On 2016 Feb 05, James Murray commented:
The superoxide dependent nitrogenase described in this
(Ribbe M, 1997) paper is extremely unlikely to exist.
The paper describes the purification of the
components of an oxygen-tolerant nitrogenase, not homologous to the
known nif,vnf, or anf-type, from Streptomyces
thermoautotrophicus UBT1, a thermophilic carboxydotroph.
Results published in February 2016 (MacKellar D, 2016) show that
three independent isolates of S. thermoautotrophicus, including the
original UBT1 strain, do not grow in the absence of combined nitrogen
and are incapable of incorporating isotopically labelled dinitrogen
into biomass, nor do they contain the claimed superoxide dependent
nitrogenase genes. The N-terminal sequences assigned to nitrogenase
components in Ribbe M, 1997, and the full DNA gene sequences in the
PhD thesis of Carla Hofmann-Findeklee (2000, KF951061.1, KF951060.1,
KF951059.1, KF956113.1) are found at near-identity in Bacillus
schlegelii DSM9132 (recently renamed to Hydrogenibacillus
schlegelii, "SdnMSL-like" sequences in KT861421.1), a
non-diazotrophic thermophilic carboxydotrophic organism isolated in
the Meyer lab (Krüger & Meyer, 1984) and known to be cultured in the
Meyer laboratory in 1994 (Hänzelmann, 1994). The independently
isolated B. schlegelii DSM2000 strain also has these sequences at
near-identity. The closest relatives to these sequences are to
Firmicutes and not Actinomycetes like S. thermoautotrophiucs. The
four "nitrogenase" sequences are easily identified as encoding a
superoxide dismutase ("st2", sdnO), and a three-subunit aerobic
carbon monoxide dehydrogenase ("st1", sdnMSL).
Ribbe M, 1997 relies on an ammonia production assay to determine the
nitrogenase activity. This assay is known to have a high background
due to environmental ammonia and protein deamination. Incorporation
of isotopically labelled dinitrogen is usually considered the gold
standard for the identification of a nitrogenase enzyme. No
incorporation of isotopically labelled nitrogen into ammonia is shown
using the claimed biochemical nitrogenase preparation. The cells were
grown in media with 1.5 g/l ammonium chloride, so there was no
selection for diazotrophy. No published demonstration of the
superoxide dependent nitrogenase has occurred outside the Meyer
laboratory.
The nitrogenase scheme described in Ribbe M, 1997 is chemically and
biologically implausible. There is no known ATPase domain, as required
by the proposed reaction scheme, in any of the described proteins. The
known nitrogenase types require the highly reducing ferredoxin or
flavodoxin as reductants. Superoxide is an unlikely electron donor
for a nitrogenase, as it is not as reducing as even NADPH or NADH, and
is reactive and toxic. No other biologically productive use of
superoxide as an electron donor is known. An aerobic reduction of
nitrogen to ammonia is unknown, and unlikely, as under the highly
reducing conditions, oxygen would most probably be reduced in
preference to nitrogen. The rate of activity described is too low to
be that of a biological enzyme supporting diazotrophic growth, as it
would take the proposed nitrogenase over 100 hours just to replace the
nitrogen in the enzyme itself, which is also incompatible with the
claimed rate of diazotrophic growth of S. thermoautotrophicus
(Gadkari D, 1992).
To summarize:
Recent evidence suggests that three independently isolated strains of S. thermoautotrophicus are not diazotrophic.
If the Meyer laboratory did contaminate their
S. thermoautotrophicus culture with a strain of B. schlegelii
(such as the DSM9132 strain), we would observe the N-terminal
sequences presented here and the DNA gene sequences also produced
in the Meyer laboratory.
The extremely low activity "nitrogenase" was described based on a problematic ammonia production assay.
A superoxide-dependent aerobic nitrogenase is chemically and biologically implausible.
Declaration: I am an author on the MacKellar D, 2016 paper, but this comment is entirely my own.
References:
Bernd Krüger and Ortwin Meyer. Thermophilic bacilli growing with carbon monoxide. Archives of Microbiology, 139(4):402–408, 1984.
Petra Hänzelmann. Isolierung und Charakterisierung von Kohlenmonoxid-Dehydrogenase aus dem obligat thermophilen
Bakterium Bacillus schlegelii. Diplomarbeit thesis, University of Bayreuth, 1994.
Carla Hofmann-Findeklee. Molekularbiologische Untersuchung der Strukturgene des aeroben N2-fixierenden Systems von Streptomyces thermoautotrophicus sowie funktionelle Charakterisierung von rekombinantem SdnO. PhD thesis, University of Bayreuth, 2000.
This comment, imported by Hypothesis from PubMed Commons, is licensed under CC BY.