706 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2024
    1. thegrass grows underfoot, at the edges of my eyes there are movements, in thebranches; feathers, flittings, grace notes, tree into bird, metamorphosis runwild.

      Relates to how the shadows at the sides, the peeks of her wings can create a full picture which creates a potential for rebellion.

    2. What I heard first the next morning was a scream and a crash.

      Fear still lingers, there's some past experience of something, the world isn't safe enough that clothes on the floor already create suspicion.

      An alternate interpretation is that this natural reaction implies that Cora is a very humane character and will foreshadow both that Cora will be an ally and that this handmaid will draw parallels to the one who hanged herself.

    3. It's impossible to say a thing exactly the way it was,because what you say can never be exact, you always have to leave somethingout, there are too many parts, sides, cross currents, nuances; too manygestures, which could mean this or that, too many shapes which can never befully described, too many flavors, in the air or on the tongue, half-colors, toomany

      She admits her own unreliability by using the physical sensory imagery and therefore showing that language is often insufficient and incapable of fully describing the human experience of the senses.

    4. is is a reconstruction. All of it is a reconstruction. It's a reconstructionnow, in my head, as I lie flat on my single bed rehearsing what I should orshouldn't have said, what I should or shouldn't have done, how I should haveplayed it. If I ever get out of here

      Post-modernism, shows that everything has been passed through her head and her perspective and that none of this is anything but a story. It is no truth, only a story, that she is constantly reflecting upon and rebuilding, just as the voice memos have been rearranged to make the most sense, to create meaning.

    5. By this time we were treating her theway people used to treat those with no legs who sold pencils on street corners.We avoided her when we could, were charitable to her when it couldn't behelped. She was a danger to us, we knew that.

      Funny how this is the reality of things? We distrust those who we pity the most?

    6. I hear the siren, at a great distance atfirst, winding its way towards me among the large houses and clipped lawns,a thin sound like the hum of an insect; then nearing, opening out, like a flowerof sound opening, into a trumpet. A proclamation, this siren.

      Distracts her from the reality of the situation, a crescendo that distracts her from the mundaneness of the world she lives in, although a siren is not anything to be ecstatic about.

    7. I revise that: within limits.

      The freedom is all relative -- all these pleasures are nothing in the past, but so much now. She has to remind herself to truly compare so she doesn't fall into insanity.

    8. But isn't thiseveryone's wet dream, two women at once? They used to say that. Exciting,they used to say

      Satirical tone of Offred's narration: What once was considered idealistic is now considered mind-numbing, which comments on the entire state of Gilead. A Utopia is really not as good as it seems.

    9. Nor does rape cover it: nothing is going on here that I haven'tsigned up for. There wasn't a lot of choice but there was some, and this iswhat I chose.

      The fact that none of these words except the word "fucking" can describe it shows that all humanity is taken out of the equation, only beastiality is left. Anything to describe a human experience of sex cannot be used (copulation, rape, making love). No emotion. Just the act itself

    10. him, like onehypnotized. If only it were true. If only I could believe

      She finds it hard to resist the falling into believing the most obviously logically fake news, which is a fight against her want to believe any news at all.

    11. His manner is kindly, fatherly; he gazesout at us from the screen, looking, with his tan and his white hair and candideyes, wise wrinkles around them, like everybody's ideal grandfather.

      Make it more marketable and trustworthy.

    12. he prisoner accepts a cigarette fromone of the Angels, puts it awkwardly to his lips with his bound hands. Hegives a lopsided little grin.

      Shows the fakeness and propaganda, trying to make Gilead look the way Gilead would like it

    13. There's a dried flowerarrangement on either end of the mantelpiece, and a vase of real daffodils onthe polished marquetry end table beside the sofa

      Dried flower arrangement = she's infertile like the dried flower. It's even more ironic because she likes tending to her garden, "her garden" when the guardian does all the heavy lifting (and so does her handmaid).

    14. wait. I compose myself. My self is a thing I must now compose, as onecomposes a speech. What I must present is a made thing, not something born.

      She is trying her best in an internal conflict to dissociate herself from the things Gilead does to her body (the commander in the ceremony, the doctor), but it is difficult because her body determines her so completely.

      She tries to fight for her mind, even when the society she is in tries NOT to objectify women -- by preventing men from expressing their desire for them.

    15. I've learned to do without a lot of things. If you have a lot of things, saidAunt Lydia, you get too attached to this material world and you forget aboutspiritual values. You must cultivate poverty of spirit. Blessed are the meek.

      Which contradicts her desire to treat her body, to have skin cream, forcing her to use even butter. Both women are pitted against each other because they have one but not the other -- one has their fertility and the other has their vanity.

    16. There are some differences, he said. He was fond of saying that, asif I was trying to prove there weren't. But mostly he said it when my motherwas there. He liked to tease her.

      This ideological difference, what does it mean? What contributed to the formation of Gilead, and does it mean that Luke was right about there being differences that cannot be erased, cannot be separated?

    17. I am poked and prodded. The fingerretreats, enters otherwise, withdraws."Nothing wrong with you," the doctor says, as if to himself.

      This is symbolic of rape, which is ironic because now Offred seeks hope in getting raped -- to be immorally penetrated is a sign of hope. Even when their society's aim was to grant women freedom from rape.

      Even though his words are reassuring, his power and the underlying tone. of rape still hangs. This is ironic because Gilead should be free from rape, of sin. And yet Gilead is turning women into sin, out of desperation. A utopia becomes more of a living hell than any sinful world.

    18. Why am I frightened? I've crossed no boundaries, I've given no trust, taken norisk, all is safe. It's the choice that terrifies me. A way out, a salvation.

      In this sense hope is tied irreversibly with fear. Having the freedom to do things is also the opportunity to get raped, to have frightening things happening. But that is hope, hope is fear, hope is an absence of certainty.

  2. Aug 2024
    1. threw the magazine into the flames. It riffled open in the wind of itsburning; big flakes of paper came loose, sailed into the air, still on fire, partsof women's bodies,

      What could this symbolize with what happened then to women's bodies?

      Freedom from and freedom to -- Their intentions were pure but the fact that women's bodies "went up into flames" meant the problem was not resolved, only got worse. Intention vs. Execution.

      It criticises modern morals and the good and bad.

      Criticises the trajectory of the feminism fight, which is ironic because a society in which women suffer is created by the fight for women's right in itself.

    2. Somewhere good

      She can time skip, she begins to be able to control her memories -- it starts off with where she'd like to go, but she trips into distress with bad memories. Even her night is fading?

    3. Regarding storytelling, it serves as a form of escape from the repression. Though it is hard to achieve (the level of focus) it is still there -- and it defies laws in the sense that even when there is nobody, a story has to be told to somebody. This abstractness also with language shows that restriction cannot exist because of these paradoxical loopholes

    4. step sideways outof my own time. Out of time. Though this is time, nor am I out of it.But the night is my time out.

      Shows a little madness in this.

      Refers to Dr. Faustus: She might be in hell, this paradox of being in and out of time at the same time. Would make sense with the craziness.

    5. as long as I amquiet. As long as I don't move. As long as I lie still.

      Anaphora: Despite the assertion that the night is mine, my own time, to do with as I will -- the anaphora later subverts it, attaching conditions to this possession of something that is usually for her.

    6. Notthe eyes. I know better than to look the interpreter in the face. Most of theinterpreters are Eyes, or so it's said

      The eyes reveal a sense of truth more than words could ever show. To look the interpreter in the eye, who is an Eye, would be equivalent to confessing a sin or confessing desire.

    7. They wore blouseswith buttons down the front that suggested the possibilities of the wordundone. These women could be undone; or not

      Simply having the possibility. Shows that possibility lies in clothing, in what you put on, in habits. What does it mean for a woman to be undone? A lot of physical things representing this lack of freedom or possibility.

    8. There is more than one kind of freedom, said Aunt Lydia. Freedom toand freedom from. In the days of anarchy, it was freedom to. Now you arebeing given freedom from. Don't underrate it

      This is ironic and very important. Freedom to and freedom from -- playing with language, a form of manipulation. Gilead is more than for its birth rate purposes... A form of gaslighting.

      Shows the role of language in perception, in reality, and yet also shows that there is a limit that the mindset can do for you. It is still suffering, without duty.

    9. hese women are notdivided into functions. They have to do everything; if they can. Sometimesthere is a woman all in black, a widow. There used to be more of them, butthey seem to be diminishing. You don't see the Commanders' Wives on thesidewalks. Only in cars

      It is ironic because the lower class has a small escape from Gilead -- like a normal family.

    10. TheRepublic of Gilead, said Aunt Lydia, knows no bounds. Gilead is within you

      This is how they control, psychological warfare, rather than anything purely external, it is all a play of the ego.

    11. AGuardian detailed to the Commander does the heavy digging; theCommander's Wife directs, pointing with her stick

      The heavy lifting is done by the guardian -- the sowing is done by the Handmaid and the reaping done by the Commander's Wife. This is an artificial purpose for the Commander's wife that serves as a method of control to "satisfy" them, to give them all they could possibly want. She's infatuated with his boldness.

    12. mells fishy,they used to say; or, I smell a rat. Misfit as odor. Despite myself, I think ofhow he might smell. Not fish or decaying rat; tanned skin, moist in the sun,filmed with smoke. I sigh, inhaling.

      Quick change from a sense of disgust, as she pretends to think in a orthodox way, but then she quickly shows her true self. Would there be a connection between this disgust of rebelliousness and yet also infatuation?

      He represents freedom, a bit of a difference

    13. He has a cigarette stuck in the cornerof his mouth, which shows that he too has something he can trade on theblack market

      He is a rebellious one too, Nick is the forbidden fruit in many aspects, not just as himself but as an opportunity for Offred

    14. We learned to whisper almost without sound. In the semi-darkness wecould stretch out our arms, when the Aunts weren't looking, and touch eachother's hands across space. We learned to lip-read, our heads flat on the beds,turned sideways, watching each other's mouths. In this way we exchangednames, from bed to bed:

      In some way, bonds and the exchanging of words/communication is what defines individuality. Individuals cannot be individuals without differentiation of the other.

      They crave human interaction with an equal (intimacy) and this kind of gives the women power. Like huey said Gilead used the method of seperating women in order to oppress them.

      This is a form of rebellion, subversion. This cannot be stamped out as shown in the "palimpset".

    15. he truth is thatshe is my spy, as I am hers. If either of us slips through the net because ofsomething that happens on one of our daily walks, the other will beaccountable

      Mutual Surveillance relying on women against women rivalry

    16. answer, the accepted respon

      "May the lord open" could mean open your legs, and Lord in this case, during the ceremony, would signify the commander? It implies patriarchy. Ever child born in Gilead is a son of God, creation of God, and the mother is the tree that bears its fruit.

    17. "Blessed be the fruit," she says to me, the accepted greeting among us."May the Lord open,"

      "And she cried out with a loud voice and said, "blessed are you among women, and blessed be the fruit of your womb!" - Luke 1:42. Represents miraculous fertility, referred to in prayer as Hail Mary!

    18. "The war is going well, I hear," she says."Praise be," I reply."We've been sent good weather.""Which I receive with joy."

      She tries to communicate with Offred, but Offred does not stray from her duty, does not take the responsibility. She therefore only replies with "Praise be". This is a scripted, call and response similar to christian mass.

    19. "Praise be," I say. I don't ask her how she knows, "

      gilead restricts language, shown in the repetition of these greetings. Raises the question of "How does she know?". She is smart, she is a potential rebel. tells us she is gathering information, listening carefully, willing to pass it on.

    20. She reaches me and we peer at each other's faces, looking downthe white tunnels of cloth that enclose us. She is the right one.

      Shows that individuality is erased through the use of the clothing. They can only recognize each other as individuals by peering down the white tunnels of cloth, looking deeper within.

      1. Ties to childbirth
      2. One wants to be a mother and cannot, the other wants a mother but cannot have one.
      3. Motherhood and yet on two sides of the spectrum.
      4. Irony of vanity holding no use with Serena
    21. I can hardly believe theAngels have a need for such scarves; anyway, the ones made by theCommander's Wife are too elaborate. She doesn't bother with the cross-and-star pattern used by many of the other Wives, it's not a challenge. Fir treesmarch across the ends of her scarves, or eagles, or stiff humanoid figures, boyand girl, boy and girl. They aren't scarves for grown men but for children

      This says something about Serena Joy: She is longing for a story and herself is unconventional. Although all she can make is artificial. And it represents her beliefs in these scarves, which in some sense contradicts the hierarchical structure in Gilead.

    22. Even now that there is no real money anymore, there's still a blackmarket. There's always a black market, there's always something that can beexchanged. She then was a woman who might bend the rules. But what did Ihave, to trade?

      This question would be answered later in the story

    23. which must once have been fine and was stillfinely kept, the fingernail at the end of the knuckly finger filed to a gentlecurving point

      Could it be that her vanity, which she puts so much attention to, is mocking her because even with all this luxury, she fails to feel satisfied in her marriage with the Commander (in relation to the Handmaid's with their lack of vanity, but who have their fertility?

    24. and I felt as if a protective arm were being withdrawn.

      The irony is in that the women should be scared of the institution, not of each other. They were once all the same, and still are, only seperated now by a rift.

    25. But I envy the Commander's Wife her knitting. It's good to havesmall goals that can be easily attained.What does she envy me?

      This lack of communication, the intentional lack of something innately essential on both sides causes this rift between women.

    26. verything except the wings around my face is red: the color of blood, whichdefines us.

      Maybe because they are both the bringer of life (blood) and the symbol of death.... idk... bro..

    27. Luke told me that. He saidthere was no corresponding word that meant to behave like a sister. Sororize

      Theme about the fact that there was always something trying to break up sisterly behaviour, bonds between women. Rather, it is always men who need to network -- women are simply possessions

    28. Or I would help Rita make the bread, sinking my hands into that softresistant warmth which is so much like flesh. I hunger to touch something,other than cloth or wood. I hunger to commit the act of touch.

      Irony that it is put in "commit the act of touch" which juxtaposes with modern (now) crimes and morals.

    29. they say. If I hadn'tof got my tubes tied, it could of been me, say I was ten years younger. It's notthat bad. It's not what you'd call hard work.

      The women are really turned on each other here.

    30. Angels of the apocalypse, angels of light, Guardian angels -- paramilitary force used to curb social violence. Wore black uniforms like Gileadean angels.

      These allusions might outline why angels are used as the enforcers of purity.

      Aunts are familial, guiders, source of help beyond parents. Supportive. Different perspective from parents...

      These are clever marketing ploys.

      Cattle prods symbolize that the women are like COWS. We breed them, milk them, used for our purposes. (Female cows).

      It is the female cows that build up the value of the society and its purpose, yet they are treated so inhumanely...

      Also used by police in the US during the Civil Rights movement and the Race Riots in the 60s.

    31. balcony ran around the room, for the spectators,and I thought I could smell, faintly like an afterimage, the pungent scent ofsweat, shot through with the sweet taint of chewing gum and perfume fromthe watching girls,

      Sensory imagery "faintly like an afterimage" -- simile, less solid/tangible than an image

      Maybe it represents an alternative reality and sets the scene for night.

      Also irony that freedom is diminishing as the future approaches, the idea of individualism becoming collectivism which is usually frowned upon

    1. I stared back with theall-knowing, I-dare-you-to-kiss-me gaze of someone who both challengesand flees with one and the same gesture

      This is where the pursuer and the pursued occurs

    2. ’d commit the ultimateindignity, and with this indignity show him that the shame was all his, notmine, that I had come with truth and human kindness in my heart and that Iwas leaving it on his sheets now to remind him how he’d said no to a youngman’s plea for fellowship.

      "Truth" is embedded in his semen that he will lay on the sheets after lots of fuddling trials by making excuses. In the end it is all his sexuality that will confess all truth and human kindness

    3. When I looked at my dessert plate and saw the chocolate cakespeckled with raspberry juice, it seemed to me that someone was pouringmore and more red sauce than usual, and that the sauce seemed to becoming from the ceiling above my head until it suddenly hit me that it wasstreaming from my nose. I gasped, and quickly crumpled my napkin andbrought it to my nose, holding my head as far back as I could.

      A obvious sign he likes it, and it was not through verbal fuddling that he communicated this, but through his body's involuntary reaction that he cannot plan nor control.

    4. indicating, allthe while, that this was being done in the spirit of fun and games, because itwas his way of pulling the rug out from under the lunch drudges sittingright across from us, but also telling me that this had nothing to do withothers and would remain strictly between us, because it was about us, butthat I shouldn’t read into it more than there was.

      The meaning pulled out of the physical touch, nothing more than it is but the communication evident.

    5. wanted his tongue inmy mouth and mine in his—because all we had become, after all theseweeks and all the strife and all the fits and starts that ushered a chill drafteach time, was just two wet tongues flailing away in each other’s mouths

      All the misunderstandings lead to simply the physicality and exchange of identity of two wet tongues, while words deceived them all

    6. And I did not wantwords, small talk, big talk, bike talk, book talk, any of it. Just the sun, thegrass, the occasional sea breeze, and the smell of his body fresh from hischest, from his neck and his armpits. Just take me and molt me and turn meinside out, till, like a character in Ovid, I become one with your lust, that’swhat I wanted. Give me a blindfold, hold my hand, and don’t ask me tothink—will you do that for me?

      ?

    7. But passion allows us to hide more, and at thatmoment on Monet’s berm, if I wished to hide everything about me in thiskiss, I was also desperate to forget the kiss by losing myself in it.

      What does this mean?

    1. B - BD = |AB||BD\cos(x - mZ ABD)

      cos(pi-m<ABD) is used here because when you arrange the vectors tail touching tail on the origin, the resulting angle between them is supplementary to m<ABD.

    2. h are the target coordinates for the end of the arm, point

      Because I have my fingertip with the position and also angle, the vector is determined. So it is actually the next joint up that angle can vary.

    3. The target coordinates of the end of the arm, which is noted as point D, are (x,y).

      my target coordinates are the end of the finger (finger-tip) at (x,y) with constraints with a 105 degree angle.

    4. ce simple geometry does not provide an easy solution to the research question, hispaper will use linear algebra and trigonometry to answer it.

      Already shown that simple geometry will not cut it -- study 2 things. Linear algebra, and trigonometry.

    Tags

    Annotators

    1. ccording to Freud, condensation and displacement are thetwo fundamental principles that determine the activity of theunconscious. They are at work in all the formations of the un-conscious (the symptom, slips of the tongue, etc.), though Freuddescribed them chiefly in relation to dreams. Condensation refersto the fact that one simple dream image can represent severalassociative chains at the same time. So, for example, it oftenhappens that a certain figure in a dream turns out on closeranalysis to represent several persons. I dream about my brother,but in the course of the analysis it turns

      Can be connected to Convergent and divergent (and induction and deduction). Condensation is the idea of the dream presenting after it has been condensed or converged, and displacement refers to the idea of disparate clues all pointing to a common theme and meaning.

    2. What is at stake here is not so much the question of whether themembers of the tribe do or do not know that there can be no preg-nancy without coitus, but rather that of whether there exists inthe symbolic system a signifier that expresses the idea that the onewith whom the woman has coitus is also the father of the childthat she bears.

      Good quote

    3. self-sufficient, pre-given referent. Both the Freudian andthe Lacanian unconscious, as it were, put external reality outof play.

      Even though Lacan objects and states that the unconscious is made of a chain of signifiers (language), he actually in some sense agrees with Freud in the sense that language is not connected to reality. It constructs reality.

    4. Moreover, the fact that a signifier only receives meaningfrom a complex network of signitive references immediatelyimplies, for Lacan, that the meaning of a signifier changes ac-cording to the context in which it is taken up.

      Thesis that confirms ever-changing meaning and instability of identity

    5. In other words, they signify primarily on thebasis of their difference from other signifiers and not, for ex-ample, by referring to a non-linguistic reality.

      Discussed in Jette's thesis (string of signifiers)

    6. Lacan’s terms, these distinctions come to us from the order ofsignifiers, and they must therefore be understood as an activelystructuring principle.

      Distinctions between subjects is purely a matter of language, when discernible things are usually gradual and not ordered. This connects to Hume's bundle theory where the human mind chooses where the boundary lies between continuity and discontinuity even when all should be gradually discontinuous -- the continuity is simply an illusion, a phantasy.

    7. we will never find anything morethan gradual differences. Yet we are not a bit “man” and a bit“woman” (or vice versa), but either “man” or “woman”—we areone or the other. This absolute difference does not exist in (lived)reality, which knows only gradual distinctions.

      This is an example of how language or symbolic signifiers alter the lived experience more than the lived experience does simply to the real. Does this mean that as one grows up and is exposed to more of the symbolic world and language, one is indulged more in the phantasy and is further from accessing the "real"?

    8. it is a question of whether there is a signifier inthe symbolic system that articulates this connection.

      The concept of fatherhood relies directly on the notion and connection between procreation and fatherhood which is passed through language, which articulates it.

    9. he connection between trompe andtromper arises simply on the basis of the material similarity be-tween the words. If the dream thus employs language t

      This is why the Freudian slip exists (the reasoning behind the freudian slip) -- since words can only exist in the unconscious in a purely material way, mistakened meanings between words are due to sound and appearance alone.

    10. Lacan connects the unconscious with language. How can thesetwo insights—that the unconscious is of the order of language,and that it is also bodily and sexual—be reconciled with eachother?

      VERBALISATION AND SEXUAL/BODILY function is together in the unconscious! very relevant for CMBYN?

    11. According toLacan, then, neither psychoanalytic orthodoxy nor academicpsychology recognizes a difference in principle between knowl-edge (psychic life) and the truth by which it is driven onward(the reality to which psychic life must adapt itself)

      Thus Lacan introduces the divide between the real and reality. Hegel and ego psychoanalysis assume that knowledge (the consciousness) and truth can always coincide and have an affinity for each other

    12. According to Lacan, the absolute knowledgethat is thus attained is like a symbolic system that expresses theessential structures of reality in its entirety. This final state can-not be described as anything other than perfect self-conscious-ness.

      Thus stating that absolute knowledge is not awareness of the real, as the real's effects but not actuality can be grasped. Simply, absolute knowledge is perfect self-consciousness where knowledge and truth combine

    13. hought with the infinity of negation. In this way the skeptic re-alizes that of which stoicism was only the concept, for true free-dom of thought is never realized in an impotent apposition ofthought and reality, but in the effective negation of the succes-sive particular determinations with which consciousness is con-fronted.

      Hegel thus states that stoicisim cannot exist because the true freedom of thought cannot exist. This is because consciousness is constantly replaced by other consciousnesses to adapt to the noticing of contradictions following new truths.

    14. every figure of consciousness is followedand replaced by a new figure of consciousness, until eventuallyabsolute knowledge is attained. Every figure of consciousness issooner or later confronted with its own incompleteness and in-ternal contradictions.

      Everchanging nature of identity seen in the everchanging nature or fragments/figures of consciousness, replacing one another until harmony is reached between contradictions and duality, into full knowledge

    15. ave they in fact shakenthe self-conception of the subject as fundamentally as Freudwould have it? Thus has Darwinism, for example, really freedhumanity from its belief that it holds a central position in real-ity? How could it, when Darwin places man at the top of theevolutionary pyramid?)

      This is the challenge: Lacan challenges the claim that the third part of the Copernican revolution, the claim that the subject is self-consciousness is more believed now than before or even at the same -- that the self continues to think so?

    16. y Freud’s reckoning, psy-choanalysis is the third in this series of wounds. No matter howmuch Darwin forced humanity to fundamentally recast its viewsof its origins, this did not stop it from believing that it coincideswith itself as self-consciousness. The Freudian revolution putsan end to this naive belief. For Freud teaches us that man “isnot master in his own house.” The subject is not to be under-stood as essentially self-consciousness; instead, it is deliveredover to unconscious forces that elude its grasp.

      Psychoanalysis is the third of the narcissistic wounds humanity is faced because it challenges the idea that the subject is self-consciousness and that we are a unified and in control being.

    17. o that the hidden “logos” ofwhich they are the expression can be brought to light. ForLacan, moreover, the fact that the unconscious “logos” at workin those experiences can be brought to light by way of languageimmediately implies that the unconscious, too, also belongs tothe order of language in one way or another.

      Lacan states that the unconscious is made of language because the states of knowledge within the unconscious can only be understood by way of language? through articulation?

    18. It illustrates, in a strikingmanner, the ontological dualism that can, without a doubt, beconsidered the basic assumption of Lacanian psychoanalysis.°This ontological dualism is related to the fact that Lacan thinksof language and the body as originally external to each other.

      This presents something about language and the body being external to one another? The duality and the contrast between language and bodily expression?

    1. However,they are both skirting around the ambivalence of language to commu-nicate,

      Adds depth to my argument surrounding words as deception, as although the unstable meaning of words can detract from the truthfulness of expression of desire and therefore, identity, the ambiguity of words can also play for time and serve, here, as a secret space of understanding, perhaps because both Oliver and Elio are queer, but maybe also because they desire one another and to have is to be? No clue

    2. Fear, thereby, acts a fulcrum tonegotiate his identity in context of his relationships.

      Fear is the deciding factor on how Elio and Oliver decide who they are in the context of their relationships there and then. Their identity is directly based on the social mirror due to fear.

    3. Which implies thatmuch of the novel is about what is left unsaid than what is said; forexample, in “Monet’s Berm” Oliver says “Don’t ever say you didn’tknow” and Elio admits “His words made no sense. But I knew exactlywhat they meant” (Aciman 150).

      Implying that much of the communication was obvious even when words were not shared ?

    1. The quotation of Elio’s language usage here—as well as the repetition, inversion, and changes inemphasis—places focus structurally on the actual words to represent the implications of thisutterance (the implications being that Elio desires Oliver).

      I guess the fact that the meaning of the repetition in words can so obviously shift and is unstable can also represent the instability of the identity and the contradictions that can occur even when the same body (or words) is being expressed.

    2. This physical expression lacks fulfillment because it does notchange the world around it: Elio did not have sex with Oliver, just his clothing. The narrativecontinues, and so this physical act fails to function as a true and fulfilling confession.

      How can i refute this? Or what can i take from this?

    3. This passage conflates Elio’s desire with the physical body. By connecting ejaculation with therevealing of his secret, Elio grounds his desire in the physical action of his body. With thismetaphor linking speaking and masturbating, he attempts to convince himself that the confessionhas been completed, resulting in a physical act.

      The only notable quote i think would support my argument. The passage of words to physical truth coming out of his body in his semen. This links the confession of the verbal to the truthful (and permanent) confession of the physical.

    1. He has to accept thatOliver is not a static concept but an individual that is, at all times, constructing and re-constructing himself in new environments, new places and with new people. The Oliver heknew in Italy cannot possibly exist forever but just as Elio feared for Oliver to change when hearrived in B., he is still scared of seeing that change manifested in a new Oliver; it is an Oliverhe might have never known in the first place

      Goes to support that the bildungsroman ends only when Elio finally accepts the multitude of aspects that Oliver holds in his identity (and in Elio's identity), the change that he fears, and that is why the novel ends only 15 years later. His maturity only arrives much later in his life.

      This much connects to the contradicting coexistence of fear and infatuation, where he both is infatuated with the multitude of aspects in Oliver's identity (skin motif) and fearful of who he is when Elio is not there to witness.

    2. When they first engage in sexual intercourse, Oliver proposes: “Call me by your nameand I’ll call you by mine” (134). This exchange of name identity is supposed to symbolize theirunity. Yet, based on what has been discussed before, it is questionable how they can extendtheir identity like that if neither of them knows who they are or hide parts of themselves fromeach other so that a complete picture of neither “Elio” nor “Oliver” is available. T

      I disagree once again, the problem is that Elio could not ever define himself or conflate himself, and Oliver had known that was impossible from the start. their exchanging of identity through sex was a show of development for Elio in understanding the true nature of identity.

    3. Oliver is not, or at least not only, the cool, unbothered muvi star while Elio isnot as wise and knowledgeable as Oliver would think him

      Shows that both characters lack the maturity.

    4. Apart from showing their true selvesand actively talking and positioning themselves in the relationship and where it should go, bothalso fail to have the confidence to challenge their pre-existing positions as only platonic friendsamong their heterosexist society.

      2 reasons why it fails

    5. heir relationship is vague asit is situated between the positions of friends and lovers. It exists on a metalevel, alwayshanging in the air but also never fully named, never fully realized.

      I disagree with this because like I said, their failure to label their relationship surpasses what the instable meaning of words can define. When a relationship takes place between always and never, on a "metalevel" (Zwischen Immer und Nie), it is more sacred than traditional roles.

    6. In the case of their relationship it would position them, brand them, as gay men.As an American in the 1980s, Oliver is aware of the consequences this brings. It could costhim his academic career and estrange him from his family and friends in the US

      Shame comes with age

    7. lio describes these abilities to read people as an“amazing gift” and focuses on how they intuit things in a similar manner (22), so that he cantell himself that they have one more aspect in common

      hmm

    8. Now, this is also an instance where it is clear that Oliver is positioning himself differentlyto what Elio is used to with him in private. Oliver is the character that seems the mostambiguous in the novel, also because Elio tries to make sense of him and is repeatedly notsucceeding.

      Oliver constantly positions himself differently, and is what sets Elio off edge, because Elio wants to see Oliver as one.

    9. Later on, he engages with a girl, Marzia, himself butthroughout the novel she is more of a means to engage in talk about it with Oliver, distracthimself from him, and fantasize about him through her. To some degree, it is one of manyattempts to imitate the behavior of the older more confident graduate student. Only later doesOliver tell Elio that he is in fact not interested in Chiara. Elio is confused

      Elio with Marzia is just a mirror of Oliver with Chiara -- because he wants to be him when he says he would like to have him.

    10. As Elio cannotmake sense of this categorization of manhood, he turns towards a more traditional behavior ofmanhood to befriend Oliver and find common ground with him: the pursuit and discussion ofwomen.

      This makes sense. Literature and his environment shapes the way he can see manhood and therefore the way he positions himself. This leads to him adopting a friendship, a more traditional position with man to man.

    11. This instability of language leads to an instability of the self as our discourses areunstable, and meaning has to be rearranged in accordance with dominant ideologies at anygiven time

      The point Jette is making is that language itself is a unstable system that produces meaning, formed from comparisons, and therefore self-expression via. language makes identity equally as unstable.

    12. Thecharacters’ failure to acknowledge the multitude of aspects that make up their identity leads tosecrecy and idealization, which hinders a realistic development of their relationship.

      Thesis: Elio and Oliver's relationship was always doomed to fail due to them unable to recognise that their identities hold a multitude of ever-changing aspects