- Apr 2014
-
www.newschallenge.org www.newschallenge.org
-
$10,000
$10K for several people over 2 years, including hotels, seems low.
-
$60,000
Will $30,000 cover all of a workshop?
-
$110,000
perhaps a range? "$100,000-$130,000", to give us some wiggle room.
-
In ONE sentence, tell us about your project to strengthen the Internet for free expression and innovation.
Talk about a new class of application and service, not just one application?
-
open-source implementation
"open-source reference implementation"
-
use-communities
typo? or just confusion grammar?
-
however if we can identify the primary subcomponents of annotation and enable their inclusion directly into web browser applications, user interactions will be noticeably smoother.
"however, by identifying the primary subcomponents of annotation, which has substantial overlap with in-browser editing–such as text selection, copying, and finding text–we can expedite their inclusion into web browsers, and user interactions will be noticeably smoother."
-
broadest possible array of use cases and needs inform the standards process
this could be read as "hypothetical". I suggest: "a broad set of the most common use cases and needs..."
-
W3C convened contributors to the Open Annotation Community Group to draft the elements of a charter for a formal Working Group on Web Annotations.
"W3C convened a workshop bringing together key stakeholders, including contributors to the Open Annotation Community Group, to draft..."
-
We believe we have effective approaches for these and other challenges, but further development and wider testing are still needed.
This undercuts the need for native implementation... maybe mention both here?
-
We assume that there is a need for annotation that the web does not presently satisfy.
Mention sites like Medium and others who are moving to an annotation-based UI to improve their reader experience. This is concrete evidence for the need for annotation.
-
.
also include: ", and a decentralized architecture that allows a user to publish in any of their preferred communities rather than a single monolithic publisher."
-
The vast majority of the web is dark to interaction of any kind. When it does exist, usually it is in the form of the comment widget which restricts conversations to general discussions of the whole article, making targeted discussion of specific assertions or facts more difficult. As a consequence, traditional commenting leads to sprawling, lower quality discussions which are difficult to manage and awkward to navigate.
Mention ability to follow a user or community contribution across multiple sites, not just isolated articles?
-
While the idea of a generalized conversation layer over the web has captured the imaginations of many for decades, we have tested this assumption ourselves in more focused ways.
trim for brevity
-
(spelling
(e.g., spelling
-
conduct their own research: annotating and organizing source material, saving links back to original context, enabling searches through this material and facilitating private discussions with other collaborators in those locations.
odd grammatical construction/transition
-
- Jan 2014
-
www.theatlantic.com www.theatlantic.com
-
The process of tying two items together is the important thing.
Annotations are at the Web’s core.
-
-
support.mozilla.org support.mozilla.org
-
Bookmarks are just a special case of annotations
-
-
www.annotationframework.org www.annotationframework.org
-
Great feature set for annotation organization and text mining, with videos
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
twitter.com twitter.com
-
Feature list of annotations, Diigo vs Delicious
-
-
twitter.com twitter.com
-
Need a place to post websites w/ descriptions and tags
Interesting crowdsourced thread on annotation-like services.
-
-
usspost.com usspost.com
-
"Is Pinterest Illegal?" Interesting implications for annotating images
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
www.teleread.com www.teleread.com
-
The ReadSocial people are the same ones who brought us BookGlutton. They have branched out into new areas. Publishers should be looking at Readsocial carefully. It provides a relatively painless way to create a social network around their books, magazines, articles, etc. The network can flow across different reading systems and the virtual groups can connect down to the paragraph level. I think it would be extremely useful for such things as travel books and college guides.
Might be of interest for API for social, annotations, or digipub in general.
-
-
www.elasticsearch.org www.elasticsearch.org
-
javascript web applications and elasticsearch
Good article on using ElasticSearch with JS
-
-
todomvc.com todomvc.comTodoMVC1
-
Developers these days are spoiled with choice when it comes to selecting an MV* framework for structuring and organizing their JavaScript web apps.
Cool project to help choose a framework, by building an app that uses each framework.
-
-
blog.stevensanderson.com blog.stevensanderson.com
-
Rich JavaScript Applications – the Seven Frameworks (Throne of JS, 2012)
Good summary of JS frameworks
-
-
www.quora.com www.quora.com
-
What are the some of the challenges that we are going to face in the next 5 years?
Interesting analysis of Node.js's possible strengths.
-
-
substack.net substack.net
-
node aesthetic.
Read for reference on Node.js conventions
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
journal.paul.querna.org journal.paul.querna.org
-
We use @Caolan's excellent Async library. Our code is not 5 level deep nested callbacks. We currently have about 45,000 lines of Javascript in our main repository. In this code base, we have used the async library as our only flow control library. Our current use of the library in our code base: async.waterfall: 74 async.forEach: 55 async.forEachSeries: 21 async.series: 8 async.parallel: 4 async.queue: 3 I highly suggest, that if you are unsure about Node.js and are going to do an experiment project, make sure you use Async, Step, or one of the other flow control modules for your experiment. It will help you better understand how most larger Node.js applications are built.
Considerations for building on Node.js
-
We decided to make a spreadsheet of the possible environments we would consider using for our next generation product. The inputs were: Community Velocity Correctness (aka, static typing-like things) Debuggability/Tooling Downtime/Compile Time Libraries (Standard/External) Testability Team Experience Performance Production We setup the spreadsheet so we could change the weight of each category. This let us play with our feelings, what if we only cared about developer velocity? What if we only cared about testability?
Good considerations for selecting a platform.
-
-
www.zdnet.com www.zdnet.com
-
Oliver Marks
Talk to Marks about DCS and annotation.
-
-
www.zdnet.com www.zdnet.com
-
"Reframeit can help curb the power of misinformation to distort our national conversation about issues that matter. Anyone who cares about the quality of public dialogue in this country should welcome the transparency it makes possible," notes Harvard professor Henry Louis Gates, Jr., Director of the W.E.B. Du Bois Institute and co-founder of The Root.
Endorsement by HL Gates. Good idea to seek endorsements by well-known or respected people.
-
This has strong implications for both outbound marketing usage and internal contextual notes.
more ad stuff
-
A case could be made for a sponsored channel - so Nike could have runner's reframeit notes appended to their rivals sites and to user forums for example. If you subscribed to this channel you would see Nike's perspective on all pages on the web they chose to mark up.
Advertising tool
-
For a rapidly changing page, such as a heavily edited wiki, reframeit could prove somewhat redundant as content is removed or heavily edited, but for core content the power of this tool is evident.
Need for editing tool integration or issue tracking workflow tags
-
The matrix of 'channels' you share comments with can be deep: the same page could have several sets of your notes appended to it for specific groups of viewers with specific interests.
Good use for "groups"
-
Comments can be framed as a General Comment, Question, Counter or Supporting Argument, Suggestion, Explanation, Answer, Cause or Effect from a pull down menu above the field where you type your comments.
Common categories for tags
-
intriguing from a workflow perspective is the ability to add notes to internal web applications, so notes can be appended to specific products for example to provide everything from training to departmental feedback
use case
-
Providing context to specific content is key to so much of web communication and the holy grail of social media marketing practitioners.
Use case
-
From a commercial perspective an example could be marking up your competitor's web site and sharing it with your sales team, who can continue to update their contextual notes in the field.
Use case
-
video above demonstrates marking up the transcript of a political speech with associated facts and links using reframeit that will be associated with specific areas of that content for as long as you want them to be.
Use Media Fragments on video
-
-
www.theguardian.com www.theguardian.com
-
Let's rethink the idea of the state: it must be a catalyst for big, bold ideas
Reframe role of government
-
-
web.law.columbia.edu web.law.columbia.edu
-
This map requires Adobe Flash Player.
Get the data and ask them to redraw it using D3.js
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
ivn.us ivn.us
-
The formula is simple: divide the population by the number of congressional or legislative districts and use the existing geo-political boundaries to come as close to the required number as possible.
How can we get this enacted/mandated?
-
-
www.theatlantic.com www.theatlantic.com
-
The federal government already spends enough on student aid to cover tuition for every public college student in America. Maybe it's time to try.
How can we start this moving in Congress?
-
- Dec 2013
-
docs.webplatform.org docs.webplatform.org
-
canonical URL
In W3C parlance, this is probably the "shortname", like w3.org/TR/SVG/.
-
annotation modes
This might be enabled by the planned "groups" feature, along with common hashtags for that group added through the group admin interface.
-
Provide status states
This feels like phase 2 or 3, but could be phase 1 if it's based on existing tag infrastructure
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
- Nov 2013
-
epubjs-reader.appspot.com epubjs-reader.appspot.com
-
It will be seen that this mere painstaking burrower and grub-worm of a poor devil of a Sub-Sub
Self-involved much?
-