10,000 Matching Annotations
  1. Last 7 days
    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The authors have provided responses and additional data, but these revisions have not adequately resolved the major concerns raised in my previous review. In particular, the evidence supporting the central premise of the study-the structural and functional relationship between polyQ assemblies and the Golgi apparatus-remains insufficient. Much of the cell biological evidence is descriptive, and the observations are not integrated into a convincing mechanistic model. Most importantly, the proposed polyQ HTT-induced Golgi dysfunction (Golgipathy) has not been convincingly established. Several findings could be alternatively explained by the association of polyQ HTT with the Golgi and the Golgi's known sensitivity to cellular perturbations. Significant concerns also remain regarding the interpretation and quantification of microscopy images, as well as the clarity of several figures. Consequently, my overall assessment remains unchanged.

      Comments on the Authors' Responses

      (1) Golgi localization of polyQ HTT

      This is a central claim of the study and therefore requires particularly rigorous and convincing evidence. Although the authors have performed additional immunostaining using different HTT antibodies, the EGFP-tagged HTT exon 1 fragments do not appear to localize to the Golgi. Why did the authors not examine the localization of EGFP-tagged full-length HTT containing an expanded polyQ tract? Such an experiment would provide an important independent validation of their immunostaining results.

      (2) 3D rendering

      This concern has not been adequately addressed. Since the authors acknowledge that the vasculature-like features are artifacts, these features should be removed to avoid misleading readers. Furthermore, it remains difficult to correlate the rendered structures with the corresponding boxed regions in the original fluorescence images.

      (3) Quantification of area and volume

      This concern remains unresolved. If polyQ assemblies consist of fine meshworks with features below the optical resolution, these structures would appear as continuous fluorescent regions rather than resolvable networks. Consequently, the measured fluorescent area or volume would not accurately represent the physical space occupied by the assemblies.

      (4) Interpretation of structural features

      This concern has not been adequately addressed. The proposed spindle-like and ring-like structures remain difficult to distinguish convincingly in the presented images.

      (5) Mitotic fragmentation

      The authors appear to have misunderstood my concern. The critical question is whether the polyQ assemblies in the same cells were intact before entering mitosis and subsequently underwent fragmentation. Comparing different interphase and mitotic cells cannot establish this sequence of events. Furthermore, Golgi fragmentation during mitosis is a well-established phenomenon. Therefore, the observed fragmentation of Golgi-associated polyQ assemblies may simply accompany normal mitotic Golgi disassembly rather than represent a distinct property of polyQ assemblies.

      (6) Nuclear localization claims

      The presented images suggest, at most, partial nuclear localization of polyQ assemblies. Nuclear accumulation appears evident in some cells but absent or much less pronounced in others.

      (7) Drug treatment and data interpretation

      My previous concerns remain unresolved. Figure 3E is still inappropriately plotted and may mislead readers. Furthermore, the rationale for selecting Onjisaponin F remains insufficiently justified.

      Additional Concern: Insufficient Description of SIM Microscopy

      In their response to Reviewer #1, Comment 3, the authors explicitly state that "Our SIM resolution reaches approximately 64 nm." However, this specification is not reported or substantiated in the manuscript. Neither the main manuscript nor the supplementary methods provide essential technical information about the SIM imaging system, including the microscope manufacturer and model, objective lens and numerical aperture, acquisition parameters, and controlling software. This is a substantial methodological omission.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript uses a valuable dataset of simultaneous LC single-unit recordings and pupillometry in awake monkeys to examine one aspect of the relationship between LC activity and pupil diameter: whether baseline LC activity predicts evoked pupil and whether baseline pupil predicts evoked LC. These relationships are largely absent in the present dataset, and the authors conclude that this type of prediction is not reliable.

      Strengths:

      This is a valuable dataset of simultaneous LC single-unit recordings and pupillometry in awake monkeys, the within-modal and within-epoch analyses are sound. The new results further caution the use of pupil diameter to infer LC activity.

      Comment on revised version.

      The revised manuscript has addressed previously raised concerns. This is a valuable contribution to the field.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript by Hernandez-Nunez et al. provides a comprehensive characterization of how heart-brain circuits develop in a vertebrate brain namely the zebrafish. The characterization is performed using a combination of modern and sophisticated imaging and neural manipulation techniques and achieves unprecedented clarity and detail to how the heart-brain communication develops early in life. The paper describes a three staged program, where first an efferent-circuit from the motor vagus to the heart develops, followed by sympathetic innervation and lastly sensory neurons innervate the heart.

      Strengths:

      The paper is very clearly and nicely written. The findings are novel and of high quality and relevance. The presentations are very clear and nicely interpreted. The analyses are well presented and applied.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):<br /> <br /> The authors have included a number of written edits to their manuscript that improves the readability of the text and also provides clarity on their experiments and findings. Together these changes better highlight the role of E-selectin as an upstream driver of innate immune inflammation in vincristine-induced neuropathy.

      A comment I made in the first review round (previous comment #3) was that NLRP3-inhibitors were only used in vitro and not used in vivo to confirm that it is this specific innate immune complex that contributes to the pathway. Instead, the downstream inflammatory mediator IL-1b was inhibited in vivo using anakinra (and not tested in vitro). The authors have referred to their previous work on NLRP3 inhibitors in their vincristine model and modified some text to delineate that in vivo, only a role for IL-1b was investigated in the E-selectin experiments in the current paper. It would be useful to clearly distinguish throughout the text, that the role of NLRP3 was only confirmed in macrophages in vitro. E.g. lines 44, 87, 740 and 773 discuss their findings on NLRP3 in macrophages, but do not specify that this is in vitro data.

      MCC950 is also known as CP-456773 and CRID3, which would be helpful to mention the first time the inhibitor is introduced as all versions of the name are used in current publications.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors describe clone-level dynamics of a SAR11 genomospecies in the Mediterranean, based on a dataset of LR-OBCs they previously generated. They distinguish 'consortia' of LR-OBC clones that co-vary/fluctuate together, primarily across depth. The authors find these consortia to be independent of phylogenetic origin within the genomospecies, concluding that their decoupling is evidence of a shift away from the current ecotype conceptual framework.

      This study provides valuable, detailed information about natural variation in SAR11 LR-OBCs within populations, but the conclusions reached are not supported by the data.

      Strengths:

      This is an exceptional dataset for studying this problem because of the sequencing depth and use of long-read technology.

      Weaknesses:

      The disconnect of LR-OBC phylogeny from species' phylogeny makes sense, for well-known reasons, but is not supported by statistical evidence for incongruent phylogenetic topologies. Also, this hypervariable genome region was described early, and evidence suggests it is transferred between strains by recombination. This work is not cited, and without this important background, it will be challenging for naïve readers to interpret this manuscript. It seems likely that the genome content and LR-OBCs are evolving independently because the latter are transferred by homologous recombination and are under selection related to viral predation.

      I also struggle with the authors' definitions of clones (at 97% sequence similarity). I would expect clones to be near-100% identical. The differing 'ranks' across the subspecies level are not defined in the manuscript, so the discussion lacks clarity on what the novel discoveries really are.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors further develop in this article an approach to quantify the release of EV cargo by fusing the HiBiT fragment of nanoluciferase to the cytosolic end of various proteins, via knock-in (rather than overexpression) in HEK293 cells. They have previously published this approach for several EV-associated proteins (Maeda 2024: tetraspanins, flotillin1, syndecan), or the autophagosome-associated protein LC3, or the mitochondrial protein Tom20 (Saito 2026). They now expand it to p62, another protein involved in the autophagy pathway. Their results convincingly show that p62 is indeed released extracellularly, at low levels spontaneously and mainly associated with larger/denser EVs (10k pellet), and much more after blocking lysosomal activity by BafA1 and mainly in small EVs (100K pellet), as well as in a free form.

      Strengths:

      The authors produce a lot of interesting experiments using knock-in or expression under the control of a mutated CMV promoter to avoid high overexpression of the studied proteins. They nicely decipher the molecular machinery involved in this secretion.

      Weaknesses:

      I am a bit unsatisfied with the way all experiments are presented, as bar graphs show individual dots of technical replicates, rather than individual dots of independent experiments (the authors specify that each experiment was performed at least twice). This representation minimizes the potential inter-experiment variability: for instance, when comparing Figure 3B where relative secretion (in BafA1) is around 25 for 10K vs 140 for 100K, and fig 4A where it is 50 for 10K vs 30 for 100K, there is a 5 fold difference of the rate of secretion in 100K, and the ratio 10K/100K is inversed between the experiments of Figure 3 and Figure 4. It would therefore be highly recommended to show all the figures of secretion rate with individual symbols for each individual experiment (calculating the mean of technical replicates for each experiment).

      It is also unclear if the truncated CMV promoters that induce a not-too-high overexpression of the p62 mutants in Figure 5 are also used for Figure 6 (KEAP and mutants) and in Figure 7 (Rab27 and mutants). If not, can the authors justify that, for these molecules, high overexpression does not preclude interpretation of the results?

      An important technical detail is missing in the WB of Figure 4B, where the authors quantify p62-HiBiT in extracellular vesicle pellets: quantification is done in pellets as compared to the cell lysate, but I did not find how the gels were loaded: equal amounts of protein from cells and pellets, or pellets coming from the same number of producing cells loaded in the gel, or other? Also, this experiment seems to have been performed and quantified only once.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Schneider et al. use a reproducible and inexpensive behavioral paradigm to study prey capture in a cluttered environment. They compare mice hunting cockroaches in a sparse, circular arena with no obstructing objects versus a cluttered arena. The authors set out to define search and pursuit phases in the cluttered environment. They claim to find signatures of short-term memory within the search phase that they propose should not be involved in uncluttered environments. They also create an agent-based framework for prey capture with and without additional objects, and predict that trials should take longer when objects are included. They provide the agent-based model with a component that prevents revisiting the same object and predicts big differences between object order visits during search and pursuit. They also create machine learning classifiers on mouse keypoint data with the goal of measuring interactions with specific objects.

      Strengths:

      The experimental set-up is excellent and broadly useful as it uses inexpensive objects to perform easily repeatable experiments. Further, the model has interesting characteristics and is well constructed.

      Weaknesses:

      The major weakness of this manuscript is the lack of comparisons throughout the text. For example, all of the claims depend on the assumption that mice are searching for roaches when they are not pursuing the roach: these non-pursuit times could be anything, including grooming, sleeping, etc. But without a comparison to animals in the same physical environment who are not searching for roaches, these claims cannot be supported with evidence. Similarly, all of the claims about complexity being required or revealing memory need to be compared to a lack of complexity to support those claims with evidence. The authors note they have both naive mice in the cluttered arena that did not hunt and their baseline data from uncluttered environments also exist, and these comparisons would allow them to address and potentially support their claims.

      Additional context:

      This manuscript lacks sufficient context from a few related areas of the literature: thigmotaxis and novel object recognition, as well as mouse proclivities (e.g. mice prefer to move forward and not backwards (Rosenberg et al. 2021). While thigmotaxis is acknowledged, it is referenced only in passing and not evaluated as a null model for how animals are behaving. Without comparisons to uncluttered or non-hunting mice, thigmotaxis, novel-object recognition, and other mouse proclivities like preferring forward movement could explain all of their behavior without a memory component

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The authors present results from an ultra-high-resolution ex vivo MRI scanning of hippocampi. Scanning was extensive, and the figures are impressive. The description and scope of this resource appear a bit limited, however, as the data do not seem to be made openly available.

      (1) Title:

      The title is a bit ambiguous as "virtual histology" has also been used in an imaging-transcriptomics context (eg https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/fullarticle/2769908). I would suggest rewording or dropping everything after 14.1T.

      (2) Abstract:

      I would reword the statement "representing, to our knowledge, the highest resolution reported for human brain diffusion MRI" to "representing one of the highest resolutions reported<br /> for human brain diffusion MRI"

      (3) Introduction:

      When talking about selective vulnerability across disorders, the authors are encouraged to specifically mention AD, schizophrenia, and temporal lobe epilepsy, as these are conditions with a close association to hippocampal structural damage.

      (4) Introduction:

      It will, for balance, nevertheless be important in the introduction to outline that high-field in vivo MRI at 3-7T can achieve resolutions at least in the order of a few hundred microns. Such resolution, combined with automated image processing, can resolve subregional detail of the hippocampus. See for example https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31245529/, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40654693/, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41592-025-02783-3 etc. As such, the statement that "clinical MRI fails to resolve the mesoscopic and microscopic organization essential for characterizing complex structures" is only partially correct, and I would suggest toning this down.

      (5) Methods:

      The methods appear relatively brief. The authors are encouraged to provide further details on the specific segmentation protocol that was used. Did multiple raters perform substructural segmentation? How high was inter- and intra-rater reliability?

      (5) Methods:

      How far is a diffusion MRI acquisition with 20 directions viable for tractography? I understand that multiple averages were used, but 20 directions appear limited to reliably sample 3D space and to, e.g., resolve complex, crossing, and kissing fibers.

      (6) Results:

      The figures are very nice, and the authors are also commended for doing such an ambitious imaging acquisition. Currently, the results appear a bit qualitative and descriptive, however. Ideally, and for greater impact, a resource such as the one presented should be made openly available for the research community, as this allows for independent verification and greater uptake of the study results. Other resources, e.g., AHEAD, BigBrain, etc. were shared with the international research community, so it would be great to see the same for this dataset.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript by Tsukamoto et al. describes a compelling approach to understanding whether inter-species differences in social behavior might emerge from differential expression patterns of the oxytocin receptor (Oxtr) in the brain. To this end, they genetically engineer BAC transgenic mouse lines with insertions of a large construct incorporating prairie vole Oxtr gene and surrounding regulatory elements. They name these lines Koi lines. They first evaluate if prairie vole-like Oxtr expression is reproduced in the Koi mouse lines, and they find heterogenous patterns across different lines that do not depend on the number of insertions. While they found that Koi mice can reproduce vole-like expression in PFC, NAc and BLA, the reproduction was never complete: one Koi line had NAc and mPFC expression, another had BLA expression, etc. They confirmed major expression patterns across 3 methods: crossing with LacZ reporter line, in situ hybridization, and ligan binding (autoradiography). To determine the expression pattern of the BAC insert but not endogenous Oxtr, the authors generated new mouse lines by crossing Koi lines with Oxtr -/- line. Importantly, they found that Oxtr expression pattern in the mammary gland was similar across all lines, and wild-type mice.

      The authors they used Koi:Oxtr-/- lines to test social behavior, specifically partner preference (a behavior specific to prairie voles) and maternal behavior. They find that different Koi lines showed different changes in these behaviors compared to wild-type mice. Moreover, while some lines showed changes in partner preference, others seemed to show changes in maternal behavior. For one of the lines (Koi4), the partner preference and the maternal behavior was incongruent.

      The manuscript then hypothesizes that Oxtr gene is positioned in different 3D chromatin strictures across species and across tissues, leading to more rigid expression in the mammary glands, but more flexible expression patterns in the brain.

      Strengths:

      This study has major implications in the field of oxytocin research, and more broadly in the field of neuromodulation. It is novel, bold, and rigorous.

      Comments on revised version.

      Weaknesses have been satisfactorily addressed in the revised manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers.]

      Summary:

      The main goal of this manuscript is to develop a mathematical model of the regulation of cortical dynamics by Cdk1 activity to explain why, in some embryos (e.g., Xenopus), surface contraction waves are believed to move in the same direction as Cdk1, while in other embryos (e.g., starfish) they are believed to move in the opposite direction.

      Strengths:

      (1) The paper addresses a very important question.

      (2) The mathematical model is sensible and suggests that the different relationship between Cdk1 and surface contraction waves might arise from the different behavior of the mitotic entry wave and the mitotic exit wave.

      (3) The authors propose a mechanism by which the wave observed at mitotic exit might not passively follow the trigger wave observed at mitotic entry'

      (4) The proposed mechanism is a potential explanation of the observed differences.

      (5) The proposed mechanism is centered on different dynamics between the nucleus and the cytoplasm, highlighting the potential importance of the nucleus (and nuclear size) in organizing cortical dynamics.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: This version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      This manuscript by Laura Korobkova and Brian Dias describes an interesting study of the role of GABAergic neurons in the zona incerta (ZI) in incentive motivation for reward.

      The authors report that DREADD inhibition of ZI neurons reduced the effort breakpoint in a progressive ratio task, which measures the intensity of incentive motivation to obtain food rewards. In other tests, chemogenetic inhibition did not alter food consumption or memory.

      Conversely, DREADD excitation of ZI neurons increased incentive motivation in the progressive ratio task, expressed as a higher breakpoint for food rewards.

      Korobkova and Dias report that prior stress exposure to a series of stressors (e.g., forced swim & water submersion, restraint, mild footshock) by itself reduced the breakpoint for food reward under vehicle, though it did not impair the ability to learn an instrumental response. However, DREADD excitation of ZI neurons in previously stressed mice increased the breakpoint to normal levels equivalent to the never-stressed group. This important finding indicates the ability of ZI stimulation to rescue the incentive motivational deficit induced by prior stress.

      In fiber photometry studies using vGAT-CRE mice to specifically identify GABA neurons, Korobkova and Dias report that ZI GABA neurons are excited by sensory signals, including neutral cues. However, after reward conditioning, ZI GABA neurons increase their activation to the CS+ cue that predicts reward, but not to the CS- cue that doesn't. ZI neurons also respond in an instrumental reward task during both lever press and reward delivery. The authors conclude that ZI neurons respond to sensory stimuli, but specifically code the motivational significance of reward-related stimuli.

      In optogenetic studies, the authors find that ZI GABA neuron stimulation during a reward CS+ enhances motivated responding to obtain reward, particularly in females, but not stimulation outside the CS+. This suggests the ZI stimulation in females may specifically enhance the incentive salience of the CS+, namely the cue's ability to trigger an increase in 'wanting' for the reward. However, that effect was not found here in males.

      Altogether, this is a fine contribution to the literature, and the authors deserve congratulations on their study and manuscript.

      Strengths:

      This is a powerful and creative set of studies that clarifies the roles of ZI neurons in sensory processing and especially in incentive motivation for rewards. The use of multiple methods and test situations to triangulate on reward motivation functions gives a well-rounded perspective on ZI function. The discovery of incentive motivation roles for ZI neurons is intriguing and improves understanding of ZI, which traditionally has been a relatively understudied brain structure. The finding that ZI stimulation may rescue stress-induced deficits in motivation is especially notable and may have therapeutic implications.

    1. Joint Public Review:

      The study by He and colleagues investigates how cell polarity regulates the transition from naïve to primed pluripotent stem cells and subsequent differentiation. By comparing knockout cells lacking the Par, Crumbs or Scrib polarity complexes, the authors identify a specific role for Par in morphological remodelling and epithelial organization. The conditioned-medium rescue experiments and the identification of high-molecular-weight secreted factors are particularly interesting and informative.

      The revised manuscript has addressed most of the concerns raised during the initial review. Additional data and discussion have improved the characterization of the Par knockout phenotype, particularly its effects on pluripotent stem cell maintenance and differentiation. The authors have also placed their findings in a clearer developmental context, connecting the observed phenotypes to rosette formation, apical domain specification, epithelialization and lumen formation during early embryonic development.

      Some limitations remain. In particular, direct experiments in embryos would have strengthened the study by establishing whether the proposed mechanism operates during normal embryogenesis. In addition, although the inhibitor and rescue experiments suggest a relationship between Par, AKT/FAK signaling and secreted factors, the proposed signaling cascade is not yet fully established.

      Nevertheless, the revised study provides valuable observations and a clearer understanding of the role of the Par polarity complex in pluripotent-state transitions and morphogenesis.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study was motivated by the general claim that delayed development of cognitive control can be beneficial for learning and investigated this claim in the specific domain of conceptual development. A comprehensive set of computational model simulations showed that delaying the onset of semantic control produces faster learning with only minimal effects on conceptual abstraction. The simulations also showed that control was most effective at intermediate levels between modality-specific "spokes" and the multimodal "hub". A meta-analysis of developmental data was consistent with the claim of delayed onset of semantic control: young children show substantially better semantic knowledge than ability to constrain that knowledge to a specific task at hand.

      Strengths:

      The computational modelling is based on a very well-established model of semantic cognition, which means that the simulations allow exploring the specific issues under investigation here in the context of a model that accounts for a very large set of semantic cognition phenomena. The simulations are comprehensive - manipulating different parameters of the model provides important insights into how (and why) it works.

      In addition to simulations exploring delayed maturation, there is an exploration of where semantic control is most effective, yielding the interesting result that control is most effective when it targets intermediate levels of semantic processing. To my knowledge, this is a novel finding and concrete prediction for future testing.

      The meta-analysis is designed in a very clever way that allows extracting evidence of semantic control from a large body of prior work. The results are quite clear and compelling in showing that semantic knowledge is acquired before children are able to use task demands to constrain the use of that knowledge.

      Weaknesses:

      Computational models of cognition inherently require simplification in order to focus on the mechanisms under investigation. However, the authors are explicit about the logic of the simplifications and how sacrificing ecological validity allows for better understanding of the computational mechanisms.

      There is a bit of a misalignment between the model simulations and the meta-analysis. In the model, there are distinct modality-specific "spokes" and control is required in order to focus on modality/spoke in a task-appropriate way. Simulation 2 specifically demonstrates that the control locus should be at intermediate or spoke layers, *not* at the hub layer, and the authors review neuroanatomical connectivity data consistent with this finding. The meta-analysis compares taxonomic vs thematic relations, both of which are multimodal. The authors correctly note that "selecting the taxonomic versus thematic relationships relies upon selecting some set of relevant features and inhibiting a different set of irrelevant features, whether these are represented in the same or different brain areas", but in the context of their model, this requires that there are distinct sets of taxonomic versus thematic features (in the same way that colour, function, etc. are distinct sets of features).

      More problematic is the inference that "taxonomic and thematic relationships ...[are]... both being encoded within the same system of representation". This statement is trivially true in the sense that both are encoded in the human brain, but presumably the authors mean something more specific. What they *can't* mean is that both are encoded in the ATL hub because their simulations specifically argued that control does not operate on the hub layer (and that PFC is not connected to the ATL). If the taxonomic-thematic distinction happens in somewhere outside the ATL hub - if there are some distinct sets of taxonomic and thematic feature spokes - then this is precisely the argument that Mirman, Schwartz and others have made and the present results are fully consistent with their view (and conflict with the view that both are represented within the ATL hub).

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study investigates the role of site-specific DNA methylation changes during spermatogenesis and their contribution to paternal epigenetic inheritance. Using MethylCap-seq, the authors identify a transient, site-specific loss of DNA methylation at transcription start sites (TSSs) of late spermatogenesis genes during the transition from differentiating spermatogonia (KIT+) to pachytene spermatocytes (PS). This demethylation event correlates with the gain of H3K4me3, which presets nucleosome retention sites in mouse sperm. The study proposes that selective loss of DNA methylation at a subset of promoters is required for nucleosome retention and the establishment of epigenetic states that may influence embryonic gene regulation. These findings provide complementary insights to earlier work by the Peters lab, "DNA methylation modulates nucleosome retention in sperm and H3K4 methylation deposition in early mouse embryos."

      Overall, the study presents a valuable dataset; however, additional analyses could strengthen the conclusions and provide further mechanistic insights.

      The revised manuscript addresses all reviewer concerns.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors seek to understand the role of different ratios of excitatory to inhibitory (EI) neurons, which in experimental studies of cerebral cortex have been shown to range from 4 to 9. They do this through a simulation study of sparsely connected networks of excitatory and inhibitory neurons.

      Their main finding is that participation ratio and decoding accuracy increase as E/I ratio decreases. This suggests higher computational complexity.

      This is the start to an interesting computational study. However, there is no analysis to explain the numerical results, although there is a long literature of reduced models for randomly connected neural networks which could potentially be applied here. The paper would be stronger if this was attempted.

      Right now, the research contribution is rather thin: a grid search on parameter values, plus a thorough discussion of what is observed, plus a lot of comments on experimental findings which are suggestive (e.g. "distinct integrative role in L2/3") but don't directly connect to the study at hand. I also have concerns about the experimental comparison which I will detail below.

      Strengths:

      Some issues I appreciated are:

      (1) The use of a publicly available simulator (Brian), which helps reproducibility.

      (2) A thorough exploration of the parameter space of interest (shown in Fig. 2)

      (3) A good motivation of the underlying question: other things being equal, how does the E/I ratio impact computational capacity?

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Lack of mathematical analysis of the network model

      (2) The analysis of experimental data uses sub-sampling as a way to get a desired EI ratio. However, the authors' central claim is that the EI ratio intrinsically changes the underlying dynamics. Sub-sampling has no influence on the dynamics.

      To elaborate on these points:

      (1) If your networks are in the "classical asynchronous" regime as described by Otojic et al. (2014), you could implement the fixed-point calculation for your specific networks. This would be equations (1), (7)-(16), (maybe also (5-6)). As you change the EI ratio, you modify f (relative numbers of E and I cells), J_{ei}, and modifying theta_{inh} will change the set point of the firing rate function.

      Why do this? Although you would not observe a state change, the difference in the stability matrix might lead to interesting hypotheses. For example: as you raise the EI ratio while adjusting J_{ei} and/or theta_inh to keep firing rate constant, does the stability matrix get closer to instability? If so, could this be an explanation for change in D_{PR}?

      (2) In "Coding capacity in different layers of visual cortex" the authors measure PR values from layer 2/3 and 4 in VISp and find that layer 2/3 has a higher PR than layer 4.

      Earlier, I had asked the authors to comment on this finding: "in Dahmen et al. 2020 (https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.11.02.365072), the opposite was found (see Fig. 2d of Dahmen et al.): layer 2 had a lower PR than layer 4. Can you explain how that difference might arise?"

      I did not find the explanation of subsampling, as an explanation, persuasive:<br /> "Furthermore, to align our excitatory/inhibitory (EI) ratios with those of the barrel cortex used in our stimulation paradigm (7.4 for layer 4, 5.32 for layer 2/3), we subsampled excitatory and inhibitory neurons from VISp layers 2/3 and 4. This contrasts with Dahmen et al. (2020) [2] , who included all neurons from these layers. "<br /> If I understand correctly the authors mean that they preferentially sampled either E neurons or I neurons from that data set, before performing their analysis. Although it is possible this could bias D_{PR} it is not clear why the observed difference should be in one direction or another. In addition, what the authors are trying to show (overall) is that a changed E/I balance does *something* nontrivial to the dynamics of the network to change dimensionality, and presumably this difference would still be visible even if you subsampled differently (i.e. subsampling has no impact on the network dynamics, it just changes which units you are allowed to see). If subsampling DID change D_{PR} significantly, this would suggest that excitatory and inhibitory cells contribute differently to network dimensionality, in a way that merits more exploration.

      (I find it a more persuasive explanation that Dahmen et al. and the authors measured D_{PR} in different recordings; spontaneous activity (mean gray stimulus) vs. natural stimuli. A priori, there is no reason to think statistical features of the activity should remain the same, under different stimuli. In short: the analyses were not comparable)

      But that also motivates the question: what happens to D_{PR} in the authors' networks, in the spontaneous state? The authors should show this as well. This would be the more meaningful comparison with the figure from Dahmen, AND would address the question: is network activity already high-dimensional, before a stimulus is presented; is the network "primed" to create high-dimensional responses?

      As I think about this more, I question the probative value of analyzing the visual recordings in this way, because sub-sampling the population seems to undercut the authors' central claim, which is it is the E/I ratio *of the interacting network* that is responsible for the dynamics.

      For example: if you simply used the whole population, or subsampled according to whatever the actual EI ratio is (in the V1 data), would you get substantially similar results? It seems that if you found higher D_{PR} in the layer with a lower EI ratio, whichever that would be, you would be making the point you want to make. TL;DR: I recommend re-doing the analyses without biased sub-sampling (i.e. don't try to get a certain EI ratio).

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's Note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The original reviews for this study were unanimously positive. Reviewers requested more extensive discussion of the study's limitations (including potential cross-species differences in familiarity with the object stimuli used), and clarification of the training procedure and some design choices (such as the choice of tasks). The revised manuscript comprehensively addresses these comments. Since reviewers did not question the accuracy or validity of the study's conclusions and mentioned that the paper can serve as an impactful example of cross-species comparisons in other fields (R2), the eLife assessment was adapted to state that this is an important study providing convincing results.]

      Summary:

      The authors set out to conduct a behavioral comparison of macaque and human vision across a wide range of visual properties. Such a comparison is critical for evaluating the use of macaques as a model system for understanding human vision and the underlying neural mechanisms. This goal represents a unique endeavour since prior studies have typically focused on only highly specific tasks. While the authors found consistent coarse representational structure for objects, evidence for Weber's Law and amodal completion, there was divergence for mirror image confusion and the use of global or local image properties.

      Strengths:

      There are three major strengths of the study. First, the authors employed a behavioral paradigm (oddball search) that allowed them to test multiple perceptual phenomena without having to train the macaques on the specific type of stimuli tested. Second, humans and macaques could be tested in an identical manner. Third, the authors tested a range of different visual properties and phenomena, allowing a broader comparison between species.

      There are also some weaknesses to the study (described below), but that doesn't change the fact that the authors have demonstrated and validated a novel approach for systematic and comprehensive comparisons of vision across species.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The review addresses an important and timely topic that concerns the role of cryo-EM in transforming RNA structural biology from a "static" discipline to one increasingly concerned with conformational ensembles and molecular dynamics. The scope is well within the eLife standards, and the style and general architecture do fit eLife.

      Strengths:

      The review is extremely well written, well-conceived and clear. The main strengths are in the breadth of coverage, the clear theme, and the inclusion of practical examples that explain in detail the construct design, sample preparation, vitrification, and data analysis. The manuscript will certainly be impactful and valuable, especially for readers who are not specialists in cryo-EM, as it provides an accessible overview of recent advances across a wide range of RNA systems.

      Comments on revised version:

      The authors have satisfactorily addressed my (minor) criticisms.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The goal of this study was to understand how thermal stress and aging are intertwined, but their transcriptional responses are distinct. The experimental premise is that insulin signaling influences the distinct transcriptomic responses, given the role of insulin in aging and stress responses, across several studies. The authors examined gene expression in whole female Drosophila that have neuronal insulin-producing cells ablated (dIlp2-gal4>reaper), to controls with only the dIlp2-Gal4. In control flies, the genomic response to heat stress and aging are independent, but in experimental flies they argue that the heat-stress response is "age-aware". This is based on a PCA analysis and the patterns of changes observed across several time points after a heat stress in young and old flies.

      Strengths:

      The authors present an interesting interpretation of the carefully collected gene expression data. The hypothesis is interesting and sheds light on how insulin signaling may influence aging and stress responses. The presentation was clear overall, though it is a complicated set of interpretations. There were several places where the authors note weaknesses in their study, including potential issues with using a subset of genes for their work, which they address. They also address the issue of selecting flies that can perform in the geotaxis assay, as they may be only examining the hardiest of flies, by additionally performing gene expression on the set that were not able to climb. They also indicate that dIlp2-gal4>reaper flies show very slow development, and that the ablation happens pre-adult stages, which are clear limitations.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) It is my understanding that sPCA analyses are meant to be more exploratory, and a stronger analysis would include multivariate statistical analysis that would indicate if an interaction is significant. Also, could the authors be missing genes that have a statistical interaction across the conditions, but would not be in the top three PC?

      (2) In addition, the authors make strong statements such as suggesting that there are "rewiring" and "topological switch" changes that are not supported by additional experimentation. While these are exciting hypotheses, the language should be more consistent with what is in the paper. No topological analysis is performed, and that word is in the title.

      (3) It is not clear that the authors controlled for strain background. Was the UAS-reaper line introgressed into the same genetic background as was used in the control cross?

      (4) The authors should be careful about over-interpreting a large fold change, and show the starting baseline and induced amounts, in addition to the fold change.

    1. Patient P10 In 2009, a 37-year-old man accessed the emergency service, and a nasal retinal detachment was detected in OD. Multiple RCHs were present in all the quadrants; the biggest lesion was located nasally. It was made up of the coalescence of many tumors and measured approximately 4 optic disc diameters (DD). BCVA was 20/400, also due to the presence of macular scars. CNS imaging detected multiple cerebellar and bulbar hemangioblastomas. Nasal scleral buckle and cryotherapy were performed, and several laser photocoagulation treatment sessions were performed. In 2012, the patient developed a new tractional retinal detachment in OD and NVG. Visual acuity of OD was nlp. At the last follow-up visit (in 2019), we did not detect RCHs in OS. Clinical details are summarized in Table 1.

      PatientID: 10

      KindredID: 6

      Case: M, 47Y0M, Ethnicity Unknown

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      FamilyInfo: A family pedigree is provided in figure 1. Both parents were molecuarly examined and did not have the mutation nor VHL syndrome. The mutation was identified as de novo, but passed onto both sons of patient 10, as they had the same deletion. The 14-year-old son (patient 11) was asymptomatic, while the 12-year-old son (patient 12) had CNS hemangioblastoma.

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0006880; HP:0009711; HP:0009713; HP:0000541 (Cerebellar hemangioblastoma; Retinal capillary hemangioma; Spinal hemangioblastoma; Retinal detachment)

      CaseHPOFreeText: A 37-year-old man accessed emergency eye service in 2009, and a nasal retinal detachment was detected in the right eye. Multiple RCHs were detected. Visual acuity was 20/400, due to the tumours and presence of macular scars. CNS imaging detected several cerebellar and bulbar hemangioblastomas. Nasal scleral buckle, cryotherapy, and several laser photocoagulation sessions were performed. In 2012, the patient developed a new retinal detachment in the right eye. Visual acuity of OD worsened showing no light detection. At the last follow-up in 2019, no RCHs were detected in the left eye.

      CaseNotHPOs: N/A

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: c.341+1_341–1(463*1_?)

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: delins

      CivicName: Null (c.341+1_341–1)

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    1. 프로그래밍의 역사에서 비슷한 변화를 찾자면 컴파일러(compiler)가 있다.

      컴파일러와 비교하는 대목에서 ‘프로그램이 실행되는 것’과 ‘의도한 대로 동작하는 것’의 차이를 예시로 보여주면 어떨까요?

      실제로 컴파일러는 문법 오류를 발견하면 오류가 발생한 위치를 알려 주고, 개발자는 컴파일을 마치려면 해당 코드를 고쳐야 합니다. 반면 AI가 요청을 잘못 해석해도 생성된 코드 자체는 문제없이 컴파일되고 실행될 수 있습니다.

      예를 들어 “이미 신청한 사람은 다시 신청할 수 없게 해 줘”라고 요청했을 때, 첫 신청이 정상적으로 접수되는 것만 보면 기능이 완성됐다고 생각하기 쉽습니다. 같은 사람이 다시 신청해 봐야 중복 신청을 실제로 막는지 알 수 있습니다. 이런 예시를 넣으면 마지막 문단에서 말하는 ‘검토자의 역할’이 구체적으로 무엇인지 더 잘 드러날 것 같습니다.

    2. 위험을 알아볼 지식이 없는 사람이 세 질문에 스스로 답할 수 있는지는 이 연구로 판단할 수 없다.

      해당 연구 이후, 프로그래밍 경험이 없는 사용자가 소프트웨어의 위험을 판단할 수 있는지 살펴본 후속 연구가 있는지 확인하면 좋을 것 같습니다.

    1. Willison

      보통 논문에서는 인용시에 연도를 붙이는데 willison(202_)식으로 써야 하지 않을지요. 그리고 아래 참고문헌 정리가 안되어 있는 것 같은데 확인 부탁드립니다. 그리고 2.1절에 참고문헌 정리양식은 직접 인용을 옆에 넣었는데 2.2절과 2.3절은 [16] 이런식으로 번호를 집어 넣어서 통일을 해야 좋지 않을까 생각합니다.

    2. 코드 지식에 대한 부담이 줄어들다 프로그램을 직접 만들려면 일반적으로 언어의 문법과 개발환경, 라이브러리의 사용법을 익혀야 한다.

      부담이 줄어들다 프로그램을 직접 만들려면 연결이 잘 안되는것 같습니다.

    3. 한 연구자의 사례: 실험에 필요한 도구를 직접 만들다 프로그래밍을 전공하지 않은 한 연구자는 실험 중 센서 데이터를 확인하고 저장하는 과정이 번거롭다고 느꼈다. 실험에 맞는 도구가 필요했던 연구자는 AI에 원하는 기능을 설명하며 직접 프로그램을 만들기 시작했다. 센서 데이터를 그래프로 보여 주고 파일로 저장하도록 요청한 뒤, 프로그램을 실행해 보고 오류나 불편한 점을 전달하며 수정해 나갔다. 실제 장비에서의 성능 확인과 추가 개발은 남아 있었지만, 필요한 기능을 구상하고 구현을 시도할 수 있었다.

      ‘한 연구자의 사례’는 출처가 없어 실제 사례인지 가상의 예시인지 판단하기 어렵습니다. 사례의 성격과 출처를 밝히고, 언급된 '필요한 기능'이 실제로 어떤 기능까지 확인했는지 덧붙이면 좋을 것 같습니다.

    1. 따라서 비개발자도 검토자와 디렉터의 역할을 같은 방식으로 수행할 수 있다고 이 연구만으로 판단할 수는 없다

      마지막 문장의 ‘이 연구만으로 판단할 수 없다’는 표현은 연구의 한계만 드러내서, 개발 경험이 왜 중요한지가 잘 보이지 않는 것 같습니다. 바로 앞에서 연구진이 문제를 알아볼 전문성이 부족하면 AI를 과신할 수 있다고 지적한 만큼, 마지막 문장도 “이 연구에서 검토자와 디렉터 역할을 수행한 개발자들은 AI가 만든 코드의 문제를 알아보고 언제 직접 개입할지 판단하는 데 자신의 개발 경험을 활용했다.” 정도로 마무리하면 어떨까요?

    2. 사람은 코드라는 재료를 직접 다루는 일에서 한 걸음 물러나(material disengagement), AI를 통해 코드의 생성과 수정을 지휘하고 필요한 곳을 골라 감독한다는 것이다 [12].

      주어와 서술어 연결할때 '이는 --라는 것이다.' 이런식으로 써야 하는게 어떨까요?

    3. Christian Meske 외, Vibe Coding as a Reconfiguration of Intent Mediation in Software Development: Definition, Implications, and Research Agenda (버전 4 수정: 2026-01-08; 초록). 학술지판: IEEE Access 13, 213242–213259 (2025).

      Meske et al. (2025). Vibe Coding as a Reconfiguration of Intent Mediation in Software Development. IEEE Access, 13, 213242–213259. DOI: 10.1109/ACCESS.2025.3645466. 참고문헌을 위와 같이 보통 참고문헌 양식으로 쓰면 어떨까요? 굳이 버전 4 수정 이렇게 써야하는지 궁금합니다.

    4. 실제 요청이 이 예시처럼 정돈된 형태만은 아니었다. Sarkar와 Drosos가 분석한 바이브 코딩 영상에서는 막연한 미적 요구와 구체적인 기술 조건이 한 요청 안에 섞여 있었고, 오류 메시지나 코드 일부가 함께 전달되기도 했다.

      코딩을 하는데 있어서 본문에서 제시된 것 처럼 정돈되지 않은 상황에 대한 예시를 제시하면 보다 이해하는데 도움이 될 것 같습니다.

    1. 이 사례는 내가 경험한 제작 참여의 한 장면이며, 바이브 코딩의 보편적인 효과로 일반화할 수는 없다.

      이런 과도한 방어적인 문장은 지양하는 게 좋겠습니다. 해당 문장을 삭제하는 편이 나을 것 같습니다. 또는, 개인 경험이라 일반화하기 어렵다면 주변 경험의 사례도 함께 간략히 적는 게 낫지 않을까요?

    2. 다만 이는 이름과 게시물에 대한 해석이며, 자연어로 개발하는 모든 사람이 막연한 느낌만 전달한다는 뜻은 아니다.

      해당 부분의 의도를 고려했을 때

      다만 이는 바이브 코딩이라는 용어 자체에 대한 해석이며, 바이브 코딩을 하는 모든 사람이 막연한 느낌만으로 코딩을 한다는 뜻은 아니다.

      이런 식으로 수정을 하는 게 어떨까 합니다. '자연어로 개발하는 모든 사람이 막연한 느낌만 전달한다는 뜻'이라는 게 다소 모호하게 느껴집니다.

    3. 개발자가 코드를 한 줄씩 작성하거나 제안된 코드를 검토하는 방식과 비교할 때, 사람의 개입 지점이 달라졌다는 점이 이 경험을 특징짓는다.

      해당 문장을

      개발자가 코드를 한 줄씩 직접 작성하거나 제안된 코드를 검토하는 방식과 비교할 때, 사람의 개입 정도가 달라졌다는 점이 바이브 코딩의 주요 특징이다.

      라고 수정하는 것이 나을 것 같습니다. '개입 지점'이라는 말이 명확하지 않고, '특징짓는다'라는 표현 또한 어색하게 보입니다.

    4. 코드 생성 자체가 새로운 현상은 아니었다.

      해당 문장을

      AI에게 코드 생성을 맡기는 것 자체가 새로운 현상은 아니었다.

      로 수정하는 것이 의도를 전달하는 데 있어 더 명확할 것 같습니다.

    5. ’바이브 코딩(vibe coding)’

      “There’s a new kind of coding I call ‘vibe coding’” 실제로 X에 올린 내용을 소개해도 생생하지 않을까 생각합니다. 그리고 전체적으로 따옴표가 시작이 거꾸로 되어있습니다.

    6. 현재 나는 다른 사회복지사들과 함께 40~64세 중장년 1인가구의 고립과 관계 단절 예방을 목표로 연결 포털을 만들고 있다.

      개인 경험에서 서비스의 기획 의도는 구체적이지만, 바이브 코딩으로 실제 어떤 작업을 했는지는 잘 드러나지 않습니다. AI에 요청한 기능, 실행하면서 발견한 문제, 수정한 내용을 한 차례 보여주면 제작에 참여한 경험이 더 선명해질 것 같습니다.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript addresses a genuinely important and long-standing problem in the field: how to exploit the therapeutic potential of TGFβ pathway blockade while avoiding the systemic toxicity that has repeatedly derailed clinical candidates. The biologic rationale is sound, the stepwise molecular design is elegant, and the central finding - a ~300-fold potency enhancement in PDGFRA-expressing human fibroblasts with no enhancement in PDGFRA-negative HEK293 cells - is striking and clearly presented. As a proof-of-concept study, the work is significant. However, the evidence base is entirely in vitro, rests primarily on a single immortalized human fibroblast line, and leaves the mechanism of the potency enhancement incompletely resolved. The study should be viewed as a well-executed first step, not as validation of a therapeutic strategy, and the findings' generalizability and mechanistic claims require further substantiation before the conclusions drawn can be fully accepted.

      Strengths:

      The paper is well-motivated. The failure of broad TGFβ pathway inhibitors in the clinic, including the recent halt of the BEACON-IPF bexotegrast trial (NCT06097260), lends urgency to the idea of cell type-targeted antagonism, and the authors situate their work clearly in that context. The incremental design logic is a particular strength: they first characterize the natural bispecific TGM6, use it to establish mechanistic principles (LYTAC-like receptor degradation, tolerance for lower-affinity TGFBR2 binders), then systematically replace the immunogenic worm domains with antibody fragments, culminating in a fully human-sequence bispecific. This stepwise approach makes the reasoning transparent and persuasive. The choice of PDGFRA as a fibroblast targeting handle is well-justified by recent literature (Tsukui et al., 2024), and the use of multiple orthogonal readouts - luciferase SBE reporter, flow cytometry for surface TGFBR2, RT-qPCR for fibrosis-relevant genes, and western blotting for pSMAD2/3 is commendable. The ~300-fold potency shift in fibroblasts, absent in HEK293 cells, is the paper's headline result and is reproduced across independent readouts in a compelling manner.

      Weaknesses:

      Mechanistic interpretation of LYTAC (Lysosomal Targeting Chimera) like activity. The authors propose that TGM6 and the bispecific act by co-engaging a co-receptor that drives lysosomal degradation of TGFBR2. The flow cytometry data showing rapid, near-complete surface TGFBR2 depletion is visually striking. However, the inhibitor experiments (Figures 1I, 1J) are imperfect support for this conclusion. Dynasore (a dynamin inhibitor) only partially restores surface TGFBR2, consistent with but not proof of endocytosis-mediated depletion. More problematically, the proteasome inhibitor MG132 is used to support lysosomal involvement, but proteasome inhibition does not directly block lysosomal degradation of transmembrane receptors. A lysosomal inhibitor (e.g., bafilomycin A1 or chloroquine) would be the appropriate reagent; its absence leaves the mechanistic claim inadequately tested. The paper also does not directly demonstrate co-internalization of TGFBR2 with either PDGFRA or LRP1 (the latter identified as the D4D5 receptor in van Dinther et al., 2026, cited by the authors).

      The potency enhancement mechanism for the PDGFRA bispecific is insufficiently dissected. The authors attribute the 300-fold potency enhancement to cell-targeting and a LYTAC-like mechanism, and flow cytometry (Figure 3D) does show greater TGFBR2 depletion with the targeted molecule. However, simple bivalent avidity effects from simultaneously engaging two receptors on the same cell surface are not formally excluded. A monovalent anti-PDGFRA control (e.g., anti-PDGFRA Fab alone, or a bispecific with a non-TGFBR2-binding VH) would help partition the targeting and degradation contributions. Similarly, no ternary complex (simultaneous binding to PDGFRA and TGFBR2) is demonstrated biochemically.

      Limited cell model diversity. The human fibroblast data all derive from a single commercially available immortalized fetal lung fibroblast line (MRC5). Whether the results generalize to primary adult human pulmonary fibroblasts, fibroblast subtypes from IPF patients, or fibroblasts from other tissues is entirely unknown. This substantially limits the translational claims in the Discussion.

      Selectivity concerns PDGFRA as the target receptor. PDGFRA is expressed not only on pulmonary fibroblasts but also on pericytes, stellate cells, some hematopoietic progenitors, and certain tumor cell types. The paper tests selectivity only against HEK293 cells, which lack many fibroblast-relevant properties beyond PDGFRA expression. Whether the bispecific engages and functionally modulates TGFβ signaling in other PDGFRA-expressing cell types is not addressed.

      The VH271-12-TGM6-D4D5 data in human cells (Figure 2F) are only duplicates. This is explicitly acknowledged, but it means the most mechanistically informative intermediate construct is under-replicated. The authors should provide p-values.

      Functional readout limitations. The RT-qPCR panel covers only two ECM genes (COL1A1 and ELN), and there is notable variability in the data (Figure 3E). The western blot for ACTA2 (Figure 3F) also shows wide individual-experiment scatter. These data are directionally consistent with the reporter assay but are not themselves quantitatively convincing.

      Conclusion:

      The core in vitro proof-of-concept claim that a PDGFRA-targeted TGFBR2 bispecific can achieve cell-selective, potency-enhanced TGFβ pathway antagonism in human fibroblasts is supported by the data as presented. However, the mechanistic framing (LYTAC-like degradation) is incompletely evidenced, the generalizability beyond MRC5 cells is untested, and there are no in vivo data of any kind. The Discussion's forward-looking statements about therapeutic application to IPF and cancer should be substantially tempered.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript provides a well‑argued discussion of the misalignment between common predictive performance evaluations reported in the literature and actually measuring clinical utility in the context of predictive psychiatry. Specifically, the authors discuss measurement reliability and prevalence as two neglected factors which can substantially inflate the assessment of model performance for clinical practice. To mitigate this, the authors offer a concrete framework and an accompanying web tool, with which adjusted performance metrics and additional predictive‑value and decision‑analytic measures.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript speaks convincingly about the risk of face validity and practical irrelevance of seemingly promising predictive models in psychiatry. The authors outline how predictive performance estimations often fail to generalize to clinical contexts and thereby potentially mislead scientific efforts. In the face of ubiquitous biomarker models and incremental improvements in the literature, the reader is reminded that, irrespective of the glory of the proposed model, low reliability of clinical measurements fundamentally affects (and limits) both effect sizes and predictive performance ("garbage in, garbage out"), and that neglecting this can ultimately lead to misinformed decisions in the treatment of individual patients. The provision of an online tool with a user‑friendly interface and clearly worked examples is a major practical asset that will facilitate adoption of the proposed framework beyond quantitative methodologists.

      Impact on the field:

      I think the tool can serve as a valuable approach to estimate a first approximation of clinical relevance for a given linear predictor model and provides researchers with a structured outline to assess their own findings in the light of translational value.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The study uses Quantitative Phase Imaging to measure and infer cell shapes, areas, volumes, and masses during the evolution of a confluent epithelium. These are important physical parameters of a monolayer and help to better understand the dynamical evolution of an epithelium and collective cell behaviors.

      Strengths:

      Quantitative Phase Imaging allows simultaneous, live-cell measurements of mass density and height that are not easily achievable by other means.

      Weaknesses:

      The biological or biophysical conclusions drawn are not fully substantiated, as QPI is the sole experimental technique used, and the analysis relies heavily on indirect 2.5D assumptions that the authors themselves question. This makes the novelty questionable, especially since a technical paper establishing this QPI pipeline for epithelia has been published elsewhere by the same authors.

      To study the dynamics of confluent epithelium, the authors applied 2D and 3D quantitative phase imaging (QPI) to measure local dry mass densities and heights of MDCK monolayers. These techniques allow simultaneous, live-cell measurements of mass density and height that are not easily achievable by other means, enabling a direct test of dry mass conservation that enriches the coarse-grained description of epithelial tissues. The authors also use the mass/height information and apical segmentation to estimate cell areas, volumes, and dry masses, leading to deductions about non-prismatic cell shapes, mass shedding, and volume reduction.

      Overall, the study demonstrates an interesting technical application of QPI. However, while I find the methodology promising, I am not fully convinced by the biological or biophysical conclusions drawn, as QPI is the sole experimental technique used, and the analysis relies heavily on indirect 2.5D assumptions that the authors themselves question. Furthermore, given that the authors have already published a technical paper establishing this QPI pipeline for epithelia (Reference 22), the present manuscript cannot claim novelty on methodological grounds alone. Its contribution therefore hinges almost entirely on the biological insights it provides. However, as I outline below, those biological insights are either expected from previous literature (non-prismatic shapes in low-density MDCK), inferred indirectly from 2.5D projections (frustum shapes), or remain at best correlative without experimental validation (mass shedding). Thus, in its current form, I struggle to identify a clear advance. Below, I outline specific technical concerns and suggest ways to strengthen the study.

      (1) Indirect inference of non-prismatic cell shapes from 2.5D projections.

      The authors segment the projected (apical) area of the cells and assume prismatic, vertical-sided geometries to calculate cell volumes, and compare them to frustum-based cell models. They conclude that cells are non-prismatic if volumes are constant. While I appreciate the modeling effort, the evidence for non-prismatic shapes remains indirect, as it relies on comparing 2.5D projected correlations rather than a direct measurement of the 3D geometry. Since the authors already have full 3D refractive index tomograms (as shown in Figure 1A), a much more direct and definitive approach would be to perform true 3D volumetric segmentation along the z-axis to directly reconstruct actual cell shapes. Additionally, structures that lead to non-prismatic shapes (e.g., cryptic lamellipodia) are well-documented for low-density MDCK cells, so I do not find this conclusion particularly illuminating for epithelium biology. To improve on this analysis, tracking the evolution of directly segmented 3D shapes as density increases beyond the range they presented would be highly instructive, as one would expect the lateral sides to become progressively more vertical under compaction.

      (2) Apparent conflict between ensemble and single-cell dry mass concentration trends.

      The ensemble-averaged dry mass concentration is shown to increase with cell density (Figure 1D). However, the single-cell tracks in Figure 3B (which span approximately 10 hours of evolution) show dry mass density to be roughly constant. Given that the monolayer density is likely changing over these 10 hours, this seems like a conflict between ensemble and single-cell data. Can the authors clarify?

      (3) Breakdown of continuum mass conservation at the cellular scale.

      The authors showed a breakdown of the 2D continuity equation at cellular scales, which is not surprising. To move beyond this, I would suggest directly testing mass conservation at the cell scale by following mass evolution of each cell using integrated mass from 3D tomograms. This would provide a much stronger conclusion than the current 2D coarse-graining analysis, which is relevant for monolayer-scale, but not at the cell-scale.

      (4) The "mass shedding" hypothesis requires experimental validation.

      The claim that cells periodically shed 10-15% of their dry mass is an important biological statement, yet it remains unclear due to the 2.5D analysis and is, at best, correlative. Given that epithelial cells are known to secrete basement membrane components, this hypothesis is testable. I would suggest the authors perform appropriate pharmacological perturbations of secretion pathways, if not genetic perturbations, and repeat the inference from 3D tomograms to see if the apparent volume/mass loss is abolished.

      (5) Sensitivity of mass measurements to the specific refractive index increment.

      The conversion from refractive index contrast to dry mass concentration relies on the specific refractive index increment. While the authors use a standard average value of α ≈ 0.18−0.2mL/g, it is worth noting that this parameter varies between different biomolecular classes. The authors should discuss the potential sensitivity of their absolute mass and concentration values to compositional shifts (e.g., changes in the lipid-to-protein ratio) that might occur as cell density increases, and provide an estimate of the error bounds this could introduce into their conclusions.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors quantified and compared the 3D kinematics of bill and tongue movements between two seed-eating bird species; one that specializes on soft seeds, and one that is more adapted to feeding on hard seeds. Their goal was to determine specifically what the role of the tongue was for processing (e.g., dehusking) seeds, and to understand how differences in biting strength between species affect other aspects of seed processing. The authors provided intricate (visual) details of seed processing movements, and showed how coordination between the tongue and cranial kinesis (i.e., mobility of the upper bill relative to the cranium) are both critically important for properly positioning seeds to enhance feeding efficiency. Many studies have detailed how seed-eating birds process seeds, but this study has elevated those to a new level of quantification and visualization for readers to fully experience firsthand. Furthermore, the authors established that the force-velocity trade-off that has been observed between bill functions (e.g., feeding and singing) is largely driven by the contractile properties of the muscles. The conclusions are well supported by the results, and the authors placed the results more broadly into the context of manual grasping, making the argument that these birds achieve high levels of dexterity with far fewer degrees of freedom, which could have potential biomimetic applications.

      Strengths:

      This study builds upon - and advances - our understanding of the feeding mechanics of seed eating birds using cutting-edge 3-dimensional modeling and kinematics. Their quantitative analyses of upper and lower bill, tongue, and seed displacements are complemented by elegant visualizations of seed processing in each species. Their comprehensive Bayesian modeling statistical framework tackles the issue of small sample sizes (i.e., few subjects) with volumes of data for each (i.e., lots of sequential kinematic variables) that plague comparative biomechanics studies, principally because (a) it is difficult to gather these high resolution XROMM and muscle contractile data on more than just a few subjects, and (b) these data streams are inherently very large, as they are gathered at high frame and sampling rates. Furthermore, I believe their approach to statistically testing for differences between species, and kinematic correlations within species, sets a new standard for our field. Another strength is in how the results were packaged: each subsection indicated how their objectives were addressed, and there were concluding statements trailing each subsection that helped deliver the key take-aways, and the visualizations of their statistical workflows in the appendices are game-changing.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have fully addressed my [relatively minor] concerns upon revision, and they, themselves, have done a sufficient job of making any limitations of their study fully transparent.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      In this manuscript, Hinojosa and colleagues analysed the changes in V1 visual responses induced by locomotion in head-fixed mice using two-photon calcium imaging. The authors observe that locomotion strongly increases the visual responses of V1 excitatory neurons that exhibit sensitizing responses to visual stimuli. Also, there is an increased response in VIP interneurons, and to a lesser extent, PV interneurons and SST interneurons (non-significant). The authors used a model fitted with data presented in the manuscript, as well as previous knowledge on cortical connectivity among different neuron types. The model suggests that the major component of the increased responses during locomotion is an increase in excitatory drive from external inputs (feedforward, feedback and modulatory), most importantly onto VIP interneurons and excitatory neurons. However, the excitatory drive of local excitatory neurons onto other surrounding excitatory and inhibitory cells is reduced.

      The manuscript is well presented and represents a valuable analysis of how locomotion modulates the activity of different subtypes of cortical neurons. However, major issues should be addressed to strengthen the results.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed all our comments satisfactorily. The revisions have strengthened and clarified the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: This version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers.]

      In the manuscript "Identification of neurodevelopmental organization of the cell populations of Juvenile Huntington's disease using dorso-ventral HD organoids and HD mouse embryos," the authors establish a fused dorso-ventral system that mimics cortex-striatum interactions within a single organoid and use this system to investigate neurodevelopmental impairments caused by HD. Specifically, they describe certain phenotypes in 60-day HD organoids and the brains of humanized mouse embryos, utilizing both wet-lab and single-cell sequencing techniques. The authors also develop dorsal/ventral and ventral/dorsal mosaic control/HD organoids, showing a capacity to rescue some HD phenotypes.

      After revision the manuscript is a valuable contribution to the field.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this paper, Ribeiro and colleagues investigate male orienting behavior during courtship to identify the neural pathways involved in visually-guided avoidance. The major claims are:

      (1) Before courtship has begun, the male generally avoids other flies. This avoidance depends on LC10d neurons (Figures 1 and 2).

      (2) LC10d neurons are broadly tuned to visual objects, and they mediate visual avoidance behavior (Figure 3).

      (3) Unilateral activation of LC10d neurons drives contralateral turns (Figure 4).

      (4) Anterior-facing LC10d neurons preferentially connect to a descending neuron called DNa10, and these neurons mediate avoidance behaviors (Figure 5).

      Overall the initial observations are supported with solid behavioral evidence, although there are issues with clarity of anayses and writing that make it difficult to evaluate at times. I thought that the latter two claims are not well supported by the data and analyses as presented. I think that improving the analysis, statistics, and, in some cases, the claims being made with the data could overcome these weaknesses.

      Strengths:

      (1) Figures 1 and 2 show solid behavioral evidence with some interesting and clever analyses, including the change detection and event-triggered analyses.

      (2) The visual tuning characterization (Figure 3) shows strong evidence that these neurons are more broadly tuned to visual objects than LC10a.

      Weaknesses:

      I found this manuscript to be a very difficult read, and I think it needs a major overhaul of the writing throughout. At multiple points, the writing is very unclear. I also ran into some points where the claims in the text are not consistent with the data. Some representative examples include:

      (1) In lines 209-210, it is stated that "Both forward accelerations and decelerations contributed to an increase in female frontal positions (Figure 2D)". However, Figure 2D seems to show that there is a decrease in female frontal positions for accelerations (all genotypes) and perhaps a weak increase in frontal position for the two silencing genotypes.

      (2) Related to the plots showing the y-axis projection of the heatmaps (e.g. Figure 1 G, I):

      a) I believe what the authors want is the orientation of the male relative to the location of the female; to quantify whether he is facing her. These plots show the distance, but then the orientation is not clear beyond anterior vs. posterior.

      b) How were these projections normalized? Are the different lines comparable in amplitude? Shouldn't these have units of % rather than a.u.?

      c) The quantification (AUC in the anterior field) is just mentioned in the figure legend with p-values. It would be useful to show the AUC values to get a sense of fly-to-fly variability and effect sizes.

      (3) There is analysis of the LOV-LexA experiments (Figure 4). With the way the data are currently presented, I don't feel confident in the claim that LC10d drives contralateral turning.

      (4) Figure 4, D and E: It should be clearer (in the text, labels on plots, and/or figure legend) what the "unilateral expression factor" is. The text (line 319) refers to a count of cells expressing on each side, but I can't figure out how it was calculated. Do negative values correspond to bias on one half of the brain while positive values correspond to a bias on the other side?

      (5) Figure 5: A straightforward reading of the DN blocking experiments would suggest that silencing DNa04, but not DNa10, changes male orientation behavior. The data in Figure 5 either only show results from the combined DNa04/10 driver or show negative results for the DNa10-only driver.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Schoeffel and colleagues investigated the plasticity of sensorimotor biases. As a test case, they used the influence of the aperture problem on the initiation of smooth pursuit: when a grating is moving in an oblique direction relative to its orientation, pursuit initiation is biased towards the direction orthogonal to the orientation before this error is corrected and pursuit tracks the actual 2D motion direction. Here, this well-known phenomenon was studied before and after a training block that contained repeated exposure to one stimulus orientation. The initial pursuit response remained biased even after training, while an early correction of this bias increased after training. The correction only occurred for stripped patterns but not for a homogeneous target, indicating that the learning was contingent on the stimulus. Since the correction occurred before sensory feedback of the initial pursuit response became available, the authors conclude that it is triggered predictively based on the motor signal.

      Strengths:

      The highlights of the study are the extensive data collection and the elaborate methods: the combination of pre- and post-tests within one session and training over five sessions allows for study plasticity at multiple time scales. The clever manipulation of stimulus features allows us to identify the reference frame of learning. The comprehensive and detailed analysis of smooth pursuit eye movements allows to reliably distinguish between the initial bias and its correction and to precisely assess the time course of correction, both within a trial and across trials.

      Weaknesses:

      The analysis is focused on smooth pursuit and does not consider catch-up saccades that were removed from the velocity traces by linear interpolation. Without information on the frequency and direction of catch-up saccades, it remains unclear whether saccades contributed to the correction and how they were affected by the training.

      The authors interpret their results as evidence that the early pursuit correction is driven by the sensorimotor signal during initiation. I do not quite understand how they can ultimately exclude the possibility that the error correction is driven by a dynamic change in the sensory motion signal.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      This study investigates whether mPFC activity reflects prediction error or salience across appetitive and aversive tasks. The authors recorded bulk calcium activity and used optogenetic manipulations to test its relationship to behavior. The cross-valence comparison, combination of photometry and optogenetic manipulations, and large cohorts are strengths. However, the experimental designs do not clearly distinguish prediction error from salience, and the optogenetic findings are difficult to interpret because the manipulations are confounded with sex. Thus, although the study addresses an important question and its methods and data may be useful to the field, the evidence does not establish that mPFC codes salience or fully support the authors' conclusions. Below are my main concerns.

      (1) The authors find no evidence of prediction-error signaling in mPFC and argue that salience explains their findings. I have concerns about this interpretation. Calcium responses could reflect sensory-event detection rather than salience. The stronger-shock manipulation is informative because mild and strong shocks evoke similar mPFC responses despite their different physical intensities. This argues against a simple relationship between the signal and stimulus magnitude. However, if salience drives neural responses, it is difficult to explain why doubling shock intensity did not increase bulk calcium activity: "the magnitude of increase did not scale with the magnitude of outcome value or RPE" (line 491, Figure 2f). A stronger shock is more painful, more unexpected, and more salient than a mild one.

      (2) The omission trials are also difficult to interpret. The absence of calcium signals during shock or pellet omission cannot distinguish between a lack of prediction error, the absence of a sensory event at the expected outcome time, or insufficient photometry sensitivity. If salience governs mPFC responses, the absence of shock may itself be the most salient outcome for the animal because it is surprising.

      (3) The conclusions overstate what fiber photometry can show. Bulk signals can average together neurons with opposing response signs. The authors can conclude that bulk mPFC photometry did not distinguish the tested outcome conditions in a manner consistent with signed prediction error. They cannot conclude from these data that mPFC lacks prediction-error or value coding.

      (4) The movement correlation is interesting, but the authors should discuss prior work linking prefrontal activity to freezing behavior (Burgos-Robles et al., 2009; Kyriazi et al., 2020; Casanova et al., 2024). Additionally, cross-correlations are computed on event-averaged traces, which show shared event-locking, not continuous coupling.

      (5) The manuscript also states that "fluctuations in Ca2+ signal were fully explained by integrated salience and general uninstructed movement across all stages of learning regardless of task-defined behavioral performance" (lines 868-870). The authors do not report a variance-explained model to support this statement.

      (6) Because the central claim is that bulk mPFC activity tracks movement, the authors should assess whether movement-related artifacts contribute to the signal, particularly during vigorous movements such as darting and shock responses. They used 405 nm light as an isosbestic control for calcium-independent motion artifacts (lines 176-178) and corrected the GCaMP signal by fitting the 405 nm signal to the 465 nm signal before calculating ΔF/F (lines 184-187; Supplemental Figure 1a-c). This correction may not remove all artifacts, including hemodynamic changes that affect the two wavelengths differently. To help readers assess whether event-related changes in the calcium signal remain after correction, the authors should show the raw 405 nm and 465 nm signals, as well as the corrected GCaMP signal, aligned to darting onset, freezing onset and offset, and shock delivery.

      (7) The freezing/darting dissociation is interesting but confounded. Darting is defined differently across cohorts: by a trained classifier using a qualitative definition ("sudden and rapid escape-like movement") in the photometry cohort, and by a velocity threshold ({greater than or equal to}54 cm/s, {greater than or equal to}0.2 s) in the optogenetic cohort. The authors should provide a quantitative definition for both cohorts and state whether shock-elicited escape responses were excluded.

      (8) The classification of rats as "pellet-responsive" or "non-responsive" is problematic. First, rats are split at zero on a distribution of post-pellet Ca2+ rises that appears unimodal (Figure 6a), and the two groups are then compared on the same calcium measure used to define them. The representational similarity analysis does not validate the grouping independently, because it uses the same pellet-evoked responses. Responsive rats also show larger responses to every task event, not only to the pellet, which raises the possibility that the groups differ in signal quality, expression, or fiber placement. The authors should compare signal-to-noise ratio, expression, and implant location between groups, and treat pellet responsiveness as a continuous variable instead of dividing rats into two groups.

      Second, the behavioral differences appeared only after a change of analysis. Summary statistics during probe testing showed no differences in reward seeking or velocity between groups (Figure 6g,h; Supplemental Figure 6). The authors then applied functional linear mixed models to the training data and reported lower reward seeking during the cue and delay, but greater reward seeking immediately after pellet delivery, in responsive rats (Figure 6i). The authors interpret these results as a more precise retrieval strategy, but the direction could be reversed. Rats that approach the magazine promptly after pellet delivery would be expected to show a calcium increase linked to that action, which, by the authors' own account, reflects movement. The authors should show, on a trial-by-trial basis, that the pellet-evoked calcium rise precedes rather than follows magazine approach.

      (9) I have several concerns about the optogenetic experiment. The constructs are not equivalent. The opsins are expressed under different promoters (Syn for ChR2, nEF for NpHR), and the GFP control uses a different serotype (AAV2 vs AAV8), so viral spread and cell-type expression may differ between groups. Both opsins are pan-neuronal and therefore also target interneurons, making the net effect of stimulation or inhibition difficult to predict. The authors should show expression spread for each construct and discuss this issue.

      (10) The opsin is confounded with sex. Figure 4b shows that most darters are female. However, darting is also present in males, and in the optogenetic experiment, where channelrhodopsin (ChR2) was expressed in males and halorhodopsin (NpHR) in females, the authors report darters in all groups (line 688: "During baseline testing, 5 out of 8 ChR2 rats, 2 out of 7 NpHR rats, and 3 out of 6 GFP rats were identified as darters"). Because distinct opsins were injected in females and males, the effects of opsin and sex cannot be separated.

      (11) Several optogenetic conclusions rest on within-group comparisons rather than comparisons with GFP controls. During the intertrial interval, GFP rats showed the same increase in freezing and decrease in velocity during light delivery as NpHR rats (Figure 8a,b), which the authors attribute to freezing naturally increasing as the next trial approaches (lines 724-726). In the context-control session (Figure 8c,d), the significant interaction is again followed only by within-group pre-versus-ON comparisons. The authors should test directly whether light-induced changes in ChR2 and NpHR rats differ from those in GFP rats. During the task, summary statistics showed no effect of inhibition (Figure 7f-i). The delay-period reduction in movement and darting (Figure 7h) is a main effect of laser across all groups, including GFP, yet the Discussion states that manipulation "in either direction decreased movement velocity (i.e., suppressed darting)" (line 813), while the Results describe the ChR2 effect as nonsignificant (line 692). Given that opsin is confounded with sex (point 10), these effects should be interpreted cautiously.

      (12) The authors hypothesized that stimulation and inhibition would have opposite effects on darting, yet both reduced darting. Still, the Discussion states that the hypothesis was "largely validated" (line 815).

      (13) The mPFC is composed of PL and IL, which have opposite effects in fear conditioning, and the recordings may also include dorsal regions. The injection coordinates (ML +1.4; lines 116-117) and the large volume of AAV9 (500 nL; line 119) make it likely that expression extended into the anterior cingulate and secondary motor cortex. Fiber placements also appear more dispersed in males than in females (Figure 1c). A movement-related signal could therefore originate in motor or cingulate regions rather than in PL, and the same concern applies to opsin spread in the optogenetic experiments. I would like to see expression maps and the movement correlation analyzed by fiber placement. In addition, the atlas levels shown in Figure 1c (+5.64 to +4.20) do not match the stated AP coordinate (+3.2) (line 116).

      (14) The criteria for learning are not defined. The Methods state only that "learning was indicated by an increase" in conditioned freezing (line 147) or in anticipatory reward seeking (line 162), without specifying a threshold or performance criterion. The two tasks also differ substantially in training. The aversive group received a single 10-trial conditioning session, whereas the appetitive group received 6-9 sessions of 20 trials, and it is not stated what determined the number of sessions for each rat. As a result, the two groups may have been at different stages of learning when prediction-error probe testing began, which complicates the cross-valence comparisons. The authors should state their learning criterion, report whether any animals failed to meet it and were excluded, show individual learning curves for both tasks, and explain how the number of appetitive training sessions was determined.

      (15) A null result in a bulk signal cannot rule out prediction-error coding, because intermixed positive- and negative-coding neurons could cancel each other out (point 3). The passages on the "ontological validity" of dopamine prediction error and on mammalian brain evolution are also not connected to the data.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Rau et al. ask whether stimulus representations change as a function of task demands, and whether properties of these task-specific representational spaces relate to the formation of episodic memories. Participants are presented with pairs of animal stimuli and rate their relationship along two pairs of feature dimensions (e.g., Size & Activity versus Proximity & Climate). Each pair defines a context. The authors reconstruct participant-specific representational spaces and investigate how their geometry relates to multivoxel activity patterns in the medial temporal lobe, how these representations reorganise across task contexts, and how neural representations relate to subsequent episodic memory.

      The paper asks whether existing conceptual knowledge representations in the MTL are dynamically reorganised depending on task demands. This is an important and well-motivated question. By leveraging participants' existing knowledge about animals together with a clever within-stimulus manipulation of task context, the study provides a relatively direct test of whether representational geometry flexibly reorganises with behavioural relevance

      The analyses are executed carefully. For example, the reconstruction of representational spaces is validated using leave-one-pair-out cross-validation, and the critical neural analyses are restricted to inferred concept pairs. The relationship between behaviourally reconstructed spaces and neural representations therefore cannot simply be explained by the specific comparisons participants made during the task. Potential confounds, such as perceptual similarity and mean BOLD activity, are explicitly controlled for in the neural similarity analyses.

      Overall, I really like this paper. The experimental design and the analyses are very thorough, and I find much of the data convincing. I have a few suggestions that I think could be addressed to improve the paper:

      (1) There is no temporal gap between the second stimulus presentation and the rating period. Because the BOLD response is slow, responses elicited by the second image, stimulus comparison and evaluation, response preparation, and potentially the motor response will overlap substantially. I am therefore concerned that an RSA effect attributed to a "task-specific representation of the concept during image viewing" might partly reflect the ensuing relational evaluation process. Could the authors clarify how well the image and rating event regressors can be separated? I would also suggest testing the RSA effect using the first images alone, because these are temporally better separated from the rating period. If the task-specific RSA effect holds for these images, the claim of task-dependent representational geometry during stimulus viewing would become considerably stronger. If this is not the case, I suggest toning down statements such as "task-relevant information affected representations during the viewing of the images, before behavioral ratings were obtained".

      (2) I am uncertain about the concept-level "remapping" measure. The authors define it as the difference in radial distance from the origin between space 1 and space 2. Firstly, could the authors clarify whether the concept-level reorganisation measure is the signed difference between distances to the origin or the absolute difference? The Methods and Figure 4 caption specify dist(space1) - dist(space2), whereas the exclusively positive values in Figure 4B and the interpretation in terms of the magnitude of reorganisation suggest that the absolute difference may have been used.

      (3) More generally, I am wondering whether a change in radial distance really measures how much a concept moves between two spaces. For example, a concept could have the same distance from the origin in both spaces while having very different relationships to the other concepts. Measuring only changes in eccentricity would show no remapping in such a case. One possible alternative would be to characterize each concept by its vector of distances to all other concepts and quantify how much this relational profile changes between spaces, for example:

      concept remapping = 1 − corr(distances to all other concepts in space 1, distances to all other concepts in space 2)

      The less similar the two relational-distance profiles are, the greater the remapping. Could the authors show whether the results hold with this or another measure that captures changes in relational embedding beyond changes in eccentricity?

      (4) The two images are encoded under quite different circumstances: the second image is immediately followed by the rating process, whereas the first image is not. The authors show that larger 2D distances predict higher subsequent memory confidence for first and second images (although the effect seems to be more pronounced for second images), but they do not report whether memory itself was better for first versus second images, nor whether the distance effect differs significantly between positions. This could be informative to know. Furthermore, the analyses relating representational distance to memory confidence appear to be restricted to subsequently remembered stimuli. Does this relationship also hold when all encoded items are included? This would more directly test whether representational distance predicts subsequent memory strength, rather than "only" confidence among images that were successfully recognised.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript addresses how and why intracellular-specific metabolites associated with biosynthesis end up outside microbial cells. Using a variety of approaches (analytical chemistry, metabolic models, comparative analyses of mutants) and incorporating their own data as well as data from previous studies, the authors find an inverse relationship between metabolite externalization and the cost of producing those metabolites, and that both uptake and efflux transporters are major participants in determining extracellular metabolite levels.

      Strengths:

      (1) Presents much useful raw information that will benefit the broader community interested in microbial physiology, ecology, evolution, and biotechnology.

      (2) Compares the authors' own data with data from previous studies.

      (3) Considers and addresses alternative hypotheses.

      (4) Varied approaches and data sets without losing sight of the core motivating questions - this is a large and impressive amount of work.

      (5) Distils many diverse data sets to deliver clear and insightful interpretations.

      Weaknesses:

      No weaknesses were identified by this reviewer. There is always more to learn, but this manuscript already delivers more than I would typically expect; this is an important advance in an area that has been of much recent interest and debate.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Precursors of N-glycans of eukaryotic glycoproteins and of bacterial cell wall/envelop components, such as peptidoglycans and lipopolysaccharides, comprise lipid carrier (dolichol in eukaryotes and polyprenol in bacteria) linked via pyrophosphate to specific oligosaccharides (lipid-linked oligosaccharides or LLO). Homeostasis and quality control of dolichol-linked oligosaccharides (DLO) are critical for homeostasis and quality control of glycoproteins. Likewise, homeostasis and quality control of bacterial LLO are critical for proper biogenesis of the cell wall/envelope. Suzuki group previously reported the identification of Saccharomyces cerevisiae DLO pyrophosphatase termed Llp1 and demonstrated its critical role in homeostasis and quality control of DLO by hydrolyzing surplus and/or abnormal DLO. VanZ, a homolog of Llp1 found in Gram-positive bacteria, had LLO pyrophosphatase activity, suggesting its role in homeostasis and quality control of precursors of cell wall peptidoglycan. However, functional homologs of Llp1/VanZ in Gram-negative bacteria and plants have been unknown. In this paper, the authors demonstrate that YfiM of E. coli and its Arabidopsis thaliana homolog AT1G15900 are remote homologs of Llp1/VanZ having similarities in organization of transmembrane domains and the catalytic regions. YfiM and AT1G15900 have LLO-pyrophosphatase activity. YfiM is critical in cell wall integrity. Together, these findings suggest the presence of pyrophosphatases involved in homeostasis and quality control of LLO in fungi, bacteria, and plants.

      Strengths:

      Taking advantage of DELTA-BLAST and the authors' original LLO pyrophosphatase assay, the authors discovered LLO pyrophosphatases in Gram-negative bacteria (E. coli YfiM) and plants (Arabidopsis AT1G15900).

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The authors used Man5GlcNAc2-PP-dolichol, N-glycan precursor, in LLO pyrophosphatase assays for VanZ, YfiM, and AT1G15900. Direct evidence for pyrophosphatase activities against their specific substrates is missing. Because of this, the substrate specificities of these pyrophosphatases for various LLOs are yet to be determined.

      (2) Although YfiM-KO E. coli was more sensitive to vancomycin than the wild-type strain (ID50 was 50 vs 80 micrograms/mL), it is unclear whether YfiM plays a role only in peptidoglycan biogenesis or in lipopolysaccharide biogenesis as well.

      (3) AT1G15900 hydrolyzed Man5GlcNAc2-PP-dolichol. Direct experimental evidence for the roles of AT1G15900 in N-glycans/glycoproteins (for example, phenotypic characterization of AT1G15900 mutant A. thaliana cells or plants) is missing.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      Using cryofixation and serial block-face electron microscopy (SBEM), P. Vijayakumar and K. Cauwenberghs characterize extracellular vesicles (EVs) and non-vesicular extracellular particles (NVEPs) within native Drosophila olfactory sensilla. The study provides a unique and valuable dataset comprising approximately 7,800 extracellular particles, systematically describing their morphology, size, density, and distribution. The ultrastructural analysis across different sensillum classes offers insights into the potential biogenesis and functions of these extracellular particles.

      Strengths:

      Cryofixation preserves EVs and NVEPs within native tissue conditions. The detailed quantification of a very large dataset provides a unique source of information on extracellular particle number, categories, distribution. The expertise of the group in the method and the tissue explored as well as their detailed quantification provide confidence in the dataset and observations.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors describe a novel method that uses genomic data to identify loci underlying barriers to gene flow among populations. The method involves estimating dxy-based trees for individual genomic windows and scanning across windows to identify deep partitions in genetic variation across populations. The authors apply this method to a pool-seq dataset collected from snapdragon populations of different subspecies that differ in flower pigmentation. Eight putative barrier loci are identified in this study, three corresponding to well-characterized flower color genes in Antirrhinum. The authors validate three other barrier loci as new candidate genes for flower color variation using genetic co-segregation analyses. The described method offers a way to identify barrier loci among populations without assigning samples into predetermined groups and can also be applied to pool-seq data that is commonly generated to examine how allele frequencies vary over geographic space. The paper would be improved by clarifying whether and how the method, as presented, reproducibly identifies barrier loci corresponding to deep divergence events.

      Strengths:

      A strength of this paper is the development of a method that can identify early genetic partitions in a set of population samples without a priori assigning them into groups. This approach will therefore be relevant to population geneticists studying species barriers. The method is flexible and can be applied to various kinds of population genomic datasets, including poolseq data.

      In a demonstration of the method, this paper identifies three new genetic loci that contribute to differences in floral color patterning between the two snapdragon taxa, which are validated using co-segregation analyses. These new findings are a significant addition to the body of work describing the polygenic basis for flower color differences among snapdragon taxa.

      Weaknesses:

      The study could be improved with further clarification of whether and how the dxy-tree scanning algorithm reproducibly identifies barrier regions. To identify groups of outlier trees, the authors first bin dxy trees based on the cophenetic correlation coefficient (c) and then identify outliers based on a threshold value of SRB=0.002. Which trees are identified as outliers appears to be sensitive to the starting seed tree (as reported in the main text), as well as the chosen value of c (as demonstrated in Figure S3). Moreover, outlier forests are chosen based on average mean division depth, and yet the mean division depth for a given forest appears to vary substantially across values of c, again demonstrated in Figure S3. The choice of c=0.5 and 0.002 as thresholds for SRB was not explained. It is unclear how readers would make their own decisions about threshold cutoffs should they apply to their own data. The manuscript would be improved if the authors address this important issue of whether and how their approach, as presented, can reproducibly identify sets of trees that represent outliers in genomic variation.

      A related issue is that by first binning trees based on similarity, then filtering on mean SRB value, the method potentially returns outlier forests containing individual trees with low SRB values. Should such trees be considered barrier loci? If so, it might be worth revisiting/softening some of the conceptual framing throughout the paper, because trees with lower SRB values would be consistent with gene flow across the partitions (i.e., not barrier loci). Would a more conservative approach be to first summarize SRB length in the set of non-singleton trees, filter individuals based on an empirically derived SRB threshold, and then cluster the set of SRB-outlier trees?

      To address these weaknesses, the authors should provide a more nuanced discussion of the nature of the genomic regions returned from their algorithm and suggest/demonstrate approaches to reproducibly return genuine barrier loci.

      Finally, we suggest the authors include a brief discussion of how variation in the rate of molecular evolution across loci affects the results, given that the SRB threshold is an absolute (not relative) threshold.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors used a visual flash discrimination task in which two flashes are presented one after another with different inter-stimulus intervals. Participants either perceive one flash or two flashes. The authors show that the simultaneous presence of an auditory input extends the temporal window of integration, meaning that two flashes presented shortly after one another are more likely to be perceived as a single flash. Auditory inputs are accompanied by a reduction in alpha frequency over visual areas. Prestimulus alpha frequency predicts perceptual outcomes in the absence of auditory stimuli, whereas prestimulus alpha phase becomes the dominant predictor when auditory input is present. A computational model based on phase-resetting theory supports these findings. Additionally, a transcranial stimulation experiment confirms the causal role of alpha frequency in unimodal visual perception but not in cross-modal contexts.

      Strengths:

      The authors elegantly combined several approaches-from behavior to computational modeling and EEG-to provide a comprehensive overview of the mechanisms involved in visual integration in the presence or absence of auditory input. The methods used are state-of-the-art, and the authors attempted to address possible pitfalls.

      Overall, these results provide new insights into the role of alpha oscillations in visual processing and offer an interesting perspective on the current debate regarding the roles of alpha phase and frequency in visual perception. More generally, they contribute to our understanding of the neural dynamics of multisensory integration.

      Comments on revised version.

      I thank the authors for carefully addressing my comments.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Song et al. introduce an Intrinsic Network Flow (INF) framework, which combines the power of dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) with dimensionality reduction from ICA. They describe brain signals through INF modes reflecting the amplitudes and relative temporal ordering between different INs, relating these INF modes to the principal functional connectivity gradient, and finally showing that the dynamic amplitudes and phases have different properties related to tasks and subject specificity. The most compelling result is that tasks are best discriminated by the relative phases of INF modes rather than their amplitudes, highlighting that task dynamics in the brain may depend on a stable mode organization while modulating the phases of these modes.

      Strengths:

      Using DMD on INs to gain a tractable insight into the spatiotemporal dynamics of the brain is a clear advantage of this work. The authors rightly point out that spatial modes and temporal dynamics are not often unified, and therefore this INF framework nicely addresses that limitation. The framework also accommodates the often neglected subcortex and cerebellum, which is an asset.

      The training/testing split combined with the replication analysis offers another compelling strength: the findings are stable and likely to generalize among healthy young adults. This is also bolstered by the analysis relating INF modes to the principal gradients of FC, which show that different principal gradients can be viewed as different modes with specific phase relationships between the component INs.

      In general, the main argument of the work is convincing: that the brain has stable modes with internal phase relationships (y) that manifest in macroscopic dynamical activity with between-mode phase offsets (θ) collectively constructively/destructively interfering to produce observed brain activity.

      Weaknesses:

      Although this main argument is convincing, the study's framing of INs as the primitives for brain-level activity is not adequately justified. ICA aims to identify latent sources (here, INs) in the data, but taking these as representations of the data from which generative arguments can be made is not presently justified. Several prior works by Braga and colleagues have shown that resting state networks can become more subject-specific and decouple when the single-subject data is sufficiently sampled (Braga et al., 2017, Neuron, among others). This raises a question about whether group-level INFs performing similarly to single-subject INFs may simply be due to the group-level INs that enter the single-subject DMD. Fully subject-specific analyses would be beneficial, but even in HCP it remains unclear whether the INs that could be identified are truly as subject-specific as some of the above-referenced works show they can be in principle.

      Along a similar point, the AR(1) null-model analysis seems like a relatively weak null, and alternative comparison or null models could better justify the primacy of INs. For example, INs could be spatially randomized (the authors already do spatial randomization for their correlational statistics) and then used in DMD to identify modes with similar between-mode phase (θ) relationships. Or more generally, if the dimensionality reduction was in the form of parcels, as commonly is the case in connectomics, do similar DMD modes appear? The authors in the discussion position their findings in relationship to geometric modes and connectome harmonics, which in principle could also enter a DMD algorithm to identify analogous INF modes. The DMD algorithm is what creates the spatiotemporal modes, and the basis for defining y(t) to enter DMD has many possible choices. Additionally, at least one previous analysis did analyze spatiotemporal structure: they used the eigenmodes of a complex Laplacian with propagation delays corresponding to phases between brain regions, and they showed that these modes themselves relate to INs (Xie et al., 2021, NeuroImage). This appears much more generative than the present article. If the authors want to claim the ICA-based INs as the decisive generators, a competition between these alternative choices would decide that result and significantly strengthen the generality of the article's main argument.

      Along this point, the authors spend considerable space in the article describing the correspondence to the principal functional gradients, yet the heart of their argument, as I understood it, is about the primacy of phase relationships in whole-brain dynamics. True, these INF modes now recontextualize the principal gradients in terms of phases, but the most convincing piece is the 23-task classification, which is relegated to the final panel of the final figure. Moreover, other convincing analyses, such as the heritability analysis and its relationship to INF amplitude, are not shown in the main text and instead placed in the supplemental figure. Related to the above comment about alternative bases to define DMD, could the relationship between principal functional gradients and the INF modes be a result of defining those very modes by INs which we already know correspond to principal gradients?

      None of these weaknesses, however, appear to directly undermine the results that the authors do present. They merely suggest that the specific interpretations the authors want to make may outrun what their results can presently support.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This computational study investigates the physical mechanisms underlying enhancer-promoter (E-P) interactions across genomic distances in Drosophila chromosomes, motivated by a previously published study that revealed unexpectedly frequent long-range contacts challenging classical polymer models. The authors performed coarse-grained polymer simulations testing three chromatin organization models: ideal polymers, loop extrusion, and compartmental segregation, comparing their predictions to experimental Hi-C contact maps, mean E-P distances, and two-locus mean-squared displacement dynamics. They found that compartmental segregation best captured both the structural and dynamic features observed experimentally, while neither ideal chains nor loop extrusion alone could reproduce all experimental observables. The combination of compartmental segregation with loop extrusion further improved agreement with experimental data, suggesting these mechanisms might be involved in Drosophila chromatin organization.

      Strengths:

      The paper has two primary strengths: First, the simulations are based on biologically interpretable mechanisms (compartmentalization and loop extrusion), which may facilitate making specific experimentally testable predictions. Second, the work uses a systematic approach to increase model complexity by directly fitting to data, first establishing that simple models fail to capture the data until arriving at a more complex model that does capture the data.

      Weaknesses:

      The authors have addressed some of the comments of the first round of review. However, some of the new additions are hard to interpret and several issues raised by both reviewers remain unaddressed.

      First, the authors have included additional analysis to better characterize the dynamics during the coil-globule transition in the simulations (Fig 4), including how MFPTs change as a function of the epsilon parameter. However, Fig. 4D is extremely hard to interpret as a colormap of a deviation between two models is very hard to read. A better plot would be to plot MFPT and relaxation time tau (raw values, not deviation) vs s for different values of epsilon, as well as the scaling exponents of MFPT and tau vs s as a function of epsilon - if indeed proximity to the transition is important for long range encounters, then the scaling exponents should exhibit some sort of specific dip at the critical epsilon. I'm somewhat doubtful if that will actually be the case though.

      Despite these additional simulation results, I maintain that the paper does not provide sufficient evidence to support its title, as I had said in the first round of review. The statement that "Near-critical chromatin fluctuations facilitate long-range contacts in Drosophila chromosomes." requires very strong evidence, not from a formal statistical physics perspective, but also from a biological perspective. It would require an explicit demonstration of (1) that there indeed are near-critical fluctuations in the experimental data and (2) that these are causal for long-range contacts. This would likely require experiments to test such a claim, such as a perturbation away from the hypothesized near-critical point to show that long-range contacts are no longer possible. That is clearly outside of the scope of this computational study. Instead, the current study shows that within a relatively limited class of models, best-fit (but by no means perfect fit, as pointed out by the authors themselves in the text) appears to be achieved near such a transition within the model class. I therefore think that a title along the lines of "Polymer simulations near the coil-globule transition are consistent with enhancer-promoter dynamics in Drosophila chromosomes" would better reflect the evidence provided in the paper.

      Furthermore, the first comment by reviewer 2 remains unaddressed. In Major Issue (1), reviewer 2 suggests to determine the impact of the homie element in the experimental data underlying the study by also analyzing and comparing model prediction to the experimental data lacking the homie element from Bruckner et al, yet as far as I can tell from the rebuttal and the text this has not been done. It's a relatively simple thing to do and should be included, at least in the SI.

      Additional suggestions

      The authors discuss the shortcomings of their model in predicting all the features of the data together, in particular the fine structure of the HiC map. In the discussion the comparison to Shi et al. (ref 66 - now published in Sci Adv), could make this more explicit: yes, the Shi model is less mechanistic, but also achieves a much better fit of the data, see e.g. the HiC Map in Fig. 2A of ref 66. That predictiveness vs interpretability trade-off could be emphasized more.<br /> Another feature that none of the proposed models in this paper captures is the fact s-dependent two-locus diffusivity reported in Bruckner et al and explained in a recent preprint: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.03.10.710930v1.

      This is expected, since all the polymer models considered here incorporate spatially uncorrelated noise (as far as I can tell), and thus the MSDs all converge to a single line (e.g. Fig. 5G). This is not a shortcoming of this work, since that effect required hydrodynamic coupling which is outside of the model class considered here, but it would be interesting to discuss this in detail in the discussion since the simulations very nicely show the absence of this coherent motion.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this paper, Jackson et al. propose a mathematical model - to be precise, an ordinary differential equation (ODE) model - of microglia migration in the retina following inflammation, which in the data used in this paper, is induced by injection of bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS). The model consists of a component describing the LPS absorption (1-2 equations) and a component describing microglia migration through three tissue layers (3 equations). The model is fitted to data from mice, rats, and rhesus macaques. The results suggest that microglia migration kinetics mattered the most for shaping the outcome, whereas LPS distribution kinetics and the initial distribution of the microglia appeared to matter less.

      Strengths:

      (1) The authors state that this is the first model of microglia migration in the retina following inflammation. While I did not check this claim in detail, I am indeed not aware of any earlier migration modeling efforts done in this specific field. There are a number of adjacent fields in immunology where the migration of other immune cells has been studied in great detail; examples include T cell migration in the lymph nodes, skin, liver, and brain, B cell migration in lymph nodes, tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes, and many others. This paper therefore adds to an already rich body of literature and could be potentially interesting for a diverse group of modelers in immunology. Several related migration models are cited in the paper already.

      (2) The paper is clearly written and easy to follow.

      (3) The model has a simple and intuitive structure and is easy to understand.

      (4) The model is analyzed in great detail, including several parameter sweeps and a range of sensitivity analyses that were performed to understand the uncertainty of model predictions.

      (5) The approach to calibrate the model primarily to data from one species and then perform a range of predictions of the impact of species-specific differences, given available data, is interesting and is not frequently done in the modeling literature, as far as I am aware. This could serve as an inspiration for other modeling studies.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Related to the first strength, the links to existing models are currently not made explicit (although the papers are cited, the models are not explicitly compared to the paper's model). A more detailed comparison could make the work even more relevant for others.

      (2) The main research question of the paper - how do the different kinetic parameters shape the outcome - is rather generic and of a somewhat exploratory nature; it does not appear to be linked to a current specific question in the field of retinal neuroinflammation. This potentially limits the impact of the work; while mathematical modelers could be interested in the first model of this specific system, biologists may find this paper more difficult to digest and may be less motivated to work through this body of work.

      (3) The ratio of model parameters to amount of data appears to be on the high side. The authors are aware of and credit this limitation, and conduct multiple sensitivity analyses and practical identifiability analyses. This is laudable, but ultimately these analyses do show signs that the model may be insufficiently constrained by the data, at least in some aspects. In this regard, it could be important to clearly state the number of raw data points used (see suggestions below).

      (4) The ODE formulation of the model could overlook important spatial variation of microglia density. Since the cells appear to be quite dispersed (from looking at the figures in reference 15), an agent-based model or other spatially explicit model could add additional important insight. Indeed, the model includes a few terms such as the saturation terms in Equations 5 and 6 that appear to be included to account for such spatial effects indirectly.

      (5) The model predicts how microglia distribution across the retina should be affected by changing administration routes and/or LPS kinetics. LPS data from rats and rhesus macaques are used to re-fit the LPS part of the model, and other parameters are kept fixed. However, it seems to be at least conceivable that the other parameters could also be species-dependent. There is no data available for checking these predictions for other species, making this part of the work more speculative.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary

      In this paper, Panti, Stagg, Sharott & Stedehouder investigate the activity of the mediodorsal thalamic nucleus (MD). In rodents, it has long been known that the MD is divided into three distinct subregions (central, medial, and lateral), differentiated by their afferent and efferent connections. However, until now, no one had demonstrated distinct electrophysiological properties in vivo across the three MD subdivisions.

      In this study, the authors recorded, in head-fixed mice performing a sensorimotor task, the extracellular activity of neurons from the different MD subdivisions using Neuropixels probes. They revealed differences in extracellular spike waveform (amplitude, repolarization latency, peak-to-trough ratio) as well as spiking and burst activity, with MDc neurons exhibiting higher firing rates, lower rate variability and higher burst index and rate than the other two subdivisions. They also show that a classifier based on these parameters allows categorization of neurons according to their MD subdivision, in particular the MDc.

      Strengths

      There is growing interest in the role of the mediodorsal thalamus, and its characterization is very important. MD subdivisions, due to their specific anatomical connectivity, can support distinct functions. The question of identifying MD subdivisions based on extracellularly recorded spikes is particularly compelling.

      The dataset is very strong and large and is well described in the supplementary figures. The work is technically sound, and every step of the methods used is well presented. The authors present all results from the different cohorts honestly, and they also perform various controls.

      Weaknesses

      I have concerns regarding the meaningfulness of the waveform analysis and statistical power, as well as the interpretation of the firing activity of MD units.

      (1) Waveform analysis and statistical interpretation:

      a) In Figure 2, the distinction between waveforms across subdivisions is unclear (especially Figure 2B). The within-subdivision variability appears far higher than the between-subdivision differences, raising questions about the meaningfulness of these statistical differences.

      In extracellular recordings, spike shape differences are inherently noisy. Even when comparing extremely distinct cell types, such as pyramidal cells vs. interneurons, clustering can still show at least some partial overlap, despite the major morphological differences in spike waveforms. The effect sizes shown here suggest that the observed statistical differences may potentially lack biological significance. I thus suggest trying alternative statistical tests that might be more robust, for example, considering the animal and session as random effects with a mixed-effects model/regression. Importantly, this approach can be applied to firing rate metrics (even though the effect sizes are larger, especially for the firing rate).

      b) For a single unit, how does spike waveform evolve over the course of a recording session? In extracellular recordings, amplitude drift for the same cell can happen. Can the authors describe how they control for/account for that in their data curation?

      (2) Data interpretation of spiking metrics:

      a) The MD activity was recorded during a sensorimotor task (auditory cues, reward delivery, lever presses). The authors mention, "Across all cohorts, recordings were obtained acutely from head-fixed behaving mice performing a sensorimotor task over several days" (results, lines 98-99). It is unclear which periods the authors analyze. For example, the authors mention "spontaneous firing rate over the entire recording window" (line 164). This is confusing because the authors also mention, "These large firing rate differences across MD subdivisions were similarly evident in passive interval windows (periods outside of bar movement or auditory stimulation related to the behavioral task" (lines 168-170). It is thus unclear what is meant by spontaneous activity.

      b) Regarding the results, the differences the authors observed between MD sub-divisions in terms of firing rate and burst characteristics may reflect the engagement of those different subregions to different aspects of the tasks. Indeed, it has long been known that there are differences in anatomical connectivity that might explain the differences observed. The activity is neither naïve nor spontaneous but rather context-dependent. The data set is very strong, with many MD units recorded across different subdivisions during such tasks. Therefore, analyzing MD units in regard to these different behavioral events is critical to interpret the results on firing rate and burst activity. For example, MDc might only present strong burst activity, higher firing when the animals are pressing the bar or, in general, when they are strongly engaged in the task (which can thus also be seen during the passive interval).

      (3) How correlated is the activity of MD units recorded simultaneously within the same subdivision? Are there synchronized firing patterns such as assemblies? If so, does this vary as a function of MD subdivisions?

      (4) An accuracy of 52.5% of a classifier compared to an effect of 33% chance level is not strong but rather moderate. Most importantly, there is spatial autocorrelation. From my understanding, the authors used a ten-fold cross-validation with 90% training and 10% testing. Was the cross-validation spatially blocked (by MD subdivision)? If not, I would strongly suggest doing so.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      This study identifies a novel PARP16-NFAT1 signaling axis that attenuates pathological cardiac remodeling, supported by strong, multi-dimensional evidence from genetic mouse models, transcriptomics, ChIP-qPCR, and molecular dynamics simulations. The findings are mechanistically novel and offer potential therapeutic targets for heart failure, though several methodological and reporting issues require further clarification and revision.

      This manuscript demonstrated that PARP16 expression is significantly downregulated in cardiac tissues from heart failure patients. Using whole-body, cardiomyocyte-specific, inducible cardiomyocyte-specific PARP16 knockout and overexpression mouse models, the authors confirmed that PARP16 effectively attenuates adverse cardiac remodeling and improves cardiac function. Mechanistically, the authors integrated multiple experimental approaches, including transcriptome sequencing, ChIP-qPCR, PARP16 knockout and transgenic mouse model generation, and all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. They revealed that PARP16 mediates ADP-ribosylation of NFAT1 in a catalytic activity-dependent manner, restrains nuclear accumulation and transcriptional activation of NFAT1, and defines a novel PARP16-NFAT1 signaling axis that modulates pathological cardiac remodeling. Overall, this study is well designed, and the multi-dimensional experimental evidence strongly supports the core scientific hypothesis. The findings provide novel mechanistic insights and potential therapeutic targets for heart failure.

      However, several aspects require further optimization, supplementation, and clarification to be improved.

      (1) There are mismatches between figure citations and graphical results. The authors should carefully check and revise relevant figures, including Figure 6BCEF and Figure 8CD.

      (2) For Figure 1CD, the original high-definition images, detailed statistical workflows, and raw quantitative data regarding PARP16 expression in human failing hearts should be provided.

      (3) The study used ANP, BNP, α-MHC, and β-MHC as hallmark biomarkers of heart failure. The biological significance and rationale of these indicators should be briefly introduced in the manuscript.

      (4) Redundant phenotypic results are observed in Figure 3B/C, Figure 4C/D, and Figure 5B/C. The authors are suggested to retain Figure 3B, Figure 4C, and Figure 5B, supplement quantitative statistical analysis of protein expression levels, and provide all high-definition images and complete statistical datasets.

      (5) In lines 313-321, the authors discussed inconsistent conclusions between the present study and reference 16 and attributed the discrepancies to different disease models and experimental approaches. Does this mean that the disease model and approaches in the article are unreliable? Has any related validation been conducted in this model? The mRNA and protein expression levels of key molecules in the IRE1α-sXBP1-GATA4 signaling pathway should be detected and validated.

      (6) The official ethical approval document (HEC No: 06/22.06.2023) and written informed consent documents for human sample collection must be submitted.

      (7) Typographical errors should be corrected throughout the manuscript, such as the incorrect word "hypertrophy" (line 100).

      (8) To validate the successful construction of genetically modified mice and ensure the reliability of subsequent phenotypic and mechanistic data, the authors need to supplement detailed genotyping primer sequences, representative agarose gel electrophoresis images, and complete genotyping statistical results.

      Addressing the above-mentioned issues will significantly improve the quality, rigor, and readability of this work.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors investigate genomic structural alterations following CRISPR-Cas9 editing of DNMT3A and SRSF2 in human HSPCs, with particular attention to DNA-PK inhibition. They report that CRISPR editing induces large on-target deletions and genome-wide structural variants, while AZD7648 has a modest additional effect. PolQ inhibition reduces large deletions, and simultaneous editing of two loci is associated with increased genomic rearrangements.

      Strengths:

      The combination of nanopore sequencing and single-cell Strand-seq provides a comprehensive approach to investigating genomic alterations. The improved analytical pipeline for detecting large deletions is a methodological strength. The identification of PolQ inhibition as a potential strategy to reduce undesirable editing outcomes is particularly valuable.

      Weaknesses:

      The genome-wide structural variant findings would benefit from independent validation, particularly the reported translocations outside the targeted loci. The analysis was performed on cultured HSC-enriched cells rather than functionally validated long-term HSCs, limiting conclusions about therapeutic safety. Additionally, the mechanistic interpretation of PolQ-dependent repair requires further support.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

      The retina adapts to statistics of the scenes it views, and in particular can adapt to million-fold changes in light intensity. The adaptation alters how the population of retinal ganglion cells encodes the scenes, and it is unclear how downstream circuits could handle different types of changes in scene encoding. This careful study investigates how a population of six different retinal ganglion cells changes their encoding response properties as a function of mean luminance level. It does this by mapping receptive fields and response nonlinearities over a million-fold change in light intensity, from the scotopic to photopic regime.

      This paper has several strengths. (1) It is clearly written and lays out clearly the alternative hypotheses it examines. (2) Its experiments are carefully done and rigorously analyzed. (3) It finds interesting results, pointing especially to two cell types that seem to stand out for their different responses to increasing light levels in these experiments. It also finds less spatial and temporal integration at low light levels than theory predicts (or than others have found).

      This paper has relatively minor weaknesses. (1) It does not particularly resolve why its results are different from prior, similar experiments, though it carefully discusses and highlights those differences. (2) The functional implications of these results, and especially the two cell types that stand out from the crowd, are not discussed with much depth. This likely reflects an issue beyond this paper: that the functions of different RGC types for visual processing in the brain remain poorly understood, which in turn makes it difficult to understand functional implications of these results.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study investigates how behavioral, morphological, and mechanosensory traits contribute to the ability of Drosophila species to use firm, intact fruits as oviposition substrates. By comparing oviposition behavior across ten species, the authors confirmed D. suzukii and identified D. immigrans as two species that can overcome the mechanical barrier imposed by firm fruit surfaces despite belonging to distinct species groups and possessing markedly different ovipositor morphologies. The study further uses the genetic toolkit of D. melanogaster to identify iav as an important regulator of stiffness-dependent oviposition inhibition and examines functional differences among iav orthologs from D. melanogaster, D. suzukii, and D. immigrans. Finally, laboratory offspring-development assays and a field survey are used to relate these behavioral and mechanistic differences to fruit use in an ecological context.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of this study is its broad comparative framework. The authors examine oviposition behavior across ten Drosophila species and identify two distinct morphological strategies associated with the ability to use firm, intact fruits: the robust, serrated ovipositor of D. suzukii, which has been previously well-documented, and the elongated, needle-like ovipositor of D. immigrans, which was less studied. This provides an interesting example of distinct evolutionary solutions for overcoming a similar mechanical barrier.

      The functional genetic analysis in D. melanogaster is a strength. The identification of iav as a regulator of stiffness-dependent oviposition inhibition, together with loss-of-function, rescue, and neuronal-silencing experiments, provides a useful mechanistic link between mechanosensation and oviposition behavior. In particular, the cross-species rescue experiments using D. suzukii and D. immigrans iav orthologs in a common D. melanogaster mutant background provide an informative approach for testing functional differences among the orthologs while controlling for much of the broader species-specific genetic background.

      The study also makes a valuable effort to connect controlled laboratory observations to ecological patterns. The inclusion of offspring-development assays and field-collected substrates extends the study beyond laboratory oviposition assays and provides an interesting ecological context for the observed differences in fruit use.

      Weaknesses:

      It is inaccurate to characterize D. suzukii as a niche specialist. It is highly polyphagous, with hundreds of recorded hosts, and Figures 1, 2, and 6 indicate the most expanded, not narrowed, niche among the species examined. The only supporting result, in Figure S1, is aversion to rotten strawberry puree, which may have other explanations, such as bacterial effects. Without further evidence, the claim is unsupported.

      More broadly, "niche" should be defined more carefully. The experiments and results support differences in oviposition or breeding niche breadth but may not necessarily capture the broader ecological niche. Adult feeding-site preference, for example, represents another component of resource use and may not necessarily coincide with oviposition-site preference.

      The proposed distinction between relatively flexible chemical sensory tuning and a strict, non-substitutable mechanical barrier may also be more nuanced than currently presented.

      Interestingly, the iav results themselves show that loss of a single mechanosensory gene not only substantially reduces oviposition inhibition on stiff substrates but also enables puncture oviposition in D. melanogaster without a corresponding change in ovipositor morphology. Although specialized morphology likely improves penetration, this result shows that a simple genetic change can strongly alter the sensory or behavioral component of the mechanical barrier. This result somewhat complicates a strict distinction between flexible chemical tuning and mechanical constraint.

      The relationship between puncture oviposition and offspring success should be interpreted cautiously. Puncture oviposition likely facilitates access to fresh fruit, but species-specific larval traits may also affect development. Puncture-induced decay could facilitate later use by other saprophagous species while giving puncture-capable species an early advantage. Thus, the association does not establish puncture behavior as the primary determinant of larval success.

      The field survey supports the use of firm-surfaced fruits by D. suzukii and D. immigrans, but some ecological conclusions are stronger than the data support. Because local species composition and abundance are not reported, it is unclear whether their high recovery reflects preferential use of firm fruits or local abundance. The field observations are valuable, but the conclusion that mechanical capability directly produces niche partitioning in the wild requires more cautious interpretation.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors used a panel of cell models to determine if CDK4/6 overexpression resulted in resistance to the EGFR inhibitor Osimertinib, and the mechanisms underlying the resistance.

      (1) Major Concerns (highest priority):

      There is a lack of detail about the methodology in the results section/figure legends, which makes it difficult to interpret the data. Sometimes, adequate information is also not included in the methods themselves. For example, Figure 1A: how many doses did each mouse receive? How long after dosing were animals sacrificed? Figures 1E and 2A, is this RNA-seq analysis?

      Using a second EGFR inhibitor for some of the key experiments would increase the rigor of the studies shown.

      (2) Nice to have experiments:

      Using CRISPR KO of CDK4 in the CDK4 amplified HCC827 and testing response to Osi and presence of replication stress would also increase the rigor of the studies.

      The authors show that in their patient data, some cell cycle regulators which are amplified in NSCLC at similar rates at CDK4/6, such as CCNE1, had no increase in FGA. Overexpressing CCNE1 and testing Osi response in their cell models would be a nice test of their proposed mechanism that it is the genomic instability and FGA that are driving resistance. This wouldn't need to be done in vivo, but could be done using cell culture-based methods.

      Similarly, testing the overexpression of some of the proposed target genes, such as STEAP1 and AGR2, on the therapeutic response to Osi in cell culture would also be a nice test of the mechanism proposed.

      Comments on revised version.

      I appreciate that the authors updated and added more detail to the manuscript's methods and the research descriptions in the figure legends, which will help with research reproducibility. However, the paper remains largely unchanged, with no additional experiments performed by the authors, even though some of the key experiments requested were suggested by both independent reviewers (i.e. loss-of-function experiments of CDK4/6 in amplified lines and a second EGFR inhibitor), highlighting the importance of the experiments that would strengthen the manuscript's conclusions.

    1. family B, with pheochromocytoma only phenotype, we detected a previously not described c.463G>A/p.Val84Met replacement. Within this family, a prenatal diagnosis was also performed.

      PatientID: BIII3

      KindredID: B

      Case: M, 4Y0M, Serbian

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      FamilyInfo: Families were selected based on their clinical data and family history. Patient’s grandfather (BI1) had pheochromocytoma, but was not genetically tested. The patient’s father (BII2) developed pheochromocytoma at 40Y0M. Genetic testing revealed the same mutation in the patient's father. In fact, a sample of amniotic fluid was taken from the patient’s mother (BII2) during the 16th week of pregnancy for prenatal testing, which was later confirmed to be the same point mutation as BII2. See pedigree in figure 1.

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0002666 (pheochromocytoma)

      CaseHPOFreeText: Patient developed pheochromocytoma at the age of one, but progressed to bilateral pheochromocytoma 3 years later.

      CaseNotHPOs: N/A

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: p.V84M (c.250G>A)

      LegacyVariant: p.V84M (c.463G>A)

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: 428813, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/variation/428813/

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: 0.000004376, https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/variant/3-10183781-G-A

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: missense variant; transition

      CivicName: V84M (c.250G>A)

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

  2. Nov 2026
    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      "Single-molecule behavior and cell-growth regulation in human RTKs" studies 52 of the 58 human receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) on the surface of live HEK293A cells using a Total Internal Reflection Fluorescence Microscope (TIRFM) system previously described in Watanabe et al.

      Single molecule tracking is conducted automated commercial Auto Analysis System (AAS; Zido) software followed by analysis in Python via scikit-learn. The analysis includes use of a Variational Bayesian-Hidden Markov Model (VB-HMM) described previously (Hiroshima, 2018). The VB-HMM analysis was used to characterize movement of RTKs with the authors concluding that the movement could be explained by the receptors transitioning between three states: immobile, slow, and fast. Single molecular transport parameters are then extracted from the analysis and averaged results are reported. How these parameters change after stimulation are then evaluated and compared.

      To relate the diffusion "behaviors" with biological function, the authors retrieve cell growth data from loss-of-function data in the DepMap project (Arafeh, 2025). By correlating selected parameters with the functional data, the authors find that behaviors in the resting and response states partially "explained their function".

      The authors then relate specific parameters through correlation to growth-inhibitory or growth-supporting signaling, amino acid sequence characteristics ("structural"), and evolutionary parameters. Additionally, the authors build a regression model to evaluate how their behavior parameters may predict RTK functional characteristics.

      Major Comments:

      (1) The primary findings from this article are the extraction of parameters of a 3-state hidden Markov model from the analyzed single molecule trajectories of 52 RTKs. It is difficult to evaluate these primary findings since the raw data, the intermediate results, and the Python analysis scripts are not readily available to the public or this reviewer. Since my initial review for Review Commons, the Igor Pro code has been made available in https://github.com/yanagawamasataka5z-oss/smDA-Igor. In response to the initial review, the authors state "Since it is impossible to upload the entire dataset, and since there are items we wish to<br /> analyze further in the future works, we will provide the data on a case-by-case basis upon request." This seems incompatible with eLife's data sharing policies. https://elife-rp.msubmit.net/html/elife-rp_author_instructions.html#dataavailability .

      Thus, the evaluation of the underlying software, applicability of the software to the problem, or reproducibility of the results from the data remain difficult to evaluate.<br /> a. The availability of raw single molecule movies from this study are not generally available and thus it is difficult possible to evaluate the efficacy of the Zido AAS software or compare to the tracks generated to other single molecule tracking software. While it is appreciated that a mosaic of the movies is made available as Supplemental Movies 1A through 1D, these are not in a form analyzable by other tracking software. Since my initial review, the authors have released sample data:<br /> https://github.com/yanagawamasataka5z-oss/smDA-Igor/tree/main/SampleData<br /> They have also included a comparison to TrackMate. This is an improvement from the initial review.

      (2) While it is appreciated that the authors combine their extracted VB-HMM parameters of RTKs to other bioinformatic data sets, the relationship to functional and structural-sequence information is only correlative. There is no attempt in this article to validate the correlative findings.

      (3) Many statistical comparisons are made in this article across cell lines, RTKs, and parameters, but it is not clear if multiple comparison corrections are applied to compensate for the false discovery rate. The authors should provide a detailed Statistical Analysis section in the methods section.

      (4) Since the initial review, there is marked improvement in the manuscript, data, and code availability. However, the availability of the data does not rise to the expectation of eLife as stated in https://elifesciences.org/inside-elife/51839f0a/for-authors-updates-to-elife-s-data-sharing-policies . The two reasons the authors state for not sharing the data are 1) size of the data and 2) "we wish to analyze further in the future works". The authors need to more clearly state the difficult in data size which prevents data sharing. The second reason does not appear to be compatible with policies of eLife. I defer to the editor on whether an exception is appropriate in this circumstance.

      Significance:

      General assessment: The main significance of this paper comes from a broad and data-rich study of 52 of 58 human receptor tyrosine kinases. Since my initial review, additional code and data have been made available, however the primary data remains inaccessible. However, the article continues to lack any statements regarding open availability of the data or the software including a "Data Availability Statement". While correlating their "behavioral" parameters to other bioinformatic datasets creates context and suggests further studies, the lack of any validation of the correlative findings limits the significance of the results.

      Advance: While the authors share large final outputs of their parameter datasets, the unavailability of the raw data makes it difficult to compare their analysis and models to other readily available analysis pipelines or models. Some code and intermediate results are now available and a comparison to TrackMate has been conducted by the authors.

      Audience: The potential audience is the field of receptor tyrosine kinases and more generally cell surface receptors. The lack of validation of their correlative results limits the value of the findings to the field. There is also a potential audience for other authors of computational trajectory analysis software if the raw data were available. The effective audience is thus limited to biophysicists or quantitative biologists capable of replicating the VB-HMM model for validation of the correlative results in falsifiable experiments.

      Reviewer's Field of Expertise: I have a field of expertise in advanced microscopy, image analysis, single particle tracking, receptor tyrosine kinases, membrane biophysics, hidden Markov models, Bayesian analysis, and software engineering.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Wang Liao and colleagues aim to provide a comprehensive synthesis of zebrafish circadian research, with particular emphasis on the decentralized photoreceptive architecture that distinguishes teleosts from mammals, and to outline future research directions leveraging emerging technologies for translational applications. The authors frame zebrafish as occupying a "crucial evolutionary and experimental niche" and argue that the model system is uniquely suited to address open questions in chronobiology.

      Strengths:

      The review is broad in scope, the coverage of physiological outputs - spanning cardiovascular rhythmicity, hepatic metabolism, immune function, reproduction, and gut homeostasis - is more comprehensive than many existing reviews in this area, and researchers seeking an entry point into any of these subfields will find useful orientation. The figures are well-designed and effectively summarise complex regulatory relationships. The section on immune rhythmicity is a particular strength, providing mechanistic detail on how specific clock components (Clock1a, Per1b, Per2, Cry1a) differentially regulate neutrophil behaviour, bacterial killing, and cytokine expression; this level of molecular specificity distinguishes it from comparable sections in the review. The brief discussion of non-canonical clock gene functions (CLOCK in neuronal connectivity, BMAL1 in stem cell state, vascular calcification) raises genuinely interesting points that are underexplored in the field and might deserve more prominence.

      The future perspectives section makes a conceptually interesting move in suggesting that the zebrafish decentralized architecture could reframe a central question in chronobiology - from how a master clock imposes order on passive peripheral oscillators, to how semi-autonomous oscillators achieve coherence. This is the most original conceptual contribution in the manuscript, and it would benefit from much further development.

      Weaknesses:

      The core limitation of this review is that it functions primarily as an annotated bibliography rather than a critical synthesis. Section after section follows the same pattern: a physiological system is introduced, several findings from recent papers are described in sequence, and the section ends. Missing throughout is an evaluative voice - where does the field agree, where does it disagree, which findings have been replicated versus remain preliminary, and which conceptual questions are genuinely unresolved versus merely unstudied? Readers with expertise in the field will find little that reframes their understanding; readers new to the field will receive information but not the interpretive scaffolding needed to assess its significance.

      The framing of zebrafish as occupying a "crucial evolutionary and experimental niche" is asserted but not substantiated. The experimental advantages of zebrafish - optical transparency, external development, genetic tractability - are real, but they apply primarily to larval stages, typically the first two weeks of development. The review does not adequately address whether the key features it highlights, particularly peripheral photosensitivity and autonomous peripheral oscillators, have been demonstrated in adult animals, where optical transparency is lost. Many of the physiological findings described (sleep-wake cycles, cardiovascular function, reproduction, immune function) are most relevant in adult or juvenile fish, yet the mechanistic underpinning often comes from larval studies. Whether the mechanisms generalise across developmental stages is not discussed, and this is an important gap that the review could acknowledge explicitly.

      The claim that zebrafish bridge invertebrate and mammalian models is conventional framing that appears in most zebrafish review articles; its repetition here adds little. More interesting - and underexplored - is the comparative question of how the decentralised clock architecture of teleosts compares with that of other non-mammalian vertebrates, or indeed with invertebrate systems such as Drosophila where peripheral tissue clocks and non-visual photoreception have also been studied. The review does not engage with this comparative dimension, which would be the natural intellectual context for the claims being made.

      The future perspectives section identifies several promising directions - optogenetic circuit mapping, whole-body longitudinal imaging, inter-organ communication, network modeling - but these are described at a high level of generality. Most are not specific to the questions raised by the zebrafish decentralized clock architecture; they would appear in any forward-looking review of circadian biology. The one conceptually distinctive idea - that zebrafish could be used to ask how distributed oscillators achieve coordinated coherence without hierarchical control - is identified but not developed into concrete experimental questions or testable predictions. The discussion of non-canonical clock gene functions in the Future Perspectives section would benefit from being more directly connected to what zebrafish specifically can offer: given that teleost genome duplication has produced additional paralogues of clock genes, there is a concrete opportunity to dissect canonical from non-canonical functions through comparative analysis of paralogues with diverged expression patterns. This point is hinted at but not made explicitly.

      Appraisal of conclusions:

      The conclusions are broadly consistent with the evidence cited, and the authors are appropriately cautious in noting that many signalling cascades and inter-tissue communication mechanisms remain incompletely characterised. The conclusion that zebrafish represents a valuable and underexploited model for circadian-disease translational research is well-supported. However, the review would be significantly strengthened if the authors distinguished more clearly between what is firmly established, what is supported by preliminary or single-study evidence, and what remains genuinely speculative.

      Likely impact and utility:

      This review will be useful as an orientation document for researchers new to zebrafish circadian biology, and the comprehensive treatment of physiological outputs across organ systems is a genuine service to the field. Its impact as an intellectual contribution is limited by the descriptive approach and the absence of original synthesis or conceptual reframing. The most interesting ideas in the manuscript - the reframing of the central/peripheral clock hierarchy question, and the potential of clock gene paralogues for probing non-canonical functions - could be further developed and, if pursued, could form the basis of a more distinctive and impactful contribution.

      Comments on revised version.

      You have answered satisfactorily most of my comments. However, a second reading showed that are still a few comments that should be addressed.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Using cryofixation and serial block-face electron microscopy (SBEM), P. Vijayakumar and K. Cauwenberghs characterize extracellular vesicles (EVs) and non-vesicular extracellular particles (NVEPs) within native Drosophila olfactory sensilla. The study provides a unique and valuable dataset comprising approximately 7,800 extracellular particles, systematically describing their morphology, size, density, and distribution. The ultrastructural analysis across different sensillum classes offers insights into the potential biogenesis and functions of these extracellular particles.

      Strengths:

      Cryofixation preserves EVs and NVEPs within native tissue conditions. The detailed quantification of a very large dataset provides a unique source of information on extracellular particle number, categories, distribution. The expertise of the group in the method and the tissue explored as well as their detailed quantification provide confidence in the dataset and observations.

      Weaknesses:

      All weaknesses previously observed have been addressed.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary

      The authors developed a whole-tumor-cell vaccination strategy using senescent tumor cells (STCs) encapsulated within a chitosan hydrogel containing liposomal celecoxib, a COX2 inhibitor. This approach aims to take advantage of the immunogenic properties of senescent tumor cells while limiting the immunosuppressive effects of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2), a component of the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP).

      The authors show that inhibiting PGE2 production enhances natural killer (NK) cell activation, promotes dendritic cell (DC) recruitment and maturation, and stimulates antitumor T-cell responses. The therapeutic efficacy of this platform is demonstrated in several mouse tumor models, including subcutaneous melanoma, intracranial melanoma, and orthotopic pancreatic cancer.

      Strengths

      (1) Vaccine design

      A major strength of this study is its approach to exploiting the immunogenic properties of senescent tumor cells while addressing the immunosuppressive effects of the SASP. By combining STCs with localized COX2 inhibition, the authors reduce PGE2-mediated immune suppression while maintaining the secretion of immunostimulatory factors. The hydrogel-based delivery system also prolongs local cell retention, potentially allowing more sustained immune stimulation.

      (2) Mechanistic evidence supporting COX2/PGE2 inhibition

      The study provides convincing mechanistic evidence supporting the role of COX2/PGE2 inhibition in restoring NK cell-DC interactions. The authors demonstrate enhanced NK cell activation, increased secretion of CCL5 and XCL1, improved DC recruitment, and increased activation of cytotoxic T cells.

      Experiments using an alternative COX2 inhibitor, meloxicam, together with exogenous PGE2 rescue, further support the involvement of this pathway in regulating DC recruitment. These findings help distinguish the effects of COX2/PGE2 inhibition from those potentially specific to celecoxib.

      (3) Antigen-dependent vaccine efficacy

      The study also examines whether the therapeutic effects depend on senescence-specific antigens or tumor antigens shared between senescent and proliferating cancer cells. Experiments comparing antigen-matched and mismatched senescent tumor cell vaccines demonstrate greater therapeutic efficacy when the vaccine and tumor share the same cellular origin.

      These findings support an antigen-dependent component of the therapeutic response and suggest that the vaccine can elicit immunity against antigens shared between senescent and proliferating tumor cells. This is relevant because the intended therapeutic targets are primarily non-senescent tumor cells.

      (4) Efficacy across multiple tumor models

      The therapeutic potential of the vaccine is evaluated across several tumor models. The authors demonstrate significant tumor growth inhibition in subcutaneous melanoma, prolonged survival in an intracranial melanoma model, and reduced tumor burden in an orthotopic pancreatic cancer model. The activity observed across these different settings suggests that the approach may have applications beyond a single tumor type.

      (5) Hydrogel degradation and local safety

      The study includes an evaluation of hydrogel degradation and local tissue responses. The hydrogel progressively degrades and is no longer detectable by approximately 28 days, with no apparent tissue damage or abnormal inflammatory infiltration at the injection site during this period. These observations provide useful information regarding the local biocompatibility of the formulation.

      Weaknesses and Opportunities for Future Investigation

      (1) Role of cDC1 in therapeutic efficacy

      Although the study demonstrates increased DC recruitment and activation, the requirement for conventional type 1 dendritic cells (cDC1s) in mediating the observed antitumor effects has not been directly established. Experiments using cDC1-deficient mice or selective depletion approaches would help determine whether this population is essential for vaccine-induced T-cell responses and tumor control. The current findings support the involvement of cDC1s but do not establish their necessity.

      (2) Long-term safety and SASP heterogeneity

      The hydrogel degradation and histological studies provide evidence of local biocompatibility over the period examined. However, the longer-term consequences of administering metabolically active senescent tumor cells remain uncertain. Hydrogel degradation does not necessarily establish complete clearance of the encapsulated cells, and the SASP contains factors with potentially opposing effects on inflammation and tumor progression.

      Although celecoxib reduces PGE2 without significantly altering the measured levels of IL-6 and TNF-α, a more comprehensive assessment of SASP composition and longer-term systemic responses would be useful, particularly given the heterogeneity of senescence across tumor types and induction conditions.

      (3) Antigen specificity

      The comparison between matched and mismatched vaccines provides evidence that tumor-associated antigens contribute to therapeutic efficacy. However, the specific antigens recognized by vaccine-induced T cells remain undefined. Direct measurements of antigen-specific T-cell responses would help distinguish the contributions of adaptive antigen recognition and innate immune activation to the observed therapeutic effects.

      Overall Evaluation

      This study presents an approach to improving whole-tumor-cell vaccines by combining senescent tumor cells with COX2 inhibition and hydrogel-based delivery. The mechanistic experiments and therapeutic studies provide convincing evidence that this formulation enhances antitumor immune responses, with activity demonstrated across several mouse tumor models. Although the specific requirement for cDC1s, the identity of the relevant tumor antigens, and the longer-term safety of live senescent cells remain to be established, the findings provide a useful foundation for further development of senescent tumor cell-based cancer vaccines.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Foik et al. report that hypochlorous acid, a reactive chlorine species generated during host defense, activates the transcription of the froABCD in P. aeruginosa. This gene cluster had previously been associated with a potential role during flow of fluids and appears to be regulated by the sigma factor FroR and its anti-sigma factor FroI. In the present study, the authors show that froABCD is expressed both in neutrophils and macrophages, which they claim is likely a result of HOCl but not H2O2 production. Fro expression is also induced in a murine model of corneal infection, which is characterized by immune cells invasion. Expression of the fro system can be quenched by several antioxidants, such as methionine, cysteine, and others. FroR-deficient cells that lack froABCD expression during HOCl stress, appear more sensitive to the oxidant.

      Strengths:

      The authors provide a number of data supporting their claim that transcription of the froABCD system is induced by reactive chlorine species. This was shown by RNAseq, qRT-PCR, and through microscopy using a transcriptional reporter fusion. Likewise, elevated expression of froABCD was shown in vitro and in vivo, excluding potential in vitro artifacts. The manuscript, while mostly descriptive, is easy to follow and the data were presented clearly and convincingly. The authors have also been responsive to concerns from the previous review.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed most of my previous concerns and I appreciate their willingness to improve the manuscript. I am still not quite convinced by their explanation of why fro expression is higher in macrophage vs. neutrophil phagosome if indeed this defense is HOCl-specific, but I am happy to leave it as it is.

      Regarding the complementation: while Sanfilippo et al. have indeed provided a complementation of the fro deletion, they have done so under very different experimental conditions, e.g. without any HOCl.

      While I would have liked to see additional mechanistic insights into FroIR regulation, I accept that the authors prefer to keep the manuscript more descriptive.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      In this manuscript, Bootsma and coworkers provide a thorough characterization of the transcriptomic features of the immune system and tumor immune microenvironment in humanized immune system (HIS) mouse models of colorectal cancer. The work is mainly descriptive, but the methodology is sound, and the data provided may help future work with this model system.

      The main strength of this work is in its simple yet technically sound design. While the concordance between human and HIS mouse immunology appears to be qualitative rather than at a fine-grained compositional level, the clear and thorough characterization of the immune cell populations in this mouse makes this work useful for future studies on this model. A major limitation is the lack of characterization beyond a purely descriptive layer. There are also a few minor concerns that need to be addressed.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      This paper presents an fNIRS neuroimaging study with a relatively large sample of preschool children (aged 3-5) that measures both positive and negative empathy within a single task. Children watch emotional events and are asked questions about both their own emotions and the emotions of others, allowing the authors to distinguish between affective and cognitive empathy. The authors propose "foundational" models of affective and cognitive empathy and argue that their findings support the idea that cognitive empathy emerges before affective empathy in early childhood.

      Strengths:

      The paper addresses a valuable question by measuring both positive and negative empathy within a single cognitive task. The use of fNIRS with a relatively large preschool sample is commendable, and the pre-registered design strengthens the contribution. The task itself is innovative, well-suited to this age group, and achieves high compliance, which is essential and notably difficult with young children. Overall, the methods are appropriate, and the empirical work is valuable.

      Comments on revised version.

      I thank the authors for their thoughtful and thorough response, and the editor for the opportunity to review the revised manuscript. The current version is substantially improved, with more accurate coverage of the relevant literature and more careful interpretation of findings. The authors have addressed the large majority of the concerns raised in the initial review. Two minor points remain.

      The "foundational" models are still presented as though they are established frameworks, when in fact this paper is their first empirical test. The labelling should reflect that. Additionally, the claim that both empathy components are present together "early in life" needs to specify that this evidence comes from studies of infants in the first year, which is what makes it relevant to the sequencing debate the authors are engaging with.

      (1) I appreciate the authors' clarification that the "foundational" models originate from their prior theoretical paper and that the current study represents the first empirical test. This is helpful context, but it also reinforces the concern. If this is the first empirical test, presenting these as named, italicised models throughout the manuscript still give the impression of established frameworks. I would suggest the authors signal more clearly in the text that these are their own proposed, as-yet-untested organising frameworks rather than concepts with an independent evidence base. I believe doing so would only strengthen the transparency of the contribution and, ultimately, the establishment of the model itself.

      (2) The authors now state in the introduction that "this linear, stage-based account has been challenged by evidence that affective and cognitive dimensions of empathy seem to be present together early in life." However, as written, the claim that both components are present together early on does not in itself challenge a linear stage-based account without specifying the ages at which this evidence was obtained. The claim would be more accurate if the authors noted that both components appear to be present as early as the first year of life (e.g., Roth-Hanania, 2025), which would make it clearer why this evidence is relevant to the sequencing debate.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The paper presents a novel method for RSA, called trial-level RSA (tRSA). The method first constructs a trial x trial representation dissimilarity matrix using correlation distances, assuming that (as in the empirical example) each trial has a unique stimulus. Whereas "classical RSA" correlates the entire upper triangular matrix of the RDM / RSM to a model RDM / RSM, tRSA first calculates the correlation to the model RDM per row and then averages these values.

      Strengths & Weaknesses:

      The reviewer comments to the two previous versions and the authors responses clearly highlight the strength and weaknesses of the approach.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this study, the authors examine how a developmentally regulated cis-regulatory element controls SOX2 expression during neural differentiation of human stem cells. The results suggest that this highly conserved long-range enhancer mediates neural-specific SOX2 regulation and offer insight into the role of promoter-enhancer contacts in this process. Although the findings are interesting, several limitations need to be addressed.

      Strengths:

      A central question in developmental biology is how genes are regulated in a context-dependent manner. SOX2, a major pluripotency factor, is expressed in diverse tissues during development, and therefore understanding the mechanisms that control its spatiotemporal expression is critical. This study addresses this important question by examining the functional relevance of a neural-specific, developmentally regulated SOX2 enhancer and its associated promoter-enhancer contacts in driving gene expression during human neural development. Using multiple model systems and techniques, the authors test the requirement of this enhancer by analyzing SOX2 expression in mutant lines, providing evidence for its role in this process.

      Weaknesses:

      A key limitation of the study is the absence of data from homozygous SOX2 enhancer deletion, which leaves the analysis incomplete and tempers the conclusions that can be drawn. Furthermore, the suitability of teratomas as a model system is questionable, given their limited capacity to recapitulate the spatial patterning, regional specification, and organized developmental processes characteristic of the human forebrain. Finally, the manuscript remains largely descriptive with little mechanistic insight.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: This version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Combining a five-year field experiment with a global meta-analysis, Wu et al. investigate how grazing intensity influences ecosystem carbon dioxide (CO₂) fluxes in grasslands and how these effects are regulated by environmental conditions such as grazing duration, wetness index, and soil temperature and moisture responses.

      The authors show that the response of net ecosystem productivity (NEP) to light grazing shifts from negative to positive along a wetness gradient, whereas heavy grazing consistently suppresses NEP across wetness conditions. Importantly, this pattern is supported by both the field experiment and the meta-analysis, suggesting that may help maintain moderate levels of grazing can potentially enhance both plant productivity and carbon sequestration under favorable moisture conditions.

      The integration of experimental data with a global synthesis is a particular strength of the study, allowing the authors to evaluate grazing impacts across both temporal variability (precipitation fluctuations in the field experiment) and spatial variability (wetness gradients across global grasslands). Overall, the conclusions are well supported by the data.

      Overall, the principal conclusions are generally supported by the reported results, and the study provides useful evidence that the effects of grazing on grassland carbon cycling depend on both grazing intensity and environmental context. The comparison between field and synthesis results is potentially valuable for understanding why grazing effects vary among grassland systems. However, some aspects of the meta-analysis remain insufficiently documented. In particular, the study-selection numbers presented in the new PRISMA diagram require clarification, and the manuscript does not clearly explain how individual response ratios were weighted when estimating the pooled effect sizes. Resolving these reporting and methodological issues would improve the reproducibility and interpretation of the synthesis.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript by Kelman and coauthors investigates how viral communities differ in the genes they encode in healthy and degraded coral reef ecosystems. Across 19 viral metagenomes from Central Pacific reefs, the authors assess the frequency of integration/excision genes as a proxy for viral community temperateness and ask whether genes associated with central carbon metabolism covary with signatures of temperateness. The main finding is that viral communities with more temperate-related genes encode more genes from the Entner-Doudoroff pathway and other reactions interpreted as anaplerotic, whereas more lytic-associated viral communities show greater representation of some pentose phosphate pathway, TCA, and redox-associated genes interpreted as cataplerotic. The authors propose a model based on these patterns in which viruses may reinforce feedback loops that influence reef microbialization state.

      In the revised manuscript, the authors have refined the separation between the observations and hypothesized effects on infection, host metabolism, and reef state, which align the claims much closer to what the data support. No new analyses were added to buttress whether the metabolic genes are linked to temperate viral genomes, to address compositional effects, or to validate the key annotations, so the evidence for the central mechanistic claims is largely unchanged.

      Overall, the study addresses an interesting and potentially important concept - that viral auxiliary metabolic genes are important components of microbial communities and can affect ecosystem functioning. Linking viral metabolism to coral reef microbialization is a creative conceptual advance. The manuscript is clearly written, and the contrasting metabolic gene profiles of these viromes is an interesting pattern that could motivate future work on how viral metabolic potential varies across reef states.

      Strengths:

      (1) The study connects viral lifestyle, central carbon metabolism, bacterial overgrowth, and reef degradation in a framework that could be useful for future studies of coral reef ecosystems and viral ecology. This is an interesting synthesis that links viral auxiliary metabolism to broader questions about microbialization and reef state.

      (2) The manuscript is generally clearly organized around a testable prediction: viral metabolic gene content should vary along a lytic-to-temperate viral community gradient. The reported enrichment of anaplerotic genes in viromes with a larger fraction of temperate viruses is an intriguing result.

      (3) The authors highlight several metabolic genes that may not have been previously reported in viral datasets or genomes. With further validation, these observations could expand the known repertoire of viral metabolic potential.

      (4) The modelling helps clarify the feedbacks the authors propose may connect viral lifestyle, bacterial metabolism, and coral reef degradation. It provides a foundation for generating hypotheses about how viral metabolic genes could influence reef microbial dynamics.

      (5) The revised manuscript is clearer about scope. The methods section now describes the read-based framework and its limitations, and the model is presented as a tool for generating hypotheses rather than as evidence.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The main limitation remains that the evidence for several key claims remains indirect. The core analysis is based on correlations between metabolic gene frequencies and integration/excision-related genes. This does not demonstrate that the metabolic genes occur in temperate viral genomes, are physically linked to lysogeny genes, are expressed during infection, or alter host metabolism. The authors did not to attempt contig-level linkage. Thus, the data support an association between VLP-associated metabolic annotations and a community-level temperateness proxy, but not a direct link between temperate phages and these metabolic functions. The manuscript does not discuss alternative explanations for these correlations. More broadly, community-level gene frequencies should not be equated with genome-level or infection-level metabolic programs. A virome may contain more anaplerotic genes overall, but this does not demonstrate that individual viruses reprogram their hosts in an anaplerotic manner or that infection produces a net anaplerotic effect. Individual viruses may encode both anaplerotic and cataplerotic genes, and a smaller number of cataplerotic genes could have stronger metabolic consequences depending on expression, enzyme efficiency, pathway position, and host context.

      (2) The revised framing is more careful, but some language still goes beyond the data. The ecological interpretation assumes that viral infection is strong enough to influence reef-scale bacterial population dynamics. However, the study does not directly measure infection frequency, lysis rates, viral production, burst size, lysogeny frequency, prophage induction, gene expression, or bacterial mortality. If viral mortality or lysogenic conversion were rare in these systems, the observed gene-frequency patterns could have limited ecosystem-level consequence. The discussion includes statements such as healthy reefs being "guarded by lytic viruses" and nutrient interventions could promote "re-viralization" for reef restoration. These are reasonable hypotheses, but they depend on infection rates, gene expression, and metabolic effects that were not measured nor discussed.

      (3) Because gene frequencies are expressed as proportions of annotated genes, the large decline in genes assigned to phages (from about half of annotated genes in lytic viromes to about 5% in temperate viromes) can force most other gene categories upward with temperateness. The authors now acknowledge this compositional effect but do not test whether the main associations hold once it is accounted for. The many correlations examined are also not corrected for multiple comparisons. As a result, individual gene-level associations, particularly the temperate-associated ones, should be treated as tentative.

      (4) The anaplerotic/cataplerotic classification still relies on sequence similarity annotations, so may be vulnerable to misannotation, or functional misinterpretation (notable examples of definitively annotated, but functionally ambiguous genes such as phoH and cobS have been well documented in viruses). The authors did not to include any further domain-based or phylogenetic checks for the genes important the main conclusions.

      Overall, the manuscript presents a valuable hypothesis and highlights new ecological patterns in coral reef viral metagenomes. The revision substantially improves the discussion of the claims, but the evidence linking temperate viruses to specific metabolic functions and reef-scale outcomes remains incomplete. The work would be strengthened by analyses that directly link metabolic genes to viral genomes or lysogeny markers, address compositional effects, validate key annotations, and more clearly distinguish observed gene-frequency associations from hypothesized effects on infection, host metabolism, and reef state.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      When contemplating the role of any sensory area in the brain, an essential question is: How much of the neural code there is inherited from the inputs versus constructed de novo by the local circuitry? This study tackles that important question for the case of the mouse superior colliculus (SC), a visual brain area that receives direct input from the retina. The specific aspects of the neural code are the representation of line orientation and direction of motion in the visual image. Over the past 10 years or so, there have been reports that the preferred directions and orientations of neurons vary systematically across the SC in a global map that is not present in the retina and therefore computed locally.

      Here the authors revisit this question by expanding the range of measurements: They record from the axonal boutons of retinal ganglion cells in the input layer of the SC, from the post-synaptic neurons there, and from neurons in deeper layers of the SC. They conclude that at any given location in the SC, the signals in retinal boutons recapitulate the tuning of retinal ganglion cells, and that SC neurons follow that organization, though it is lost in the deeper layers. Notably they find no evidence for a global map of these response properties other than what is contributed by retinal input.

      Strengths:

      The study combines multiple recording methods - calcium imaging and electrical recording - to capture the activity of retinal inputs to the colliculus, the tuning of neurons in the superficial layers close to the input, as well as neurons in deeper layers. Furthermore, the work connects to the recent literature on gradients of tuning properties among retinal ganglion cells. All these set the stage for testing the correspondence between retinal inputs and collicular outputs.

      Weaknesses:

      The methods used to identify direction-selective and orientation-selective neurons based on visual responses are overly permissive, and don't match common usage in this research area. Furthermore, the measurements covered only a small fraction of the visual field, which limits their ability to distinguish between different hypotheses for the global map of visual response properties. Relatedly, the claim that retinal input patterns explain much of the layout in superior colliculus should be made more quantitative.

      Comments on the latest version:

      The manuscript has improved in clarity. However, my main concern remains, and it affects how this work can be positioned relative to the literature.

      As pointed out in my first review, the criteria for "direction-selective" and "orientation-selective" are different from almost the entire literature in this field. In Fig 1D-I, all 12 boutons and neurons are declared both DS and OS. 11 out of these 12 respond to only one of the 2 gratings with the same orientation. Most everyone in the field would say that these units are DS but not OS. Calling them OS is like saying a cell is "royalty-selective" even though it only responds to "king" but not to "queen".

      Ideally, one would like to measure orientation selectivity with a stimulus that contains no motion. Fig S1 shows examples of this. Based on responses to drifting gratings and moving bars (panels A-B), all 4 of these units are purely DS, not OS (by the conventional standard). When tested with static gratings (panel F), 2 of them don't even respond. And a 3rd has no visible tuning to orientation. Yet all of these were counted as strongly OS in the study (panel F).

      Because of this unusual conflation of DS and OS, the objects and relationships analyzed in the present study are simply different ones from those in the rest of the literature, like apples and oranges. This makes it hard to interpret any supposed discrepancies between the present findings and the previous work.

      Take for example de Malmazet 2024, perhaps the most closely related study of retinal boutons in the SC. By their standards "While 18% of responding boutons were classified as exclusively DS, 10% were exclusively OS and a small fraction (1.5%) were both". Distinguishing DS from OS boutons is useful because "OS and DS boutons appear to be largely independent populations, consistent with known response properties of identified ganglion cell populations in the retina". Also "OS and DS boutons are distributed differently within the retinorecipient layers." Clearly these subsets of boutons, and therefore their tuning properties, are different from the ones reported in the present manuscript. The reader should be aware of these caveats.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The manuscript by Mengxing et al., reports an assessment of three thalamic nuclei (auditory, visual, somatosensory) in a 3 x 2 factorial design to test for specificity of responses in thalamic nuclei (as defined by an anatomical atlas, Iglesisas et al. 2018), to linguistic processing particularly in the left hemisphere. The conditions are reading, speech production, and speech comprehension and their respective control conditions. The control condition consists of resynthesised material of the three conditions and therefore differs in task as well as stimulus content. The authors report the following results:

      (1) BOLD-response analyses: left MGB linguistic vs non-linguistic significant; left LGN linguistic vs non-linguistic significant. There is a hemisphere x stimulus Interaction for the MGB.

      (2) MVPA: left MGB linguistic vs. non-linguistic significant; bilateral VLN linguistic vs. non-linguistic significant; significant lateralisation in MGB (left MGB responses better classified linguistic vs. non-linguistic in contrast to right).

      (3) Functional connectivity: there is, in general, connectivity between the thalamic ROIs and the respective primary cortices independent of linguistics.

      Strengths:

      The study has a clear and comprehensive design and addresses a timely topic. Thalamic nuclei and their interaction with the cerebral cortex regions are likely key to understanding how perception works in a world where one has to compute highly dynamic stimuli often in an instant. Speech and written text are prime examples of ecologically important, extremely dynamic, and complex stimuli. The field of the contribution of cerebral cortex-thalamic loops in speech and language processing is wide open, and the study presents a solid approach to address their role in different language modalities (i.e., reading, comprehension, production). Particularly the left MGB specialisation for linguistic content seems to me a solid finding of the study. This is revealed both in the BOLD-response analysis as well as the MVPA analyses and is unlikely to be driven by a potential confound of differences in the stimulus material as this is accounted for by the interaction (linguistic vs. non-linguistic in left MGB vs. right MGB).

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The spatial resolution of the fMRI acquisition of 2.4 mm3 pre-empts the claim of modulation of first-order thalamic nuclei for the auditory modality. The MGB is composed of multiple subnuclei that are not all first-order. Resolving the subnuclei would require different procedures and likely higher spatial resolution to avoid partial volume effects (Moerel et al., 2015; Mihai et al., 2019).

      (2) The task conditions differed in both stimulus content as well as tasks. The linguistic tasks included single-word reading (visual), speech single-word comprehension (auditory), and single-word speech production (motor); while non-linguistic tasks involved viewing scrambled images (visual), listening to noise sequences (auditory), and producing unintelligible sounds (motor). It therefore remains unclear whether the difference in linguistic conditions are due to task-effects or due to stimulus differences.

      Appraisal:

      The open question the authors want to address is whether first-order thalamic nuclei "show functional modulations dependent upon whether the stimuli being processed are linguistic or non-linguistic". To address the question the authors want to examine the "engagement of first-order relay thalamic nuclei specifically in [...] three language systems: LGN in reading, MGN in SC [speech comprehension], and VLN in SP [speech production]." In my opinion the study does not yet fully achieve this aim. First, it is unclear whether it is really the linguistic components that modulate the thalamic nuclei, or other differences between the active tasks and the passive listening/viewing or production of unintelligible sounds or differences in stimulus composition that could be equally revealed by non-linguistic meaningful stimuli against resynthesised versions of these. As said above, this criticism does not apply to the interaction found in the auditory modality that reveals stronger modulation for the linguistic condition in contrast to the non-linguistic condition in the left MGB in contrast to the right MGB. Second, to delineate the first-order thalamic nuclei would in my view need other procedures and higher spatial resolution.

      References

      Iglesias, J. E., Insausti, R., Lerma-Usabiaga, G., Bocchetta, M., Van Leemput, K., Greve, D. N., van der Kouwe, A.,Fischl, B., Caballero-Gaudes, C., & Paz-Alonso, P. M. (2018). A probabilistic atlas of the human thalamic nuclei combining ex vivo MRI and histology. NeuroImage, 183(July), 314-326.641 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2018.08.012

      Mihai, P. G., Moerel, M., de Martino, F., Trampel, R., Kiebel, S., & von Kriegstein, K. (2019). Modulation of tonotopic ventral medial geniculate body is behaviorally relevant for speech recognition. eLife, 8, e44837. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.44837

      Moerel, M., De Martino, F., Uğurbil, K., Yacoub, E., & Formisano, E. (2015). Processing of frequency and location in human subcortical auditory structures. Scientific reports, 5, 17048. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep17048

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Beginning with the rationale that the unfolded protein response (UPR) and oxidative stress response (OSR) both impact T cell differentiation and effector functions, the authors investigated whether a metabolically activated drug (AA147) shown to enhance the UPR and (via electrophilic disinhibition of Nrf2) OSR can alter CD4 fate and function. Using pharmacologic and focused genetic manipulations in cultured mouse CD4 cells, they found that AA147 attenuated Th17 cell differentiation via Nrf2 activation. In other CD4 subsets, they found that AA147 had no effect on differentiation but nonetheless decreased effector cytokine expression via an independent effect on IRF4. Based on these results, the authors propose that AA147 and similar drugs might be candidate therapies for autoimmune diseases, many of which are associated with pathologic Th17 cells.

      Strengths:

      The experimental design and associated data are generally appropriate and sufficient to support the authors' conclusions. Although several conclusions rest on pharmacologic rather than genetic interventions, they utilized genetic manipulation in key studies to support their conclusions. Namely, they utilized Nrf2 KO cells to demonstrate the necessity of Nrf2 for AA147 effects on Th17 differentiation.

      Weaknesses:

      A general weakness is the lack of in vivo data to support their findings. From the literature, it appears that AA147 can be given to intact mice with beneficial effects in autoimmune models such as experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE). This would provide the opportunity to confirm the decreased Th17 differentiation and the proposed mechanism in a relevant animal model.

      Because of the reliance on pharmacologic interventions, some of the conclusions are also based on somewhat indirect evidence that assumes both the specificity and completeness of on-target effects.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript reported a miniscope that implemented a Hi-Lo structured imaging technique for recording neural activity. The authors presented solid data supporting the advantages of having Hi-Lo, which suppressed the image background and generated better-quality raw images for neural decoding. The better raw images, in turn, improved real-time decoding results to a level close to offline decoding. The manuscript demonstrated a closed-loop brain-machine interface using real-time decoding of the Hi-Lo images from the miniscope.

      Strengths:

      The work is solid and presents a valuable technique improvement in a head-mounted brain miniscope.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Offline processes are progressing fast and could quickly become capable of running real-time with hardware advancement and algorithm optimalization. The physical technique improvement, i.e. Hi-Lo, that allows simpler but real-time decoding methods, is in competition with advanced decoding methods, which may be capable of real-time process quickly.

      (2) The miniscope also implemented depth tuning and demonstrated multi-plane imaging. The depth tuning speed, however, is too slow for 3D imaging of neural activities. In practice, acquisition must select one or two depths and extract ROI from them. There is potential to use the depth tuning to target a certain group of neurons. But the work did not sufficiently discuss how the depth-tuning and multi-plane imaging capability was used in in vivo studies, or what criteria were used to set the image depth of the ROI.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Acute brain injury can disrupt neural circuits, thereby altering brain function. While such injuries can induce various forms of plasticity, the mechanisms by which they contribute to improved functional outcomes post-injury remain inadequately understood. This study investigates this plasticity by assessing the effects of an optic lobe lesion on specific fly behaviors. The findings indicate a significant impairment in the ability to fixate on visual stripes immediately following the injury, whereas locomotor behavior remains largely unaffected. Notably, longitudinal studies of the injured flies demonstrate substantial recovery in stripe fixation ability and unique behavioral traits one week post-injury, suggesting the involvement of plasticity mechanisms. Inhibition of adult neural progenitor cell proliferation prior to injury prevents significant improvements in visual orientation during the identified plasticity window, indicating that progenitor activation may facilitate the recovery of stripe-oriented behavior. Thus, individual tracking of orientation behavior in *Drosophila* provides an effective quantitative framework for examining functional recovery and inter-individual variability in the adult brain following injury.

      Strengths:

      This study demonstrates that flies with localized damage to the optic lobes exhibit significant recovery in stripe-fixation behavior, a function specifically impaired by lesions in these lobes. By employing quantitative tracking of individuals in the Buridan arena, the study elucidates individual recovery trajectories during a critical window of plasticity. These trajectories are partially influenced by injury-induced plasticity, particularly through the activation of progenitor cells. The findings underscore the potential of optic lobe lesions in Drosophila as a promising model for further exploring the relationship between altered cellular interactions and the recovery of brain function following acute injury.

      Weaknesses:

      The article possesses potential strengths; however, these are not explicitly demonstrated. Specifically, the analyses conducted are inadequate to fully support the manuscript's primary claims with the data provided. A comprehensive characterization of the lesions at one and three weeks post-injury is essential, employing markers for neuronal progenitors and glia, the neuropil, and cell proliferation or death. Moreover, the connection between the dorsal cluster neurons (DCN) and the potential enhancement in visual behavior post-injury remains ambiguous. Consequently, a morphological analysis of this cluster in both control and lesioned flies is necessary to substantiate the study's conclusions. Furthermore, inactivating this cluster, for example, through the use of UAS-Kir2.1, would ascertain its significance in the plasticity process described herein.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study aims to study stereoscopic vision under conditions of binocular rivalry by using "functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to examine how interocular suppression reshapes disparity processing".

      Strengths:

      The strategic goal of being able to study stereoscopic vision when one or the other eye is dominant in rivalry is of potential interest.

      Weaknesses:

      There is evidence from earlier publications that pure eye rivalry (complete dominance of perception by one eye) is difficult to achieve in a controlled way. The authors present two types of random dot stereograms to subjects in the MR scanner under two different conditions. The stereograms are annular regions that surround a central disk, which contains grating patterns that, for condition 1, have the same orientation presented to the left and right eyes (concordant) but, for condition 2, have different orientations, 90 degrees apart, so that rivalry is perceived. In the centre of the visual field, a binocular fixation target is presented, which subjects must monitor for brief changes in orientation.

      The idea is that when the grating pair is rivalrous, there may be some measurable disruption of stereo responses, on the reasonable assumption that non-rivalrous binocular input would favour accurate stereo vision. Thus, it is argued that eye rivalry would be disruptive for stereo vision. There are two phenomena that intrude upon the goal of achieving pure eye rivalry. The first is methodological: using the paradigm of obliging the subject to view a rivalrous stimulus, whilst testing the response to stereo stimuli, typically results in a mixture of eye rivalry (which is relevant for this study) and pattern rivalry (which is an unwanted intrusion). Simply viewing a pair of patterns with different inputs to the left and right eyes does not guarantee that the rivalrous state is driven by eye rivalry (Kovács et al., 1996; Logothetis et al., 1996; Blake, 2001). It may be driven by pattern rivalry, which is a separate phenomenon that is not expected to have any simple predictable effect on a spatially adjacent stereo stimulus.

      The second issue with the study design is that there are earlier experimental investigations that show that rivalrous binocular stimuli do not simply switch between one fully formed percept and its alternative. There are intermediate states in which different portions of the visual field are dominated by one percept whilst other parts of the visual field are dominated by its alternative (Blake, 2001). In some studies, the case has been made that there are travelling waves of alternation that pass over the visual field (Wilson et al., 2001). Thus, the rivalrous stimulus is often reported as fragmented in space and time. On the basis of these previously published studies, it is entirely possible for there to be rivalry in the region occupied by the pair of gratings and adequate binocular fusion in the regions with the random-dot stereograms. As the main result is that the presence of rivalrous stimuli in one part of the visual field has at best a weak effect on processing of binocularly correlated random dot patterns in a different part of the visual field, it seems important to take this issue into account in the interpretation of results from this study.

      Another area of concern is that there are previous reports that the pattern of microsaccades differs between rivalrous and non-rivalrous states (Sabrin and Kertesz, 1980). There are no measures of eye movements in this study, but microsaccades are very effective in stimulating V1 and later dorsal stream areas. Extra activations of cortex during the rivalrous state could decrease the ability of a near/far decoder to report stereo depth in the stimulus, because the extra activations create extra MR-signals that are not relevant for near-far decoding.

      These extra MR-signals, for example, might be driven by conjugate movements of the binocular stimulus across both eyes' retinas or by disconjugate movements that cause irrelevant changes in near/far neuronal activations. In the latter case, as these changes are not time-locked to the disparity changes in the random dot figures, they represent an intrusive signal to a near/far decoder. Further intrusive signals interfering with near/far decoding may arise when binocular tuned-inhibitory neurons become activated by small misconvergences of binocular eye position.

      This discussion also highlights a point that the near/far decoder is sensitive only to particular organizations of stereo-sensitive units within the cortex. The decoder is most effective when different MR voxels are sensitive to near as opposed to far disparities. This means that the decoder essentially favours an odd symmetric sensitivity to disparity with respect to the zero-disparity fixation plane. Even-symmetric sensitivity (classically tuned-excitatory or tuned inhibitory sensitivity---(Fischer et al., 1979; Prince et al., 2002) is not probed with this decoder.

      All these issues mean that many of the main claims of the paper within the current draft (importance of dorsal areas, differences based on interocular suppression, selectively weakened V3A-centered coordination) are called into question.

      Literature Cited

      Blake R (2001) A Primer on Binocular Rivalry, Including Current Controversies. Brain and Mind 2:5-38.

      Fischer B, Poggio GF, Lennie P (1979) Depth Sensitivity of Binocular Cortical Neurons of Behaving Monkeys [and Discussion]. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B, Biological Sciences 204:409-414.

      Kovács I, Papathomas TV, Yang M, Féher Á (1996) When the brain changes its mind: interocular grouping during binocular rivalry. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 93:15508-15511.

      Logothetis NK, Leopold DA, Sheinberg DL (1996) What is rivalling during binocular rivalry? Nature 380:621-624.

      Prince SJD, Cumming BG, Parker AJ (2002) Range and mechanism of encoding of horizontal disparity in macaque V1. Journal of Neurophysiology 87:209-221.

      Sabrin HW, Kertesz AE (1980) Microsaccadic eye movements and binocular rivalry. Perception & Psychophysics 28:150-154.

      Wilson HR, Blake R, Lee S-H (2001) Dynamics of travelling waves in visual perception. Nature 412:907-910.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Du and colleagues carefully report a fossil specimen of a swimming flap belonging to the radiodont Amplectobelua symbrachiata from a new locality of the early Cambrian Chengjiang Biota. The margin of this isolated flap preserves a W-shaped notch with a thickened dark band along the notch edge. The authors interpret this structure as a healed predation scar formed during the life of the radiodont and further discuss potential attackers and the complexity of the Cambrian high-trophic-level food web. The preservation of the soft-bodied fossil specimen is exquisite, and the manuscript is high quality and novel.

      Strengths:

      The topic is novel and interesting, and the exquisite specimen itself has high potential paleoecological value. It is particularly commendable that the authors attempt to discuss the origin of this anomalous structure by integrating morphology, Micro-XRF, analogy with wound healing in extant arthropods, and functional morphological estimation. The research approach is relatively comprehensive. This study has considerable scientific significance for exploring predator-prey relationships at high trophic levels in the Cambrian marine ecosystem. In addition, an important highlight of the manuscript is that it clarifies that the distal dorsal spines and terminal spines of the frontal appendages of radiodonts are paired, rather than uniserial as previously thought, correcting some previous misunderstandings.

      Weaknesses:

      The paper does have some shortcomings. My main concerns are as follows:

      (1) In the inferential chain from the "W-shaped anomaly" to "antemortem injury", then to "healing", then to "predation", and finally to "high-trophic-level feeding loops", the strength of evidence at several links is not entirely consistent. Some sentences present interpretive conclusions as directly proven facts.

      (2) One of the most critical pieces of evidence is the W-shaped notch and the dark band along its edge. The authors compare the dark edge to scarification structures in trilobites and to melanisation during wound healing in extant arthropods, and on this basis further interpret it as a healed predatory injury. However, the current evidence first supports that the structure may represent an antemortem trauma and subsequent repair, but is not sufficient to uniquely prove that it was caused by predation. Even if the W-shaped notch is indeed an antemortem injury, it could still be related to other mechanical injuries, non-predatory attacks between individuals (e.g., resulting from intra- or interspecies competition), molting-related tears, or other traumatic processes. It is generally difficult to correlate one type of wound with one potential predator. The W-shaped wound could also have resulted from multiple injuries during a single attack. I suggest that the authors treat "whether repair occurred" and "whether caused by predation" as two independent questions and argue them separately, and avoid treating the W-shaped outline itself as a diagnostic feature of predation.

      (3) The authors provide a discussion of alternative explanations such as decay, burial, molting, parasite-induced pathological changes, developmental malformations, and competitive behavior, which is a strength of this paper. However, some of the current arguments mainly rely on "lack of evidence supporting these alternative explanations" to support the predation interpretation, which is still insufficient.

    1. Joint Public Review:

      This work investigates the evolutionary conservation and functional significance of FoxO transcription factors in the response of airway epithelia to diverse stressors, ranging from hypoxia to temperature fluctuations and oxidative stress. Utilizing a comprehensive approach encompassing Drosophila, murine models, and human samples, the study investigates FoxO's role across species. The authors demonstrate that hypoxia triggers a dFOXO-dependent immune response in Drosophila airways, with subsequent nuclear localization of dFOXO in response to various stressors. Transcriptomic analysis reveals differential regulation of crucial gene categories in respiratory tissues, highlighting FoxO's involvement in metabolic pathways, DNA replication, and stress resistance mechanisms.

      The study underscores FoxO's importance in maintaining homeostasis by revealing reduced stress resistance in dFOXO Drosophila mutants, shedding light on its protective role against stressors. In mammalian airway cells, FoxO exhibits nuclear translocation in response to hypoxia, accompanied by upregulation of cytokines with antimicrobial activities. Intriguingly, mouse models of asthma show FoxO downregulation, which is also observed in sputum samples from human asthma patients, implicating FoxO dysregulation in respiratory pathologies.

      Overall, the manuscript suggests that FoxO signaling plays a critical role in preserving airway epithelial cell homeostasis under stress conditions, with implications for understanding and potentially treating respiratory diseases like asthma. By providing compelling evidence of FoxO's involvement across species and its correlation with disease states, the study underscores the importance of further exploration into FoxO-mediated mechanisms in respiratory health.

      The authors have thoroughly addressed the primary concerns raised by the reviewers, substantially improving the manuscript.

      Strengths

      (1) This study shows that FoxO transcription factors in Drosophila, mouse, and human airway epithelial cells undergo nuclear translocation in response to stressors including hypoxia, temperature, and oxidative stress. FoxO factors were shown to mediate immune and stress responses to hypoxia and stress in Drosophila airway tissue. Strikingly, reduced FoxO expression was observed in mouse models of asthma and in airway samples from asthma patients. The findings support a model in which FoxO coordinates adaptive epithelial stress responses that maintain airway homeostasis under environmental challenges. Understanding the intricate regulation of FoxO transcription factors provides insights into modulating immune and inflammatory pathways and offers potential avenues for therapeutic interventions against respiratory diseases and other illnesses.

      (2) The work employs diverse model systems, including Drosophila, murine models, and human samples, thereby establishing a conserved role for FoxOs in airway epithelium and aiding translational relevance to human health.

      (3) The manuscript establishes a strong correlation between FoxO expression levels and respiratory diseases such as asthma. Through analyses of both murine models of asthma and asthmatic human samples, the study demonstrates a consistent reduction in FoxO expression, indicating its potential involvement in the pathogenesis of respiratory disorders. This correlation underscores the clinical relevance of FoxO dysregulation and opens avenues for developing treatments for respiratory conditions like asthma, COPD, and pulmonary fibrosis, addressing significant unmet clinical needs.

      (4) The study unveils intriguing mechanistic details regarding FoxO regulation and function. Particularly noteworthy is the observation of distinct regulatory mechanisms governing dFOXO translocation in response to different stressors. The independence of hypoxia-induced dFOXO translocation from JNK signaling adds complexity to our understanding of FoxO-mediated stress responses. Such mechanistic insights deepen our understanding of FoxO biology and pave the way for future investigations into the intricacies of FoxO signaling pathways in airway epithelial cells.

      Weaknesses

      (1)There is conceptual ambiguity between transcript expression and the regulation of FOXO factors through posttranslational modifications, distinct from expression levels.

      (2) The mammalian experiments remain primarily descriptive and do not establish a functional requirement for FOXO in epithelial stress resistance or a causal contribution to asthma. The authors now acknowledge these limitations more clearly, although some Discussion statements still refer to FOXO activity when transcript levels were measured. Further information on validation of the new trachea-specific dfoxo manipulation would strengthen the functional evidence. Some inconsistencies in the immunostaining Methods and Figure 6 labels and legend also require clarification.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors combine a two-day associative-inference task with EEG in two experiments involving 136 participants. Participants learn overlapping AB and BC pairs and subsequently infer AC relationships after a stress or control procedure. The second experiment adds retrieval practice after learning. Stress-related reductions in inference performance and bridge-category decoding in Experiment 1 are attenuated or reversed in Experiment 2.

      The revision provides useful additional analyses and more explicit acknowledgment of the design's limitations. I no longer interpret Figure 4A as evidence of below-chance inference. However, several conclusions in the title, abstract, and Discussion remain stronger than the revised evidence supports.

      Strengths:

      The study addresses a worthwhile question by combining behavioral measures, an experimentally induced stress manipulation, and temporally resolved EEG. The independent visual localizer and decoding during the pre-choice period provide useful evidence that information related to the absent bridge category is available during inference.

      Importantly, the evidence is not limited to a significant stress effect in one experiment and a nonsignificant effect in the other. The manuscript reports direct stress-by-experiment interactions for inference performance, response time, and decoding. The behavioral interaction also remains significant after adjustment for both-correct premise-triad counts. The exploratory mediation analysis, Bayesian comparison, and trial-level model improve the transparency of the evidence and deserve explicit credit.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Premise memory strength and inference specific protection remain difficult to separate

      The authors now acknowledge that strengthening AB/BC memories may contribute to better AC performance, and the exploratory mediation analysis supports this possibility. This is a useful clarification. However, a residual direct association after adjustment for premise memory does not establish an additional inference-specific mechanism. Premise memory was measured after inference using a coarse 2AFC test, and the mediation concerns the overall association with retrieval practice rather than specifically explaining the stress-by-practice interaction. Similarly, restricting analyses to both-correct trials or adjusting their number cannot equate underlying memory strength. The Discussion should therefore avoid treating the nonsignificant difference between the two control groups as evidence that the benefit transcends strengthened associations or specifically preserves online integration.

      (2) The cross-experiment comparison supports an association with attenuation

      The new interaction analyses strengthen the evidence that the stress effect differs between experiments. Nevertheless, retrieval practice was introduced in a separate follow-up cohort, so its effect remains confounded with experiment. The authors appropriately acknowledge this limitation; it should also guide the title and broader conclusions. "Associated with attenuation" is better supported than "prevents" or "restores." Likewise, the reported BF01 of 2.77 provides only weak support for no stress effect in Experiment 2 and does not establish equivalent performance. A randomized factorial study would provide a stronger causal test, but the present findings remain informative with appropriately limited claims.

      (3) The neural findings support category level information with limited mechanistic specificity

      The shift toward "bridge-related category information" is appropriate because the decoder distinguishes faces from buildings. It cannot identify reinstatement of the particular B item linking a given AB-BC pair. The association with inference success is meaningful, but category imagery, retrieval strategy, and item-specific recollection are not dissociated. Nor does this association establish that the decoded activity is necessary for inference or mediates stress-related impairment. Despite the response letter's clarification, the abstract and conclusion still describe rapid bridge-element reactivation as an essential or causal mechanism. Consistent category-level, correlational language would align these passages with the analyses. The claim that retrieval practice prevents the theta reduction is also tentative: the reported within-experiment tests and overall, between-experiment comparison do not directly test a stress-by-practice interaction for theta (Section 3.6).

      (4) Retrieval specific and item specific benefits remain unresolved

      The lack of a matched restudy or additional-exposure condition limits conclusions about the distinctive contribution of retrieval practice. The authors now acknowledge this appropriately. They also explain that practice responses cannot be reliably scored, so the proposed successful-versus-unsuccessful practice analysis is unavailable. The new participant-and-triad mixed-effects model is a useful robustness check, but its interaction is uncertain (p = .058), and it cannot establish whether protection follows successful retrieval of particular items or a broader change in strategy. These limitations remain unresolved by the new model.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript investigates the interplay between spontaneous attention and melody formation during polyphonic music listening. The authors use EEG recordings during uninstructed listening to examine how attention bias influences melody processing, employing both behavioural measures and computational modelling with music transformers. The study introduces a very clever pitch-inversion manipulation design to dissociate high-voice superiority from melodic salience and propose a "weighted integration" model where attention dynamically modulates how multiple voices are combined into perceived melody.

      Strengths:

      (1) The attention bias findings (Figure 2) are compelling and methodologically sound, with convergent evidence from both behavioral and neural measures.

      (2) The pitch-inversion manipulation appears to super elegantly dissociate two competing factors (high-voice superiority vs melodic salience), moreover, the authors claim that the chosen music lends itself perfectly to his PolyInv condition. A claim I cannot really evaluate but which would make it even more neat.

      (3) Nice linking between hypotheses and operationalisations.

      Weaknesses:

      My main remaining concerns are about Figure 3, which appears central (e.g. the title) and where the evidence remains, I'm afraid, incomplete.

      (1) Statistics. As R3 observed, the stats in Fig 3 are across repetitions and not over subjects -- therefore the p-value does not appear to support population inference, and the key striking interaction in the figure does not appear to be tested? I don't see how the author response addresses this.

      (2) Model checks. I asked how correlated the monophonic and polyphonic surprisal values are with each other. The revision reports correlations before and after inversion, which answers a different question. From Figure 3c it appears to be the case that the poly feature adds nothing to classification in PolyOrig, so it is also unclear whether Figure 3 reflects attention or a mis-specified feature.

      I also noticed that the statistics in Figure 3 changed (see recommendation)

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors examine the neural correlates of face recognition deficits in individuals with Developmental Prosopagnosia (DP; 'face blindness'). Contrary to theories that poor face recognition is driven by reduced spatial integration (via smaller receptive fields), here the authors find that the properties of receptive fields in face-selective brain regions are the same in typical individuals vs. those with DP. The main analysis technique is population Receptive Field (pRF) mapping, with a wide range of measures considered. The authors report that there are no differences in goodness-of-fit (R2), the properties of the pRFs (neither size, location, nor the gain and exponent of the Compressive Spatial Summation model), nor their coverage of the visual field. The relationship of these properties to the visual field (notably the increase in pRF size with eccentricity) is also similar between the groups. Eye movements do not differ between the groups.

      Strengths:

      Although this is a null result, the large number of null results gives confidence that there are unlikely to be differences between the two groups. Together, this makes a compelling case that DP is not driven by differences in the spatial selectivity of face-selective brain regions, an important finding that directly informs theories of face recognition. The paper is well written and enjoyable to read, the studies have clearly been carefully conducted with clear justification for design decisions, and analyses are thorough.

      Issues raised earlier regarding the localisation of face-selective regions between the two groups have been thoughtfully qualified in the revised manuscript. The use of a fixed-window localisation procedure (whereby large group-level ROIs are used to begin, with the top 20% most selective voxels selected in each individual) is a nice touch, ensuring a matched number of voxels in each ROI across groups, despite the clear differences in selectivity. Other clarifications to the results and discussion have also improved the manuscript.

      Weaknesses:

      One small issue concerns the relation between this study and prior work in low-level vision. The authors state in the introduction and discussion that there are "few" studies linking pRF properties to performance, citing only one. This ignores the numerous studies that have been conducted in this area - it would be ideal either to qualify these statements or to cite a greater number of these studies. The revised manuscript also includes mention of correlational analyses in the discussion which would be better placed in the results to begin.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: The reviewers discussed the revision. They agreed that the authors made a good faith effort to thoughtful response to the queries and concerns raised, and this manuscript should be published. Although some concerns about the applicability of the methods for a wider range of plant tissues remain. This has been expressed more clearly in the eLife Assessment above, and the authors may want to consider adding their own cautionary language to the manuscript, for example that they were not successful with intact plant leaves.]

      Summary:

      This in situ cryo-ET workflow of selected plant structures provides several detailed strategies using plunge-freezing and the HPF waffle method and lift-out for notoriously difficult samples (compared to cell culture, yeast, and algae, which are far more prevalent in the literature).

      Strengths:

      A very difficult challenge whereby the authors demonstrate successful vitrification of selected plants/structures using waffle and lift-out approaches for cryoET. Because there are relatively few examples of multi-cellular plant cryo-ET in the literature, it is important for the scientific community to be motivated and have demonstrated strategies that it is achievable. This manuscript has a number of very helpful graphics and videos to help guide researchers who would be interested in undertaking that would help shorten the learning curve of admittedly tedious and complex workflows. This is a slow and tedious process, but you have to start somewhere, and I applaud the authors for sharing their experiences with others, and I expect will help other early adopters to come up to speed sooner.

      Comments on revised version:

      The authors made a good faith effort to thoughtful response to my queries and concerns, and this manuscript should be published. I really appreciate it. I suggest one final amendment, and it can simply be an insertion of a couple sentences. I'm still concerned by the more niche plant sample types being used, admittedly due to limitations in freezing of more mainstream plant species and/or tissues, and leaves in particular. The workflows described in the manuscript definitely could work IF freezing could be adequate. The authors go to lengths describing what makes it a challenge to vitrify, and they comment in rebuttal that they so far have been unsuccessful in intact leaves of higher plants. Yet, they do not explicitly make that statement in the manuscript itself. I want to be sure that a reader doesn't invest much time and money thinking this paper on "Making plant tissue accessible..." is actually not broadly accessible to any plant tissue. As described it is specific or workable in "select" plant tissue types or species due to freezing limitations and/or strategies employed. I am asking to place some simple cautionary guiding language in the discussion or elsewhere.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work explores the relationship between sexual conflict and species diversification in a clade of small water striders. They use multiple phylogenetic methods to establish a potential phylogenetic tree and explore incomplete lineage sorting and introgression. They then compare their calibrated species tree with phenotypic measures of many species to try to infer the relationship between species diversity and sexual conflict. They show evidence for both ILS and introgression within the broader clade. They also find evidence that male leg diversity is associated with speciation, potentially due to sexual conflict, and that male genital grasping structures as well as female anti-grasping traits have less evidence for an association with speciation. This paper seems like a generally rigorous and interesting addition to the literature on sexual conflict and speciation, and I believe the conclusions are well supported with only a few minor concerns with methodology.

      Strengths:

      This paper verifies results using multiple methodologies to ensure robustness to changes in software uses and presents convincing evidence for the hypotheses tested.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) I think the lack of empirical functional evidence on these traits is still a weakness, despite the authors adding caveats within the text (lines 622-629). I am unsure if these species are readily accessible or reared in the lab, but to do some sort of trial where the male traits are ablated in some way to verify that they are necessary, and also that they incur a fitness loss on females is critical for the interpretations of this paper.

      (2) Uncertainty within the phylogeny (Figure 1) also appears to be quite drastic, although I am not an expert in phylogenetic reconstruction. Looking at the uncertainty around each branch point makes drawing any strong relationship in the order of evolutionary changes less convincing, although with revisions the authors now provide appropriate caveats for their inference in some areas of the manuscript.

      (3) Lines 463-469: I find it dubious to say 'no significant differences' and then present a p-value of 0.052 and just a few paragraphs later present a p = 0.0178 as significant. These p-values are similar and not necessarily meaningful here. It appears you identified a very weak correlation between traits, that happen to fall on either side of an arbitrary cut-off of 0.05. Whether such a weak relationship with such low confidence is biologically meaningful is more important, which I assume it is not regardless of the p-value. I'd suggest adding confidence intervals rather than p-values.

      (4) Lines 561-577: I'm not certain why throughout the manuscript the authors somewhat confidently assert that male traits evolved first, and despite the increased diversity relatively in male traits, could female resistance traits not have evolved first due to the documented costs of superfluous matings, and then a novel selection pressure resulted in a radiation of male coercion traits?

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors have addressed some of my concerns and made more transgenic lines to verify the pattern and function of ATHB2-miP produced from the alternative TSS. However, I'm still not convinced by the new data and have questions about their interpretations.

      (1) I find it hard to understand the data shown in Figure 5.

      a. Figure 5B: It's reasonable that the peptide I was detected exclusively in ATHB2-WT because it was at a position before the alternative TSS. It's hard to evaluate peptide II because it could be included in ATHB2miP depending on the exact position; the authors should clearly label it and clarify. However, I had a hard time understanding why peptides III and IV were detected only in ATHB2-WT and peptide V only in ATHB2-alt-all three peptide regions should be included in both ATHB2-WT and ATHB2-alt proteins. The silent mutation that disrupted the alternative TSS should not change the full-length ATHB2 protein (Figure 5C)! Please share your insights on this strange observation.

      b. Figure 5C: Please indicate which ATHB2-WT and ATHB2-alt lines were used in this assay. Please provide a marker for the anti-FLAG immunoblot and indicate protein band sizes in both the Coomassie staining and the anti-FLAG immunoblot. It's unclear to me whether 2 and 3 are two bands-they are too close on the immunoblot to be viewed as two separate bands. It seems to me that both bands 1 and 2 are larger in ATHB2-alt than in ATHB2-WT-is this true, or is it due to a tilted image?

      c. Figure 5D: I'm wondering whether both ATHB2-alt lines showed constitutively longer hypocotyl length was caused by higher expression levels of ATHB2 full-length proteins than in ATHB2-WT lines. The authors didn't compare the protein levels in ATHB2-WT and ATHB2-alt lines. Figure 5C was a pulldown assay, in which the total input of immunoprecipitated proteins was normalized, and thus could not tell us whether the ATHB2-alt line had a higher ATHB2 protein level than the ATHB2-WT line.

      (2) Regarding my previous comment #4, I understand that the authors may want to study this in the future. However, since the exact position of the alternative TSS has been released in the manuscript, it's not a problem for readers to find the promoter sequences of ATHB2 and ATHB2miP. I suggest that the authors provide a little more analysis of these two promoters because it's natural for readers to ask about the mechanism by which both promoters drive expression specifically in the SAM and hypocotyl. Do they share cis-elements such as WUS-binding sites, ARR-B elements, or AuxRE?

      (3) Regarding my previous comment #7, the authors didn't answer part of my question. I wrote, "The authors claimed that ATHB2 acts as a growth repressor in deep shade but a growth promoter in the canopy and proximity shade (Lines 366-368). However, it appears that regardless of the shade conditions, most mutant and transgenic lines were not significantly different from WT (Figure 4C)." No explanations were provided. Based on Kunihiro et al., 2011 (DOI: 10.1093/pcp/pcr076), overexpressing ATHB2 full-length CDS led to constitutively long hypocotyls. If ATHB2-miP inhibits the function of the full-length ATHB2, one would expect that overexpressing ATHB2-miP might inhibit hypocotyl growth. Interestingly, the performance of 35S::miP was opposite to the prediction and showed different responses in the three WL conditions in Figure 4C-35S::miP was significantly longer in the deep-shade WL control (PAR 13 µmol m-2 s-1) but was the same as WT in the canopy and proximity shade WL controls (45 µmol m-2 s-1). Please provide a reasonable explanation. Besides, one issue remains-the authors only provided one transgenic line each for 35S::miP and t-athb2 35S::miP, and the miP protein levels were not shown in these lines.

    1. Sixteen patients were screened for variants in one or more of the RCC predisposition genes VHL, FH, FLCN, MET or SDHB (Table 2). No pathogenic variants were found in FH, FLCN, MET or SDHB, but we did find a start codon variant (c.3G>A, p.Met1Ile) and a missense variant (c.631A>C, p.Met211Leu) in VHL in a patient from cohort 2 (Fig 3). Both VHL variants are classified as class 3 variants (VUS) according to the classification guidelines from IARC [26].Open in a separate windowFig 3Pedigree of family 6002.The arrow indicates the proband. The age of RCC-onset and histological subtype the renal tumor is listed below the proband (III:3). A start codon VUS (c.3G>A, p.Met1Ile) and a missense variant (c.631A>C, p. Met211Leu) in VHL and a intron variant (c.1729+8T>C) in BAP1 was identified in a peripheral blood sample from the proband. The proband’s maternal uncle (II:1) was diagnosed with testicular cancer.

      PatientID: III:1

      KindredID: 6002

      Case: M, 28Y0M, Ethnicity Unknown

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      FamilyInfo: Maternal uncle (II:1) had a history of testicular cancer but no genetic data was available.

      CohortInfo: Patients met at least one of the criteria: RCC < forty years of age or bilateral or multifocal RCC < sixty years of age or family history of RCC or three relatives with RCC, melanoma or mesothelioma (at least one case of RCC) or patients diagnosed with RCC and melanoma. Family history of RCC is defined as two or more first-degree relatives with RCC. Patients with a previously identified pathogenic variant in a renal cancer predisposition gene were not included. Patient inclusion took place from February 2014 to January 2015. This patient was grouped in “Group 1” where only one family member was affected by renal cell carcinoma (n=20).

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0006770 (Clear cell renal cell carcinoma)

      CaseHPOFreeText: N/A

      CaseNotHPOs: N/A

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: The patient has been through the national screening program for putative VHL, which includes MRI of the cerebrum, spinal medulla and abdomen, neurological examination, auditory tests, ocular examination and blood work for chromogranin A and metanephrines, with normal results.

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: Figure 3

      Variant: p.M1I (c.3G>A)

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: 135406, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/clinvar/variation/135406/

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: 0.00007043, https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/variant/3-10183534-G-A

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: missense_variant;transition

      CivicName: M1I (c.3G>A)

      MultipleGeneVariants: Germline, VHL, c.631A>C (p.Met211Leu)

      MultipleGeneVariants: Germline, BAP1, c.1729+8T>C

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Scattering of light sets the practical limits on optical imaging depth in living brain tissue. It arises from a refractive index mismatch between the fluid surrounding cells (~1.34) and the structures embedded in it (~1.35-1.43), and, unlike optical aberration, it cannot be effectively pre-compensated by adaptive optics. The authors present an approach that reduces scattering at its source, raising the refractive index of the extracellular fluid with a medium built around iodixanol, a non-ionic iodinated compound already approved for intravenous use in humans, formulated to remain isosmotic with standard artificial cerebrospinal fluid. They then evaluate it on three counts: how much it clears tissue, whether animals tolerate it, and whether circuit activity survives it. The paper also reports the limits of the approach, documenting reduced spontaneous exploratory behavior in treated animals.

      Strengths:

      The optical characterization in brain slices is rigorous. The authors quantify clearing with the modulation transfer function, show that the effect reverses on washout, show that it does not develop in untreated tissue over matched durations, and repeat the measurement with a low-numerical-aperture objective specifically to separate reduced scattering from corrected aberration. Together these establish the core optical claim that the treatment reduces scattering, and not merely that it corrects aberration. The behavioral work is thorough: blinded testing across a series of behaviors, along with appropriate controls including a non-surgical group to separate the effects of surgery from those of the reagents, and computed tomography to verify that each tested animal received the compound. The authors also report the limitations explicitly, identifying a dissociation between motivated tasks (largely unaffected) and spontaneous exploration (substantially reduced). The retinal recordings are a well-chosen functional assay, and benchmarking against 2% isoflurane is useful.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) It is not clear how the reported improvement of 150-200% in penetration depth was derived, or how penetration depth was operationally defined. The authors should clarify both.

      (2) Depth in the intact animal could be characterized more fully. Figure 5b plots contrast ratio against depth to roughly 450 µm, and Figure 6f shows a single plane at 430 µm, but neither gives a systematic depth series or a criterion-based depth limit. The contrast gain in Figure 5b also appears scattered rather than following a trend with depth, which deserves comment; limited penetration of the agent into deeper tissue may contribute.

      (3) The quantitative analysis in Figure 6 could be strengthened. It currently shows traces from a single cell, with no population-level comparison of event rate, amplitude, decay kinetics, or pairwise correlation. As it stands, the figure supports the optical claim that the same cells are brighter, but not the physiological claim made alongside it.

      (4) The authors may, if they choose, strengthen the biocompatibility analysis by adding histology for gliosis and cell death, measures of intracranial pressure or edema, and quantification of tissue volume change.

      (5) The abstract overstates the behavioral result, stating that "Brain-cleared mice were motile and unimpaired on a variety of behavioral tasks." The animals were indeed motile and completed every task, and the motivated-task result is fair, but "unimpaired" is not the right summary of the spontaneous-activity data the authors themselves collected.

      (6) The interpretive consequences of the behavioral findings could be discussed in more detail. A reduction in spontaneous locomotion and exploration of this magnitude would likely confound studies of spontaneous behavior, exploratory drive, or anxiety-like measures. Readers would benefit from explicit guidance on which designs are compatible with in vivo clearing. This is an argument for stating the method's domain of validity, not against the method.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript presents some interesting results that further delineate and characterize the origins of rhythmicity in a paradigmatic model system, the Aplysia feeding network.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript writing is clear and concise. The figures present the data well (with one exception noted below), and the mathematical and statistical analyses are rigorously done. The results support most of the authors' conclusions, except for three Discussion points as noted below. This manuscript does make a significant contribution to our understanding of how rhythmic motor patterns are generated in a relatively simple, widely used animal model, thus, these results are of considerable importance.

      Weaknesses:

      There is one significant data inconsistency the authors need to address. Three of the Discussion points are not supported and need removal or revision, and I have a few minor comments.

      Major Comments:

      (1) In Figure 3A, for the noncontingent (NC) group, the plotted mean rate of BMPs is highly discrepant from the rate of BMPs in Figure 2A1, assuming the stated 10 min trace duration is accurate. More importantly, that mean rate is discrepant from the 89 sec spectral density peak in 2A2. However, that mean rate does appear consistent with the rate of NC fast oscillations in Fig. 2A1 and with the 57 sec peak in 2A2. Thus, it appears the fast oscillation rate was actually plotted in 3A. For the contingent (C) group, the rates are about the same, so I can't tell if the same issue is present. Check if this inconsistency is also an issue for Figure 3B. Revise these figures as needed. Revise any manuscript text as needed to account for, or explain, this inconsistency.

      (2) Page 10, lines 210-214. The presented data do not establish that IP3 removed the memory trace. Instead, IP3 could have obscured the trace without removing it. To really establish that the trace was removed, IP3 would have to be removed to see if the trace returned or not. This caveat should be noted in the Discussion.

      (3) Discussion, lines 452-454. This statement about replay is completely unwarranted because nothing in your preceding text deals, specifically, with replay of activity patterns. Replay is a specific term as occurs, for example, when rats spontaneously replay a sequence of neural activations that previously occurred when they were running along a track. If you want to discuss replay, you have to add some more references and discussion that spell out any link between oscillations and replay.

      (4) Discussion, lines 460-463, and 590-592. I am highly skeptical that the relatively small subthreshold oscillations, as opposed to the much larger voltage bursts, can propagate through gap junctions to an extent that would initiate electrical activity in neighboring cells. It would appear that the subthreshold oscillations would be attenuated to be negligible, after going through gap junctions. I could envision, instead, that the effect of voltage bursts, propagated through gap junctions, can suffice to initiate activity in neighboring cells. Please discuss further and revise as necessary.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Sensory hair cells of the inner ear convert mechanical sound vibrations into electrical signals through mechano-electrical transduction (MET). While the protein components of the MET machinery have been studied extensively, much less is known about how the surrounding membrane lipid environment contributes to hair cell function. The recent discovery that TMC1 and TMC2 also function as lipid scramblases has brought renewed attention to the importance of membrane lipid asymmetry and the mechanisms that maintain it in sensory hair cells.

      In this study, the authors identify the P4-ATPase ATP8B1 and its partner TMEM30B as key regulators of membrane lipid asymmetry in outer hair cells. Using complementary genetic models, HA-tagged knock-in mice, localization analyses, and functional experiments, they show that ATP8B1-TMEM30B is enriched in stereocilia and the apical membrane of outer hair cells and is required to maintain phosphatidylserine asymmetry, support hair cell survival, and preserve normal hearing. The parallels between the ATP8B1/TMEM30B loss-of-function phenotypes and TMC1 deafness-associated mutants with constitutive scrambling support a model in which ATP8B1-TMEM30B flippase activity maintains membrane lipid asymmetry and homeostasis, whereas constitutive TMC1-mediated phospholipid scrambling disrupts this balance and contributes to membrane instability.

      The authors have addressed the points raised during the initial review thoroughly. The revised manuscript includes clearer methodological details, additional physiological characterization, improved presentation and quantification of several datasets, and a more balanced interpretation of the localization and mechanistic findings. These changes improve both the clarity and rigor of the study while leaving its main conclusions unchanged.

      As with any study that opens a new area of investigation, important mechanistic questions remain. In particular, it will be interesting to determine how disruption of membrane lipid asymmetry ultimately impairs MET function and triggers hair cell degeneration, how flippase and scramblase activities are coordinated in vivo, and how these pathways are integrated with the broader molecular machinery underlying mechanotransduction. These questions highlight the exciting directions that this study opens for the field.

      Overall, this work provides evidence that ATP8B1-TMEM30B is a critical regulator of stereocilia membrane lipid asymmetry and represents an important contribution to our understanding of membrane homeostasis in auditory hair cells. I have no further major concerns and support publication.

      Comments on second revision:

      I appreciate the authors' efforts to address the issue and perform the additional experiment, and I agree that removing these data is reasonable and does not affect the main conclusions of the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors aim to elucidate the mechanisms by which grid cells in the medial entorhinal cortex generate predictive representations of spatial location. To address this, they built a computational model integrating intrinsic neuronal dynamics with structured network connectivity. Specifically, they combine a conductance-based single-cell model incorporating biologically realistic HCN channels with a continuous attractor network that reflects known properties of grid cell circuitry. Their simulations show that HCN conductance can shift grid fields forward by approximately 5% of their diameter, consistent with experimental observations in layer II grid cells. Additionally, by introducing asymmetry in the connectivity of interneurons, the model produces larger forward shifts, which parallels properties observed in layer III grid cells. Together, these two mechanisms provide a unified framework for explaining layer-specific predictive coding in the entorhinal cortex.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the study lies in its conceptual contribution. The authors propose two distinct mechanisms to generate forward-shifted grid fields for predictive coding. One mechanism is intrinsic and depends on the time constants associated with HCN channels. The other is network-based and results from asymmetries in interneuron connectivity. These two mechanisms correspond to different observed properties of grid cells in layer II and layer III, respectively. The modeling is based on previously validated frameworks of continuous attractor network models (e.g., Burak & Fiete; Kang & DeWeese), but it incorporates several novel features, including the incorporation of biophysically realistic HCN channels, a network architecture that excludes stellate-stellate connections and relies on interneurons, and asymmetric interneuron connectivity.

      Weaknesses:

      One of the proposed mechanisms for predictive coding, namely asymmetric interneuron connectivity, is a novel idea. However, this type of connectivity has not yet been demonstrated experimentally in the medial entorhinal cortex. Therefore, the biological plausibility of this mechanism remains uncertain and will need to be evaluated in future empirical studies. The revised manuscript now clearly acknowledges this limitation and discusses how this prediction could be tested experimentally, for example through paired recordings or connectomic reconstruction of interneuron-stellate cell connectivity.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have adequately addressed my previous comments, and the revised manuscript has been substantially improved. I have no further major comments.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This work shows experimentally and computationally that single CA1 neurons can perform mismatch detection on patterned CA3 inputs and that STP and EI balance underlie this detection.

      Strengths:

      It has been known that STP can enhance the EPSP when the corresponding presynaptic input exhibits abrupt changes in firing rate. This work provides experimental evidence and further computational support for the hypothesis that the basic computation through STP is useful for detecting abrupt changes in the spatial pattern of synaptic inputs at the Schaffer collaterals. Their results indicate the novel view that mismatch detection is most efficient when gamma-frequency bursting inputs exhibit mismatches between theta cycles. These results are robust against variations in external and internal conditions.

      Weaknesses:

      While this study shows an intriguing example of combined experimental and computational studies, the results of the experiments and those of the computational model display non-negligible deviations in some conditions. However, discrepancies are expected in modeling studies due to the simplifications in the model setting and guide the directions of future research.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study examines whether children at the beginning of formal reading instruction possess visual knowledge of letter shapes that can be distinguished from their ability to name letters. In a large sample of children learning Kannada, many children reliably distinguished upright from inverted letters despite limited letter-naming performance. Children also searched more efficiently for upright than inverted letters, and this search advantage was uniquely associated with letter-shape familiarity after controlling for letter-naming performance and other measured factors. These findings suggest that familiarity with the visual structure of letters can emerge before extensive formal instruction in letter-name or letter-sound associations.

      Strengths:

      The study addresses a relatively understudied component of emergent literacy by distinguishing visual familiarity with letter shapes from explicit letter naming. This question is theoretically important, particularly in light of functional subdivisions within the visual word form area, with posterior regions associated with letter and orthographic shape and anterior regions with linguistic features of orthography (Caffarra et al., 2021; Lerma-Usabiaga et al., 2018). The large sample of children at an early stage of reading instruction provides an informative opportunity to examine these abilities before they become highly correlated through extensive reading experience. The revised manuscript has also been strengthened by convergent results across multiple analytical approaches.

      Weaknesses:

      The comparison between letter-shape familiarity and letter-name knowledge is influenced by differences between the receptive familiarity task and the production-based naming task, although the authors now appropriately acknowledge this limitation. More importantly, the cross-sectional study does not establish whether early letter-shape familiarity contributes to subsequent literacy development; longitudinal evidence will be needed to determine its role in later reading acquisition.

      Comments on revised version:

      I am satisfied that the authors have addressed most of my previous comments. I have only a few minor comments that require further attention.

      (1) Direct comparison of familiarity and recognition effects

      The newly added regression and mixed-effects analyses strengthen the finding that familiarity is associated with the upright-search advantage after controlling for recognition and the other measured factors. However, the central comparative claim remains incompletely tested. A significant effect of familiarity alongside a nonsignificant effect of recognition does not establish that the two associations differ significantly. The authors should directly compare the effects of these two abilities. Otherwise, the conclusion should be limited to stating that familiarity explains unique variance after controlling for recognition, rather than that familiarity is more strongly associated with the upright-search advantage.

      (2) Interpretation of the VGG-16 analysis

      I appreciate the addition of the VGG-16 analysis, which provides an interesting characterization of the visual relationship between recognized and unrecognized letters. However, the interpretation of these results is potentially ambiguous. For example, the positive correlations indicate that children with higher familiarity and recognition scores tended to show greater VGG-derived visual separation between their recognized and unrecognized letter sets. This pattern could suggest that the visual structure or discriminability of the letters contributes to which letters become recognized, rather than simply ruling out generalization from recognized letters. The authors should therefore consider and discuss alternative interpretations of this finding rather than presenting it solely as evidence against the generalization account.

      (3) Placement and reporting of the additional analyses

      Several analyses added in response to the reviewers are important to the manuscript's main conclusions but remain primarily in the Supplementary Information. Although the GLME and VGG-16 analyses are briefly mentioned in the main Results, they are not reported in sufficient detail for readers to evaluate the central evidence. Given that the GLME directly models the orientation-dependent associations and the VGG-16 analysis addresses an important alternative account of familiarity with unrecognized letters, these analyses should be described in greater detail in the main manuscript. In addition, the analyses concerning familiarity and recognition reported in Section S1 of the Supplementary Information deserve a brief summary in the main Results, as they provide a fuller picture of the relationship between familiarity and recognition-the central topic of the study.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      This article presents a study consisting of two experiments, which aim to dissociate and quantify the distinct motivational functions of phasic and tonic pain within a naturalistic and immersive VR setting. Specifically, the Authors test two hypotheses: (i) that phasic pain acts as a punishment signal that drives avoidance learning; (ii) that tonic pain reduces motivational vigor, promoting energy conservation and recuperation. In both experiments, participants performed a free-operant foraging task, where they collected virtual pineapples to earn points.

      In Experiment 1, phasic pain was delivered as a brief electric shock to the grasping hand when picking up green pineapples. As phasic pain intensity increased, participants were less likely to choose painful fruits. A reinforcement learning model that incorporated reward, pain cost and effort cost was able to successfully capture behavior.

      Experiment 2 combined effects of phasic and tonic pain. Tonic pain was induced by a pressure cuff on the non-dominant arm, simulating sustained discomfort. Interestingly, tonic pain did not affect the perceived intensity or avoidance of phasic pain. However, it significantly reduced movement velocity and pineapple collection rate, interpreted as a reduction of motivational vigor. A temporal decision model incorporating vigor cost successfully captured these effects.

      Concomitant EEG recordings showed that tonic pain was associated with reduced alpha and beta power in parietal and temporal areas. Phasic pain ratings and decision values distinctively correlated with skin conductance responses.

      Overall, these findings indicate that phasic and tonic pain have distinct and dissociable motivational effects.

      Strengths:

      This is an ambitious study that provides a quantitative dissociation of the roles of phasic and tonic pain in adaptive behavior, by integrating ecological neuroscience, motivational theory, and computational modeling. The use of immersive VR combined with a free-operant foraging task offers a more ecologically valid context to study pain-related behavior compared to traditional paradigms. Furthermore, the study employs a multimodal approach by combining behavioral data, computational frameworks, physiological signals and EEG. In particular, one of the main strengths of the study is the use of sophisticated computational modeling to capture phasic and tonic pain effects. The experiment codes are available on GitHub, increasing reproducibility.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study addresses a fundamental question in cognitive neuroscience regarding how the brain transitions from a reactive state of following external instructions to a proactive state of self-directed agency. The authors utilize an ambitious multimodal design by combining the spatial precision of fMRI with the temporal resolution of EEG across two independent datasets from the University of Florida and UC Davis. The work shows that while both instructed and willed attention engage the Dorsal Attention Network, willed choices additionally recruit a frontoparietal network including the dACC and anterior insula. By applying multivariate pattern analysis, the authors further demonstrate that the chosen direction of attention can be decoded from this network only on choice trials, and that pre-cue alpha patterns carry information predictive of subsequent spontaneous choices. This suggests a neural link between pre-existing brain states and intentional action, representing a significant technical effort to characterize the neural scaffolding of internal goal generation.

      Strengths:

      The primary strengths of this work include the integration of fMRI and EEG, which allows the authors to bridge the gap between slow metabolic signals and fast oscillatory brain states. The use of two independent cohorts is a commendable effort to ensure the reproducibility of the willed attention effect, which is often a concern in small-sample neuroimaging studies. Additionally, the move beyond univariate activation toward information-based mapping remains the strongest aspect of the work, as it shows that the identified network actually contains specific information about the direction of attention. However, the per-site decoding effects are modest and, in the UF dataset alone, do not survive correction (Table A1). The revision further adds permutation- and cluster-based inference, channel-subset and trial-balanced EEG decoding, and clearer methodological reporting, all of which improve transparency.

      Weaknesses:

      The revised manuscript addresses most of my earlier concerns, and the additional analyses improve the transparency of the work. The remaining points concern interpretation rather than the findings themselves. The decoding shows that the frontoparietal network carries the self-chosen direction of attention, but the present data do not establish the temporal ordering proposed in Figure 6. Similarly, the pre-cue alpha effect is consistent with a spontaneous brain-state bias, but without a measure of eye position or of when decisions are made, an oculomotor contribution or choices settled before the cue cannot be excluded. Finally, the link between pre-cue predictability and post-cue frontoparietal activity rests on a between-subject comparison, and the neural efficiency interpretation is one of several possible readings. Readers should weigh the proposed model with these limitations in mind.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The authors describe a massively parallel reporter assays (MPRA) screen focused at identifying polymorphisms in 5' and 3' UTRs that affect translation efficiency and thus might have a functional impact on cells. The topic is of timely interest, and indeed, several related efforts have recently been published and preprinted (e.g., https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37516102/ and https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10635273/).

      Comments on revisions:

      The authors have now repeated the screen and collected new data that is high quality. From my perspective the manuscript has improved and I don't have any standing issues remaining.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Bortoluzzi and Rohenkohl investigated the interaction between presaccadic attention (PSA) and feature expectation. PSA refers to enhanced perceptual sensitivity or neural responses at the location of an upcoming saccade, and has been taken as evidence for (partial) coupling between spatial attention and the oculomotor system. Although its spatial component has been extensively studied, much less is known about how PSA interacts with feature processing, such as orientation or spatial frequency. This question is particularly interesting as some have proposed that PSA may contribute to visual stability across saccades.

      In two psychophysics experiments, participants prepared a saccade to a cued location while a low-contrast grating, clockwise or counterclockwise, appeared either at the saccade target or the opposite location. One orientation was frequent (64%) and the other infrequent (16%), with 20% target-absent (catch) trials. Participants reported target presence and, when present, orientation. The authors found that sensitivity (d') was higher at the saccade target location, showing the well-known presaccadic enhancement. Surprisingly, sensitivity was lower for the high-probability orientation. Importantly, these two effects did not interact. Moreover, presaccadic enhancement increased with time, approaching saccade onset, whereas the low-probability advantage weakened. They also reported that saccade latency was prolonged for the low-probability orientation, an effect reproduced in a follow-up experiment. The authors conclude that PSA enhances perception independent of feature expectation, and additionally, feature expectation influences both perceptual sensitivity and oculomotor responses.

      Strengths:

      (1) The topic addressed here is important for understanding the nature of presaccadic attention (PSA), particularly how PSA interacts with feature processing. The factorial design allows a clear dissociation of the effects of PSA and feature expectation.

      (2) The dissociation between PSA and feature expectation was examined in multiple ways. In addition to testing their overall interaction, the analysis of their temporal profiles provides further evidence that the two effects may reflect distinct processes. Several statistical analyses were also conducted to rule out differences in saccade latency as an explanation for the lack of interaction.

      (3) The investigation of stimulus probability on saccade latency provides an interesting test of how feature information may influence oculomotor responses.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The manipulation of feature expectation involves both goal-driven and stimulus-driven components. On one hand, participants were explicitly informed that one orientation was more probable throughout the experiment, which could potentially induce feature-based attention toward the more probable orientation. On the other hand, this manipulation necessarily resulted in greater exposure to one orientation than the other. This difference in exposure could potentially account for the lower sensitivity observed for the high-probability stimulus, through repetition suppression or longer-term sensory adaptation. If the feature-probability effect partly reflects such stimulus-driven mechanisms, its independence from spatially driven presaccadic attention may be less surprising. This interpretation warrants more discussion. More broadly, it remains unclear whether feature expectation would still be independent of PSA if expectation were manipulated in a way that better isolates the top-down aspect of the manipulation, or by manipulating feature-based attention cues.

      (2) The effect of feature probability on saccade latency may be considered in relation to the broader literature on oculomotor interference. Previous studies have shown that visual events during saccade preparation can delay saccade initiation and even alter saccade trajectories. Although the present manipulation differs from classic findings, the interference (by the low-probability stimulus), if any, is presented at the target location. Even so, this literature may provide a framework for interpreting the latency effect. It would also be informative to examine whether feature probability affects saccade trajectories.

      Importantly, the fact that stimulus probability affected saccade onset timing leads to the question regarding whether stimulus probability also affect manual reaction time, the interval between stimulus onset and the button press indicating the perceptual decision. It is important to rule out a potential speed-accuracy trade-off before concluding that stimulus probability affects perceptual sensitivity.

      (3) The descriptions of the implementation of the 2-ADC model are very sparse, and largely delegate it to the reference of the original papers Sridharan et al., 2014 and 2017. I suggest that, to serve as a stand-alone paper, there should be more detailed descriptions about how the model was implemented, and how the d' and criterion were calculated from the full contingency table. I also have reservations, or uncertainty, regarding how the current experimental design can be directly fitted into Sridharan et al.'s original 2-ADC framework. In the original Sridharan et al. model, when the target is present, they consider a design where the "alternative" involves only one dimension with two mutually exclusive alternatives, which is target present at location 1 versus target present at location 2. This allows them to model the internal responses in a two-dimensional space, one dimension for one location (with possible extension to N locations/channels).

      In the present study, the authors instead used the two orientation categories as the two ADC alternatives, which is in principle compatible with the feature-based extension discussed by Sridharan et al. However, the experiment is more complex, adding an additional dimension: the spatial location. Either orientation can occur at either of two locations, with target occurrences at the two locations being mutually exclusive. Thus, the complete stimulus space contains four signal states (High vs. Low probability orientation X 2 locations) plus target absence. That is, the sensory evidence that has to be considered includes four variables: oriH_loc1, oriH_loc2, oriL_loc1, oriL_loc2. It is presently unclear why and how this higher-dimensional problem is decomposed or reduced to a 2-ADC framework by assuming only the two orientations matter, while the location seems to be ignored. The authors should clarify the mapping from stimulus and response contingencies onto the 2-ADC model and justify their use of this framework.

      One could potentially treat the two locations as two independent tasks and apply the 2-ADC framework separately to each location. However, this would require the two locations to be statistically independent, including allowing targets to be present at both locations. In the current design, the locations are coupled: target-absent trials require both locations to be empty, and the presence of a target at one location implies its absence at the other. Conversely, evidence that one location is target-absent increases the probability that the target is present at the other location (given the contingency described in Figure 1b). It would therefore be helpful for the authors to clarify the rationale for this design and justify the appropriateness of applying the 2-ADC model for estimating d' and criterion.

    1. Does it matter what I want? Since when has it mattered what I want? So why should it start mattering now? Do you think I wanted to be impregnated by that old dog? Do you think I wanted to travel all this way across this country of our forefathers only to live in dirt and poverty? Do you really think I wanted the child for whom I made the journey to die only five years after it left the womb? Or my son to be taken from me? So what difference does it make whether I have a wedding or whether I go? It is all the same. What I have endured for nineteen years I can endure for another nineteen, and nineteen more if need be. Now leave me! Leave me to rest.”

      this passage illustrates the heavy inescapable weight of womanhood. lucia frustration reveal that female existence is defined by endurance rather than personal choice showing denial of woman automy

    2. Nyasha didn’t want to go home that Christmas either, and this made me apprehensive, because it was likely that there would be another of our bloody family scenes.

      this paragraph illustrates the struggle of women within their families since they are stricted by their families to do some activities hence they live without freedom. Nyasha refuses to go home because she needs independence over family conflicts

    3. o Babamunini took over the living-room and all the unmarried women, including Lucia, slept in the kitchen. There were at least eight of us sleeping there for the whole two weeks that our reunion lasted. I was comfortable enough because I had slept in the kitchen all my jife, but Nyasha could not fail asleep until the last people had stopped talking. And, she said, it was just as well that she had grown used to smoke from cigarettes, otherwise the smoke in the kitchen would have made her uncomfortable. It was true. The kitchen was smoky, because we cooked on the open hearth in the centre of the room. The hearth was a depression in the floor surrounded by a tripartite tripod of iron on which the pots were balanced; a depression surrounded also by large, smooth stones which were for balancing as well and enabled us to cook more than three pots at one time.

      Women carry most of the domestic responsibilities, while men are not expected to perform the same work.

    4. Don’t push me too far,’ Babamukuru pleaded. Mustering up his courage, Chido tried to help. ‘They were only talking for a few minutes, Dad,’ he said, and was ordered to be silent. “You, Chido, keep quiet,” Babamukuru snapped. ‘You let your sister behave like a whore without saying anything. Keep quiet.’ “Babawa Chido,’ began Maiguru, but was silenced immediately. Nyasha grew uncharacteristically calm at times like this. ‘Now why,’ she enquired of no particular person, ‘should I worry about what people say when my own father calls me a whore?’ She looked at him with murder in her eyes. ‘Nyasha, be quiet,’ Chido advised. ‘Chido, I have told you to keep out of this,’ reminded Babamukuru, gathering himself within himself so that his whole weight was behind the blow he dealt Nyasha’s face. ‘Never,’ he hissed. ‘Never,’ he repeated, striking her other cheek with the back of his hand, ‘speak to me like that.’ Nyasha fell on to the bed, her miniscule skirt riding up her

      Nyasha is beaten for coming home late, and her father called her "whore". This show her struggles as a girl.Babamukuru does not uses the word to tell the time. He uses it to shame her .He uses it to make her body crime. A boy who comes home late would be called "naughty". He would be told to be careful. But a girl home late is called a "whore" and beaten. That is struggle for girl her own father called her "whore". Always boy is corrected, a girl is condemned.

    5. Anna came and knelt down in the doorway to tell us that supper was nearly ready. ‘For heaven’s sake, Anna, stand up!’ commanded Nyasha irritably. ‘Every time you come in here I tell you not to kneel down, but you keep on doing it. What’s the matter with you?’ And then she was ashamed of herself. ‘Now, honestly, just listen to me. Getting all cross and crotchety!

      Class and gender: Anna is a poor woman serving the household, and her kneeling shows the hierarchy.

    6. To our surprise, Maiguru did leave, by bus, early the next morning. She did not slink away in the dark, but quite openly packed a suitcase, put on her travelling clothes, had her breakfast and left. Babamukuru was still feeling injured, which was why, I thought, he let her go, but Nyasha had a different theory. She thought Babamukuru simply did not believe that Maiguru would doit. Would do it, could do it. It made no difference, she said. The point was that he did not believe. Babamukuru, she said, expected his wife to get cold feet before she got to the bus-stop or, at the latest, before the bus pulled away. It would have been useful, Nyasha said, if things had turned out that way, because then Babamukuru would always have been able to remind his wife that she had tried to leave and had failed. Unfortunately, she told me, Babamukuru had to wait until Maiguru had boarded that bus and had gone to discover whether he was right or not, and by that time it was too late to do anything about it.

      This passage shows that Maiguru is not completely powerless. Despite the challenges in her marriage, she finally takes action to express her dissatisfaction. I think this demonstrates the importance of women having the courage to stand up for their rights.

    7. She did tell us, didn’t she, what she thinks, and did anyone say anything? No. Why not? Because Maiguru is educated. That’s why you all kept quiet. Because she’s rich and comes here and flashes her money around, so you listen to her as though you want to eat the words that come out of her mouth. But me, I’m not educated, am I? I’m just poor and ignorant, so you want me to keep quiet, you say I mustn’t talk.

      This shows how economic differences can affect relationships between women. Mainini feels that her opinions are ignored because she is poor. It reminds me that every woman deserves to be heard regardless of her financial position.

    8. Since for most of her life my mother’s mind, belonging first to her father and then to her husband, had not been hers to make up, she was finding it difficult to come toa decision.

      Tambu's mother has never been allowed to choose anything. When she asks Lucia “Since when has it mattered what I want?”, it shows how a woman’s life is controlled by her father and then her husband.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is a useful study by Angla et al that investigates the basis of observations made from previous studies where loss of Onecut (OC) transcription factors lead to changes in spinal interneuron populations that do not themselves normally express OC. The authors hypothesize that OC expression in spinal motor neurons has non-cell-autonomous effects on pre-motor interneuron (V1, V2a/b/c) population size and distribution. By knocking out OC in the motor neuron lineage (i.e., downstream of Olig2, a motor neuron progenitor marker gene), they indeed show that motor neuron-specific loss of OC expression decreases V2c interneuron number and alters the spatial distribution of V1, V2a, V2b, V2c populations. Using bulk RNA-sequencing of WT and OC conditional knockout (cKO) motor neurons, the authors identify that neurotrophic factor Ntf3 as another factor that is responsible for the non-cell-autonomous effects on the interneuron population; upon knock out of Ntf3 downstream of Olig2 they show that this leads to increased interneuron numbers and alters their spatial distribution, ultimately leading to dysregulation of spinal motor circuits and motor activity.

      Strengths:

      The authors use sophisticated genetic tools to precisely remove OC and Ntf3 expression in a lineage-specific manner and comprehensively assess the downstream effects across brachial, thoracic, lumbar levels of the spinal cord, as well as at two developmental timepoints, E12.5 and E14.5.

      Weaknesses:

      The evidence supporting their claims is incomplete. In figure 2 and 4, the control distributions (despite reporting the same populations in the same regions) look different, suggesting large sample-to-sample variance in distribution. The authors explain that this is due to several technical limitations in their study.

      Furthermore, the way the Ntf3 results are framed can be misleading; it reads as though one of the main claims of this study is that OC acts through Ntf3.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

      In this study, the authors set out to investigate spatial RNA processing events, specifically alternative splicing and 3' UTR usage, in mouse brain and kidney tissues using ReadZS and SpliZ methodologies on spatial transcriptomics data. The research contributes to understanding tissue-specific gene expression regulation from a spatial perspective. The study introduces a novel approach for analyzing spatial transcriptomics data, allowing for the identification of RNA processing and regulation patterns directly from 10X Visium data. The authors present convincing evidence supporting the identification of novel RNA processing patterns using their methodology, which holds significant implications for researchers in the field of spatial transcriptomics and the study of alternative splicing and 3' UTR usage.

      The conclusions of the study are mostly well-supported by the data; however, certain aspects could be improved to strengthen the findings.

      (1) The conclusions of this study would be strengthened by conducting a more extensive tissue sample analysis and including biological replicates. Additionally, appropriate batch effect corrections should be applied when dealing with biological replicates.

      (2) The 3' UTR usage and alternative splicing should be compared among clearly labeled clusters for a more comprehensive analysis.

      (3) The authors should clarify their rationale for choosing ReadZS and SpliZ approaches and provide comparisons with other methods to demonstrate the advantages and potential limitations of their chosen methodologies.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors present a novel approach to subcellular spatial proteomics by combining laser microdissection with expansion microscopy and LC-MS/MS analysis (SPEx). They implement two different workflows for LMD and LC-MS/MS quantification:

      (1)The standard approach in which an area of interest is cut out by LMD, subjected to proteomics analysis and compared to the rest of the cell without the dissected ROI.

      (2) The subtraction approach in which ROIs are removed and the remaining cellular material is compared to samples containing both the surrounding material and the ROI.

      The authors assess the technique by applying it to subcellular targets of various size, volume and protein compositions such as the nucleus, nucleoli and Golgi. They demonstrate that SPEx can identify proteins enriched or reduced in ROIs.

      Strengths:

      The general, relatively easy and inexpensive nature of this approach, as well as its potential applicability to many cell types and subcellular areas of interest provides an exciting alternative to subcellular fractionation, native immunoprecipitation or genetically encoded proximity labeling constructs. Moreover, by visually selecting ROIs for subsequent analysis, subcellular context or organelle morphology can be taken into account as discussed by the authors in the discussion section.

      Weaknesses:

      The authors addressed our concerns and technical questions in revision.

      A main limitation of the current method is that it relies on isolation of structures of interest in 2D. The authors discuss some alternative approaches that might allow future access to more 3D target isolation.

      There remain several unexplored minor extensions of the technical development of the method, including comparing the proteomes of organelles that are visually distinct, and applying different anchoring procedures to try to increase protein retention.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The study identifies and characterizes a set of amino acid states that make the protein robust to other mutations, to the point of being able to compensate mutations that render wildtype proteins entirely non-functional. The study uses a previously published dataset and uses it to find and study such super-compensators. It then analyzes the biophysics and fitness landscape structure of what may be behind the compensation, identifying stability as an important parameter that, nevertheless, is not sufficient to explain all of the compensatory effect. These findings have important implications for our understanding of protein evolution, with these super-compensators possibly acting in a role of "permissive mutations" and open up evolutionary trajectories that may be closed without them. Perhaps the identification of such super-compensator substitutions can be incorporated into various protein design approaches.

      Strengths:

      The paper presents a compelling case with a rigorous analysis of the expected error rates of observation. While not unique, the current state-of-the-art in the field typically does include experimental error rate estimation like this work. The paper also does a good job in exploring the issue, including looking at plausible biophysical basis of super-compensators.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed all of my concerns in the revision.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors provide a compelling story linking NAD dependent HSD3b6 gene expression in the eyelid to a viscous cycle involving decreased steroidogenesis and AR signaling, pro-inflammatory cytokine release, inflammation, CD38 activation and further NAD+ decline that induces meibomian gland atrophy leading to dry eye disease. The work follows on studies published by the authors in Nature Aging and uses a previously reported HSD3b6 knockout mouse to try and show meibomian gland atrophy, inflammation and CD38+ cell recruitment. Overall the data presented does not appear to support the authors conclusions, and the described interactions seem to be overstated, in that if HSD3b6 was critical to meibomian gland function, one might expect complete loss of the meibomian gland in knockout mice, which is not the case.

      Comments on revised version:

      It should be noted that while the authors indicate the CD38 is significantly up-regulated in the HSD3b6 KO mouse, the increase was not sufficient to show a significant adjusted P-value after revision of the manuscript. Bulk RNA sequencing also shows no significant change in meibum lipid gene expression for aged mice that are treated with 78c, an inhibitor of CD38, that the authors indicate increases NAD levels leading to increased meibomian gland size compared to vehicle treated mice. Unfortunately, there was no increase in meibum lipid gene expression with 78c or with 78c+NMN treatment as identified by adjusted P-value.

    1. https://www.facebook.com/groups/4770669677posts/posts/10164413651119678/

      The Haas Atlas (page 7) would identify the foundry mark as being a Hulse-Typen manufactured Pica face for Smith-Corona: https://archive.org/.../typewriter.../page/n5/mode/2up

      Page 31 of the 1954 Smith-Corona Typewriter Type Styles and Keyboards Catalog would indicate it seems to match up solidly with the Pica Gothic No. 4 typeface: https://typecast.munk.org/.../1954-smith-corona-scm.../ Especially look at the Q, the J, and the 8. The '64 NOMDA guide Mark links is the same, but doesn't have as extensive a typesample.

      Many machines, and especially the American manufactured ones, don't always have foundry marks which line up with the respective catalogs.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      This is a very elegant and experimentally convincing study. Using systematic screening of actin tail formation in two bacterial strains and employing a panel of CRISPR-CAS ko cell lines, the authors identify the dynamin-related GTPases GVIN as antibacterial agent, which forms an oligomeric coat around an intracellular Burkholderia strain. The bacterial O-antigen LPS layer is required for the formation of the GVIN coat, which disturbs the polar localization of the bacterial actin-polymerizing BimA protein.

      The experiments appear of high quality, figures are well prepared, and clean and statistically significant results are provided. I have no criticism on the presented approaches.

      The identification of a novel GBP1-independent pathway targeting intracellular bacteria is not only of fundamental importance for the immunity field, but also of high interest to researchers in other areas, for example, evolutionary or structural biologists.

      Comments on revised version.

      This is a beautiful study.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers, given the substantial revisions completed since the original submission: these have improved the clarity and transparency of the results in a relatively complex study. These changes largely address those concerns raised in review that do not relate to the underlying experimental design and the control of the distinct task conditions.]

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors investigate the impact of rare and extreme events on rodents' decision-making under risk, in gain and loss contexts. They describe the behavior of 20 rats performing a four-armed bandit task, where probabilistic gains (sugar pellets) and losses (time-out punishments) can - in some arms - incorporate extremely large - but rare - outcomes. They report that most rats are sensitive to rare and extreme outcomes despite their infrequent occurrence, and that this sensitivity is primarily driven by extreme loss events which they try to avoid, rather than extreme gains that they seek to obtain.

      They finally propose a modification of standard reinforcement-learning, which features a specific sensitivity to rare and extreme outcomes and can account for the observed behavior.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript really taps into a surprisingly neglected but very relevant aspect of decision-making: the effect of rare and extreme events (REE). The authors have developed an experimental setup that seemingly allows investigation of this aspect, which is not trivial given the idiosyncratic properties of rare and extreme events.

      The parameters of the experimental setup seem also to be well thought off: basically, in the absence of REE, some options are objectively better than others (because, in expectation, they overall deliver more food, or minimize time-out punishments), but this ordering reverses if REE are taken into account. This allows for a clean test of the integration of REE in the rodent's decision-making model.

      The data is presented and analyzed in a very descriptive but exhaustive and transparent way, down to the description of individual rodent's behavior.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The authors did very little to address our concerns outside of written clarifications. While they altered wording to describe Gsb from "pioneering" to "chromatin priming" our stance remains that there is no evidence shown to confirm that Gsb plays a role in chromatin remodelling. (IE while ectopic expression of Gsb results in a different chromatin conformation, there is no evidence that the ectopic expression of Gsb alters an already established chromatin state.) Additionally, the phenotypic experiments show loss of NB5-6 reporter and neuronal markers upon loss of Gsb which confirmed the developmental requirement for Gsb within the endogenous NB5-6 domain, but another striking feature that was described was that loss of Gsb also results in loss of NB3-5 identity. The abrupt change to a new NB lineage made this portion of the manuscript feel a bit disjoined and while this is described as an additional reciprocal phenotype, there are still no sequencing data or other evidence as to how this loss has occurred.

      We disagree that pioneer or chromatin-priming activity should be inferred strictly from single timepoint binding profile. We also disagree that any "remodeling" was shown. To sufficiently show remodeling, one must express a factor at/after a time where the chromatin conformation has been established to be already open/closed and then show the expression of that factor induces conformation changes to the opposite conformation. Otherwise, it is hard to infer whether these chromatin changes are due to the presence of the factor blocking the normal conformational changes that should occur.

      The authors mention they walked back the terminology from "pioneering" to "chromatin priming" and make it clear that Gsb does not act alone to establish the chromatin landscape. We are not sure that this is proper terminology either.

      We mention that the phenotypic data do not align with the sequencing data. The authors added text to clarify the rationale behind each experiment - some being to induce outside of the endogenous domain with clean genetic access while others to obtain information within the endogenous spatial domain.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript the authors study the distribution of the KMT2A methytransferase across the human ribosomal gene loci (rDNA) and the effects of its depletion on rDNA chromatin modification using a KMT2A conditional cell line. They used ChIP mapping data and claim to show that KMT2A depletion does not affect H3K4me3 levels but does reduce acetylation of H3K9 and reduces PCAF (KAT2B) binding. They further claim that KMT2A depletion causes stalling of RNA Polymerase I at the upstream "Spacer" promoter duplication on the rDNA.

      Weaknesses:

      I found the manuscript very confusing. In particular, I found it short on short on experimental detail and I found the data in general to be unconvincing. It is my opinion that the authors overinterpret their data, leading to unrealistic and unsupported claims. The manuscript also avoided discussing relevant recent studies on the regulation of the rDNA and of rDNA chromatin, most citations being to data 15 to 20 or more years old. This is most apparent when discussing the factors such as UBTF and SL1 that determine preinitiation complex assembly and the status of active versus inactive rDNA chromatin. Both have seen significant advances in recent years, and these should be thoroughly discussed.

      Specific comments:

      The authors do not describe the generation of the KMT2A conditional HEK293T cells or their treatment. Since these cells form the basis for subsequent experiments, they must be explained fully. I found that the conditional cell line had already been used in a previous unrelated publication "Chinchole et al. 2022". This manuscript explained that the KMT2A knockout is induced via Dox controlled Cas9 in a HEK cell clone constitutively expressing guide RNAs to KMT2A. The KMT2A knockout requires a 7 day treatment with Dox, leaving wide open the question of direct versus indirect effects of KMT2A loss, and perhaps explaining some of the discrepancies with published data.

      In mapping the interactions of KMT2A across the rDNA by ChIP they use 18 PCR amplicons, some of which the authors inaccurately state as targeting specific rDNA elements. For example, they state Primers (that is, Amplicons) #1-3 target the spacer and core 47S promoters. In fact, amplicon #2 overlaps neither of these promoters and lies centrally within the 1kbp of enhancer repeats between them. Exactly why emphasis is put on KMT2A chipping at these two promoters is anyhow questionable since KMT2A levels (Figure 1) appear equally high at multiple IGS amplicons.

      Discrepancies with published data are particularly apparent in their mapping of H3K4me2, H3K4me3 and H3K9ac, all directly relevant to their conclusions. These modifications have been shown in several publications to map to a single major site a few hundred bp upstream of the spacer promoter in multiple human and mouse cell types. Since the authors fail to monitor H3K4 methylation and H3K9 acetylation at this dominant site they also fail to provide significant evidence that KMT2A in fact affects H3 methylation or H3 acetylation on the rDNA.

      The KMT2A deletion drastically reduces PolI and UBF (UBTF) engagement across the rDNA, and consistent with this, SL1 and RRN3 engagement is reduced as are 47S levels. Thus, whatever the 7-day KMT2A deletion is doing to the cells it is certainly inducing a very significant shut-down of active rDNA. How such an extreme experimental model can tell anything of KMT2A functions is unclear.

      In the last results section, the authors further claim "Loss of KMT2A results in a stalled RNA Pol I complex at the spacer promoter" (Figure 4 and S4). To support this the authors try to map spacer promoter transcripts but mistakenly claim that the amplicon #1 can detect these transcripts. In fact, this amplicon overlaps the Spacer Promoter initiation site and so could not detect transcripts coming from this promoter. Published data, not cited, have demonstrated that PolI stalling at the spacer promoter occurs as a normal phenomenon on the active rDNA. Its loss is associated with suppression, not the opposite as inferred in this manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      The authors examine the relative contributions of SNP and transcriptomic information to predicting trait variation and phenotypic plasticity in switchgrass. Using a diversity panel of 426 genotypes evaluated in Texas and Michigan, USA., this study demonstrates that transcriptomic predictors could outperform genomic markers in predicting environmental differences for traits like biomass yield and tiller count, highlighting the trait-dependent advantage of transcriptomic information over SNPs. However, combining SNPs and transcriptomic predictors generally yielded limited improvement in prediction accuracy.

      A principal limitation of this study concerns the experimental design and the robustness of transcriptomic predictors. With only one transcriptomic sample per genotype in each environment, within-genotype variation in transcript abundance cannot be estimated, making it difficult to distinguish genotype-specific expression responses from individual-plant variation. Unlike SNP genotypic information, which provides a stable representation of a genotype's inherited genetic variation underlying phenotypic differences, transcript abundance is highly sensitive to environmental conditions, developmental stages, and physiological state at the time of sampling. As a result, the stability of the transcriptomic predictors and their predictive performance across independent environments, years, or sampling conditions remain untested. Furthermore, the stability of feature selection across different training populations has not been established, raising additional questions about the reproducibility of the identified candidate genes. Together, these limitations constrain their generalizability and the biological interpretation of transcriptomic associations with phenotypic plasticity.

      Overall, this study provides valuable comparative evidence regarding the predictive performance of genomic and transcriptomic information. Its principal contribution lies in demonstrating that the relative predictive advantages of these information sources are trait-dependent and their integration does not necessarily improve prediction accuracy. While the predictive findings are supported, the biological interpretations extend beyond the evidence presented, as the identified transcriptomic predictors and their interactions do not establish causal genetic effects, epistasis, or direct regulatory relationships. Therefore, the proposed genetic mechanisms and environment-specific interactions should be regarded as hypotheses requiring independent biological validation, rather than established mechanistic findings.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors ask whether Samp1 contributes to the reorganization of the genome and the regulation of gene expression during muscle-cell differentiation. Using C2C12 cells, they find that Samp1 depletion impairs differentiation and is accompanied by altered transcriptional responses and changes in peripheral chromatin and chromosome 8 distribution. These findings support Samp1's involvement in the differentiation program, although the causal relationship between the spatial and transcriptional phenotypes remains unresolved.

      Strengths:

      The study addresses a biologically significant question: how proteins at the nuclear envelope contribute to the coordinated changes in genome organization and gene expression that accompany cell differentiation. Its main contribution is to extend the established requirement for Samp1 in myogenesis to measurable spatial and transcriptional phenotypes, providing a more specific basis for investigating its function.

      The complementary imaging approaches examine chromatin organization at different scales. Fluorescence ratiometric imaging assesses the relative distribution of chromatin reporters across the nucleus, whereas chromosome 8 imaging provides a chromosome-specific measurement. Agreement between these approaches strengthens the observation that Samp1-depleted cells undergo an altered spatial response to differentiation conditions, while leaving the underlying mechanism open.

      The four-time-point transcriptional analysis adds temporal information that an endpoint comparison would miss. It allows readers to examine baseline differences and subsequent responses to differentiation conditions, and provides a potentially useful resource for identifying genes and pathways associated with the impaired differentiation program.

      The work also builds on earlier validation with an independent depletion construct and rescue of differentiation by RNAi-resistant Samp1. This prior evidence strengthens the biological foundation of the present study. Together, the results identify Samp1 as a useful target for further investigation of the relationship between nuclear organization and muscle development.

      Weaknesses:

      The study leaves open how the differentiation, spatial, and transcriptional changes are connected. By day three, control cells have formed myotubes, whereas Samp1-depleted cells largely remain myoblasts. This is a consequence of the depletion and does not invalidate the comparison. However, it means that altered chromosome positioning could contribute to the differentiation defect or arise because differentiation has been disrupted. The authors acknowledge that the mechanism remains unresolved; the findings should therefore be interpreted as evidence that these processes depend on Samp1, without establishing that changes in genome positioning drive the transcriptional response.

      The earlier rescue of differentiation strengthens the evidence for Samp1's role in myogenesis. The new spatial and transcriptional findings, however, have not been tested by rescue. This leaves some uncertainty about whether these particular effects are specific to Samp1 depletion in the stable cell line used here.

      The connection between impaired gene repression and association with the nuclear lamina remains indirect. The published Lamin B1 DamID data describe normal differentiation and do not measure what happens to lamina association after Samp1 depletion. They support the proposed connection but cannot establish it.

      The imaging measurements also need a cautious interpretation. The peripheral chromatin index describes relative fluorescence enrichment, rather than directly measuring heterochromatin abundance. The biological meaning of changes such as an index of approximately 1.1 versus 1.3 is therefore not immediately clear. Similarly, the chromosome 8 analysis measures the distribution of chromosome-paint signal within five optical sections rather than the entire chromosome territory. The results support spatial differences, but their magnitude may depend on nuclear geometry, the sampled sections, and image-processing choices whose influence is not fully assessed.

      Some conclusions about the transcriptional response go beyond what the statistical comparisons directly test. A significant change during differentiation in control cells and a nonsignificant change in depleted cells do not, by themselves, establish that the responses differ. The comparison between groups at day three provides evidence of expression differences, but does not determine whether the changes from their respective starting points differ.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The manuscript combines MspA nanopore measurements with molecular simulations to investigate p53-TAD, its cancer-associated N29K/N30D variant, and its interactions with MDM2 and EGCG. The experiments demonstrate a promising approach for distinguishing sequence- and ligand-dependent single-molecule signals. The manuscript is clearly written, and the use of multiple simulation trajectories is a strength. However, the structural and thermodynamic interpretations extend beyond what the current simulations establish. I recommend addressing the following points.

      (1) The assignment of low-current states to compact conformations near the constriction, and intermediate-current states to more expanded conformations higher in the vestibule, is plausible but not directly validated (Figures 1-2; main text, pp. 4-9). Current blockage can depend on protein position, orientation, charge distribution, and pore contacts as well as compactness. The simulations do not calculate ionic conduction, and the four structural clusters in Figure 2f do not have an established correspondence to the six experimental current states. Could the authors provide a validated conductance calculation for representative configurations, or explicitly present these structural assignments as hypotheses? In particular, an EGCG-associated current level overlapping S4 does not establish that the ligand stabilizes the same structural ensemble sampled by apo p53-TAD.

      (2) Figure 2c-d presents occupancy-derived profiles and regional differences using free-energy terminology. However, the simulations describe finite-duration, constant-force capture trajectories initiated outside the pore, rather than demonstrated equilibrium sampling. Could the authors establish stationarity, evaluate dependence on the analysis window, and explain how the applied bias and normalization are treated? Otherwise, these results should be described as driven occupancy profiles, without interpreting their differences as equilibrium stabilization energies. Similarly, Figure 5 should be clearly identified as a schematic reconstruction rather than a measured molecular free-energy landscape.<br /> The apparent EGCG affinity of 0.43 {plus minus} 0.49 μM also requires cautious interpretation. This value comes from event-frequency measurements at +75 mV and is poorly constrained. Event frequency depends on capture efficiency as well as solution binding populations. At +200 mV, manual voltage reversal censors spontaneous pore-escape times for long-lived complexes; moreover, pore escape and molecular dissociation are distinct processes. Please clarify which kinetic and thermodynamic quantities the assay can establish. The proposed confinement-mediated reduction in the entropic cost of EGCG binding is reasonable as a hypothesis, but is not demonstrated by these measurements.

      (3) The SMD protocol distributes a constant force over acidic residues, restrains the pore, and confines p53-TAD within a cylindrical potential (Figure S12; Supplementary Methods, lines 174-198). These approximations are acknowledged, but their influence on the WT-mutant comparison remains unresolved. The double substitution approximately preserves net charge while changing its distribution, and the force prescription treats acidic and basic residues differently. Do the positional and conformational differences persist across pulling strengths, restraint widths, and alternative force assignments? Please also confirm that the simulated pore contains the mutations present in the experimental M2-MspA-NNN construct.<br /> The selected p53-TAD and MDM2 fragments omit full-length p53 regulation and interdomain coupling. This is a construct limitation, rather than a necessary consequence of the narrow constriction, because capture occurs within the wider vestibule. The existing discussion of wider pores and tethering could be extended to clarify this distinction. Phosphorylation-dependent TAD dynamics would be an interesting future application, although the present states cannot be assigned to modification-sensitive conformers without additional evidence.

      (4) The mutant exhibits increased intramolecular contacts, but the pore-resident radius-of-gyration differences are only approximately 0.2-0.3 Å, with small standardized effects (Figure 2e; Table S1). Several other descriptors have confidence intervals spanning zero, including the bulk Rg difference. Consequently, the simulations support modest sequence-dependent changes more strongly than a pronounced shift in global compactness. Figure S15 also identifies altered protein-pore contacts, which could contribute directly to positional occupancy and current differences. Could the authors provide convergence analyses, trajectory-level uncertainty, and sensitivity to starting ensembles, and distinguish intrinsic compaction from altered pore association?

      (5) The replacement of MDM2-complex events by EGCG-associated events is consistent with inhibition, but differential capture could also change the observed event populations (Figures 3-4). The manuscript acknowledges this possibility on p. 12. Could the authors clarify its implications for the inhibition claim and provide an orthogonal measurement or appropriate controls to distinguish reduced complex abundance from preferential detection? Charge, steric geometry, and pore interactions should be considered without assuming that compaction necessarily explains enrichment.

      No new simulations directly investigate EGCG binding or MDM2 competition. Ensemble-based ligand modeling could strengthen the interpretation, but docking poses or short trajectories alone would not establish preferential binding to S4, binding affinity, or conformational selection versus induced fit. The discussion should place the proposed mechanism alongside prior EGCG-p53 studies, including the computational predictions involving Trp23-Lys24 and Pro47-Thr55 reported by Bahena Culhuac and Bello, 2024. If additional modeling is beyond the scope of this work, the claims concerning S4 stabilization, compaction, and MDM2 displacement should be qualified accordingly.

      Overall, the experimental platform is promising. The principal revision needed is to distinguish the observed nanopore signal changes from their proposed molecular explanations. Targeted robustness tests and appropriately qualified structural and thermodynamic claims would substantially strengthen the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Dila Rizalar, Villaseñor and colleagues report the membrane trafficking steps undergone by CD98hc, a major component of the LAT1 amino acid transporter. They found that CD98hc entered cells through Fast Endophilin-Mediated Endocytosis (FEME) and quickly recycled back to the plasma membrane (PM) together with beta1-Integrin to mediate a stable supply of amino acids and support metabolic homeostasis.

      Strengths:

      The work was planned, executed and analysed to a high standard. A variety of cell models, techniques and assays were performed and combined with mathematical modeling. Appropriate analyses and statistical tests were used to support their conclusions.

      Overall, the evidence provided is convincing.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The proposed endosomal recycling pathway(s) (positive for Rab9, Rab11 and Rab14) is/are not believed to support recycling fast enough (c. 10-20 min) to explain the very short timeframe (c. 1 min) reported by the authors. This apparent discrepancy should be clarified by the authors, ideally with small additional work.

      Notably, the fast Rab4-dependent recycling of TfR directly from Rab5 sorting endosomes has more consistent kinetics (c. 2-4 min, see the classic papers from the Mellman, Maxfield and Zerial labs) and should be investigated or at least discussed.

      (2) LAT1 (and thus possibly CD98hc) were previously reported to enter cells through Clathrin-mediated Endocytosis (CME) upon potent PKC activation (PMA) or entry into cell quiescence (Barthelemy and André, Sci Rep 2019 and Kahlhofer J et al. EMBO J 2025). Interestingly, instead of being recycled back to the PM, LAT1 was then routed to lysosomes for degradation.<br /> Does LAT1 co-traffic with CD98hc along the FEME - fast endosomal recycling loop identified by the authors?

      If so, the authors could discuss the physiological context in which the whole transporter shifts between the 2 routes (FEME-recycling in steady-state maintenance and CME-Lysosome upon acute signaling? There is a precedent in EGFR for such variation in endocytic fates upon signal strength).

      If not, the authors could discuss why the 2 chains would traffic differently (in such a scenario: CD98hc through the FEME-recycling arm and LAT1 through CME-Lysosome).

      (3) The study would benefit from mechanistic insights about the molecular details linking CD98hc to FEME.

      Specifically, identifying motif(s) and/or adaptor(s) binding to the main FEME adaptors (Endophilin A1, A2 or Bin1) would be a valuable improvement of the work and would provide a strategy to design a point mutant version of CD98hc that would be unlinked to FEME.

    1. Reviewer #3 (Public review):

      This manuscript focuses on the presence/origin of directional memory during epithelial cell migration. It starts by analyzing single cells and then moves to more complex systems (confluent layers and scratch assays). The paper first demonstrates that the migration in all of these systems is well-described by persistent random walks which likely emerge from fractional Brownian motion. This is an important demonstration, as it implies orientation memory in the systems. Then the paper proceeds to attempt to discern the origin of this memory and claims to establish key roles for adherens junctions and vinculin dimerization. While for the most part the manuscript is well-written, there are some signification overinterpretations in experimental results. The largest issue is demonstrating the role for vinculin dimerization, which is not a well-studied phenomena inside living cells, as all data is reliant on a single point mutation (Y1065E).

      (1) Likely the most significant issue with the manuscript is the interpretation of the vinculin Y1065E variant and the assumption that the only defect the mutations causes is a lack of dimerization. Vinculin dimerization is mediated by a conformational change in the vinculin tail domain induced by F-actin binding (Thompson, FEBS Letters, 2013). Dimerization of the vinculin tail domain has been clearly demonstrated in in vitro systems involving purified proteins, as the authors point out in the manuscript. However, the dimerization of full-length vinculin has not been well characteristic in living cells. There are several reasons to suspect dimerization is potentially not prevalent in cells. For instance, in the presence of other actin binding proteins, there may not be sufficient available binding sites available on neighboring actin filaments to facilitate dimerization. Additionally, pY1065 vinculin and vinculin Y1065E have been associated with increased vinculin activation (Huang, JBC, 2014), so other effects seem possible. While the Y1065E variant clearly has an effect on the tension sensor readout and vinculin dynamics, further experimental evidence is needed to show that these effects are due to lack of dimerization in living cells. Perhaps most importantly, the vinculin tension sensors used in this study have been used extensively in knock-out systems and intermolecular FRET has not been observed (PMID: 20613844, 33335089, 30523675). To justify the definitive claims made in the manuscript, the authors likely need to develop, or employ, an assay for detecting vinculin dimerization in living cells. The authors could choose between intermolecular FRET, proximity labeling assays (i.e. antibodies with DNA for signal amplification), bimolecular fluorescent complementation (i.e. split GFP) based approaches, or some other approach. It should be noted that working with full length vinculin, not just Vt, and designing assay that can incorporate vinculin Y1065 variants (Y1065E and potentially Y1065A/F) would strengthen results. Also, the authors should be aware that the observation of strong dimerization may invalidate the use of FRET-based tension sensors in this system or at least necessitate intermolecular FRET control experiments.

      (2) A major conclusion in the manuscript is that in response to overexpression of a specific vinculin constructs, focal adhesions behave the same in single cells, confluent cells, and collectively migrating cells for all the mutants but Y1065E. However, outside of the FRET measurements, there is not much evidence to support this claim. The authors should perform a greater comparison of the focal adhesions between the systems used in the manuscript (single cell, confluent cells, collectively migrating cells). Key measurements would include focal adhesion number per cell, focal adhesion size, focal adhesion orientation, vinculin dynamics (e.g. FRAP), focal adhesion stability, and some indicators of focal adhesion composition. For the last aspect, focusing on focal adhesion components that also have roles in adherens junctions, such as VASP, seems appropriate. Without such characterization, it is an overinterpretation to assume that focal adhesions are the same in each system and, therefore, effects are due to vinculin behavior in the adherens junctions.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors studied the development of hippocampal connectivity gradients based on open datasets and performed correlation analyses with other MRI features as well as gene expression information from other datasets. Although the main findings are correlational and cross-sectional, the analyses are overall sophisticated and replicated in several datasets.

      Strengths:

      The hippocampus is a key region in understanding large-scale brain organization and cognition, and the authors applied advanced and suitable analytics to study its development. The paper is overall well-organized and well-written, and the findings are relevant for studying large-scale brain development.

      Weaknesses:

      While sophisticated, several of the analyses appear mainly correlational, cross-sectional, and rely on cross-dataset contextualization, which should also be stated as a limitation of the current work.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers.]

      Summary:

      The authors set out to investigate how well the onset of a self-initiated movement could be predicted at different times prior to action onset. To do so, they collected EEG and MEG data across 15 human participants who watched natural landscape images on a screen. These participants performed active self-initiated movements, or observed passive actions, to have a new image appear. By comparing the neural activity prior to active and time-matched passive actions, the authors found that even though a build-up of neural activity is visible close to 1s prior to action, action onset could only be reliably predicted around 100ms prior to action. These results confirm what was already suggested in previous literature: the commitment to action is only clear from the late stages in the visible neural ramp-up to action onset.

      Strengths:

      (1) The paper presents a well thought out methodology to assess the predictive value of neural activity prior to a self-initiated movement and passively observed action, while keeping all other experimental factors identical. This methodology can be applied outside the specific scope of this paper as well, in efforts to assess the correspondence of a neural signature with an observed behavior.

      (2) The results are a strong confirmation of what was suggested less clearly in previous research (Trevena & Miller, 2010, Consciousness & Cognition; Schmidt et al., 2016, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews; Travers et al., 2020, NeuroImage).

      Comments on revised version.

      I thank the authors for addressing my concerns in the Introduction and Discussion of their paper. I don't require any further edits at this point.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Niu and colleagues tackle several questions concerning the assembly of the heterotetrameric kinesin-1 complex, comprising kinesin heavy chains (KHCs) and kinesin light chains (KLCs), its interaction with adaptor proteins (the mitochondrial adaptor TRAK2), and the implications of these interactions for kinesin autoregulation.

      Broadly, the study comprises four parts; strengths and weaknesses are described for each in turn.

      First, the authors examine the coiled-coil interface that enables tight binding between KHC and KLC. Binding-site mapping supports previous observations that KHC and KLC interact through the CC3 region of KHC and the amino-terminal coiled-coils of KLC. These regions are modelled using AlphaFold3, and the resulting models are used to inform mutagenesis experiments that identify critical residues within the hydrophobic core of the interface. Although the binding site has previously been reasonably well defined, both biochemically and using computational models, this work extends those findings to individual residues at the interface and provides supporting biophysical analysis. This provides useful experimental validation of the computational models and important tools for the field to enable the selective uncoupling of KHC and KLC.

      Second, the authors examine how the mitochondrial adaptor TRAK2 interacts with KHC. Previous studies have defined the critical regions of KHC CC4 and TRAK2 reasonably well, and the authors' biochemical mapping broadly supports these findings. They extend this through biophysical analysis and computational modelling that proposes a 2:2 stoichiometry and an interesting assembly in which CC4 separates to enable formation of a four-helix bundle with TRAK2. This AlphaFold model is supported by biophysical, biochemical, and cell-imaging analyses, including the identification of point mutations that disrupt the interaction. These findings are important because the molecular basis of KHC CC4 interactions with diverse cargo adaptors has remained somewhat opaque, and this study begins to place these interactions on a firmer molecular footing. Some of the principles proposed here may also extend to other KHC-binding adaptors.

      Third, and of particular interest, the authors examine the interplay between KLC and TRAK binding to KHC. This is important because previous work has generally favoured the view that mitochondrial transport is independent of KLCs, although some studies disagree. Whether KLCs are excluded from TRAK-containing complexes and vice versa and, if so, how this occurs has remained unclear. The authors provide evidence suggesting that the extended coiled-coil region of KLC, outside the direct high-affinity KHC-binding interface, modulates CC4 to prevent TRAK binding, suggesting that KHC-TRAK and KHC-KLC complexes may be mutually exclusive. Precisely how this mechanism translates into transport regulation within the cell remains unclear, but the effort to establish a structural hypothesis for understanding this interplay is valuable.

      Fourth, the authors provide evidence for a novel, weak interaction between CC1 and CC4 that they propose may contribute to kinesin-1 autoinhibition and its regulation by KLC and TRAK-an 'autoinhibitory latch'. I found this part of the work more preliminary because, although the biophysical and biochemical analyses provide some support for such an interaction, unlike other aspects of the study, it is less well supported by computational modelling or mutational analysis. Moreover, there is no direct evidence for how this interaction might function in the context of full-length kinesin-1 autoinhibition, for example through assays of motor activity or conformational state, and the proposed model is not particularly clear with respect to full-length KLC (including its TPR domains) or regulation by MAP7.

      Taken together, the study makes a valuable contribution to our understanding of several facets of kinesin-1 assembly, cargo recognition, and regulation. Key strengths lie in the complementary biochemical, biophysical, computational, and cell-imaging approaches used to support most of the key findings, together with the definition of several very useful point mutants that should inform future work.

      There are, however, some general weaknesses surrounding unnecessary or overstated claims of novelty and the connection to prior work, and some factual errors. These can be straightforwardly addressed through better integration of the existing literature into the narrative, without detracting from the authors' contributions. Some conclusions appear to extend beyond the available data, and these should be tempered accordingly. Computational models should also be presented more thoroughly and systematically, together with confidence metrics and multiple ranked outputs. The Methods should more clearly describe the constructs and sequences used so that the work can be straightforwardly reproduced, alongside information on replication and additional quantification. Some clarification around measured stoichiometries and the authors' interpretation for some of the short coiled-coil fragments will also be important.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Nakatani and De Schutter conduct an in-depth computational investigation of astrocyte electrophysiology. Utilizing a conductance-based NEURON model with realistic astrocyte morphology, the study replicates both in vitro and in vivo experimental protocols to characterize local and global depolarizations of the astrocyte membrane. The findings indicate that bath-applied (global) potassium stimuli induce membrane potential changes that follow the potassium equilibrium potential throughout the cell, whereas localized potassium stimulation disrupts this behavior. In the latter case, the local response is governed by the ratio of local conductances. The authors further analyze the observed electrical compartmentalization to identify which molecular components directly affected by synaptic stimuli - such as potassium clearance, glutamate transport, and GABAA and NMDA receptors - could plausibly generate this effect under physiological conditions. The study concludes that perisynaptic astrocyte processes (PAPs) can respond to specific synaptic inputs in an electrically isolated manner, exerting minimal influence on the soma.

      The central prediction - that astrocyte processes can be electrically compartmentalized from the soma under local synaptic stimulation, while bath stimulation produces a globally uniform response - is both interesting and surely significant for understanding and measuring astrocyte electrophysiology. However, the manuscript's incomplete model description and disorganized Results section hinder assessment of how well the conclusions are supported. Addressing these issues could render the model a valuable resource for the community and a useful framework for guiding and interpreting voltage-imaging experiments in astrocytes.

      Strengths:

      (1) The study addresses a timely, long-standing question and may pioneer a multiscale approach to quantifying astrocyte electrophysiology beyond the traditional view of an electrically passive, isopotential glial syncytium. The findings are consistent with recent voltage-imaging evidence of localized depolarization in astrocyte processes.

      (2) A key strength of the study is the use of a state-of-the-art, morphologically realistic compartmental model that captures both somatic and peripheral dynamics. This approach addresses spatial and temporal resolutions that are challenging to achieve experimentally.

      (3) Simulating both in vitro-like (bath perfusion) and in vivo-like (local, synapse-driven) stimulation protocols within a unified framework may explain discrepancies observed between experimental results obtained under these differing conditions.

      (4) The model predictions are benchmarked against experimental voltage-imaging data, and the systematic analysis of individual molecular contributors-including potassium channels, glutamate transporters, and synaptic receptors-yields testable predictions.

      (5) The topic is relevant to a broad and multidisciplinary audience, including researchers in glial biology, synaptic physiology, and computational neuroscience.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Terminology and clarity

      The manuscript relies heavily on jargon and abbreviations, which impedes readability. The central concept of a "Nernstian" depolarization or response, introduced in the title, is unconventional and not explicitly defined. It appears that "Nernstian" refers to a membrane potential that follows the potassium Nernst potential (EK) of the astrocyte. This terminology is ambiguous, as the analysis is restricted to K+ and does not ensure that the astrocyte response excludes contributions from other ion Nernst potentials.

      Furthermore, "Nernstian" reflects a modeling choice rather than an alternative such as the Goldman-Hodgkin-Katz formalism. Additional terms in the abstract, including "a variety of biochemicals," "astrocyte peripheries," "isolated peripherals," and "empirical" model, are also ambiguous. Because these terms are central to the main claim, they may confuse readers.

      (2) Framing of the research question

      The introduction is brief and does not clearly articulate the research question or the manner in which the study addresses it. The motivation, which should draw on cell anatomy (including the gap-junction-coupled syncytium), molecular composition, and stimulation protocol, is underdeveloped, and the knowledge gap is not explicitly identified.

      (3) Incomplete model description

      Model design, parameters, and stimulation protocols are often not described or justified, and references are missing (e.g., for K2P, TREK1/TWIK1, and the Na+/K+ pumps). In particular:

      a) it is not explained how the three ionic species (Na+, K+, Cl−) needed to account for synaptic currents interact and are modeled in the extracellular and intracellular spaces, nor how they contribute to the astrocyte membrane potential;<br /> b) the diffusion formulation (Equation 9) neglects any tangential component of diffusion, an approximation that is left unjustified;<br /> c) gap junctions are modeled as ohmic currents driven by the potential difference between astrocytes, but the network arrangement, location, and distribution of the coupled astrocytes and of the gap junctions in the simulations are not specified;<br /> d) the analytical results (Equations 46-50) are not obviously derived from Equation 16, and the essential derivation steps are missing;<br /> e) it is unclear whether and how the voltage indicator ArcLight is modeled when comparing simulated traces with experimental fluorescence data.

      Overall, the simulation setup lacks clarity, which limits reproducibility and impedes evaluation of the study's conclusions.

      (4) Organization and rationale of the results

      The Results are difficult to interpret owing to unclear organization and an ambiguous rationale. The derivation and application of the scale parameter ΓK (Equation 1) are unclear; in particular, its dependence on axial conductance appears inconsistent with the assumption that intracellular diffusion does not influence PAP responses (cf. van Egeraat et al., Biophys. J. 1993).

      (5) Unsupported or missing results

      Several statements are not supported by the data presented: some claims could not be matched to any evidence (e.g., L104-106), results described in the text could not be located in the figures (L159-164), comparisons are reported as "data not shown" (L140-143), and the source of the "realistic ECS sizes" (L191-194) is unclear. The authors do not demonstrate the validity of the extracellular K+ perturbation used to mimic action potentials.

      (6) Presentation of figures

      The figures are often crowded and stylistically inconsistent. Most importantly, in Figures 3, 4, and 6, the rendering of the noisy experimental data obscures the simulation results they are meant to benchmark, making it difficult for readers to assess agreement between model and experiment.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary

      In "Mouse models with human antibody repertoires for inducing multiple lineages of HIV-1 broadly neutralizing antibodies", Tian et al. report the production of 6 humanized mouse models to support HIV-1 vaccine design studies aiming to induce different classes of broadly neutralizing antibodies.

      These mice were designed to express immunoglobulin genes of human bNAbs targeting four different conserved epitopes of the HIV-1 Envelope while allowing the development of CDRH3 and CDRL3 diversity during gene rearrangements.

      Strengths:

      (1) The manuscript is clearly written, and findings are clearly presented with self-explanatory figures. The Introduction and Discussion sections provide very valuable context to understand the relevance of these mouse models and are accessible to a general reader. It is appreciated that the data are presented with transparency, highlighting both strengths and weaknesses of the mouse models.

      (2) The characterization of the mouse models is overall thorough and rigorous. Immunization data to confirm functionality are not presented; however, it is understandable that this information will be presented in the context of subsequent studies. The authors indicate that these mice have been distributed to different teams.

      (3) These mice will be very valuable tools for the HIV-1 vaccine community to evaluate vaccine candidates in a "closer-to-human" setting that allows a certain level of polyclonality while using human immunoglobulin genes.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The authors investigate the use of the knocked-in human immunoglobulin genes in heavy chains and light chains and provide the frequency of productive rearrangements using these genes. However, there is no information about the frequency of the right heavy-light chain pairs. This information would be important to calculate the real frequencies of potential bNAb precursors in these mouse models.

      (2) The authors use HTGTS-rep-seq to investigate immunoglobulin gene rearrangements at the genomic DNA level. This method is very useful for analyzing gene recombination because it provides information about both productive and non-productive rearrangements. However, this method does not provide information about BCR expression, and it is not optimal for investigating repertoire composition. BCR expression would provide a more rigorous characterization of the mice and confirm functionality.

      (3) The goal of this study was to produce models that could provide a diverse bNAb-like repertoire. Specific quantification of the diversity of the repertoire is not provided. The study does not provide information about the sequences that do not use the intended genes.

      Overall, the availability of these humanized mouse models will be very valuable for the HIV-1 vaccine community and will provide valuable pre-clinical models to advance the design and testing of vaccine candidates.

    1. 2 Partial deletion Deletion of exon 1 and 2 1 0

      GroupID: 2

      DiseaseAssertion: VHL

      Group size: 1

      GroupNumberMales: N/A

      GroupNumberFemales: N/A

      GroupEthnicity: N/A

      GroupAgeRange: N/A

      Group Info: Retrospective analysis of a longitudinal cohort of 21 VHL germline mutation carriers and retinal haemangioblastomas. All patients were categorized in two genotypic categories: missense mutations and truncating mutations.

      GroupPresentingHPOs: HP:0009711 (retinal capillary hemangioma)

      GroupHPOFreeText: The patient presented with retinal capillary hemangioma.

      GroupNotHPOs: N/A

      GroupNotHPOFreeText: N/A

      GroupPreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: Table S1

      Variant: Exon 1-2 deletion

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: cDNA level information: c.(?_1)_463+?del

      MutationType: exon_loss_deletion

      CivicName: Exon 1-2 deletion

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study explores the role of Dynamin 2 (Dnm2)-mediated clathrin-mediated endocytosis (CME) in the fate determination of neural progenitor cells in the embryonic cerebral cortex, with particular attention to its asymmetric regulation of ligand and receptor functions in the Notch signaling pathway. Using conditional knockout mice, in vitro co-culture systems, in utero electroporation, and luciferase reporter assays, the authors propose that Dnm2 is required for neural stem cell maintenance and that CME plays a dual role in Notch signaling.

      Strengths:

      The authors systematically demonstrate the critical role of Dnm2 in embryonic cerebral cortical development. They show that Dnm2 is the predominant dynamin isoform expressed in the embryonic central nervous system, and that its conditional knockout disrupts ventricular zone (VZ) architecture, causes premature depletion of radial glia (RG), and leads to precocious neurogenesis, accompanied by periventricular hemorrhage and perinatal death.

      Weaknesses:

      I believe that some conclusions of this study should still be treated with caution. Specific comments follow:

      (1) scRNA-Seq analysis of the Dnm2-cKO cortex at E11.5 and E13.5 is needed, or alternatively, additional LGE-MGE scRNA-Seq should be performed, to examine whether the key gene expression changes are conserved across the MGE-CGE-LGE and cortex.

      (2) Regarding Figure 5 (Loss of Dynamin 2 leads to abnormal accumulation of Dll1 and altered NICD distribution in the E11.5 cortex), I do not understand why Dll1 accumulation occurs primarily in the medial cortex.

      (3) A detailed schematic model is needed to illustrate the function and mechanism of action of Dnm2.

      (4) Dnm2-cKO exhibits extensive cell death and vascular abnormalities. The authors should explain the possible specific causes.

      (5) Clinical relevance: Are there specific forebrain phenotypes associated with Dnm2 mutations in humans? What are the possible reasons? This study appears to have limited relevance to Dnm2-related human disease.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary and Strengths:

      In this manuscript, the authors continue their efforts to characterize metabolism-related phenotypes and molecular changes in Down syndrome mouse models, with a focus on Ts66Yah in the present study. Because the phenotypes described are relevant to metabolic abnormalities observed in individuals with Down syndrome, these findings are important. In addition, Ts66Yah is a relatively new model generated by removing the triplicated region of Mmu17 from Ts65Dn, which is not syntenic to Hsa21. Thus, Ts66Yah retains the triplicated region of Mmu16 that is syntenic to a region of Hsa21, carried on an extra chromosome.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Figure 3 and Figure 10: The authors should offer a possible explanation for why the GTT and ITT differences between Ts66Yah and wild-type males observed under chow conditions are no longer evident under HFD conditions. The statement in the Abstract that "both male and female Ts66Yah mice share a common phenotype of pronounced glucose intolerance and insulin resistance" appears stronger than the data support. Under chow conditions, impaired insulin sensitivity by ITT is observed in males but not females. Moreover, although the Abstract states that glucose intolerance and insulin resistance are further exacerbated by HFD, the GTT and ITT abnormalities under HFD appear to be predominantly observed in females, whereas the genotype differences are no longer evident in males. The Abstract should therefore be revised to more accurately reflect these sex- and diet-dependent effects.

      (2) Figure 7B: In the female liver PCA plot, PC1 is labeled as explaining 13.2% of the variance, whereas PC2 explains 21.6%. Since principal components are ordered by decreasing explained variance, PC1 should explain greater variance than PC2. The authors should verify whether the axis labels or percentages are correct.

      (3) Figure 14 legend: A cutoff of log2FC > 0 was used, whereas Figure 8 uses a log2FC cutoff of 0.5. The authors should explain the rationale for using different thresholds in the two analyses.

    1. Joint Public Review:

      Kitanovski and colleagues compare TCRβ repertoires from paired primary tumors and sentinel lymph nodes from 24 treatment-naive melanoma patients. The paired design and comprehensive repertoire analyses are important strengths, and the study provides solid evidence for differences between these compartments, including reduced diversity and greater clonal dominance in primary tumors.

      The principal limitation is that antigen specificity is inferred from bulk TCRβ sequencing rather than directly demonstrated. Database annotation and sequence similarity are useful for generating hypotheses, but neither an annotated β-chain nor membership in a sequence-similar community establishes antigen specificity. In particular, the absence of a database match should not be interpreted as evidence of neoantigen recognition. Claims concerning neoantigen specificity should therefore be moderated or supported by additional evidence.

      The ClustIRR analysis is potentially useful for identifying relationships among predominantly private TCR repertoires, but its added value and robustness require further evaluation. Benchmarking against conventional repertoire-overlap or alternative TCR-similarity approaches, testing sensitivity to key clustering parameters, and determining whether the results are driven by highly abundant communities would substantially strengthen the analysis. HLA genotype and the non-independence of pairwise repertoire comparisons should also be considered when interpreting inter-individual repertoire similarity.

      Overall, the study provides a valuable dataset and convincing evidence for spatial differences in melanoma TCR repertoire architecture, while the biological interpretation of individual TCRs and communities in terms of defined antigen or neoantigen recognition remains less well supported.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Damphousse, Calvin and Redish recorded from dorsal hippocampus in rats running past a robotic predator to reach food. They re-analyzed the cohort from Calvin et al. (2025, PLoS Biol) and added a new cohort. They compared three behaviors: retreats right after an attack, mid-track aborts (MTAs) where the rat turns back without being attacked, and mid-track continues (MTCs) where the rat pauses and then carries on. The authors report that retreats and MTAs, though both end at the nest, differed in speed and in decoded position. During retreats, decoding stayed near the attack zone. During MTAs, it was weighted more toward the nest and the far end of the track. Pauses that ended in an abort showed more decoding of the attack zone than pauses that ended in continuing, and a similar difference was seen on the way out, before the pause.

      The main contribution is conceptual. Separating fear-like escape from anxiety-like withdrawal within the same task is a real step beyond showing that the hippocampus represents threat. The task places the robot, the attack threshold and the reward at different points on the track, which makes the decoding easier to interpret. Figs. 5-7 use the same analysis layout, so the comparisons are easy to follow. The main patterns are seen in both cohorts, even though the cohorts differ in several procedural details.

      The revision tightens the abstract, clarifies how epochs were defined and normalized, and acknowledges that the results are correlational. Overall, the data support the main conclusion that hippocampal representations differ between reactive and anticipatory responses to threat. The paper should interest people working on hippocampus, defensive behavior and approach-avoidance conflict, and the task offers a good way to study how threat and reward are weighed against each other.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Charonitakis and co-authors characterize dishabituation in adult flies, where they use olfactory habituation to octanol, then dishabituate the flies with disruptions of electric shock or yeast odors. They systematically investigate the neurotransmitters and neural circuits involved in dishabituation and figure out a lot about how this process works in the brain, as an independent circuit. I like the paper and I like the very structured approach to figuring out the problem.

      Strengths:

      The introduction nicely sets the stage for the work presented, bringing in knowledge from other organisms and motivating the study.

      The results section lays out a logical set of experiments, using a common set of behavioral assays in many flies exposed to thermogenetic or optogenetic manipulation. The paper systematically figures out the necessity and/or sufficiency of specific brain regions and neurotransmitters, culminating in a new understanding of how the important process of dishabituation works.

      I like the bar graph representation for the data throughout, with the helpful icons - if a paper figures are going to be 90% bar graphs it helps when they are super clear like this. And I like how the all the parts build up to the conclusion in the last figure, nicely summarizing the thorough characterization of dishabituation.

      Weaknesses:

      There are no major concerns, and I appreciate the addition of a new figure that details the habituation / induced dishabituation protocol, along with additional discussion of dishabituation, and framing the topic for a more general audience.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript describes how defective food grinding due to loss of TGF-beta signalling leads to fat loss via specific neuropeptides and their cognate receptors in C. elegans. They define transcriptional mechanisms from the ADL sensory neuron to neuropeptide relays from neurons to the gut, wherein enzymatic effectors mediate fat metabolism. The genetic evidence presented to support this neuropeptide circuitry is based largely on transcriptional changes detected in bulk mRNA, cell-type-specific rescue, and lipid measurements using Nile Red staining in permeabilized/fixed animals and with lipidomics. The findings are of interest to researchers in neuropeptide regulation of physiology.

      Strengths:

      (1) The multifaceted analysis of dbl-1 and sma-6 provides good evidence that the primary defect leading to metabolic phenotypes is due to pharyngeal function.

      (2) The transcriptional survey of neuropeptide expression under fasting and in TGF-beta pathway mutants will be a useful resource for many labs studying neuropeptides in food sensing.

      (3) Outlining the process from dietary restriction to fat metabolism in the gut provides a big-picture view that establishes physiological relevance.

      (4) Identifying new functions for specific neuropeptides and their receptors in fat metabolism.

      Weaknesses:

      Evidence that links NLP-10-NPR-35 signalling to FLP-18-NPR-4 is weak, and primarily rests on overlaps in npr-35 and flp-18 expression, as well as rescue of flp-18 under the npr-35 promoter. It remains possible that FLP-18 acts from those neurons, but is not activated by NPR-35 signalling, since the mechanisms downstream of NPR-35 are unclear in this context. Strengthening this link would require showing a change in FLP-18 activity; for example, showing npr-35-dependent changes in flp-18 transcription in npr-35-expressing neurons.

      The expression patterns of the neuropeptides and receptors that guide the sites of cell-specific rescue experiments are from well-fed animals. However, it remains a possibility that starvation alters neuropeptides and their receptors are expressed, which would produce a different circuit.

      Different food levels produce different physiological and transcriptional responses. The manuscript largely assumes that starvation is equivalent to food reduction when they are physiologically distinct states.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript describes results from a series of experiments designed to test different facets of the gating model and potential alternative explanations. In most respects, the results are squarely inconsistent with the gating model. Some of the authors' attempts to test the model force the authors to define the model in greater detail than even the model's proponents typically do. That is a revealing exercise in itself, which is well worth bringing to the field's attention. The manuscript is well written for the most part, and figures illustrate results clearly.

      Strengths:

      The gating model states that pauses in the activity of a select subset of SNr neurons disinhibit (i.e., "open the gate" to) a specific desired action, whereas a larger population of SNr neurons increase their firing so as to suppress other potentially conflicting actions. Selection of different actions is performed by the generation of pauses and increases in activity in different subsets of SNr neurons. Contrary to that prediction, the authors report that SNr neurons that show a reduction in firing for one action tend to show reductions in activity for other actions as well and, similarly, increase-type neurons tend to show increases for all of the actions examined. The authors tested the generality of these observations across a series of experiments that compared activity between markedly different actions (moving forelimb vs. tongue), similar actions (different directions of forelimb movement) and several forms of self-directed and spontaneous movement. Moreover, the authors examined the activity of anatomically identified subsets of SNr neurons that innervate forelimb and orofacial sub-regions of the superior colliculus. Combined, the series of experiments described here provide overwhelming evidence against any straightforward "simple" form of the gating model of basal ganglia function.

      Weaknesses:

      The most important limitations of the manuscript actually arise from additional ambiguities of the gating model - ambiguities that may be worth mentioning in the manuscript. For example, how granular is the action selection process supposed to be? Perhaps the SNr circuits examined in the present study are selecting "actions" defined at a level that the authors did not examine. This is not a major limitation, however, given the concerted effort invested in testing different levels of granularity and contexts. This relates to another ambiguity of the model in that basal ganglia output does not affect actions directly, but only indirectly via its influences on downstream multi-synaptic neural circuits.

      Another ambiguity of the model is how to interpret the activity of neurons that don't respond. In other words, are comparisons of decrease- and increase-type responses the appropriate comparisons to make to test the model? The present study compares decrease- vs. increase-type responses, but perhaps no-response and increase-type neurons should be lumped together. After all, the simplest version of the action selection hypothesis (cf. Hikosaka) considers the high baseline tonic activity of SNr neurons to be action suppressive by itself, without an additional task-related increase. A comprehensive action selection model should include an explanation of the relative roles of non-response and increase-type responses. The current manuscript would benefit from a discussion of this ambiguity and a rationale for the decisions the authors made to make the model testable.

      A third ambiguity of the model is how to interpret graded changes in SNr firing rate. It comes as no surprise that the authors observed slow ramp-like changes in SNr firing rate prior to movement initiation in the absence of an immediate sensory trigger. The authors interpret these ramp-like changes as being equivalent (from the perspective of the gating model) to the abrupt changes in firing rate observed around the time of initiation for movements that are sensory-triggered. But the simple gating model presents basal ganglia output as having only three states: no-change, pause, and increase. Implied in the model is that these changes in firing rate influence not only what action is performed but also when it is performed. It is not clear that slow ramping responses qualify as "open the gate" disinhibitory temporally-abrupt signals. The manuscript could provide more explanation concerning the position the authors take to make ramping responses fit into the gating model.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Movements, including reflexes, can undergo changes during development. This is the case for the angular vestibulo-ocular reflex in many species, including the Xenopus laevis frog. This study aimed to study the underlying mechanisms by which this reflex matures during development of larval Xenopus laevis using electrophysiology and electron microscopy. Their electrophysiological recordings of the motor axons of the abducens motor nerve during evoked angular vestibulo-ocular reflex reveal that a subpopulation of abducens motoneurons, those that are silent rather than spontaneously active, increase their firing rate and modulation during the angular vestibulo-ocular reflex during development. Furthermore, electron microscopy imaging of the developing abducens motor nerve shows increased myelination. Light microscopy reveals increased innervation of the lateral rectus muscle

      Strengths:

      Recordings during the evoked angular vestibulo-ocular reflex enable assessment of activity of motoneurons during the movement. Recordings done at specific developmental stages reveal convincing changes in modulation of firing of silent motor units that are distinguished by their high-amplitude spikes in nerve recordings. Microscopy, both electron and light, provide strong evidence for increased myelination of the abducens motor nerve and innervation of the lateral rectus muscle.

      Weaknesses:

      The authors did not provide data showing why the silent motor units became more responsive with development. Is it related to maturation of the sensory inputs to these neurons or changes in intrinsic properties?

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The authors investigate a previously described behavior of sexually immature female Drosophila melanogaster, wherein immature females flick their wings in response to male courtship. They record, analyze, and characterize the auditory signals generated by these wing-flicks and show that these sounds reduce male courtship song and copulation attempts. The study combines several techniques including behavioral observations, acoustic analysis, developmental experiments, sensory manipulations, and neuronal manipulations to investigate the stimulus dependence and neural basis of this behavior. Amidst all the literature on sexual communication, this study uniquely addresses an interesting question on communication during sexual maturation, providing valuable insights on why and how sexual maturation could be signaled.

      A major strength of the study is its behavioral and acoustic measurements with manipulations of sensory input and identified neurons. Comparative analysis of immature wing-flick, male-male aggression, and male courtship song was equally interesting. The developmental analysis also provides a clear temporal relationship between female maturation, wing flicking, and mating receptivity. Together, these experiments provide compelling evidence that immature female wing flicking is a reproducible behavior in response to male courtship, and that it significantly reduces male copulation attempts. Identifying a defined population of neurons that coordinate this response behavior further supports this study.

      However, it must be pointed out that some of the broader conclusions extend beyond what is directly demonstrated. In particular, while the evidence supports the interpretation that wing flicking functions as a rejection or deterrence signal from sexually immature females, the designation of this behavior as a signal of "asexuality" and the proposed evolutionary relationship between female wing flicking and male agonistic wing flicking are less firmly established. Furthermore, I think the similarity in acoustic structure and the involvement of related neuronal populations is not sufficient to conclude a) that the two behaviors share an evolutionary origin or b) that one behavior evolved through modification of the other. Similarly, proposed explanations concerning energetic costs, predation risk, and adaptive benefits should be presented as hypotheses rather than conclusions unless directly tested. These interesting points can be included in a subsection "Ideas and Speculation", to clearly distinguish directly demonstrated effects and evolutionary or mechanistic interpretations.

      In conclusion, the study contributes to our understanding on communication during sexual maturation.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Proctor et al. developed the COB (chloroplast outer-envelope beta-barrel) database, a resource for identifying, classifying and structurally analysing chloroplast outer envelope beta-barrel proteins, built by combining sequence search, machine-learning classification, structural prediction and similarity-based database expansion. The scale and accessibility of the resource is a genuine strength, and it will be useful to researchers working on chloroplast protein import, outer envelope membrane biology and membrane protein evolution. However, several of the manuscript's central claims are not adequately supported by the data presented.

      First, the classifier's negative training set consists entirely of non-transmembrane beta-barrel proteins, so its reported accuracy does not demonstrate reliable discrimination from other protein classes (like alpha-helical membrane proteins). The similarity-based expansion that substantially grew the database demonstrates only internal consistency among related sequences, not independent validation, and errors in the seed set will propagate through it. By design, this approach also misses divergent beta-barrels, as the author's own recovery of OEP40 and TOC159 outside the classifier illustrates. This is important because the authors identify the evasion of divergent barrels from these types of tools as a gap in the field. For these reasons, the database should not be described as "comprehensive".

      Second, the structural conclusions and the biological implications made substantially outpace the evidence. The reported prevalence of "open" barrel conformations is, for now, a feature of the AlphaFold predictions, not a demonstrated biological phenomenon, and the authors themselves note these may be artefactual. Similarly, the hybrid-barrel analysis is built almost entirely around TOC159-family proteins, which are heavily overrepresented in the Arabidopsis input set. The manuscript does not test whether this apparent "universal" interaction is anything more than a compositional artefact of that enrichment, and most of the novel interactions have only moderate confidence scores. As framed, both the title and multiple statements in the text assert a general topology of "open and hybridized" for this group of proteins that only experimental data can establish.

      Third, the evolutionary comparisons between Streptophyta and Chlorophyta, and between chloroplast and bacterial beta-barrels, are presented as robust differences but are not supported by any formal statistical treatment of proteome size, taxonomic sampling or phylogenetic non-independence.

      Overall, the database and classifier are a valuable contribution for further exploration and experimental validation of chloroplast outer envelope membrane beta-barrel proteins, but the manuscript's broader structural and evolutionary claims need to be substantially tempered, and the title changed, to match what the data actually show.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Maeda et al. propose an algorithm for meta reinforcement learning (Meta RL) that they term "hybrid deep reinforcement learning" (HDRL), which combines two distinct learning mechanisms: one that occurs through continual synaptic plasticity (via backpropagation-through-time), and the other that occurs through recurrent dynamics (i.e., in-context learning). The standard approach to Meta-RL, which I will refer to here as "RL2", is one that involves learning only through recurrent dynamics; this model has found recent application to understanding meta reinforcement learning in the brain. One downside of RL2 as a model of meta-learning in the brain is that, in learning only through recurrent dynamics, RL2 essentially throws the baby out with the bathwater by assuming synaptic plasticity does not have a role in moment-by-moment learning. This study therefore makes a valuable contribution in showing how both synaptic plasticity and recurrent dynamics can be combined in a single model. Importantly, this model does not require an explicit mechanism for mediating between these two learning mechanisms; rather, the authors show that the task (and meta-task) itself determines which mechanisms the model comes to rely on. They then show that their HDRL model can better explain differences in behavioral strategies across conditions of a perceptual decision-making task, and use in silico perturbations to establish that these differences in strategies are due to the distinct contributions of their model's two learning mechanisms. Finally, the authors provide evidence that the neural population activity of mice recording during each task has a consistent structure as the activity of artificial neurons in their HDRL model, but not to the standard RL2 model, which always relies on learning through recurrent activity. This study offers an important extension of the standard method for Meta RL, to one that is both more biologically plausible (i.e., because it seems unreasonable for plasticity to only occur periodically as it does in RL2) and more computationally interesting (i.e., as it explains how these two distinct learning strategies may be deployed automatically based on task demands).

      The paper's conclusions seem fairly well supported by their analyses; however, there were a few details that need to be clarified.

      (1) There are many architectural differences between the H-DRL vs RL2 model, which precludes a true comparison between the two models solely on the addition of Weight RL. The implementation of H-DRL is relatively stripped down compared to RL2, in terms of using Elman rather than LSTM, standard RL vs A2C, only positive activations allowed, and Q-learning instead of policy gradient. Because of these implementation details (none of which seem essential to the 'real' difference between these models), it is difficult to know exactly how these models differ. E.g., if the differences in behavior are in part due to the differences in architecture between HDRL and RL2 rather than to the differences in learning mechanisms.

      (2) The conclusion that mouse behavior is more consistent with HDRL than with RL2 seems likely but is not sufficiently supported by the analyses. One thing I wondered was whether all model instances were truly converged; RL2 will of course take much longer than HDRL to learn since it is only updated per session. The authors' claim that mouse behavior is more like HDRL than RL2 seems to be based on the BIC comparison in Figure 2f, but insufficient detail is given to understand what this analysis is. Figure 2e, by comparison, seems to present all three models as similar (though this comparison is difficult to make given the different y-axes).

      (3) The interpretation of the two-step task feels incomplete, and potentially in conflict with the interpretation of HDRL in the rest of the paper. When trained on the two-step task, HDRL is presented as reproducing a mixture of model-based and model-free behavior. What does the RL2 model do in this context? Later, on the perceptual decision-making task, HDRL seems to be presented as being model-based-like (and using recurrent activity) in one context and model-free-like (and using plasticity) in the other. Is it the case that in the two-step task, HDRL is simply doing both? As is, it's unclear to me how I should interpret the analyses related to the two-step task.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      "A comparative single-cell transcriptomic atlas for diverse populations of vertebrate hair cells" by Basu et al. aims to define pan-hair cell enriched (HCE) genes across hair cell subtypes from four vertebrate species through integration of published scRNA-seq, SMART-seq, and single-nucleus RNA-seq datasets. Pan-HCE genes are weighted using AUC values, where AUC is used to identify genes enriched in hair cells relative to supporting cells. The resulting dataset is made publicly available, allowing researchers to compare gene expression across species. The dataset integration and creation of a public resource are clear strengths for the inner ear community.

      Strengths:

      This manuscript presents a valuable cross-species resource and a substantial integration effort.

      Weaknesses:

      Weaknesses addressed by the authors in the text include the lack of human cochlear scRNA-seq comparisons to mouse/chicken cochlear hair cells. While the rationale that the datasets were not available at the time of investigation is acceptable, the use of human cochlear datasets would be the ideal experimental comparison to mouse and chicken cochlear hair cells.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study develops a large-language-model implementation of the complementary learning system (CLS) framework for continual episodic learning. The authors employ a pretrained open-weights model to serve as a neocortex-like semantic knowledge store and introduce a novel hippocampus-like memory system in which each episode is assigned its own sparse rank-2 masked LoRA adapter, eliminating interference at encoding. A separate semantic embedding model provides a retrieval key for each episode, and winner-take-all routing selects the adapter whose stored embedding best matches an incoming cue. The reported storage efficiency of approximately 2-3 trainable parameters per token suggests that this one-adapter-per-episode scheme could scale to large numbers of memories, although its total storage requirements also include the embeddings used for content-addressable retrieval.

      A key finding is that successful encoding of an episode does not guarantee flexible access to its contents. Although a correctly selected adapter can reconstruct its stored episode, the model performs poorly when asked to answer questions about that episode directly. The iRAG procedure addresses this by inserting the reconstruction into the base model's context. Consolidation through replay of the original passages enables reconstruction without adapters, but direct question answering remains substantially less successful, even with richer training objectives. Overall, the paper provides a technically impressive implementation of episodic memory in LLMs. However, several aspects of its learning and consolidation procedures significantly limit its correspondence to CLS, as discussed below.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of this work is the concrete parametric implementation of a CLS-like division of labor within a modern transformer network. The episodic memory system incorporates key properties of the biological hippocampus, including pattern-separated encoding and content-addressable retrieval. The interaction between the selected adapter and the LLM provides an appealing functional analogue of hippocampal-cortical reinstatement, in which activation of a sparse episodic trace biases distributed cortical processing so as to reconstruct the mnemonic content of an episode.

      A second strength is that the model cleanly separates interference during episodic storage from interference during retrieval. By assigning memories to non-overlapping parameter traces, individual episodes remain faithfully stored even at large memory loads. Performance declines for more strongly overlapping memories can therefore be attributed largely to competition during retrieval. This distinction shows that successful pattern separation does not by itself guarantee reliable access to stored memories.

      A final strength is the careful optimization and evaluation of the episodic memory system. The authors introduce a masked LoRA that substantially reduces parameter cost relative to standard LoRA approaches, systematically identify the most parameter-efficient placement of these adapters, and show that storage cost scales approximately linearly with episode length, with similar results across two base models. They also test the framework on two datasets with quite different memory structures: largely independent, topically diverse Wikipedia passages and more strongly correlated autobiographical episodes with recurring people, places, and themes.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The model implements the two learning regimes motivated by CLS: pattern-separated episodic learning and slower learning in shared weights. However, it does not implement the central proposed interaction between them, whereby hippocampal traces reinstate experiences that serve as training events for neocortical consolidation during offline periods (e.g., Káli & Dayan 2004, Nat. Neuro.; Singh et al. 2022, PNAS; Sun et al. 2023, Nat. Neuro). Instead, consolidation here relies on replaying the retained ground-truth passages and therefore does not depend on the episodic memory system at all. The authors could either demonstrate consolidation driven by replay from the episodic adapters or more explicitly discuss this simplification and its implications for the CLS comparison.

      (2) The authors characterize the episodic system as implementing "fast learning" or "rapid storage". However, encoding involves repeated optimization on the same passage, with up to 1,000 epochs per attempt and potentially multiple retraining attempts. This raises questions about its correspondence to the rapid, single-shot learning that characterizes the hippocampal component of CLS and is supported by evidence in the trisynaptic pathway (e.g., Nakazawa et al. 2003, Neuron; Nakashiba et al. 2008, Science). The authors should (a) report the distribution of optimization steps, retraining attempts, and mask sizes required for successful encoding on the two datasets and (b) clarify this distinction when relating the model to biological hippocampal learning. They could also examine whether larger adapters reduce the optimization required, clarifying the trade-off between storage efficiency and encoding speed.

      (3) Relatedly, it is unclear whether there is meaningful variability in the number of optimization steps required across episodes and whether characteristics of the passages explain this variability. For example, do passages containing less predictable content require more training and/or larger adapters? One way to examine this would be to consider the frozen base model's pre-learning perplexity for each passage and test whether this predicts optimization steps to criterion or final parameter count, controlling for passage length. Such an analysis could help clarify what determines the difficulty and resource cost of forming a new episodic memory.

      (4) The consolidation results raise concerns about the model's capacity for stable lifelong learning, as incorporating new memories comes at a cost to existing knowledge. The presented consolidation for 1000 memories produces substantial degradation of the base model's existing capabilities, particularly under the conditions that most improve direct access to consolidated knowledge. In a lifelong setting, subsequent consolidation would presumably continue to cause interference not only for pre-existing semantic knowledge but also for memories incorporated during earlier consolidation cycles. The alternation between NREM and REM sleep has been proposed as one biologically motivated solution to this problem, with NREM supporting integration of recent hippocampal memories into cortex and REM helping to reactivate and protect pre-existing cortical knowledge (Norman et al. 2005, Neural Networks; Singh et al. 2022, PNAS). The authors already note that a lifelong system would need to interleave encoding and consolidation and determine which memories to replay; it would also be valuable to discuss how previously consolidated knowledge and broader base-model capabilities could be protected across repeated cycles of consolidation.

      (5) It appears that the consolidation conditions reported in Fig. 9 might differ substantially in training exposure. As described in Supplementary Note 5, "passage-only" uses one example per episode, "paraphrase augmentation" uses ten, and the "knowledge instruction" and "masked reconstruction" conditions add many further training examples. Because training is specified in epochs, could the authors clarify whether these conditions are matched for optimizer steps or training tokens? If not, it would be helpful to determine how much of the improvement in direct QA and accompanying loss of base-model capabilities reflects the specific objectives versus greater training exposure. A step- or token-matched control would help disentangle these possibilities.

      (6) The reported storage efficiency of approximately 2-3 parameters per token appears to refer only to the masked LoRA adapters, despite each episode also requiring a stored 1,024-dimensional embedding for routing. The authors appropriately note that this index is part of the memory system's storage cost and is in fact substantially larger than the adapter store. It would therefore be useful to incorporate the routing embeddings into the reported per-token storage estimate, or otherwise report the total storage cost per episode/token alongside the adapter-only figure.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study describes targeting Poltheta Helicase with a new drug RP-3467. The properties of the drug and a clinical response in a gBRCA1 Ovarian Cancer Patient with a mutation in TP53BP1 are described.

      Strengths:

      This is an important and interesting set of observations.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The response of the patient with a TP53BP1 mutant tumor is of interest but requires more clarification before solid conclusions can be drawn. The presence of the TP53BP1 mutation after but not before olaparib treatment is suggestive of selection, but in the absence of demonstration of a biallelic loss, this is conjecture. It could be a co-selected passenger mutation. The authors should report the TP53BP1 variant allele fraction, LOH, and orthogonal validation should be performed by targeted deep sequencing or ddPCR. This would establish the prevalence before and after selection and enhance the interpretation of the functional effects of the mutation observed.

      (2) To further strengthen the proposed mechanism, the authors should consider knocking in the mutation (or a similar LOF mutation) into an appropriate cell line and establish resistance to olaparib and sensitivity to the combination, as well as each drug individually. This will address the latter question of whether it is the poltheta inhibitor or the combo that is responsible for the clinical response.

      (3) In the animal experiments, "synergy" is overstating the situation. Without an interaction analysis, this is an enhanced combination activity. Also, several of the animal experiments have a small N. It would be better to show the growth of tumors in individual mice.

      (4) The authors propose that Poltheta inhibition could prevent the emergence of reversion mutations. This is not addressed in the paper, and if they want to suggest this, they should provide some evidence.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      This manuscript by Zhou, Williams, Millner, and colleagues reports findings from a large-scale, multicenter study of Klebsiella pneumoniae (Kp) isolates. These isolates were sequenced using short-read sequencing and extensively characterized using a variety of field-appropriate tools, such as Kleborate, AMRFinderPlus, and PlasmidFinder. Then, the authors measured the growth of these Kp isolates across many (>200) environmental conditions they pre-determined as important for making human-centric fitness conclusions. These genotype and phenotype data were integrated, and the authors deployed an association-based strategy to identify genetic determinants of the observed fitness effects. Finally, the authors built models to predict fitness outcomes using the associated genetic determinants. From these data, the authors conclude that fitness is "an emergent property" of a given Kp isolate's genetic background and environmental constraints, with a nod toward the future development of biomarkers to predict fitness outcomes using genotype alone.

      The primary strength of this study is the integration of two large datasets, one genotypic and the other phenotypic. This approach is novel in its scale (genotypic, geographic, etc.), which adds to the strength of the overall conclusions. These conclusions, for the most part, are consistent with the data. As such, this study can act as an example to other studies tying genotype to phenotype, especially in the context of careful genetic analysis and rational phenotypic design. A secondary strength is that the findings are supported by other, smaller-scale studies such that there is a growing consensus as to the general fitness determinants employed by Kp that are potentially driving its increased global importance as a bacterial pathogen.

      The primary weakness of this study is that some confounding factors are not taken into account or are deemphasized. The primary confounding factor is that the associations between genetic signatures of fitness are not fully considered. This is especially important given that an important driver of Kp fitness is its accessory genome, which is heavily influenced by mobile genetic elements and plasmids. The use of short-read sequencing leads to an inherent inability to tie fitness effects to such genetic elements, which may lead to masking or overinterpretation of particular genotype-phenotype relationships. For example, nearly all of the gene-level determinants of condition-specific fitness and pleiotropic genes are known plasmid-associated genes; however, it is unclear if these specific genes are driving fitness or if they are merely signatures of other associated genetic elements. This broadly weakens the conclusions and translatability, and in the absence of long-read sequencing to resolve genetic architecture, it is an unresolvable weakness. A second is the over-interpretation of the variables used to assess bacterial growth, which is the primary fitness metric. Colony opacity can be influenced by Kp capsule production, which is a highly variable trait that is associated with environmental conditions. Finally, it is unclear whether clonal isolates are excluded to avoid overinterpretation of fitness outcomes.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is an interesting study that explores how human RPE could be used as source for new retinal neurons. This is a welcome addition to the field of retinal regeneration which is currently focused almost exclusively on the regenerative capacity of Muller glia cells. The line of inquiry is firmly rooted in findings from amphibian and embryonic chick model systems and advances a fetal human retina RPE based screening system as a rich resource for insights into human RPE biology, including as a potential stem cell source.

      The authors investigate the potential of fetal human RPE cells to be reprogrammed into retinal neurons using overexpression of pro-neural factors. While this is a critical knowledge gap in the field of retinal regeneration with significant promise for developing regenerative therapies, several methodological concerns impact the interpretation of results. Firstly, while the authors sought to evaluate factors that enhance RPE reprogramming when co-expressed with ASCL1, nearly all co-expression constructs tested failed to achieve appreciable expression of ASCL1, leaving a central hypothesis of this study largely untested (Major concern 1). Second, although the authors were able to detect a cluster of photoreceptor-like cells in their screen, they were unable to identify which reprogramming construct generated this cluster (Major concern 2). Finally, an essential control that definitively demonstrates the value of combinatorial transcription factor reprogramming is missing (Major concern 3). In summary, the authors establish a valuable new paradigm for culturing and reprogramming fetal human RPE, and even more importantly, demonstrate successful reprogramming to neural fates. However, the discussion and interpretation of results needs to be modified significantly to make it clear that (i) the outcome of many co-expression paradigms remains effectively unknown/untested due to failed over-expression of ASCL1, and that (ii) the reprogramming construct giving rise to photoreceptor-like cells could not be conclusively identified from their initial screen.

      Strengths:

      (1) Powerful new screening system advanced for exploring the regenerative potential of human feta RPE cells.

      (2) Co-expression vector system for testing additive effects of proneural transcription factors

      Weaknesses:

      Major concerns:

      (1) The authors executed a screen for combinations of factors that can enhance ASCL1-mediated reprogramming of RPE into retinal neurons. However, the expression level of ASCL1 was remarkably low in virtually all co-expression paradigms (see Fig. 3C). Notably, the reprogramming combination with the highest potency (ASCL1 + NEUROD1) was also the one exhibiting the highest level of ASCL1 expression. The "failed" reprogramming of most of the co-expression constructs (ASCL1+LMO1, ASCL1+EZH2, and ASCL1+RAX2) is potentially a false negative resulting from low transgenic expression of ASCL1.

      (2) The authors interpretation is that the overexpression of NeuroD1 and Ascl1 generated a new cluster that expressed markers of photoreceptors such as RXRG and RCVRN (see Figure 3D). However, there does not actually appear to be any overlap between the ASCL1+NEUROD1 cluster (orange dots, left panel) and the cells expressing markers of photoreceptors (yellow/green/purple?/black? dots, right panel; yellow being ASCL1-EZH2, green being ASCL1, purple being ASCL1-and black being control - though color coding here is admittedly somewhat confusing). Thus, the photoreceptor-like cluster of interest actually seems to correspond to gray cells that were unmapped / exposed to an unknown programming cocktail. So, it remains completely unknown which reprogramming construct generated this cluster.

      (3) To conclusively establish the additive role of NEUROD1 in reprogramming, it would be prudent to compare ASCL1 + FA directly to ASCL1+NeuroD1+FA. This control was not included but is needed for a more complete interpretation of results.

      Comments on revised version.

      We thank the authors for their thoughtful responses to our concerns and for modifying a figure to improve clarity. However, we were disappointed to see that the responses to our major concerns were not incorporated into the revised manuscript, as we believe they provide context that is essential to proper interpretation of the data. Minimal revisions of the current manuscript would address our first two major concerns. This could be achieved by adding two additional sentences, for example incorporating the sentences below which are excerpted from the authors response to our concerns:

      The following excerpt from the authors response would address major concern 1 if incorporated into the relevant section in the main text of the manuscript:

      "Insufficient ASCL1 expression in the combinations might have led to lack of reprogramming, representing a false-negative result."

      And this excerpt would address major concern 2:

      "The farthest subcluster with highest RCVRN/RXRG expression was not assigned ASCL1-NEUROD1 identity."

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors investigate chemical strategies to disrupt the interaction between the SARS-CoV-2 accessory protein Orf9b and the host mitochondrial receptor Tom70, an interaction implicated in suppression of type-I interferon responses. They employ two discovery approaches: a crystallographic fragment screen against the Orf9b homodimer and a high-throughput fluorescence polarization screen for compounds that compete with Orf9b binding to Tom70. The study identifies fragment-binding hotspots on Orf9b, develops lipidated analogs that stabilize the Orf9b homodimer, and discovers Tom70-binding compounds with low micromolar activity that inhibit Orf9b binding in vitro.

      Strengths:

      Impressive amount of work using a variety of complementary approaches and methods to validate binding (FP, SPR, and computational modelling and SAR). The combination of crystallographic fragment screening on Orfb9 and HTS on Tom70 provides two independent routes for perturbing the Orf9b-Tom70 interaction. The structural work seems to be of very high-quality. The fragment campaign is extensive, yielding a substantial number of fragment-bound structures and identifying biologically meaningful binding hotspots on Orf9b.

      Finally, the screen results in reporting useful chemical starting points. Although potency remains modest, the study provides tractable scaffolds and a clear framework for future optimization.

      Comment on revised version.

      I don't have any further comments. The authors have addressed my suggestion by adding a statement for future work in the discussion.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers.]

      Summary:

      The main goal of this manuscript is to develop a mathematical model of the regulation of cortical dynamics by Cdk1 activity to explain why, in some embryos (e.g., Xenopus), surface contraction waves are believed to move in the same direction as Cdk1, while in other embryos (e.g., starfish) they are believed to move in the opposite direction.

      Strengths:

      (1) The paper addresses a very important question.

      (2) The mathematical model is sensible and suggests that the different relationship between Cdk1 and surface contraction waves might arise from the different behavior of the mitotic entry wave and the mitotic exit wave.

      (3) The authors propose a mechanism by which the wave observed at mitotic exit might not passively follow the trigger wave observed at mitotic entry'

      (4) The proposed mechanism is a potential explanation of the observed differences.

      (5) The proposed mechanism is centered on different dynamics between the nucleus and the cytoplasm, highlighting the potential importance of the nucleus (and nuclear size) in organizing cortical dynamics.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The proposed mechanism works if the activity in the nucleus is much higher than the high activity (high state of the bistable system) of the cytoplasm. So, as the wave propagates across the cytoplasm, the activity around the nucleus remains higher, which potentially causes a delay in the onset of Cyclin B-Cdk1 degradation in the region around the nucleus compared to the surrounding cytoplasm. This effect happens over a typical length scale, and if such a length scale is comparable to embryo size, this becomes the predominant mechanism. However, such a mechanism should exist near the nucleus independently of embryo size. So, it seems that for embryos where the wave back and wave front should travel together, nuclear activity must be adjusted not to be much higher than cytoplasmic activity. Is there any experimental evidence that the overall activity of Cdk1 is higher in the nucleus than in the cytoplasm?

      (2) The authors give the existence of trigger waves as a fact. While the predominant view is that such waves exist in the first cycle of the Xenopus embryos (however, this is from measurement of the cortical contractions, so a bit circular for this paper), it is unclear if waves exist in the starfish embryo, so the potential explanation that the starfish embryo simply has different Cdk1 dynamics cannot be ruled out.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers.]

      The study provides a robust bioinformatic characterization of the evolution of pT181. My main criticism of the work is the lack of experimental validation for the hypotheses proposed by the authors.

      Previous comments on the study:

      (1) One potential reason for the decline in pT181 copy number over time may be a high cost associated with the multicopy state. In this sense, it would be interesting if the authors could use (or construct) isogenic strains differing only in the state of the plasmid (multicopy/integrated). With this system, the authors could measure the fitness of the strains in the presence and absence of tetracycline, and they could be able to understand the benefit associated with the plasmid transition. The authors discuss these ideas, but it would be nice to test them.

      (2) It would be interesting to know the transfer frequencies of the multicopy mobilizable pT181 plasmid, compared to the transfer frequency of the plasmid integrated into the SSCmec element (which can be co-transferred, integrated in conjugative plasmids, or by transduction).

      (3) One important limitation of the study that should be mentioned is that inferring pT181 PCN from whole-genome data can be problematic. For example, some DNA extraction methods may underestimate the copy number of small plasmids because the small, circular plasmids are preferentially depleted during the process (see, for example, https://www.nature.com/articles/srep28063).

      Comment from the Reviewing Editor:

      In the revised version the authors have addressed comment 3 from Reviewer #1 through additional analysis, finding that the decline in copy number over time remains significant after controlling for instrument used, type of DNA extraction technique, and sequencing centre. The suggestion in Comment 1 from Reviewer #1 has not been acted upon as the authors state that this additional experimental work "goes beyond the scope of the paper" and is being explored for a future study. Similarly, the suggestion in Comment 2 from Reviewer #1 has not been acted upon as the authors state that "inferring these rates from natural sequence data is not feasible in this case given the low heterogeneity of the plasmid sequence. A laboratory-based experimental study could not address the real transfers we observe over the course of decades, as in vitro S. aureus transfer rates are often not good proxies for in vivo".

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript reports exceptionally preserved, millimeter-scale segmented bilaterian microfossils from the Fortunian Kuanchuanpu Formation in South China. The authors propose that these non-biomineralized animals were preserved through microbial pseudomorphs rather than direct phosphatization, filling a critical taphonomic and evolutionary gap in early animal segmentation.

      Strengths:

      This paper filled the critical taphonomic and evolutionary gap in early animal segmentation.

      Weaknesses:

      Extremely similar work has already been published by Xian et al., 2026, PNAS, with specimens from absolutely the same formation, and they also proposed that these animals are segmented. So in this context, this work's significance is eclipsed.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors employed Cryo-ET to visualize the structural organization of the tripartite attachment complex or the TAC, which is a unique structure connecting the flagellar basal body to the mitochondria in Trypanosoma brucei, a protozoan parasite causing human sleeping sickness in sub-Saharan Africa. The TAC is essential for segregation of the mitochondrial DNA, or kDNA, via the connection to the segregating basal bodies during the cell cycle. Although molecular characterization of the TAC and its components has yielded insights into the function of the TAC, the structural organization of the TAC, especially the largest protein p197 within the TAC, remains poorly defined. Using intact zoid cells, the authors provided, for the first time, a high-resolution image of the cytoplasmic part of the TAC in its native context, resolved the basal body, the mitochondrial membranes, the exclusion zone filament connecting the BB to the outer mitochondrial membrane, and quantified the geometry of the region surrounding the TAC. These observations led to a proposed role of p197 as a length-variable connector to reconcile stable kDNA anchoring with the mechanical demands of BB movement. Overall, the work advances our understanding of the structure and function of p197 within the TAC in trypanosomes.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of the manuscript is the application of Cryo-ET in imaging the structure of the cytoplasmic part of the TAC, with a focus on the largest protein p197, which provided novel insights into its molecular function. Trypanosome cells are too thick for Cryo-ET, and the authors adopted intact zoid cells for Cryo-ET, allowing the resolution of the TAC structure in native conditions.

      Weaknesses:

      While this is the first attempt to image the TAC by Cryo-ET, which provided new insights into the potential role of p197 in mediating the connection between the BB and the mitochondria, there is a lack of mechanistic understanding of how p197's length is regulated and how the varying length of p197 coordinates with basal body movement. Also, it is unclear why the cell needs to regulate the length of p197, given that the main function of p197 is to connect the BB and the mitochondria for the segregation of kDNA via the BB.

      The proposed length variation for p197 is an interesting idea, but it is unclear what exactly the authors meant by saying that p197 is length variable. Do they mean that the central repeats in p197 can fold/extend to variable lengths, or do they mean that p197 with variable lengths contains different numbers of the central repeats? This should be clarified.

      The current work can be strengthened by performing some molecular and/or biochemical experiments to assess the function of p197 to complement the Cryo-ET-based structural characterization reported in the manuscript. Expression of some smaller-sized p197 proteins with varying numbers of central repeats in p197 RNAi cells will provide evidence for the proposed function of p197 length variation.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Ribeiro et al. investigate the molecular mechanisms affecting the efficiency of synthetic cell-penetrating peptide (CPP) uptake by cultured mammalian cells. CPPs are frequently coupled to cargoes that can change cell function and are highly useful to investigators studying cell biology. Moreover, CPPs are potentially amenable to delivery of cargoes that can affect cells in clinically useful ways, with several under investigation as potential anti-cancer treatments. A challenge to the therapeutic use of CPPs is their inefficient delivery to their intended molecular targets, with poor cellular uptake being a major barrier.

      The present study presents new insights into the cellular and plasma membrane properties that can affect CPP uptake. In the studied cell line, the authors find that cell cycle-dependent changes in the plasma membrane potential correlate with uptake of a CPP conjugated to a fluorescent dye. These changes correlate with mRNA abundance of a voltage-gated potassium channel, KCNH1. RNA silencing of KCNH1 expression or pharmacological blockade of KCNH1 currents impairs CPP uptake, supporting the proposed model.

      Strengths:

      (1) Identified KCNH1 expression and function as a specific modulator of CPP uptake in U2OS cells and LAN1 cells.

      (2) Data show a clear correlation between the plasma membrane potential, cell cycle stage, and efficiency of intracellular CPP delivery in these cells.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Some of the claims are more generalized than warranted by the presented evidence. Is KCNH1-dependent modulation of cell cycle-dependent changes in the plasma membrane potential and ensuing effect on CPP uptake a niche property of this channel in some cell lines? Or a more broadly generalized function? I think this can be addressed merely through more careful or caveated language in the manuscript. However, an additional experiment that would be potentially informative and complementary to the chronic high-potassium depolarization experiments would be to examine the impact of heterologous expression of a hyperpolarizing potassium channel (for example, Kir2.1).

      (2) Please provide more details on how endosomes were identified and measured.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors have carried out a study of lipid membrane permeabilities on different nucleoside/tide isomers. The study primarily relied on PAMPA as the experimental technique for assessing permeabilities, although interestingly, the authors found that there was a correlation between permeability and retention time on a C18 column. The authors specifically looked at the permeabilities of furano and pyrano alpha/beta nucleosides/tides, since a major question is why biochemistry uses only the beta furano isomers, when three other isomers based on anomeric configuration and ring size are also possible. The authors found that for all A, U, G or C nucleoside isomers, the beta-furanoside is consistently the most lipid-permeable. These findings were also supported by computational (DFT and MD) studies. The authors conclude that such a property could plausibly have been a chemical selection mechanism that favoured these isomers when they first started interacting with protocell membranes.

      Strengths:

      There are two major strengths to this study: (1) it offers an alternative/additional explanation backed by experimental and computational evidence as to how the canonical ribonucleotides (namely, the beta-furanoside isomers) were selected by interactions with protocell membranes; (2) it makes the important observation that retention time on a C18 column is correlated with permeabilities determined by PAMPA, the "industry standard", suggesting that LC could also be a convenient way to assess relative permeabilities of analytes of interest. With this report, there are many promising follow-up studies that can be carried out in the context of synthetic lipid protocells in order to further support the hypothesis that selective permeability played a major role in early chemical/Darwinian evolution.

      Weaknesses:

      The biggest weakness is that there needs to be more of a critical discussion of chemical vs Darwinian selection. There are two basic hypotheses for how the canonical ribonucleotides came to be: they were the products of prebiotic synthesis and chemical selection pressures, or they emerged as a product of natural selection after Darwinian evolution already became established. While the experimental evidence in terms of ribonucleotide prebiotic synthesis is discussed well, the work of Eschenmoser in particular, which supports the alternative hypothesis that RNA is the product of Darwinian evolution, should be discussed in more detail on page 4.

      The authors should also acknowledge somewhere in the discussion/conclusion that there is a certain amount of bias that the field has towards extant biology, and this bias could be influencing how certain results are interpreted as beneficial for ribonucleotide selection, when the same result might be used to argue against it. For example, the fact that the 2',3'-cyclic phosphates are the most permeable among the phosphate regioisomers might be used to argue these were the preferred substrates for oligomerization in a protocell, given it had a catalyst which could do it, like a short peptide. While the differences in permeabilities are quite solid, what it means in terms of selection could be applied to multiple, specific scenarios, each with its own interpretations and implications.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors studied the development of hippocampal connectivity gradients based on open datasets and performed correlation analyses with other MRI features as well as gene expression information from other datasets.

      Strengths:

      The hippocampus is a key region in understanding large scale brain organization and cognition, and the authors applied advanced and suitable analytics to study its development. The paper is overall well organized and well written, and the findings are relevant for studying large-scale brain development.

      Weaknesses:

      While sophisticated, several of the analyses appear mainly correlational, cross-sectional, and rely on cross-dataset contextualization, which should also be stated as a limitation of the current work.

      Comments on revised version.

      I thank the authors for their revisions which have improved the paper.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors build a connectome-scale resource for studying mitochondria in the Drosophila Hemibrain. The authors segment and classify millions of mitochondria, quantify their size, abundance, appearance, and spatial relationship to synapses across thousands of neuron types, and extend neuPrint so that these organelles can be queried together with neuronal connectivity. The analyses identify substantial mitochondrial variation across cell types, systematic differences between pre- and postsynaptic mitochondrial organization, associations with neurotransmitter class, and changes in mitochondrial properties with synaptic fan-out.

      Strengths:

      The scale and accessibility of the resource are the major strengths of this work. The mitochondrial annotations are integrated with an established connectomic dataset and can be queried through neuPrint, which should make the study useful to researchers beyond the immediate biological questions addressed here. The manuscript also describes the underlying data model and how mitochondrial information is linked to neurons and synapses.

      The manuscript compares mitochondrial organization across multiple levels, including individual cells, cell types, brain regions, synaptic polarity, neurotransmitter class, and synaptic fan-out. Several descriptive results are particularly clear, including the tendency for mitochondria to be closer and larger at presynaptic than postsynaptic sites and the identification of cell-type-specific patterns.

      The biological interpretations are generally placed in the context of prior experimental literature on synaptic energy demand, calcium handling, and mitochondrial positioning. In many places, the authors appropriately use cautious language such as "may," "possible," and "consistent with," which helps distinguish mechanistic hypotheses from direct measurements. The cited literature therefore provides a reasonable biological framework for interpreting the structural observations, even where the corresponding physiological variables are not measured in this specimen.

      The authors also acknowledge important limitations of the Hemibrain sample, including incomplete neurons, regional differences in reconstruction quality, and the fact that the analysis represents a single physiological snapshot. The public code and data infrastructure further increase the utility and reproducibility of the study.

      Weaknesses:

      The dataset has extraordinary cellular coverage but derives from one Hemibrain specimen. Claims about "natural ranges," generality across Drosophila neurons, or organizational principles extending beyond this specimen should therefore be phrased with some caution. This is particularly relevant for cell types represented by only one or a few instances. For example, MBON13 is represented by a single cell in this dataset, so its unusually high mitochondrial investment is well supported for that instance, but variability of this property within the cell type cannot be assessed here. This is consistent with the authors' own acknowledgement in the Discussion that detailed conclusions for individual cell types may require larger numbers of cells.

      The mitochondrial appearance classes support several biological conclusions, particularly the differences associated with brain region and neurotransmitter class. The manuscript describes how dark, medium, and light training labels were generated and reports strong validation of mitochondrial detection and nearby-mitochondrion recall, but I could not find a corresponding independent validation of the three appearance labels themselves. Some assessment of classification reproducibility, for example using a held-out manually assessed set, a confusion matrix, or inter-annotator agreement, would strengthen confidence in conclusions that depend on these categories.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      This study addresses an important question: whether dopaminergic activity in Drosophila functions as a general value signal across behavioral contexts. Its main strength is the breadth of the experimental program, combining multiple DAN driver lines, several operant paradigms, rescreening, and more targeted follow-up experiments. The cross-paradigm design is well suited to test whether self-stimulation effects generalize.

      The main weakness is that several conclusions extend beyond what the experiments directly establish. The genetic tools define populations rather than the same identified neurons at single-cell resolution. In the key time-course experiments, the data more clearly support a reduction of initial avoidance toward neutrality than a consistent aversive-to-appetitive sign reversal. Similarly, the non-contingent comparison uses continuous pre-exposure rather than a stimulation-history-matched open-loop condition; it therefore shows that simple non-contingent exposure is insufficient, but does not isolate agency itself as the causal variable.

      The general claims are also constrained by incomplete overlap among the initial screens and by design changes between the original and follow-up joystick experiments. Overall, the study provides useful evidence that the behavioral effects of DAN activation are weak, context-dependent, and time-dependent, while the claims about neuronal identity, positive valence, agency, and a general dopamine "common currency" require more cautious framing.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Olmstead et al. present a single-cell nuclear sequencing dataset that interrogates how hippocampal gene expression changes in response to distinct physiological stimuli and across circadian time. The authors perform single nucleus RNA sequencing on mouse hippocampal tissue after (1) kainic acid-induced seizure, (2) exposure to an enriched environment, and (3) at multiple circadian phases.

      The dataset is rigorously collected, and a major strength is the use of the previously established ABC taxonomy from Yao et al. (2023) to define cell types. The authors further show that this taxonomy is largely independent of activity-driven transcriptional programs. Using these annotations, they examine activity-regulated gene expression across neuronal and glial subclasses. They identify ZT12, corresponding to the transition from the light to the dark period, as transcriptionally distinct from other circadian time points, and show that this pattern is conserved across many cell types. Finally, they test how circadian phase influences activity-dependent gene expression by exposing mice to an enriched environment at different times of day, and report no significant interaction between circadian phase and enriched environment exposure.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed the comments from the first round of review.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Doronin et al. performed wide-field calcium imaging to investigate the cortex-wide activity dynamics in mice after the administration of the psychedelic DOI.

      Strengths:

      The lab has extensive experience with this approach. The analyses are not trivial, but here the authors progressively step through the rich data to identify salient effects. The observed effects at the level of cortical networks will be of great interest to the field, both for basic scientists interested in circuit mechanisms of psychedelics and for human researchers who may want to reverse translate from humans to mice.

      Weaknesses:

      The analyses were extensive, but the choices made for the analyses are quite specific, and there are places where other analyses may be more appropriate and logical. For example, instead of comparing activity with serotonergic axonal density, compare with Htr2a transcript because the receptor is the drug target. Moreover, data were combined for day 1 and day 5 for an unclear reason. Furthermore, a few statements in the text did not seem fully supported by the results and may be over-interpreted.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study by Weber et al. investigates how artificial activation or inhibition of dopaminergic neurons innervating the Drosophila larval mushroom bodies in the context of learning paradigms influences individual properties of acquired memories. Similar approaches have been undertaken in the past (e.g., in the adult); however, the reduced complexity of the larval system makes this study valuable, especially as it eases the possibility for informed modelling approaches, as done here. A special aspect shown here is that artificial training overrides the need for context typically observed for recall of larval aversive memories.

      Strengths:

      This study adds insights into how the larval mushroom bodies store memories. The behavioral data using genetically precise manipulation of identified neurons is combined with computational modelling. Information on the physiological basis of the underlying mechanism is not provided. In light of the claim of ‚temporal precise optogenetic manipulation' and the authors ‚manipulating the intrinsic physiology' of DANs, this is important and should be stated clearly. While this reviewer agrees that the ‚temporal precision' is provided for memory phases, this might not be true for physiological parameters, especially when using tools like ChR2-XXL.

      Thus, this study offers interesting behavioral and cellular insights; however, this reviewer also recommends specifying claims on temporal and physiological precision more carefully.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The authors should be more precise about temporal and physiological windows/properties. It is recommended to discuss the published properties of the optogenetic tools used and how this might influence the obtained results, especially when comparing the results to 'naturally' reached learning after pairing stimuli in the absence of optogenetic intervention.

      (2) The authors should comment more directly as to why pairing odors with activation or inhibition of DANs does not lead to measurable learning (Figure 1).

      (3) A key finding is that DL DAN activation leads to context-independent memories (as also somewhat indicated in the title). To make this claim, the 'natural' training experiments should be conducted in parallel, or these potential limitations should be mentioned. However, if the authors state that the results using regular conditioning approaches are so clear that this is not necessary, the should state that.

      (4) Potential caveats of activating chloride channels over prolonged time periods should be mentioned.

      (5) The appropriate literature showing odor-evoked synaptic depression to MBONs (e.g., cited in lines 431/432) in the context of learning should be cited throughout.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study investigates the structural basis of neuromodulatory transmission in the cerebral cortex. Using genetic labelling, correlative light and electron microscopy (CLEM), and focused ion beam scanning electron microscopy (FIBSEM), the authors reconstruct cholinergic axons originating from the basal forebrain and serotonergic axons from the raphe nuclei in the mouse somatosensory cortex, and compare their ultrastructural organisation with that of glutamatergic and GABAergic axons.

      The study provides detailed quantitative evidence that cholinergic and serotonergic axons have an axonal architecture fundamentally different from that of classical fast-transmitting glutamatergic and GABAergic axons. In particular, vesicles in cholinergic and serotonergic axons are distributed more diffusely along the axon and are only weakly associated with morphologically identifiable synaptic specialisations. These findings provide strong structural support for the idea that volume transmission represents a major mode of signalling by these neuromodulatory systems in the cortex.

      Although the paucity of conventional synaptic contacts made by cortical neuromodulatory axons has been reported previously, including in classical work by Descarries and colleagues, the present study provides substantially more detailed and quantitative three-dimensional evidence. The study also reveals characteristic differences among neurotransmitter systems in vesicle density, vesicle distribution relative to synaptic membranes, and vesicle morphology.

      Strengths:

      A major strength of this study is the combination of genetic labelling, CLEM, and high-resolution FIBSEM, which allows molecularly identified cholinergic and serotonergic axons to be reconstructed without the electron-dense reaction products used in conventional immunoelectron microscopy. This enables detailed analysis of vesicles and membrane specialisations along extended axonal segments.

      Another important strength is that the analysis is not restricted to individual boutons or varicosities. Instead, the authors analyse vesicle distributions continuously along reconstructed axons and compare them quantitatively with glutamatergic and GABAergic axons. This provides a more comprehensive assessment of the relationship between vesicle distribution and morphologically identifiable synaptic sites.

      Overall, the data are convincing and support the authors' main conclusions. In particular, the finding that most vesicles in cholinergic and serotonergic axons are spatially dissociated from identifiable synaptic specialisations provides strong structural evidence for predominantly non-synaptic or volume transmission. The work should therefore be of broad interest to researchers studying neuromodulation, cortical circuitry, and connectomics.

      Weaknesses:

      I do not identify any major methodological weakness. The manuscript is well prepared, and the experimental results generally support the authors' conclusions. I have only a few points that could further improve the interpretation and discussion.

      First, in the Introduction, ionotropic receptors are emphasised in the context of rapid actions of acetylcholine and serotonin. However, these neuromodulators can also produce relatively rapid effects on cortical neurons through G-protein-coupled receptors. This could be acknowledged, for example, with reference to Gulledge et al. (2009) and Tanaka & North (1993).

      Second, the implications of the findings for volume transmission could be discussed somewhat more explicitly. If acetylcholine and serotonin are released extrasynaptically and are not immediately degraded or removed, they may diffuse through the extracellular space and activate receptors located at some distance from the release site. Thus, their actions need not be restricted to cellular elements immediately adjacent to vesicle-rich regions of the axon. A brief discussion of the sequence from action-potential-dependent Ca²⁺ entry and transmitter release to extracellular diffusion and activation of spatially distributed receptors would strengthen the interpretation.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary and strengths:

      This manuscript examined whether realized thermal and aridity niche limits were associated with extinction risk across more than 23,000 terrestrial vertebrate species. The authors found that climatic niche limits were phylogenetically conserved and that species with lower upper thermal limits were more likely to be threatened, while relationships with aridity niche limits were weaker and less consistent. They then used simulations based on current extinction-risk patterns and found taxon-specific changes in the distribution of climatic niche limits and loss of phylogenetic diversity under simulated future extinction scenarios.

      The study addresses an important question at an impressive taxonomic scale, and the underlying dataset and analyses have the potential to provide valuable insights into how climatic niche limits relate to patterns of extinction risks.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) One main concern is a disconnect between the central framing of the study and what the analyses can establish. The manuscript proposes that climatic niche limits increase species' vulnerability to climate and land-use change, yet extinction risk is measured using overall IUCN threat status, which integrates pressures from many different causes, including exploitation (e.g. hunting; pet trade), disease, and invasive species. For several of these threats, there is no clear mechanistic basis for why climatic niche limits should influence extinction risk. Consequently, the observed association does not establish that climate or land-use change is the underlying driver of the relationship between climatic niche limits and extinction risk. Analysing whether climatic niche limits are associated with extinction risk from climate- and habitat-related threats would provide a more direct test of the proposed mechanism.

      (2) The treatment of Data Deficient species is another important concern. The authors classified Data Deficient species as Not Threatened in their analysis. However, previous studies have shown that many may in fact be threatened (Borgelt et al., 2022, Communications Biology; Jetz and Freckleton, 2015, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B). This issue is particularly important here given the large number of Data Deficient species, especially among reptiles and amphibians, for which extinction risk may itself be underestimated (Caetano et al., 2022, PLoS Biology; González-del-Pliego et al., 2019, Current Biology). Treating these species as Not Threatened could therefore influence the reported relationships and should be evaluated through additional analyses.

      (3) The role of the phylogenetic diversity analysis in addressing the central question is also unclear. The primary question concerns the relationship between climatic niche limits and extinction risk, whereas the subsequent analysis examines phylogenetic diversity loss following simulated extinctions. Disproportionate losses of phylogenetic diversity following non-random extinction are already well studied (e.g. Hughes et al., 2022, Current Biology; Oliveira et al., 2020, Global Ecology and Biogeography; Davis et al., 2018, PNAS). The authors should therefore clarify what this analysis adds beyond existing work and how it provides a meaningful extension of the climatic niche-extinction framework.

      (4) The interpretation of the future extinction scenarios is also stronger than warranted by the simulations. The authors appropriately acknowledge that these scenarios do not explicitly incorporate climate or land-use change, but subsequently interpret the results as suggesting that climatic niche constraints shape future extinction pathways and that climatically vulnerable species will be disproportionately affected. Identifying species with lower climatic niche limits as climatically vulnerable is reasonable within the framework of the study. However, because the simulations are based on present-day extinction-risk transition probabilities rather than future climate- or land-use-driven processes, they do not establish that future climate or land-use change will preferentially drive the extinction of these species.

      Overall, the manuscript addresses an important question and provides potentially valuable data and analyses. However, several of the central conclusions currently extend beyond what the analyses can directly support. Addressing the issues above would substantially strengthen the manuscript and clarify the scope of its conclusions.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Sensory preconditioning protocols have been used to understand how the brain controls aversive or appetitive behavioral responses towards stimuli that have never been directly reinforced. In this study, the authors combine pharmacological NMDA blockade in a specific brain region previously involved in sensory preconditioning (i.e., perirhinal cortex) and different versions of a light-tone sensory preconditioning task in rats (i.e., different number of associations during preconditioning, distinct temporal separation between stage 1 and stage 2, stimuli order) to better understand how the integration between separated stimuli occurs. Overall, the main conclusion of the study is that the number, order, and time determine how distinct experiences are encoded and stored in the brain, which clearly advances the understanding of how these complex cognitive processes are regulated by the brain.

      Strengths:

      (1)The manuscript is very well written, and the methodology is well detailed, fully aligned with previous work by the research group.

      (2) Results from each pharmacological manipulation and/or protocol configuration are clear, demonstrating the robustness of their findings.

      (3) The overall conclusions are very interesting and clearly advance our understanding of higher-order conditioning processes.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The Discussion is overly redundant with the Results and should be rewritten to place the findings more clearly within the existing literature and add specific important topics for the field (e.g., type of stimulus presentation, other brain circuits involved, etc).

      (2) Before-after and sex-disaggregated data should be presented to better show statistical differences between periods with or without cue during the test and between sexes.

      (3) The authors should broaden their coverage of recent literature on light-tone higher-order conditioning beyond their own previous work.

    1. Housbondes at chirche dore I have had fyve --                 I have had five husbands at the church door -- 7       If I so ofte myghte have ywedded bee --                 If I so often might have been wedded -- 8       And alle were worthy men in hir degree.                 And all were worthy men in their way.

      I never imagined that people in the past were so more open-minded than people today.

  3. Oct 2026
    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the reviewers' suggestions.]

      Summary:

      This paper presents a toolkit for the transformation of Blastocystis. The authors have screened a number of selectable agents, promoters and reporter genes and present their findings. This resource will be of immense use to those in Blastocystsis field, as well as those seeking to establish transformation tools in other species where such tools do not yet exist. Establishing new transformation tools is extremely challenging, and the authors have done an excellent job.

      Strengths:

      The authors have carried out a systematic screen of promoters, reporter genes and selectable agents. They have screened numerous for each, and all the data is presented. It is good to see when things did not work as well as when things did - so this data set is extremely useful indeed.

      Comments on previous version.

      The authors have revised their manuscript to clarify that molecular analyses have not yet occurred and have resolved the technical/publication issues with the figures. I look forward to seeing these tools used in future publications to answer important questions in Blastocystsis research.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This is an interesting study that addresses whether mitochondrial DNA (mitoDNA) variants impact telomere length (TL), which may be relevant to potential maternal inheritance of TL in offspring. The study addresses this question using an innovative cybrid model approach in which mitochondria from donor platelets from 7 individuals that vary in TL and differ in mitoDNA variants are fused with 143B cells that lack mitochondria. MitoDNA variants that exhibited reduced complex I activity showed telomere shortening in cybrids, and increased telomere dysfunction. Interestingly, these phenotypes could be reduced with NAC antioxidant and NAD+ supplementation, suggesting that ROS and oxidative DNA damage at telomeres contributed to the telomere shortening. They further showed that cybrids with lower levels of ROS correlated with longer TL in the lymphocytes of the mitochondrial donors.

      This study has many strengths, including the use of cybrid technology, which allows for analysis of how mitochondria and mtDNA variants from various human donors influence telomere length when introduced into the same genetic background of 143B mitochondria deficient cells. Other strengths include the use of human donors that vary in leukocyte telomere length, and analysis of multiple endpoints of telomere integrity and mitochondrial function in the resulting cybrids. This study provides convincing evidence that mtDNA variants influence TL, through a mechanism involving mitochondrial derived ROS, potentially causing telomeric oxidative damage. These results may help explain prior work demonstrating a link between mitochondrial function and telomere length regulation during embryogenesis and development. The data are robust, and the manuscript is well written. Overall, the results support the conclusions and will likely have an impact on the field of mitochondrial function and telomere length regulation, with important implications for development, aging, and aging-related diseases.

      Given the heterogeneity in TL and mtDNA variants in the human population, the conclusion could be further strengthened by increasing the number of donors and cybrids analyzed. Other minor weaknesses stem from the limited number of samples. For example, the study presented limited telomere FISH metaphase analysis of chromosome end fusions, telomere damage, and telomere attrition rates due to low sample numbers. Furthermore, the proposal that acute oxidative stress was induced by a metabolic shift from glycolysis to OXPHOS in vitro is based primarily on assumptions from prior work, rather than direct demonstration in the current study. However, results with the NAC antioxidant combined with NR strongly support this assumption. Overall, the findings from this study are convincing and provide a solid foundation for expanding this analysis in the future to include a greater number of samples from donors for cybrid analysis.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Epileptogenesis involves deficits in GABAergic inhibition mediated by chloride-permeable GABA(A) channels, which are caused by elevated intracellular chloride. These changes in chloride homeostasis result from increased activity of the NKCC1 chloride importer and loss of function of the KCC2 chloride extruder. The authors used organotypic hippocampal slice preparations from mice expressing the genetically encoded chloride indicator Clomeleon as a model of posttraumatic epileptogenesis to show that these changes are mediated by the WNK-SPAK/OSR1 pathway. Blockade of the WNK-SPAK/OSR1 pathway with WNK463 alleviated epileptic activity. These findings provide important insights into the mechanisms of epileptogenesis and open new avenues for treating epilepsy.

      Strengths:

      The conclusions are well supported by the detailed pharmacological analysis.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors addressed all the recommendations in their revised manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers.]

      Leukemia-driving NUP98 oncofusion proteins form chromatin-associated biomolecular condensates in the nucleus, and these structures are important for oncogenic transformation. Most NUP98 fusions do not contain domains that mediate the recognition of specific DNA elements. Instead, they entail domains that are important for chromatin regulation. For instance, the NUP98::KDM5A fusion features a fusion of the NUP98 N-terminus with the third PHD domain of the histone demethylase KDM5A. As PHD domains are critical for the recognition of methylated histones without any sequence specificity, it is not clear what controls the condensation and chromatin binding of NUP98::KDM5A, leading to the induction of oncogenic transcriptional programs.

      In this work, the authors use a combination of cellular and in vitro studies to show that biomolecular condensation of NUP98::KDM5A is dependent on H3K4me3 binding. Their model proposes that concentration-dependent chromatin-associated condensation of NUP98::KDM5A depends on local densities of H3K4me3 on chromatin and the levels of the fusion oncoprotein. In line with this, the analysis of gene expression data from NUP98::KDM5A-positive AML cells shows a positive correlation between differentially expressed genes and H3K4me3 levels.

      This is an interesting manuscript that aims to dissect the molecular mechanisms underlying biomolecular condensation of the NUP98::KDM5A oncoprotein. The work is solid, and the results are well explained and presented in a logical order.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Jacobs et al. report how acute psilocybin influences value-based decision-making and associated neural correlates in the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) of rats performing a probabilistic two-choice task with reward probability varying in blocks. The authors highlight that acute psilocybin does not influence basic outcome-sensitive choice strategies (i.e., win-stay/lose-shift), but find that psilocybin increases choice variability and optimal choices in low-uncertainty contexts. Using RL modeling, the authors chose one of five models examined because it represented the behavior around transitions. This recapitulates their behavioral results, showing changes in choice variability (entropy) specifically under high-uncertainty conditions and improving asymptotic performance under low uncertainty. Single-unit recording from mPFC during the task revealed that psilocybin may enhance the representation of reward-preferring neurons and suppress non-reward-preferring neurons, with no changes to outcome encoding and total/relative value signals largely intact. The authors interpret these findings as evidence that psilocybin rebalances mPFC processing to favour learning from positive outcomes, potentially offering a candidate neural coding mechanism for psilocybin's purported ability to increase cognitive flexibility acutely. While the research question is highly significant, the experimental design, analysis, and interpretations have critical shortcomings.

      Strengths:

      Understanding how psilocybin influences behavioral effects like reward learning and cognitive flexibility is critical to understanding its potential use in the clinic. The behavioral, neural, and modeling studies use a powerful set of approaches that are useful for understanding this complex problem.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Design and sample size were major concerns. Only 8 rats were used, and the primary comparison is within-subject psilocybin vs. the immediately preceding "baseline" day rather than a fully counterbalanced or randomized drug/vehicle design. Since psilocybin sessions always followed baseline sessions (never the reverse), order effects, practice effects, or day-to-day drift cannot be fully excluded. Additionally, a saline control was only available for 5 of 8 animals, on a haphazard schedule ("due to unanticipated technical issues"), so the claim that effects are pharmacologically specific to psilocybin rather than to injection/novelty stress rests on a small, incomplete control dataset.

      (2) There are a number of major concerns regarding behavioral confounds. Results about the number of trials performed in each condition seem buried in the methods instead of being provided with the rest of the behavioral data. Critically, the results show a 40% reduction in the number of trials completed. This is important to highlight and consider in the context of reduced motivation/hunger, and also in terms of the associated neural activity. Additionally, the percentage of rewarded trials is not reported - this is important for the interpretation of the behavioral results. For example, is the increased choice variability following psilocybin treatment measured by entropy advantageous? Does this result in more or fewer rewarded trials?

      (3) Any differences in neural data are greatly diminished by the behavioral differences. Given the extraordinary long latency (averages of up to 20s) to reward receipt, it is unclear how the neural data in Figure 3 referencing reward is meaningful given the time frame is a maximum of 1.5s post-response. How can neurons be labeled non-reward-preferring based on their activity well before they retrieved the reward? Further, it is unclear how the post-response neural activity should be interpreted in the context of this long and variable latency to retrieve reward. The abnormally long latency to retrieve a reward is not discussed, especially in the context of response latencies on the order of 2 to 4s. Furthermore, the difference between groups (7 versus 20 s) should be discussed because this may represent a difference in motivation/hunger/response drive between groups and influence the interpretation of both behavioral and neural data.

      Additionally, it is unclear how to interpret the neural data given the offset timing between groups because of the large behavioral differences. For example, given the decrease in latency to respond following the psilocybin treatment, the neural data shown (aligned to the response; e.g., Figure 6A, B) is largely offset from the time of trial initiation. There is no discussion of what is occurring behaviorally during the latency, which may be the cause of the different neural signatures.

      (4) For the RL Modeling, there is circularity in the author's approach to choosing a model - namely, based on the "posterior predictive ability to recover psilocybin effects". The author's process for arriving at Model 3 as the specific "preferred" model over the intermediate options (particularly Model 4 with stickiness) is not well-described. The validation step (of recovering the key psilocybin behavioral transition signatures) is circular and not sound evidence for model adequacy rather than independent confirmation. I would want to see the actual PSIS-LOO comparison table (with SEs and Pareto k diagnostics) from Supplemental Figure 2A before fully accepting that Model 3 was clearly the best-justified choice rather than simply the most convenient one given convergence constraints. There was no prior predictive check with the parameters being chosen from the literature. Additionally, the Bayesian parameter effects rely on a relatively lenient 80% HDI threshold (rather than 95%).

      (5) Some minor concerns:

      a) The order of the Type I and II neurons appears to be reversed in this sentence based on the rest of the results/figures. "These neurons had distinct temporal patterns, showing reward-related increases immediately at action or later in the action/outcome epoch and are depicted as Type I and Type II, respectively".

      b) Connecting results from Figures 3 and 4 would be interesting; in other words, showing how Type I/II neurons look in Figure 4 plots.

      c) In Figure 1H, are the post-transition trials collapsed across high and low next blocks, since it seems from the depicted trial order that low uncertainty blocks can be followed by either a high uncertainty block or another (reversed) low uncertainty block.

      d) The methods by which the authors arrived at the binned value neurons are not well-described, and more clarity on how authors arrived at relative and total value estimates would be helpful.

    1. P12F6M2410ynOU20/200nn20/20nnn

      PatientID: 12

      KindredID: 6

      Case: M, 12Y0M, Ethnicity Unknown

      DiseaseAssertion: Hemangioblastom

      FamilyInfo: A family pedigree is provided in figure 1. The patient’s father carried the same mutation as patient 12, but the father’s occurred de novo, as neither of the father’s parents carried the mutation. The patient’s father had cerebellar, retinal and bulbar hemangioblastomas, and retinal detachment. The patient’s 14-year-old brother (patient 11) was asymptomatic.

      CasePresentingHPOs: HP:0010797 (hemangioblastoma)

      CaseHPOFreeText: Patient had a CNS hemangioblastoma.

      CaseNotHPOs: HP:0009711 (retinal capillary hemangioma)

      CaseNotHPOFreeText: Patient did not have Retinal capillary hemangiomas.

      CasePreviousTesting: N/A

      PreviouslyPublished: N/A

      SupplementalData: N/A

      Variant: c.341+1_341–1(463*1_?)

      LegacyVariant: N/A

      CaseProblemVariantFreeText: N/A

      ClinVarID: N/A

      CAID: N/A

      gnomAD: N/A

      VariantEvidence: N/A

      MutationType: delins

      CivicName: Null (c.341+1_341–1)

      MultipleGeneVariants: N/A

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The paper presents an elegant task designed to investigate humans' ability to generalize knowledge of learned graph structures to new experiences that share the same structure but are built from different stimuli. Using behavior and MEG recordings, the authors test evidence for neural representation and application of structural knowledge.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have addressed my concerns and have largely toned-down the overstatement of their findings which was pervasive in the previous version of the manuscript. However, the revised title still seems rather misleading given the findings presented. I suggest the authors revise this to: 'A neural mechanism for transfer of abstract structural knowledge in humans'.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, Malfatti et al. study the role of Chrna2 Martinotti cells (Mα2 cells), a subset of SST interneurons, for motor learning and motor cortex activity. The authors trained mice on a forelimb prehension task while recording neuronal activity of pyramidal cells using calcium imaging with a head-mounted miniscope. While chemogenetically increasing Mα2 cell activity did not affect motor learning, it changed pyramidal cell activity such that activity peaks become sharper and differently timed than in control mice. Moreover, co-active neuronal assemblies become more stable with a smaller spatial distribution. Increasing Mα2 cell activity in previously trained mice did increase performance on the prehension task and led to increased theta and gamma band activity in the motor cortex. On the other hand, genetic ablation of Mα2 cells affected fine motor movements on a pasta handling task while not affecting the prehension task. While overall this study addresses an important and timely question, limitations in the design of the motor learning task and data analysis significantly weaken the conclusions drawn in this manuscript.

      Strengths:

      The proposed question of how Chrna2-expressing SST interneurons affect motor learning and motor cortex activity is important and timely. The study employs sophisticated approaches to record neuronal activity and manipulate the activity of a specific neuronal population in behaving mice over the course of motor learning. The authors analyze a variety of neuronal activity parameters, comparing different behavior trials, stages of learning, and the effects of Mα2 cell activation. The analysis of neuronal assembly activity and stability over the course of learning by tracking individual neurons throughout the imaging sessions is notable, since technically challenging, and yielded the interesting result that neuronal assemblies are more stable when activating Mα2 cells.

      Overall, the study provides compelling evidence that Mα2 cells regulate certain aspects of motor behaviors, likely by shaping circuit activity in the motor cortex.

      Weaknesses:

      I appreciate the authors' efforts to address the remaining issues raised by the reviewers and agree that it becomes clearer by refocusing the study away from learning towards effects of Ma2 cell activation on motor execution. I also appreciate added clarifications throughout the manuscript.

      That said the study still relies heavily on measuring changes throughout "performance refinement", which is just another word for learning. Given their task design, it is hard to assess any learning or refinement over the course of training. This makes it hard to interpret why certain changes in neuronal activity occur at the defined sessions. The main conclusion thus is that there is "a complex interplay between Mα2 activity, oscillatory brain dynamics, and motor function", as the authors state as well in their discussion. I would encourage a further focus or restriction of the data presentation and interpretation on motor execution and limit any plasticity findings on training session 6, where the reaching task properly starts, such as in the study the authors reference (10.1016/j.neuron.2021.07.030).

      Relatedly, the authors cannot say that "enhancing Mα2 cell excitability improved the performance of a motor task relying on an already refined skill (Figure 6C)" (lines 1134-1136). Since there is no improvement in success ratio throughout the training prior to CLZ injection (Supp Fig. 7A), there is no evidence for learning or skill refinement in the period where the pellet is presented on the plate.

      Regarding the Ca2+ image analysis, the baseline subtraction approach the authors use only appropriately reduces part of the technical variations seen with 1p Ca2+ imaging. It only partially accounts for differences in GCaMP expression or different illumination across cells, or slower task-independent fluctuations in neuronal activity. Given the goal of the analysis is to show activity modulation in the peri-trial interval around prehension onset, some version of trial-wise baseline normalization (which is commonly used) is necessary and would likely result in less confusing results.

      Minor:

      - Unclear which session traces in figure 1I are from.

      - Label in Supp Fig. 7A should say "switch from spoon to plate".

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      In the previous revision the authors addressed some of the points, but they also make some technical errors. My overall view of the manuscript hasn't changed since the original evaluation.

      Previously I noted that SC sparsity presents an issue when comparing to full FC matrices. They authors misinterpreted the Honey et al paper. They resampled ALL entries of the SC matrix (including zeros) from a Gaussian distribution. In effect, this assigns zeros small (but uniform) weights. In Honey et al, the authors resampled only existing edge weights from a gaussian distribution (the rationale at the time was that there might be pushback against the extremely heavy-tailed edge weight distribution). In other words, the zeros are still zeros following this resampling procedure.

      That said, I agree that the log transform is likely useful or necessary given edge weight distributions.

      In short, I still think that the approach is interesting and meritorious, I just don't think the execution is correct.

      Comments on revised version.

      In this revision the authors addressed my remaining points.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      The authors have substantially strengthened the manuscript in response to my comments. In particular, they have improved the treatment of non-canonical calls, added further illustrative examples at the level of individual RNA variants, repeated pathway enrichment using an appropriate expression-matched background, assessed treatment-associated cell viability, and moderated several biological claims. The revised manuscript is now most compelling as a technical benchmarking and best-practice resource for high-confidence prediction of a common RNA chemical modification from nanopore direct RNA sequencing.

      The matched-input comparison of two methods, use of unmodified RNA controls, and inhibitor treatment are important strengths. Together, these experiments provide solid support for the central conclusion that careful filtering and appropriate controls can substantially reduce likely false-positive calls and yield a reproducible set of high-confidence predictions. The added analyses also provide useful illustrations of the capacity of long-read sequencing to assign predictions to individual RNA variants, although they do not establish broad superiority over the short-read comparison method.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, Ding et al. use genetic mouse models to demonstrate that atrial trabeculation is more dependent on Tie1/Tie2 signaling than ventricular trabeculation. With additional experimentation that would support the current claims, the results may hold significant value, as atrial trabeculation remains an understudied phenomenon in cardiac biology with potential implications for atrial cardiomyopathy and atrial fibrillation.

      Strengths:

      Detailed characterization of atrial versus ventricular trabeculation across different developmental timepoints, and the use of appropriate animal models to address the scientific question at hand.

      Comments on revised version.

      I thank the authors for their detailed comments on the reviewers' comments. There however remain some issues that should be properly addressed to make the manuscript stronger.

      (1) The authors state that Tie1 and Tek levels are noticeably higher in atrial vs ventricular endocardial cells. Can the authors provide the appropriate statistics to give strength to this claim, since the Supplemental Figure 1F does not indicate robust chamber-specific differences? As normal statistics (t-test, Mann-Whitney, ANOVA) cannot be applied to raw RNAseq data, the authors should collect independent samples and perform qRT-PCR analyses on these.

      (2) When Tek is depleted in endothelial cells at E12.5, ventricular defects are also observed at later stages. Presumable, this could mean that earlier depletion of Tek, prior to initiation of ventricular trabeculation, might have resulted in equally severe atrial and ventricular defects. Similarly, they observe that, when Tie1 is deleted early on (tamoxifen administration at E10.5), combined with the heterozygous deletion of Tek, both atrial and ventricular defects are observed. While their postnatal studies do suggest a differential impact of Tie2 on atrial vs ventricular trabeculation (or the maintenance thereof), a more thorough analysis is needed to truly support the authors' claim that Tie1 and Tie2 synergistically impact atrial trabeculation more dramatically than ventricular trabeculation. However, to give weight to this claim, they should perform EC-specific depletion of Tie1 and Tie2 (or at least 3 out of 4 alleles) at different developmental stages, where tamoxifen is administered prior to ventricular or atrial trabeculation.

      (3) Earlier reports indicate that a part of Tie1 null mutants (app. 15%) die in utero. Did the authors also observe this phenomenon in their mutant lines, and did these animals have more severe atrial defects?

      (4) Although the reviewers did not request detailed mechanistic insights into the molecular mechanisms that drive Tie1-mediated atrial trabeculation, several of the reviewers' requests (e.g. YAP/TAZ staining) were unfortunately not performed. This is a shame, as peer review is instrumental to strengthen manuscripts and increase their validity. It would have therefore been nice if the authors had at least made an attempt to address some of outstanding reviewers' questions.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      There is prior literature showing a robust relationship between sulcal interruptions in the posterior occipital temporal sulcus (pOTS) and reading ability. The goals of this study were to extend these findings to children examined longitudinally as they become better readers, and to examine the underlying white matter properties in individuals with and without pOTS sulcal interruptions. To do this, the authors collected longitudinal structural, diffusion, and behavioral data in 51 children (TP1 age 5.5, TP3 age 8.2 years).

      First, the authors found that the gyral gap was consistent across time within the subject. This is expected, as they state in the introduction that sulcal patterns are typically established in utero. Next, they found that children with an interrupted pOTS have higher reading scores (across a variety of measures) at timepoint (TP) 3 than children with continuous pOTS, and this was specific to the pOTS, as no associations emerged for the anterior OTS or MFS; this is again expected from prior literature. They then found that the binary presence of this gap, but not anterior OTS or MFS predicted T3 reading performance. Further, they found that a subsample of the lowest readers at TP1 did not have differences in reading score by gyral gap, but that this difference emerged at TP3. Additionally, the gyral gap at TP1 is similar to variance TOWRE 3 reading skills as some behavioral measures at TP1. Examining underlying white matter in a smaller subset of children, the authors found higher MD in children with an interrupted pOTS vs. those with a continuous pOTS, which was contrary to their hypothesis, and higher local connectivity for interrupted, aligning with their hypothesis, but this difference was no longer present when accounting for TP3 reading scores. The authors conclude that structural properties, in this case, the gyral gap, may guide neural plasticity for reading.

      Strengths:

      This paper has an interesting set of longitudinal data to examine the perhaps changing relationship between sulcal interruptions in the pOTS with reading scores. I commend the authors on data collection and attention to detail in the anatomical analyses.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      In this work, T. Wijerathne et al. investigated and reported the agonistic effect of Yoda1 and Yoda2 over PIEZO2 function using patch clamp electrophysiology, Ca2+ imaging, and molecular dynamics. They find that Yoda1 sensitizes PIEZO2 to membrane tension, can induce Ca2+ influx, and decreases its inactivation to a lesser degree than it does to PIEZO1 channels. Additionally, their data shows that Yoda2 sensitizes PIEZO2 channels to membrane indentation to a greater extent, but it has a weaker effect on channel inactivation than Yoda1. Interestingly, they report that a mutation in a conserved arginine between PIEZO channels can be used to abolish PIEZO1-mediated Ca2+ flux in response to Yoda molecules. As a whole, the results presented here should be put into perspective against previous and future works involving systems where both PIEZO1 and PIEZO2 might be expressed. This is especially true for works where Yoda1 has been used as a basis for determining the absence of PIEZO2.

      Strengths:

      The authors use multiple techniques to investigate how Yoda molecules affect the three most important biophysical aspects of PIEZO channels that, when changed, result in pathophysiological responses: a) sensitivity to mechanical stimuli, b) Ca2+ entry, and c) channel inactivation. Lastly, they find a specific amino acid/region that could be exploited for drug design and/or development.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The study investigates the Drosophila non-visual light receptor rhodopsin7 with regard to its role in light information processing and resulting consequences for behavioral patterns and circadian clock function. Using behavioral, in situ staining, and receptor activation assays together with different fly mutants, the authors show that rhodopsin7 is an important determinant of activity under and response to darkness, which likely signals via a pathway distinct from other, visual Drosophila rhodopsins. Based on phylogenetic analysis, the authors further discuss a potentially conserved functional role of non-visual photoreceptors like rhodopsin7 and the mammalian melanopsin light information processing and circadian clock modulation.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript follows a very clear structure with all investigations logically building onto each other. Background information and methodology are provided in appropriate detail so that readers can fully understand why and how experiments were conducted. It is further praiseworthy that the authors provide the details that allow also non-experts in the field to fully understand their approaches. Experimental work was conducted in a highly standardized manner, and also considered potential "side-aspects" like the consequences of temperature cycles and changed photoperiods. The detailed and clear description of the obtained results makes them very convincing, with (almost) all observable patterns being addressed.

      By highlighting the evolutionary old phylogenetic position of rhodopsin7 and its conservation across numerous clades, the authors provide strong reasoning for the relevance of their work, also pointing out the similarities to the mammalian melanopsin. The postulated hypothesis regarding protein structure and functioning, as well as the role in light information processing and behavioral and circadian clock modulation are well based on the authors' observations, and speculative aspects are correctly pointed out.

      Weaknesses:

      Where the manuscript still has potential for improvement is the discussion, which in its current form does seem slightly self-contained and does not fully integrate the findings of previous studies on Drosophila rhodopsin7. As the introduction specifically points out that previous findings have been contradictory, this seems like a missed opportunity. Further details on this are provided in the recommendations below.

      Similarly, the manuscript currently lacks a discussion of the possible relevance of rhodopsin7 (and other non-visual light receptors in other organisms) in the context of a species' environment and lifestyle, i.e., what is the relevance/benefit of having rhodopsin7 in the fly's everyday life? While this clearly involves speculation, when done carefully, it can elevate the paper's relevance from a primarily academic to a societal one.

      An additional point concerns the title and abstract, which postulate rhodopsin7 roles in contrast vision as well as motion and brightness perception. Contrast remains poorly defined in the text, leaving it ambiguous whether it refers to bright/dark contrasts, e.g., along edges, or the temporal contrast that results from dark pulses (startle response). While the latter seems to apply here, the former is likely more intuitive. Thus, this aspect should be rephrased (also in the title) or properly clarified early on. Regarding motion detection, this is backed up by the optomotor response results, but the findings stand somewhat isolated from the other results, lacking a clear connection aside from general visual processing. Lastly, brightness perception is mentioned in the abstract, but never again, possibly due to inconsistent phrasing throughout the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors have addressed many of the concerns. In sum, this study examined how ErbB4 signalling in parvalbumin-positive (PV) interneurons contributes to olfactory bulb (OB) microcircuit function and olfactory behaviour in mice. Using RNAscope, single-cell RT-PCR, conditional Erbb4 deletion, awake in vivo recordings, slice electrophysiology and optogenetics, the authors report that ErbB4 was expressed in PV interneurons of the EPL and IPL, and that its loss impaired odour discrimination and dishabituation, reduced GABAergic transmission onto mitral cells, and elevated ongoing LFP power. The experiments were well-designed, but several central claims were not yet adequately supported by the data as presented.

      Strengths:

      Pretty comprehensive set of experiments.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) Figure 1. The investigation time of the AAV-Cre-GFP group varied considerably across isoamyl acetate concentrations. Were there any differences between the AAV-GFP and AAV-Cre-GFP groups at the 0 (mineral oil) condition? Since the threshold was defined by a comparison against mineral oil, a baseline difference would propagate directly into the threshold estimate and could reduce exploratory drive rather than an olfactory deficit.

      (2) Previous papers have reported that ErbB4 is expressed in neuroblasts of the SVZ and RMS, and that disruption of NRG1-ErbB4 signalling may decrease GABAergic neuron number and alter distribution (Anton et al., Nat Neurosci 2004; Ghashghaei et al., PNAS 2006). The authors showed in Figure 2L that ErbB4 expression in the OB was already decreased at P7, suggesting reduced neuron number and disrupted neuronal distribution. The authors should therefore quantify the number and laminar distribution of the different neuronal types in the OB. Cresyl violet staining showed that gross lamination was preserved, but could detect changes in cell density or in the relative proportions of interneuron subtypes.

      (3) Figure 4C. First of all, there were no indicators marking the sessions, so we had no idea what state the mice were in. Also, why did the odour-evoked MFRs of PV-Erbb4⁺/⁺ and PV-Erbb4⁻/⁻ mice show opposite trends during the 0-2 s window in the first session - were there any differences in the behaviour of the two groups during this session? As the mice were head-fixed on a floating ball, locomotion and sniffing should have been monitored, since both strongly influence M/TC firing.

      (4) Figure 4K-L. The authors did not explain why spontaneous and odour-evoked MFR were so much different among the "no response" M/TCs. Did this mean that ErbB4 knockout in PV interneurons disrupts the function? This would imply a tonic rather than a stimulus-locked disinhibition, which is a different claim from the one made in the Discussion. In addition, the authors stated that panel 4L indicates "the distribution of types of odour-evoked responses was significantly altered in PV-Erbb4⁻/⁻ mice compared with PV-Erbb4⁺/⁺ mice, suggesting compromised odour detection" - what exactly does this mean? A shift in the proportions of response categories is also compatible with a changed baseline firing rate altering the classification itself.

      (5) Figure 5. The power of all frequency bands in PV-Erbb4⁻/⁻ mice was higher than in PV-Erbb4⁺/⁺ mice, including the gamma band. However, Tan et al. (2022) reported that inhibition of ErbB4 kinase activity decreases LFP power and GABA release, which is inconsistent with the present data. This discrepancy should be addressed explicitly. A uniform elevation across all four bands was atypical for a PV-dependent mechanism and could reflect a global scaling difference; separating periodic from aperiodic components and reporting normalised power would help.

      (6) Photocurrent amplitude and mCherry⁺ PV cell density was not compared across genotypes; Figure 9-figure supplement 1B-C showed photocurrents for only one group. Since the authors themselves reported in Figure 7-figure supplement 1 that PV interneurons in knockout mice reduced mEPSC frequency and amplitude and increased AP frequency, the presynaptic population was clearly not in an equivalent state. The reduced oIPSC could therefore result from differences in ChR2 expression level or in the number of labelled cells. Photocurrent curves and mCherry⁺ cell density must be provided for both groups.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The inclusion of a summary schematic in this revision significantly improves the manuscript. We have also modified the last sentence of the original editorial assessment.]

      Summary:

      The authors demonstrate the stereoselective role of D-serine in 1C metabolism showing that D-serine competes with L-serine and inhibits mitochondrial L-serine transport. They observe expression of 1C metabolites in their metabolomics approach in primary cortical neurons treated with L-serine, D-serine and mixture of both. Their conclusions are based on the reduction in levels of glycine, polyamines and their intermediates and formate. Single cell RNA sequencing of N2a cells showed that cells treated with D-serine enhanced expression of genes associated with mitochondrial functions such as respiratory chain complex assembly and mitochondrial functions with downregulation of genes related to amino acid transport, cellular growth and neuron projection extension. Their work demonstrates that D-serine inhibits tumor cell proliferation and induces apoptosis in neural progenitor cells highlighting the importance of D-serine in neurodevelopment.

      Strengths:

      D-amino acids do not merely function as ligands at receptors but have underlying roles in signaling and metabolism. These roles are just beginning to be uncovered. The authors elucidate the metabolic role of D-serine in the context of neuronal maturation by its suppression of mitochondrial L-serine availability for SHMT2 and 1C flux. This is the strength of the manuscript. The implications for the metabolic role of D-serine in neurons is a highlight and underlines its roles in neuronal metabolism.

      Comments on previous version.

      This reviewer is satisfied by the effort made by the authors based on the prior comments raised.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This study by Tsuji et al. explores a mechanical threat model in Drosophila using air puffs as a stimulus. The authors first establish the paradigm and show that air puffs induce cardiac deceleration along with increased locomotion. They then identify dopamine as a key regulator of this response and go on to map the underlying circuit. In doing so, they pinpoint two pairs of DA-WED neurons as critical players. They carefully used intersectional strategies to achieve relatively clean labeling of these neurons, which helps ensure that the observed effects can be attributed specifically to DA-WED neurons. They further show that DA-WED neurons are both required and sufficient to drive cardiac deceleration, and that their activity increases in response to air puff stimulation. These neurons also contribute to the locomotor response. Directly inducing cardiac deceleration via optogenetic manipulation of cardiomyocytes also increases locomotion, suggesting a link between cardiac state and behavioral output.

      Strengths:

      Overall, the experiments are thoughtfully designed, well controlled, and clearly presented. The figures are easy to follow, and the conclusions are generally well supported by the data. The manuscript is also clearly written, with a discussion that acknowledges potential caveats and outlines future directions. The genetic tools, behavioral paradigm, heart rate measurement approaches, and stimulation methods introduced here will be valuable resources for the community. few minor comments:

      Comments on revised version:

      I thank the authors for responding to my questions, they have thoroughly addressed my comments. I am therefore supportive of publication of the manuscript.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

      Summary:

      This study by Z. Moradi, S. Jahedazad, and colleagues presents a refined two-choice assay paradigm for investigating thermotactic behavior in groups of Drosophila melanogaster. The authors developed an experimental setup that maintains a stable temperature profile and utilized supervised classifiers based on extracted locomotion parameters to distinguish between temperature conditions within the arena as well as antennal ablation status. The integration of a Braitenberg vehicle model to simulate fruit fly exploration patterns and U-turn behaviors at thermal boundaries represents a valuable contribution to the study of collective thermotaxis.

      Strengths:

      (1) The detailed description of the behavioral assay and the rigorous calibration methods make the experimental setup reproducible.

      (2) The incorporation of a state-of-the-art animal tracking system enables the precise extraction of multiple locomotion parameters, providing valuable insights into the fruit fly exploration as well as for predicting temperature-dependent behavioral responses. The methodology could be potentially adopted in other studies.

      (3) The authors' decision to study thermotactic behavior in groups is a noteworthy addition. The finding that overall staccato movement patterns remain largely unaffected by antennal ablation, while the frequency and duration of pairwise encounters increase with temperature, offers valuable insights into individual sensory processing vs the influence of collective behavior.

      Weaknesses:

      (1) The study investigates groups of fruit flies, which is an interesting contrast to previous single-fly studies. While group dynamics are mentioned as potentially important, no direct comparison or analysis was conducted between individual vs group, which would have been a straightforward and valuable addition. The strength of intergroup interactions remains unclear, as the pairwise encounter parameters appeared to have low significance according to the importance factor analysis.

      (2) The manuscript does not clearly articulate the novelty of the work; the innovative aspects are present but not effectively highlighted.

      (3) The descriptions of the locomotor parameters and Braitenberg modeling, which constitute the most critical components of the study, are not optimally presented in the main text. The authors should provide a more detailed rationale for why certain locomotion parameters emerged as more influential (i.e., with higher importance scores) than others. Additionally, clearer explanations from a physical or mechanistic perspective would help readers better appreciate and interpret the significance of these findings.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The authors show that during prophase I of male meiosis, nucleoli disassemble and nucleolar components relocalize to the sex chromosome (XY) body. They further demonstrate that this process is regulated by the ATR-dependent signaling pathway that mediates meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI). Pharmacological disruption of pre-rRNA synthesis using the RNA polymerase I inhibitor BMH-21 leads to the recruitment of RNA polymerase II to the sex chromosomes and ectopic expression of sex chromosome-linked genes. These findings uncover a previously unrecognized role for pre-rRNAs in maintaining transcriptional silencing during meiosis. The study employs a combination of cell biology, genetics, and genomics approaches, and the conclusions are supported by compelling, well-organized data.

      Comments on revised version.

      I have read the revision and I have no additional questions.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editor's note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Ma et al. use human-chimpanzee tetraploid cells, across different cell types, to identify the genetic causes and then transcriptomic consequences of divergence in DNA methylation. They conclude that the evolution of DNA methylation is driven primarily by cis-regulatory changes, and that the evolution of CpG sites contributes to cis-regulation while transcription factor expression underlies some trans changes. They then argue that divergence in DNA methylation is associated with changes in gene expression and may contribute to human phenotypes.

      The tetraploid model is able to provide compelling evidence that most regulatory evolution occurs due to cis-regulatory changes, and that sites that have diverged in DNA methylation level cluster together into DMRs which share similar divergence patterns and genetic architecture. This stands in intriguing contrast to trans-mechanisms which explain most variation within modern human populations. The authors proceed to show that trans-effects can be explained, in part, by nearby TF binding motifs and many cis-regulatory changes are explained by CpG-disrupting variants. While these mechanisms clearly contribution to divergence in DNA methylation, the degree to which they explain cis- and trans-regulatory divergence would be valuable.

      Next, the authors seek to show that differences in DNA methylation are functionally relevant. Consistent with previous results, they show that differences in DNA methylation are (weakly) associated with changes in gene expression. They hypothesize that genes with concordant regulatory should exhibit great methylation-expression coupling than other genes and show that cis-expression/cis-methylation pairs are more strongly correlated than trans/trans pairs. I think that looking at cis/trans or trans/cis changes would also be useful. Another limitation is that this analysis is limited to promoter regions. It is not clear how many divergent DMRs that includes and how many of those genes have differences in expression. The key question is whether differences in DNA methylation are functionally important, and the answer provided by these analyses is "sometimes".

      Finally, the authors make a case for lineage-specific selection on DNA methylation that is connected to human traits. Using a sign-test, they identify sets of genes which have likely experienced selection in humans and may underlie human phenotypes.

      In conclusion, I think this study provides a valuable resource for differences in DNA methylation between humans and chimpanzees across tissues and provides important insight into the relative abundance of cis and trans regulatory divergence. Additional research is necessary to investigate the underlying regulatory mechanisms and more care needs to be taken in exploring the functional consequences.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      The study describes the migration of epidermal keratinocytes through porous membranes and observed a unique size selection whereby only on 3-micron membrane are keratinocytes able to migrate and reform an intact epidermis. The authors propose that the model replicates three cell states of intact epidermis, EMT, and MET. They also show that this response depends on the actin cytoskeleton, keratin 6, and Piezo1, and the migration could be stimulated with TGFbeta ligands.

      Strengths:

      Strengths of the study include the establishment of a simple yet robust in vitro model that capture all three cell states, which could be useful for future investigation of wound healing or metastasis across a range of epithelia. There is also good quantitative characterisation of the pore size effects, providing some interesting observations about the physical regulation of keratinocyte migration, and the study provides some initial insights into the regulatory mechanisms. The images and presentation are clear.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      In this manuscript, the authors describe the use of BindCraft computational protein design to create a series of binders to the chemokine CCL25. This chemokine normally mediates CCR9-dependent trafficking of immune cells to the gut, making it a potential target for the treatment of inflammatory bowel disease and related conditions. Importantly, CCL25 also binds a scavenging receptor, ACKR4. The computational protein design approach used does not involve defining particular epitopes to be targeted, allowing a free search for any potential interaction surface.

      Among four designs tested, three were predicted to interact at a similar site on the chemokine, while a fourth clone, VUP25111, was predicted to bind to a different site. All four designs showed binding to CCL25, with similar high-nM KD values in all cases. The first three clones showed evidence of direct competition with the receptor for CCL25 binding, while VUP25111 showed incomplete inhibition of binding. In functional assays, all clones acted as antagonists except for VUP25111, which inhibited arrestin recruitment by CCR9, but did not affect G protein activation by CCR9 or arrestin recruitment by ACKR4 (which signals exclusively through arrestin and not G protein).

      Strengths:

      The work is completed to a high technical standard, and the functional diversity of the clones is intriguing. It is exciting to see pathway-selective modulation of signaling, and this basic paradigm is likely to generalize to other chemokine/receptor systems. The exceptional complexity of chemokine signaling makes this an excellent area to explore the development of modulators that can restrict signaling to a specific subset of receptors.

      Weaknesses:

      No major weaknesses were noted by this reviewer.

      Comments on revised version:

      The revision looks fine to me.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      In this study, Hossain et al. investigated the role of Interleukin-2-inducible T cell kinase (ITK) in autoimmune lung injury, demonstrating that ITK-deficient (Itk-/-) mice are protected against pristane-induced pulmonary hemorrhage (PH). Authors suggest that this protection correlates with a significant remodeling of the T cell compartment in Itk-/- mice, including increased frequency of memory-like CD4+ and CD8+ T cells (CD44⁺CD62L⁺) as well as higher frequency of Treg populations. Furthermore, adoptive transfer of ITK-deficient Treg isolated from injured ITK-deficient mice confers protection against pulmonary hemorrhage in WT recipients.

      Strengths:

      The adoptive transfer of congenically marked wildtype and Itk-/- Treg populations clearly demonstrates that ITK-deficient Treg can actively rescue pre-existing lung injury and reverse systemic secondary metrics like proteinuria in wild-type recipients, providing proof-of-concept validation for the therapeutic utility of the ITK-Treg axis.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The manuscript presents a study combining human functional MRI (fMRI), electroencephalography (EEG), and human judgement data within a two-step regression framework to determine when several regions of interest (ROIs) along the so-called third visual pathway for social perception are activated, and which aspects of visual representations of social interactions they encode. The goal is to determine whether social interactions are encoded through a hierarchy of representation along the third pathway, and whether this hierarchy is implemented in a feedforward manner.

      The first analysis linking EEG to fMRI data identifies early activation (within 60 ms) in early visual cortex (EVC) and later (onset between 112 and 310 ms) activations in selected, more anterior ROIs along the pathway, i.e., motion-selective MT, extrastriate body area (EBA), object-selective lateral occipital cortex (LOC), and posterior and anterior social-interaction superior temporal sulcus regions (pSTS and aSTS). The second analysis linking EEG-fMRI data to stimulus features derived either computationally from the images or from human judgments shows that EVC activity arises early (within 68 ms) and is predicted by low-level visual features and motion energy. Activity in all other ROIs emerges after 140 ms (or later) and is predicted by motion energy (in MT, EBA and LOC), arousal (in MT), spatial expanse (in LOC, pSTS and aSTS), agent distance (in LOC, pSTS and aSTS) and communication (in aSTS). No effects of facingness, object-directedness, joint action, or valence are found in any ROI.

      Two observations are highlighted: features important for recognizing social interactions (i.e., agent distance) are encoded with a similar latency in the mid-level LOC and in STS; the communication content is selectively encoded in anterior STS.

      It is concluded that social interactions are processed in a hierarchical way, with more abstract information (i.e., communication) encoded in more anterior regions. Moreover, because this higher-level information is encoded at similar or even shorter latencies than mid-level features in mid- and high-level ROIs, these findings are taken to challenge a strictly feedforward hierarchy within the third visual pathway.

      Strengths:

      This is a timely manuscript concerning a newly discovered and now extensively investigated brain network, purportedly dedicated to social perception. In the manuscript, the selectivity of this network for the perception of social interactions is assumed rather than demonstrated. Instead, the study addresses two related questions that are critical for understanding how the network (or pathway) is organized and functions: (i) whether representations are hierarchically organized, progressing from more specific information (lower-level visual features) to increasingly abstract information (interaction category, e.g., communication), and (ii) whether processing follows a feedforward mechanism with prior and rapid encoding of lower-level features of social interactions, followed by encoding of mid-level and higher-level features.

      Addressing these questions is important because it goes beyond the knowledge of where social information is represented, toward understanding what kinds of visual input and transformations support the recognition of social interactions, and how the processing stages are organized (e.g., in a feedforward manner or with recurrent interactions). Establishing both aspects would define the particular computational architecture supporting the human ability to understand visual social interactions.

      The manuscript is also methodologically valuable, as it introduces a variation of more conventional fMRI-EEG fusion analyses. This method establishes fMRI and EEG correspondences, thus revealing spatiotemporal dynamics of brain activity (i.e., where activity occurs in the brain, at which time point), and further links these dynamics to stimulus features (i.e., which aspects of the stimuli predict activity in a given brain area at a given time). The description and discussion of the method in the manuscript are clear and transparent. This facilitates replication and allows appreciation of the rationale of the approach and its potential for future research.

      Weaknesses:

      The method introduced in the manuscript appears to be a valuable addition to the range of non-invasive approaches to study the spatiotemporal dynamics of representations in the human brain. The results presented in the manuscript, however, do not make a strong case for the sensitivity of the method.

      The study fails to replicate several effects that have demonstrated reliability across previous studies. In particular, motion energy in the stimuli only poorly predicts - relatively late -activity in motion-sensitive MT. Moreover, unlike several previous studies, including work by McMahon, Isik, and colleagues, the study finds no effects of facingness (or any other mid-level features) in EBA, object-directedness in LOC, joint actions in pSTS, and valence in pSTS. The manuscript does not discuss discrepancies, raising concerns about the sensitivity and validity of the method. In particular, the absence of previously reported effects is difficult to interpret without considering whether the method is sufficiently sensitive to detect the relevant stimulus dimensions.

      Another related and unexplored issue concerns the potentially limited correspondence between EEG and fMRI signals, and between stimuli used to derive the stimulus features for the analyses and stimuli used in the actual EEG experiment. EEG and fMRI data were collected in different samples, and different individuals may assign different social value to the same events, potentially affecting neural processing in regions such as the pSTS (see e.g., work by Varrier, Finn et al.). Furthermore, the stimuli used in the EEG experiment were derived from, but differed from those used in the fMRI experiment. Although this is not entirely clear from the manuscript, it appears that stimulus features were measured for the original stimuli used in the fMRI experiment and assumed to be valid also for stimuli in the EEG experiment. The manuscript does not acknowledge these issues, or other potential sources of noise arising from them, either on their own right or in relation to the above null effects. This makes it difficult to determine whether the absence of several expected effects reflects genuine characteristics of neural representations or limitations of the measurement and analysis pipeline.

      Beyond the methodological concerns, the results themselves are less straightforward than the manuscript suggests. Evidence for hierarchical representation emerges from the effect of low-level visual features in EVC and the encoding of communication in aSTS. Activity in all ROIs 'in the middle', from MT, EBA and LOC to pSTS, is predicted by a mixture of low- and mid-level stimulus features, whose effects in some cases come online after the encoding of the interaction category in aSTS (at 195 ms). This raises important questions concerning how a higher-level representation of an interaction category can emerge before the encoding of the lower- or mid-level information that is presumably diagnostic of that category. The manuscript would benefit from a more thorough discussion of this issue, particularly because the temporal ordering of these effects is central to the authors' claims about hierarchical and feedforward processing.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      In their manuscript Arjun et al. investigate the role of the histone acetyl transferase Gcn5 in controlling Drosophila blood cell homeostasis in the larval lymph gland. Using gcn5 zygotic mutants as well as targeted knock-down and over-expression of Gcn5 in various lymph gland cell populations, they show that these manipulations impact niche cell number, blood cell progenitor maintenance, plasmatocyte differentiation, crystal cell differentiation, DNA damage accumulation. Their results indicate that Gcn5 controls autophagy and show that reducing the expression of the autophagy machinery affect blood cell differentiation. By using drugs as well as genetic approaches to modulate the mTOR pathway, they found that Gcn5 levels are regulated by mTOR, but that the impact of this pathway on blood cell homeostasis can override Gcn5 function.

      Overall, the main conclusions are sound. They bring interesting insights into the regulation of autophagy by Gcn5 and mTOR and lay the ground for further dissections of Gcn5 function and mode of action during Drosophila lymph gland development.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors have modified the title, abstract and discussion to tune down some of their conclusion and provide a more nuanced interpretation of their data. They have also modified some figure panels as requested.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      In this paper, Pal and colleagues propose a mechanistic unification of two influential accounts of inter-areal communication: communication through coherence and communication subspaces. A major strength of the paper is that it does not treat coherence and communication subspaces as independent phenomena, as typically done, but instead derives both from the same circuit with divisive normalization. In this framework, noise-driven fluctuations around the normalized fixed point determine covariance and cross-power structure (which, in retrospect, makes so much sense to be related). Then, they show how these determine linear prediction performance and the effective dimensionality of the communication subspace. They also show (however not very visually, see recommendation below for a figure) how divisive normalization is crucial to shape inter-areal coherence and the dimensionality of communication.

      I found this conceptual contribution potentially very influential, but somewhat obscured by the technical complexity of the model. The central intuition (I think) is that recurrent normalization can organize cross-area fluctuations, both frequency-specific correlations and cross-covariances. Took me a while to grasp this insight, mostly because I was stuck with the model details. Note that I have some experience with network dynamics, but not with this particular model.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      This study was designed to manipulate and analyze the effects of chemosensory cues on visuomotor control. They approach this by analyzing how eye-body coordination and brain wide activity are altered with specific chemosensation in larval zebrafish. After analyzing the dynamics of coupled saccade-tail coordination sequences - directionally linked and typically coupled to body turns - the authors investigated the effects of sensory cues shown to be either aversive or appetitive on freely swimming zebrafish on the eye-body coordination. Aversive chemicals lead to an increase of saccade-tail sequences in both number and dynamics, seemingly facilitating behaviors like escape. Brain-wide imaging led the authors to neurons in the telencephalic pallium as a target to study eye-body coordination. Pallium neuron activity correlated with both aversive chemicals and coupled saccade-tail movements.

      Comments on revised version.

      The revised manuscript addresses my previous concerns.

    1. Reviewer #2 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Mione et al. aim to resolve a long-standing question in comparative neuroscience: whether the macaque brain contains a functional analogue to the distributed human multiple-demand (MD) network. To address this, they employ a direct cross-species fMRI comparison using a multi-step saccadic maze task in humans and a simplified two-step version in macaques. By contrasting goal-directed navigation against a control condition that requires similar motor responses but no strategic planning, the study isolates the neural signatures of cognitive control across species.

      Strengths:

      The most compelling aspect of this work is its methodological alignment. Previous attempts to compare these systems often relied on comparisons of human BOLD signals and macaque single-unit recordings. By running parallel fMRI protocols, the authors establish a shared measurement basis that allows for a more direct comparison. The resulting activation maps demonstrate conserved network topology in dorsolateral and dorsomedial frontal cortex and insula. Individual-level data are presented alongside a conjunction map across the two animals, with the threshold used to define common activations stated explicitly, and supplementary analyses restricted to correctly completed trials or using a smaller smoothing kernel leave the main features intact. This strengthens confidence in the frontal correspondences that appear robust.

      Weaknesses:

      A design asymmetry between the human and monkey tasks remains. In humans, 2-, 4- and 6-step problems were intermixed within blocks, whereas macaques solved only two-step trials. Because participants never know when a harder problem will occur, they may stay in a state of proactive cognitive control (Braver, 2012) throughout the block, which could inflate MD activation even during simpler trials and complicate direct comparison with the monkey data. The authors acknowledge this limitation but do not quantify or correct for the effect.

      Individual-level consistency for some claimed MD regions is limited. The two monkeys differ considerably in parietal cortex, and a conjunction analysis shows no common activation there even at a permissive threshold of t > 1.5. Strong dorsal/medial parietal and ventrolateral prefrontal activations were each seen in only one animal, and the abstract presents them accordingly. This is an honest presentation, but it leaves the evidence for these regions resting on one subject, so whether they can be regarded as part of a macaque MD network remains uncertain.

      In the Discussion, the authors conclude that results from single animals "tell against" genuine species differences in these regions. The implied reasoning appears to be that if macaques truly lacked parietal and ventrolateral prefrontal nodes, neither animal would have shown activation there. Since one monkey did show it, they take this as evidence that the regions are not genuinely different between species, attributing the other animal's absence to limited power or insufficient task demands. This inference is difficult to justify with only two animals and no common activation across them at any meaningful threshold. A single positive result does not establish that a region reliably belongs to the macaque MD network.

      Overall, this manuscript provides solid evidence for functional correspondence between human and macaque cognitive control networks in dorsomedial frontal cortex and insula. Individual-level data are presented transparently, with conjunction thresholds stated explicitly and limitations acknowledged throughout. What remains is largely interpretive. Given only two animals and no cross-animal convergence in parietal or ventrolateral prefrontal regions, claims that these form part of a macaque MD network should be read as provisional.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      Naina Gour and colleagues provide a detailed observational study in which they demonstrate that MRGPRX4, a human G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR), is expressed exclusively in human melanomas and, when expressed in mouse melanocytes, drives the development of melanomas in mice. These findings provide evidence that MRGPRX4 has the properties of an oncogene, at least in certain cellular environments.

      Strengths:

      A strength of this work is the nice historical note in which overexpression of MAS1, a GPCR, led to classic studies of transformed fibroblasts in culture and tumors in nude mice. Cloning of MAS1 led to the identification of the MRGPR family of receptors, now known to be key players in neuroimmune and neurosensory phenomena. Here, the story comes full circle with a member of the MRGPR family being linked to a tumor, specifically melanoma. Perhaps the story is not entirely surprising given that the neural crest serves as a precursor for both nerves and melanocytes. But it is nice to see.

      Additional strengths include the vast array of tools and techniques employed, from public databases to engineered mice, to establish firmly that MRGPRX4 is expressed in melanomas, although not in every malignant cell.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      This manuscript describes a chemical screen for activators of the eIF2 kinase GCN2 (EIF2AK4) in the integrated stress response (ISR). Recently, reported inhibitors of GCN2 and other protein kinases have been shown at certain concentrations to paradoxically activate GCN2. The study uses CHO cells and ISR reporter screens to identify a number of GCN2 activator compounds, including a potent "compound 20." These activators have implications for the development of new therapies for ISR-related diseases. For example, although not directly pursued in this study, these GCN2 activators could be helpful for the treatment of PVOD, which is reported for patients with certain GCN2 loss-of-function mutations. The identified activators are also suggested to engage with the GCN2 directly and can function devoid of GCN1, a co-activator of GCN2.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript appears to be a largely rigorous study that flows in a logical manner. The topic is interesting and significant.

      Weaknesses:

      Portions of the manuscript are not fully clear. There are some experimental presentation and design concerns that should be addressed to support the stated conclusions.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The manuscript by Kang et al. examines Gasdermin family member localization in keratinocytes and further reports that the PP2A inhibitor caliculyn A induces a pyroptosis-like morphology, presumably due to cytoskeletal disruption. Gasdermin A and B then translocate from the cytoskeleton to the membrane, where they enable keratin secretion without cleavage. The manuscript is well-controlled, and the data are convincing. The findings could be triangulated more effectively with additional microscopic studies to complement the fractionation experiments.

      My specific comments are as follows:

      (1) Nitrogen cavitation experiments and fluorescence microscopy have shown that the N-terminus of Gasdermin A first localizes to the mitochondrial membrane and then to the plasma membrane (Kondolf et al., JBC, 2024). The same was shown for GSDMD by Judy Lieberman's group in a 2024 Immunity paper. It is surprising that the fractionation experiments didn't include mitochondrial localization.

      (2) It appears that the blots in Figure 2 showing purity of fractionation (Lamin, LDHA, KRT19) are the same as those in Figure 1. I am assuming the experiment was performed at the same time. I think this should be made crystal clear, and it also raises the question of why not just include GSDMC in Figure 1, since they already have the other Gasdermins in that figure.

      (3) There's negative data in this manuscript, but I consider it important. Gasdermin antibodies are problematic, and caspase cleavage of GSDMC has been inconsistent. This negative data is important to share.

      (4) In Figure 1, why do GSDMD and GSDME show cleavage products without stimulation (minor point for curiosity)?

      (5) The fractionation experiments would be more convincing if they were complemented by microscopic localization. Antibodies might be an issue, but others have used fluorescent tags successfully (need to tag the Gasdermins internally).

      (6) PP2A is a broad serine-threonine phosphatase with hundreds of substrates. It's hard to rule in a cytoskeletal role to the exclusion of all the other changes caliculyn will cause - especially after 3 hours of exposure. A paragraph discussing this could be added to the Discussion. It's surprising that the authors don't disrupt the cytoskeleton in other ways.

      (7) I'm confused by the data in Figure 5C. Knocking down GSDMA and GSDMB causes no change in keratin release (and may even increase it). If the point of the manuscript is that these cause protein secretion, shouldn't there be a change? Do they affect secretion?

      (8) Along these lines, which GSDMB isoforms are present in the cell? It's well established that exon structure affects function.

      (9) Minor point for curiosity: N/TERT cells can be differentiated and can form organoids. Have the authors attempted to determine if differentiation affects their findings? This would be especially interesting given the different localizations of GSDMA and GSDMB in the layers of the skin.

      Overall, this manuscript provides valuable data for the field. Although it includes negative results, I believe sharing them is crucial. The experiments are well-executed and mostly convincing, though some aspects, particularly Figure 5C, appear contradictory. The manuscript would benefit from this reputable lab addressing the earlier points, especially the microscopic testing of the hypothesis.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Badarnee and colleagues analyse fMRI data collected during an associative threat-learning task. They find evidence for parallel processes mediated by the mediodorsal, LGn and pulvinar nuclei of the thalamus. The evidence for these conclusions is promising, but limited by a lack of clarity regarding the preprocessing and statistical methods.

      Strengths:

      The approach is inventive and novel, providing information about thalamocortical interactions that are scant in the current literature.

      Comments on revised version.

      No further comments. The authors have adequately addressed my concerns.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The study focuses on the characterization of drug‑tolerant persisters (DTPs), a subset of tumor cells that survive therapeutic elimination, in an experimental melanoma model (SKMEL5 cell line) under BRAF‑targeted therapy. Using single‑cell RNA sequencing combined with barcode‑based lineage tracing, the authors interrogate DTP heterogeneity and lineage origins. The major conceptual novelty claimed is a shift from an asserted "consensus view" in which DTPs are treated as distinct, uniform cell states, toward the inference that DTPs comprise a heterogeneous population of sub‑states within a single treatment‑defined regime. They also demonstrate, in this model, a lack of strong lineage bias in the emergence of DTPs. Finally, the authors refine and corroborate prior observations of shifts in calcium/ion‑channel regulation and increased ferroptosis sensitivity in DTPs.

      Strengths:

      The work offers a conceptually interesting reframing of DTPs, emphasizing population‑level heterogeneity and the existence of sub‑states. Even if the "consensus view" it challenges is somewhat overstated, this perspective is likely to stimulate further discussion and more nuanced DTP conceptualization.

      The combination of single‑cell transcriptomics with barcode‑based lineage tracing provides strong evidence, in the SKMEL5/PLX4720 model, that DTP origin is not limited to rare pre‑existing subpopulations. The observation that most lineages contribute to the idling DTP population, with relatively modest changes in abundance, provides a useful contrast to observations in other experimental systems.

      Integrated bulk RNA‑seq and bulk ATAC‑seq analyses showing concordant signatures across transcriptional and chromatin accessibility data provide useful systems‑level insights into how prolonged BRAF inhibition enriches ion‑transport and calcium‑handling pathways in idling DTP populations.

      Direct calcium‑flux experiments demonstrate reduced store‑operated calcium entry in idling DTPs despite similar ER Ca2+ content in untreated and treated cells. This functional assay provides a convincing, mechanistically interpretable readout that supports the proposed ion‑channel remodeling in the idling state.

      The use of a well‑characterized, widely used BRAFV600E melanoma line (SKMEL5) facilitates cross‑comparison with prior work on BRAF inhibitor responses in melanoma.

      Weaknesses:

      The central "state vs sub‑state" conceptual claim has two major issues. First, the "consensus view" that the authors assert (that DTPs are distinct, uniform cell states) is a straw man. The discreteness of phenotypic states depends on the resolution and interpretive framework (discrete categories versus continuum). I do not think there is a clear consensus on the discreteness of the DTP cell state. Much like the "clone vs subclone" dichotomy, "state vs substate" is typically used operationally rather than in reference to strictly defined biological entities. Therefore, the distinction the authors draw between "states" and "sub‑states" is a subtle reframing of the resolution hierarchy rather than a genuinely new challenge to a deeply held field‑wide belief. The shaky grounds of this distinction are reflected by the internal inconsistencies in the authors' own verbiage: in the introduction, the authors state the inference "idling DTP....are still composed of multiple phenotypic states," which directly contradicts the substate distinction. Second, the experimental evidence is insufficient for a meaningful distinction between states and substates. The distinction primarily relies on low‑dimensional PCA/UMAP representations in Figure 1, where therapy-naive cells form 2 clearly distinct clusters, while BRAFi collapses cells into a single cluster with 2 distinct subclusters. It is unclear if the structure will hold if additional dimensions are considered. Further, as the authors themselves note, the data are essentially snapshots rather than trajectories. Without explicit analysis of higher‑dimensional structure or time‑resolved state transitions, it is unclear that a meaningful distinction can be made.

      The findings are derived entirely from a single experimental model: one BRAFV600E melanoma cell line (SKMEL5) treated with a single research‑grade BRAF inhibitor (PLX4720). However, authors frequently use phrasing that implies broader generalizability to DTPs across cancers and therapies. This can be misleading, especially given convincing experimental evidence for distinct alternative scenarios in other systems. For example, DTPs emerging predominantly from specific rare subpopulations have been well documented in multiple experimental models, including melanoma models and BRAF inhibitors. The authors should more carefully delimit the scope of their conclusions to this particular melanoma/BRAFi model system context and more explicitly acknowledge where other systems have been shown to behave differently.

      Interpretation of the lack of an apparent bias in lineage tracing studies strongly depends on the magnitude of the selection bottleneck before the cells enter the idling DTP state. If a substantial fraction of cells do not make it to the DTP, then the finding poses a challenge to generalizations from other experimental systems. If most cells survive, then the lack of selection at the barcode level is trivial.

      The discussion of DTP heterogeneity and rare cell states would benefit from a more precise and balanced engagement with the existing literature. Some cited papers (including several reviews) are only loosely connected to the specific claims, while several highly relevant primary single‑cell studies on rare‑state variability and drug‑induced reprogramming (for example, work from the Shafer and Raj groups) is not explicitly discussed. This weakens the positioning of the proposed conceptual framework within the broader DTP/systems biology fields.

      Impact:

      In my opinion, the evidence presented in this work, in its current form, is insufficient to support the strong conceptual claims about the cell‑state architecture of DTPs. Nonetheless, the study makes a meaningful contribution by bringing a population‑level, dynamic perspective to understanding DTP biology. Even if one disagrees with the authors' interpretation, the work is valuable in pushing the field beyond the entrenched "gene A is a critical regulator of hallmark B in cancer C" mold and encourages more explicit consideration of phenotypic heterogeneity, trajectories, and treatment‑defined cell‑state landscapes when thinking about overcoming persistence and resistance.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      Cai et al. investigated the role of ripples in the hippocampus and coupled between hippocampus and neocortex in visual short-term memory (VSTM) using a similar lures match-to-sample task. The main findings are that hippocampal, but not neocortical ripples, ramp up during the maintenance period, peaking shortly before the memory response is given. This ramping up effect was stronger for correct compared to incorrect trials. Furthermore, the authors show that stimulus category could be better decoded during coupled hippocampo-neocortical ripples compared to uncoupled ripples. These results provide compelling novel evidence for a role of ripples in supporting human visual short-term memory.

      Strengths:

      (1) State-of-the-art intracranial EEG in 13 patients during a well-designed visual short-term memory task, with simultaneous hippocampal and neocortical recordings.

      (2) Thorough analysis pipeline with validation to detect ripple events and distinguish them from spurious ripple activity (i.e. as induced by IEDs).

      (3) Use of multi-variate classifiers to resolve neural representation of the stimuli.

      Comments on the latest version:

      I am fully satisfied with their responses and clarifications and I have no further comments.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      [Editors' note: this version has been assessed by the Reviewing Editor without further input from the original reviewers. The authors have addressed the comments raised in the previous round of review.]

      Summary:

      A fundamental technique for the identification of peptide-specific CD8 T cells is the use of fluorophore-conjugated and peptide loaded MHC tetramers. Classically, refolding of specific peptides with MHC monomers can be labour intensive, and not optimal for screening large numbers of different peptides. Hence, UV-exchanged tetramers have been developed to upscale this, however, still has some associated challenges such as UV-mediated damage to peptide complexes. Here, Pothast, C.R. et al demonstrate the efficacy of using temperature exchanged tetramers for the prevalent alleles HLA-A*03:01, A*11:01, B*07:02, and C*07:02. Building upon their previous work with HLA-A*02:01, H-2Kb, and HLA-E. They first demonstrate the complex stability of tetramers with different affinity peptides at high temperature, showing complex destabilisation can be rescued with higher affinity peptides. This is followed by an optimisation of peptide exchange temperatures, tailored for each allele. The authors then demonstrate successful binding to clonal T cell lines, and then a step further with viral peptides against PBMCs from individuals with confirmed infection history. For the latter they compare to conventional tetramers and demonstrate comparable signal.

      Due to the prevalence of these 4 alleles, the ease-of-handling, and short time requirements, these tetramers are likely to show high utility.

      Strengths:

      The manuscript is well-written and results are solid, although more detail may add clarity to some of the results, in particular figure 1 and 2. Other than the points reported below, the study uses accurate controls to demonstrate the specificity of the tetramers, and the data is convincing.

      Overall, their interpretation of the results is accurate and the discussion thorough, additional comments may be included to cover potential tetramer batch variability, and differences in the stability of different alleles. Specifically, whether certain alleles require higher affinity peptides to be stable, compared to others.

      Comments on revised version.

      The authors addressed the weaknesses highlighted in the previous version, specifically addressing that they do not conclude that thermal peptide exchange is not superior to existing technologies, but may be more feasible, as well as including a section on the stability of the different alleles and template peptides. The authors also updated the labelling and description of figures, making them much more interpretable. Addition of the LILRB1 reporter cell line to demonstrate successful peptide exchange and stability adds extra validity to the results.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      The authors have substantially strengthened the manuscript in response to my comments. In particular, they have improved the treatment of non-canonical calls, added further illustrative examples at the level of individual RNA variants, repeated pathway enrichment using an appropriate expression-matched background, assessed treatment-associated cell viability, and moderated several biological claims. The revised manuscript is now most compelling as a technical benchmarking and best-practice resource for high-confidence prediction of a common RNA chemical modification from nanopore direct RNA sequencing.

      The matched-input comparison of two methods, use of unmodified RNA controls, and inhibitor treatment are important strengths. Together, these experiments provide solid support for the central conclusion that careful filtering and appropriate controls can substantially reduce likely false-positive calls and yield a reproducible set of high-confidence predictions. The added analyses also provide useful illustrations of the capacity of long-read sequencing to assign predictions to individual RNA variants, although they do not establish broad superiority over the short-read comparison method.

      A few claims remain insufficiently supported. First, the discussion of non-DRACH sites should cite Cancer mutations rewire the RNA methylation specificity of METTL3-METTL14 (Science Advances, DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.ads4750). In particular, Figure 3C of that study shows that the normal METTL3-METTL14 enzyme retains measurable activity on non-DRACH substrates; this provides a useful precedent for describing the inhibitor-sensitive GGAUU calls as plausible candidates rather than treating non-DRACH calls, especially those detected only by GLORI, as presumptively artefactual. The revised manuscript appropriately notes technical and biological explanations for non-canonical calls and identifies the GGAUU sites as candidates requiring further validation, but this additional context would improve interpretation.

      Second, the comparison between Dorado and GLORI remains overinterpreted. The matched-input design and inhibitor perturbation are important strengths, but the current analysis does not establish that sites detected only by GLORI are false positives or that Dorado is a reference standard. This would require, for example, direct comparison of inhibitor responsiveness among GLORI-only and shared sites, while accounting for coverage, conversion efficiency, and other method-specific biases; therefore, phrases such as "GLORI exhibits reduced specificity," "largely spurious," and "validated by an orthogonal approach" are not fully supported by the data presented.

      Similarly, the thresholding approach should not be described as "unbiased." The analysis is useful and empirically informed, but it relies on selected parameters, a manually specified penalty, and predetermined decision criteria. Describing the procedure as "data-driven" or "empirically calibrated against matched unmodified RNA controls" would more accurately convey both its value and its limitations.

      The additional RNA-variant examples are helpful, but they demonstrate an advantage of long-read data rather than broadly proving that Dorado "outperforms" GLORI for RNA-variant-level quantification. A more accurate formulation would be: "Direct RNA sequencing provides RNA-variant-resolved predictions that are not readily assignable using short-read GLORI data, as illustrated at several loci."

      Finally, the authors now acknowledge that the functional significance of cell-type differences remains unresolved, but the abstract still presents the results as evidence of "finely tuned" regulation, and the discussion links them to neuronal function. The data provide solid evidence for differences in predicted modification proportions between cell types, but the evidence is incomplete for claims about functional consequences; these statements should therefore be framed as context or hypotheses for future study rather than as inferences from the present experiments.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The authors aim to study mutational paths connecting WW domains with different binding specificities. Their approach combines an unsupervised sequence generative model based on RBMs with a path-sampling algorithm. The key result is that most intermediate sequences along the designed transition paths retain measurable binding activity in wet-lab assays, whereas paths containing the same mutations introduced in a randomized order are largely non-functional. This difference is attributed to epistatic interactions captured by the RBM model.

      Strengths:

      Exploring mutational paths in high-dimensional protein sequence space is a challenging problem. The computational framework used here is state-of-the-art and is strengthened by systematic experimental characterization of binding activity. The study is comprehensive in scope, including multiple transition paths both within and across WW specificity classes, and the integration of modeling with high-throughput experimental validation is a clear strength.

    1. Reviewer #1 (Public review):

      Summary:

      The study describes the migration of epidermal keratinocytes through porous membranes and observed a unique size selection whereby only on 3-micron membrane are keratinocytes able to migrate and reform an intact epidermis. The authors propose that the model replicates three cell states of intact epidermis, EMT, and MET. They also show that this response depends on the actin cytoskeleton, keratin 6, and Piezo1, and the migration could be stimulated with TGFbeta ligands.

      Strengths:

      Strengths of the study include the establishment of a simple yet robust in vitro model that capture all three cell states, which could be useful for future investigation of wound healing or metastasis across a range of epithelia. There is also good quantitative characterisation of the pore size effects, providing some interesting observations about the physical regulation of keratinocyte migration, and the study provides some initial insights into the regulatory mechanisms. The images and presentation are clear.

      Weaknesses:

      While there are some insights into the underlying mechanisms, there could be more detailed analysis of the key signalling pathways and functional relationships between actin, keratins, Piezo, and EMT genes. Although the extent of new biological insight is somewhat limited, the study still demonstrates the utility of the model, and these points may be important questions to address in future studies.