BLOG: How NOT to Answer the Salary Question
- The article argues that answering the "What is your current/expected salary?" question with a single number is a strategic mistake that limits your earning potential.
- Giving a specific number early in the process creates an "anchor" that recruiters will use to keep the offer as low as possible.
- Instead of providing a number, the author suggests pivoting the conversation toward the value you bring to the role and the total compensation package.
- A key strategy is to ask for the company's budgeted range for the position first, which puts the onus on the employer to disclose their limits.
- If forced to give a range, ensure the bottom of your range is the minimum you would actually accept, while the top represents your "dream" scenario.
- The goal of salary discussions in early interviews should be to establish "alignment" rather than a final price tag.
- Delaying the specific salary talk until after you have "wowed" the team gives you more leverage, as they are now invested in hiring you specifically.
Hacker News Discussion
- Many commenters emphasize that while "not answering" is a common piece of advice, it can be impractical for those who lack extreme leverage or are in urgent need of work.
- A popular counter-strategy mentioned is to confirm the salary range during the very first recruiter call to avoid wasting hours on interviews for a role that cannot meet your financial requirements.
- Users suggested that if you do provide a number first, you should always include a disclaimer that you "look at the entire package holistically" (benefits, equity, PTO) to maintain flexibility for later negotiation.
- There is a consensus that once a final offer is made, you should almost always ask, "Is there any way you can come up a little bit from that?" as this simple question frequently results in a 5-10% bump with minimal risk.
- Some participants shared "pleasant surprise" stories where refusing to name a price led to offers significantly higher (+50% or more) than what they would have asked for.
- The discussion highlights a shift toward transparency, with many noting that asking for the "salary band" is becoming a standard and respected practice in tech hiring.