverance if the school or classroom context helps them develop positive mindsets and effective learning strategies.”
How can we. help students develop positive mindsets and effective learning strategies?
-
If they hear the message that a failure is a final verdict on their ability, they may well give up and pull back from school. But if instead they get the message that a failure is a temporary stumble, or even a valuable opportunity to learn and improve, then that setback is more likely to propel them to invest more of themselves in their education.
Are these the only two types of messages a student can receive in response to their failure?
-
She was particularly interested in what she called the “narrative” that exists within each school with regard to success and failure — the messages, subtle and not so subtle, that students receive when they fai
What is the "narrative" at your SL school that a student receives when they fail?
-
17. Messages
An examination of the messages teachers send to students - intentionally or not.
-
spending a few hours each week in close proximity to a certain kind of teacher changed something about their behavior.
What kind of teacher do you think has this kind of impact?
-
institutional structures affect individual behavior and, specifically, how certain educational structures — like school funding mechanisms, teacher contracts, or patterns of segregation — might incline students toward success or failure.
So Farrington was looking at the issue from a individual level (psych), as well as more societal/institutional level (sociology)
-
eachers convey to their students deep messages — often implicitly or even subliminally — about belonging, connection, ability, and opportunity.
What does this communication look like?
-
you can’t clearly identify and measure skills, it’s hard to convince people to take them seriousl
This is a critique with a priority being placed on data based decisions.
-
And perhaps what students need more than anything for these positive academic habits to flourish is to spend as much time as possible in environments where they feel a sense of belonging, independence, and growth
Wow, this seems like it would require a drastic change in school environments.
-
16. Assessment
I wonder what the connection will be between motivation and assessment!
-
And they feel a sense of relatedness when they perceive that their teachers like and value and respect them.
relatedness is only about relationship between teachers and students - what about student to student relationships?
-
Deci and Ryan acknowledge that many of the tasks that teachers ask students to complete each day are not inherently fun or satisfying; it is the rare student who feels a deep sense of intrinsic motivation when memorizing her multiplication tables.
What difference would it make if the things students were asked to do was inherently fun and satisfying?
-
How do we motivate low-income children to work harder and persevere in school? Or, digging deeper: How do we motivate anybody to do anything?
ideally motivation is internal not external
-
The more books students read that summer, the more money they received.
This reminds me of some summer reading programs where prizes were based on the number of books read.
-
behaviorist approach
If your school using PBIS, it is very much based on behaviorism
-
14. Incentives
Incentives = rewards?
-
12. Building Blocks
What do you predict are the building blocks that author Tough is writing about in this chapter?
-
Given that neurobiological context, it’s hard to argue that an out-of-school suspension will do much to improve that student’s ability to self-regulate.
Yes, solution does not help to address underlying issues and makes for more problems - academic ones.
-
Talking back and acting up in class are, at least in part, symptoms of a child’s inability to control impulses, de-escalate confrontations, and manage anger and other strong feelings — the whole stew of self-regulation issues that can usually be traced to impaired executive-function development in early childhood.
Identifies some of the behaviors that results from an inability to self-regulate
-
And suspension rates are substantially higher among certain demographic groups
Learn more about CA new law regarding school Suspensions and expulsions: [SB 274 Skinner via ED100] https://ed100.org/blog/2023-pass-fail-veto
-
Most American schools today operate according to a philosophy of discipline that has its roots in the 1980s and 1990s
Remember that suspension/expulsion rates need to be reported by schools in their SARC report.
-
far from rational.
Implication - children's behavior may not reflect rational choices
-
assume
Why it's important to check our assumptions.
-
In reality, though, many schools and school systems look at students who are struggling in those areas and instead think: How do we discipline them?
Based on your SL experiences, do you agree that most schools prioritze discipling rather than helping kids to attach, bond, deal with stress, and self-regulate?
-
13. Discipline
Why do you predict that author Tough is starting our consideration of helping to build necessary skills and mindsets with a chapter on DISCIPLINE?
-
How exactly do the neurobiological adaptations that result from an adverse early childhood evolve into the social and academic struggles that so many disadvantaged students experience in school? How do most schools deal with those students? And what alternative approaches might produce better results?
Author Tough is identifying the focus and purpose of the rest of the book.
-
When educators neither prioritize these skills and mindsets nor integrate them with academic development, students are left without tools for engagement or a language for learning,
Take-away point - we, as educators, need to know how to prioritize these skills and mindsets.
-
Which means that when children arrive in kindergarten without these foundational skills, there are often few resources in place to help kids develop them, and school administrators are often at a loss to know how to help.
What are the FOUNDATIONAL SKILLS that author Tough is referring to?
-
hat creates more stress, which often feeds into behavior problems, which leads, in the classroom, to stigmatization and punishment, which keeps their stress levels elevated, which makes it still harder to concentrate — and so on, and so on, throughout elementary school.
How do we break this doom loop?
-
Which means that neurocognitive dysfunctions can quickly become academic dysfunctions.
connection between brain development and school-based learning
-
early warmth and responsiveness send the opposite message: You’re safe. Life is going to be fine. Let down your guard; the people around you will protect you and provide for you. Be curious about the world; it’s full of fascinating surprises. These signals trigger adaptations in children’s brains that allow them to slow down and consider problems and decisions more carefully, to focus their attention for longer periods, and to more willingly trade immediate gratification for promises of long-term benefits.
The benefits of a stable, warm, and responsive childhood
-
public becomes legally responsible for every child’s education and skill development.
corresponds with Ericson's idea that school represents a child's entrance into life.
-
- Oct 2023
-
paultough.com paultough.com
-
But other programs based on similar psychological principles seek to transform the environments where children spend time outside the home in their early years.
Focus is now on what to do to help children succeed.
-
“serve-and-return is going on even in the most adverse home circumstances. Rather than get preoccupied in these homes with what parents are doing wrong, we just zero in on this one positive moment, and then we make the moment salient to parents by slowing things way down.
the importance of building parent confidence
-
By drawing attention to and praising the moments that promote connection and attachment
Making the "invisible" visible
-
It appears to be relatively easy to support and counsel disadvantaged parents in ways that make them much more likely to adopt an attachment-promoting approach to parenting.
Is there a window when this needs to be taught?
-
as many low-income parents do, it’s not easy on your own to nurture in your children a rich vocabulary.
oh, the rich get richer - aka "The Matthew Effect"
-
experimental programs to try and narrow those gaps by encouraging low-income parents to read and talk more with their children. But it’s hard to find reliable evidence that programs like these result in long-term improvements in the language abilities of disadvantaged children.
I wonder why this didn't necessarily result in long-term improvements.
-
Well-off kids have on average more access to books and other printed materials; just as important, their parents speak to them more than low-income parents speak to their children — by some estimates, far more — and the speech they use is more complex.
Noted advantages that mean starting school ahead.
-
In most families, there was no significant impact of the home visits on the children’s mental development or school outcomes,
early focus on health based home visits didn't necessarily impact school outcomes - interesting.
-
hich kind of parental behaviors matter most, and which kind of direction or instruction from home visitors is most likely to incline disadvantaged parents to adopt those behaviors?
This would offer insights into early parent education.
-
But the educational value of pre-K for children who aren’t poor is still in dispute; studies have found little or no positive effect (or even a negative effect) of universal pre-K programs on the skills of well-off children.
Interesting, I didn't realize this. I wonder if this is because of the type of TK we offer.
-
generally means programs for four-year-olds (and a few three-year-olds) that are focused on academic skill building.
Is this true of the TK classes you've seen?
-
in one recent international ranking, the United States placed 31st out of a group of 32 developed nations in the proportion of total public spending on social services that goes to early childhood.
Shameful. Why don't we, as a country, seize the opportunity to lay strong foundations?
-
the years before a child’s sixth birthday
This is why TK and Early Childhood Ed is so important
-
hat childhood is a continuum, and if we want to help improve outcomes for disadvantaged children, we need to look for opportunities to intervene in positive ways at many different points along that continuum
I'm glad that Tough reminded us of this point. I like the idea that interventions should be occurring in multiple places - not a one shot deal.
-
- Sep 2023
-
paultough.com paultough.com
-
These researchers have concluded that the primary mechanism through which children’s environments affect their development is stress.
This is interesting because there seems to be a lot more stress these days.
-
we tend to divide childhood into a series of discrete chapters
I understand this to be referring to the stages of development that we often focus on. Our that way that we think about early childhood, childhood, adolescence, etc.
-
My premise is that no program or school is perfect, but that each successful intervention contains some clues about how and why it works that can inform the rest of the field. My goal is to extract and explain the core principles of each program I write about and look for common threads running through them.
Author's goal is to figure out what makes a program work and see if that's true for other successful programs.
-
Scaling up doesn’t work as well in social service and education as it does in the tech world.
I wonder why scaling up- taking something that seems to be working and offering it on a larger scale - doesn't work as well in social service or education.
-
- Sep 2022
-
inst-fs-pdx-prod.inscloudgate.net inst-fs-pdx-prod.inscloudgate.netview11
-
were moderated by color-blind attitudes
we have this here too
-
no overall changes in levels of empathy.
why not/
-
Interracial contact is not unhelpful, but by itself may not improveattitudes.
Not sure what to make of this - seems counter intuitive.
-
positive racial attitudes can bedeveloped best by directly confronting children’s actual questions and assumptions aboutrace, racism, and differences they see among people
where do kids have the opportunity to engage in such conversations - esp conversations that are lead by skilled facilitators?
-
Least effective were stories or lessons that featured another racial orethnic group
This was not an effective way to change attitudes - towards others??? not clear
-
Ginwright argues that cultural identity is important, but that we need to attend tointersections between race, culture, and class
Importance of Intersectionality
-
Math in a Cultural Context (MCC)
Is this ethnic studies?
-
MAS improved the achievement of mainl
Did the curriculum have an impact on other groups? Or were the only students taking this class Mexican American?
-
impact of ethnic studies on students poses a challenge
There are challenges in how researchers measure the impact of ethnic studies. Therefore many research seems to highlight traditional outcomes like retention rates and achievement on standardized test.
-
Some curriculum projects in thisreview exemplified all or most of the hallmarks, most often the creation of curriculum fromperspectives of specific marginalized and/or colonized groups. After that, there is widevariation
Ethnic studies can mean very different things
-
Several state and local affiliates are already engaged in laying the curricular, legislative andpolicy foundation to integrate research-based ethnic studies into K-12 schools and highereducation. Increasingly, we are seeing campaigns organized by educators and communitypartners to require schools to offer ethnic studies courses
Seems like this point is outdated. Thinking about what’s going on in places like Florida.
-
- Apr 2020
-
www.commonsense.org www.commonsense.org
-
Ensure your most vulnerable students and their families are supported during the school closures.
From your perspective, is this sufficient support?
-
-
www.tolerance.org www.tolerance.org
-
Are there any specific resources, articles or other information you recommend?
Seems like a useful list of resources.
-
Finally, we understand that in other countries, rates of domestic violence and child abuse have increased during the COVID-19 crisis. Stress and increased isolation are risk factors for abuse. Families experiencing difficult financial issues or job loss during this time might be especially at risk. But all families will be under increased stress and isolation with varying levels of support and resources.
This is one of the scariest and most unfortunate aspects of the current situation that we have to deal with. Will probably only get worse as people's economic situation get worse - esp since the govt is doing much to provide additional financial support (though the stimulus checks are a start).
-
how kids might respond to stress and consider how stress might play out by age group
This seems like an important point and something to look into further.
-
students who have had anxiety; students who have depression or suicidal ideation; students who have learning and attention disorders; students whose families may have lost jobs or income; students who have loved ones particularly vulnerable to the COVID-19 virus; students who have a caregiver who is a healthcare worker or in another occupation where they are exposed to the virus or are being asked to respond in an intense way; students who may be less supervised because of caregivers’ work.
I thought that this list expended, for me, situations that I need to be aware of and take into account. Are there others that you'd add to the list?
-
Four-corner breathing simply involves inhaling deeply and exhaling deeply four times. Students can complete this breathing exercise by standing up and taking one inhale and exhale breath while facing each of the four corners in a room.
This seems like it would even be good to do in face-to-face classrooms - when we're able to return!
-
n work with students right now, educators should let relationships be the focus
I agree with this, but see the major challenge as being able to reach those students who don't have reliable access to technology or the internet. This is a major cause of worry.
-