975 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2015
    1. the Christian Indians

      were they unwillingly converted? seems like a good reason to revolt...

    2. only Heaven can reward your reverence, though I do not doubt that his Majesty (may God keep him) will do so.

      only heaven can give you a true reward, but the King will probably also give you a material reward, so don't worry!

    1. Even to the last, I could not convince the Indians that we were of the Christians...

      the Natives trust de Vaca & his people, and can't imagine them being associated with the cruelty of the other Christians

    2. who must be obeyed and served,

      they think quite a lot of themselves, these other Christians. they seem jealous of the relationship de Vaca and his comrades have formed with the Natives

    3. the Indians being ever diligent to bring us all they could.

      taking advantage of the Natives' kindness & seeing them as servants

    4. and given them to the Christians,

      okay, they're not objects...

    1. they must be won by kindness, which is a way certain, and no other is.

      a different approach than most explorers/conquerers took. he's seeing them as people and thinks they should be treated accordingly

    2. but preferred to die rather than live in dread of such cruel usage as they received

      this is incredibly sad

    3. they looked as though they would willingly die.

      wow...

    4. The sight was one of infinite pain to us

      to see such beautiful/useful land go to waste?

    5. hearing more of Christians.

      how does he know these men were Christians?

    6. we gave many thanks to God our Lord

      of course you did

    7. he answered that they came from heaven.

      the Natives see the explorers as god-like

    8. over six hundred open hearts of deer.'

      thats a lot of deer hearts....

    1. they place their houses on the skirt of a wood, the thickest and most tangled they can find, and near it make a ditch in which they sleep.

      use the land as a resource & almost as a weapon

    2. When no longer offended and their anger is gone, they return. From that time they are friends as if nothing had happened

      they've gotten it out of their systems & are over it

    3. until their heat has subsided.

      cooling off

    4. they strike each other with the fists, fighting until ex- hausted, and then separate.

      facing their problems like men!

    5. It is com- mon among them all to leave their wives when there is no conformity, and directly they connect themselves with whom they please.

      oh?

    6. the Indians leave him to perish, unless it be a son or a brother; him they will assist, even to carrying on their back.

      leave the weak behind, unless they are family

    7. in seasons of scarcity, the children were allowed to suckle, that they might not famish

      yeah, but how can the mothers keep producing milk for that long? especially with poor nutrition/not enough food?

    8. The children are suckled until the age of twelve years, when they are old enough to get sup- port for themselves.

      wow...12 is when a child can finally feed themselves in this culture? that's a long time to be dependent...especially considering that the life expectancy probably wasn't that high

    1. On one occasion while I slept, the fire fell upon the straw, when it began to blaze so rapidly that not- T^-ithstanding the haste I made to get out of it,

      yikes! not a pleasant way to wake up!

    2. while walking naked as I was born.

      why does he have no clothes?

    3. I was detained some time.

      you mean you were lost, de Vaca

    4. for every day went on increasing his compassion and his gifts.

      the Natives' compassion and gifts are growing every day...thank them!

    5. many came to us that night sick

      hypochondriacs

    1. sat down among us, and from the sorrow and pity they felt, they all began to lament so earnestly that they might have been heard at a dis- tance, and continued so doing more than half an hour.

      they feel this loss so deeply, even though it is not their own. and yet, they are "barbarians"

    2. but when they saw us thus, in a plight so different from what it was before, and so extraordinary, they were alarmed and turned back.

      its strange that they turn back after seeing the Europeans in a weaker and more helpless state

    1. He answered that it was no longer a time in which one should com- mand another] but that each should do what he thought best to save his own life

      everyone is on their own. things are getting serious

    2. He answered saying that could not be done, because the boat was far to sea and he wished to reach the shore

      no, we can't go help the others because the Governor doesn't want to

    3. They entreated us to go with them, and said they would give us the Christ- ians, water, and many other things

      sounds like a trap to me

    4. and of more authority and condition than any we had hitherto seen

      that would be why they are chiefs...

    5. The Governor replied that he would give up the hostages when they should bring the Christians they had taken.

      we'll trade you!

    1. In the boat

      did they figure out how to build boats?

    2. more than forty men of disease and hunger

      how many were there to begin with?

    3. we knew not how to construct, nor were there tools, nor iron, nor forge, nor tow, nor resin, nor rigging; finally, no one thing of so many that are necessary, nor any man who had a knowledge of their manufacture; and, above all, there -was nothing to eat, while building, for those who should labor...

      soo....they've got nothing.

    4. and could pass out of it only through death,

      that's not very optimistic

    5. and that whatever might happen to one should be the lot of all, without any forsaking the rest.

      they're a team

    6. that of the persons mounted, the greater part commenced secretly to plot, hoping to secure a better fate for themselves by abandoning the Governor and the sick, who were in a state of weak- ness and prostration.

      survival of the fittest! abandon the weak!

    7. Grod,

      praise Grod!

    8. There were not horses enough to carry the sick, who went on increas- ing in numhers day hy day, and we knew of no cure.

      the Europeans are sick as opposed to the Natives...interesting

    9. to the place I had visited.

      he's been here before?

    1. They are of admirable proportions, very spare and of great activity and strength.

      they are intimidating...maybe this is why he thinks of them as barbarians

    2. com- manded the cavalry to dismount and charge the In- dians on foot.

      mmm....doesn't seem like a great idea.

    3. the people beyond were less numerous and poorer, the land little occupied, and the inhabitants much scattered ; that thenceforward were great lakes, dense forests, immense deserts and solitudes

      how could he have possibly gathered all this info from the Natives? did they speak his language?

    4. As we sallied they fled to the lakes near by, because of which and the large maize fields, we could do them no injury

      the Natives have an advantage because they know the land

    5. asking for their women and children, whom we re- leased

      oh, by the way, we captured all Native women and children! but let me keep talking about animals...

    6. very cold.

      he's clearly never been to New England...

    7. the Gelves

      the Gelves?

    1. truth

      there is no TRUTH!!!

    2. and for some persons difficult to believe, nevertheless they may without hesitation credit me as strictly faithful. Better than to exaggerate, I have lessened in all things, and it is sufficient to say the relation is offered to your Majesty for truth.

      he's telling the truth, okay?!?

    3. and bring them to a know- ledge of the true faith and true Lord,

      heavily focused on religion...I'm assuming Christianity. seems very passionate about seeking to convert the "barbarians"

    4. it might testify to my exertion in the royal behalf.

      makes it seem like the whole of his experiences is solely in service of/for the crown

    5. To me, one only duty remains, to present a relation of what was seen and heard in the ten years I wandered lost

      ten years?! wow...

    6. that I should not have to speak in order to be reckoned among those who for diligence and fidelity in affairs your Majesty honors.

      his legacy speaks for him

    7. but coming in the providence of God and solely by His will.

      so fortunate people are blessed by God and unfortunate people can't do anything about their circumstances b/c God did not choose them to be the fortunate ones? hmm...

    1. extreme of blackness

      what is "extreme blackness" to him? he's lived his whole life with pretty much whit europeans

    2. that I have come to another conclusion respecting the Earth

      what authority does he have to say this? I mean, come on.

    1. the inhabitants on discovering us abandoned their houses, and took to flight, carrying of their goods to the mountain.

      smart people!

    2. penetrate

      not a good enough reason to use the word "penetrate"

    3. This is so beautiful a place

      he repeatedly mentions the beauty of the place, but refuses to just appreciate the beauty of the land and its people for what they are. he has to take it, own it, and change it.

    4. The Indians on board the ships called this island Saomete. I named it Isabela.

      completely disrespects the name that the Natives have given the island

    5. seemed to take great pleasure in serving us.

      because they don't know how evil they are yet

    6. It appeared to them that we were honest people

      appearances can be deceiving!

    7. where I gave it the name of Santa Maria de la Concepcion

      okay, so he's just making up his own names for places

    8. San Salvador

      from where? did he just make up a Spanish name for the places he is "discovering"?

    9. I could conquer the whole of them with fifty men, and govern them as I pleased.

      Wow...bold statement.

    10. if they had any gold

      greedy

    11. wrought in a wonderful manner considering the country

      already speaking as if he is above/better than the native people

    12. and would be good servants and I am of opinion that they would very readily become Christians, as they appear to have no religion

      how does he gather all this information? just by looking at them?

    13. Weapons they have none

      none that you know of. no European weapons.

    14. coarse like that of a horse’s tail

      already comparing them to animals

    15. that he before all others took possession (as in fact he did) of that island for the King and Queen his sovereigns, making the requisite declarations, which are more at large set down here in writing.

      he claims the piece of land before even stepping foot on said land? hmm...

    16. At two o’clock in the morning the land was discovered, at two leagues’ distance;

      finally!

    17. a piece of cane

      sugar cane?

    18. for the Admiral had given orders to that effect.

      so much lying about seeing land! or are they hallucinating?

    19. the needles

      by needles he means compass, right?

    20. Those on board the Nina ascended the rigging, and all declared they saw land. The Admiral also thought it was land,

      the power of suggestion!

    21. demanded of the Admiral a reward for his intelligence.

      seems a bit greedy...

    22. Part of the day saw no weeds, afterwards great plenty of it.

      exciting!

    23. Saw a whale, an indication of land, as they always keep near the coast.

      Do whales keep to the coast?

    24. Here the pilots found their places upon the chart: the reckoning of the Nina made her four hundred and forty leagues distant from the Canaries, that of the Pinta four hundred and twenty, that of the Admiral four hundred.

      how are the three ships communicating with each other if they are this far apart?

    25. the seamen were terrified

      why?

    26. saw a large fragment of the mast of a vessel

      that can't be a good sign

    27. that the crew might not be dismayed if the voyage should prove long.

      did they not know that the plan was to sail around the world before departing?

    28. which he affirmed he saw every year, and always of the same appearance

      well yeah...land doesn't move(at least not very quickly)

    29. perpetual Viceroy and Governor in all the islands and continents which I might discover and acquire, or which may hereafter he discovered and acquired in the ocean; and that this dignity should be inherited by my eldest son, and thus descend from degree to degree forever

      that's a lot of power...could go to someone's head...

    30. countries of India

      that's what you think!

    31. the holy Father had never granted his request, whereby great numbers of people were lost, believing in idolatry and doctrines of perdition

      conflicts over religion led to many deaths of those who weren't followers of the "right" religion

    1. would

      wish? I wish I had a husband?

    2. purely Indian

      purely Native American?

    3. Truly it would have been wise and well for those of early times if they could have held their tongues.

      curiosity killed the cat?

    4. From this day ye may feed yourselves and find your own venison, for this child shall do so no more for you.”

      she turns her back on her own people, and therefore they suffer

    5. Ye

      there's no way she actually said "ye"...too English-y

    6. For when he did but point his finger at a moose, or anything which ran, it would drop dead;

      is this reference to the use of guns?

    7. but his little eyebrows were of stone.

      poor kid!

    1. their religion.

      their religion is a cult by whose definition?

    2. Then I ate this medicine and everything changed.

      holy magic medicine!

    3. one leading to a hole in the earth and the other extending up above.

      heaven & hell?

    4. The coffin will be set before you and then you will see your body.

      a near-death experience that gives you a new perspective on life

    5. Bring whatever desires you possess along with you and then come and eat or drink this medicine. This is life, the only life. Then you will learn something about yourself, so come.

      he's preaching

    6. It is a cure for all evil.

      do they basically worship this "medicine"?

    7. ill

      he is using "ill" for being physically, mentally, and spiritually unwell

    8. now for the first time one was cured.

      he's becoming a kind of religious healer

    9. Indian doctors and then I tried all of the white man’s medicines,

      if he isn't white, why is he referring to Nat. Am. as Indians? Does he mean actual Indians from India?

    10. Winnebagoes

      his people

    11. “If I take this road I am likely to meet some people, but if I take the other road, I am not likely to meet anyone.”

      for some reason this line reminds me of "The Road Not Taken"

    12. “If I take this road I am likely to meet some people, but if I take the other road, I am not likely to meet anyone.”

      for some reason this line reminds me of "The Road Not Taken"

    13. “Let us eat peyote again to-night.”

      he's hooked!

    14. I saw a man with horns and long claws and with a spear in his hand.

      the devil?

    15. “All right, I’ll do it.”

      didn't take much convincing

    16. If only some of my own people were here!

      own people? His name is John, so is he white?

    17. the younger members who have been strongly permeated with Christian teachings translate the prayer into, “God, the Son, and the Holy Ghost.”

      interesting that Christian influences literally changed the meaning of the words of the Peyote baptism to its younger members

    18. by John Rave

      the leader

    19. parts of the Bible

      Does the Peyote religion have ties to Christianity?

    20. asking forgiveness

      forgiveness for what? their "sins"?

    21. member of the cult

      why is it considered a cult?

    22. Christmas

      was Christmas a significant holiday/day for the Peyote?

    1. Since that time white men have come to America.

      so was Glosskap the first "white man" in America?

    2. I came to this country to have my mother baptized as a Catholic.

      why?

    3. They gave him an anchor and an English flag.

      is Glooskap the first "European" to "discover" American when he returns w/ an English flag?

    4. America (England?)

      did he discover both? he just appeared in America and seemingly had European knowledge (a gun & hunting horn) and then goes to England & kind of discovers that

    5. The people had never seen a canoe before.

      flipping the script. Native American goes to England to educate the people about America. Also, white people are fascinated by a canoe vs. the traditional idea of Nat. Am. fascinated by ships.

    6. This was before the white people had ever heard of America.

      taking the power of discovery from white people

    7. and so provisioned his great canoe.

      preparing for a long journey. how did he know where he was going/how long he'd be gone?

    8. stone canoe

      why stone? doesn't seem like a great material for a boat.

    9. “Whenever you wish to kill anything, though it were half a mile off, point this stick at it.”

      is the stick a gun?

    10. A stranger

      stranger with more advanced hunting knowledge. maybe a European?

    11. Woodchuck

      tribe? not a literal woodchuck...

    12. How Glooskap went to England and France, and was the first to make America known to the Europeans.

      This could be a good text for class b/c it is a different telling of the "discovery" of America. Takes the power out of the white people's hands and into Native American's

    1. the spirit of the plant suggests to him the proper remedy.

      suggests that knowledge of medicine is a kind of magic/spiritual ability

    2. agreed to furnish a remedy for some one of the diseases named,

      medicine!

    3. ut this so enraged the others that they fell upon the Ground Squirrel and tore him with their teeth and claws,

      brutal!

    4. to make their victims dream of snakes twining about them in slimy folds and blowing their fetid breath in their faces, or to make them dream of eating raw or decaying fish, so that they would lose appetite, sicken, and die.

      seems almost like a mental disease

    5. with rheumatism, so that he, is rendered on the instant a helpless cripple

      using disease as a weapon

    6. The deer next held a council under their chief,

      do these gatherings of animals represent Nat. Am. tribes that met to discuss what to do about the Europeans colonizing their land?

    7. by cutting his claws,

      by making himself more like man, he was able to use the weapon

    8. increased so rapidly that their settlements spread over the whole earth and the poor animals found themselves beginning to be cramped for room

      pushed animals out of their native lands, just like white people did to Nat. Am.

    1. Diluting any literature, much less that of a traditionally oppressed and misun- derstood group of peoples, serves little purpose. Trying to create a multi-ethnic course or unit simply perpetuates the old Euro-American notion that everything not European must somehow be "the same" and a bit inferior

      hard to strike a good balance when attempting to study "Nat. Am. Lit"

    2. "Indians" are most familiar and recognizable when ahorse and inarticulate

      stereotypical

    3. Formulary roles, conclusions, and situations replace humanity and individual diversity.

      stereotyping has affected the way we understand Nat. Am. culture

    4. There is a danger, however, that the American reading audience may take Momaday's books as literal statements of fact rather than as the products of artistic imagination and license.

      people misinterpret an artistic expression of a Nat. Am. as cold, hard facts about their culture

    5. a Native American's "statement," though certainly not the Native American point of view

      there is no single "Native point of view"

    6. This ritualized form of lan- guage, the bastardized product of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century clerical trans- lators at treaty conferences, has become so associated with Native American utter- ance that today its usage in certain circles is practically mandatory to insure ethnic credibility.

      by telling their own perspective of Native culture, white people have ruined the culture itself by forcing their views of Native culture onto the Natives themselves

    7. unctuous

      excessively flattering

    8. confirm to the white reader that contact with Euro-Americans was the most significant event in the forty-thousand-year history of Native people on this continent

      pretty self-centered of us

    9. White writers almost invariably portray Native American cultures as fragile, regressive, deteriorating entities

      we get a false sense of who Nat. Am. are because we only learn about them through the perspectives of white people

    10. By far the greatest volume of fiction pertaining to Native Americans has been written about them by non-Natives.

      most of our knowledge about Nat. Am. culture comes from non-Natives...doesn't make much sense

    11. this little story has great impact

      we miss out on many layers of the story when it is written and not told in its original form

    12. he agreed without any clarification of the terms

      kind of a complex idea. on a first reading, w/o background knowledge, I wouldn't understand that the story is about contracts.

    13. without such knowledge, how can we, as reader or listener, penetrate to the core of meaning in an expression of literary art?

      how can we possibly understand a thing like Nat. Am. Lit if we don't understand their individual cultures & societies?

    14. amalgam

      mixture

    15. The idea of national conquest, total victory or defeat, or the development and evolution of a sophisticated military technology were conspicuously (relative to the European example) absent.

      a lack of knowledge/understanding of the concept of war & conquest contributed Nat. Am. downfall

    16. fascinating

      strange

    17. Surely these quintessentially un-European creatures (no clothes, no crosses, etc.) could not be human. Perhaps they were a new species of ape; perhaps manifested devils . . . but certainly not souls!

      that's a pretty dramatic conclusion just based on perceived superficial differences!

    18. Societal diversity was accepted, tolerated, and assumed, and each group took pride in its own distinctive features, including its own oral (literary) traditions.

      very different mindset from European nations, who generally take pride in their home country and the similarities they share, as opposed to differences

    19. But there was not, and is not.

      because there is no single common language or culture that is entirely shared btwn. Nat. Am. tribes?

    20. "Native American litera- ture,"

      because none of it is written?

    1. Since that time white men have come to America.

      so was Glosskap the first "white man" in America?

    2. I came to this country to have my mother baptized as a Catholic.

      why?

    3. They gave him an anchor and an English flag.

      is Glooskap the first "European" to "discover" American when he returns w/ an English flag?

    4. America (England?)

      did he discover both? he just appeared in America and seemingly had European knowledge (a gun & hunting horn) and then goes to England & kind of discovers that

    5. The people had never seen a canoe before.

      flipping the script. Native American goes to England to educate the people about America. Also, white people are fascinated by a canoe vs. the traditional idea of Nat. Am. fascinated by ships.

    6. This was before the white people had ever heard of America. The white men did not discover this country first at all.

      taking the power of discovery from white people

    7. and so provisioned his great canoe

      preparing for a long journey. how did he know where he was going/how long he'd be gone?

    8. stone canoe

      why stone? doesn't seem like a great material for a boat.

    9. "Whenever you wish to kill anything, though it were half a mile off, point this stick at it."

      is the stick a gun?

    10. A stranger

      stranger with more advanced hunting knowledge. maybe a European?

    11. Woodchuck

      tribe? not a literal woodchuck...

    12. How Glooskap went to England and France, and was the first to make America known to the Europeans.

      This could be a good text for class b/c it is a different telling of the "discovery" of America. Takes the power out of the white people's hands and into Native American's