How does a culture that prizes equality of opportunity explain, or indeedaccommodate, its persistently marginalized people?
- Mar 2024
-
-
-
Lest the reader misconstrue the book’s purpose, I want to make the pointunambiguously: by reevaluating the American historical experience in classterms, I expose what is too often ignored about American identity. But I’mnot just pointing out what we’ve gotten wrong about the past; I also want tomake it possible to better appreciate the gnawing contradictions still presentin modern American society.
The author lays out what she hopes to accomplish with the book.
-
It starts withthe rich and potent meaning that came with the different names given theAmerican underclass. Long before they were today’s “trailer trash” and“rednecks,” they were called “lubbers” and “rubbish” and “clay-eaters” and“crackers”—and that’s just scratching the surface.
An interesting broad array of names for the "lower classes" in United States history.
-
Britishcolonists promoted a dual agenda: one involved reducing poverty back inEngland, and the other called for transporting the idle and unproductive tothe New World.
This is some of the broad thesis which we'll be looking out for evidence within the text.
-
The hallowed American dream is thegold standard by which politicians and voters alike are meant to measurequality of life as each generation pursues its own definition of happinessunfettered by the restraints of birth (who your parents are) or station (theposition you start out from in the class system).
Did it help that America was broadly formed during the start of the Industrial Revolution and at a time in which social mobility was dramatically different than the period of history which proceeded it?
And how much of this difference is split with the idea of the rise of (toxic) capitalism and the switch to "keeping up with the Jonses" which also tends to drive class distinctions?
-
economic stratification createdby wealth and privilege.
basic definition of class
could probably do with some distinction of education as well....
-
eugenics
-
American exceptionalism, 7, 69, 190, 310, 318
-
Isenberg, Nancy. White Trash: The 400-Year Untold History of Class in America. 1st ed. New York, New York: Viking, 2016.
annotation link: urn:x-pdf:417c67707ad8fbb5300140892c8666cc<br /> alternate annotation link: JH facet
Tags
- history
- capitalism
- Dan Allosso Book Club
- keeping up with the Jonses
- class divisions
- American exceptionalism
- American identity
- class
- white trash
- equity
- Industrial Revolution
- evolutionary theory
- social mobility
- productivity
- themes
- eugenics
- American history
- poverty
- definitions
- open questions
- Nancy Isenberg
- sociology
Annotators
-
-
pipdecks.com pipdecks.com
-
Also targeting business executives (via YouTube) as a storytelling deck: https://pipdecks.com/pages/storyteller-tactics-card-deck
Described as "expert knowledge in your back pocket", and sold as a "toolkit" with "practical step-by-step recipes", and "templates."
They offer 7 decks of tactics for Brand, Team, Storytelling, Innovation, Productivity, Team, Workshop, Strategy.
-
-
www.vaultofculture.com www.vaultofculture.com
-
[[Shawn Gilmore]] in On the Page: Paul Sheldon's Typewriter in Misery (1987) — The Vault of Culture<br /> on 2022-06-15
-
-
www.pasadenanow.com www.pasadenanow.com
-
www.ribbonsunlimited.com www.ribbonsunlimited.com
-
clairelasecretaire.wordpress.com clairelasecretaire.wordpress.com
-
Local file Local file
-
Words like quality and excellence are misapplied sorelentlessly that they border on meaningless.
Has education in the United States fallen prey to lip service about its importance. Have we substituted an idea of it's value for the actual value itself?
Almost everyone says education is important and that we value it, but do we put our money where our mouth is?
-
while efficiency was a goal, quality was the goal.
-
Mistakes are part of creativity.
-
A subversion takes place in whichstreamlining the process or increasing production supplants the ultimate goal, with eachperson or group thinking they’re doing the right thing—when, in fact, they have strayed offcourse. When efficiency or consistency of workflow are not balanced by other equally strongcountervailing forces, the result is that new ideas—our ugly babies—aren’t afforded theattention and protection they need to shine and mature.
-
Katherine Sarafian,a producer who’s been at Pixar since Toy Story, tells me she prefers to envision triggering theprocess over trusting it—observing it to see where it’s faltering, then slapping it around a bitto make sure it’s awake. Again, the individual plays the active role, not the process itself. Or,to put it another way, it is up to the individual to remember that it’s okay to use the handle,just as long as you don’t forget the suitcase.
-
As Brad Bird, who joined Pixar as a director in 2000, likes to say, “The process eithermakes you or unmakes you.” I like Brad’s way of looking at it because while it gives theprocess power, it implies that we have an active role to play in it as well.
This is a useful frame with respect to any process.
How would one apply it to zettelkasten for those having issues in their workflows?
-
Once you’re aware of the suitcase/handle problem, you’ll see it everywhere. People glomonto words and stories that are often just stand-ins for real action and meaning. Advertiserslook for words that imply a product’s value and use that as a substitute for value itself.Companies constantly tell us about their commitment to excellence, implying that this meansthey will make only top-shelf products. Words like quality and excellence are misapplied sorelentlessly that they border on meaningless.
-
Imagine an old, heavy suitcase whose well-worn handles are hanging by a few threads. Thehandle is “Trust the Process” or “Story Is King”—a pithy statement that seems, on the face ofit, to stand for so much more. The suitcase represents all that has gone into the formation ofthe phrase: the experience, the deep wisdom, the truths that emerge from struggle. Too often,we grab the handle and—without realizing it—walk off without the suitcase. What’s more, wedon’t even think about what we’ve left behind. After all, the handle is so much easier to carryaround than the suitcase.
Ed Catmull analogizes the idea of pithy business statements and aphorisms as old, heavy suitcases and their handles. It's easy to grab onto the handle and walk of only with it, particularly when the weight and inconvenience of the suitcase and its actual contents are no longer attached. One needs to make sure that their comfortable old suitcase handle is still attached to the case and the valuable, hard-won wisdom of the contents inside.
-
Likewise, we “trusted the process,” but the process didn’t save Toy Story 2 either. “Trust theProcess” had morphed into “Assume that the Process Will Fix Things for Us.” It gave ussolace, which we felt we needed. But it also coaxed us into letting down our guard and, in theend, made us passive. Even worse, it made us sloppy.
One could consider the simplicity of ars excerpendi/zettelkasten against the phrase "trust the process", and this is fine for some of the lower level collecting methods, but one needs to be careful not to fall trap to the complacency of only collecting and not using the collection to actively create.
Many people rely too much on the collection portion of the process and don't put any work into the use or creation portions. They may be left wondering what the ultimate value is of their unused collection of treasure.
-
Likewise, we “trusted the process,” but the process didn’t save Toy Story 2 either. “Trust theProcess” had morphed into “Assume that the Process Will Fix Things for Us.” It gave ussolace, which we felt we needed. But it also coaxed us into letting down our guard and, in theend, made us passive. Even worse, it made us sloppy.
Compare "trust the process" as a guiding principle with "let go and let God" which has a much more random and chaotic potential set of outcomes.
-
“Story Is King” differentiated us, we thought, not just because we said it but also becausewe believed it and acted accordingly. As I talked to more people in the industry and learnedmore about other studios, however, I found that everyone repeated some version of thismantra—it didn’t matter whether they were making a genuine work of art or complete dreck,they all said that story is the most important thing. This was a reminder of something thatsounds obvious but isn’t: Merely repeating ideas means nothing. You must act—and think—accordingly. Parroting the phrase “Story Is King” at Pixar didn’t help the inexperienceddirectors on Toy Story 2 one bit. What I’m saying is that this guiding principle, while simplystated and easily repeated, didn’t protect us from things going wrong. In fact, it gave us falseassurance that things would be okay.
Having a good catch phrase for guidance can become a useless trap if it becomes repeated so frequently that it loses meaning. Guiding principles need to be revisited, actively worked on, and ensconced into daily activities and culture.
examples: - Google and "don't be evil" - Pixar (and many others) and "story is king" (cross Reference Ed Catmull in Creativity, Inc.) - Pixar and "trust the process" (ibid) #
-
Likewise, we “trusted the process,” but the process didn’t save Toy Story 2 either. “Trust theProcess” had morphed into “Assume that the Process Will Fix Things for Us.” It gave ussolace, which we felt we needed. But it also coaxed us into letting down our guard and, in theend, made us passive. Even worse, it made us sloppy.
-
I read many such books as I set about trying to become a better, more effective manager.Most, I found, trafficked in a kind of simplicity that seemed harmful in that it offered falsereassurance. These books were stocked with catchy phrases like “Dare to fail!” or “Followpeople and people will follow you!” or “Focus, focus, focus!” (This last one was a particularfavorite piece of nonadvice. When people hear it, they nod their heads in agreement as if agreat truth has been presented, not realizing that they’ve been diverted from addressing thefar harder problem: deciding what it is that they should be focusing on. There is nothing inthis advice that gives you any idea how to figure out where the focus should be, or how toapply your energy to it. It ends up being advice that doesn’t mean anything.) These sloganswere offered as conclusions—as wisdom—and they may have been, I suppose. But none ofthem gave me any clue as to what to do or what I should focus on.
Curious that he might write this in a business book on creativity which is highly likely to fall trap to the same simple advice or catchy phrases.
Does he ultimately give his own clear cut advice that means something?
I'm reminded here of Dan Allosso's mention of the David Allen quote from Getting Things Done: "It is better to be wrong than to be vague."<br /> https://hypothes.is/a/yOFrNubcEe6AsafBDjDzBw
Are business books too often vague when it would be better for them to be wrong instead?
-
Not knowingwhere else to turn, I remember buying a copy of Dick Levin’s Buy Low, Sell High, Collect Early,and Pay Late: The Manager’s Guide to Financial Survival, a popular business title at the time,and devouring it in one sitting.
Many managers turn to reading for advice: - books allow you to live multiple lives and have greater experience - some books however only encapsulate generic advice that one either already has or would soon have even without reading.
-
Catmull, Ed, and Amy Wallace. Creativity, Inc.: Overcoming the Unseen Forces That Stand in the Way of True Inspiration. 1st ed. New York: Random House, 2014.
Annotation link: urn:x-pdf:30663863383637656631613936313361656266663266383336636530383636623965393736396531323237383235353363353236653830623034366132373130
Tags
- management
- flip the script
- streamlining
- zettelkasten
- false sense of security
- goals
- let go and let God
- guiding principles
- quotes
- efficiency
- complacency
- substituted value
- wisdom
- reading to have multiple lives
- mistakes
- cognitive bias
- educational reform
- References
- metonymy
- business management books
- business mantra bias
- systems
- process
- vagueness
- sociology
- suitcase handle analogy
- Ed Catmull
- creativity
- Brad Bird
- analogies
- ugly bablies
- ars excerpendi
- aphorisms
- Amy Wallace
- creative process
- Pixar Animation Studios
- reading practices
- loss of meaning through repetition
- trust
- trust the process
- lip service
- advice
- Katherine Sarafian
- business management
- zettelkasten for creation
- leadership
- combinatorial creativity
- quality
Annotators
-
-
lifelonglearn.substack.com lifelonglearn.substack.com
-
[[Dan Allosso]] in Vague or Wrong?
He highlights the David Allen quote from Getting Things Done: "It is better to be wrong than to be vague."
-
-
www.youtube.com www.youtube.com
-
KSMQ Public Television
"The Typist" follows the life and work of Larry Tillemans, believed to be the last living clerk-typist from the Nuremberg Trials. As a sergeant in the U.S. 3rd Army, it was Larry's duty to document the testimony of victims and perpetrators of the Holocaust -- information that deeply affected the young Minnesotan. After years of carrying this emotional burden, Larry decided to share his experiences with as many people as possible, a tireless effort that brought the value of first-person testimony to a world struggling to remember the lessons of Nuremberg.
-
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
You need to understand and learn the basic ideas, from scratch.ZK is a lifetime job.
reply to u/Aponogetone at https://www.reddit.com/r/Zettelkasten/comments/1bideq7/comment/kvjwhzf/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
I'm not 100% sure I understand your first point from a contextual perspective. What are you trying to get across here with this comment? Generally I tend to learn and understand the basic ideas of a text on my initial inspectional read. Often these are so basic as to not require any real note making at all. The second, more analytic read of the material usually clarifies anything missing and this is typically where I create some of my most valuable notes.
While I philosophically appreciate your second point, and over time it can build some intriguing insights, one should remember, that like many systems, it's only a tool and is thus useful for the timespan and project(s) for which that tool is fit for purpose. Holding onto ideas like this too tightly don't allow enough space for future creativity and flexibility. The executives at the buggy whip factory also felt that theirs was a lifetime job once.
-
in literature notes, do you write all of the stuff from a single article/book/whatever in one note, or do you split them all into individual notes of their own, one little piece on each card/note?
reply to u/oursong at https://www.reddit.com/r/Zettelkasten/comments/1bideq7/literature_notes_question/
My bibliographic/literature notes are my personal (brief) index of what I found interesting in the book. I can always revisit most of what the book contained by reviewing over it. When done I excerpt the most important and actionable items on their own cards with a reference back to the book and page/loc number. Depending on my needs I may revisit at later dates and excerpt other pieces from my indexed items if it turns out I need them.
From an efficiency perspective, I find that it seems like a waste of time to split out hundreds of lower-level ideas when I may only need the best for my work.
-
-
slate.com slate.com
-
[[Mark Lawrence Schrad]] in Why the World of Typewriter Collectors Splits Down the Middle When These Machines Come Up for Sale<br /> at 2024-03-16 12:00 PM <br /> (accessed:: 2024-03-19 10:23:08)
-
typewriters are ultimately instruments of human creation, not destruction.
This is a bit too rosy when we've just seen it used to help in the bureaucracy of death.
-
The typewriter division of Wanderer Werke continued unencumbered, manufacturing precision typing machines such as this one, emblazoned with its striking “WW” crest (which bears a striking similarity to the Wonder Woman logo from the 1980s).
-
The typewriter was made in Siegmar-Schönau—a suburb of Chemnitz—by Wanderer, an early German pioneer in manufacturing bicycles, motorcycles, cars, and later military trucks and tanks for the Wehrmacht, the armed forces in the Nazi era. In the 1930s, Wanderer’s automotive division was one of four car companies consolidated into the Auto Union AG, which later became Audi. Indeed, one of the four interconnected rings on the Audi brand logo represents Wanderer.
-
They collect artifacts, I collect histories.
-
a typewriter with the “special key” is no more or less odious than one without; it is just a matter of the meanings we humans impart upon it.
- consider too that the originators don't benefit though compare this with the seller who may have that sentiment benefiting.
-
some argue that the typewriter is just an inanimate object; a tool crafted for a specific purpose, which assumes neither the responsibility of the user nor his blame.
though what about when the creator is human and not inanimate?
-
More frequent were machines built with the double-lightning-bolt SS Siegrune, usually above the No. 3 or 5 key. With sieg meaning “victory,” the runes became ubiquitous in Nazi Germany as a shorthand rallying cry for “victory, victory!” In their more sinister application, the SS runes became the logo for the Schutzstaffel—the notorious paramilitary units most responsible for the wanton slaughter of 6 million Jews across Europe.
-
In very rare circumstances, a German typewriter would be made with a dedicated swastika key, like this one at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum.
-
The largest online typewriter community currently boasts some 29,000 members, with no signs of slowing down.
Facebook group: Antique Typewriter Collectors https://www.facebook.com/groups/4770669677
-
Larry McMurtry thanked his trusty Hermes 3000 typewriter while accepting his Golden Globe for Brokeback Mountain.
-
At the conclusion of the war, local Czech authorities, armed militias, and regular military units ethnically cleansed nearly 3 million Bohemian Germans from Czechoslovakia. From the high-altitude perspective of postwar geopolitics, President Edvard Beneš dubbed it Czechoslovakia’s “final solution of the German question.”
-
As strange as it sounds today, German klein (“small” or portable) typewriters were among the most sought-after souvenirs for soldiers fighting in World War II. Think of it: Adjusted for inflation, top-of-the-line portable typewriters cost roughly the same as your MacBook Pro today, and their usable lives were measured not in months or years, but decades and generations. Consequently, thousands of Uranias, Gromas, Erikas, Rheinmetalls, Continentals, Olympias, and other high-quality, precision-made German machines were looted from Nazi military and government offices, businesses, and even from civilian homes, whether their owners were dead or alive. “War trophy” is of course a pleasant euphemism: It denotes a reward for heroism, bravery, and sacrifice, while simultaneously acknowledging that even the good guys steal, pillage, and destroy amid the haze of total war.
Tags
- swastika key
- Continental (typewriters)
- Rheinmetall
- Bohemia
- logos
- Hermes typewriters
- Wonder Woman
- Nazi Germany
- keyboards
- Groma
- inanimate objects
- Urania
- World War II
- Wanderer
- Golden Globes
- archaeology
- Schutzstaffel (SS)
- typewriter collecting
- sentimentality
- brand logos
- symbols
- car marques
- historical method
- cui bono?
- artifacts vs. histories
- war trophies
- semantics
- cancel culture
- creation vs. destruction
- Olympia typewriters
- Hermes 3000 typewriter
- ethnic clensing
- Erika
- Auto Union AG
- typewriter renaissance
- Audi
- Larry McMurtry
- separating work from artist
- typewriters
- meaning
- Edvard Beneš
- read
- oral histories
- collections
- artifacts
- Czechoslovakia
- portable valuables
- SS Siegrune
- swastika
- German manufacturing
- Awards acceptance speeches
- portable typewriters
- problematic
Annotators
URL
-
-
-
In the 1740s, Thomas Harrison invented a wooden filing cabinet in which the file cards could be hooked on little tin plates. On each of these plates was written the name of the entry (i.e., the re-spective subject heading), and the plates were arranged in strictly alphabeti-cal order.22
Thomas Harrison invented a wooden filing cabinet in the 1640's for storing slips of paper. Each slip could be hooked onto tin plates which contained the topical or subject headings that were arranged in alphabetical order.
Harrison's description was anonymously published with corrections and improvements by Vincent Placcius in De arte excerpendi. Vom gelehrten Buchhalten liber singularis (Stockholm/Hamburg, 1689), 124–59, in his hand-book on excerpting systems.
Update 2024-03-18: The 1740s reference here must be a misprint and is perhaps 1640s as Harrison was a 17th century person and Placcius published results in 1689.
-
Samuel Hartlib was well aware of this improvement. While extolling the clever invention of Harrison, Hartlib noted that combinations and links con-stituted the ‘argumentative part’ of the card index.60
Hartlib Papers 30/4/47A, Ephemerides 1640, Part 2.
In extolling the Ark of Studies created by Thomas Harrison, Samuel Hartlib indicated that the combinations of information and the potential links between them created the "argumentative part" of the system. In some sense this seems to be analogous to the the processing power of an information system if not specifically creating its consciousness.
-
-
-
Instead of jotting down every note, thought, observation, excerpt, andreading on a single slip of paper and leaving them there, Placcius recom-mends grouping them, by dint of appropriate libros excerptorum (see figure2.5),39 excerpt books that follow the pattern that had guided the design ofregisters and bound library catalogs since Konrad Gessner; Placcius citesthe entire section “ De Indicibus Librorum ” from the Pandectae .40 Perhapshis strong vote for the bound form of this storage technology and againstJungius’s method is a way of warning against lifelong knowledge accumula-tions that merely gather treasures without being recombined and pub-lished as new books. Jungius, keen on including new resources, delays hisown publications time and again, leaving them unfinished or simply asraw paper slip potential in storage, on call. 4
-
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
How to start a commonplace book .t3_1bfu16h._2FCtq-QzlfuN-SwVMUZMM3 { --postTitle-VisitedLinkColor: #edeeef; --postTitleLink-VisitedLinkColor: #6f7071; --postBodyLink-VisitedLinkColor: #6f7071; }
Colleen Kennedy has a nice primer: https://www.academia.edu/35101285/Creating_a_Commonplace_Book_CPB_
It may also help to have an indexing method so you can find things later. John Locke's method is one of the oldest and most compact, though if you plan on doing this for a while, having a separate book for your index can be helpful. You can also create your index using index cards the way that Ross Ashby did; see: https://ashby.info/index.html
For John Locke's method try: - https://archive.org/details/gu_newmethodmaki00lock - https://publicdomainreview.org/collection/john-lockes-method-for-common-place-books-1685/
If you're into history, development, and examples of how people did this in the past, Earl Haven's has an excellent short book:<br /> Havens, Earle. Commonplace Books: A History of Manuscripts and Printed Books from Antiquity to the Twentieth Century. New Haven, CT: Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, 2001. https://www.oakknoll.com/pages/books/99718/earle-havens/commonplace-books-a-history-of-manuscripts-and-printed-books-from-antiquity-to-the-twentieth
-
-
www.mcsweeneys.net www.mcsweeneys.net
-
[[Kate Brennan]] in Gen Z Beowulf at 2024-03-06 <br /> (accessed:: 2024-03-15 13:17:00)
-
-
www.schoolandholmes.com www.schoolandholmes.com
-
www.sherlockholmespodcast.com www.sherlockholmespodcast.com
-
en.wikisource.org en.wikisource.org
-
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Main_Page
A free library that anyone can improve.
Potentially useful as a concordance search for a variety of books, articles, and other sources which have full textual search.
-
-
victorianweb.org victorianweb.org
-
“Do you know, Watson,” said he, “that it is one of the curses of a mind with a turn like mine that I must look at everything with reference to my own special subject. You look at these scattered houses, and you are impressed by their beauty. I look at them, and the only thought which comes to me is a feeling of their isolation and of the impunity with which crime may be committed there.”
Indexing the world into a commonplace book, zettelkasten, or other means can create new perspectives on the world in which we live. It thereby helps to prevent the sorts of cognitive bias which we might otherwise fall trap to.
This example of Homes indexing crime gives him a dramatically different perspective on crime in the countryside to Watson who only sees the beauty in the story of "The Adventure of the Copper Beeches."
-
By eleven o’clock the next day we were well upon our way to the old English capital. Holmes had been buried in the morning papers all the way down, but after we had passed the Hampshire border he threw them down and began to admire the scenery. It was an ideal spring day, a light blue sky, flecked with little fleecy white clouds drifting across from west to east. The sun was shining very brightly, and yet there was an exhilarating nip in the air, which set an edge to a man’s energy. All over the countryside, away to the rolling hills around Aldershot, the little red and grey roofs of the farm-steadings peeped out from amid the light green of the new foliage. “Are they not fresh and beautiful?” I cried with all the enthusiasm of a man fresh from the fogs of Baker Street. But Holmes shook his head gravely. “Do you know, Watson,” said he, “that it is one of the curses of a mind with a turn like mine that I must look at everything with reference to my own special subject. You look at these scattered houses, and you are impressed by their beauty. I look at them, and the only thought which comes to me is a feeling of their isolation and of the impunity with which crime may be committed there.” “Good heavens!” I cried. “Who would associate crime with these dear old homesteads?” “They always fill me with a certain horror. It is my belief, Watson, founded upon my experience, that the lowest and vilest alleys in London do not present a more dreadful record of sin than does the smiling and beautiful countryside.” “You horrify me!” “But the reason is very obvious. The pressure of public opinion can do in the town what the law cannot accomplish. There is no lane so vile that the scream of a tortured child, or the thud of a drunkard’s blow, does not beget sympathy and indignation among the neighbours, and then the whole machinery of justice is ever so close that a word of complaint can set it going, and there is but a step between the crime and the dock. But look at these lonely houses, each in its own fields, filled for the most part with poor ignorant folk who know little of the law. Think of the deeds of hellish cruelty, the hidden wickedness which may go on, year in, year out, in such places, and none the wiser.
-
-
-
Is the Zettelkasten just for organised people?
-
-
app.thebrain.com app.thebrain.com
-
betula.mycorrhiza.wiki betula.mycorrhiza.wikiBetula1
-
https://betula.mycorrhiza.wiki/
Betula is a free federated self-hosted single-user bookmarking software for the independent web. Use it to organize references or maintain a linklog.
-
-
-
philosophy.williams.edu philosophy.williams.edu
-
https://philosophy.williams.edu/files/Egan-Learning-to-Be-Me.pdf
Learning to be Me by Greg Egan
-
-
blyt.net blyt.net
-
This could be used as a stand alone app for viewing and arranging "index cards" as a digital outliner for organizing ideas.
A slideshow could be thought of as an individual playlist or outline for a particular article, chapter, or book.
-
Phoenix Slides https://blyt.net/phxslides/
via Peter Kaminski:
A fast, free image viewer I use for sifting through thousands of images:
-
-
Local file Local file
-
Circularising
-
Office Organisation, of which the work here discussed forms part, 2has been considerably modified within recent years, and Avhatis called the " card system " has now come very much into vogue.
The nebulous, but colloquial "card system" was a common, but now lost moniker for the use of a card index in business settings in the early 1900s.
-
-
writingslowly.com writingslowly.com
-
https://writingslowly.com/2024/03/13/the-card-index.html
Richard ties together the "aliveness" of card indexes, phonographs, and artificial intelligence in an interesting way. He also links it to the living surroundings of indigenous cultures which see these things in ways that westerners don't.
-
People marveled at new invention after new invention and there was a tendency to see mechanical and especially electrical advances as somehow endowed with life. The phonograph, for example, was held to be alive and print adverts even claimed it had a soul.
I love the tying together of the "aliveness" of a zettelkasten with the "soul" of the phonograph here.
-
-
www.thespruceeats.com www.thespruceeats.com
-
https://www.thespruceeats.com/pink-squirrel-cocktail-recipe-759770
The cocktail Ainsley Hayes is drinking in the steam pipe trunk distribution venue (her office) in S2 E13 of The West Wing after the 3rd State of the Union.
-
-
setapp.com setapp.com
-
Setapp https://setapp.com/
One subscription which gives access to multiple applications (for iOS/Mac)
Mentioned by PK who uses it.
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
hookproductivity.com hookproductivity.comHome1
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georges-Louis_Leclerc,_Comte_de_Buffon
Influenced Jean-Baptiste Lamarck and Georges Cuvier
-
-
theinformed.life theinformed.life
-
Listened to [[Jorge Arango]] in Alex Wright on Informatica from 2023-08-13
-
By having a longer historical view, it actually tends to extend our time horizons in both directions. So, by thinking more about the past, it sets us up to think more about a long-term future and to challenge ourselves to think more expansively and ambitiously about what might come by having the sense of a wider aperture to think about rather than just thinking about the here and now or what’s coming out in the next cycle.
-
Institute For The Future at Palo Alto that likes this technique. It’s called “Look Back to Look Forward.”
-
if you’ve ever heard of the futures cone, it’s this idea of you know, this kind of widening aperture; the further out you look, the less predictable things are.
-
The whole industry is built on this concept of planned obsolescence. That’s the term that I think IBM famously came up with in the sixties, where basically you’re intentionally trying to constantly sell people on the new new thing. And that’s what drives the stock price up. And that’s what drives the press cycle. And that’s what gets people to buy new products and things. And so, the whole industry is predicated around this idea of there’s always a new thing around the horizon.
Where did the concept of planned obsolescence originate? Was it really IBM as Alex Wright suggests here?
How does planned obsolescence drive capitalism? And as a result of that is there a balance between future innovation and waste? Is there a mechanism within capitalism that can fix this waste (or dramatically mitigate it)?
-
I worked as an academic librarian, for about six years.
This somehow was missing from his bio with respect to Paul Otlet???
Tags
- tools for thought
- capitalism
- academic librarians
- timelines
- information overload
- why history
- predictions
- Look Back to Look Forward
- perspective
- planned obsolescence
- Alex Wright
- innovation
- Informatica
- predicting the future
- The Informed Life
- listen
- IBM
- futures cone
- open questions
- future
- capitalism can't fix everything
- Institute for the Future (Palo Alto)
Annotators
URL
-
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
quote from Schopenhauer’s essay, ‘How to think for oneself’, §268:“the most beautiful thought, if not written down, is in danger of being irretrievably forgotten.”It’s from the passage where he observes that Lichtenberg thought for himself in both senses of the phrase, unlike Herder.The original essay, “Selbstdenken” was part of Schopenhauer’s book Parerga und Paralipomena II. Last authorised edition, Erstausgabe Berlin, A. W. Hayn 1851, online textLooks like Povarnin was a Schopenhauer fan!
-
'картотек' (card index), to find the relevant section (it's section 51. The fascination with index cards, p.68). This is pretty much the only part of the booklet that discusses index cards, though.
card index in Russian is 'картотек'
-
-
qnnnp.medium.com qnnnp.medium.com
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
S. I. Povarnin, How To Read BOOKS (1924)
https://www.reddit.com/r/Zettelkasten/comments/1b9wqza/s_i_povarnin_how_to_read_books_1924/
-
I also recommend a book called "An alphabet of the intellectual labour" (азбука интеллектуального труда). It had at least ten editions, I've read the 10th edition from year 1928.
suggested by u/japdlsd at https://www.reddit.com/r/Zettelkasten/comments/1b9wqza/comment/ku8fuv2/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
-
-
github.com github.com
-
Obsidian templates via Edmund Gröpl<br /> https://github.com/groepl/Obsidian-Templates
aka u/International_Bed897 and also on forum.zettelkasten.de
-
-
munk.org munk.org
-
-
“Six big devils from Japan quickly forgot how to waltz”
-
Pack my box with five dozen liquor jugs
-
-
www.youtube.com www.youtube.com
-
Passion of the Nerd aka @popotoproductions3015 in The Toolbox Fallacy
This wasn't quite the toolbox fallacy definition I expected, but was a larger philosophical framing of a smaller version specific to getting things done (GTD).
Many people move from tool to tool hoping the next one will somehow "fix" things. In reality, it's having a tool and USING IT which creates progress.
Remember that it's rare that supposed innovation will be the fix, but picking a road and traveling down it will at least get you somewhere.
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
Many GTDers have fallen for The Toolbox Fallacy.
highlights link to this video: https://youtu.be/sz4YqwH_6D0
via https://www.reddit.com/r/gtd/comments/1b984sc/fellow_gtders_which_tools_do_you_use_to_track/
-
-
theinformed.life theinformed.life
-
Listened to Jorge Arango in Maggie Appleton on Digital Gardening<br /> Episode 118
-
there’s something really magical about the information density of visuals and graphics, which I would argue is based on the fact that humans are deeply embodied in visual creatures before we were linguistic textural creatures. And so it’s kind of pulling on a much richer, kind of higher bandwidth information channel for us.
-
-
theinformed.life theinformed.life
-
Listened to [[Jorge Arango]] in Beck Tench on Tinderbox
-
when I finish reading an article, I'm excited to go to Tinderbox and play with what I've just learned. And that is just rare. Normally that sort of work is is tedium and it doesn't feel that way.
not all tools are fun and each may be different for different people
-
persuasive technology, BJ Fog's contribution to the problem that we're all faced with today, which is that were addicted to our devices. So how does that work? Well, basically his theory has three parts where you have motivation, you have ability, and there's a trigger. And if you're above a certain threshold, you have the right motivation and the right ability, that trigger will trigger a behavior. If you don't have enough motivation, or if you don't have enough skill set, then that trigger won't work. Or if you have the motivation in the skill set, and the trigger doesn't happen, then you'll never trip into the behavior.
-
This episode's transcript was produced by an AI. If you notice any errors, please get in touch.
puts the work on the reader/user rather than the producer
Tags
- putting in the work
- tools for thought
- persuasive technology
- BJ Fogg
- Beck Tench
- minimizing work
- The Informed Life
- addiction
- errors
- zettelkasten
- listen
- tools for thought affordances
- artificial intelligence transcriptions
- Tinderbox
- motivation
- fun
- artificial intelligence
- Jorge Arango
Annotators
URL
-
-
www.shopbrodart.com www.shopbrodart.com
-
2024-03-07 Brodart's website is up and running again, finally.
-
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
www.geograph.org.uk www.geograph.org.ukGeograph1
-
fontmeme.com fontmeme.com
-
https://fontmeme.com/fonts/special-elite-font/<br /> Special Elite
-
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prestige_Elite<br /> Prestige Elite
-
-
fonts.google.com fonts.google.com
-
Installing & managing fonts—including variable fonts
https://fonts.google.com/knowledge/using_type/installing_and_managing_fonts
-
-
www.ylolfa.com www.ylolfa.com
-
https://www.ylolfa.com/products/9781800992887/my-way-to-welsh<br /> My Way to Welsh: A complete course for home learning<br /> Heini Gruffudd
ᔥDeborah-SSi in Heini Gruffudd's new book - Welsh / General / Questions - SSi Forum<br /> (accessed:: 2024-03-07 07:59:11)
-
-
www.texasstandard.org www.texasstandard.org
-
-
Paul Otlet, another great information visionary, to create a worldwide database for allsubjects.
Otlet's effort was more than a "database for all subjects", wasn't it? This seems a bit simplistic.
-
http://userpages.umbc.edu/~burke
http://userpages.umbc.edu/~burke
Bibliography and thanks sections for the book
Bibliography available at https://userpages.umbc.edu/~burke/fieldbib716pdf.pdf
-
This volume traces the Fields and science information systems to the beginningsof the Cold War.
summary of the book in 1 sentence
-
Concilium Bibliographicum
-
Burke, Colin B. Information and Intrigue: From Index Cards to Dewey Decimals to Alger Hiss. History and Foundations of Information Science. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2014. https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262027021/information-and-intrigue/
annotation URL: urn:x-pdf:3ca2bc5e94d24cfc51c7b40b4ea7daf9
-
-
github.com github.com
-
https://github.com/pdurbin/slopi-communication<br /> SLOPI communication
via SJ FoTL
-
-
opencollective.com opencollective.com
-
-
https://github.com/holepunchto/hypercore
Hypercore is an evolution of DAT.
(See also: https://awesome.datproject.org/)
It's one of the most interesting and promising things Aram Zucker-Scharf has seen in a decade.
-
-
composer.dxos.org composer.dxos.orgREADME1
-
composer.dxos.org composer.dxos.orgComposer1
-
Short url: https://tinyurl.com/3cfysbvp
-
-
photos.google.com photos.google.com
-
Jerry Michalski's trip to Bahrain in Feb 2024 for Meta and Formula 1
-
-
pkmsummit.com pkmsummit.com
-
jarche.com jarche.com
-
read [[Harold Jarche]] in dead blog walking at 20
-
-
www.zylstra.org www.zylstra.org
-
www.pcusa.org www.pcusa.org
-
www.icongrouponline.com www.icongrouponline.com
-
en.forum.saysomethingin.com en.forum.saysomethingin.com
-
This morning I ran across a copy of Jane Austen's novel Emma with some of the keywords on each page translated into Welsh as footnotes at the bottom of the page. Apparently it's part of a series of classic books published by Icon into a variety of different languages and meant for language learners.
The full list of their titles with Welsh can be found here: Webster's Welsh Thesaurus Editions
I'm curious if anyone has used these before, and if so, how helpful they've found them for building their Welsh vocabulary as they read English language works.
Is anyone aware of Welsh language books that have this sort of English vocabulary cross listed on the page? (Sort of the way in which lingo.360.cymru has news stories in Welsh with English translation help along the way?)
syndication link: https://en.forum.saysomethingin.com/t/websters-welsh-thesaurus-editions/40131
-
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
NovelsSense and Sensibility (1811) Pride and Prejudice (1813) Mansfield Park (1814) Emma (1816) Northanger Abbey (1818, posthumous) Persuasion (1818, posthumous) Lady Susan (1871, posthumous)Unfinished fictionThe Watsons (1804) Sanditon (1817)Other worksSir Charles Grandison (adapted play) (1793, 1800)[p] Plan of a Novel (1815) Poems (1796–1817) Prayers (1796–1817) Letters (1796–1817)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Austen#List_of_works
Novels
- Sense and Sensibility (1811)
- Pride and Prejudice (1813)
- Mansfield Park (1814)
- Emma (1816)
- Northanger Abbey (1818, posthumous)
- Persuasion (1818, posthumous)
- Lady Susan (1871, posthumous)
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
boffosocko.com boffosocko.com
-
indieweb.org indieweb.org
-
www.amazon.com www.amazon.com
-
Catmull, Ed, and Amy Wallace. Creativity, Inc.: Overcoming the Unseen Forces That Stand in the Way of True Inspiration. 1st ed. New York: Random House, 2014.
-
-
www.cgdev.org www.cgdev.org
-
David Witzel said:
I was trying to find David Roodman's "open book" on microfinance from 2010. Lots of link rot - not sure where it best lives now.
He had interesting stories about how difficult/useful the open writing process was. https://www.cgdev.org/article/microfinance-open-book-blog-qa-david-roodman
-
-
-
Cahoone, Lawrence. The Modern Intellectual Tradition: From Descartes to Derrida - Course Guidebook. The Great Courses 4790. Chantilly, VA: The Teaching Company, 2010. https://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/modern-intellectual-tradition-from-descartes-to-derrida.
Cahoone, Lawrence. The Modern Intellectual Tradition: From Descartes to Derrida. Audible Audio Edition. The Great Courses 4790. Chantilly, VA: The Teaching Company, 2013. https://www.amazon.com/Modern-Intellectual-Tradition-Descartes-Derrida/dp/B00DTO5BTO.
Annotation URL: urn:x-pdf:92bff7dc89e6440afc484388b7b72d79
alternate version: https://jonudell.info/h/facet/?user=chrisaldrich&max=100&exactTagSearch=true&expanded=true&url=urn%3Ax-pdf%3A92bff7dc89e6440afc484388b7b72d79
-
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
Facebook marketplace, set location in various regions. (Ymmv)Ebay (flooded with junk, diamonds in the rough are either overpriced or seller wants high shipping)Auctionninja.com (like shopgoodwill, but higher quality items on average and higher final bids on interesting items)Hibid.com (I've gotten a thing or two here)Estatesales.net (I've gotten good deals here)Estatesales.org (usually redirects to respective company sites to bid there)Shopgoodwill.com (hard to win bids on interesting items)Goodwillfinds.com (the higher end/rarer items they receive go here, so higher prices)Craigslist (usually baren of typewriters)Kijiji (I don't find much that's both interesting and feasible to ship)Etsy (meh, overpriced)
-
-
www.404media.co www.404media.co
-
typewriterdatabase.com typewriterdatabase.com
-
The platen was quite hard to begin with, around 100 on the Shore A hardness scale, though it would feed two sheets reliably. The platen was cleaned and treated with methyl salicylate, which brought the hardness down to about 92, and has remained at that hardness for several months.
https://typewriterdatabase.com/1948-smith-corona-clipper.21427.typewriter
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Smith-Corona Galaxie 12 XII Blue
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/191956978<br /> 2024-03-02 sold $102.00 !! 4 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Smith-Corona Silent
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192328912<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $9.99 fair<br /> 1 bid
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Olympia
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192255013<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $112.00<br /> 8 bids<br /> (broken space bar)
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
sources.werd.io sources.werd.io
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
1969 Smith-Corona Galaxie Deluxe Steel Blue
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192125668 <br /> 2023-03-02 sold<br /> $18.00 (opening price)<br /> 1 bid
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Brother Charger 11
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192239320<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $31.00<br /> 11 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Remington Standard Super Riter Vintage 1956 Mechanical Desktop Typewriter-TESTED
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/191848428<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $26.00<br /> 5 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Remington Quiet-Riter
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192242999<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $16.00<br /> 3 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Sears Malibu
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192251351<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $18.00<br /> 5 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
L.C. Smith & Corona
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/191521413<br /> 2024-03-02 UNSOLD<br /> $24.99<br /> 0 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Smith Corona Galaxy 12
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192252614<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $36.00<br /> 2 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
SMITH CORONA Super Correct Model 6E Typewriter with Hard Case
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192474910<br /> 2024-03-02 UNSOLD<br /> $11.99<br /> 0 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Smith Corona Sterling
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192152257<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $23.50 3 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Smith Corona Classic 12 Typewriter W/Case
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192262866<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $23.00<br /> 4 bids
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Rheinmetall Green Typewriter with Case and Key
https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192239575<br /> 2024-03-02 sold<br /> $402.00 31 bids
-
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
WM2D2
Based on context here, u/WM2D2 of Florian Lengyel of zettelkasten.de context.
-
-
www.ebay.com www.ebay.com
-
https://www.ebay.com/itm/386823811291
Don't see these often. Rubbermaid stackable plastic card indexes offered for $70.00 on 2024-03-02
cost per drawer: $23.33
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
www.ebay.com www.ebay.com
-
https://www.ebay.com/itm/266697740403
2024-03-02 Listed for sale or best offer at 1,275. 72 drawers with plastic drawers. Darker wood, in good shape. missing 4 rods and has one damaged front frame.
Likely mid-70s to early 80s
Freight shipping available or local pick up in Comfort, TX.
Cost per drawer: $17.70
Tags
Annotators
URL
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Brother Charger 11
2024-03-01<br /> $53.99<br /> https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192321322
-
-
shopgoodwill.com shopgoodwill.com
-
Olivetti Underwood 21
2024-03-01<br /> $67.99 sale<br /> https://shopgoodwill.com/item/192324052
-
-
www.goodwillfinds.com www.goodwillfinds.com
-
-
Positivism asserted that allcultures move through progressive stages of development: first the-ological, then metaphysical, and finally “positive.”
Is positivism the source of some of the "progress of human civilization" which David Graeber and David Wengrow point out as problematic in The Dawn of Everything?
Were their prior philosophical movements which may have fed into this forward moving impression? Great chain of being also plays into some of this from a hierarchical perspective.
-
. Positivism asserted that allcultures move through progressive stages of development: first the-ological, then metaphysical, and finally “positive.”
-
-
Local file Local file
-
Notes
The audiobook version of this "text" omits the notes, acknowledgements, and importantly the indexes!
It ends with the coda followed by a copyright and production statement.
-
Anindexer who tags a document has already done the work needed toproduce an ‘active index’, where each locator is a clickable link thatwill bring up its target page immediately.
-
Theindexer will want a feel, before they begin, for the concepts that willneed to be flagged, or taxonomized with subheadings. They mightskim the book – reading it in full but at a canter – before tackling itproperly with the software open. Or they may spend a while, as apreliminary, with the book’s introduction, paying attention to itschapter outline – if it has one – to gain a sense of what to look outfor. Often, having reached the end of the book, the indexer will returnto the first few chapters, going over them again now that they havegained a conceptual mapping of the work as a whole.
It's no wonder that Mortimer J. Adler was able to write such a deep analysis of reading in How to Read a Book after having spent so much time indexing the ideas behind The Great Books of the Western World.
Indexing requires a solid inspectional read at minimum, but will often go deeper into contexts which require at least some analytical reading. To produce the Syntopicon, one must go even further into analytical reading to provide the proper indexing of ideas so that they may be sub-categorized and used for deeper analysis for things such as comparison and contrast of those ideas.
-
-
hardhistoriesjhu.substack.com hardhistoriesjhu.substack.com
-
Read [[Martha S. Jones]] in Sleuthing the Card Catalog
-
The Library of Congress discontinued the use of “Negroes” as a subject heading in 1976.
-
I fingered my way through where I thought I’d find entries: African American, Afro-American, Black. Nothing there. I had to then brainstorm like it was 1999, or was it 1989, 1979, or even earlier, to discover the right term. As far back as 1984, the Library of Congress, whose subject headings most research libraries in the United States utilize, admitted that it was “frustrating” to search for Black people in its catalog because two terms were simultaneously in use: “Afro-Americans” and “Blacks.”1 Neither term made it into the old Peabody Library catalog, so perhaps it and the terminology it reflected dated from an even earlier time.
Research on keywords and their shifting meanings over time can make things difficult for the novice researcher. This example from Martha S. Jones certainly highlights this perspective even in under a century of semantic shift.
-
-
www.ebay.com www.ebay.com
-
https://www.ebay.com/itm/374936561744
Previously listed (late Summer 2023). Offered for bidding at $7,200 for a Jens Risom Library Card catalog on/around 2023-09-16. Local pickup from Pageland, SC. Ex-library from Davidson College Library in North Carolina tag number 01359.
Section of 6x5 and another of 6x7 for a total of 72 drawers with a middle section which has two pull out writing drawers.
Cost per drawer at opening bid: $100.00
2023-09-25: Relisted at https://www.ebay.com/itm/374948492633
2024-02-29 Relisted at https://www.ebay.com/itm/375282966486
-
- Feb 2024
-
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
-
https://github.com/travisbrown/cancel-culture
Cancel culture, tool for fighting abuse on Twitter, which can also be used to archive one's Tweets.
Example: An archive of a user's Tweets: https://gist.github.com/rondy/e6fc62e6968f39428df5eb1746f0d308
-
-
press.princeton.edu press.princeton.edu
-
Dames, Nicholas. The Chapter: A Segmented History from Antiquity to the Twenty-First Century. Princeton University Press, 2023. https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691135199/the-chapter.
Suggested by Eric Sinclair in Dan Allosso Book Club
-
-
chat.openai.com chat.openai.com
-
https://chat.openai.com/g/g-z5XcnT7cQ-zettel-critique-assistant
Zettel Critique Assistant<br /> By Florian Lengyel<br /> Critique Zettels following three rules: Zettels should have a single focus, WikiLinks indicate a shift in focus, Zettels should be written for your future self. The GPT will suggest how to split multi-focused notes into separate notes. Create structure note from a list of note titles and abstracts.
ᔥ[[ZettelDistraction]] in Share with us what is happening in your ZK this week. February 20, 2024
-
-
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
www.reddit.com www.reddit.com
-
Let's reframe things here in part because it's highly illustrative of both the phrases as well as the specific question you raise.
Imagine Andy Matuschak reading Sonke Ahrens' How to Make Smart Notes (CreateSpace, 2017) and making notes on what he feels is important. As he reads, he does what is prescribed, namely, he restates the idea in his own words based on what he's read. In doing this he takes the idea of "evergreen" content from journalism settings (and later SEO settings) which he was familiar with and applies that name to what Ahrens called permanent notes to expound on his understanding of Ahrens! (An evergreen article in newspaper work is an article which was written for a particular recurring holiday, event, or story and is regular. Why spend huge amounts of staff time writing that truly original Valentine's day article? The broad stories about gifts to give and restaurants to visit really don't change from year to year. Just dust it off and reprint it, as readers are unlikely to have saved or remembered it and it becomes free re-purposable content.)
Of course, in rewriting this definition, Matuschak adds in some additional baggage for those who aren't carefully reading his work. He adds some additional emphasis on revisiting one's ideas and rewriting them over time, which is certainly fine, but I think the novice note maker puts too much emphasis on this portion thinking that each permanent or evergreen note must eventually become polished to perfection. In practice, most seasoned writers don't and won't do this. In fact, I suspect if you looked at Matuschak's note on evergreen notes, you'd find that it probably hasn't changed since the day he wrote it other than agglutinating links from other notes.
This doesn't mean that one can't modify or change their ideas over time, this is certainly useful and good, but I suspect that the majority aren't doing it the way that might be imagined by Matuschak's original statement or the way that his idea was picked up by the (niche) digital gardening community and spread primarily in the work of Maggie Appleton. It's some of this evolution of Matuschak's definition which bled into digital gardens, which have some overlap with zettelkasten and the note taking realms, which have muddied the waters. As a result, one should take it as general advice and apply it to their own situation, needs, and practice.
For those who use their own notes for writing, one will often mark their cards/notes to indicate that they've used those ideas in various projects so that they're not actively repeating themselves ad nauseum. Some of the additional tweaks one might make to their notes from a style or context specific perspective are also left to the editing portion rather than being done in the notes themselves. As a result of some of this, unless there is a dramatic flaw in a note, there isn't generally a lot of additional work one would come back to it to revise it. If it does require that sort of major revision, then perhaps the better method would be to make a new note and linking it to the original along with an explanation of the error. I typically wouldn't recommend polishing individual notes to some Plationic idea of perfection. Doing so is often just make-work which distracts from one's time which could be better spent doing additional reading or actual thinking. If you're going to do that sort of polishing work, do it at the end when you've got a longer piece of writing you're including your note in.
The real question now, is how are you personally going to define permanent notes, evergreen notes, or other related phrases like atomic notes? This practice is called by Mortimer J. Adler and Charles Van Doren "coming to terms" with an author's work and is part of their analysis for how one should read a book to get the most out of it. I highly recommend reading How to Read a Book (Simon & Schuster, 1972 or Touchstone, 2011) as a companion to any of the usual note taking manuals.
If you want to continue the experiment on a better unified definition of permanent notes, evergreen notes, atomic notes, etc., you can find a pretty solid bibliography of note making, writing, and reading manuals to peruse at https://boffosocko.com/2024/01/18/note-taking-and-knowledge-management-resources-for-students/#Recommended%20reading.
While one could certainly go down the rabbit hole of reading all these resources, I would recommend only looking at one or two and spending your time working on actual practice. It's through practice that you're more likely to make actual progress on your own problems and questions.
reply to u/franrodalg at https://www.reddit.com/r/Zettelkasten/comments/1azoo9m/permanent_vs_evergreen_notes_am_i_thinking_about/
-
-
Local file Local file
-
Duncan, Dennis. Index, A History of the: A Bookish Adventure from Medieval Manuscripts to the Digital Age. 1st ed. London: Allen Lane, 2021. https://wwnorton.com/books/9781324002543.
annotation link: urn:x-pdf:a4bd1877f0712efcc681d33d58777e55
-
scholastic learning
How much different things may have been if the state, and not the Church, had been the progenitor and supporter of the early university?
How might education have been different if it came out of itself (or something like curiosity or even society in general) without the influences on either church or state?
-
scholastic learning would favour externaldemonstration over inner revelation, intellectual agility over endlessmeditation.
-
the reading-out of commentaries (a format with a now-familiar name: the lecture)
Link between the commentaries of the early middle ages and modern lectures
-
centralizing reforms of Pope Gregory VII calledfor a more professionalized clergy. Church officials should now betrained administrators, versed not only in the scriptures but also inthe principles of accounting and law. A papal decree of 1079 orderedthat cathedrals should establish schools for the training of priests,
-
Not so the tenth-century John of Gorze, who issaid to have pored continuously over the psalms with a soft buzzing‘in morem apis’: in the manner of a bee.8
quoted portion via:<br /> John of St Arnulf, ‘Vita Joannis abbatis Gorziensis’, Patrologia Latina, 137.280D.
relationship to collecting like the bees (rhetoric)
relationship to humming and rocking practices of Hassidic readers/learners/memorizers
-
Looking back on his first encounters withAmbrose, Bishop of Milan, in the late fourth century, Augustineremembers noticing the curious way Ambrose would read: ‘his eyeswould scan over the pages and his heart would scrutinize theirmeaning – yet his voice and tongue remained silent’.7 This –reading in silence – is not normal, and Augustine wonders whatcould possess Ambrose to adopt such a practice. (Was it to preservehis voice? Or a way of avoiding unwanted discussions about the texthe was reading?)
quoted section via:<br /> St Augustine, Confessions, trans. by Carolyn J. B. Hammond, 2 vols. (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2014), I, p. 243 (VI 3.3).
-
As thehistorian Jean Leclercq, himself a Benedictine monk, puts it, ‘in theMiddle Ages, one generally read by speaking with one’s lips, at leastin a whisper, and consequently hearing the phrases that the eyessee’.6
quoted section from:<br /> [au moyen âge, on lit généralement en pronançant avec les lèvres, au moins à voix basse, par conséquent en entendant les phrases que les yeux voient.] Jean Leclercq, Initiation aux auteurs monastiques du Moyen Âge, 2nd edn (Paris: Cerf, 1963), p. 72.
What connection, if any, is there to the muscle memory of movement while speaking/reading along with sound/hearing to remembering what we read? Is there research on this? Implications for orality and memory?
-
in the nunnery, where St Caesarius prescribes two hours to beset aside for reading in the early morning and a nominated reader tobe the only audible voice both at mealtimes and during the nuns’daily weaving. And woe betide the sister who finds herself drifting off:‘If anyone should become drowsy, she shall be ordered to standwhile the others are seated, so that she can banish the heaviness ofsleep.’5
quoted portion from:<br /> The Rule for Nuns of St Caesarius of Arles, trans. by Maria McCarthy (Washington, DC: Catholic University of America Press, 1960), p. 175.
see related version in Benedictine Rule: https://hypothes.is/a/oJWB5tKAEe6FRGuIAPWmZQ
-
the Benedictine Rule stipulatesthat monks should then apply themselves to two hours of reading,after which they may either go back to bed, ‘or if anyone mayperhaps want to read, let him read to himself in such a way as not todisturb anyone else’.4 At mealtimes, one monk will be appointed toread to the others, who must keep absolute silence ‘so that nowhispering may be heard nor any voice except the reader’s’.
quoted portions from:<br /> St. Benedict’s Rule for Monasteries, trans. by Leonard J. Doyle (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 1948), p. 67.
-
StAugustine draws this same parallel when he writes to a communityof nuns, ‘let it not be only your mouth that takes food, but let yourears also drink in the word of God’.3
quoted section from:
St Augustine, Letters, trans. by Wilfrid Parsons, 5 vols. (Baltimore, MD: Catholic University of America Press, 1956), V, Letter 211, ‘To a Convent of Consecrated Virgins’, p. 43.
-
‘Blessed Lord, which hast caused al holy Scriptures to bee written forour learnyng; graunte us that we maye in such wise heare them,read, marke, learne, and inwardly digeste them.’2
quote from:<br /> The Booke of the Common Prayer and Administration of the Sacraments (London: 1549), sig. B iiv.
-
What happens to the page layout now that the book is beingused as a container for many discrete pieces of information, ratherthan for a single, continuous narrative?
-
Hugh will be the first to produce aconcordance to the Bible, to break the book down and rearrange itinto an alphabetical index of its words.
Hugh of Saint-Cher was the first person to produce a concordance of the Bible around 1230.
-
was the first to argue that rainbows arecaused by light refraction
earlier source:
Amelia Carolina Sparavigna, ‘On the Rainbow, Robert Grosseteste’s Treatise on Optics’, International Journal of Sciences 2.9 (2013): 108–13 (109).
-
In fact, this final detail is a mistake, an anachronism. Hugh died acouple of decades too early to have benefitted from this invention:two magnifying glasses bound together by a rivet in their handles.
The image of Hugh of Saint-Cher wearing glasses in the fresco at the former convent of San Niccolò, Chapter Room, Treviso, is an anachronism as their invention was decades following his death in 1263.
-
the fresco, byTomasso da Modena, was painted in 1352). It stresses theDominicans’ commitment to Bible study and to scholarship, and noportrait conveys this more than the image of Hugh of St Cher.
Image from: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:38_Ugo_da_San_Caro.jpg
Ugo da San Caro, serie dei Quaranta domenicani illustri, ex convento di San Niccolò, Sala del Capitolo, Treviso, 1352 (altezza di ciascun ritratto 150 cm circa) Image by Risorto Celebrano, licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.
Thought to be one of the first images of a person wearing glasses. Image dated 1352.
-
Between them, theyset up the axes by which we think about indexing: word versusconcept; concordance versus subject index; specific versusuniversal.
context: the simultaneous invention of two different methods of indexing: subject indexes and concordances
-
Grosseteste’s great table – or Tabula
This introduction to Grosseteste's Tabula seems to be in medias res...
Tags
- X
- archaeology of orality
- Hugh of Saint-Cher
- zettelkasten
- food analogies
- inventions
- firsts
- internal vs. external
- prayers
- glasses
- 1549
- John of Gorze
- anachronisms
- educational reform
- papal decrees
- meditation
- accounting
- open questions
- Bible studies
- concordances
- card index as database
- history of universities
- education reform
- commentaries
- law
- orality vs. literacy
- lectures
- orality and memory
- 1079
- indexing
- intellectual history
- religious reforms
- Benedictine Rule
- Robert Grosseteste
- XVI
- Augustine
- Jean Leclercq
- church vs. state
- Tomasso da Modena
- history
- XI
- book as container
- apes
- digital age
- church and state
- quotes
- pedagogy
- professionalization
- Pope Gregory VII
- scholasticism
- universitites
- muscle memory
- images
- References
- humming
- definitions
- history of education
- digesting material
- giving voice
- analogies
- Dennis Duncan
- reading aloud
- containers
- Book of Common Prayer
- annotations
- St. Caesarius' Rule
- frescos
- sound
- refraction
- reading practices
- Benedictine Order
- XIII
- Tabula
- card index
- reading with a pen in hand
- buzzing
- Ambrose of Milan (Saint Ambrose)
- optics
- indices
- silent reading
- Thomas Cranmer
- rainbows
Annotators
-
-
-
[[Kevin Kelly]] in 1,000 True Fans
-
-
www.youtube.com www.youtube.com
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWVrz5oCt2w<br /> The meaning of Hand Gestures in Art History<br /> Amuze Art Lectures
Middle and ring fingers together to represent modesty. (He doesn't say it, but it also could stand for "M" as in Medici??)
Finger pointing at viewer may indicate a self portrait.
Woman's hand on abdomen may represent pregnancy, a fertile marriage, or the desire to bear children.
-
-
en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
-
I'm curious if anyone frames their zettelkasten practice in terms of disputation via the scholastic tradition? <br /> context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disputation
-
-
www.npr.org www.npr.org
-
Why not have heart balm tortes as a pastry for Valentine's Day
-
HASDAY: The joke about criminal conversation is that it's not criminal, and it's not conversation. That's how you can remember it.BERAS: That's good.HASDAY: It's not criminal. It's not conversation.BERAS: It's sex. That's what it is - just sex. Essentially, you had sex with my wife. It was often the husband suing.
-
Jill Hasday, a law professor at the University of Minnesota, and she is kind of like a heart balm expert. She wrote about them in this book called "Intimate Lies And The Law."
relationship of this area of law with respect to debt and David Graeber's Debt theses?
-
https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1197958200
rel-alternate: https://www.npr.org/2024/02/09/1197958200/heart-balm-cheating-infidelity-sue
-