eLife Assessment
This study presents important findings on the insecticidal mechanism of betulin, a plant-derived metabolite, in controlling the aphid Myzus persicae and it provides a demonstration that betulin targets the GABA receptor in aphids, with strong supporting evidence from transcriptomic, biochemical, electrophysiological, and genetic approaches. In particular, the identification of a specific conserved residue (THR228) critical for betulin binding advances our understanding of insect neuropharmacology and offers translational potential for pest management strategies. The evidence supporting the primary claims is solid, with well-integrated methodologies and appropriate controls; however, some interpretative and methodological limitations remain, including the option to further explore off-target effects, as well as the broader evolutionary and ecological context. Addressing these points would strengthen the broader implications of the study.