Diversity and Inclusion vs. Equity and Social Justice
- Jul 2017
-
www.insidehighered.com www.insidehighered.com
-
- Jun 2017
-
Local file Local fileuntitled1
-
The digital humanities as a humanitiesproject
Svensson, Patrik. 2012. “The Digital Humanities as a Humanities Project.” Arts and Humanities in Higher Education 11 (1–2): 42–60. doi:10.1177/1474022211427367.
-
-
lucumr.pocoo.org lucumr.pocoo.org
-
I think it's natural for like-minded people to group together but the longer that process continues the more of an echo chamber it becomes. What's worse is the longer you wait to try to get people involved in the project that would naturally not try to join the harder it will be. When your team is 4 men, the first woman which joins will make a significant impact. When your team is already 20 men you need to get a lot more women on board to have the same impact. But it's not just gender that is making a difference, it's in particular cultural backgrounds. The reason Unicode is hard is not because Unicode is hard, but because a lot of projects start out with a lack of urgency since many of the original developers might live in ASCII constrained environments (It took emojis to become popular for people to develop a general understanding of why Unicode is useful in the western world).
First time I've seen the slowness of emoji to be presented as a diversity issue. Given how well used they are, it's a good example of how diverse teams miss features that may seem obvious in retrospect.
-
- May 2017
-
www.theguardian.com www.theguardian.com
-
“organise the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful”.
Google obviously wants to have all the answers to all possible absurd questions. The danger with this goal is that they positioned the persons that represents part of the diversity of the world as not worthy of being treated with respect.
-
- Feb 2017
-
-
Mirror Activity
This and the next activity are good to explore diverse identities – or uniformity of some identity dimensions – in a group.
-
Circles handout
That's probably something like this: https://www.mnscu.edu/system/equity/documents/Danger%20of%20a%20single%20story%20circle%20handout.pdf
-> or see p. 16
-
Circles of My Multicultural Self
Good activity to explore the multiple identities, combinations of identities, and intersectionalities of individual persons. Use?
-
-
www.difficultdialoguesuaa.org www.difficultdialoguesuaa.org
-
A reflective writing technique that encourages personal reflection, provides opportunities for all voices to be heard, and leads to deeper, more thoughtful conversations
Shared Writing: This seems particularly useful for online conversations that are asynchronous, as it is based on reading statements, commenting on them, and passing the comments around.
-
Hatful of Quotes
Like this one, particularly if quotes are well-chosen, especially in a larger group that otherwise has not done much reading/thought about questions of privilege, discrimination, and marginalized experiences.
-
circLE oFobJEcts
I like this activity if the aim is to make personal connections and get to know the individuals involved in a learning group. As a result, probably best for a small group. Requires some preparation as participants have to be asked to bring an object to the meeting.
-
80Identity Groups
Interesting activity. Question: Is this useful in a larger group, or only in a smaller group? The calling-out portion enables people to participate without talking, which accommodates larger numbers; but the exposure can be intimidating – particularly for students, who then may just stay put. Maybe start with "easy" identity groups – sports team supporters? – that people are willing to show? Or would this undermine what the conversation should be about?
The discussion portion may get out of hand in a larger group; may need subgroup formation.
-
- Jan 2017
-
www.theatlantic.com www.theatlantic.com
-
“really disrupt and complexify ... what they believe they know about race [and] students or families who live in poverty.”
-
- Dec 2016
-
www.theguardian.com www.theguardian.com
-
“Because you don’t come up with the right answer if everyone at the table looks the same and thinks the same and has the same experience – you never come up with the best answer. So when you get these seats at these tables of power, your obligation is to make sure the conversation is diverse.”
Well said.
-
- Nov 2016
-
artstor.wordpress.com artstor.wordpress.com
-
Many Latin American countries hold similar celebrations, with some colorful regional differences: In Ecuador, the Day of the Dead is observed with ceremonial foods such as colada morada, a spiced fruit porridge, and guagua de pan, a bread shaped like a swaddled infant
Different traditions in many places for the same holiday.
-
- Oct 2016
-
artstor.wordpress.com artstor.wordpress.com
-
celebrate the season, there are thousands of suitably macabre images in the Artstor Digital Library
museum for halloween images all over,
-
Guatemalans build and fly giant kites
-
Ecuador, the Day of the Dead is observed with ceremonial foods
celebrated by having their cutures favorite food.
-
Many Latin American countries hold similar celebrations, with some colorful regional differences:
same but different
-
People in Mexico often build altars using brightly decorated sugar skulls, marigolds (popularly known as Flor de Muerto, “Flower of the Dead”),
differnt beliefs within a culture
-
the celebration conflates the Catholic holidays with an Aztec festival dedicated to a goddess called Mictecacihuatl, the “Lady of the Dead.”
Aztecs honor a god
-
Mexico is known as Día de los Muertos, “Day of the Dead,”
Honor the dead in Mexico
-
Roman Catholic heritage, All Saints Day and All Souls Day (November 2)
different day for a different religion with a different reason.
-
- Sep 2016
-
www.educationdive.com www.educationdive.com
-
As many universities are being queried by the federal government on how they spend their endowment money, and enrollment decreases among all institutions nationally, traditional campuses will need to look at these partnerships as a sign of where education is likely going in the future, and what the federal government may be willing to finance with its student loan programs going ahead.
To me, the most interesting about this program is that it sounds like it’s targeting post-secondary institutions. There are multiple programs to “teach kids to code”. Compulsory education (primary and secondary) can provide a great context for these, in part because the type of learning involved is so broad and pedagogical skills are so recognized. In post-secondary contexts, however, there’s a strong tendency to limit coding to very specific contexts, including Computer Science or individual programs. We probably take for granted that people who need broad coding skills can develop them outside of their college and university programs. In a way, this isn’t that surprising if we’re to compare coding to very basic skills, like typing. Though there are probably many universities and colleges where students can get trained in typing, it’s very separate from the curriculum. It might be “college prep”, but it’s not really a college prerequisite. And there isn’t that much support in post-secondary education. Of course, there are many programs, in any discipline, giving a lot of weight to coding skills. For instance, learners in Digital Humanities probably hone in their ability to code, at some point in their career. And it’s probably hard for most digital arts programs to avoid at least some training in programming languages. It’s just that these “general” programs in coding tend to focus almost exclusively on so-called “K–12 Education”. That this program focuses on diversity is also interesting. Not surprising, as many such initiatives have to do with inequalities, real or perceived. But it might be where something so general can have an impact in Higher Education. It’s also interesting to notice that there isn’t much in terms of branding or otherwise which explicitly connects this initiative with colleges and universities. Pictures on the site show (diverse) adults, presumably registered students at universities and colleges where “education partners” are to be found. But it sounds like the idea of a “school” is purposefully left quite broad or even ambiguous. Of course, these programs might also benefit adult learners who aren’t registered at a formal institution of higher learning. Which would make it closer to “para-educational” programs. In fact, there might something of a lesson for the future of universities and colleges.
-
As many universities are being queried by the federal government on how they spend their endowment money, and enrollment decreases among all institutions nationally, traditional campuses will need to look at these partnerships as a sign of where education is likely going in the future, and what the federal government may be willing to finance with its student loan programs going ahead.
To me, the most interesting about this program is that it sounds like it’s targeting post-secondary institutions. There are multiple programs to “teach kids to code”. Compulsory education (primary and secondary) can provide a great context for these, in part because the type of learning involved is so broad and pedagogical skills are so recognized. In post-secondary contexts, however, there’s a strong tendency to limit coding to very specific contexts, including Computer Science or individual programs. We probably take for granted that people who need broad coding skills can develop them outside of their college and university programs. In a way, this isn’t that surprising if we’re to compare coding to very basic skills, like typing. Though there are probably many universities and colleges where students can get trained in typing, it’s very separate from the curriculum. It might be “college prep”, but it’s not really a college prerequisite. And there isn’t that much support in post-secondary education. Of course, there are many programs, in any discipline, giving a lot of weight to coding skills. For instance, learners in Digital Humanities probably hone in their ability to code, at some point in their career. And it’s probably hard for most digital arts programs to avoid at least some training in programming languages. It’s just that these “general” programs in coding tend to focus almost exclusively on so-called “K–12 Education”. That this program focuses on diversity is also interesting. Not surprising, as many such initiatives have to do with inequalities, real or perceived. But it might be where something so general can have an impact in Higher Education. It’s also interesting to notice that there isn’t much in terms of branding or otherwise which explicitly connects this initiative with colleges and universities. Pictures on the site show (diverse) adults, presumably registered students at universities and colleges where “education partners” are to be found. But it sounds like the idea of a “school” is purposefully left quite broad or even ambiguous. Of course, these programs might also benefit adult learners who aren’t registered at a formal institution of higher learning. Which would make it closer to “para-educational” programs. In fact, there might something of a lesson for the future of universities and colleges.
-
- Jul 2016
-
medium.com medium.com
-
what is the English-speaking world missing out on by not reading the content written in other languages
Though he’s been associated with a very strange idea he never had, Edward Sapir was quite explicit about this loss over a hundred years ago. Thinking specifically about a later passage warning people about the glossocide English language. But it’s been clear in his work from long before that excerpt that we’re missing out when we focus on a single language.
-
people who are not fluent in English
In this case, it can apply to quite a few academics who are native speakers of one of the aforementioned “world languages”. Difficult to be a monolingual academic in an exclusively local language. Much easier as a French- or Mandarin-speaker to become an academic without learning much English. And speaking of monolinguals, there is a clear bias in tech towards monolingualism.
-
the voice of the rest of the world
-
a handful in a few major world languages
One might think that those other languages are well-represented. People connected with the Open Knowledge Foundation are currently tackling this very issue. Here, Open Education isn’t just about content.
-
A Postcolonial Look at the Future of #EdTech
Timely. Sent it to a few people, already, as it connects with several discussions we’ve been having on neocolonialism in EdTech, including the content side of Open Education (OER). Some of it reminds me of Crissinger’s critical take on OER, based on her experience with Open Access.
Tags
- ethnolinguistics
- global inequalities
- Open Knowledge Foundation
- Open Education
- monolinguals
- #EdTech
- language diversity
- #xMOOC #cMOOC
- #IvanIllich
- ethnocentrism
- giving voice
- MOOC Hype
- empowerment
- linguistic diversity
- World Languages
- OER
- Neocolonialism
- cultural diversity
- diversity
- language survival
- postcolonialism
- sociolinguistics
- Language Insecurity
Annotators
URL
-
-
www.educationdive.com www.educationdive.com
-
closing the “digital use divide.”
Speaking of the diversity embedded in divides…
-
-
www.edtechmagazine.com www.edtechmagazine.com
-
Bridging the Digital Divide
Really wish people were to consider the multiple divides which affect digital inclusion. That notion has been a significant part of the subtext in our Cyberspace sociology course. Explicitly discussed here: doi:10.1111/jcom.12045 It’s a bit like Belshaw’s use of the plural to discuss literacies. Makes it more difficult to claim that we’ve completely solved the issue if we acknowledge its diversity and complexity.
-
-
campustechnology.com campustechnology.com
-
help TAs — especially those from other countries
-
While TAs are intended to help students understand the material, their teaching skills vary and they come at the job with widely different backgrounds.
-
The ultimate goal of the project is to support improved teaching and learning in university classrooms by bridging cultural divides between students and their teachers.
Did not expect this line of thinking, from the headline.
-
-
www.educationdive.com www.educationdive.com
-
there is some disparity and implicit bias
-
-
-
make money for Californian white people
The Man is Californian.
-
At Google, I'll be encouraged to take annual Bias-Busting training, gathering with other privileged honkeys to encourage one another's virtuous respect of black coworkers we don't have.
-
Google decided to close Atlanta engineering, and they mainly went as a group to Square
-
-
-
It creates resentment towards minorities because you are forced to take take this training that treats them like charity cases which in turn encourages the “lowering the bar” mentality.
-
It encourages thinking that “you’ve done your part” since you’ve been taken training on diversity
-
feel they are extremely open minded & tolerant
Self-reported open-mindedness is a bit like bragging about being “cool”.
-
technical interviews are completely worthless as a predictor for whether someone is a good hire or not
-
-
medium.com medium.com
-
We believe that America’s diversity is our strength.
Apart from the political context for such statements, it’s interesting to note that a link between innovation and diversity is made more frequently in technology than in education (where diversity is taken as a challenge).
-
-
www.educationdive.com www.educationdive.com
-
Black students in these schools took AP Physics at almost 11 times the rate as black students elsewhere, and they passed the exams at 3.4 times the rate
1100% is a lot of percent.
-
-
mfeldstein.com mfeldstein.com
-
How does the increasing diversity of our student population make good teaching more challenging and what is the best approach to meeting that challenge?
At the same time, this is partly a loaded question. From another perspective (say, in anthro), diversity is richness. It’s part of a broader context. Teachers do need to vent about new challenges. Some may even think that diversity is what makes their lives more difficult. And they may wish for that time when all students were exactly alike.
-
- Jun 2016
-
www.nybooks.com www.nybooks.comWords1
-
“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.”
-
-
www.theatlantic.com www.theatlantic.com
-
The War on Stupid People
Lots of difficult things with this text, including the title. The obsession on measurable “smarts” is an important topic and the possible measures to prevent this obsession from impacting (US) society make sense. But it’s really tricky to discuss intelligence in such ways. Part of the text reads as further essentialisation of measured intelligence. Yet it sounds clear from the possible measures described that this form of intelligence takes at least part of its meaning in a given social context.
Maybe the deep issue with a text like this is that it’s hard to get people to shift from one consistent mindframe (paradigm, episteme) to another. More specifically, it’s hard to discuss intelligence in a context where the concept has become so loaded.
Would have lots more to say about this from my parents’ experiences (an occupational therapist who spent a career with people labelled as having “intellectual disabilities” and a psychopedagogue who worked in “special education” with students from a low-income neighbourhood who had “learning disabilities”). Maybe later.
-
-
googleforeducation.blogspot.com googleforeducation.blogspot.com
-
we need to broaden perceptions and stereotypes of CS
Though it’s probably a simple mistake, the notion that Google is “broadening … stereotypes of CS” might have some truth to it.
-
-
www.newyorker.com www.newyorker.com
-
Prescriptivists dislike the use of “impact” as a verb
Glad Anglophone prescriptivists aren’t having their way. If they did, chances are that the language would have a similar fate to German as a colonial language. Chances are that a predilection for normative language has greatly impacted language insecurity among Francophones.
-
- Apr 2016
-
hapgood.us hapgood.us
-
preservation of divergent goals
-
- Nov 2015
-
chronicle.com chronicle.com
-
may not transfer well across borders because of language and context
Can we embrace diversity?
-
-
blog.mahabali.me blog.mahabali.me
-
Because the sad thing about empathy is that we are more likely to be empathetic toward people who remind us of ourselves. Where it is easier to imagine ourselves in their shoes. On a second level, we are more likely to empathize with a group of people of whom we know some personally (or at least we know of/about them) because in reality I deeply believe that most people are good. And so if you know enough people of a certain category, most of them will be good. When we don’t know anyone from a certain category we are likely to dehumanize them
-
-
www.edsurge.com www.edsurge.com
-
particularly for women of color.
-
college was never quite as uniform as we thought it was
Again, the “Myth of the average student”.
-
wide range of metacognitive skills
http://tedxtalks.ted.com/video/The-Myth-of-Average-Todd-Rose-a
-
open access
Not really what we tend to mean by “open access” in academia, but closer to “open education” than one might assume. It can be less about the cost of textbooks than about inclusion. And diversity.
-
- Dec 2013
-
www.garann.com www.garann.com
-
Well-intentioned (and grammatically correct) though it may be, changing pronouns has very little impact on inclusivity. When you’re starting from a default position of exclusivity, when people automatically associate you with the tone-deaf cringefests that are one of open source’s worst problems, when people see your community and your leadership and find very few diverse participants, when your actions don’t illustrate how people can play a role if they won’t prove themselves better coders than those already involved, hanging up a sign saying “no one is disallowed” is not going to be enough. Saying you want to be inclusive does not create a culture of inclusivity.
Actions, not words.
-
- Oct 2013
-
rhetoric.eserver.org rhetoric.eserver.org
-
Foreign words, like men, and like many of our institutions, have come to us, I might almost say, from all nations.
Language is formed on complex interactions and has many histories, especially English. It cannot be classified as our language and other language because these so often overlap
-