10,000 Matching Annotations
  1. Nov 2022
  2. Oct 2022
    1. We have found that these public preprint reviews and assessments are far more effective than binary accept or reject decisions ever could be at conveying the thinking of our reviewers and editors, and capturing the nuanced, multidimensional, and often ambiguous nature of peer review. eLife will now let them stand on their own by publishing every paper we review, along with our reviews and an assessment as a Reviewed Preprint, a new type of research output we hope will become the norm across science.

      It would be interesting to know more this, particularly what is meant by "effective" and how this improvement was assessed.